The Atheist Experience 540 with Matt Dillahunty and Tracie Harris

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 12

  • @n.presley917
    @n.presley917 3 года назад

    Yasek(sp) - 31:03 - addressing the belief/idea that non-Christians are slated for Hell/torture/etc. and the apparent emotional stance of those who state said view.
    David - 1:15:08 - misunderstood Tracie's presentation and incoherently disagrees over the "reasonability" of theological speculation.

  • @angeloiannitelli6589
    @angeloiannitelli6589 2 года назад

    I really hope David took an English comprehension course or 50 since 2008.

  • @Thormp1
    @Thormp1 5 лет назад +2

    Believer: Your Relationship with god is simply a profound and dynamic relationship with the self, with your ego. This is why god can seem so very real to you. In a sense he is real. He is you. This is why god's opinions are so very often your opinions. This is why two believers of the same religion can both claim to agree with god's opinion but not with each others. When you pray and god gives you answers you are the source of those intuitions. You are simply having a conversation with yourself and don't even realize it. This is why god can always assuage any doubts of the believer. You see, "God" knows exactly how you think because he is you. He knows your tastes, your biases and all the gaps in your logic. Therefore it follows that "he" knows what arguments you will find compelling and what mental gymnastics you are capable of to ignore any arguments to the contrary. Ironically I probably can't convince you of anything I stated above because of the very fact that it is in fact true. You are "god".
    The next time you hear someone preaching or waxing poetic about god, Jesus, Mohamed or Joseph Smith, change all the names and pronouns you hear them say, in your mind, so that they refer to the person speaking and trust me you will get a whole new perspective on life.
    This is why believers have such a strong emotional reaction whenever they encounter a non-believer. They simply misperceive the non-believers rational skepticism about the supernatural and occult as an assault on their "god" which is to say their own personal identity.
    There are a vast multitude of religions and superstitious beliefs in the world that espouse many mutually contradicting doctrines. Therefore they cannot all be true. but they can certainly all be false. Even if one were actually proven to be true it would still follow that human beings have a rather remarkable propensity for making up entire religions from whole cloth. I think that all religions and other supernatural beliefs are cultural phenomena of purely human making. Much of this impulse in human culture is driven by peoples existential angst, their innate and instinctive fear of death. Their own death and the death of the people they love. It can seem easier to deal with death by convincing ourselves that it is not real. "My loved one is not dead they are in the afterlife", we tell ourselves. And "Of course I will never die! that's absurd!". You all need to grow up. Embrace the suck! And make the most of the time you actually do have.
    You are mortal. Death is real...... Get over it.
    I sincerely and earnestly do not believe that gods exist. But you have each other. Perhaps that alone could bring meaning to your lives.
    However if you insist on believing in supernatural claims at a minimum please do us all a big favor and don't give your hard earned money to religion pimps and hucksters.

  • @n.presley917
    @n.presley917 3 года назад +1

    great sections between callers, clearly pointing out the nasty rhetoric and illogic of statements by then-Gov. Rick Perry and common folk-theology tropes like the unknowability/incomprehensible nature of a deity [whose attributes one then proceeds to assert as though they are known/knowable].

  • @davedukes136
    @davedukes136 5 лет назад +2

    I find it funny
    The devout seriousness
    Of utter nonsense
    Haiku Dave

  • @jameslarimer9211
    @jameslarimer9211 5 лет назад +1

    29:14 C'mon, Matt. Rick Perry doesn't know what a fractal is.

  • @Imatallguy1
    @Imatallguy1 5 лет назад +1

    Matt assigned motivation here. And then he realized it. And learned. What a champ.