WHY MUSLIMS FEAR DOGS - Is Man’s Best Friend Pure or Impure?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 июл 2024
- Islam is yet to resolve the question pertaining to the owner and companionship of dogs. Although Middle Eastern history is literally littered with references to dogs from both a religious and cultural perspective, in today’s world, dogs are considered as impure and command a great level of fear and disgust from the Muslim populations.
This video explains how various schools of Islamic law attempt to allow or prohibit the interaction with dogs. A full presentation of the various proofs and attributions for the “For” and “Against” camps is included, as well as an analysis of context and how such context may formulate and enlighten more informed points of view when assessing the proofs.
There is a difference between the purity and impurity of dog, a beautiful creation of Allah among many other beings on this earth, but why the fear and hatred? This is what must change.
#dog #dogs #canine #islam #muslim #pure #purity #prohibition #halal #haram #animal #doglover #dogoftheday #puppy #saliva #youtubedog #quran #hadith #impurity #interpretation #jurisprudence #islamic #prophet #companionship #ilovedogs #cleanliness #adogsworld
Subscribe: bit.ly/3jCXuCw:
Instagram: tareqkandari
Twitter: tareqkandari
Patreon.com/TheKandariChronicles
You said like it ( if you do actually like it )
I’ve never seen anyone saying that ! I’m very touched with your honesty & Allah puts blessings with every little things we do for Him ! You barely see people in this world with pure consciousness UNFORTUNATELY
I am humbled by your message and yes, I want to share knowledge with people and to assist them in better understanding and mainly the world I know a little about.
@@tareqkandari7277
Thanks
Btw your videos are very calming & informative ! Oh yes your background is spot on 👌
*I never knew this was a debate in Islam I learn something new everyday thanks for the deep analysis.*
It is indeed. One that again has polarities of opinions. Like music or pictures and so on.
Tareq, is there a reason you didn't mention rabies as a factor in the teachings? To me, that would have made it all make sense, especially their saliva!?!!@@tareqkandari7277
Fear ?? You mean avoid (for "impurity" reasons).
Muslims don't "fear" dogs! They don't want dogs (esp. dogs' siliva) to touch them or touch their clothes/drip on their clothes.
I have 2 dogs in my Bustaan (small farm). We don't let them inside the Bustaan's house though. And if any of their siliva touched my clothes I wash it (to be fit to pray wearing it).
@@cooldesertknight9013 I understand your distinction but i do sense that this avoidance has unfortunately crept into a fear and not solely to avoid impurity.
@@tareqkandari7277 if you mean fear like fear to general big animal then you're right
Great video, Tareq, as usual. This is something I struggle with a lot within my own community and family,(flashbacks of discussions with my beloved mom 😂)being a proud dog owner for over 20 years and having had multiple dogs throughout the years. I can tell you one thing: they are truly man's best friend.
I believe we need a more nuanced approach to this issue. It's clear from the Quran that Allah mentions dogs positively, in Surah Al-Kahf (The Cave) and other texts.
Regarding the hadith that says a dog is impure, it is meant when a dog licks your plate, that is najasa, or impure, and you have to wash it seven times. Let me tell you, if a human being licked my plate, I would wash it 15 times with soap. So, no worries there. I think there are a lot of misconceptions about dogs among Muslims that need to be addressed.
It's really a shame that, as Arabians, we have such deep connections with domesticated animals throughout history, like the Arabian horse, the camel, and hawks. We truly are kind to animals in our essence. Missing out on dogs really hurts me.
Your video brings much-needed clarity to this topic, and I hope it encourages more open-mindedness and understanding within our communities. Thanks for tackling this important issue.
Abdullrahman bin Nooh
Abdulrahman, it seems you and I struggle with similar pains regarding the value of our Islamic and Arab identity and history. I appreciate all your wonderful insights and I believe they help tell the same story but from a different perspective hence empowering the ideas being presented.
1. you can't just compare a human to a dog behavior in terms of licking plate, there is no way you can monitored a dog within the entire house , including clothes, chair, table, prayer matt or even which part of the floor it drooled at. you can ask a human if something like that happend but not a dog, they wont answear you or point to the place they've licked.
2. logic or reason kind of hazy on this topic because it include another being on the equation, angels. nobody forbid owning a dog regardles whatever attachment ones had on it, the hadith tells the condition on how you can keep it without harm, otherwise consequences will arise like those lost benefit of good deeds every single day.
3. i'm not an arab, some of us here in indonesia keep dog, but if we keep dog, it will never go inside the house, the western lifestyle is diffrent, totally diffrent. eating, sleeping, kissing, cuddling, and all this, is this how it happened in arab culture? ever heard the term bestiality?? im pretty sure its prominent only in the west.
4. perhaps you love something that are bad for you, perhaps you hated the things that are good.
Fellow Indonesian here and I know position that is more positive towards dogs in the country, supported by scholars who speak with scholarly authority.
Not going to argue here, I know enough to spend my time more productively out of youtube, just want to share that I was raised with the company of generations of loyal dogs. They protected me against snakes and boars, and they sleeped in living room. If it is not Indonesian culture for you, then call it subculture. I am ok.
Brother Abdulkarim السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
If you read Surah Al-Kahf, you'll see that Allah سبحانه و تعالى mentioned, "They were three and the dog was their fourth, and they were five and the dog was their sixth," and so on. The exact verse says, "Some say they were three, the fourth of them being their dog, and others say they were five, the sixth of them being their dog" (18:22). This clearly shows that Allah acknowledged the dog's presence among the righteous people He protected.
The notion that angels cannot come into your house and cannot record your deeds because of a dog is quite unfounded. Allah does not mention dogs in the Quran for no reason; everything Allah mentions has a purpose. The idea that dogs chase away angels or prevent them from entering your home is a disputed hadith and not universally accepted.
The Quranic mention of the dog with the people of the cave signifies that dogs can indeed have a place among the righteous. Dismissing dogs as entirely haram and impure overlooks the broader context and the nuances within Islamic teachings.
Also i did not mention that the dog should be inside living room or cuddling, it seems you compare things with western standards!
I am from Saudi Arabia we hold our culture and norms tightly we don't see the world as Western or anti Western that is a colonized mentality that i advise you to lose,The mention of bestiality from you proves that mentality.
Also i advice you to learn Arabic amd read the Quran properly, indeed you are missing out otherwise.
My Allah guide you, me and all
@@AbdulKarim-hz4pz
Brother السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
If you read Surah Al-Kahf, you'll see that Allah سبحانه و تعالى mentioned, "They were three and the dog was their fourth, and they were five and the dog was their sixth," and so on. The exact verse says, "Some say they were three, the fourth of them being their dog, and others say they were five, the sixth of them being their dog" (18:22). This clearly shows that Allah acknowledged the dog's presence among the righteous people He protected.
The notion that angels cannot come into your house and cannot record your deeds because of a dog is quite unfounded. Allah does not mention dogs in the Quran for no reason; everything Allah mentions has a purpose. The idea that dogs chase away angels or prevent them from entering your home is a disputed hadith and not universally accepted.
The Quranic mention of the dog with the people of the cave signifies that dogs can indeed have a place among the righteous. Dismissing dogs as entirely haram and impure overlooks the broader context and the nuances within Islamic teachings.
Also i did not mention that the dog should be inside living room or cuddling, it seems you compare things with western standards!
I am from Saudi Arabia we hold our culture and norms tightly we don't see the world as Western or anti Western that is a colonized mentality that i advise you to lose,The mention of bestiality from you proves that mentality.
Also i advice you to learn Arabic amd read the Quran properly, indeed you are missing out otherwise.
My Allah guide you, me and all
It’s an absolute shame that some confuse najis with a call for cruelty. It’s more telling of the person than anything else. Look at cats, they are clearly mentioned in hadiths yet cruelty towards them is all too common
I used to fear dogs. Then one day i was walking home with a cricket bat and ball and a small dog cornered me, barking like mad. I got well scared. Then i thought I've got me bat, i can defend myself. After what must have been a couple of minutes the dog stopped barking turned around and wandered off. That day i realised it only wanted to play with the ball.😂😂😂. From that day my fear went completely. I was about 8 then. It's true brother, i dunno why we're fearful of dogs. Only reason i can think of is that whenever i was naughty my mum used to threaten me of expelling me out side for my bad behaviour, stating that the dogs are going to bite me😂😂😂 and i pleaded with her "noooo pleeaaasse" I'm not going to be naughty anymore. Maybe thsts what it was. I dunno brother. Now, with kids of my own I've told them my story and they're not bothered or fearful of dogs. So I'm thinking it's my up bringing and how i interpreted that into a fear. Thank you for posting. It's a good one.
Thank you, for this both-side-argument. Personally, i hold no religion, but i do have an obvious personal interest in the subject. I happen to walk a dog 4 times a day in a neighbourhood that includes a number of muslim communities. I strive to better my relationship with all people around me, so we eat and drink, our children play on the street together, and we talk kindly. But my dog makes these things awkward. This information can help me be more mindful of them, or perhaps start a conversation.
Grettings from morroco ahki we can have a dog in a condition for hunting, for security, protecting livestocks and other forensic needs
The hadiths are clear. Angels will never enter a house with a dog....Dogs are good for hunting but never bring them in the house.
Keep the outside!
Even in Shafii school, Ibn Al-Mundhir chose to view dog saliva and even stool as ritually pure substance. He was a Shafiite with strong tendency of Zahirism. I would not think that is extreme position in Islam.
Well explained brother. Jazakallahu khair.
Brother Tareq, Lovely Dog u have, I personally don't keep them or have ever due to my own personal preferences but they have proved to be a loyal companion to all kinds of people.
Thank you for such a brilliant clarification, All the best 🙏🙏
This is an interesting discussion. Maybe it has a specific context, but it would also be interesting to include the hadith about the angels not entering a house where there's a dog. I think there are some sources that need to be brought in to get a more complete picture.
We don't have fear of dogs but because we aren't used to having them as pets most importantly because we aren't allowed to have dogs unless the dog is used for house guarding, or for cattle guarding. Not as a fancy toy.
Very interesting topic, and beautiful visual and setup😊well done!
Thank you for very clear elucidation. I DO like your presentation!
regardless of the purity or impurity of a dog , the hadiths which you yourself included prohibit the owning of a dog for other than hunting , farming or guarding (by analogy this could be extended to any beneficial use , like guide dogs) and even then they should be kept outside the house .
That would depend on context, it is understood it could be argued an individual who suffers from epileptic fits, and similar dangerous health conditions would require the dog to be close by at all times, the individual's life and possibly others if with them could be at risk, such dogs detect these things before they happen and warn those involved of the danger, Allah makes exceptions as saving lives is a must. Also, It has been explained that angels will do what Allah orders them to do, so the context of the hadith is important, for example, do you think the Angel of death would not enter your home to take your soul because you have a dog in the house? or is it the angels (may Allah bless them all), will not 'freely' enter a home containing dogs, idles, and/or pictures of people? Man also accepted the Shepard-hood of creation when Allah asked 'Who would accept the roll, we must bear this in mind with all things Allah has created and again He tells us all His creation worships Him and Allah knows best
@@-Muslims as for the example you mentioned with dangerous illnesses , i agree .
as for the angels , we do not know much about how they operate or what they are capable of , so they could be able to preform their duties from afar , or some of them are permitted to abandon their duties in the presence of a dog while others are not , or something else. the important thing is that most angels that would have entered your house , would not if there was a dog in it . and that is a good enough reason to keep a dog out unless one needs it.
and Allah knows best.
Great work! ❤
Regarding the saliva point (this has no basis aside from me btw, just a thought), I think it is halal because you cook meat anyways ?, like, if its saliva has something harmful of bacteria or its likes it dies from heat
That’s a good point to make as well.
But a dog isn't halal since it is a fanged animal. And we're specifically talking about the saliva of a dog.
@@amirulafiq4371 according to the Maliki school, they are halal to eat too
if something is haram it is not on the basis of bacteria, it is haram because Allah has made it haram for humans, cats have clean saliva but they haram to eat because Allah says its haram
@@user-yh1qd7lj5f im not referring to consuming the animal, Im referring to consuming meat that the animal has hunted
fear due to lack of Islamic knowledge, the hadith about the dog eating from a plate has been explained to me by 3 schools of thought. 1 you have to witness the actual eating, not anything else, 2 The same hadith has been described as 'but the hair of the dog is halal' Dogs rolling in sand or becoming wet through rain or swimming has purified its fur as with humans. like a dog licking clothes, hands or other required only requires wiping with water not going to extremes. and Allah knows best
Peace bro, to u and ur dog :) I think this is one of your best works, as it is dedicated to one of the most interacted creatures of God. I Personally think Dogs are a good companion, and God also honours the dog in being a good companion amongst the people of the Cave. In my personal opinion, Hadith literature demonises other animals along with the Dog, which is highly questionable, as if God would have consider it not clean or pure, why was it with the people of the cave, why did God gave special precedence to that dog ???
Al-Quran | 22:46 | Have they not travelled in the earth and had hearts with which to reason, or ears with which to hear? And it is not the eyes that are blind, but blind are the hearts which are in the breasts.
Hope this Video & my Comment opens up the eyes of people who's hearts have blinded due to the confusions of this world, Thank you 🙏
Thank you for your video 👍
If I’m understanding your thesis, the issue is not about the sharii rulings but rather the cultural affects that have skewed the laymen’s understanding of the status of dogs?
Regardless, I feel uncomfortable and nervous whenever a dog gets near me, especially with the fact that they can get unpredictable, and therefore dangerous
ur scared 😱 of a dog 😂 how weak are u
I was thinking similarly. I feel anyone who decides to own a dog must assume the responsibility of a decent level of training. Dogs are great creatures and shouldn't be bought like an accessory of desire, loosely evading space, or snapping with no training or control.
Yeah humans are famously in control of their emotions and never cause senseless harm
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Omer, i understand your emotional reaction, but allow me to give a small advice: by far most dogs (pets anyway, farm animals or fighting dogs are much further from their natural state) will mirror exacly what emotions you express. If you are confident, they are confident (and much safer, predictible etc), if you ignore them confidently, they might have a quick sniffle, but will ignore you too. If you fear them, they will fear you(and try to intimidate you), and if you yell and run, they will bark and run too. Try it out, let me know.
@@NoGoZoon yea, I knew about this before, but this doesn't make me feel any better. I actually developed a habit of getting into offensive mode whenever I see a close aggressive dog, cuz most stay away like this
I dont like to keep dogs or any other animals in the house. But if a see i good boy outside, I am petting it. Even if have to wash myself 7 times afterwards.
Absolutely brilliant said, I am a maliki and imam maalik is clear that dogs are not najis unless they are afflicted with a disease like rabies etc which can harm man
Not entirely
The Maliki position is all is not Najis except the Saliva. Further Maliki school holds the same position regarding losing good deeds if you get said dog for no reason or function (not protection, not herding dog, dog for the blind…etc).
Now if you get a small dog and try to convince your self a others its for protection then Bruh…that does not qualify.
If you want a more comprehensive answer then go to Safina society and brother is from the Maliki school of that and there is a whole learning Majlis discussing this
I would get a big dog to protect the house in the USA
There is difference between peting dog and keeping dog for saftey and hunting, and you missed this difference, and remember that dog of ashab e kahaf did enter the kahf but he was sit on the door of kahf.
Thank you brother. I always felt the same way, and believed that Mohammed pbuh must of liked animal.
Muslims don't fear anyone except Allah...
thanks for the information but it's better without the music background
Dogs are very loyal animals abd they protect our sheeps
Are we even sure these particular Hadiths are true (regardless if they pro or con). There are so many contradiction.
I'm in the school that stated dogs saliva najis. Does it make me fear dogs? it depends, if it's a pitbull for sure lol. In my observation, people fear dogs because it's uncommon here (in western indonesia).
This is my first time hearing any mention of the dog Qitmir. What is the source stating that the dog with people of the cave was called Qitmir?
We don't even know who exactly the people of cave were and their names
Keeping dog(s) are allowed as long as it is strictly placed outside the residential building and the owner follows strict Hygiene procedures. Dogs are useful for hunting and security/forensic purposes in the context of Shariat. Not sure about the ruling on keeping them purely as pets.
I think the same applies to all animals but there seems to be a distinction between dogs and the rest of the animal world. We keep chickens, sheep and others in our homes in our past. That was the nature of things. To protect what you owned.
According from what I know, if you keep a dog without proper reasons mentioned above, your good deeds accumulated so far will eventually be reduced day by day, leaving only bad/evil deeds intact.
Additionally, according to the scientists who research about the dog, dogs are best vector/medium to carry diseases while cats aren't (except for rabies which all animals are susceptible to).
So, dogs' suitable role is as guard, not pets. And they should live outside house, though giving them dog house is a good idea.
@@tareqkandari7277 Why do you like to keep a dog at home despite the Hadith of no angels entering the home and you losing reward for every day you keep the dog inside? Just curious
I don't think it is meant that the whole dog is najis. The same hadith mentions a picture and it is not najis.
Some schools of law by demonising dogs does result in the perception that the dog entirely is a najiss creature.
There is an authentic hadith : Angels will never enter a house with a dog. There is no baraka in such condition. Dogs are to guard the house and the herd of sheeps. Only ! Not as a pet inside home.
Assalamou Alaikum
Respectfully.
I will acknowledge that you have touched both sides.
I feel your heart is more inclined to 1 side though and I feel it's because of emotion and not theological & logical deliberation.
Sorry sir. Please don't feel resentful towards me.
Also Dear Senior,
Kindly don't use the term "Karma" which I saw on your instagram since it has its roots in idolatrous religions.
Well I don’t fear dog , In fact I like them but I gotta pray too
Dogs can detect evil!
the food caught by a dog is still cleaned and cooked.. different from saliva on a utencil that must be washed 7 times..
Decades ago I saw a Muslim person change his path when he was walking because a dog was in his way. The dog owner was visibly offended but didn’t say anything. I’m not a pet owner but feel the same way about cats: I don’t discriminate, I don’t want any pets!
We love dogs in Turkiye, but we get annoyed when they splash water while shaking themselves dry. We also try to keep them away when they try to lick our hands and clothes when we approach them. Because he lies down where he urinates and eats dirty things like carrion. That's why it infects people with this dirt. You cannot worship with such filth. In fact, in my sect (Hanafi) this is more liberal, but we still pay attention. The Kurdish brothers belong to the Shafi sect and although they keep dogs in their villages, they have much stricter rules regarding dogs than we do. They do not like to be touched very much and if they accidentally lick their hands, they will wash it. I have even seen people rub it with soil 7 times as an old tradition. There are those who change their clothes when they touch them. They have much stricter rules in this regard. But these are not all about dog love, they are just precautions about his tendency to get involved in dirt.
Do some research on how many times a Dog has attacked a child. When will people admit that a dog is unpredictable and remains a wild animal? I always hold my heart tight when such an animal passes my children.
@@angelosaleh8344 There is no reason to be afraid at all. If your kids don't attack the dog there is no problem. I used to have a cat who could slab (with her nails out) visitors if she didn't like them. And there are many cats who have harmed people with their nails. That doesn't make cats bad or danderous. There have been reasons for them to do that. Just like horses have hurt humans. Just ignore the animals if you want nothing to do with them.
Brother, make a video on Islamic Neoplatonism.
it's unpure only when you going to prayer just wash or bath and do wudu before going to prayer short and simple
I would say people fear God’s wrath (if they fail) rather than fear dogs, because bringing a puppy into the house it is as if you’re adopting a child , it’s a huge huge responsibility! You have to be caring , loving, extremely patient with your pet until its last day..
I’ve also noticed that dog lovers ,in many cases , don’t like people.
This is bizarre to learn that exists a Muslim fear & strange criticism of dogs??!!! And that it is written into the teachings, wow?!!
Some many black folks too have dog & their bite fears. With how historically they were violently used against them, at least makes their fear to have reason. That and the fact the scars leave their skin color more white I'm told is another substantial reason for their dog fears.
I can see how Muslim fears from wild dogs and the harms they're capable of, like devastating chicken coops they needed for survival, especially in the past played into this cultural fear. Rabies alone or also had to have a major aspect of this fear is my best guess as to the root of the problem !!
Humans never fail to suprise me with their superstitions & beliefs, or worse their actions & behaviors tied to religion, or not!
Well noone is forcing you to understand it. Cultures are different across the globe.
I for one dont understand many things westerners do.
But i dont comment on it publicly, judging it by how "bizarre" it is.
@@humhumhum-jo3wx I meant no offense and yes, you're not alone questioning many of the people western ways! ☮️
@@brendasmart553 as Someone from Majority Muslim Country its mostly Fear of getting bite and Rabies, and if you wanna get Dog as pet you need take care carefully or you will be frown down because reason above
@@irpanfauzi1160 Ahhh yes, I had came to the rabies connection 3/4 down in my post! As it was only in 1885 that the rabies vaccination was invented for humans, agreed, it was a very real & indeed a scary dangerous problem!!! I am curious why Tareq didn't factor this important 🧩 piece of data into this video? And I have no idea if rabies vaccines for dogs & cats are even mandated at all, or as effectively as here in the USA compared to the more Muslim countries? The power is in prevention of rabies & we here pretty well have had it long under control... But that's here. Rabies also was the culprit, it turns out, for all the historic werewolves type stories! Now, these teachings & cultural dilemmas regarding dogs, makes full sense! I'm trying to remember when the Quran and accompanying texts, social customs, laws, etc, were written. Long before rabies vaccines for certain! ✌️😎
Very good job information truly needed
I feared dogs; when I was a kid, the Dog chased me twice, Dog bit my father, and I know one guy died due to dog saliva
Hello Bella-what's happening-please bark if you see abu hurraira[father of cats]
Dogs in the Quran ?? Are'nt they dirty (Najis) ?!!!!!
I heard this from a Muslim friend. So I told him to read the Quran and find what Quran says about dogs. It is interesting to know that dogs are mentioned in the Quran 5 times, not just once, 7:176, 18:18, 18:22 (three times). NO WHERE does God call the dogs dirty animals or give any indication that they should be avoided or treated the way many Muslims think they should. Actually the story of the people of the cave, in Sura 18, gives the indication. that we should appreciate.
The people of the cave, 3, 5 or 7 were mentioned in the Quran and every time God insists on letting us know that their dog was there with them. Their story can be as complete without the mention of the dog, but God did, Why ?
God is telling us these righteous people were in the cave with their dog, if it is not righteous to have dogs, God would not have told us that story in which the dog has to be remembered as being there. We have to know the quality of God, if we were to worship Him correctly. When God says something He means it, and when he does not, he means it as much. If God did not curse the dog and call it all kinds of name, it is because God wants us to know that He created that beautiful creature and He expected us to make all use and companinonship with that animal that accompanied these righteous people of the cave.
Fabricated hadiths contradict the Quran. Many of them narrated by Abu Hurayra. Abu Hurayra, whose name is translated as , father of the little cat, hated dogs and women and from his mouth came many hadiths that insulted women and cursed the dogs and make them undesirable animals that need to be avoided and in other hadiths killed.
These fabricted hadtihs were falsely attributed to the prophet Muhammed who cannot utter but the teachings of the Quran and would only be a living example of the Quran itself. The prophet Muhammed who lived by the Quran could not have done anything but agree with the Quran,not contradict it. God gave us a great criteria to judge His truth form the man-made fabrications;
What breed is Bella?
@@Ushmadand Bella is a Pomsky. A mix breed of a Pomeranian and a Husky. But she’s all husky when it comes to attitude.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 so she is likely a talking prankster. A husky used to bully my poor terrier..punk was almost human when he was in a mischievous mood. Thank you for sharing 🙏
@@tareqkandari7277Very cute. Good video as always, I believe the Hanbali opinion to be correct but the video points out how irrational my discomfort with a creation of Allah is. Jazakallah Khair.
Bella is beautiful indeed, what is her breed tareq? Being from Alaska, i cant help notice she looks like a miniature version of a Husky or Siberian dog! I could look at her all day long and pet her as much as possible if blessed to be in her presence!! Im unfortunately not allowed to have any pets at the house I rent...
Thank goodness my Petra 🐕never brought me anything that she wanted me to eat.
Hehehe. Petra the angel avoided putting you in that position.
@@tareqkandari7277 What about cats? I’ve heard that Mohamed liked cats, and once took advice from a cat.
Either way, I’ve never eaten a bird or mouse that one of my cats has presented to me over the years.
the keeping of dogs in cities should be illegal they are nasty and people don't deserve them, many buy them then throw them out when they realize how much a responsibility owning one is, owning one is not a just personal choice and there has to be licensing involved there are so many strays now in Egypt that get rabies and attack people because of the negligent imitation of the west in all aspects of life.... najis or not owning dogs shouldn't be taken lightly and without a practical purpose shouldn't be allowed.
the hatred for the black dog or cat is it csn be a shape shifting jin.i luv dogs 🐕 but i hate when they bark and never shut up and how quickly angry or excited they get.
the "shape shifting jin" thing is bidaa
Interesting! BTW may I ask if you are Persian/Iranian?
Dogs can read your brain from a distance and treat you accordingly. If you don't fear or have good feeling about it, it will highly likely not hurt you.
Also watch videos on how to respond to dog attack.
Totally disagree with title. Seems like a click bait.
To generalize fear in this way isn't scholarly.
Besides the saliva and rabies that often contracted dogs, remember that angel can't read the Qur'an? That angels will sit down and listen to people reading the Qur'an, specifically after fajr. Imagine how many good deeds that probably won't get a witness from angel or the angel might have problems to say amin or to take notes of the good deeds? Just because there's a dog in the house, and if you really have the intention to keep a dog , you won't just keep it for a day or too, mostly years or even decades, and that means no angel for decades to keep in touch with you. The angel are shy creatures and dogs probably will bark if it can sees them anyway. Even the prophet wouldn't eat garlic for respect to the angels, but I guess that's a different context and closeness.
Where did you get these made-up gibberish narratives? I suppose Aḥaadiiṯ!!!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 yes it is from hadiths, u got a problem with someone who talked about things with a clear foundations?
@AbdulKarim-hz4pz
"You got a problem with someone who talked about things with a clear foundation?"
No! I don't have a problem with someone who talked things with a clear foundation.
If the dog is trained and kept well and clean, just the same as if one had a cat, and the same as the very person. Then, I don't see a problem!!
No Angel comes to the house for a Muslim person I described above, clean and behaves well as one should. Then it's a gibberish, Allaah will determine, certainly not the Aḥaadiiṯ narrators!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 so you made your opinion as a foundations of your reasoning?
seeing how you belittle the hadiths makes me wonder, all this dog problem, did it mentioned in the quran? if there is a mention please tell me, if not why are you bother with people who clearly interested and following the hadiths? if you wanna keep a dog just do it, you dont belive in any harm on it anyway.
yes allah will determine eventually, but how do you know that? what is your reason to say that allah will determine? or how will he determine? there must be rules and law. i'm guessing because we as muslim understand that allah also give us knowledge and guidance in this world, one of those are clearly the quran and the prophet himself, thats why we can say it clearly that allah will determine, otherwise how will he determine, or what he determining for? if allah didnt teach us guidance to follow, we might as well put at the same level as animals.
sadly though, tape recorder or camera did not exist back then, all we have is to preserved the knowledge from the prophet is just his companions and manuscript or as you called it ''narators'', Didn't the Quran also narrated to the prophet by the angel jibril? and in turn the prophet narrated it ''orally'' to his companion? did he put it on a tape recorder or a book? no! did he recieved the quran like we did in a bookstore? one transaction for the whole book? no!
The companions are the one that did those, they write it in stones, wood and leather, and eventually passed down to us in the form of manuscript.
Woww... lies told by Bukhari in Hadith are source hallucination for people like you. True scholar should really revise and dismiss at least 75% of it.
Misleading title.
These examples with dogs explain how complex Muslim world is.
@@kolitmas624 it's not complex, we don't hate dogs, we are just afraid of dangerous dog bites, dogs are very sensitive creatures, they also have feelings and social behavior. Kids are sometimes afraid of dogs too. One of my family was bitten by dog on his head, he had to do serious operations.
I totally agree with this video.
Very nuanced. Thanks !
Can you make such nuanced video on
1. "interpretations of islam on photography"
2. "Interpretations of islam on cinema"
3. "Interpretations of islam on music"
For number 3 check out ruclips.net/video/2eoiplh-yns/видео.html
For number 2 I think this video can provide some context.. ruclips.net/video/CZCTRRbVSEk/видео.html
@@tareqkandari7277 thanks for the guidance. Jazakallah
@@tareqkandari7277 thanks for the guidance. Jazakallah
One more thing your channel inspires me scholarship (you give me vibes of nassim nicholas taleb)
Inshallah someday i'll start something of my own
Keep doing the good work !
Regardless of religious dogma, dogs are and will always remain, man's best friend.
I am a cat person and I can assure you a cat will not be as loyal and loving to you as your dog.
And one last thing, at the end of the day, a dog will die for you. A cat simply won't.
The point of cats is to catch rodents and scare away the birds. I have a fig farm but if it weren't for my cats scaring away the pesky sparrows, I wouldn't have any figs.
I feed them chicken parts that I wouldn't eat myself like the skin, neck, hip, etc. and they've lovingly and loyally protected my figs.
If you hate dogs I cannot like you
that's great. stay away lol
The various mentions of dog reveal serveral things.
1. The Quran Sharif itself is not extreme against dogs. It just focuses on cleanliness, maintaining which was extremely important in epidemic ridden pre modern times.
2. The Quran, focusing on epidemic control, considers all animals as belonging outside human habitats, except the cleanest like cats.
3. Not having dogs without purpose in the Hadith is due to fear of rabies.
4. The Hadith should not be taken too seriously ("Black dog with 2 spots over its eyes !"). Religion ultimately derived its power from un questioning obedience. Sometimes they would assert this by giving silly orders which cannot be refused.
Given modern inventions like vaccines, Islam needs to be re-interrpeted in this light.
You can't just re-interpret Islam based on your limited understanding. You are just assuming that dogs are physically impure that is why Islam has its rules. Vaccination won't remove that issue. If it did, Allah would have told us. Just as the case of the housefly wings.
no. lol
3. is straight up your opinion that you just innovated 🤡
@@3mar00ss6I think he is right. We are not living in the 1400 when there was no vaccines. Wake up, we’re living in the 21st century where we have vaccines and vets
Never trust ppl who dont like dogs n music😊
Because it's fur smells. I smell it on people in the elevator in my building. The dog is nasty. You need to keep the dog outside. And wash it alot.
Muslims don't fear dog. What a misleading title. One of Gods commands is to not keep dogs inside house as their saliva is considered impure, if one touches their saliva, muslims are bound to wash that spot 7 times, one of which should be with earth. More can be said about it, but the main point is to obey God's commands. Muslims are allowed to keep dogs in the farm to protect and guard other farm animals or as guard dogs outside houses. Islam forbids Muslims to keep dogs, and the punishment for that is that the one who does that loses one or two qirats from his hasanat (good deeds) each day. No muslim can afford losing this amount of good deeds when they dont even do good deeds close to that amount in a day. An exception has been made in the case of keeping dogs for hunting, guarding livestock and guarding crops . Personally dogs are loud and unclean animals and craps everywhere, their saliva is dangerous, some are vicious, they attack human and even kills humans. There are likable characteristics in them, but more dislikable.
anyone know why dogs eat their own 💩 the licking to clean themselves is obvious though, just wait a while before you let them lick you on the mouth 😂 #logic101
@@sheep.herder cat also lick the butt and eat feces.
Animals are generally weird, you can train them to not be
Dogs commit incest and homosexuality, sooooo
@@GaaraNous of course cats also do, like most animals - they weren't gifted like humans with hands to clean. my daughter has two housecats because they are admired for their cleanliness and most importantly prophet Muhammad,peace be upon him was fond of them...everytime i go into her home it smells like cat faeces, not to mention the whole house, including clothes are covered in _pure_ cat hair. common sense must prevail, cats and dogs were domesticated and were free prior to this (wild) i *"personally"* like keeping fish as pets 🐟 🤣
@@sheep.herder
It's not correct to say that Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad loved or hated this particular thing or that particular, as really no-one knows. Only people's hearsay recorded as if it were facts!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 could be, as you mentioned... still doesn't change what I wrote.
Completely wrong. Dogs are not clean. That's doesn't mean that they are not God's creature. One man enters paradise just because he climbed down a well to just get a water for a dog
The only unclean ideology is isLAME
@@testexam Of course they’re not clean, if you don’t take care of them properly
Nah Bruh nothing Wrong with dog if you keep it as good boy and girl, The Problem is if you not keep it as a good boys and girl there is sicknes if you get bitten by sick dog Rabies what i said
We also dont like pigs does that mean we fear them. You are way off, You know full well that Muslims say that dogs are Najis so it has nothing to do with fear, How can a Muslim who has Taqwa, fear anything but Allah SWT do you not see the contradiction. I dont think you thought this through properly. Try again buddy
I'm getting error subscribing to your channel
Very strange Jasper. Not sure why that would happen.
@@JasperPlays you better not to. He is banning people for saying that Israel is legitimate country
@@Alex_lol He is correct. The land belongs to Palestinians because Palestinians are genetically closer to the Israelite. And yes in the Quran there was a man name Israel and his descendants are the Palestinians. not the the ambiguous European Jews colonialists. And the exodus wasn't part of Roman policy.
@@hafizumar107 f*ck that. Palestine and all of Mediterranean belongs to Italians as they are descendants of romans. Let’s give every piece of land to everyone who once owned it. (That was sarcasm (for people who think that Palestine is a legitimate nation))
The actual innovator is said to be Abu Huraira. In English that is father of the cat, lol.
May Allah be pleased with Abu Huraira. You must be a rafidhi who worships 12 demigods.
when you take ahadith and apply it in our age without its historical/environmental context and without compassion or reason you will get something that to an outsider looks arbitrary, cruel and illogical you end up with crazy rulings around dogs, pictures, music, tattoos, women shaping their eyebrows, the shape and size of ones beard etc etc, we end up arguing over these peripheral things all the time forgetting islams core message of connecting and surrendering to Allah our complete accountability to Him and doing good to others ( humans and animals ) to please Him
Dogs cannot be in the house.
The animal itself doesn't want to be sleeping inside either. They would much rather sleep in a barn or a dog shed outside.
Also I'd like to point out that the killing of dogs couldn't have been because they were aggressive or rabid. It's clear that they were killed because it is prohibited to keep them in houses. Angels do not enter a house where there's a dog.
Why it is prohibited to the extent that they were killed is unknown. It's a divine mandate unclear of its rationalization as do some other mandates.
Nonsense Nonsense Nonsense
I dont understand your point. Why would the dogs in the homes be killed? And how was this performed logistically? Without any filter, so even hunting dogs were killed?
@@tareqkandari7277
Because as you've pointed out keeping dogs not for anything useful is haram. Even those that are useful are supposed to be kept separate in their own shelters as per scholars of fiqh specifically the Shafi'is and Hanbalis
@@tareqkandari7277
As I pointed out I don't know the reasoning. I take what is apparent in the hadith. To say that they were initially killed because they were dangerous is to impose onto the text what is not there.
Jibreel is afraid of dogs. He runs when he sees a dog. They scare him.
Narrated Salim's father: Once Gabriel promised the Prophet (that he would visit him, but Gabriel did not come) and later on he said, "We, angels, do not enter a house which contains a picture or a dog."-Sahih al-Bukhari 3227
The Hadith doesn’t say angels fear dogs. Is lying about Islam a Christian thing?
@@LWeil-pu2wj Jibreel doesn't enter the house because of the dog. It means he is afraid....what else could be the reason?
@@marcusj9947 The word “picture” in the Hadith is mistranslated . The real meaning is “statue”. So based on your own interpretation angels fear statues as well. The Hadiths clearly says angels don’t enter a house which contain dogs and statues and no where in it says angels runs away from dogs.
@@LWeil-pu2wj you are a liar. If you have a problem with the translation taking it up with the Saudi's who own the hadiths and the sunnah website. They did the translation and the scholars who did it said it's picture.
Again if Jibreel is not scared of the dog why is he not entering the house? Jibreel sees a dog and runs for the hills.
@@LWeil-pu2wj The word is picture. The scholars of the hadith translate it as picture. If you have another scholar showing otherwise bring otherwise stop trying to re-interpret this
We dont fear dogs we have Kangals high Turkish Shepherd dogs
Our dogs have good life becayse they have freedom and terrain to run and we have sheeps
Your titel about muslims is not correct