Does the Quran Prophesy the End of Israel? | Dr. Shabir Ally
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июн 2024
- Does the Quran prophesy the end of the state of Israel? There's been a lot of social media commentary on this subject, and Dr. Shabir Ally weighs in. He says that chapter 17 in the Quran is thought to be a commentary on current affairs. He says this modern interpretation comes from a place of desperation and a desire to find hope in the Quran. However, he argues that the verses in question were futuristic from the time God told the Israelites it would happen, but not futuristic in our time. Dr. Shabir doesn't like this modern interpretation for another reason: it likens contemporary Muslims to those who originally destroyed the temple in 586 BC. He says we can draw an indirect lesson from this verse: all human beings need to be aware that if they misuse the power God gives them, God can diminish them in this life. (Watch part 2 where Dr. Shabir responds to viewer comments: • Part 2: Does the Quran... )
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to iGive@QuranSpeaks.com OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: ruclips.net/user/subscription_...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
God doesn't prophesize. God decrees, informs, he's the originator, creator of the information.
Agree 100%. He decrees . He does not predict.
Sure,Allah does not speculate.He decrees
@@ai77716
You expect "they"?!
@@ai77716 I get your point of adding a male pronoun before God himself.Translators generally consider “He” to be the best translation for “huwa” (هو), which is the pronoun used throughout the Qur’an in reference to the Divine. However, this is not because they believe that huwa being grammatically masculine implies that Allah is male or male-like. “We” is also used without implying that Allah is plural or refers to multiple deities. Even in English, the “royal we” is a known linguistic convention for denoting greatness and sovereignty, not plurality.
@@starkninja9504 this i agree, logically correct....its translation! Almighty is infinite blissful reality! Not any gender as commonly misinterpreted
ISRAEL WAS CHOSEN WITH CONDITIONS AND HAD BROKEN ALL OF THEM.
Yes!!! The land no longer belongs to the Jews because they broke their covenant with God, they rejected and killed prophets. God put the Jews in exile for breaking their covenant and they are not supposed to enter the land. Even according to the Torah the Jews can not enter the land without God’s permission or when the Messiah returns. So you guys have once again disobeyed God and entered the land without God’s permission. You took the land by shedding blood and it is a sin for the Jews.
Very well said indeed. The thing about "The chosen people" was for taking responsibility to convey Allah message through his prophets, not to choose them because they are a superiour race as the Jews keep claiming. They have even made their religion a racial religion. If you are not a Jew by blood you are not allowed to embrace this religion. Pathetic!
Yep. God was clear about not going back until they get the Green light... The Bible is the Bible for many good reasons, one of them is the direction
To which life MUST be lived in order to be saved. Here and now!
The manipulation is sickening to me. Israel only means the land of Jacob that’s Abraham have given the land to
Yes and Jews (real Jews) know that. According to them its a sin to seek the establishment of a Jewish state. Its is Zionism and Zionist who seek the establishment of a Jewish state. Zionist follow Hertzel not Moses. Hertzel was a known Atheist. Extremely important to understand this..
Let's pray to Allah to protect Palestinian people
Mairu protect cheyyum cheytha pravarthiku anubhavikum pinne mongeetu karyam illa
God will not protect palestine because he is the one who is destroying it...😂😂
He has done a great job so far.
Yeh the GREATEST of DECEIVERS(QUEERAN 3:54) will PROTECT the FAKESTINIANS🤣🤣🤣🤣🖕👊🏿
Please don't pray to Allah pray to God a living God
Dear Friends! The First occasion was when Thutmose-III invaded Palestine and did exactly what Netanyahu is doing in GAZA today!
(For inhabiting Jews, suffering in Sinai.)
The second occasion is just what is happening now.
Initially Emptying Gaza & Later West Bank too!
Netanyahu is the re-incarnation of Thutmose-III.
But they knew very well, as the Era is going to be an Era of Truth, that the Jews would be crushed!
It was NOT a Prophecy! Jews had written, what they had planned to do and they knew that they would be punished!
Hence, they knew that Israel would come to an END!
River-to-the sea, for the Palestinians!
There's no such thing as reincarnation
That's a pagan idea.
I never heard such stupidity like this 🤔🙄😂, Thutmoses III Th, invaded Palestine 🙏🙏🙏🤔😂😂😂😂😂
Please unite as 1 Ummah
Thurman?
Yes, last 12 Imam mahdi+mighty warrior Isa. Benjamin Netanyahu is the last minister for Zionist Israel(Bani Israel)
@@michaelevans9620 you are seemingly ignorant.
In sha Allah, soon we will all unite as one ummah
@@islamisthetruth5642 Why? Fool, you should strive to unite with God or Allah or whatever other name is used. He is The One who gifted you human chance for this very purpose. The muslim world can do nothing for your salvation.
Your dad is a good man but he gave a complicated explanation and missed the most important part of that part of Surah Isra. “In ud tum Ud Na.” If you return (to evil) We shall return (to punishment).” The repetition of punishment is not limited to two - it is as many times as necessary.
Peace be upon you my brothers and sisters. Soon I will reveal to you the secrets of the end of the State of Israel and not the children of Israel. The time is approaching. I have decoded the verses of Surat Al-Isra using reverse engineering. Frankly, what I achieved with the calculation amazed me. I will give you two pieces of evidence to prove to you that the Qur’an is from God. The rest I will not reveal until after two weeks, God willing. I will record a video first in Arabic. Then in English. Anyone who wants to publish the video is welcome. All scholars of interpretation will discover the verses that made them make mistakes in interpretation. I'll give you the first clue. If we divide the order number of Surah Al-Isra in the Qur’an, which is the seventeenth number, into units and tens, it will give us seven (for days) and ten (for months), i.e. the month of October. October 7 is the date of the Battle of Al-Aqsa Flood. The second evidence: The Battle of Al-Aqsa Flood. The word Al-Aqsa is mentioned in the first verse, and the word “Flood” alludes to the verse in which Noah was mentioned, which is verse number three. The rest of the numbers I will reveal to you soon. The number of the year 2023 is also encoded in these verses. You will only be able to extract this number mathematically.
Yes, you are correct
❤
Great bro
You are right bro
It brings my heart so much peace and joy knowing that Allah has promised my brothers victory. Alhamdulillah!!!
He have not promised anyone anything.
@@GunillaSvensson-cu9vf clearly you have not digested what has been said in this video. It's pretty much a promise that this time around, if they don't get their acts together, they will be completely destroyed like they were by the Romans and others. If you missed that part, watch it multiple times and if you still refuse to understand it, then the Quran also mentions "They are deaf, dumb and blind, and so they do not think and understand." (Al-Baqarah 2:171)
@@KPK4LIFE what is written in the quran have nothing to do with anything,means nothing, it is just a book written by a man, or a woman.
@@GunillaSvensson-cu9vfYou will see.
@@GunillaSvensson-cu9vf You are clearly ignorant or chose to be.
I’m no scholar but I believe verse 8 answers the question somewhat:
“It may be that your Lord will have mercy on you but if you repeat (the crime) We shall repeat (the punishment)”
This is the way of God. If you return to the same prohibited conduct you face the same consequences. The question is has Israel returned to the same conduct of ‘corruption’ and ‘arrogance’ on the land?
YES
Agree. Some historian needs to look up the level of atrocities conducted then and compare them to now. Dr Shabir uncle wasn't able to comprehend this simple interpretation and aunty called it Gods prophecy when God doesn't prophesize, God decrees and creates.
It's TOTALLY YES now ..of POV now...
All of religion and religious are fake to make slaves of others and do the blood shed in the name fake prophets and books
Religions has killed more people than all the other wars combined in the history of mankind 🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸murderers🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸
Thanks!
Always educational and always engaging - thanks for uploading.
In Isaiah 11:11, God promised to stretch out his hand to regather Israel from the four corners of the earth “a second time” (the first time being from the lands of the Babylonian exile).
We know from Hosea 3:4-5 that it would occur in the last days, and Amos 9:15 tells us that they will never be uprooted again.
Jeremiah 11 and John 8 44?
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "The Hour will not be established until the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends amongst you as a just ruler, he will break the cross, kill the pigs, and abolish the Jizya tax. Money will be in abundance so that nobody will accept it (as charitable gifts).
Sahih al-Bukhari 2476
@HackerPULSE90 yes Allah is Mohammed, both are the same, and Mohammed was a false prophet, his character exposes him .
No prophet ever raped women or slept with kids
God didn't say butcher Palestinian women and children
True
Jeremiah 33:7-34:17
I will restore the fortunes of Judah and the fortunes of Israel, and rebuild them as they were at first. I will cleanse them from all the guilt of their sin against me, and I will forgive all the guilt of their sin and rebellion against me. And this city shall be to me a name of joy, a praise and a glory before all the nations of the earth who shall hear of all the good that I do for them. They shall fear and tremble because of all the good and all the prosperity I provide for it. “Thus says the Lord: In this place of which you say, ‘It is a waste without man or beast,’ in the cities of Judah and the streets of Jerusalem that are desolate, without man or inhabitant or beast, there shall be heard again the voice of mirth and the voice of gladness, the voice of the bridegroom and the voice of the bride, the voices of those who sing, as they bring thank offerings to the house of the Lord: “‘Give thanks to the Lord of hosts, for the Lord is good, for his steadfast love endures forever!’ For I will restore the fortunes of the land as at first, says the Lord. ...
So.. Zionist God is Satan?
Only Satan will encourage you to bring destruction to the world, to bring chaos and killing other living being😂
Thanks bro but it's no use talking to them.They refuse to listen but atleast they must show respect because that is the reason why there is war today.They don't respect
Well, that is before the lord cursed them and exiled them to never return or establish their own sovereignty.
After all they killed over 300 prophets last being Zakaria and John the Baptist.
And according to Christians they also killed Jesus. No where in the Bible does it say support the jews, on the contrary Jesus himself called them the children of the devil.
But current events were Prophecized in Zakaria 14. He is talking about the Palestinians fighting evil.
@h.6479 it's future tense.We also have the Ezekiel prophecy which he says he will come defend Israel himself so once again u guys need to chill,raise yo kids right, don't start trouble and value yo lives ..
@Hshdzsskidi Yes, future tense, but after the Babylon incident. So it happened long time ago.
If all Muslim and christian would think like this guy then the world be a better place to live
Dr. Shabir Ally is one of the best scholars I have ever liked. His presentations and debate exceed my expectations.
Mashallah I am very proud of your work ❤❤❤❤
There’s also in the same Surah in verse 8 a clear warning AFTER the two prophesied destructions, and it goes as follow :
عَسَىٰ رَبُّكُمْ أَن يَرْحَمَكُمْ ۚ وَإِنْ عُدتُّمْ عُدْنَا ۘ وَجَعَلْنَا جَهَنَّمَ لِلْكَـٰفِرِينَ حَصِيرًا ٨ ( Perhaps your Lord will have mercy on you, but if you return, We will return.And We have made Hell a ˹permanent˺ confinement for the disbelievers.”
Did muslims destroy Isreal already?
Revelation 20 says this too.
@@musicsubicandcebu1774 In Genesis 13:14-15, God told Abraham, “Lift your eyes now and look from the place where you are … for all the land which you see I will give to you and your descendants forever.”
And Genesis 15:18 states, “On the same day the LORD made a covenant with Abram, saying: ‘To your descendants I have given this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the River Euphrates.’”
God gave the land forever to Abraham and his descendants unconditionally.
Whatever it is ,its human beings explanation . Our feeble minds cannot truly fathom Allah's plans snd actions . But we know His plans are the best and divinely fair for dunia and akhirat . Alhamdulillah Allahu Akbar
Sahih Muslim 41:6902:"Allah Messenger said:"Last Hour will not come until my Ummah fight each other & there is large scale massacre among them muslims."
You better read this Quran verses.
Quran chapter 5:64
Allah have two hand, both are right hand.
What do you think?
AMIN...AMIN...AMIN...YA RABBI ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
@@seagull7579a što ti misliš.....pametnjakovicu!!!!!???????????
@@semsamatanovic5454we think that is insane because we believe God is spirit but again we respect your beliefs..
Thank you .
Insha’Allah! I pray that that day will come sooner than later.
You will have to pray all your life and still it won't happen. Wait and see.
God of Israel is greater than Allah who was revealed after Christ in Islam
@@aam1975 there is not doubt of that. That's why his people are highly successful and always in the lead. Amen.
I'm an atheist through and through but it's good to see a positive channel like this in these dark times.
I'm Christian and I want to say their beliefs contradicts ours so wouldn't it be best they respect that,like we n jews respect theirs?peace than war?Palestinians were given a chance to share the land but choose destruction, despite us jews n Christians showing them proof that The State of Israel was a prophercy fulfilled.
Are you forgetting what happened bani Israil when they were rejecting the land, and asked Nabi Musa (Moses) As and Allah to fight the ancestor of Palestine alone, then Allah forbidden them (bani Israil) live without lands for 40 years. After Nabi Yusya As who has stopped the sun defeat the ancestor of Palestine, but in one condition only people who believe Allah can go to Yerrusalem. In Nabi Daud (David) and Sulaiman (Solomon) AS era, they're treating Palestine equal to bani Israil because they become Allah's followers, so there no reason to kick them out. Remember nabi Isa (Jesus) lives among Palestinian, and they're most follower of his. And once again who has betrayed Isa (Jesus) As, if you denial my statement, you're a Zionist.
@woodstalon1881 again u blabbing on yo beliefs which contradicts ours. Geez there is no point arguing but rather just respect each other's beliefs for the sake of peace. This is why there is no peace in The middle east because u guys are just inconsiderate. If u study the Bible, u will begin to understand that Israel existence is a prophercy fulfilled..
How can you be atheist and at the same time believe in this mambo jambo
😂😂
Your explanation makes sense but if they were already punished twice for their misbehavior then it's 100% certain that they will be punished again for the current misbehavior which is even worse compared to the past ones.
No, it wasn't prophesied.
17:8 answers your question
7 times more ....
No. The Quran affirms the Jewish Bible and the Bible states the land will return to the Jewish people.
The Quran did not state the Promise Land will go to the followers of Mohammed. In fact, the word Jerusalem is not mentioned.
@@aliyaj1018 torah 2024 ? no no no ....
But he God also end the verse
وإن عدتم عدنا..
Like everytime you are back will be back to you too.
"What Is Happiness
What is happiness
Wealth cannot buy a healthy body
Fame and qing [emotions] are the dirt kicked up by the dusty wind
Modern notions and conduct obstruct the divine path
Not believing in the divine, one deceives oneself
Tradition can make people pure and simple
Kindness is recognized by all Gods
Most are Gods incarnate, having come to await the Creator
Obtain the Fa [Heavenly Law] to remake the divine body at the end times, leaving delusion and hardship behind
Saving the beings of your heavenly kingdoms, a promise you made when descending to Earth
The Holy One has struck the heavenly drum to announce the spread of Dafa
How many people have awoken, becoming rational and clear
How many will be saved and return to heavenly palaces
December 12, 2019"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin IV, from Falun Dafa teachings)
Quoting from "Qoo-run" :
In Sura Al-Mai'dah (5:21) "Aladdin" addresses the children of Israel as "O my people," urging them to enter the Holy Land. The verse states "O my people enter the Holy Land which Allah has assigned to you and do not turn back !!!
Ya, but act like noble and exemplary human beings too as the Talmud and Torah told them to not act more like the devil's advocates and carrying out such dastardly deeds that Satan would be proud of. In
😅😅😅😅
I suggest to read what Shaarawi wrote about that ( the 2 occasions should be under the Islam area according the Arabic wording). Sheikh, please check and advise.
The second was under Islamic rule as you tightly said it and it had expired after second world war 2
Wealeykumselam Brother and sister Good job appreciated
WE LOVE PROPHET SULAIMAN (AS)...🤲💐🌹💐
Psalm 83 verse 4
Why should any person or country come to an end ? God loves all and is present in all .
A complete lecture about this verse is done by Dr Israar Ahmad RA in urdu in 2004 by name ' Ummati Muslima Ka Maazi Haal Aur Mustaqbil' . I request everyone to see to it. Dr Israar has related how we are related to it now. It is a lecture of 2+ hours.
Once an urdu/ hindi speaker starts hearing Dr israr ahmed then insha Allah he will understand a great deal.
Send link
I've watched and read many of his books on this topic.
Dr,. Israr Ahmad was a great scholar of his era who spoke about islam as it was without innovations and as muslims our majority was thinking islam of a religion but he was the one after Iqbal and Maudoodi, who purified islam and talked about the socioeconomic and political system of Islam...
Incomplete explanation: Explain up to verse 017.008 "It may be that your Lord may show Mercy unto you (you may come back); but if ye revert , We shall revert: And we have made Hell a prison for those who reject.
By the way, Quran is speaking about children of Israel, not State of Israel ( Illegal State of Israel)
I do not see any sense in his so called explanation, but an escape from being bold against Anti Muslim forces.
Dr Shabbir usually bend towards Anti Islamic or Anti Muslim sides and want to please them, or say he do not want them to be angry on him. That is the reason he always try to explain against majority views of Islamic Scholars. He some time even go against Quran and Hadees as well. In case of Meraj and Israa, he even one time said, Prophet may go physically but in dreams or in Aalame Arwah. Very respectfully I will say he is not brave enough to be firm on Islamic beliefs especially on which Non Believers comment frequently. I do not want say, he is coward, but I must say, he is not bold enough to take stand firmly.
Easy, Allah gives mercy to his servants. But if the servant does not change or repent. Then Allah will decide
ኣላህ ጥራይ እዩ እቲ ዝያዳ ፍትሓዊ። እቲ ኣዝዩ መሓሪ። እቲ ኣዝዩ ለባም።
This life given to you is the Lords's mercy.
You know not all of them are bold like Hamza Yusef or Imran Hosein. Some are afraid of assassination, losing their chanel, or don't want to loss their money donor.
I really like this imam, he’s very knowledgeable. I would love to see him and a rabbi scholar have a civil, educational discussion .
We have to be specific here. Because the Bible is in two: old testament and New testament, all talked about Israel and Israelis. So can I know whether the portion of the Quaran you're relying on this topic is taking cognizant of old testament Israel or new testament Israel, which?
Bible was changed by ZION nist...to their likes
In the ayat there is explicitly a difference between the two promises. Allah has explicitly stated that the first promise has been completed, which means that it is something that happened in the past. When it comes to the second, it is indicated what will happen to them, which will actually take place in the future. Nowhere in the aya is indicated that it is a promise that has been completed.
In the ayat, Allah warns Bani Israel what the consequences are for their behavior: if you do good, you do it for yourself and if you do bad, you do it for yourself. From the Quranic perspective it is something that will take place in the future.
Your explanation makes sense. Even if they were already punished twice for their misbehavior then it's 100% certain that they will be punished again for the current misbehavior which is even worse compared to the past ones.
ok, if you say like this thn why arent the muslims being punished for their corruption? look at saudi or even pakistan.. who u think will be the one standing against israel and usa? ppl dnt get it.. this is the end. qayamah is near any day now. there is no redemption for muslims as they are the most corrupt.. if you think houthis/yemeni thn look at their attrocities on their own ppl.. every group you talk about is no better thn israels.. the yahood will answer for their genocides but probably in the next world. yajooj majood are here and this is the end
He literally explains in the video why this interpretation is not necessarily true
so you mean Muslims will destroy the temple and their synagogues while it is clear that these temples are holy for us too and we are prohibited to kill innocents and destroy houses and temples , i agree with Dr ali that it is not about future
Thanks brother You dont beat around the bush like many scholares. You call a spade spade. You explain excactly as Sheikh Imran Hussain explained the faith of Bani Israil 30 years ago.
Is the interviewer the Sheiks daughter? It finally hits me about that. Great energy and topics.
yes. its in the bio.
Yes she has a PhD and is brilliant. If my background was in her field and I wanted to try to start a PhD program, again, I would probably request to be her supervisee.
Wow, 20 years of denial, where does my youth go, my life my precious
God bless you!
And Ishmael will be a savage man; His hand is against everyone and everyone’s hand is against him.” (Genesis 16:11-12)
Wow. I haven’t heard that before.
How about this.Genesis 17:20
As for Ishmael, I have heard you; behold, I have blessed him and will make him fruitful and multiply him greatly. He shall father twelve princes, and I will make him into a great nation.
Peace be upon you my brothers and sisters. Soon I will reveal to you the secrets of the end of the State of Israel and not the children of Israel. The time is approaching. I have decoded the verses of Surat Al-Isra using reverse engineering. Frankly, what I achieved with the calculation amazed me. I will give you two pieces of evidence to prove to you that the Qur’an is from God. The rest I will not reveal until after two weeks, God willing. I will record a video first in Arabic. Then in English. Anyone who wants to publish the video is welcome. All scholars of interpretation will discover the verses that made them make mistakes in interpretation. I'll give you the first clue. If we divide the order number of Surah Al-Isra in the Qur’an, which is the seventeenth number, into units and tens, it will give us seven (for days) and ten (for months), i.e. the month of October. October 7 is the date of the Battle of Al-Aqsa Flood. The second evidence: The Battle of Al-Aqsa Flood. The word Al-Aqsa is mentioned in the first verse, and the word “Flood” alludes to the verse in which Noah was mentioned, which is verse number three. The rest of the numbers I will reveal to you soon. The number of the year 2023 is also encoded in these verses. You will only be able to extract this number mathematically.
@@mu3alimwrong. Obadiah prophesied against them also. They and Edom joined to destroy Israelites.
You ishmaelites have you reward in punishment
@@mu3alim And the child grew and was weaned. And Abraham made a great feast on the day that Isaac was weaned. 9But Sarah saw the son of Hagar the Egyptian, whom she had borne to Abraham, laughing.b 10So she said to Abraham, “Cast out this slave woman with her son, for the son of this slave woman shall not be heir with my son Isaac.” 11And the thing was very displeasing to Abraham on account of his son. 12But God said to Abraham, “Be not displeased because of the boy and because of your slave woman. Whatever Sarah says to you, do as she tells you, for through Isaac shall your offspring be named. 13And I will make a nation of the son of the slave woman also, because he is your offspring.” 14So Abraham rose early in the morning and took bread and a skin of water and gave it to Hagar, putting it on her shoulder, along with the child, and sent her away. And she departed and wandered in the wilderness of Beersheba.
Israel has no problem with the Arab states around it but with the Arabs who live in Israel and seek to destroy it. The ones who want to usurp their land and throw them in the sea. Let Ismael live in its allotted land and let Isaac live in its land.
Excellent explanations, Thanks a lot
This is very nice and everybody should pray
Jazaakullah khair
As a Christian, I enjoyed Dr Sabir' thoughts and yes the two cities and their inhabitants mentioned are the first relating to genocide. And Prophazing is telling those who choose to listen, what will take place in the future and only GOD knows that. @therealsheikh Yes?
As a christian you don't know your bible. If you did you would know the blessings God had given Isreal. Why do you think Arabs want to take Isreal ?
Dr Sabir is wrong on many points. You should listen to his debates with David Wood. Sabir lost.
@@darinhanson6945once they were blessed,those who are with Mose....laiter the companions of Mose started disobeying him and started worshiping calf ,fire etc which is completely against ideology of monotheism, and laiter, when Jesus came with God massage as a massanger, to them they can't accept him as a true massanger rather they harassed Jesus and laiter start conspiracy to eliminate him but God saved him...as a result God becomes very angry at them and not send any other massanger and cursed them and,so they aren't blessed anymore
You are what the Bible referred to as seed planted on the sea shore that can be easily washed away. Because your faith is shaky.
@@shemovrere7431 and that,sea was dried to, to protect the seed and to grow the tree by the will of almighty, hadn't you noticed Christianity was dried up...... and Islam was rising upward in field of Christianity
I've to go through repeatedly to understand this scholarly video over a burning topic
Me TOO 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️
“Scholarly “😂
OK now study the Ezekiel prophecy. It totally contradicts the Quran but u don't find us n jews starting wars with u .It's time u guys show respect like we do.
This channel should be called let the Jahal Speak because instead of what the Quran clearly states, Dr Shabir presents what a Tafseer of some Jahal Ulma Sue says. His tafseer is his own opinion. Allah did not have any hidden secrets in the Quran that only a few individuals would understand and the rest of us are dependent on them to read it through their lens which he got from his sect not from independent sources of the Quran and Sahi Hadith.
Throughout Dr Shabir's Islam/Christianity debates, he always referred to scriptures such as the Quran, Bible, and Hadith but when it comes Quran alone he refers to some Ulmah Sue Tafseers and their opinion. No Tafseers were written or given to us by Rasool Ullah or Sahaba. Read Sahi Muslim Dr. Shabir and it tells you that The only tafseer of the Quran is from Sahi Asnaad Ahadees, not your Ulmah Sue's opinions or how they interpreted it.
@@Farhan_Chohan83 u might be correct as he may be lacking in some interpretation but introspection needed which may be in contradiction to conventional approach..eg..i think u r aware.. good healthy debate currently raging regards.. surah..bani israil.. jazakallah khair..ref..dr yaseer qadi..also like to add.. calling jaheel.. meaning.i think..ignorant..is outright audacious
You are an honourable, intellectual and humble brother. Your family & children reflect your level of Islamic dignity. Maashallah.
isLIEmoSUPREMACIST DIGNITY?🤣Oh the IRONY🤮👊🏿
@@craigthurlow9308
Learn basic English. Or maybe you’re intellectually challenged.
im really not understanding your point please
Not sure but I think the 8th verse explains the current situation as it says "if you go back to your corrupted ways We will punish you again" for me this suits bani israel now as they are corrupting alot in Palestine
If you believe they are bani israel you truly know nothing.
The Truth descendants of Jacob are scattered throughout the Earth.
@@readors Which means another punishment is on the horizon and this is where the cycle may end as we near the end times. Ever heard of the term "the curse of eighth decade"?
May be it says loud and clear about you corrupting ways? Did you consider this?
Nonsense. Corruption would mean worshipping false gods like trans and glad. The Quran says to slay the idolators and its right. Israel was forced to fight in 48 and 67, and in 99 offered a good peace deal (not quite good enough, since Haram Al Sharif should have been neutral), and Arafat rejected it and launched 2nd Intifada. Then they left Gaza and instead of a new Singapore with hotels, they got Hamas and terror. God would punish the Israelites if they did not defend themselves.
@@Pacmon0 1st corruption means every false action such as killing 34000 civilians mostly children and women, forcing the people to move from one area to another, cutting humanitarian aids, and most importantly occupying other peoples land. 2nd please give me the verse where Quran says to slay the idolators and its right. Dont be like a talking parrot repeating what he hears....and 3rd for what so called israel was forced to fight, please educate urself in history before commenting...anyway regardless if u wanna educate urself or u wanna keep be ignorant, we are going back to our homeland...from the river to the sea palestine will be free
LORD GOD ALMIGHTY IS IN AN EVERLASTING COVENANT WITH ISRAEL~
Genesis 17:7-8 says "I will establish my covenant as an everlasting covenant between me and you and your descendants after you for the generations to come, to be your God and the God of your descendants after you. The whole land of Canaan, where you now reside as a foreigner, I will give as an everlasting possession to you and your descendants after you; and I will be their God.
Genesis 17:19 "Then God said, Yes, but your wife Sarah will bear you a son, and you will call him Isaac. I will establish my covenant with him as an everlasting covenant for his descendants after him."
Genesis 17:21 "But my covenant I will establish with Isaac, whom Sarah will bear to you by this time next year."
Your book is written by human beings. Only Islam is the truth. Allah God Almighty doesn't help the oppressors who killed thousands of children. Are you OK in your head?
Jeremiah 11 and John 8 44 ?
@@seraajregal4663 bs, you obviously don't understand scripture, Jeremiah has been fulfilled, and Jesus was talking to the religious elite.
@@GODOURSALVATION. AMEN AMEN AMEN!. Thank youu~ 🤗💜
Thank u so much
As a child of Yahweh and a follower of Yeshua I am pleased to see the gentleness of these commentors. The message is cloudy but the peace is clear. Let all men everywhere see through the logos to the pure oil of God and His Love for those who love peace not demanded by tyranny but built up in humility and sensitivity to His Ruach Ha'qodesh.
Very knowledgeable teacher 💜
Dr shabir is very sincere and a good person , he gives hope
A good person, yes. But to whom does he give hope? Hope of what?
Peace comes from being content and thankful to One's maker for this chance of human life to better the soul. I never hear that from him.
Is the biggest sign of day of judgement?
Does the reverse also have weight?
That's my question too
Very confusing and complicated for me.
Please can someone explain second time has happened or it's going to be in the future?
I'm not sure but About 70 or 80years ago the scholars at that time said that both of the events have taken place but at that time things were different and Jews and Israel were not near the position they are in today and now by watching the genocide of Israel and it's oppression it's being said that this is going to be happen second time and had only happened once in past.
The First Temple was destroyed in 587 BC by the Neo-Babylonian Empire. The Second Temple was destroyed in AD 70 by the Romans.
The 2nd times of great fitna is now happening..
will never happen
It depends on the interpretation, classical scholars said both of them were in the past, but modern scholars said the k
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Bless Yemen 🇾🇪 the heros of West Asia ! Bless South Africa 🇿🇦 the defenders of human life
Well said . Amen.
AMEEN
I request the Israel to free Palastine from the 🌎 🇮🇱💪
One sided 🙄🙄🙄
Viva Yemen 🇾🇪 Viva South Africa 🇿🇦 Viva Résistance! Free Palestine 🇵🇸 !
To the the end of Israel, read Book of Ezekiel 38&39 chapter,Jeremiah 9&10 chapter,psalm 83,.and read DEUTERONOMY CHAPTER 4 most important chapters about Israel in the BIBLE..
Israel ends after Armageddon, since it will be called Beulah and the religion closer to Islam (Isaiah): all nations will come to Israel/Beulah, to bow down to God, for 30 days, sunup to sundown.
Write it don't make an assignment to me
Thanks you
And We have indeed made the Qur'an easy to understand and remember: then is there any that will receive admonition? - Yusuf Ali (54:17).
😂😂
Read isaiah 54:1-17, no weapons against the blessed Hebrew (Zion)
@@peterkipkirui-jt5pv Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United States and Israel are all white colonial settler states.
This means they were founded on genocide, dispossessing indigenous people of their land, colonization and imposing theirs as the dominant culture.
Israel still completing their process.
PS: Does this Biblical quote include when the ‘blessed Hebrew’ is committing mass genocide (as we witness everyday on Aljazeera)?
@@peterkipkirui-jt5pv The Bible will always be a thousand steps ahead of the fake man-made Quran.
Prophet Muhammad saying is the evidence.
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him."
Sahih al-Bukhari 2926
He who watches over Israel neither sleeps nor slumbers . All who rise against you shall scatter.
That is not a biblical verse,but a fabricated by Scofiel bible which was funded by Darby. Don't forget Scofeild was imprisoned for theft in 1886.educate yourself before fabricated biblical bandwagon.
Which Israel? Your brain has been washed.
Does God watches over Israel means that God keeps the State of Israel safe because the State of Israel was created and could only exist with God's permission?
Yea? Are you talking about the one who “rested” after creating heavens and earth. Sounds like the one you speak of likes to rest once in a while. Lol.
@sadiamushtaq2953 true,but he hasn't taken a day off since 1948.
Recite Surah Al Hashr 8 time please
what happened to my comment? is youtube deleting it?
MAY ALLAH DO THIS
HAVE MERCY ON US😭😭😭😭
I am so very grateful for this teachers' thoughtful comments, which seem to strive to help people make up their own minds without the sweeping generalizations and conclusions many make. Allah who is Most Merciful and Most Gracious guides us to seekout those informed individuals when we have questions about His Word. For myself, this is the sort of insights I need, and pray fervently that Allah will grant you all that you need to continue this work. Alhamduilah.
Alhamdulillah
I'm Christian and I think because this contradicts our Bible, U guys need to understand why u must choose to respect the Abrahamic faiths rather than fight.Palistinians had the chance to share the land but chose war n killed their own children..
Simple terms. GOD'S Rules order are clear👉🏽The sin & the good.Without balance gods mission is meaningless. God cannot favour the children of Isreal without conditioning them to do good justice.
@@HshdzsskidiI'm afraid you're extremely misinformed. Jews, Muslims and Christians lived in relative peace for hundreds of years in Palestine before zionist tried to create an ethno-supremacist apartheid state for Jews only by ethnically cleansing the Christian and Muslim populations living there. Palestinians had in fact welcome Jewish refugees from Europe after WW2 and just imagine they allowed them to live in their homes and son they were forced from their own homes by the refugees they had helped. Palestinians are fighting for freedom. This has nothing to do with religion and everything to do with Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian territories and almost 70 years of Israeli state terrorism against helpless civilians.
@@Hshdzsskidi The indigenous Palestinian Muslims, Christians and Jews never had a problem sharing the land. They even welcomed waves of European Jewish immigrations, known as aliyas, starting in mid 1800's without any problems. It was not until they became aware of these recent immigrants' plans to occupy the most fertile parts of the land and create their own country on them by ethnically cleansing the indigenous non-Jewish population that conflict started.
Though they themselves had been victims of bigotry in their original homelands, the European zyonists brought with them the kind of racism, ethnocentrism and exclusivism that was not previously known to indigenous Palestinians. That is why Palestinian Rabbis also opposed the creation of Israel and many ultra Orthodox rabbis still do to this day.
In the Bible it states Matthew 24 they asked Jesus what will be the sign of the end, the first thing he said was don't trust anybody and the second thing he said was not one stone will stand upon another, everyone will be thrown down, and he was standing at the Mount of Olives. What does that mean to you? Does the Quran have a Matthew 24? It will be interesting to live through the end time to see who's right.
When you read these verses along with the traditions of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) talking about the end of times and the establishment of the Islamic government, whose capital will be Jerusalem, surely, for that to happen, the current status quo would have to cease to exist.
Is Dr. Safiyyah Ally a relative of Dr. Shabir Ally?
Yes his daughter I heard.
daughter. if you click on the channel bio it tells you. 😊
Yeh their COUSINS SHAGGED🤪🖕👊🏿
His Daughter
God is warning and letting the world know the end result of the Israelis. God knows best. All visibility to God. Good reasoning. All humans have the right to live in good faith.May God bless you!!❤✌🏽👍🎈🎈
Huh we also have prophecies and this contradicts our beliefs so wouldn't it be best for Palestinians to choose to respect that for the sake of their kids lives??
@@Hshdzsskidi What do your prophesies and beliefs say?
Persecutions Are Coming :
“Now brother will deliver up brother to death, and a father his child;
and children will rise up against parents and cause them to be put to death.
And you will be hated by all for My name’s sake.
But he who endures to the end will be saved.
When they persecute you in this city, flee to another.
For assuredly, I say to you,
you will not have gone through the cities of Israel before the Son of Man comes.
(Matthew 10 : 21 - 23)
The Great Tribulation :
“Therefore when you see the ‘abomination of desolation,’ spoken of by Daniel the prophet,
standing in the holy place”(whoever reads, let him understand),
“then let those who are in
JUDEA (Palestine, West Bank!)
flee to the mountains.
Let him who is on the housetop not go down to take anything out of his house.
And let him who is in the field not go back to get his clothes.
But woe to those who are pregnant and to those who are nursing babies in those days!
And pray that your flight may not be in winter or on the Sabbath.
For then there will be great tribulation,
such as has not been since the beginning of the world until this time, no, nor ever shall be.
And unless those days were shortened,
no flesh would be saved; but for the elect’s sake those days will be shortened.
(Matthew 24:15 - 22)
The Saints Reign with Christ 1,000 Years :
And I saw thrones, and they sat on them, and judgment was committed to them.
Then I saw the souls of those who had been
"BEHEADED" (sound familiar??)
for their witness to Jesus and for the word of God,
who had not worshiped the beast or his image,
and had not received his mark on their foreheads or on their hands.
And they lived and reigned with Christ for a thousand years.
(Revelation 20:4)
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "The Hour will not be established until the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends amongst you as a just ruler, he will break the cross, kill the pigs, and abolish the Jizya tax. Money will be in abundance so that nobody will accept it (as charitable gifts).
Sahih al-Bukhari 2476
Human reasoning again ....God has all the right to take away the lives of those who're not pleasing to Him like He did in Biblical times when sent Israel to destroy unwanted people like for example the amalekites, the jebusites and so on...can you call that genocide? God is a giver of life and take it back if we are not pleasing to Him...
How is prophecy made? Who and what kind of people can actually declare words of prophecy? Prophecy is made by prophets, but who are prophets? Where and how do they get that power? Can anyone just become a prophet by themselves or does someone pronounce anyone a prophet?
With all the respect in the world, and with the knowledge that you are an expert in this field, please can you explain with greater clarity- I could not make head or tail of what you were saying in many places. It was very confusing!
Thanks for kind information
Its fact we waiting this time
Not waiting every muslim has to be Ready for as per what Allah wants from muslim.
Chosen people means that God has chosen Israelites to give them Torah ( تورات ) to be the custodian of Torah, to guid then to salvation with a condition that they must obey the laws of God and stay clear of corruptions and arrogance. This “ Chosen People” must not be interpreted as that the mighty God prefer Jews over other people and or Jewish religions is superior over other religions like Christianity and Islam. After all, the Christ the messiah was born in a Jewish family and brought upon a new religion of Christianity and ask all Jews to follow him as he said he is the messiah God promised to Jews in Torah to be followed by all Jews.
And Jesus PBUH was KILLED by JEWS 👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽
The only problem is Jesus did not tell the people to create a religion after him Christianity should not exist. The Torah and the Ingeel Quran are the only holy books that say worship ONE God your creator.
@@trixie7265 who is created your religion ?
@@trixie7265Islam is a religion of the late Muhammad 😅which he brought 500yrs later after Jesus Christ
Wrong.
Chosen ABOVE ALL PEOPLE.
Is it bending time space? That would be good.
Dr. Israr Ahmad says that there will be a formation of Greater Israel, which includes northern part of Saudi Arabia and most of the ME countries.
Well spoken and well said
Well presented and I believe correct analysis. Don’t hate!!!
HATE is HARD WIRED into KORANIMAL FILTH DNA🤮🖕👊🏿
The year 2025 was shown to me in a premonition back in 1998 which was connected to other events that showed would unfold in 1999 .
What Bible says about this?
Romans 11:25-27
I do not want you to be ignorant of this mystery, brothers and sisters, so that you may not be conceited: Israel has experienced a hardening in part until the full number of the Gentiles has come in, and in this way all Israel will be saved. As it is written: “The deliverer will come from Zion; he will turn godlessness away from Jacob.And this is my covenant with them when I take away their sins.”
That's d truth!
For now Allah is with israel
@@gooyeeramdanraj9353rubbish !
Jesus is lord !
Paul wrote the epistle of Romans. With help from a greek scribe Tertius of Iconium. Paul himself was a Roman citizen & his first language was Greek. Jesus never said that he is God. Romans & Greeks were still believed in many gods Zues and Hercules ( son of Zues) and so on... However, Right at the same time that Christians were calling Jesus "God" is exactly when Romans started calling their emperors "God." So these Christians were not doing this in a vacuum; they were actually doing it in a context. I don't think this could be an accident that this is a point at which the emperors are being called "God." So by calling Jesus "God," in fact, it was a competition between your God, the emperor, and our God, Jesus.
@@SHAZIASADLER I'm afraid you are mistaken. Jesus called himself "I Am," which is the title that God gave to Moses on the Holy Mountain. He most certainly said that he was God, and eternal, claiming that he was here before Abraham was. Paul did not create the idea that Jesus was God. He merely submitted to the truth.
Even Isaiah said the child born to the virgin would be "eternal God." (Isaiah 7:13-9-7). Even Muslims believe that Jesus was born of a virgin. But the prophecy is clear that the child born would be "everlasting father, mighty God." Jesus is the Lord Most Hight. He was the angel in the wilderness, and the Lord who created the earth. He was in the beginning with God, and was God. Who is this Muhammed? What sign did he perform to prove himself a prophet?
Yes .I have solid ground .
If we take it was declared in Moses time... Then how can the first occasion is in past tense... Because, that happened after Moses not before.
Dr Shabbir is one of my favorite scholars.
Very wise answer
Thank you very much
Please correct me if I am wrong.
Isn't that the Children of Israel refered to bani israel.
The Bani Israel are called by this name because Israel was another name for the Prophet Yaqub (alaihis salam) (Jacob), and from his twelve children came the twelve tribes that constituted Banu Israel.
Bani Israel in Quran is ummah of Moses. Simple.
Yes, according to Islam, they were a Jewish community or Children of Israel. According to the Bible, Jacob was renamed Israel. He had twelve children who became the twelve tribes of Israel. They multiplied by heaps and bounds during the enslavement in Egypt, so by the time they came out of Egypt, and after 40 years in the wilderness, there were about 30,000 to 2 million of them. 40,000 were armed for battle. They had many enemies. So you are right to say Prophet Yaqub goes by the name Jacob and his children were the 12 tribes of Israel.
Hope So!
Qur'an is not only for Israel but for for whole humanity. This verse can be true for any society which does wrong twice for its people, it can be true for India too.
Where does Quran say it is for Israel? It is Arabic book written for Arabs. It says that Torah is for Israel.
No it specifically mentions Bani Israel. Not just any nation that wrongs twice..
@@peterhwang352
The dude is taking about the verse not the book. In any case the Qur'an was not 'written' for the arabs. It was send down for the whole of humanity
It says Bani Israel.
In your dreams repent and turn to JESUS false books watch Christian Prince
Numbers 24:9
Good News Translation
9 The nation is like a mighty lion;
When it is sleeping, no one dares wake it.
Whoever blesses Israel will be blessed,
And whoever curses Israel will be cursed.”
God came to earth through the womb of Mary descendant of King David.
His sole purpose was to reconcile rebellious mank😮ind away from rebellion and back to
Don't lie.... blind follower
God don't need to be born trough a woman....God was there from the beginning And will never DIE...Please use your logic...read the Quran and you will get all your answers in THEIR
The Bible says that it will be divided and scattered.
Where does it say ?
Provide reference ?
I will read about that ?
Is that in Old Or New Testament ?
And BTW Eid Mubarak 💖
@ 10 April 2024
# 11:23 AM
This is bulshit statement...prove it or u make your imagination to answer everything in religion??? Just imaging like other schoolars???
Which chapter and verse of the Bible?
You forgot one important point from the verses:
They will be raised to "great arrogance/might"
Tell us please when were they given such great might as they have now since the revelation of the Quran.
Lol do they not run the world??
@@yassar855I think he wonders if today's power of israelis is the first or the second one
PLEASE PRAY FOR ALL CHRISTIAN! PALESTINIAN PEOPLE VERY SOON CONVERTED TO CHRISTIANITY😢😢😢😢❤❤❤❤
Alhamdulillahi, there is no doubt in the Qran msgs. Thanks.
There is a land who belong to the Jewish people( ISRAEL ). But there is also a land who belong to the Arab people (PALESTINE). The States solution is possible .
No there isn't. It's one state called Palestine where Muslims, Christians and Jews live together in peace. There is no place for a racist Israel state where Jews are first class citizens and the rest have less rights than the Jews' pets.
You can't go by that logic. Israel only occupies 1/36th of the original land that God promised them. So that means Palestine would have to be relocated to Saudi Arabia, or as far as Yemen.
@@seanc2788 What are you saying ? According the Bible the West bank belong to the Jewish people . But the North belong to the Palestinian people .
@@abdillahihollandis7481 The land no longer belongs to the Jews because they broke their covenant with God, they rejected and killed prophets. God put the Jews in exile for breaking their covenant and they are not supposed to enter the land. Even according to the Torah the Jews can not enter the land without God’s permission or when the Messiah returns. So you guys have once again disobeyed God and entered the land without God’s permission. You took the land by shedding blood and it is a sin for the Jews.
@@seanc2788 God promised them the land but the Jews broke their covenant and committed many sins. The land no longer belongs to the Jews because they broke their covenant with God, they rejected and killed prophets. God put the Jews in exile for breaking their covenant and they are not supposed to enter the land. Even according to the Torah the Jews can not enter the land without God’s permission or when the Messiah returns. So you guys have once again disobeyed God and entered the land without God’s permission. You took the land by shedding blood and it is a sin for the Jews.
The Israelites, Chosen as an example to Every Nation throughout the Ages: What is TO BE (to receive Divine Bliss) and What is NOT TO BE (to receive Divine Wrath) irrespective of religious dispositions; be a Christian, or, a Muslim, or, a Jew, or, a Hindu (Sanatan Dharma), or, a Buddhist etc. There is NO CHOSEN PEOPLE!
I will tell you armegoden is here. The quran have mention the big smoke that will cover the sky [nukes] it's on place.
Second 👉🏽isreal is on last stage of what is mention here.
Third: 👉🏽the highest Jews priest said Natanyau is going to be the last prime minister for isreal?
Fourth :Natanyau have refused peace resolution. What does that mean the war will spread. And don't think big powers will win? The cold shot wars are here & the end of unipolarism has begun?
Why is all this happening? Bekos justice is hijacked & bekos of that the world is disoriented losing both its sense & direction😭with lost of justice 🇦🇪The problems of this world will be more & more & be more faster than before & more worst than before. God knows everything but I call it karma. A great karma will haunt us if we drop justice 🤲🏿God bless south Africa & free 🇦🇪.
Chosen for hell. I agree
Izabrani sa davolima .
The Time will tell.
Ma Shaa ALLAH
JAZAKALLAH KHAYR for sharing ❤❤❤ALHAMDULILLAH ❤❤❤
One of the best videos I have ever heard. Much love.MashaAllah.❤
Please explain me what was the name of God before Islam was found. By what name did. Abraham, Issac and Moses Called God. Becouse there was no arrabic language at all. Please. Thak you 🙏
Love the discussion! Thank you!
Quran Also says: If You Repeat the Crime, We ( God- Royal We) Will repeat the punishment." *Surah Al-Isra 17:8 -Glorious Qu'ran ( Reminder)
Quran 2:47 Allah favour the people of Israel.
@@co_co_mit doesn't mean if they were favored in one time with guidance ; they will not be punished if they disobey their messengers and corrupt the land.
Lol Royal we? So Allah is like lonely he has to associate for himself the titles of the Royalty? Also when the Royalty uses "we" it's because it's including the Queen or if the Queen is speaking then the King, the princes and the nobility so the term Royal we is just a joke to try to avoid the disaster of Allah referring to himself as "we".
@@projustice503 yes because by "we" they mean the office of the Royalty which includes their nobles and ministers.
This was a very vital discussion. I have to agree with Dr. Shabir Ally. A lot of the stuff that is prophesied in the holy book whether it's Bible or Quran it was mentioned in those Century of the generations that when you read what has taken place as the time went on a lot of those things did get fulfilled. People sometimes forget that biblical Israel it's not the same thing as Zionist state political movement Israelis. Now that does not mean that consequences cannot take place because of leaders of nation on taking certain actions that can lead to trouble for there country. I came out of Christian Zionist Doctrine. I think Zionism is being exposed even with pre-millennialism Dogma. Thank for your input Dr, shabir Ally peace to you
Well said brother
Yeah it's being exposed alright. Right up to the point that Jesus is seen coming through the clouds.
I agree. Present day Ashkenazi Jews are not even the descendants of ancient Israelites
They aren't the children of israel.
The children are SCATTERED and have been for a long time..