I think that the Jets winning a Super Bowl with Aaron Rodgers is more likely than picking Nick Fowles to win a Super Bowl MVP in the 2016 offseason. TL:DR anything can happen especially when considering the NFL scriptwriters. Love your content! Keep it up 👍
why matt stafford did it first year on the rams it’s not completely implausible he’s carried pretty mid teams to an nfc champ many times and came up just short im not gonna act like none of them can be his fault too but his team should get credit where crudit is due it’s genuinely surprising he hasn’t been back not even once, and way to clickbait with the title “the downfall of arod” bro has not had a downfall on the field he’s been to many many nfcs and just came up short which isn’t arod having a downfall you don’t win mvps late in ur career AND take ur team to nfc champs while ALSO having the lowest int rate, gimmie a break guy you just deceiving ppl atp 😭😭
@@KrispigKarpi’ve not seen any other vids but this vid is a load of 💩 💀 look at my other reply on this comment to get the full perspective on how this guy clickbaited and majorly deceived ppl
In my opinion, it all went downhill after 2014. After that collapse vs the Seahawks, the team couldn’t recover from it. 2020 and 2021 were the only realistic chances of winning since then and we choked it away.
Took me years to get over that loss. I legit repressed those memories. That loss was devastating. Couldnt let myself get that attached again. It was a strange baton handoff of devastating losses that postseason. First the cowboys with the infamous dez Bryant catch, then the packers infamous meltdown, and then the seahawks with the worst interception thrown in post season history. One of the few times I was happy with tom brady winning
I blame GreenBays front office and their business practices. Never relying on trades, never drafting high in the draft for Receivers, and always sticking with bad personel.
Look at Peyton Manning’s early playoff record. John elway back in the day used to get crushed in super bowls. We don’t consider Aaron an all time great just because he can win super bowls. Dan marino went to one and never got back. We consider him an all time great because he can win games on any given Sunday, carry a team in crisis, win the division consistently, and get you to the postseason. And Aaron has does all of that. He has the second most MVPs for a reason.
@bananaman5668 true. I just find it stupid when people just blindly go “oh we’ll have the conversation when he gets to 3 or 4 rings.” As if Tom Brady (no offense) didn’t have an all time defense led by an all time coach. And as of Tom Brady didn’t have a 10 year gap between his third and fourth rings.
Rodgers is 2nd all time for playoff touchdowns and has a playoff QB rating of over 100. all of this playoff stats are better than cry baby brady except "football fans" have no clue about any of it
@bananaman5668that's the problem. Aaron didn't get that great team. Green Bay for most of his career were horrible at running back, and embarrassingly bad at the corner position because their GM is cheap. Aaron didn't walk into a top 10 defense and a solid core like these other guys did. Mahomes had Tyreek, Kelce, Chris Jones. Montana had Rice, Ronnie Lott. Brady had Moss, Edelman, Gronk, Donta Hightower, the greatest kicker ever. Manning had Welker, Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Von Miller. These dudes had legitimate hall of fame help. Aaron didn't, so it's people who are casuals who underrated Aaron Rodgers. By the time Green Bay finally got a defense they had no receivers. Green Bay in 2010 was great and obviously thats why they won, but in the next 3-4 years their defense absolutely fell apart. Their defense allowed 37 POINTS A GAME in their losses. That's over 5 touchdowns. It's ridiculous to expect someone to drop 3-400 yards and 4 touchdowns along with opening up the run game to win games when Brady at points was dropping 175-225 yards and 1 touchdown, and winning the game.
Peyton and Marino got criticized for the same thing. The reason it doesn’t hurt Peyton as much anymore is because looking at the entire career of every QB, if you take out the postseason, Peyton is pretty much the perfect QB. He was the smartest QB, revolutionized calling the plays on the line of scrimmage, consistently won with different coaches in the regular season, and succeeded at the highest level with two different teams. The postseason is the only knock on Manning but it’s a big one.
I'm REALLY glad you talked about the Nick Collins injury. I feel that goes UNDERLOOKED when talking about the 2011 Packers, because I feel with him, we wouldn't have been as bad on defense in that year and years after in the safety room. That was SUCH a huge loss that I feel not many people talk about. This was a really awesome video!
That very year, they were upset by the Giants in the divisional round. A major part of the loss was two huge TDs they gave up to Hakeen Nicks. Both TDs were the result of horrible secondary breakdowns. It's very likely that they win with Nick Collins.
@@Disxreet a cool tidbit about his longevity if anything, not meant to disparage. I’ll try to rephrase the point in the future if that’s the effect it had.
Packers Playoff losses in the Rodgers era ranked by most heartbreaking: 1. 2014 NFC Championship vs Seahawks This one takes the cake, no contest. Rodgers was the MVP that year, and the the defense picked of Wilson FOUR TIMES. And then the onside kick happens and they blow a game that they were nearly guaranteed to win, with a chance to go back to the Super Bowl. I also think this loss had a truly cursed feeling and had a ripple effect that culminated in several disappointing seasons after. 2. 2020 NFC Championship vs Bucs This was probably the best all around team the Packers had after 2010, Rodgers put up one of the best seasons ever, and just when the NFC looked wide open with Brees looking washed, the 49ers and Rams riddled with injuries, and the Seahawks suffering an embarrassing upset, Brady walks into the NFC and in his FIRST YEAR, goes to Lambeau and beats them, winning as many NFC Championships as the Packers did in the entire Rodgers era. 3. 2011 Divisional Round vs Giants This could’ve been higher but those Giants teams were something special. This might’ve been the best team in totality, but their defense was horrendous, the 2010, 2020, and 2021 teams were all more balanced. However the receiving corps and offensive weapons on this team were ridiculous, Rodgers had maybe the best QB season ever (I disagree but it has a case). 15-1 and lost their first Playoff game. 4. 2021 Divisional Round vs 49ers Their last chance, the defense played close to perfect, but Rodgers couldn’t get more than 10 points, and the special teams have a punt and FG blocked, as well as only having 10 guys to contest the game winning FG. 5. 2012 Divisional Round vs 49ers Kaepernick set the all time record for rush yards by a QB in a game, this was a demolition job back when the Packers were still viewed as serious contenders and were favored before the season to win it all. 6. 2016 NFC Championship vs Falcons The Falcons historic passing offense obliterated them, and the Packers offense was shut out in the first half by a terrible defense. Atlanta was clearly better but this was a harsh end to the 8 straight wins that put the red hot Packers in position to return to the Super Bowl. 7. 2019 NFC Championship vs 49ers The Packers had no chance of winning this game and were lucky to be here in the first place. Rodgers had clearly taken a downturn over the previous two seasons and they squeezed out a bunch of one score victories. They were nowhere near the level of the 49ers or Chiefs, and their run defense got completely exposed, as the 49ers run game demolished them while throwing only 8 times. It was over when it was 27-0 at halftime. 8. 2015 Divisional vs Cardinals I guess losing a game where Rodgers throws two Hail Mary’s sucks, but they had no chance this year, the Panthers would’ve demolished them anyway. 9. 2013 Wild Card vs 49ers Once again they didn’t have much of a chance this year either and it was in the Wild Card. 10. 2009 Wild Card vs Cardinals Honestly, this just showed how great Rodgers could be and he hadn’t emerged yet.
Great job of showing how big a choke Aaron is. This is why, while he is a great QB, I will never consider him an all time great except as a prima dona.
@@winoodlesnoodles1984 you shouldnt share your opinions out loud with other people. Good lord you are a horribly negative person. Just showed up to fan that flame of hatred huh? Shows how much you got going on in your life... whoops did I say that out loud? 🥶🥶🥶
The loss to the 49ers in 2021 is the second worse loss. All they had to do was avoid the special teams shitting the bed. But 2 years in a row the packers horrible special teams got severely outplayed by one of the other leagues worst special team units. And matt lafleur just completely ignored the problem. Packers just miraculously always find a way to lose in dramatic fashion when it comes to the playoffs. It was the same with favre
2012-2016 was beyond painful to watch. The 2015 loss consisted of me watching that punching a locker, 3 others screaming in a room, and 2 guys fighting over a knife and one getting his hand cut in half nearly. All within 3 seconds.
@@ghoul5371 I’m definitely wasn’t done lol but packers have certainly been perennially underperforming. Which is strange because if you consider a “dynasty” but a core team who consistently tops, not Super Bowl winners, then packers from 2010- basically 2017 were a dynasty. Just minus the super bowls but always always a Super Bowl favorite. Same with Seahawks and 49s during same time. Love the packers and excited to see basically and entirely new team from the team we’ve seen for the past 17 years. Only names remaining are players who were drafted in mid 2010s as the oldest players. A very young team with tons of potential. And now I gotta root for jets too!
@@ma.2099yeah that’s what I always say we were literally the patriots of the nfc just without the bowls we got to championship games left and right and we’re the only team in the playoffs every year from 2009-2017 besides the patriots😂💯
@@ma.2099but hey man I’ve learned to appreciate the wins they got us in that time and we still had 1 at one point we won 19 games in a row at one point from the end of 2010 through most of 2011 he gets one with the jets and what are people gonna say then lol he just needs 2💯
I think the main issue with the Packers is a reluctance to move on from bad coaches. They did it with Dom Capers, and their new defensive coordinator seems to be repeating
I'm a bears fan and I don't which is worse: Us losing a trip to the super bowl to our 6 seed divisional rival, or having to see Cutler fumble our second super bowl in 5 years.
i was digging for this exact comment. He’s got the miracle moments on steroids, with the post season ring to make it more then just a memory. Rodgers was always one play away. Mahomes got the play and the legacy. Rodgers is an all timer but Mahomes competes with brady cause he’s the best of aaron’s superhuman moments and tom’s success so far. we’ll see for the rest of his career tho.
@avad2 I have to disagree. Aaron Rodgers has lost games where he's thrown 3 tds and 400 yards including scoring with almost no time left. With that kind of performance you shouldn't be having to make hero ball plays at the end of the game to win, thats a really bad sign of a bad team.His defense gave up over 30 points in 5 of his playoff appearances and he scored to put GB ahead or tied with almost no time left and never got to go back on the field for 3 of his playoff losses. Statistically, almost every Super bowl Champ had defenses that give up no more than 24 points a game including playoff games. Its not a tennis match, it's football. It takes all 22 players. Green Bay has built grade d teams for most of Aaron Rodgers career. They wasted that man's talent. Where Patrick Mahomes has had injuries where his team maintained success without him amd Tom Brady has had Super Bowl runs where he's throwing the ball more than 20 yards less than 10 times through the entire playoff run, setting up punts and kicks all game long. Bad QBs win Super Bowls woth good teams, it doesn't go the other way around though.
@@greatestnitemare6626 so I’m guessing you either think bradshaw, montana, brady, or peyton had bums on the secondary every time they won a super bowl or lemme guess, Dan Marino is your goat?
I’m a life long packers fan and Texas resident the only nfl game I ever went to was the 2007 Aaron rodgers game where he came in for Favre and looked good. At first we were angry cause we’d come to see Brett Favre before he retired but by the end we were happy to have a competent offense
It’s funny how his draft situation ended up because one of the reasons people point as to why Aaron Rodgers doesn’t have a second super is a lack of quality weapons, which is something the 49ers routinely have crap ton of.
This is a great video. A funny, sad, and insightful look into one of the greatest QB careers ever. Just thankful I got to witness it from start to finish
Broooooo an HOUR EPISODE!!! You’re the man tubfrog, one of the best content creators on the platform. Great research and great videos bro thank you so much!
As a packers fan, I love Aaron Rodgers and all the good things he did for us in the last decade and a half. Obviously this video was painfull for me to watch, but at this point, all that is left for the packers fans is to believe that the talent will repeat for the third time with Jordan Love and hopefully he wins more titles.
@@ZiggyZoubecause Mahomes has an all time great offense around him, one of the greatest coaches ever, and a solid defense. Without Tyreek and Kelce and Chris Jones and Andy Reid Mahomes may win a ring but definitely not as easy as he did. He's great but he's become massively overrated, dude constantly has a top 5 tight end of all time to throw to and all the help in the world, this most recent super bowl earned some respect from me but Aaron Rodgers hasn't had HALF the team mahomes has had. Outside of Jermichael Finley he's had 0 threat at tight end, up until Aaron Jones Green Bay had a godawful running game through Eddie Lacy which made them predictable, and a bottom 10 defense especially at corner. Green Bay has for most of Aaron's career been TERRIBLE at the corner position because their GM likes to be cheap. He wasn't willing to invest more and Aaron's career suffered because of it. And no, having a couple good receivers doesn't make up for the rest of your team being shit
@@ZiggyZou Sad but true. Mahomes has known how to take advantage of the opportunities that have been presented to him in his career and that is why he already has such a good record. The only thing is that like any qb, when they have not supported him, he has also suffered, just remember Super Bowl 55.
I wish I had a few more beers in my system when I watched this. For real tho, this was a great breakdown of the highs and lows of the Rodgers era in GB. That 2016 run the table season should have at least ended in a SB appearance. Rodgers was in God-mode from the second half of the season.
@gbrow1604 agreed. Packers played the falcons earlier that season, and it was a great back and forth shootout. Maybe it's me being biased, but I can't remember a more continuously snakebiten QB/team.
This show actually puts out decent football content and I’m glad to see it grow slowly but surely.. Ive seen over a dozen videos but wasn’t subscribed but now that’s changed.. I subscribed! Keep up the good work!
TubFrog is doing an excellent job. He keeps us updated on the week’s action and Tubby also makes unique videos that give a different perspective on plays, positions, the year of the season, and top players. I thoroughly enjoy and appreciate the work Tubby puts into his videos. 😊
As a packer fan born in ‘03 this video gives me immense happiness and sadness. I grew up watching Brett continue to get more washed, then was skeptical of rookie rodgers. When we won the Super Bowl I was thinking that we were going to become a dynasty. I’m glad someone is shedding light on how the packers somewhat failed rodgers and were unlucky at the same time. Packers fans have rings so it’s not all bad but it’s crazy to me how many chances we had to add a couple rings. Great video though, it reminds me of the good times but also where it all went wrong
@@josepht8746and at 5yo was skeptical of Rodgers 😂 Scientists do experiments on kids that age to see if skepticism is even in the brain yet. "Like this rock is soft" to see if they believe them lol the intricacies of draft, develop, mini camps, preseason, scouting reports....
Thank you for the video. Not an assault of distracting music, no cutesy humor. Fast paced and crisply spoken with informative content. All the best and thanks again!
You could argue McNabb was an overachiever. Reid still making terrible decisions every game, to this day. Just finally he has a guy in mahomes, who is just too good to let Reids bad play calling lose games. Mahomes is carrying Reid and alone has changed Reid legacy.
@@kenw2225 Nope... McNabb is the one that threw up in the huddle during a Super Bowl. And got called out by his own teammates for not being able to handle it.
Charles Woodson is one of my favorite DBs EVER. Put him at corner and he’ll lock you up, put him at safety with will play sideline to sideline, go across the middle and he’ll make you pay, he can come off the edge on blitzs, and when he got the ball in his hands that dude made plays. We don’t see a lot of those kinds of safety’s anymore. Unfortunately special teams aren’t really important except for field goals… we will never see a Devin Hester caliber return man, dude can change the entirety of a game off of one return. Truly 3 sides of the ball.
Like Favre before him, they're absolute stat monsters, HOF caliber QB's that seem to fall on their face in the playoffs. That meltdown against Seattle was it for me, after that I was never really willing to trust that Rodgers was anything to fear in the post season.
Tom Grossi cameo? Wow, great video. The lore of Tom Brady's photo is really funny. Your videos are sliwly getting better and better. Good work. Also you doing a collab with Tom Grossi would be really cool to see.
Literally the 49ers have had to lose 2 super bowls and 3 nfc championships since then. The team that gave gb all the heartbreak, went on to have worse heartbreak in more important games. You could argue Dallas and bills as other contenders for most heartbreak since 2011 also. But 49ers suffered the worst in the past 14 years. It's not really close.
@@Fluffy__211 Thank you! I’m really sick of the whole “Stop whining because you guys won 5 SBs already.” Last SB was 30 years ago! The 49ers are due for a 6th one.
The Packers were terrible at drafting, went a decade with a bottom 15 defense and went 12 years with a bottom 10 (mostly bottom 5) special teams. You can point out the good teammates Rogers had but The Packers failed to build a proper team. No free Agents and no trades to help subsidize for their bad drafting. The packers lacked a league average run defense , they lacked a number 2 CB and had sub-par safties for the better part of the last 12 years after the 2010 title run. Rogers gets some of the blame but really The Packer Way has been a complete failure.
As a 49er fan that just watched your Seattle video, this one is sweet. We are the Packer killer in the playoffs. I'm patiently waiting to get to that in this video. Kap, and Harbaugh, to more recent Kyle and Jimmy G. Before then it was Favre beating Steve Young and we never could beat them. We did finally with TO great catch, but i can't forget how many times Pack sent my Niners packing home. 😅
49ers fan. Love Rodgers. Like the Packers. Happy to see love play well too. Rodgers got the shaft by playing 49ers in half his playoff loses. He always had to play loaded 49ers teams in playoffs. His teams just didn't have the defense to help him vs them
FINALLY somebody notices how the defense was ASS after the superbowl win. I constantly hear stupid children who don't understand football saying "Aaron blows it in the postseason" but they never look at the defense routinely giving up 30+ points a game.
I believe that what has biased our perception towards Rodgers, is the fact that an unknown player which if you don't know his name I'm talking about TB12. What Brady do has made us see that it may have been a bad run what Rodgers and GB had. Brady made us believe that winning rings was something somehow easy when in reality it is much harder.
The biggest ding on his legacy at the end of it all will be that he played at the same time as Tom Brady, he’s had basically the same career as Brett Favre (accomplishment wise) but he did it while he was in the shadow of the best to ever do it.
And when you boil it down the real difference between the two was they both averaged 27 points per playoff game; but, one of them played with a defense that allowed 20 points per game while other's defense allowed 26.
To be clear, none of Brady's Super Bowl runs featured them winning all their playoff games by more than 6 points. So, if he's playing with a defense that allows 6 points per game more than what he had, there's a very good chance he actually has 0 Super Bowl rings.
Tom Brady had 16 and 5 top defenses top defenses in his career while Aaron Rodgers had only 1 top 10 which happened to be the year he won the SB. That’s why Rodgers didn’t win another SB for the packers!
Great video but I think there’s one small detail missing. That super bowl run when the Pack had to beat the bears in the reg season I think they also needed the Eagles to beat the giants in the last game of the season which came down to a wild decision to punt the ball to Jackson who fumbled and then picked up the muffed punt for a tuddy cementing the Packers entrance into the playoffs in which they would go on to win the chip. That’s a very wild circumstance of that whole story I think should have been highlighted, but also very detailed and great work
Rodgers is/was an absolute animal at the QB position. His statlines looked straight out of a season of Madden on easy. There is a reason that guy has so many damn MVP's.
He didnt even need luck. Just needed his team not to implode around him year after year. Bradys career on the other hand has played out like a movie script almost every year. The rams fumble it 3 possessions in a row in the second half vs the bucs. Or drew brees throwing 3 second half interceptions. Chris jones lining up offside on the play brady throws a game sealing interception. Or the tuck rule. Or the jaguars not imploding down the stretch. Or malcolm butler's game winning interception. When brady fails his team has almost always bailed him out
it is nice to see someone have an unbiased look at rodgers career. There has been so much outside of his control... there was even stuff left out of this video that all contributed to the failures of green bay. Rodgers was the reason i got into football. say what you want but tom brady never threw the ball as good as him and even mahomes probably will never do the things he has done. it take a great franchise to make a dynasty just as much as its players. and unfortunately during rodgers career the packers had everything working against them.
I like hockey more than football because all you need is one Stanley cup win to achieve greatness. No one asks “why not more?” But anyway great video brother
It's all Brady's fault. His career and sustained success is such a outlier historically that everyone just laments "why don't you win 2-3, look at Brady!" It's ridiculous
100% disagree. In general, winning a super bowl does achieve greatness. What is being argued is all time greatness. Dan Marino never won a super bowl and is considered an all time great.
@@EZR725 I legit have read on YT comments where people were giving Brady credit for the 2020 Tampa Bay defense being great. Casual fans are just idiots.
As a Pats fan I really eanted to see the 1 loss Packers meet NE in the Super Bowl. I hated that a subpar Giants team got there instead.....then I Really HATED it after the game
Glad you made mention of that meaningless Cardinals and Packers regular season game where Boldin and Woodson ended up injured with both teams needlessly hurting themselves in the long run that season. Baffling then and still baffling now.
Well one can argue that because they got scared and sat their starters from that point, is why they lost against the Giants. All the dropped passes. The whole team played rusty. Its what people reflect on when anytime in the future if we can rest our players for the playoffs...we didn't.
In NFC Championship Games: Rodgers has a TD/INT ratio of 9:7. However 5 of the 9 TDS occurred when the Packers were trailing by 21 or more-total garbage time. So in meaningful play, Rodgers had 4 touchdowns in 5 NFC CG appearances. Factor in the countless times that Rodgers went 3 and out in critical situations or kicked FGs instead of touchdowns. For those complaining about the defense, the defense handed Rodgers the championship against the Bears, the Seattle game and the 2021 SF divisional game. GB also won the turnover ratio against Seattle and Tampa-and lost both games. Rodgers has been mediocre or worse in the championship round-the stats don’t tell the whole story.
What's crazy is the Packers from 1992-2022 had an elite , all time great, top 10 quarterback starting every game and only have 2 Superbowls in that time !! For 30 years they've had a rock solid HOF QB and they only got 2 super bowls out of it , while some teams haven't had a great QB in 30+ years
Here's what happened in every 49ers match up against Rodgers in the playoffs. 1. Kap runs on them 2. a better team beat the Packers. 3. Raheem Mostert runs on the Packers 4. Special Teams.
A legendary choke in 2014, then the FO failing to reallt assemble a strong supporting cast (or even a middle-of-the-road one) for at least 6 years, then the defense choking after Brady gave them 3 picks, then Rodgers himself playing the worst playoff game in his carreer. That's how.
And now when he’s finally done in Green Bay the only team who wants him are the desperation and missery incarnate New York Jets, his childhood team starting and winning with the 2022 Mr Irrelevant. That’s fucking heartbreaking.
Aaron Rodgers, like Dan Marino, doesn't play defense, and defense wins championships. A lot of quarterbacks would have many Super Bowl rings with Bill Belichick's playoff defenses
You’re leaving out parts of the story, one it is weird that San Fran did not go with Rogers because Rogers was projected as a number one pick as leaders the night before the draft. In the fact that he was from Northern California, he was a San Fran fan/ticket holder. He was not the second best player going into the draft. Aaron Rodgers is Rated higher than Alex Smith.
Tub is the Mahomes of NFL YTers. He’s off to a Hall of Fame start, already looking like the potential goat. He hasn’t been around long enough to solidify his legacy, but he came off the bench & immediately became a superstar.
A lot of great players don't even win 1 Super Bowl. A-Rod should be able to end his career with his head held high when the time comes. In the meantime, we should wish him the best of luck in NY
Excellent take on the situation. Reasonable, thoughtful… the polar opposite of what most fans are saying. Because your average NFL fan isn’t exactly good with “logic.”
It was amazing how ARod outdueled Caleb Henie 21-14 to make his only Super Bowl. It was as epic as Peyton Manning defeating the Rex Grossman led Bears in the Super Bowl. Just think, if Lovie Smith had QBs half as good as Rodgers or Manning neither of those GOAT contenders and faces of the NFL may have had a Super Bowl.
I’m not the biggest Rodgers guy, but he beat Mike Vick’s Eagles, #1 seed Falcons with prime Matt Ryan, and prime Big Ben in that playoff run. Definitely caught a break vs the Bears but no doubt he’d best Cutler if he beat all those other superior QBs as well
I think the defense stuff is overblown. Don’t get me wrong there were certain years where they were awful, but plenty of others where they were decent/good. I mean the defense played nearly flawlessly against the 49ers in 2021 and the offense scored 10 points. In 2020, his stats look fine, but actually watching the game, he did most of that stuff once the game was already out of hand and they were down 28-10, he didn’t do much before then. Yes in the 2016 and 2019 NFC Championship, the defenses were not good in the first half, but guess what? Neither was Rodgers. He was shut out in the first half of both games which is part of why they were down so much. In the 2014 NFC Championship, he wasn’t very good either, and scored 2 total field goals in the second half. The offense did absolutely nothing. As unlucky as the onside kick was, the defense got an interception up 12 with 5 minutes left, Rodgers went 3 and out and immediately gives the ball back to Seattle. Even in the loss to the Giants he didn’t play that well despite some big breaks from the officials early on. Yes the defenses were absolutely at fault some of the years, but Rodgers often had a huge role too.
@@goldenstatewarriors9418I would disagree. When talking about Aaron Rodgers playoff losses, there’s 3 ways you can categorize them: Played well, should’ve won (had an average to elite statistical performance, lost due to entirely unique circumstances that by all means never should have happened, for instance missed penalties on a game losing play, dropped interceptions on game losing drives, etc) Didn’t play well, should’ve won (had a below average statistical performance, but despite that lost to entirely unique circumstances that by all means should not have happened) Played well, normally lost (had an average to elite statistical performance, but lost in a regular way, like the defense allowing an incredible amount of points, losing the Overtime coin toss, nothing flukey) Basically, there are games where Rodgers played great and would’ve won if not for flukey circumstances, games where Rodgers played bad but still would’ve won if not for flukey circumstances, and games where Rodgers played great but the team just wasn’t good enough. I’ll go over all the years you pointed out, and which category they belong in. Starting with: Played good, still lost. 2011 Divisional vs New York: Playing against the eventual Super Bowl Champions, Aaron Rodgers individually had a pretty decently good game. His defense absolutely sucked though, allowing a whopping 37 points. Also, his receiving core didn’t help much either, as the Packer’s receivers combined for six (6!) drops, which was actually the most dropped passes of any game in the entire 2011 season. Still, nothing unique really happened in this game, Rodgers’ receivers failed him and the defense sucked which is pretty typical, so I can’t say that Rodgers deserved to win this game. 2016 NFC Championship vs Atlanta Let’s get this out of the way, 44 points allowed on 9 possessions. For reference, that is more points allowed than Tom Brady’s defense has ever in his entire 23 year long career. Allowing 44 points is completely unacceptable. With that out of the way, the first thing people say about Rodgers’ performance is that he was shut out in the first half. The reality is that wasn’t his fault, not many people remember that Rodgers led the Packers into the redzone on both of his first 2 offensive drives of that game. The first ended in a missed field goal by his kicker, and the 2nd was thrown away by a Running back fumbling the ball away in typical Aaron Jones fashion. After the Packer’s 2nd drive, the score very well could’ve been 10-17, but instead it was 17-0, and at this point the pressure was on Rodgers the entire game, hence what some would say as a bad performance. Overall, trying to keep up with the rate at which his defense was allowing scores, whilst also battling your own teammates missing scores and turning over the ball makes this a pretty decisive ‘not his fault’ game. Though even with that being said, nothing really flukey happened, so Rodgers took the L and that was that. 2019 NFC Championship vs San Fran This is probably the most embarrassing loss for the Packers defense in the Rodgers era. The 49ers attempted, not completed, attempted just 8 passes the entire game. The Packers defense could not stop a nosebleed as they allowed nearly 300 rushing yards and 4 rushing touchdowns, allowing a pretty typical Packers defense 37 points. Aaron Rodgers, like in the last two, played decent to good, but couldn’t keep up with his defense. It’s not like something happened to justify that Rodgers should’ve won, but it certainly wasn’t his fault that they didn’t. That’s for that category, other playoff losses that fit here are: 2012 Divisional vs San Fran 2015 Divisional vs Arizona Now, games that Rodgers played bad in, but still should’ve won anyway if not for incredibly flukey moments: 2014 NFC Championship vs Seattle: The Seahawks played an absolutely dreadful early and mid game, but questionable coaching decisions on the packers side lead to many drives stalling within the 15 and settling for field goals instead of TDs. With under 5 minutes left in the game, the Packers were up 19-7. Wilson finally woke up and led a touchdown drive, making the score 19-14 with 2 minutes left in the game. All it would take the Packers to go to the super bowl is 1 onside kick recovery, but then Brandon Bostick happened. Bostick was apparently feeling himself, and attempted to play hero with a jumping catch on the onside, muffed it, and seattle recovered the ball. It only took Seattle 3 plays to score on the Packers defense again, and they converted a 2 pointer to go up 19-22. After touching the ball for the first time since being up 19-7, Rodgers’ led a game tying field goal drive with 1 minute left on the clock to work with, that sent the game into overtime. Rodgers would never touch the ball again as on the first play of OT Wilson would complete a 35 yard touchdown pass to seal the game for Seattle. There were 2 separate instances in this game where the Packers had the ball on the Seattle 1 yard line on 4th and 1, and instead of attemping a TD both were settled for Field Goals. Rodgers did not play good, and his defense for the first 3 quarters gave the offense so many chances to put the game away, regardless of the terrible coaching decisions. But here’s something I notice, Tom Brady has had a lot of really bad playoff performances, where he plays terrible for 3 quarters, but wakes up in the fourth and wins the game, everyone immediately forgets about those terrible 3 quarters, and he’s the hero of the game for winning it when it mattered most. Why don’t we praise Rodgers for doing exactly the same in this game? After coming back onto the field for the first time since being up 19-7, and under a minute on the clock, Aaron Rodgers absolutely clutches the game and saves the team from losing when it mattered most, only to never see the ball again. And of course there’s the biggest culprit, Brandon Bostick’s drop on the kick return that would’ve sealed a super bowl trip. Rodgers did not play good outside of his late game clutch drive, but the Packers deserved, and should’ve went, to the Super Bowl if not for that incredibly flukey onside kick drop. 2021 Divisional vs San Fran Rodgers’ worst performance in a playoff loss ever, and the best performance by the Packers defense in a playoff loss as well. So, why did the Packers deserve to win? What flukey moments happened? Simply put, the special teams killed the team. With a missed field goal that Rodgers & co set up, and an incredibly flukey blocked punt touchdown, the Packers’ special teams cost them 10 points in a game that was decided by 3. Rodgers played horribly, but even then he outperformed the opposing offense! He scored more points than the 49ers did! If not for the Special Team’s blocked punt, the Packers would’ve won regardless of the offensive struggles! Finally, the last category. Games where Rodgers did play good, and the team should’ve won. 2020 NFC Championship vs Tampa Bay. Where to begin with this one. CB Kevin King gave up 14 points single-handedly (including a comically mistimed jump) as well as the season-ending defensive PI call on an overthrown pass by Brady on 3rd down that otherwise would’ve meant a punt back to Green Bay. Despite Brady already throwing 3 interceptions, he also had a dropped 4th interception by Chandon Sullivan on what would become a TD drive. Aaron Jones fumbled twice, the second of which setting up the Buccs with an 8-yard TD drive, with multiple lineman illegally downfield that should have called the play back which was somehow missed, to extend their lead in the 3rd, Davante Adams dropping a game tying TD pass in the 2nd, and Aaron Rodgers’ lone interception came on a play that should’ve been called back on a missed clear defensive holding on Allen Lazard. In a single sentence, this NFC Championship is probably the single worst officiated game of all time, and somehow everyone one of those missed penalties came in extremely crucial moments (all touchdown drives or touchdown plays or turnovers) all went to the Buccaneer’s favor. There is not a game that Rodgers deserved to win more than the 2020 NFC Championship. In total, Rodgers should’ve appeared in 3 super bowl total, this year being one of them. Other playoff losses that fit into this category: 2009 Wildcard vs Arizona 2013 Wildcard vs San Fran
That wildcard game against the eagles has haunted my memories ever since. Such a sad way to end such a great duel, although obviously I'm biased as an eagles fan
When Aaron had an elite defense he won a championship. Got to keep in mind the game has evolved so much since then. It wasn’t just a track meet like it is today.
Another interesting video would be about Ditka's Bears from the '80s and examining how, despite that great defense, they only managed to win one Super Bowl.
Favre was worse. He was part of a team that won one Super Bowl. People tend to forget The Pack had a # 2 D in 1996; so that win wasn't about Favre. The year after, he threw INT to lose the Super Bowl against The Broncos. After that, he's thrown INT in every playoff game he was in. How that constitutes he to be on top 5 or 10 and Hall of famer is beyond me.
Having Marino, Elway, & Unitas a whole damn tier below Rodgers & Brees is insulting. Lets respect eras here & appreciate what those "tier 3" qbs did in a more dominating & physical era where rules didnt baby the qb position.
As a Bengals fan, if joey B goes the rodgers route and could just get us one SB while being consistent for a number of years, id be happy. That being said, it is WILD that GB has had two all-time greats (on the field, fuck favre) for the last 30 years and have only gotten two rings out of it.
I think overall the colts are worse. Only 1 Super Bowl with Peyton Manning and they completely ruined luck. Also only 2 rings between Peyton and Unitas. At least the packers have 4 rings going back to Bart Starr.
@@MAVJ for the 2000s I agree that’s pretty astonishing, but I feel like in the 2010s Ben should have won at least one more with all the talent the Steelers had in the early-mid 2010s.
I estimated that Rodgers would win 3 SBs when he won his 1st if he stayed healthy. He did but fell so short of returning so many times. Tom Grossi's tribute video for Rodgers is so good, almost choked me up and im a Broncos fan lol
I still remember when he took over and damn did he get so much hate from the fans! Nobody gave him a chance and they all wanted Farve back. It was a pretty sad moment but I think that's what motivated him the most to become the best. I don't think a lot of people fully understands what he went through and overcame to get to where he's at. I think this is why he loves proving people wrong because it's always been the way things have been since the very beginning. He's definitely given Green Bay everything he had but I think the front office have failed him big time by never going all out to give him the defense and weapons he needed to win Superbowls. Rodgers never had a top 5 defense like Brady had except for 2010 when he won it all! GB seriously could and should of been able to build a dynasty with Rodgers. I hope that system starts to change and start doing what matters most when the time comes for this next era.
The ineptness of two titles in 30 seasons of hall of fame quarterback play. It was quite a ride, but damn. Should have brought home more hardware. Btw - why does this guy record in his daughters bedroom in front of that…portrait?
Listen, idc how good rodgers was in 2014, JJ watt was literally the MOST VALUABLE PLAYER IN 2014. Dude scored on offense and defense. Like how does that not warrant MVP?
Rodgers choked hard vs the Seahawks with Russ throwing 4 Fing picks and losing a fumble aka that’s 5 TOS in one game bruh if you are a MVP QB you gotta play like it especially with the other QB playing like crap till the last couple minutes(that or you should take pay cuts to help make the team better or keep vets and rookies or bring in free agents)
One thing not really noted was the playoff game against the Vikings and Joe Webb was a sign of what was to come against Kaepernick. Webb was gashing the Packer's defense with his legs but the Vikings inexplicably refused to lean on that and continued to have him ineffectively try to throw the ball.
It's very weird for me, a Bears fan, to have decided to give you a sub because of an Aaron Rogers vid..... but your research and delivery is so damn thorough.... if it's cool with you bro. Imma tell my friends it was because of the Raiders vid, but you'll know the truth, bud. You got a Bears fan to sub you off a Packers vid. Well done.
Great video! But sadly that’s just how it goes in the NFL, multiple amazing QBs have come up short somehow and not won a Super Bowl or only won 1 Super Bowl. It’s a team sport, but it’s just so strange bc a lot of the teams they played in the playoffs weren’t even good. Who’s to say if he even made it to the Super Bowl he would’ve won, it would’ve been vs hard teams like the Pats, Steelers, Kansas city, and other teams that were meant to win regardless of who they played
New York is only going to last a year. He will be traded again or retire after this year. When they are 2-4 and the media is harassing him he's going to snap
If aaron rodgers wins a super bowl with the jets I'm going to lose my marbles
I think that the Jets winning a Super Bowl with Aaron Rodgers is more likely than picking Nick Fowles to win a Super Bowl MVP in the 2016 offseason. TL:DR anything can happen especially when considering the NFL scriptwriters. Love your content! Keep it up 👍
It depends on what the script writers will do this year
why matt stafford did it first year on the rams it’s not completely implausible he’s carried pretty mid teams to an nfc champ many times and came up just short im not gonna act like none of them can be his fault too but his team should get credit where crudit is due it’s genuinely surprising he hasn’t been back not even once, and way to clickbait with the title “the downfall of arod” bro has not had a downfall on the field he’s been to many many nfcs and just came up short which isn’t arod having a downfall you don’t win mvps late in ur career AND take ur team to nfc champs while ALSO having the lowest int rate, gimmie a break guy you just deceiving ppl atp 😭😭
@@KrispigKarpi’ve not seen any other vids but this vid is a load of 💩 💀 look at my other reply on this comment to get the full perspective on how this guy clickbaited and majorly deceived ppl
I'll be unanimously elected president of the USA before the jets win another superbowl.
Ok we HAVE to discuss Tom in the background
It was hard to keep my eyes off him. Should’ve had a face cam of Tom for the whole hour.
@@schmidtytimedo it like the Manning cast but with him and tom
I saw this before the video started and now I’m like 😩
I didn’t even know there was a video about Aaron Rodgers going on next to the Tom image
I mean Brady is the best looking dude in NFL history.. he’s just paying his respect where it’s due..
In my opinion, it all went downhill after 2014. After that collapse vs the Seahawks, the team couldn’t recover from it. 2020 and 2021 were the only realistic chances of winning since then and we choked it away.
Took me years to get over that loss. I legit repressed those memories. That loss was devastating. Couldnt let myself get that attached again.
It was a strange baton handoff of devastating losses that postseason. First the cowboys with the infamous dez Bryant catch, then the packers infamous meltdown, and then the seahawks with the worst interception thrown in post season history. One of the few times I was happy with tom brady winning
@@donsolosThe lions cowboys game had controversy as well before that lol.
I still can’t watch that 2014 game I had to skip it fast on those clips
@@donsolosseahawks fan here. Then next in the sb seahawks lost just as badly to pats. These playoffs were crazy.
I blame GreenBays front office and their business practices. Never relying on trades, never drafting high in the draft for Receivers, and always sticking with bad personel.
Look at Peyton Manning’s early playoff record. John elway back in the day used to get crushed in super bowls. We don’t consider Aaron an all time great just because he can win super bowls. Dan marino went to one and never got back. We consider him an all time great because he can win games on any given Sunday, carry a team in crisis, win the division consistently, and get you to the postseason. And Aaron has does all of that. He has the second most MVPs for a reason.
@bananaman5668 true. I just find it stupid when people just blindly go “oh we’ll have the conversation when he gets to 3 or 4 rings.” As if Tom Brady (no offense) didn’t have an all time defense led by an all time coach. And as of Tom Brady didn’t have a 10 year gap between his third and fourth rings.
Rodgers is 2nd all time for playoff touchdowns and has a playoff QB rating of over 100. all of this playoff stats are better than cry baby brady except "football fans" have no clue about any of it
@bananaman5668that's the problem. Aaron didn't get that great team. Green Bay for most of his career were horrible at running back, and embarrassingly bad at the corner position because their GM is cheap. Aaron didn't walk into a top 10 defense and a solid core like these other guys did. Mahomes had Tyreek, Kelce, Chris Jones. Montana had Rice, Ronnie Lott. Brady had Moss, Edelman, Gronk, Donta Hightower, the greatest kicker ever. Manning had Welker, Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Von Miller. These dudes had legitimate hall of fame help. Aaron didn't, so it's people who are casuals who underrated Aaron Rodgers. By the time Green Bay finally got a defense they had no receivers. Green Bay in 2010 was great and obviously thats why they won, but in the next 3-4 years their defense absolutely fell apart. Their defense allowed 37 POINTS A GAME in their losses. That's over 5 touchdowns. It's ridiculous to expect someone to drop 3-400 yards and 4 touchdowns along with opening up the run game to win games when Brady at points was dropping 175-225 yards and 1 touchdown, and winning the game.
Frankly all have great points in this thread from their POV.
Peyton and Marino got criticized for the same thing. The reason it doesn’t hurt Peyton as much anymore is because looking at the entire career of every QB, if you take out the postseason, Peyton is pretty much the perfect QB. He was the smartest QB, revolutionized calling the plays on the line of scrimmage, consistently won with different coaches in the regular season, and succeeded at the highest level with two different teams. The postseason is the only knock on Manning but it’s a big one.
I'm REALLY glad you talked about the Nick Collins injury. I feel that goes UNDERLOOKED when talking about the 2011 Packers, because I feel with him, we wouldn't have been as bad on defense in that year and years after in the safety room. That was SUCH a huge loss that I feel not many people talk about. This was a really awesome video!
That very year, they were upset by the Giants in the divisional round. A major part of the loss was two huge TDs they gave up to Hakeen Nicks. Both TDs were the result of horrible secondary breakdowns. It's very likely that they win with Nick Collins.
He was definitely an integral part of the packers defense and a huge loss that people tend to forget about
@@gbrow1604I was at that playoff game.
Ouch.
Collins was soo good. Huge loss.
#1 in takeaways. BJ Raji, charles woodson, clay matthews III
Aaron Rodgers won a Super Bowl when I was in 5th grade. I’m 24.
People age. Not exclusive to you. You’re not special.
@@Disxreet a cool tidbit about his longevity if anything, not meant to disparage. I’ll try to rephrase the point in the future if that’s the effect it had.
Did you get held back? If you were 24, wouldn’t you be in 6th grade when they won the SB?
i'm 26 smh
@@Nazisarelamehe’s a rodgers butthurt fanboy
Packers Playoff losses in the Rodgers era ranked by most heartbreaking:
1. 2014 NFC Championship vs Seahawks
This one takes the cake, no contest. Rodgers was the MVP that year, and the the defense picked of Wilson FOUR TIMES. And then the onside kick happens and they blow a game that they were nearly guaranteed to win, with a chance to go back to the Super Bowl. I also think this loss had a truly cursed feeling and had a ripple effect that culminated in several disappointing seasons after.
2. 2020 NFC Championship vs Bucs
This was probably the best all around team the Packers had after 2010, Rodgers put up one of the best seasons ever, and just when the NFC looked wide open with Brees looking washed, the 49ers and Rams riddled with injuries, and the Seahawks suffering an embarrassing upset, Brady walks into the NFC and in his FIRST YEAR, goes to Lambeau and beats them, winning as many NFC Championships as the Packers did in the entire Rodgers era.
3. 2011 Divisional Round vs Giants
This could’ve been higher but those Giants teams were something special. This might’ve been the best team in totality, but their defense was horrendous, the 2010, 2020, and 2021 teams were all more balanced. However the receiving corps and offensive weapons on this team were ridiculous, Rodgers had maybe the best QB season ever (I disagree but it has a case). 15-1 and lost their first Playoff game.
4. 2021 Divisional Round vs 49ers
Their last chance, the defense played close to perfect, but Rodgers couldn’t get more than 10 points, and the special teams have a punt and FG blocked, as well as only having 10 guys to contest the game winning FG.
5. 2012 Divisional Round vs 49ers
Kaepernick set the all time record for rush yards by a QB in a game, this was a demolition job back when the Packers were still viewed as serious contenders and were favored before the season to win it all.
6. 2016 NFC Championship vs Falcons
The Falcons historic passing offense obliterated them, and the Packers offense was shut out in the first half by a terrible defense. Atlanta was clearly better but this was a harsh end to the 8 straight wins that put the red hot Packers in position to return to the Super Bowl.
7. 2019 NFC Championship vs 49ers
The Packers had no chance of winning this game and were lucky to be here in the first place. Rodgers had clearly taken a downturn over the previous two seasons and they squeezed out a bunch of one score victories. They were nowhere near the level of the 49ers or Chiefs, and their run defense got completely exposed, as the 49ers run game demolished them while throwing only 8 times. It was over when it was 27-0 at halftime.
8. 2015 Divisional vs Cardinals
I guess losing a game where Rodgers throws two Hail Mary’s sucks, but they had no chance this year, the Panthers would’ve demolished them anyway.
9. 2013 Wild Card vs 49ers
Once again they didn’t have much of a chance this year either and it was in the Wild Card.
10. 2009 Wild Card vs Cardinals
Honestly, this just showed how great Rodgers could be and he hadn’t emerged yet.
Great job of showing how big a choke Aaron is. This is why, while he is a great QB, I will never consider him an all time great except as a prima dona.
@@winoodlesnoodles1984 you shouldnt share your opinions out loud with other people. Good lord you are a horribly negative person. Just showed up to fan that flame of hatred huh? Shows how much you got going on in your life... whoops did I say that out loud? 🥶🥶🥶
The loss to the 49ers in 2021 is the second worse loss. All they had to do was avoid the special teams shitting the bed. But 2 years in a row the packers horrible special teams got severely outplayed by one of the other leagues worst special team units. And matt lafleur just completely ignored the problem. Packers just miraculously always find a way to lose in dramatic fashion when it comes to the playoffs. It was the same with favre
@@donsolosAgreed-All they would have had to do was beat Matthew Stafford/Rams at Lambeau the following week to get the SB.
*Lambeau
2012-2016 was beyond painful to watch. The 2015 loss consisted of me watching that punching a locker, 3 others screaming in a room, and 2 guys fighting over a knife and one getting his hand cut in half nearly. All within 3 seconds.
bro i was so fucking mad
the 2014 loss had me in tears and the 2016 loss had me done with football
@@ghoul5371 I’m definitely wasn’t done lol but packers have certainly been perennially underperforming. Which is strange because if you consider a “dynasty” but a core team who consistently tops, not Super Bowl winners, then packers from 2010- basically 2017 were a dynasty. Just minus the super bowls but always always a Super Bowl favorite. Same with Seahawks and 49s during same time. Love the packers and excited to see basically and entirely new team from the team we’ve seen for the past 17 years. Only names remaining are players who were drafted in mid 2010s as the oldest players. A very young team with tons of potential. And now I gotta root for jets too!
@@ma.2099yeah that’s what I always say we were literally the patriots of the nfc just without the bowls we got to championship games left and right and we’re the only team in the playoffs every year from 2009-2017 besides the patriots😂💯
@@ma.2099but hey man I’ve learned to appreciate the wins they got us in that time and we still had 1 at one point we won 19 games in a row at one point from the end of 2010 through most of 2011 he gets one with the jets and what are people gonna say then lol he just needs 2💯
I think the main issue with the Packers is a reluctance to move on from bad coaches. They did it with Dom Capers, and their new defensive coordinator seems to be repeating
We hired the same D coordinator that was the coordinator on the 0-16 Lions. Im still so confused how anyone thought that would be a good idea.
@@samthemessiah9330yeah not a good hiring practice. We don’t move on when we need to. FeelsBadMan
God spared us. We got Rodgers vs Big Ben when it coulda been Jay Cutler vs Mark Sanchez 🙏😂
Romans 10:9-10.
I'm a bears fan and I don't which is worse: Us losing a trip to the super bowl to our 6 seed divisional rival, or having to see Cutler fumble our second super bowl in 5 years.
Patrick Mahomes is having the career everone thought Aaron Rodgers would've had
i was digging for this exact comment. He’s got the miracle moments on steroids, with the post season ring to make it more then just a memory. Rodgers was always one play away. Mahomes got the play and the legacy. Rodgers is an all timer but Mahomes competes with brady cause he’s the best of aaron’s superhuman moments and tom’s success so far. we’ll see for the rest of his career tho.
@avad2 I have to disagree. Aaron Rodgers has lost games where he's thrown 3 tds and 400 yards including scoring with almost no time left. With that kind of performance you shouldn't be having to make hero ball plays at the end of the game to win, thats a really bad sign of a bad team.His defense gave up over 30 points in 5 of his playoff appearances and he scored to put GB ahead or tied with almost no time left and never got to go back on the field for 3 of his playoff losses. Statistically, almost every Super bowl Champ had defenses that give up no more than 24 points a game including playoff games. Its not a tennis match, it's football. It takes all 22 players. Green Bay has built grade d teams for most of Aaron Rodgers career. They wasted that man's talent. Where Patrick Mahomes has had injuries where his team maintained success without him amd Tom Brady has had Super Bowl runs where he's throwing the ball more than 20 yards less than 10 times through the entire playoff run, setting up punts and kicks all game long. Bad QBs win Super Bowls woth good teams, it doesn't go the other way around though.
@@avad2Mahomes does not make Rodgers esque plays lol. Gtfo man. Rodgers had bums and a trash coach in 2010s
@@avad2Mahomes is getting saved by his defense. Dude has been mid for the past couple of years
@@greatestnitemare6626 so I’m guessing you either think bradshaw, montana, brady, or peyton had bums on the secondary every time they won a super bowl
or lemme guess, Dan Marino is your goat?
The shoutout to Nick Collins made this video perfect. The LB coach with Clay in the superbowl gave me chills. What a great video bro.
I’m a life long packers fan and Texas resident the only nfl game I ever went to was the 2007 Aaron rodgers game where he came in for Favre and looked good. At first we were angry cause we’d come to see Brett Favre before he retired but by the end we were happy to have a competent offense
It’s funny how his draft situation ended up because one of the reasons people point as to why Aaron Rodgers doesn’t have a second super is a lack of quality weapons, which is something the 49ers routinely have crap ton of.
Rodgers probably wins 4 super bowls if he's drafter by 49ers. 2011, 2012, 2019, 2022. He at least has 2.
This is a great video. A funny, sad, and insightful look into one of the greatest QB careers ever. Just thankful I got to witness it from start to finish
Broooooo an HOUR EPISODE!!! You’re the man tubfrog, one of the best content creators on the platform. Great research and great videos bro thank you so much!
As a packers fan, I love Aaron Rodgers and all the good things he did for us in the last decade and a half. Obviously this video was painfull for me to watch, but at this point, all that is left for the packers fans is to believe that the talent will repeat for the third time with Jordan Love and hopefully he wins more titles.
As a chiefs fan it’s weird that mahomes has as many super bowls as Rodgers and Favre combined in 30 years.
Mahomes did it in 5 years
@@ZiggyZoubecause Mahomes has an all time great offense around him, one of the greatest coaches ever, and a solid defense. Without Tyreek and Kelce and Chris Jones and Andy Reid Mahomes may win a ring but definitely not as easy as he did. He's great but he's become massively overrated, dude constantly has a top 5 tight end of all time to throw to and all the help in the world, this most recent super bowl earned some respect from me but Aaron Rodgers hasn't had HALF the team mahomes has had. Outside of Jermichael Finley he's had 0 threat at tight end, up until Aaron Jones Green Bay had a godawful running game through Eddie Lacy which made them predictable, and a bottom 10 defense especially at corner. Green Bay has for most of Aaron's career been TERRIBLE at the corner position because their GM likes to be cheap. He wasn't willing to invest more and Aaron's career suffered because of it. And no, having a couple good receivers doesn't make up for the rest of your team being shit
@T_Chainz Well that was you just walking in to toot your horn on a post with no relevancy. Lol
Good for him though.
@@ZiggyZou Sad but true. Mahomes has known how to take advantage of the opportunities that have been presented to him in his career and that is why he already has such a good record. The only thing is that like any qb, when they have not supported him, he has also suffered, just remember Super Bowl 55.
@@tropicmix8765same thing could be said about Brady: ATG coach, ATG TE, HOF skill positions on defense. It’s football man
I wish I had a few more beers in my system when I watched this. For real tho, this was a great breakdown of the highs and lows of the Rodgers era in GB. That 2016 run the table season should have at least ended in a SB appearance. Rodgers was in God-mode from the second half of the season.
I really think that if Crosby doesn't miss the easy FG and Ripkowski doesn't fumble, that game would have at least been a lot closer.
@gbrow1604 agreed. Packers played the falcons earlier that season, and it was a great back and forth shootout. Maybe it's me being biased, but I can't remember a more continuously snakebiten QB/team.
I remember the packers being down to a 4th string and practice squad players at corner by the end of that season. I know the Falcons would kill us.
This show actually puts out decent football content and I’m glad to see it grow slowly but surely.. Ive seen over a dozen videos but wasn’t subscribed but now that’s changed.. I subscribed! Keep up the good work!
TubFrog is doing an excellent job. He keeps us updated on the week’s action and Tubby also makes unique videos that give a different perspective on plays, positions, the year of the season, and top players. I thoroughly enjoy and appreciate the work Tubby puts into his videos. 😊
As a packer fan born in ‘03 this video gives me immense happiness and sadness. I grew up watching Brett continue to get more washed, then was skeptical of rookie rodgers. When we won the Super Bowl I was thinking that we were going to become a dynasty. I’m glad someone is shedding light on how the packers somewhat failed rodgers and were unlucky at the same time. Packers fans have rings so it’s not all bad but it’s crazy to me how many chances we had to add a couple rings. Great video though, it reminds me of the good times but also where it all went wrong
I feel you brother. All the memories over the past years
You were 5 years old when Rodgers started his first game, you didn’t grow up watching Favre lmao
@@josepht8746and at 5yo was skeptical of Rodgers 😂
Scientists do experiments on kids that age to see if skepticism is even in the brain yet. "Like this rock is soft" to see if they believe them lol the intricacies of draft, develop, mini camps, preseason, scouting reports....
You'll look back on your comment with embarrassment when you start shaving.
Thank you for the video. Not an assault of distracting music, no cutesy humor. Fast paced and crisply spoken with informative content. All the best and thanks again!
A video about how Donovan McNabb was one of the greatest choke artists in the history of the NFL would be cool.
Ah yes… McFlabb I forgot about him.
You could argue McNabb was an overachiever. Reid still making terrible decisions every game, to this day. Just finally he has a guy in mahomes, who is just too good to let Reids bad play calling lose games. Mahomes is carrying Reid and alone has changed Reid legacy.
@@kenw2225 Nope... McNabb is the one that threw up in the huddle during a Super Bowl. And got called out by his own teammates for not being able to handle it.
Romans 10:9-10.
@@blickedxbWasn’t that just a rumor though ?
Under 50k subs?! Outrageous. Let's get this man more Subs, because he's criminally underrated.
Charles Woodson is one of my favorite DBs EVER. Put him at corner and he’ll lock you up, put him at safety with will play sideline to sideline, go across the middle and he’ll make you pay, he can come off the edge on blitzs, and when he got the ball in his hands that dude made plays. We don’t see a lot of those kinds of safety’s anymore. Unfortunately special teams aren’t really important except for field goals… we will never see a Devin Hester caliber return man, dude can change the entirety of a game off of one return. Truly 3 sides of the ball.
Like Favre before him, they're absolute stat monsters, HOF caliber QB's that seem to fall on their face in the playoffs. That meltdown against Seattle was it for me, after that I was never really willing to trust that Rodgers was anything to fear in the post season.
Big factssssssss!!!! 💯💯💯
He was injured in that playoff run lol what, and never saw the ball in OT
He definitely had his chances but you can’t disregard all the times he took GB further than they should have in the playoffs. 2016 is a major example.
HOF caliber???? Foh you mean locks
At 17:25 the little blip of 28-3 really takes the cake
Ngl that made me giggle
Tom Grossi cameo? Wow, great video. The lore of Tom Brady's photo is really funny. Your videos are sliwly getting better and better. Good work. Also you doing a collab with Tom Grossi would be really cool to see.
One of my favorite new channels I've stumbled upon. Love your stuff dood 🤙
Since that Super Bowl, no team has has more playoff heartbreak than the Packers.
real
The saints would like to talk 😂
Literally the 49ers have had to lose 2 super bowls and 3 nfc championships since then. The team that gave gb all the heartbreak, went on to have worse heartbreak in more important games. You could argue Dallas and bills as other contenders for most heartbreak since 2011 also. But 49ers suffered the worst in the past 14 years. It's not really close.
@@kenw2225Finally… someone mentions how much pain we have been through. Everyone says, you’ve won 5 super bowls… not in 30 years….
@@Fluffy__211
Thank you!
I’m really sick of the whole “Stop whining because you guys won 5 SBs already.”
Last SB was 30 years ago! The 49ers are due for a 6th one.
The Packers were terrible at drafting, went a decade with a bottom 15 defense and went 12 years with a bottom 10 (mostly bottom 5) special teams. You can point out the good teammates Rogers had but The Packers failed to build a proper team. No free Agents and no trades to help subsidize for their bad drafting. The packers lacked a league average run defense , they lacked a number 2 CB and had sub-par safties for the better part of the last 12 years after the 2010 title run.
Rogers gets some of the blame but really The Packer Way has been a complete failure.
As a 49er fan that just watched your Seattle video, this one is sweet. We are the Packer killer in the playoffs. I'm patiently waiting to get to that in this video.
Kap, and Harbaugh, to more recent Kyle and Jimmy G.
Before then it was Favre beating Steve Young and we never could beat them. We did finally with TO great catch, but i can't forget how many times Pack sent my Niners packing home. 😅
As someone who's been a Packers fan since '08, I probably hate San Francisco more than any other team. That 2021-22 divisional game still kills me.
49ers fan. Love Rodgers. Like the Packers. Happy to see love play well too. Rodgers got the shaft by playing 49ers in half his playoff loses. He always had to play loaded 49ers teams in playoffs. His teams just didn't have the defense to help him vs them
FINALLY somebody notices how the defense was ASS after the superbowl win. I constantly hear stupid children who don't understand football saying "Aaron blows it in the postseason" but they never look at the defense routinely giving up 30+ points a game.
He chokes as well
I believe that what has biased our perception towards Rodgers, is the fact that an unknown player which if you don't know his name I'm talking about TB12. What Brady do has made us see that it may have been a bad run what Rodgers and GB had. Brady made us believe that winning rings was something somehow easy when in reality it is much harder.
The biggest ding on his legacy at the end of it all will be that he played at the same time as Tom Brady, he’s had basically the same career as Brett Favre (accomplishment wise) but he did it while he was in the shadow of the best to ever do it.
And when you boil it down the real difference between the two was they both averaged 27 points per playoff game; but, one of them played with a defense that allowed 20 points per game while other's defense allowed 26.
@@bonesawisready684no the main difference is one showed up in the post season, the other one didn't
To be clear, none of Brady's Super Bowl runs featured them winning all their playoff games by more than 6 points.
So, if he's playing with a defense that allows 6 points per game more than what he had, there's a very good chance he actually has 0 Super Bowl rings.
That’s crazy because wasn’t Brett Favre‘s last throw as the QB for
Minnesota Vikings an interception as well??
Tom Brady had 16 and 5 top defenses top defenses in his career while Aaron Rodgers had only 1 top 10 which happened to be the year he won the SB. That’s why Rodgers didn’t win another SB for the packers!
Great video but I think there’s one small detail missing. That super bowl run when the Pack had to beat the bears in the reg season I think they also needed the Eagles to beat the giants in the last game of the season which came down to a wild decision to punt the ball to Jackson who fumbled and then picked up the muffed punt for a tuddy cementing the Packers entrance into the playoffs in which they would go on to win the chip. That’s a very wild circumstance of that whole story I think should have been highlighted, but also very detailed and great work
You made me relive my pain all while having my soul touched by Brady
Rodgers is/was an absolute animal at the QB position. His statlines looked straight out of a season of Madden on easy. There is a reason that guy has so many damn MVP's.
If Aaron Rogers had even half the luck Tom Brady has had in the playoffs, he would have like 3 rings atleast
He didnt even need luck. Just needed his team not to implode around him year after year.
Bradys career on the other hand has played out like a movie script almost every year. The rams fumble it 3 possessions in a row in the second half vs the bucs. Or drew brees throwing 3 second half interceptions. Chris jones lining up offside on the play brady throws a game sealing interception. Or the tuck rule. Or the jaguars not imploding down the stretch. Or malcolm butler's game winning interception.
When brady fails his team has almost always bailed him out
Thanks for helping me relive what I thought I forgot. Dude I'm very impressed with your.vids and being so young. Keep killing it
the packers draft philosophy was been to always draft the best player available regardless of they need someone at that position or not
That's not true , they reload the WR core about every 3-4 years and get rid of there most expensive WR since Rodgers has been QB.
it is nice to see someone have an unbiased look at rodgers career. There has been so much outside of his control... there was even stuff left out of this video that all contributed to the failures of green bay. Rodgers was the reason i got into football. say what you want but tom brady never threw the ball as good as him and even mahomes probably will never do the things he has done. it take a great franchise to make a dynasty just as much as its players. and unfortunately during rodgers career the packers had everything working against them.
Brady is on a higher level compared to this bum.
I like hockey more than football because all you need is one Stanley cup win to achieve greatness. No one asks “why not more?” But anyway great video brother
It's all Brady's fault. His career and sustained success is such a outlier historically that everyone just laments "why don't you win 2-3, look at Brady!" It's ridiculous
@@jacobwilliams1223not realizing how rare of a perfect storm 2000's New England was
100% disagree. In general, winning a super bowl does achieve greatness. What is being argued is all time greatness. Dan Marino never won a super bowl and is considered an all time great.
And it's also dumb given how Football is the sport where your best player has the least impact on the outcome of a game by far
@@EZR725 I legit have read on YT comments where people were giving Brady credit for the 2020 Tampa Bay defense being great. Casual fans are just idiots.
You can re-live your life when watching these docs, year by year, memories from each year. Beautiful.
As a Pats fan I really eanted to see the 1 loss Packers meet NE in the Super Bowl. I hated that a subpar Giants team got there instead.....then I Really HATED it after the game
I wanted to see them in 2014 play in the Super Bowl
Sucks to suck
Jay Cutler, mr Olympia 4X , and former bronco QB , bodybuilding sensation!
Glad you made mention of that meaningless Cardinals and Packers regular season game where Boldin and Woodson ended up injured with both teams needlessly hurting themselves in the long run that season. Baffling then and still baffling now.
Well one can argue that because they got scared and sat their starters from that point, is why they lost against the Giants. All the dropped passes. The whole team played rusty. Its what people reflect on when anytime in the future if we can rest our players for the playoffs...we didn't.
That Aaron rodgers v Carson Palmer playoff game is one of the best games I’ve ever watched
In NFC Championship Games: Rodgers has a TD/INT ratio of 9:7. However 5 of the 9 TDS occurred when the Packers were trailing by 21 or more-total garbage time. So in meaningful play, Rodgers had 4 touchdowns in 5 NFC CG appearances. Factor in the countless times that Rodgers went 3 and out in critical situations or kicked FGs instead of touchdowns. For those complaining about the defense, the defense handed Rodgers the championship against the Bears, the Seattle game and the 2021 SF divisional game. GB also won the turnover ratio against Seattle and Tampa-and lost both games. Rodgers has been mediocre or worse in the championship round-the stats don’t tell the whole story.
Tom in the back is scary
Legend has it Brady’s son has that exact same picture on his wall
Binged all the videos of yours I didn’t see yet last night so thanks for keeping the party going
What's crazy is the Packers from 1992-2022 had an elite , all time great, top 10 quarterback starting every game and only have 2 Superbowls in that time !! For 30 years they've had a rock solid HOF QB and they only got 2 super bowls out of it , while some teams haven't had a great QB in 30+ years
it’s crazy to me eli manning has as many SB as the packers era favre and rodgers combined!
@@penguinsinorbit2034 Yeah its mind blowing lol
Looks like Rodgers groomed love to be an all time great also. He's probably gonna win a super bowl himself. If they can ever best 49ers
@@kenw2225 yup !
@@kenw2225 I think Love have what it take to finally beat the niners.
Excited for a new upload. This guy is reaching 50K….. I subscribed when he was at 17K.
Keep growing .... with the good content, TubFrog!
Keep up the great work🔥🔥💥🔥
Here's what happened in every 49ers match up against Rodgers in the playoffs.
1. Kap runs on them
2. a better team beat the Packers.
3. Raheem Mostert runs on the Packers
4. Special Teams.
A legendary choke in 2014, then the FO failing to reallt assemble a strong supporting cast (or even a middle-of-the-road one) for at least 6 years, then the defense choking after Brady gave them 3 picks, then Rodgers himself playing the worst playoff game in his carreer. That's how.
Never forget that Aaron Rodgers last completed pass as a packer was to a Detroit Lions defender
Last completed pass period
His childhood team just completely owning him over and over is rough.
And now when he’s finally done in Green Bay the only team who wants him are the desperation and missery incarnate New York Jets, his childhood team starting and winning with the 2022 Mr Irrelevant.
That’s fucking heartbreaking.
Aaron Rodgers, like Dan Marino, doesn't play defense, and defense wins championships.
A lot of quarterbacks would have many Super Bowl rings with Bill Belichick's playoff defenses
You’re leaving out parts of the story, one it is weird that San Fran did not go with Rogers because Rogers was projected as a number one pick as leaders the night before the draft. In the fact that he was from Northern California, he was a San Fran fan/ticket holder. He was not the second best player going into the draft. Aaron Rodgers is Rated higher than Alex Smith.
The c in eviscerated is silent. Great content, man!
21:34 “I didn’t fumble, I was separated from the ball” -rashad mendenhall
RESPECT MY CAREER!
God what a random and dumb hill to die on lol
This was worth the 1hr. Great video 🎉
Nothing hurts more than the Seahawks loss……. But I remember all these games.
Loving all of your content Tubby, keep it up man
Tub is the Mahomes of NFL YTers. He’s off to a Hall of Fame start, already looking like the potential goat. He hasn’t been around long enough to solidify his legacy, but he came off the bench & immediately became a superstar.
@@jluchetteMahomes never will be the goat
A lot of great players don't even win 1 Super Bowl. A-Rod should be able to end his career with his head held high when the time comes. In the meantime, we should wish him the best of luck in NY
Excellent take on the situation. Reasonable, thoughtful… the polar opposite of what most fans are saying. Because your average NFL fan isn’t exactly good with “logic.”
17:26 I love the random 28-3 reference for a split second
The forbidden 28-3 reference.
It was amazing how ARod outdueled Caleb Henie 21-14 to make his only Super Bowl. It was as epic as Peyton Manning defeating the Rex Grossman led Bears in the Super Bowl. Just think, if Lovie Smith had QBs half as good as Rodgers or Manning neither of those GOAT contenders and faces of the NFL may have had a Super Bowl.
I’m not the biggest Rodgers guy, but he beat Mike Vick’s Eagles, #1 seed Falcons with prime Matt Ryan, and prime Big Ben in that playoff run. Definitely caught a break vs the Bears but no doubt he’d best Cutler if he beat all those other superior QBs as well
Oh hell yeah boys we got a TubFrog drop today I'm canceling my plans and pressing play!! I was gonna cancel anyways but now I got a banger to watch 🤪
Still pisses me off to even remember the Dez Bryant heist
That was a catch
1:09 holy crap, Daunte Culpepper. I used to love that guy.
In conclusion, Rodgers lack of defenses, a single bad performance in 2021, and special teams is why he never won another
Yep. It's conclusive.
Worst ST I've ever seen.
I think the defense stuff is overblown. Don’t get me wrong there were certain years where they were awful, but plenty of others where they were decent/good. I mean the defense played nearly flawlessly against the 49ers in 2021 and the offense scored 10 points. In 2020, his stats look fine, but actually watching the game, he did most of that stuff once the game was already out of hand and they were down 28-10, he didn’t do much before then. Yes in the 2016 and 2019 NFC Championship, the defenses were not good in the first half, but guess what? Neither was Rodgers. He was shut out in the first half of both games which is part of why they were down so much. In the 2014 NFC Championship, he wasn’t very good either, and scored 2 total field goals in the second half. The offense did absolutely nothing. As unlucky as the onside kick was, the defense got an interception up 12 with 5 minutes left, Rodgers went 3 and out and immediately gives the ball back to Seattle. Even in the loss to the Giants he didn’t play that well despite some big breaks from the officials early on. Yes the defenses were absolutely at fault some of the years, but Rodgers often had a huge role too.
@@goldenstatewarriors9418I would disagree. When talking about Aaron Rodgers playoff losses, there’s 3 ways you can categorize them:
Played well, should’ve won (had an average to elite statistical performance, lost due to entirely unique circumstances that by all means never should have happened, for instance missed penalties on a game losing play, dropped interceptions on game losing drives, etc)
Didn’t play well, should’ve won (had a below average statistical performance, but despite that lost to entirely unique circumstances that by all means should not have happened)
Played well, normally lost (had an average to elite statistical performance, but lost in a regular way, like the defense allowing an incredible amount of points, losing the Overtime coin toss, nothing flukey)
Basically, there are games where Rodgers played great and would’ve won if not for flukey circumstances, games where Rodgers played bad but still would’ve won if not for flukey circumstances, and games where Rodgers played great but the team just wasn’t good enough. I’ll go over all the years you pointed out, and which category they belong in.
Starting with: Played good, still lost.
2011 Divisional vs New York: Playing against the eventual Super Bowl Champions, Aaron Rodgers individually had a pretty decently good game. His defense absolutely sucked though, allowing a whopping 37 points. Also, his receiving core didn’t help much either, as the Packer’s receivers combined for six (6!) drops, which was actually the most dropped passes of any game in the entire 2011 season. Still, nothing unique really happened in this game, Rodgers’ receivers failed him and the defense sucked which is pretty typical, so I can’t say that Rodgers deserved to win this game.
2016 NFC Championship vs Atlanta
Let’s get this out of the way, 44 points allowed on 9 possessions. For reference, that is more points allowed than Tom Brady’s defense has ever in his entire 23 year long career. Allowing 44 points is completely unacceptable. With that out of the way, the first thing people say about Rodgers’ performance is that he was shut out in the first half. The reality is that wasn’t his fault, not many people remember that Rodgers led the Packers into the redzone on both of his first 2 offensive drives of that game. The first ended in a missed field goal by his kicker, and the 2nd was thrown away by a Running back fumbling the ball away in typical Aaron Jones fashion. After the Packer’s 2nd drive, the score very well could’ve been 10-17, but instead it was 17-0, and at this point the pressure was on Rodgers the entire game, hence what some would say as a bad performance. Overall, trying to keep up with the rate at which his defense was allowing scores, whilst also battling your own teammates missing scores and turning over the ball makes this a pretty decisive ‘not his fault’ game. Though even with that being said, nothing really flukey happened, so Rodgers took the L and that was that.
2019 NFC Championship vs San Fran
This is probably the most embarrassing loss for the Packers defense in the Rodgers era. The 49ers attempted, not completed, attempted just 8 passes the entire game. The Packers defense could not stop a nosebleed as they allowed nearly 300 rushing yards and 4 rushing touchdowns, allowing a pretty typical Packers defense 37 points. Aaron Rodgers, like in the last two, played decent to good, but couldn’t keep up with his defense. It’s not like something happened to justify that Rodgers should’ve won, but it certainly wasn’t his fault that they didn’t.
That’s for that category, other playoff losses that fit here are:
2012 Divisional vs San Fran
2015 Divisional vs Arizona
Now, games that Rodgers played bad in, but still should’ve won anyway if not for incredibly flukey moments:
2014 NFC Championship vs Seattle:
The Seahawks played an absolutely dreadful early and mid game, but questionable coaching decisions on the packers side lead to many drives stalling within the 15 and settling for field goals instead of TDs. With under 5 minutes left in the game, the Packers were up 19-7. Wilson finally woke up and led a touchdown drive, making the score 19-14 with 2 minutes left in the game. All it would take the Packers to go to the super bowl is 1 onside kick recovery, but then Brandon Bostick happened. Bostick was apparently feeling himself, and attempted to play hero with a jumping catch on the onside, muffed it, and seattle recovered the ball. It only took Seattle 3 plays to score on the Packers defense again, and they converted a 2 pointer to go up 19-22. After touching the ball for the first time since being up 19-7, Rodgers’ led a game tying field goal drive with 1 minute left on the clock to work with, that sent the game into overtime. Rodgers would never touch the ball again as on the first play of OT Wilson would complete a 35 yard touchdown pass to seal the game for Seattle. There were 2 separate instances in this game where the Packers had the ball on the Seattle 1 yard line on 4th and 1, and instead of attemping a TD both were settled for Field Goals. Rodgers did not play good, and his defense for the first 3 quarters gave the offense so many chances to put the game away, regardless of the terrible coaching decisions. But here’s something I notice, Tom Brady has had a lot of really bad playoff performances, where he plays terrible for 3 quarters, but wakes up in the fourth and wins the game, everyone immediately forgets about those terrible 3 quarters, and he’s the hero of the game for winning it when it mattered most. Why don’t we praise Rodgers for doing exactly the same in this game? After coming back onto the field for the first time since being up 19-7, and under a minute on the clock, Aaron Rodgers absolutely clutches the game and saves the team from losing when it mattered most, only to never see the ball again. And of course there’s the biggest culprit, Brandon Bostick’s drop on the kick return that would’ve sealed a super bowl trip. Rodgers did not play good outside of his late game clutch drive, but the Packers deserved, and should’ve went, to the Super Bowl if not for that incredibly flukey onside kick drop.
2021 Divisional vs San Fran
Rodgers’ worst performance in a playoff loss ever, and the best performance by the Packers defense in a playoff loss as well. So, why did the Packers deserve to win? What flukey moments happened? Simply put, the special teams killed the team. With a missed field goal that Rodgers & co set up, and an incredibly flukey blocked punt touchdown, the Packers’ special teams cost them 10 points in a game that was decided by 3. Rodgers played horribly, but even then he outperformed the opposing offense! He scored more points than the 49ers did! If not for the Special Team’s blocked punt, the Packers would’ve won regardless of the offensive struggles!
Finally, the last category. Games where Rodgers did play good, and the team should’ve won.
2020 NFC Championship vs Tampa Bay.
Where to begin with this one. CB Kevin King gave up 14 points single-handedly (including a comically mistimed jump) as well as the season-ending defensive PI call on an overthrown pass by Brady on 3rd down that otherwise would’ve meant a punt back to Green Bay. Despite Brady already throwing 3 interceptions, he also had a dropped 4th interception by Chandon Sullivan on what would become a TD drive. Aaron Jones fumbled twice, the second of which setting up the Buccs with an 8-yard TD drive, with multiple lineman illegally downfield that should have called the play back which was somehow missed, to extend their lead in the 3rd, Davante Adams dropping a game tying TD pass in the 2nd, and Aaron Rodgers’ lone interception came on a play that should’ve been called back on a missed clear defensive holding on Allen Lazard. In a single sentence, this NFC Championship is probably the single worst officiated game of all time, and somehow everyone one of those missed penalties came in extremely crucial moments (all touchdown drives or touchdown plays or turnovers) all went to the Buccaneer’s favor. There is not a game that Rodgers deserved to win more than the 2020 NFC Championship. In total, Rodgers should’ve appeared in 3 super bowl total, this year being one of them.
Other playoff losses that fit into this category:
2009 Wildcard vs Arizona
2013 Wildcard vs San Fran
@@goldenstatewarriors9418 thank you!!
@@simon_carrick8198 Exactly.
That wildcard game against the eagles has haunted my memories ever since. Such a sad way to end such a great duel, although obviously I'm biased as an eagles fan
When Aaron had an elite defense he won a championship. Got to keep in mind the game has evolved so much since then. It wasn’t just a track meet like it is today.
He had decent and good defenses since 2012 and still hasn’t made it to a sb. He’s a playoff choker.
As we saw in 2014 and 2021, great defense performance doesnt guarantee Rodgers a win
He never had a d as good as sf or sea teams that kept beating gb. Maybe 2010. He's always had to carry his team
Another interesting video would be about Ditka's Bears from the '80s and examining how, despite that great defense, they only managed to win one Super Bowl.
Favre was worse. He was part of a team that won one Super Bowl. People tend to forget The Pack had a # 2 D in 1996; so that win wasn't about Favre. The year after, he threw INT to lose the Super Bowl against The Broncos. After that, he's thrown INT in every playoff game he was in. How that constitutes he to be on top 5 or 10 and Hall of famer is beyond me.
1996 wasn’t about Favre? Yes, the team was loaded and #1 in all three phases of the game but he was also league MVP.
As a Packers fan, I was obligated to subscribe. Excellent work, and excellent conclusion!
Love the new picture of Tom
he's so hot
Having Marino, Elway, & Unitas a whole damn tier below Rodgers & Brees is insulting. Lets respect eras here & appreciate what those "tier 3" qbs did in a more dominating & physical era where rules didnt baby the qb position.
As a Bengals fan, if joey B goes the rodgers route and could just get us one SB while being consistent for a number of years, id be happy.
That being said, it is WILD that GB has had two all-time greats (on the field, fuck favre) for the last 30 years and have only gotten two rings out of it.
I think overall the colts are worse. Only 1 Super Bowl with Peyton Manning and they completely ruined luck. Also only 2 rings between Peyton and Unitas. At least the packers have 4 rings going back to Bart Starr.
@@ErikCB912 that is crazy they only mustered one. Especially when Roethlisberger got two over at Pittsburgh
@@MAVJ for the 2000s I agree that’s pretty astonishing, but I feel like in the 2010s Ben should have won at least one more with all the talent the Steelers had in the early-mid 2010s.
@ErikCB912 That's a good point. I forgot the Roethlisberger, Bell, and Brown team wasn't the one that won that second SB.
I estimated that Rodgers would win 3 SBs when he won his 1st if he stayed healthy. He did but fell so short of returning so many times. Tom Grossi's tribute video for Rodgers is so good, almost choked me up and im a Broncos fan lol
"Harnessed the spirit of a prime Zach Wilson" wow 🤣
Im done 😂😂😂
Both farves and Rodgers last throws as packers were ints.
Clicked immediately to watch the vid then see a picture of Tom Brady in the background. 😂😂😂😂
I still remember when he took over and damn did he get so much hate from the fans! Nobody gave him a chance and they all wanted Farve back. It was a pretty sad moment but I think that's what motivated him the most to become the best. I don't think a lot of people fully understands what he went through and overcame to get to where he's at. I think this is why he loves proving people wrong because it's always been the way things have been since the very beginning. He's definitely given Green Bay everything he had but I think the front office have failed him big time by never going all out to give him the defense and weapons he needed to win Superbowls. Rodgers never had a top 5 defense like Brady had except for 2010 when he won it all! GB seriously could and should of been able to build a dynasty with Rodgers. I hope that system starts to change and start doing what matters most when the time comes for this next era.
The ineptness of two titles in 30 seasons of hall of fame quarterback play. It was quite a ride, but damn. Should have brought home more hardware. Btw - why does this guy record in his daughters bedroom in front of that…portrait?
Listen, idc how good rodgers was in 2014, JJ watt was literally the MOST VALUABLE PLAYER IN 2014. Dude scored on offense and defense. Like how does that not warrant MVP?
The poster of Tom Brady looks like something a 14 year old girl would hang on her wall.
Thats just realllly good coaching from Coach Greene there, RIP sir
Rodgers choked hard vs the Seahawks with Russ throwing 4 Fing picks and losing a fumble aka that’s 5 TOS in one game bruh if you are a MVP QB you gotta play like it especially with the other QB playing like crap till the last couple minutes(that or you should take pay cuts to help make the team better or keep vets and rookies or bring in free agents)
Thanks for saying this.....I've been saying it for years
Love the content keep it up my guy
He though he was slick putting the 28-3 @17:26 🤣
One thing not really noted was the playoff game against the Vikings and Joe Webb was a sign of what was to come against Kaepernick. Webb was gashing the Packer's defense with his legs but the Vikings inexplicably refused to lean on that and continued to have him ineffectively try to throw the ball.
The Packers' old head coach is the current Cowboys head coach. Doesn't take a genius to connect the dots.
It's very weird for me, a Bears fan, to have decided to give you a sub because of an Aaron Rogers vid..... but your research and delivery is so damn thorough.... if it's cool with you bro. Imma tell my friends it was because of the Raiders vid, but you'll know the truth, bud. You got a Bears fan to sub you off a Packers vid. Well done.
“He struggled against all-time great defenses.”
lol
Great video! But sadly that’s just how it goes in the NFL, multiple amazing QBs have come up short somehow and not won a Super Bowl or only won 1 Super Bowl. It’s a team sport, but it’s just so strange bc a lot of the teams they played in the playoffs weren’t even good. Who’s to say if he even made it to the Super Bowl he would’ve won, it would’ve been vs hard teams like the Pats, Steelers, Kansas city, and other teams that were meant to win regardless of who they played
New York is only going to last a year. He will be traded again or retire after this year. When they are 2-4 and the media is harassing him he's going to snap
I'm not even going to watch the video; but I love the premise for the video. Here's a like. Have a good day.