Of the early sonatas, the G major Hob. XVI:6 is one of those about which there is very little doubt about it being by Haydn, chiefly because he *did* write it; An unfortunate comment; where did you find this nonsense ?
@@elaineblackhurst1509 Please, read Complete Piano Sonatas Vol. 1, Edition without fingering. Haydn, Franz Joseph. Henle Verlag. 2020 (Urtext). You will find all the data in the preface. Don't kill the messenger. I've played almost every Haydn Sonata on the piano and have him as one of my preferred composers. However, there are many doubts about some sonatas wrongly attributed to Haydn, especially among the early ones, and Hob XVI; 6 is one of them. And there are no doubts about the next ones: Sonate G-dur Hob. XVI:11lll, Sonate Es-dur Hob. XVI:16, Sonate A-dur Hob. XVI:5, Sonate Hob. XVI:Es2 Add. mitsamt dem Finalsatz and Sonate Hob. XVI:Es3 Add. Finale der Sonate Nr. 9 ohne Hob. Es-dur, as neither of these sonatas was composed by Haydn. So maybe my comment is unfortunate to you, but you're wrong. Think twice before what you write.
@@Fryderyk_Franciszek Fair point; what you have written is new to me and I will check out the details further. My own feeling is that this sonata both sounds and feels like early Haydn, but you’ve made your point clearly and well, and I may need to revise my thinking.
@@Fryderyk_Franciszek As I said, I would look into this matter, but I have already found that the autograph manuscript score with the usual ‘In nomine domini Giuseppe Haydn’ is to be found in the Royal College of Music in London; the autograph of the second and third movements being in Germany (Henle-Verlag edition of the complete sonatas Volume 1 2020). Can you explain this ?
Sparkling!!!
9:55
Excellent! 👍
Superbe
Cool
-1:20
Hi
Mhhh..🤔..für mich etwas zu technisch...es fehlt mir etwas...kann im moment nicht sagen was es ist..
This sonata is another one wrongly attributed to Haydn.
Of the early sonatas, the G major Hob. XVI:6 is one of those about which there is very little doubt about it being by Haydn, chiefly because he *did* write it;
An unfortunate comment; where did you find this nonsense ?
@@elaineblackhurst1509 Please, read Complete Piano Sonatas Vol. 1, Edition without fingering. Haydn, Franz Joseph. Henle Verlag. 2020 (Urtext). You will find all the data in the preface. Don't kill the messenger. I've played almost every Haydn Sonata on the piano and have him as one of my preferred composers. However, there are many doubts about some sonatas wrongly attributed to Haydn, especially among the early ones, and Hob XVI; 6 is one of them. And there are no doubts about the next ones: Sonate G-dur Hob. XVI:11lll, Sonate Es-dur Hob. XVI:16, Sonate A-dur Hob. XVI:5, Sonate Hob. XVI:Es2 Add. mitsamt dem Finalsatz and Sonate Hob. XVI:Es3 Add. Finale der Sonate Nr. 9 ohne Hob. Es-dur, as neither of these sonatas was composed by Haydn. So maybe my comment is unfortunate to you, but you're wrong. Think twice before what you write.
@@Fryderyk_Franciszek
Fair point; what you have written is new to me and I will check out the details further.
My own feeling is that this sonata both sounds and feels like early Haydn, but you’ve made your point clearly and well, and I may need to revise my thinking.
@@elaineblackhurst1509 My pleasure ;).
@@Fryderyk_Franciszek
As I said, I would look into this matter, but I have already found that the autograph manuscript score with the usual ‘In nomine domini Giuseppe Haydn’ is to be found in the Royal College of Music in London; the autograph of the second and third movements being in Germany (Henle-Verlag edition of the complete sonatas Volume 1 2020).
Can you explain this ?
9:55