How to Read a Broken Roman Statue | The Head of Nero | Curator's Corner S6 Ep7
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 авг 2021
- It’s A.D. 61, Emperor Nero rules over the Roman Empire. In the east of the province of Britannia, the head of a bronze statue ends up in a muddy river. Who put it there and why? How do we solve the mystery of this Roman head in the river?
Curator Thorsten Opper tells us what clues to look out for when faced with a Roman portrait and explains how to envision the whole object from studying only a part. Put yourself in the shoes of a citizen of Roman Britannia, and explore how they might have viewed such a statue of the emperor, Nero.
This bronze head of emperor Nero is currently on display in the exhibition Nero: The man behind the myth at the British Museum, and you can book tickets to see it in the flesh here: bit.ly/2Xf39U9
Want to get a Roman-tic gift for the emperor/empress in your life? Maybe just read up a bit more on Nero; the man, the myth? Our shop is stocked full of Nero inspired books, miniature gladiators and replica jewellery and frescoes. Every purchase helps support the British Museum, and to keep making videos like this for all of you. Find out more here: bit.ly/3ARtBlc
Nero was a seriously seriously messed up dude. Cant imagine buying anything that could be seen as supporting such a monstrous man.
"Order your Nero Brand Human-Candle making kit now! Defenseless Christians not included!"
@@knightforlorn6731 If we consider all massive slaughters done by Christians in the name of their faith, Nero should be a saint. I can't imagine anyone who really knows history supporting Christianity.
It seems less idealised than later images. It’s more realistic in style.
Great video. Meat and Potatoes for me.
Part of my humble library.
Roman and Greek History, Etc.
If you're into “Roman” stuff Michael Curtis Ford's “Gods and Legions is the book to read. If you're into history I suggest you get Ammianus Marcellinus' History. The ass kicker here is that Marcellinus actually went to battle with Emperor Julian. The Loeb Classic is almost an adventure novel all by itself.
As far as Gladiators go a couple of “definitive” books are The Way of the Gladiator by Daniel P. Mannix and Spartacus by Howard Fast. Here are books from my library. Ass kickers every one.
Ammianus Marcellinus History Loeb Classical Library
The Battle for Gaul by Julius Caesar Illustrated edition by Anne & Peter Wiseman.
Caesar: The Civil War by Jane F. Gardner
Suetonius: The Twelve Caesars by Robert Graves
The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire by Edward Gibbon
The Way of the Gladiator by Daniel P. Mannix
Spartacus by Howard Fast
Julian by Gore Vidal
Gods and Legions by Michael Curtis Ford
The Ten Thousand by Michael Curtis Ford
The Last King by Michael Curtis Ford
Marius had long ago showed us that the legionary has a weapon that is the bane of the civilized world, one more formidable than the dual-edged Roman short sword, more effective than the bronze-headed javelin, of greater defensive strength than the concave bronze-sheathed shields. It is a weapon in which the legionary is trained from his first day of induction and which he uses daily, in peacetime or in war, on the march or hunkered in camp under siege from flaming missiles. And upon their arrival at The miscyra, every able-bodied Roman immediately whipped out this most fearsome of all weapons:
The Legionary's shovel.
Before even breaking to rest or scouting for supplies, the Roman troops had unpacked their shovels and commenced digging, and the dirt flew, and the dust rose. In the space of an afternoon, a Roman camp for thirty thousand men had been constructed just beyond range of our catapults. Before dark it had been ringed on all sides with a trench twelve feet deep and three feet across, the dirt thrown up into an embankment ten feet high inside the ring. Topped with a thick palisade of sharpened stakes. Inside, four sturdy walls were constructed of felled trees, guarded by squat log towers twenty feet high, stationed every fifty feet and surmounted by bolt-hurling field catapults. Inside, a space of a full two hundred feet was left between the walls and the tent line, a distance calculated to prevent our missiles and burning arrows from reaching the tents. This space was occupied by prisoners, cattle, plunder and supplies. Withing a few hours, the Romans had constructed a stronghold that would be the envy of a lifetime's work of many civilizations poorer then theirs. A fortress impregnable.
Yet this was not a permanent stronghold they had built. This was the Roman's usual daily campsite, Every day of a legionary's working life he would dig such a trench, construct such an embankment, hew trees, and build such palisade. All to be torched at sunrise, when the legions marched off to their next encampment. Javelins, when thrown, may miss their mark entirely. Shields may cave upon impact with a Scythian battle-ax; and a sword, though reliable at close quarters, still dulled, broke upon ribs. Or shivered if struck upon armor. But the shovel...the shovel was the legionary's best friend, his most faithful protector, the one weapon that allowed him to sleep soundly at night, behind his magnificent trenches and embankments. The shovel could stop a cavalry charge cold, stymie hordes of barbarians. Rome conquered not with its brutal leaders, not with the strength of its soldiers, not with the ingeniousness of its weapons...but with the most rustic, pigheaded, inglorious, gods-bedamned tool of them all...the shovel.
Michael Curtis Ford “The Last King
Read one of the best books you'll ever read; Gods and Legions”
The Sword of Attila by Michael Curtis Ford
The Fall of Rome by Michael Curtis Ford
Gates of Fire by Steven Pressfield
Tides of War by Steven Pressfield
The Virtues of War by Steven Pressfield
Thucydides: History of the Peloponesian War.
Last of the Amazons by Steven Pressfield
Alexander the Great by Paul Cartledge
The Spartans by Paul Cartledge
Eagle in the Snow by Wallace Breem
The Eagle and the Raven by Pauline Gedge
The Last Legionary: Life as a Roman Soldier in Britain AD 400 by Paul Elliott
Gladiator: The Roman Fighter's (Unofficial) Manual by Philip Matyzak
Legionary: the Roman Soldier's Manual by Philip Matyszak
On Roman Military Matters (De Re Militari) by Flavius Vegetius Renatus
More of this presenter! He is very knowledgeable, sharing a good insight of the object's background and enjoyable to listening to. That 15 minutes just totally flown away.
Absolutely,i wish i had a teacher like him i would never had slept in the lectures.
Agreed!
@gergely sz - Would you expect the British Museum to hire curators who weren’t incredibly knowledgeable??
@@Lityerses You slept in lectures bc you had no intellectual curiosity, which isn’t the fault of your teachers. I read so many comments by people who don’t take responsibility for their own learning, and who somehow think that education should be a floor show….then, if they aren’t entertained enough, they feel they’ve been wronged. Honestly, we’ve all had to endure subjects and teachers we didn’t much like, but that isn’t an excuse for not learning.
@@voraciousreader3341 I see your point and you are right but not on my case because i did not sleep on all the lectures,i slept on the ones that i felt useless.It is not because i have no intellectual curiosty if it was the case i wouldn't spent hours online in search of lectures,i have studied Roman,Egyptian an Turkish history,i learned english myself and still trying to learn other languages so even though you are right on some points but not only me,many people are unlucky when it comes to the teachers you got to take this into account aswell.
Seen from below, the head gives a very different, and much more majestic, impression from how it looks when viewed at eye level. Obviously, the proportions were calculated to give the best impression when people stood beneath the pedestal and looked up at the statue.
Perspectives can be tricky.
Thinking about the "view from below," we usually see other adults more or less straight on, so that's how we are used to judging the proportions of a face. A statue on a plinth forces us into the position of a young child who has to look upwards to adults.
Narrowing the chin reduces the perspective effect so that the face seen from below looks more like the face seen head-on. Did Roman sculptors employ subtle perspective effects like that? Probably, because we think Greek and Roman masons or architects did when they built their temples with the columns tapering or leaning slightly.
@JONATHAN SUTCLIFFE That salad needs some mayonnaise.
@@faithlesshound5621 The precision of the temples proves the architects play on perspective. Nero was a funny looking imp in his earlier sculptings. The Romans liked their realism to the point of including warts and big ears on some sculptures but Octavian's likenesses always seemed too perfect.
@@brianpeck4035 Perhaps Nero lacked Cromwell's self-confidence, when he asked to be painted "warts and all." Octavian had to be perfect as Augustus, even before he became a god, whereas Alexander could have his deaf ear hinted at in his sculptures.
What strikes me in the progression through different portrait styles is how you could see how Nero grew from a boy into a chunky man. Remarkable.
He presumably took some pride in that too. Didn't object to being shown as very rotund
@@tpower1912 My understanding (that could maybe be a complete misunderstanding) is that in some societies it was a sign that one was healthy and wealthy enough to afford enough food to be overweight.
Fat. The word everyone is looking for is "fat."
@@r0bw00d Mmmm...I believe you are quite right. He was a big boy at the end there - his neck was incredibly wide in comparison to his head, and I'm sure that can't have been good for his health. I suspect Nero was a snorer.
Yeah, he chunked up pretty quick. Those plovers eggs or whatever he lived on must have been rich.
The Meroe head of Emperor Augustus is very fascinating. It shows how far Rome's influences went, that the most well preserved head was found as far away as Sudan.
I find it more interesting that very likely both statues had a similar fate. The head of Augustus did not ended up in Meroe because of the influence of the Romans, it was quite the opposite. The queen of Kush started an invasion of Roman Egypt where this head then was looted. Back in their capital Meroe they buried the head beneath the staircase of a temple.
From that lower angle it is actually a pretty impressive face, full of character almost regal.
Well done!
This was a very interesting talk, and I'd also like to compliment this curator (?) for the great collection of books behind him.
🤣
Let's have more, of Curator Thursten Opper or his colleagues! It brings me back to the days of quiet, gripping, authoritative discussions, and allies them with my interest in historical bronzes. Thank you British Museum, and thank you Curator Thursten Opper.
This is fascinating and well explained- thanks so much
I've always thought this piece of art, beautiful as it is, reminds me of Alfred E Neuman.
QUID? ME FATIGO?
hahahaha Bush jr did as well
Great presentation and curator. I learnt so much in 15 minutes. More like this, please!
Loved I Clavdivs series from the 70's
Super interesting. Please make more like this.
~ 5 min in: the view from below. Unsurprisingly, the Romans had figured out perspective (or nicked it from the Greeks) and arranged their statues so they looked correct from below. Just as Michaelangelo did with his David.
I (and, I suspect many of us non-specialists) often forget that the ancient peoples were just as clever as us: they just didn't have the technology or (probably more important) the thousands of years of previous thinking recorded or remembered but, in any case, learned from.
I’m not Greek, nor Italian, and impartial to the subject. But there is more, as in older, history, than “the Romans”. Pheidias (Phidias, ~465BC .. ~425BC) competed with his pupil-gone-independent Alkamenes when Athens-city asked both to come up with their respective versions of a statue portraying goddess Athena. It had to be placed on a tall column. At ground level, Alkamenes’s statue looked beautifully perfect and Pheidias’s version had all sorts of deformations. Placed on a column, though, Pheidias’s version won and this story got passed on. Many clever inventions are older than we think and a higher form of intelligence may have been required even to survive in that age, than is today with all modern luxuries. When we read about Plato’s “Cave” metaphor, that was his way of saying the masses lacked deep knowledge and consciousness, then we could say that modernity has replaced the cave by a TV or computer display. Yes, everything flows but there is little change.
@@jpdj2715 As I said, the Romans may have nicked it from the Greeks. And they seem to have been very aware of earlier science and technology: Babylonian maths, for example. Yes, as you said, lots of things appear to go back much further than we at first think.
Interesting. Amazing how this curator can help put historical items in context. I'll have to watch this again--this presentation is pretty dense with information, and possible interpretations.
This video just flew by. An excellent presentation that makes you want to dig deeper, hear more and visit the Museum.
A really fascinating and informative presentation by an excellent presenter! Thank you very much indeed! I do hope we see more featuring him in future.
Really enjoyed this! Lots of info and I LOVED the selfie!!!
Wow !
Very interesting to actually see real evidence of Boudiccas revolt against Roman rule, after just hearing about it for years. Its fascinating to look at Nero's head and see the actual marks a blows of the Iceni axes. A real and tangible link to ancient Britons.
BM content just gets better and better, gripping voice that draws you in and fantastic work by the video editor!
I think I recall this being on display at Colchester Castle Museum in the 1980’s as a statue of Claudius destroyed during the revolt of 61AD
Amazing curator. I appreciate this upload. Many thanks for your time sharing your knowledge and insights.
Thank you so very much! Enjoyed the presentation immensely.
I really enjoyed this presentation by Mr Opper. Love the pointing out of the clever use of perspective. Hope we get more #curatorscorner from him.
That Statue of Boudicca and her daughters is the most beautiful to me!
This came to me as a suggested video. I am so pleased it came my way, because it all happened on my doorstep. The River Alde where it wasfound is only a few miles away. Colchester is about seven miles away and London about Seventy miles. I was brought up on the Iceni and Boudica. I will be subscribing to "curator's corner". I still love learing about history, even though it was 45 years since I left college. Thanks for this great video.
These videos are really precious ! It’s rare having the possibility to listen to such experts with so detailed explanation. Thanks !
Especially for those of us who will never go to the British museum. Thanks
Curators' Corner is always interesting.
Fabulous artifacts and scholarship!
Great lecture. I wish I had this knowledge few years back when I was visiting the British Museum.
Wonderfully interesting and informative - thank you ~
Excellent summary. Thank you.
in this video you can see why the coins became heavier and heavier as Nero got older.
this was awesome. loved it and this speaker :)
Curators Corner is the best piece of entertainment in the last 10 years...
Fascinating and very well presented--many thanks.
Excellent and so informative. Great video.
Thus has parallels with the statue of Edward Colston in Bristol. Perhaps throwing statues of your enemy into water is a more ancient protest than we think.
This is an outstanding presentation. Thank you, Thorsten.
Excellent presentation! Very informative. Thank you 👏
These are really good, great presenter.
Very much enjoyed this, thank you!
A really interesting talk... thank you !!
Fantastic presentation! Thank you so much for letting this incredibly erudite man share his vast knowledge with us.
His talk is well-detailed and engaging, and I was thinking of how many of us here appreciate this opportunity to learn more about ancient sculpture.
Love the British Museum. Thank you for letting knowledge spread around the world ❤
Fascinating - the curator really knows how to makes things interesting. I was surprised at the difference in perspectives - from below the head did have a completely different feel - again that's fascinating.
Fascinating from both an artistic and a historical perspective - thank you.
Thank you very much Mr. Opper. Very interesting.
His thrill is contagious. I do enjoy these explanations of those things I've always been happy to see on their own; they become alive in the telling. Thank you for yet another look at ancient lives.
I thank my lucky stars I have found this wonderful channel. A treasure trove of delights.
Loved this thoroughly. This presenter knows his stuff!
I bet whoever poked out the statue's eyes got a rush of satisfaction.
Really enjoyed this.
I loved that lecture. I will be able to look at portraiture with so much more - knowledge and appreciation and insight! So wish I could view in person. Soon. This Canadian will be there.
Fascinating, thank you- I need to go and see the exhibition now!
More please. This presentation is excellent.
I would love to see more from this presenter. I've seen bunches of these, and this gentleman stimulates the mind very well.
Discovered by a schoolboy who will not be named. Why? I would like to know his name. He was clearly cheated out of his prize and the recognition for finding it. At least preserve his name and tell us who he was.
Looking into the past no better presenter to do it with. Thank you for posting.
That was very interesting. Thank you very much.
Wonderful presentation, thankyou.
Gazing into the eyeholes more like. When statues lose their eyes it always gives them a rather unsettling look.
very interesting and entertaining!
Fantastic! Thank you.
I hope to see this presenter frequently. I very much enjoyed this segment.
That was fascinating!!
Wonderful. Thank you.
Very interesting stuff
I could watch/listen and learn from this expert for hours !! I hope there are many more such videos!! Incredibly informative/brilliantly presented_______
Ancient Rome still rules at least in the category of a fascinating subject!!__|
I love the head casually tucked in the bookshelf
Great video. I rely like the emphasis on the symbolism rather than focusing on how realistic it is.
Finally something that someone left behind in Britain and not stolen from a colonised country.
Also could make you think, reflecting on the time you yourself were colonised and tried to resist.
thankyou for sharing this 🙂 x
Gold. As always.
A lovely talk, simply presented. The river Alde, as in Aldeburgh is usually pronounced 'awld'.
Excellent job
Thorsten is a national treasure and he isn’t even British
What is he Chinese?
@@Mynipplesmychoice German or Austrian, I assume by his name you fucking fool
@@Mukkki alright so I’m guessing your Chinese by your reaction… do u know karate?
@@Mukkki cause I just got my yellow belt
He talks about the Iceni revolt. I wonder how much imperial tax revenue was going to the Vitellian camp, which controlled northern Gaul, and how much of it was disrupted by this event.
Hello my name is Door Stopper... 🙃
It was a great presentation and Mr Thorsten Opper is a pleasure to listen to. Thank you!
Great talk, thanks so much from old New Orleans 🤓
👏👏👏 Thank you very much!
Excellent Thankyou
Love every second
Excellent
Well, at first I was sure the head was of Claudius, but a little digging showed that while Claudius and Nero shared the small chin and large ears, the brow ridges are different, and the relationship between nose and mouth are different, and then Nero had sort of a knob on his chin which Claudius didn't have. In fact, Claudius' chin was almost non-existent. So, exactly as the curator said, the profiles clear up the identity.
Can’t say I am as convinced. That looks like every image of Claudius I have seen and not one of the images of Nero.
@@genadearagon8977 Look at the ones when Nero was very young -- he looked a whole lot like Claudius, only with a sort of knob on his chin. I wish the curator had explained how they decided it was Nero.
Fascinating 🖖🏼
boadicea camped near where i grew up, on the suffolk side of the river stour (the border between suffolk and essex), between sudbury and bures. maybe it was the night before
Talking of bringing Emperors back to life, the experiments in AI to put flesh on the statue heads (search for Mystery Scoop Roman Emperors) is a novel approach - looks like they will have to tweak such recreations to take account of perspective.
This is definitely the most Julio-Claudian looking depiction of Nero I've seen.
This is great, thanks for posting! One suggestion: do some audio balancing. The presenter's voice is very quiet compared to the rest of the sound (the music).
Oh god, the progression of those coins LOL. Nero really turned into a little porker.
Nero is one the greatest actors of all time, how can u be so disrespectful?take it back and say your sorry
he so obviously liked nam-nam
For the last 50+ years the British Museum have told me this is Claudius so it is quite difficult to see it now as Nero but Thorsten makes a good case. The museum still describe it as "Claudius or Nero" so I am not the only one sitting on the fence.
Fascinating
Going to the exhibition on Saturday!
Lucky you
I love this series.
Nero had a strange face and head with those ears but his profile is pretty striking.
How interesting!
Very interesting.
An interesting talk.
I should add a little of an art historian’s perspective to this excellent archaeological historian’s perspective. The head is slightly greater than life size, especially in width. As pointed out here, this looks far more naturalistic from the perspective of the intended viewing of the statue.
However, there is another aspect not mentioned here, because it has nothing to do with the political history of the sculpture. It is about artistic proportion. In reality the head and body standing are about seven and a half heads high. During the classical Greek and Roman period they used a proportion of eight heads height meaning that Greek and Roman statuary tends to exaggerate the musculature of the torso, and the heads tend to look a little small by our modern standards. This was probably due to the belief at the time that human passions originate within the torso, plus strong musculature was associated with manhood and strength.
We still carry a time capsule of this Roman viewpoint in modern English language. For example we still use the phrase ‘venting the spleen.’ Of course we now know that emotions are generated within the central portion of the brain, but the ancient Greeks and Romans literally thought that ‘venting’ originated in the spleen. They also believed that love literally originated in the heart. It is another hangover from the classical period that in modern romantic language we still associate love with the heart, despite our modern knowledge that it actually comes from the brain. This Roman view that emotions originate within the organs of the torso resulted in them thinking of the head as less important than the torso and this is reflected in an artistic proportional system that conveyed this cultural view of the human body.
This means that this head which is slightly larger than life size would have been on a body that was visibly even larger than natural proportion would suggest. This has propaganda value and would emphasize the impressiveness of the emperor to the Roman and British viewers, but also would meet the idea of the time of correct artistic proportions. To the ancient Greeks and Romans our modern proportional standards for depicting the human body, despite being demonstrably closer to reality, would appear grotesque and vulgar.
Could there be more of the statue still in the river?!
Nero looks like he’s having his hair cut.
It's Claudius. No, now we believe it's Nero. Great, now I have to rewrite parts of my historical novel! Thankfully it's only a name change in two or three places. LOL I will not, however, be rewriting the bit where that head is hacked off a bronze mounted on a horse outside the temple.
"Gazing into the eyes of Nero now"
The bust has empty holes where the eye sockets are....