The Atheist Experience 556 with Matt Dillahunty and Tracie Harris

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 35

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +9

    So the guy at 50:22 is frustrated that we don't know why the Universe exists, yet he's perfectly willing to plug in "God" which ANSWERS NOTHING, which you think would leave him even more frustrated. What knowledge, exactly, did he gain about the question by just saying "God?" Did plugging "God" into the question get him any actual answers?

  • @steveyuhas9278
    @steveyuhas9278 3 года назад +4

    Tracie's Batman Begins parallel to the story of Sodom and Gomorrah was freakin awesome.

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +12

    First call about 30:10

  • @paul.c.gregory
    @paul.c.gregory Год назад

    I know it’s important to get to the callers but I’d have loved to hear the rest of Tracie’s analysis, had me enthralled.

  • @tedgrant2
    @tedgrant2 6 лет назад +22

    We all know that Jesus didn't have a human father.
    So he was only half human. He didn't have any male chromosomes.
    Therefore the wasn't male, because the father's Y chromosome was absent.
    Therefore Jesus was a woman.

    • @Multi1628
      @Multi1628 5 лет назад +8

      Hilarious, and another observation to make ill-informed theist heads explode...

    • @blackhat4206
      @blackhat4206 3 года назад +5

      @@Multi1628 Although, then one would likely have to explain genetics to the theist as well.

    • @steveyuhas9278
      @steveyuhas9278 3 года назад +2

      @@blackhat4206 Having to explain genetics AND trans people at the SAME TIME to a theist??? Psshhhh nawwww

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +9

    Well an intelligent species like ours, we just HAD to have a creator.... which is funny because we didn't start out very intelligent, cave men for a long time, then skip ahead, dark ages, then skip ahead industrial revolution... why didn't we start out with computers, space shuttles and skyscrapers?

  • @Multi1628
    @Multi1628 5 лет назад +12

    ~ The caller was loud and equally obnoxious. How does a person successfully say nothing and sound so awful in doing so - thank you, Tracie and Matt, for even making sense of the loud, awful AND obnoxious callers. Cheers, DAVEDJ ~

    • @viviondioline
      @viviondioline 4 года назад +1

      Lol you put a signature on a comment
      Yours Truly,
      Bernard

    • @steveyuhas9278
      @steveyuhas9278 3 года назад

      I love it when people do that. It's charming.
      Love,
      Steve

  • @jeff6660
    @jeff6660 3 года назад +1

    Substituting a WHO for a WHAT is just substituting one mystery for another mystery.

    • @NibbleIT
      @NibbleIT 2 года назад +2

      Same mystery, just asking the question correctly without assuming a who.

  • @letmenot
    @letmenot 2 года назад +1

    9 million fucking ads....

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +2

    Tracie, "It's magic." Love it.

  • @HighStakesDanny
    @HighStakesDanny 6 лет назад +3

    2019

  • @Bella-vt7ol
    @Bella-vt7ol Год назад

    Good grief the first caller has the mental capacity of a 4 yr old…

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +2

    Matt you don't have a 90-minute call in show if it takes 30 minutes before you even take a call.

    • @rolandkushm.d.710
      @rolandkushm.d.710 5 лет назад +3

      They probably stall the first call until the lines fill, so they can go from call to call without having huge gaps in the show.

    • @eleSDSU
      @eleSDSU 4 года назад +3

      The show lasts 90 minutes and it's a call in show, therefore a 90 minute call in show. A 30 minute game show does not contain 30 minutes of "game"...

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад

    Weird, I used to think that prior to the Big Bang or when it occurred there was no matter or energy and that all energy and matter came into existence as a point which then expanded. But lately I hear people saying that the point existed before the expansion began.

  • @MicrophoneHell-ec3bm
    @MicrophoneHell-ec3bm 6 лет назад +1

    Abraham was not a Jew. Judaism came long after Abraham. The first Jew was Judah son of Jacob (Israel). Abraham's great grandson. Also, Moses wasn't a Jew either.

    • @trishayamada807
      @trishayamada807 5 лет назад +1

      Microphone Hell it’s hard to be Jewish, Luke Moses, if you never existed anyway. LoL

    • @eleSDSU
      @eleSDSU 4 года назад

      Not really, Moses (fictional or not) was Jewish. Abraham I'd have to think about it, it's arguable. Mythology is awesome, so awesome that some take it waaaaay too seriously, specially the latest fanfic.

    • @Theproclaimed
      @Theproclaimed 2 месяца назад

      None of those people existed in the first place

  • @RonaldStepp
    @RonaldStepp 6 лет назад +1

    So saying matter and energy can't be destroyed and they might be eternal. Okay, Devils advocate hat on, if you can't say God existed eternally without answering "well, what made God," why don't you also have to answer, "well, what created matter and energy?"

    • @anthonygrimaldi8768
      @anthonygrimaldi8768 5 лет назад +2

      I believe the answer to your question is that we are looking for the answers of wether or not matter always exsisted or not and religion is simply forbidden to question men who wrote things thousans of years ago claiming god told/inspired them to write what is in the scriptures. We have evidence for the big bang right back to just after the expansion began. Religion has only the words men wrote thousands of years ago

    • @richardgates7479
      @richardgates7479 4 года назад +1

      No, you don't need an answer because the question isn't about "what". The theist answer is about the "what and why", and as was pointed out that isn't a question because it is circular.

  • @secretskeleton7744
    @secretskeleton7744 6 лет назад

    ?

  • @angeloiannitelli6589
    @angeloiannitelli6589 Год назад

    It's ridiculously stupid when a "long time listner" has to be told to turn down their TV.

  • @raulmartinez9458
    @raulmartinez9458 5 лет назад

    Why Tracie looks so hot wearing that color