How was it Warren’s fault? He didn’t read it because he knew something was not correct. It was more Faye Dunaway’s fault in my opinion for taking the card and reading without comprehending what she was reading first.
As the one person who "KNEW something was up", it was Warren's responsibility to let that be known. If he had simply said to the audience, "Ladies and gentlemen, I'm sorry, but I seem to have been given the wrong card", then this would have been an "embarrassing moment" for the Academy, but not the biggest fuck up in Oscar history.
@@THERSC216 Jordan Horowitz was very rude to Warren Beatty when he snatched the card from Beatty's hand. He graciously handed the Oscar to the rightful winner but was super rude to Warren Beatty!
Warren was trying to get Faye to look at it she made the decision to say La La Land. A lot of actors don't seem to have a thought in their heads or know what to do without a script.
Ernie: Yep, she ran off while Warren stayed behind like a trooper to explain the error, yet theres people who still criticize him. And the ones who made the actual mistake barely got blamed!
TYCHOMONOLITH13 yea I understand that the guy was upset about the whole thing but to snatch that from another old guy was very rude and disrespectful..
+myrah shetty I think he was upset for the right reasons. The actual winners had been cheated out of their big moment, all those "in charge" were doing nothing - and had let him and others give heartfelt and teary acceptance speeches as they stalled. I did feel bad for Beatty, given how the card was snatched from him. I believe he obviously had it as he intended to make the correction.
What are you talking about, almost didn't get the Oscar...THEY DID GET IT! Imagine being La La Land and thinking you've just won then having it ripped away from you. Are you on crack?
there’s only one thing that i’m puzzled about over the years: how did the oscar live v.o. read out la la land’s bio if they knew it was moonlight that was gonna win best picture? i get the wrong envelope thing and i don’t think warren was to blame here but why did the oscar’s continue to read out la la land’s bio though? do they have a bio written for every single nominee?
Yeah they have one ready for every single nominee, to minimise the amount of people that know and prevent it leaking as much as they can. It's highly secret information until the announcements themselves
Emma forced that last statement that she loved the movie, sure she probably liked it, but not enough for it to beat her own starring film. Let's be real.
Was just thinking that! And I don't like how she said "I had the envelope so I don't know what they're talking about" like there was some conspiracy or something. Poor Warren!
Moonlight definitely deserved Best Picture over La La Land! NO DOUBT! That movie destroyed me. It touched all the feels and it is one of those pictures I’ll never be able to watch again. 😩
That’s exactly why it shouldn’t have been best picture. No one is interested in watching that movie a second time. The whole point of great movies is to watch then over and over again. This was an Oscars “too white” over correction. Also the fact the main competitor was La La Land, also a very imperfect but ambitious movie. But it would be tough coming off “Oscars Too White” scandal and giving the award to a movie about American jazz music … featuring a white jazz musician.
@@79Glitch It's such an absurd criticism to claim that "great movie are meant to be watched over and over again". Movies that impacted me the most (and ones that I consider truly outstanding) would generally get one or two viewings, because they hit a very hard message that needs some time to process. Movies that are just entertaining action/comedy flicks might get half a dozen repeats, because they're just comfortable enjoyment. People usually don't want to have an existential crisis every time they watch a movie, most of the time people just want something comforting or entertaining to watch. Unless you are studying film or reviewing them. Also, your racism is showing with your Oscars rant.
@@htpkey Moonlight is fine. It’s just not a best picture caliber movie. But the Oscars get it wrong more often than they get it wrong more than they get it right, so it’s par for the course? But that is actually a separate argument from what I was making. The argument about a good movie, book, painting, song, album, or any piece of art that is produced at the highest level is probably also something that one wishes to re-visit more than once … that is a tangential or philosophical argument. If something is “too powerful” to consume more than once or twice … I would contend that is NOT a good piece of art. That would be evidence of a work that is manipulative or didactic, by definition; it doesn’t hold up to the standards of art. Anyone who has studied art history, or even film history like you mentioned, would be very familiar with this concept: true art achieves stasis; non-art (advertisements for example, or pornography) purposefully compel emotions in a manipulative way, I.e. it is kinetic. But that is just a pedantic response to your point, not really a judgement on Moonlight … because I think Moonlight is a well made and artistic movie. It’s just not worthy of being a best picture. But neither was the Queen biopic, or Green Book, or Coda, or The Artist, or the majority of the winners in the past ten years. The Oscars is a ridiculous event that means very little at this point. I guess I should have clarified my viewpoint? But Moonlight absolutely rode the wave of Oscar’s too white, and if you deny that … you’re either naive, clueless, or lying. And someone should be able to point out the obvious without a cheap ad hominem attack in a comment thread. Anyone playing that loosely with accusations like that is highest suspect, in my opinion. If that is your go to conclusion, knowing nothing else about the commenter beyond a few sentences … what does that say about your own biases? Its indicative of the kind of language and thought policing of the fascist cancel culture that is so persistent amongst the uneducated masses on places like … RUclips, or social media. Well … I guess I found you in your natural habitat then?
@@79Glitch Are you even aware of how Oscar winners are selected? It's not an objective process, at best It's a popularity contest conducted by people within the film industry.
two copies of every card, the real one and a back up. Emma won best supporting actress, for some reason Warren was handed the best supporting actress card. It's not his fault
Even Warren should also tell to stage manager if he get confused or hand him the wrong envelope.Beside it's written Emma stones La La Land best actress on the card and even on the front envelope as well.At least Warren should read that too, but he didn't. If he read carefully what's written on the card he would make a mistake he should inform the stage manager but he just pulled in out get confused and let that woman read.a hrim² Warren a kha ni actress tiin envelope hmaah poh in ziak reng sia puang lui tlat chawwhhh
Beatty read it, knew it was incorrect as the envelope was best Actress not picture and should have done the right thing and just pause for a moment, he has year's of experience in the industry, that was a horrible thing to do and many people felt that way.
This was an all around disaster. Everyone who was involved were caught in an unfortunate situation which made each of them look ridiculous. First off, the company handling the cards was incompetent. Warren Beatty & Faye Dunaway looking senile on top of their confusion, being in their old age. The douche producer/sore loser Jordan Horowitz who angrily snatched the card from Warren. Then there's Jimmy Kimmel who is just generally an unnecessary, cringy try-hard. I just love rewatching this moment!
It's Jimmy Kimmel role attempting to explain something he knew NOTHING about. (sort of like he does with African American issues in general (like he replaced Arsenio Hall) NOT. Dude STFU.@@epicphail2926
If it were up to me it could have been Moonlight La La Land Arrival Hidden Figures Lion Queen Of Katwe Life, Animated Rules Don’t Apply Inferno The Salesman My Life As A Zucchini Allied Elle Winner Moonlight And yes the real envelope would have said it
Never have old people present awards. Even after Faye announces La La Land as the winner, Beatty just stands there silently and lets the whole fiasco unfold.
The blame for this Academy Award fiasco goes primarily to PriceWaterhouseCoopers Managing Partner Brian Cullinan for giving Warren Beatty a duplicate of Emma Stone's Best Actress envelope instead of the Best Picture envelope. Cullinan had been Tweeting while holding multiple envelopes instead of focusing on his immediate job. However, Warren Beatty also shares in the blame because he knew that he had the wrong envelope. Beatty has been in the movie business virtually his entire life, he's won an Oscar himself, he's been center stage many times opening award envelopes and presenting others with Oscars through the decades, and--most important of all--he knows that the Oscar for Best Picture is always awarded to the producers of the movie, which rarely includes an actor or actress. So as soon as he saw Emma Stone's name on the card, instead of the producers, he should have immediately recognized that he somehow got the wrong envelope. He then could have temporarily stopped the proceedings and explained to the audience that he needed to check something before making the announcement of the winner. Even I learned that the producers always got the Best Picture Oscar when I watched my first Academy Award show when the Best Picture went to The Godfather. The winner of that Oscar was Albert S. Ruddy, someone who I had never heard of before at the time. I was surprised because I knew the director, the author, the actors and actresses, and even the director of photography and the composer of the music, but I didn't know who Albert S. Ruddy was. My parents explained that he was the producer of the movie; they told me what the producer's role in the movie was, which involved a lot of creative and business responsibilities and decisions; and they told me that the producers always receive the Best Picture Oscar. I never forgot that. And neither should Beatty have forgotten that fact.
The Academy is partially to blame as well for not renewing the previous designer's contract to design and produce the cards and envelopes. The previous designer< Marc Friedland, printed the envelope with black lettering on a white card mounted on a gold envelope. They switched to another designer--or may have done it in-house--who printed the category _Best Actress_ in small type at the bottom of the card and the film title in the same size as the person's name and printed the envelope with gold lettering on a red envelope which is difficult to read under low lighting conditions when the envelope was handed to the presenter backstage. The small type of the category on the card and the low contrast of the lettering on the envelope combined with the visual impairment of the aging eyesight of the two presenters eliminated this fail safe mechanism of the process.
Sylvester Stallone is the real winner for Best Supporting Actor of 2015 for Creed. (No offense to Mark Rylance for Bridge of Spies) Roma is clearly the real winner for Best Picture of 2018. (Not Green Book) The Social Network is the real winner of Best Picture of 2010. (Not The King’s Speech 👎🏽) David Fincher is the real winner for Best Director of 2010 (Not Tom Hooper for The King’s Speech No offense though) and Jesse Eisenberg tied up with Colin Firth for Best Actor of 2010 Brokeback Mountain is the real winner for Best Picture of 2005. (Not Crash) Kung Fu Panda is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2008. (Don’t get me wrong. I love WALL-E, but it’s just both WALL-E and Bolt are both great movies too both distributed by Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures) The Revenant or Mad Max: Fury Road are both real winners for Best Picture of 2015 (Not Spotlight) Martin Scorsese is the true winner for Best Director of 2002 for Gangs of New York Pulp Fiction/ Forrest Gump are both tied up for Best Picture of 1994 Kate Winslet tied up with Helen Hunt for Best Actress of 1997 Kate Winslet tied up with Alicia Vikander for Best Supporting Actress of 2015 Avatar/ The Hurt Locked tied up for Best Director and for Best Picture of 2009 La La Land is the real winner for Best Picture of 2016 Avengers: Endgame is the true real winner for Best Visual Effects of 2019 (Not 1917) Fantastic Mr Fox 🦊/ Coraline are both real winner for Best Animated Feature Film (Up is the true real winner for Best Picture of 2009, making it the first Disney Animated Film to win for Best Picture) How To Train Your Dragon/ Toy Story 3 tied up for Best Animated Film of 2010. Wreck-It Ralph is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2012. (Not Brave, even though it’s great too.) Klaus 🎅🏽 🎄 is the clear winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2019 (Not Toy Story 4; even though that movie was good too.) Leonardo DiCaprio is the real winner for Best Supporting Actor of 1993 for What’s Eating Gilbert Grape Johnny Depp is the real winner for Best Actor for Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl of 2003 (No offense to Sean Penn though) Hugo is the real winner for Best Director (Martin Scorsese) and for Best Picture of 2011 John Travolta is the real winner for Best Actor of 1977 for Saturday Night Fever Ryan Gosling is the real winner for Best Actor of 2016 for La La Land. (No offense to Casey Affleck though) The LEGO Movie is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2014 (even though it was robbed for no reasons) The late Chadwick Boseman, May he R.I.P., is the true winner for Best Actor for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom of 2020 Andrew Garfield is the true winner for Best Lead Actor of 2021 for Tick, Tick… BOOM! (Definitely not Will “Slappy” Smith for King Richard after what he did to Chris Rock. I’m glad he got banned for 10 years. He better not get nominated again after what he did was insanely wrong.)
Beatty read it, knew it was incorrect as the envelope was best Actress not picture, he should have done the right thing and just pause for a moment, he has year's of experience in the industry, he said he wasn't trying to be funny?..that was a cr#p thing to do.
Are you sure you watched the same video as everyone else? Beatty paused for so long, Faye got tired and he showed the mistake on the card to her. She just straight up read the movie name without seeing Emma Stone written on it. The only trouble is they didn't know what to do if they had the wrong card. And the academy officials in charge of the cards were nowhere to be seen.
La La Land deserved the Oscar as much as Moonlight did. Both movies were fresh and amazing. But no doubt La La Land won the maximum number of Oscar awards, and the only movie with the highest number of Oscar nominations in history along with the highest number of golden globes. Much love to both teams anyway.
+Ultimate Warrior Sigh; yes, I am. But I don't believe that there's no such thing as bad publicity. PwC can proclaim its fault all it wishes to - which I'm sure isn't much! - but it's the Academy that will (and should) ultimately be held responsible - for placing two accountants, one of them preoccupied with taking and tweeting backstage photos, who know nothing about running such a show, in charge of correcting just such mistakes, which neither stepped up to do. I don't see what they could possibly stand to gain, except, perhaps, some lawsuits.
![DRAGON BALL: Sparking! ZERO - Fused Warriors Trailer [BUDOKAI TENKAICHI Series]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/84p4Lvyfyes/mqdefault.jpg)
they are both in their 80's and were in a scary moment. He was confused, the person who gave him the wrong envelope is to blame
beatty is to blame, these people are pampered , he doesnt have the sense to ask for help
How was it Warren’s fault? He didn’t read it because he knew something was not correct. It was more Faye Dunaway’s fault in my opinion for taking the card and reading without comprehending what she was reading first.
No.
@@severetiredamage6754how can you possibly blame someone that didn't even do anything?
Faye Dunaways blabber mouth should get some blame too....Poor Warren.., atleast he KNEW something was up
ikr
Blame the root of the problem, the guy who gives the card.
Exactly!
As the one person who "KNEW something was up", it was Warren's responsibility to let that be known. If he had simply said to the audience, "Ladies and gentlemen, I'm sorry, but I seem to have been given the wrong card", then this would have been an "embarrassing moment" for the Academy, but not the biggest fuck up in Oscar history.
Donald Lancon Jr Exactly, he allowed the failure to unfold without warning anyone.
LaLas producer was pure class. I can only imagine how upset he was, but to handle it so well tells a lot about him. ❤❤
He was embarassed but he handled it with class
@@THERSC216 Jordan Horowitz was very rude to Warren Beatty when he snatched the card from Beatty's hand. He graciously handed the Oscar to the rightful winner but was super rude to Warren Beatty!
I wouldn’t call it rude! He could’ve freaked out but he kept it cool, but he was rightfully upset.
Warren was trying to get Faye to look at it she made the decision to say La La Land. A lot of actors don't seem to have a thought in their heads or know what to do without a script.
Wow, Faye Dunaway totally missed any bullets...Bonnie shot it but Clyde got it.
but he handed it to her
Ernie: Yep, she ran off while Warren stayed behind like a trooper to explain the error, yet theres people who still criticize him. And the ones who made the actual mistake barely got blamed!
This was 2017 😲
I thought this only happened 2 years ago.
Where the hell has that time gone
I miss 2017 😢
Someone gave bonnie and Clyde the wrong thing
Harry Boyd
Wasn't the first time they got shot down.
Hilarious how the dude just snatches the real card out of Beatty's ancient hands.löl.
TYCHOMONOLITH13 I died! 😂😂😂 so rude!
TYCHOMONOLITH13 Beatty gereatric old fool.
TYCHOMONOLITH13 yea I understand that the guy was upset about the whole thing but to snatch that from another old guy was very rude and disrespectful..
myrah shetty hes an old fool anyway
+myrah shetty I think he was upset for the right reasons. The actual winners had been cheated out of their big moment, all those "in charge" were doing nothing - and had let him and others give heartfelt and teary acceptance speeches as they stalled. I did feel bad for Beatty, given how the card was snatched from him. I believe he obviously had it as he intended to make the correction.
Jimmy Kimmel missed an opportunity to say as a joke that he saw Matt Damon play with the envolops backstage.
Matt Damon lookalike did it.
OMG now I see it 😂
😄😄
Just spotted him 😂😂😂😂😂
At 0:08 he says best, and "best" shows up on the screen behind him to the right.
how the hell did you spot that...?
I have no idea
Alex Guerrero eye of a hawk
Wow...
@@raykall haha was about to say the same thing. Great catch though lol
Russia Hacked the Oscars.
You guy's are absolutely crazy, I love you !!!!
Why is it such a huge apology to La La Land when Moonlight almost didn't get the oscar they won? They are the ones that should be devastated.
What are you smoking, imagine someone gave you the most prestigious award of your life and then ripped it away moments later.
What are you talking about, almost didn't get the Oscar...THEY DID GET IT! Imagine being La La Land and thinking you've just won then having it ripped away from you. Are you on crack?
"I have to apologise"
**Columbia snaps her head at him**
When I saw the Price Waterhouse rep (Cullinan?) wandering around onstage, I thought it was Matt Damon pranking Kimmel.
there’s only one thing that i’m puzzled about over the years: how did the oscar live v.o. read out la la land’s bio if they knew it was moonlight that was gonna win best picture? i get the wrong envelope thing and i don’t think warren was to blame here but why did the oscar’s continue to read out la la land’s bio though? do they have a bio written for every single nominee?
No one knows the winners except for Price Waterhouse till the envelope is opened so they would have to have a bio ready for every nominee
Yeah they have one ready for every single nominee, to minimise the amount of people that know and prevent it leaking as much as they can. It's highly secret information until the announcements themselves
You’d think Warren Betty would have called someone over and showed them the wrong card and asked for the right card......
Emma forced that last statement that she loved the movie, sure she probably liked it, but not enough for it to beat her own starring film. Let's be real.
Cullinan should have been up there apologizing his ass off. How ridiculous that Warren was blamed for any of this.
When he saw the wrong card, he probably should have said so. Instead, he passed it on to Bonnie who just saw LA LA Land, so that's what she announced.
4:03 "FIRED!"
Pricewaterhouse Cooper - FIRED!
Geez, emma stone, that was some over the top declaration of how much she loves moonlight. Uggh
Was just thinking that! And I don't like how she said "I had the envelope so I don't know what they're talking about" like there was some conspiracy or something. Poor Warren!
Moonlight totally deserves it!!!
Hell noo
I think La La Land deserved it tbh
They should train hosts about what to do if this happens.
Moonlight definitely deserved Best Picture over La La Land! NO DOUBT! That movie destroyed me. It touched all the feels and it is one of those pictures I’ll never be able to watch again. 😩
That’s exactly why it shouldn’t have been best picture. No one is interested in watching that movie a second time. The whole point of great movies is to watch then over and over again. This was an Oscars “too white” over correction.
Also the fact the main competitor was La La Land, also a very imperfect but ambitious movie. But it would be tough coming off “Oscars Too White” scandal and giving the award to a movie about American jazz music … featuring a white jazz musician.
@@79Glitch It's such an absurd criticism to claim that "great movie are meant to be watched over and over again".
Movies that impacted me the most (and ones that I consider truly outstanding) would generally get one or two viewings, because they hit a very hard message that needs some time to process. Movies that are just entertaining action/comedy flicks might get half a dozen repeats, because they're just comfortable enjoyment.
People usually don't want to have an existential crisis every time they watch a movie, most of the time people just want something comforting or entertaining to watch. Unless you are studying film or reviewing them.
Also, your racism is showing with your Oscars rant.
@@htpkey Moonlight is fine. It’s just not a best picture caliber movie. But the Oscars get it wrong more often than they get it wrong more than they get it right, so it’s par for the course? But that is actually a separate argument from what I was making.
The argument about a good movie, book, painting, song, album, or any piece of art that is produced at the highest level is probably also something that one wishes to re-visit more than once … that is a tangential or philosophical argument.
If something is “too powerful” to consume more than once or twice … I would contend that is NOT a good piece of art. That would be evidence of a work that is manipulative or didactic, by definition; it doesn’t hold up to the standards of art.
Anyone who has studied art history, or even film history like you mentioned, would be very familiar with this concept: true art achieves stasis; non-art (advertisements for example, or pornography) purposefully compel emotions in a manipulative way, I.e. it is kinetic.
But that is just a pedantic response to your point, not really a judgement on Moonlight … because I think Moonlight is a well made and artistic movie. It’s just not worthy of being a best picture.
But neither was the Queen biopic, or Green Book, or Coda, or The Artist, or the majority of the winners in the past ten years. The Oscars is a ridiculous event that means very little at this point. I guess I should have clarified my viewpoint?
But Moonlight absolutely rode the wave of Oscar’s too white, and if you deny that … you’re either naive, clueless, or lying. And someone should be able to point out the obvious without a cheap ad hominem attack in a comment thread. Anyone playing that loosely with accusations like that is highest suspect, in my opinion. If that is your go to conclusion, knowing nothing else about the commenter beyond a few sentences … what does that say about your own biases? Its indicative of the kind of language and thought policing of the fascist cancel culture that is so persistent amongst the uneducated masses on places like … RUclips, or social media.
Well … I guess I found you in your natural habitat then?
@@79Glitch I've never seen someone post so much conjecture, subjectivity and assertions and try to pretend it's some kind of "objective statement".
@@79Glitch Are you even aware of how Oscar winners are selected? It's not an objective process, at best It's a popularity contest conducted by people within the film industry.
Jordon seemed pissed the way he ripped it out of Warren's hand lol
I was devastated! I couldn't eat or sleep for days, oh the agony.
"Moonlight" also won the Golden Globe for Motion Picture, Drama.
No longer the most surreal moment, my man 😁😁😁
So embrassing....even watching from the TV.
Wow, how Jordan directly admited & spoke loud on stage is cool
that's proves that they aint politicians they're entertainers...and I'm thoroughly entertained with they're f#ck up
That guy Jordan snatched it
Those cards are honestly confusing to read. They should see vox's videos about this problem.
two copies of every card, the real one and a back up. Emma won best supporting actress, for some reason Warren was handed the best supporting actress card. It's not his fault
"Snafu" stands for "situation normal, all fucked up."
how could the producer of la la land snatch the card so rudely from warren. he is a very old man atleast respect his age man!
Because he’s a douche
Shut the tuck up he was pissed. You fucking insane bitch
That´s why I think they should always show the card to a camera when they announce the winner.
Even Warren should also tell to stage manager if he get confused or hand him the wrong envelope.Beside it's written Emma stones La La Land best actress on the card and even on the front envelope as well.At least Warren should read that too, but he didn't. If he read carefully what's written on the card he would make a mistake he should inform the stage manager but he just pulled in out get confused and let that woman read.a hrim² Warren a kha ni actress tiin envelope hmaah poh in ziak reng sia puang lui tlat chawwhhh
Beatty read it, knew it was incorrect as the envelope was best Actress not picture and should have done the right thing and just pause for a moment, he has year's of experience in the industry, that was a horrible thing to do and many people felt that way.
What Happened is pretty simple, Warren Beatty was handed the wrong envelope.
This was an all around disaster. Everyone who was involved were caught in an unfortunate situation which made each of them look ridiculous. First off, the company handling the cards was incompetent. Warren Beatty & Faye Dunaway looking senile on top of their confusion, being in their old age. The douche producer/sore loser Jordan Horowitz who angrily snatched the card from Warren. Then there's Jimmy Kimmel who is just generally an unnecessary, cringy try-hard. I just love rewatching this moment!
Jordan Horowitz took a confusing and humiliating moment and handled it with class during a huge live event.
@@makeadifference4all no he didn’t lol he acted like a pissed off little bald man
It's Jimmy Kimmel role attempting to explain something he knew NOTHING about. (sort of like he does with African American issues in general (like he replaced Arsenio Hall) NOT. Dude STFU.@@epicphail2926
It was the accountant’s fault they apologized for it
Reporter -Most surreal moment ever at an Oscar awards show .
Will Smith - I think not
I think this was worse.
Wow, the first sentence from this video didn't age well 🤣
And the "right" envelope please...
IT WAS MATT DAMON!!!!!!!!
Jimmy Kimmel said, it was always Matt Damon fault 😂
The way he snatched the card out of Warren Beatty's hand..
If it were up to me it could have been
Moonlight
La La Land
Arrival
Hidden Figures
Lion
Queen Of Katwe
Life, Animated
Rules Don’t Apply
Inferno
The Salesman
My Life As A Zucchini
Allied
Elle
Winner Moonlight
And yes the real envelope would have said it
Colombia was the only word Steve could read. 😂😂😂😂🙈
2nd most surreal moment now. 2022
Never have old people present awards. Even after Faye announces La La Land as the winner, Beatty just stands there silently and lets the whole fiasco unfold.
Emma Stone told on they a** lol
And then Will Smith came along 😄
That baldy and Emma Stone are so bitter and mean!
1:20 - Hell I'd be pissed if I knew I lost freakin best picture....
Baldy lol
I would be too tf
Stfu you don’t understand
Horowitz got it right. It takes a real human to do the right thing even when he doesn't have to.
Shocking. Imagine if something important actually happened
You lot are making a big deal out of this, Hollywood sensationalism at its finest.
Lol, Jimmy is blaming Warren smh
The blame for this Academy Award fiasco goes primarily to PriceWaterhouseCoopers Managing Partner Brian Cullinan for giving Warren Beatty a duplicate of Emma Stone's Best Actress envelope instead of the Best Picture envelope. Cullinan had been Tweeting while holding multiple envelopes instead of focusing on his immediate job.
However, Warren Beatty also shares in the blame because he knew that he had the wrong envelope. Beatty has been in the movie business virtually his entire life, he's won an Oscar himself, he's been center stage many times opening award envelopes and presenting others with Oscars through the decades, and--most important of all--he knows that the Oscar for Best Picture is always awarded to the producers of the movie, which rarely includes an actor or actress. So as soon as he saw Emma Stone's name on the card, instead of the producers, he should have immediately recognized that he somehow got the wrong envelope. He then could have temporarily stopped the proceedings and explained to the audience that he needed to check something before making the announcement of the winner.
Even I learned that the producers always got the Best Picture Oscar when I watched my first Academy Award show when the Best Picture went to The Godfather. The winner of that Oscar was Albert S. Ruddy, someone who I had never heard of before at the time. I was surprised because I knew the director, the author, the actors and actresses, and even the director of photography and the composer of the music, but I didn't know who Albert S. Ruddy was. My parents explained that he was the producer of the movie; they told me what the producer's role in the movie was, which involved a lot of creative and business responsibilities and decisions; and they told me that the producers always receive the Best Picture Oscar. I never forgot that.
And neither should Beatty have forgotten that fact.
The Academy is partially to blame as well for not renewing the previous designer's contract to design and produce the cards and envelopes. The previous designer< Marc Friedland, printed the envelope with black lettering on a white card mounted on a gold envelope. They switched to another designer--or may have done it in-house--who printed the category _Best Actress_ in small type at the bottom of the card and the film title in the same size as the person's name and printed the envelope with gold lettering on a red envelope which is difficult to read under low lighting conditions when the envelope was handed to the presenter backstage. The small type of the category on the card and the low contrast of the lettering on the envelope combined with the visual impairment of the aging eyesight of the two presenters eliminated this fail safe mechanism of the process.
They should show card to public after announcement.. like they showed after the mistake happened
Only steve for us we love steve
How about getting Steve Harvey host the Oscars next?
The moonlight gang😂🤣
Piss up , brewery! Does PwC have any involvement in postal services?
"Moonlight-Gang"
You know old ppl cant watch the clear name or words and maybe that went with them.
no they have two copies of every card, so emma stone had it same with warren
Beatty dropped faye in the shit rather than explain the problem with the card to her.
we love screw ups....theyr real and fun and not all tidy....
The worst Miss Universe's host was Steve Harvey, but the first prize for not knowing what to do is Jimmy Kimmel!
Who to blame? The persons who gave the envelope to them! Or the PWC persons.
The PWC person was the person who mistakenly handed the wrong envelope to Beatty.
Jimmy Kimmel's appeared as the beast of this joke
MOONLIGHT put me to sleep.
still won stay mad 🤣🤣
@@madinae3589 They won because Hollywood wanted to virtue signal but their big moment go ruined.
Naked gun 3
So just like in the movie you saw a guy but he was not a real guy, he was gay, the winner was Moonlight not Lala Land.
Faye Runaway . . .
Snafu?tofu?
I blame steve harvey for this
Jimmy kimmel
I don't believe for a nanosecond that this wasn't planned.
Ok, where’s your proof that it was planned?
@@EamonKelly This mix-up coincidentally happened during Best Picture.
@@atticusmcfly And How does that mean it was planned? All that happened was that they were accidentally given the wrong card.
So what, they made a mistake , he had the wrong envelope. ....its not Fayes fault, too bad. IN my eyes Lala land and Moon shine won.
You mad whitey?
Moonlight won. Not LaLa Land. MoonLIGHT. And they deserved it one of the greatest movies of all time
Sylvester Stallone is the real winner for Best Supporting Actor of 2015 for Creed. (No offense to Mark Rylance for Bridge of Spies)
Roma is clearly the real winner for Best Picture of 2018. (Not Green Book)
The Social Network is the real winner of Best Picture of 2010. (Not The King’s Speech 👎🏽) David Fincher is the real winner for Best Director of 2010 (Not Tom Hooper for The King’s Speech No offense though) and Jesse Eisenberg tied up with Colin Firth for Best Actor of 2010
Brokeback Mountain is the real winner for Best Picture of 2005. (Not Crash)
Kung Fu Panda is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2008. (Don’t get me wrong. I love WALL-E, but it’s just both WALL-E and Bolt are both great movies too both distributed by Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)
The Revenant or Mad Max: Fury Road are both real winners for Best Picture of 2015 (Not Spotlight)
Martin Scorsese is the true winner for Best Director of 2002 for Gangs of New York
Pulp Fiction/ Forrest Gump are both tied up for Best Picture of 1994
Kate Winslet tied up with Helen Hunt for Best Actress of 1997
Kate Winslet tied up with Alicia Vikander for Best Supporting Actress of 2015
Avatar/ The Hurt Locked tied up for Best Director and for Best Picture of 2009
La La Land is the real winner for Best Picture of 2016
Avengers: Endgame is the true real winner for Best Visual Effects of 2019 (Not 1917)
Fantastic Mr Fox 🦊/ Coraline are both real winner for Best Animated Feature Film (Up is the true real winner for Best Picture of 2009, making it the first Disney Animated Film to win for Best Picture)
How To Train Your Dragon/ Toy Story 3 tied up for Best Animated Film of 2010.
Wreck-It Ralph is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2012. (Not Brave, even though it’s great too.)
Klaus 🎅🏽 🎄 is the clear winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2019 (Not Toy Story 4; even though that movie was good too.)
Leonardo DiCaprio is the real winner for Best Supporting Actor of 1993 for What’s Eating Gilbert Grape
Johnny Depp is the real winner for Best Actor for Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl of 2003 (No offense to Sean Penn though)
Hugo is the real winner for Best Director (Martin Scorsese) and for Best Picture of 2011
John Travolta is the real winner for Best Actor of 1977 for Saturday Night Fever
Ryan Gosling is the real winner for Best Actor of 2016 for La La Land. (No offense to Casey Affleck though)
The LEGO Movie is the real winner for Best Animated Feature Film of 2014 (even though it was robbed for no reasons)
The late Chadwick Boseman, May he R.I.P., is the true winner for Best Actor for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom of 2020
Andrew Garfield is the true winner for Best Lead Actor of 2021 for Tick, Tick… BOOM!
(Definitely not Will “Slappy” Smith for King Richard after what he did to Chris Rock. I’m glad he got banned for 10 years. He better not get nominated again after what he did was insanely wrong.)
My favorite Oscar moment since the Streaker!!!
How about the slap
It's fine. Not a big deal.
They only said they love moonlight because its black they cannot say they dont love it because it would be racist.
The way the guy pulls it out of his hand is so rude f
Warren Beatty has always appeared to be a fencepost One more example
Wow 82 years 🤔 ...and when a black movie win best picture at Oscars.. BTW I was crushing on ema stone till I saw this shit
There needs to be one name only on each card. Nothing else
There is only one name on the card, idiot. But there are two cards. Didn’t you watch any of this?
Painful
Beatty read it, knew it was incorrect as the envelope was best Actress not picture, he should have done the right thing and just pause for a moment, he has year's of experience in the industry, he said he wasn't trying to be funny?..that was a cr#p thing to do.
Are you sure you watched the same video as everyone else? Beatty paused for so long, Faye got tired and he showed the mistake on the card to her. She just straight up read the movie name without seeing Emma Stone written on it. The only trouble is they didn't know what to do if they had the wrong card. And the academy officials in charge of the cards were nowhere to be seen.
Steve Harvey. Blame him.
NO WAY!! Steve Harvey does not compare to this mess. The Oscars need to Just Hold these various L's all by themselves. The OSCARS suck. STOP watching!
All I want to know HOW DE HE SEE LA LA LAND EMMA STONE
They explained in the video...didn't you watch it?
they were given the wrong envelope
Situation Normal All Fucked Up
La La Land deserved the Oscar as much as Moonlight did. Both movies were fresh and amazing. But no doubt La La Land won the maximum number of Oscar awards, and the only movie with the highest number of Oscar nominations in history along with the highest number of golden globes. Much love to both teams anyway.
Racist ABC has La La Land featured on this video instead of Moonlight. Figures.
I picked up on racism also. From the video at 1:29 : " '...is there gonna be a RIOT in here?' 'Audible gasps as the moonlight GANG...' "
DAMN
Surprising that gay film didn't win all the awards at that oscars
Obviously a publicity stunt
+drummerelle Uh, right; planned for the final seconds of the show so as to - boost ratings??
Salice McCool you are still talking about it now..
+Ultimate Warrior Sigh; yes, I am. But I don't believe that there's no such thing as bad publicity. PwC can proclaim its fault all it wishes to - which I'm sure isn't much! - but it's the Academy that will (and should) ultimately be held responsible - for placing two accountants, one of them preoccupied with taking and tweeting backstage photos, who know nothing about running such a show, in charge of correcting just such mistakes, which neither stepped up to do. I don't see what they could possibly stand to gain, except, perhaps, some lawsuits.
no it's an honest mistake.
U know it wasn’t
Does anyone hear Beatty saying “it says Emma Stone”? Just writing it on the screen doesn’t make it so. This is just bullshit damage control.
killustrator yes. You can hear it. Increase your damn volume.