Rainer Zitelmann: Hitler and Stalin’s Socialist Dream

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @DadSavesAmerica
    @DadSavesAmerica  11 дней назад +3

    If you like what you see and want to stay up to date with Dad Saves America, please subscribe here on RUclips or over on Substack, where you can find weekly articles and the audio version of the podcast, with more to come in the near future!
    www.dadsavesamerica.com

  • @investorbettor505
    @investorbettor505 11 дней назад +30

    “Fascism and communism are not two opposites, but two rival gangs fighting over the same territory . . . both are variants of statism, based on the collectivist principle that man is the rightless slave of the state.” -Ayn Rand

    • @vb_matic4166
      @vb_matic4166 10 дней назад +1

      Two sides of a rusty coin.

    • @LebanonBologna40
      @LebanonBologna40 4 дня назад

      So true… Hitler purportedly hated communism, and the communists were fighting the Nazis only to come in and pick up where they left off after the war.

  • @Dionysus-gv9lz
    @Dionysus-gv9lz 11 дней назад +14

    Should be more criticism and debate directed towards Roosevelts labor and social welfare programs. He effectively made himself a dictator serving 4 terms, and if he hadn’t died while serving he might have continued clinging to power. He transformed America.

    • @LebanonBologna40
      @LebanonBologna40 4 дня назад

      Yep, and not for the better. Even during the time he was criticized for his dictatorial tendencies.

  • @PMMagro
    @PMMagro 3 дня назад +1

    It is an ancient idea that "good" people are smart, good looking, good at everything and "bad" people vice versa.

  • @emikke
    @emikke 11 дней назад +20

    The whole video was amazing, it explains succinctly that National Socialism really is a Socialist ideology

    • @nascar0509
      @nascar0509 10 дней назад +7

      Tik history channel also explains how they were and are strains of Socialism fascism being a international unionised form I believe.

    • @TheTimdoyle
      @TheTimdoyle 10 дней назад +4

      TIK history channel has numerous videos about this. There’s even a 4 1/2 video explaining fully. Definitely worth watching.

    • @olgakipke3720
      @olgakipke3720 9 дней назад +2

      Of course it is. It's even called national socialist.

    • @Mcarthywasright
      @Mcarthywasright 8 дней назад

      Oh boy. Only in America where you work your whole life to remove yourself and protect resources from the dregs of society can you unironically call this socialism fascism. That’s not a thing. I’d say this is a smooth brain take but there isn’t much brain to smooth. Tell your grand kids to enjoy public school and riding the train for me

    • @sdrc92126
      @sdrc92126 7 дней назад

      The 25 points of NS are clearly socialist. They should be taught in school. It's half a page of text...but I don't know if reading is taught anymore. Their main focus was on environmentalism. Actually, most of them are taught, but under a different name of esg and dei...🤔

  • @AkiraNakamoto
    @AkiraNakamoto 7 дней назад +3

    Glad to see that there is one wise man amongst the god-damned sociologists.

  • @gabrielrodriguez821
    @gabrielrodriguez821 8 дней назад +4

    Unfortunately, FDR liked Stalin too. Stalin legit played both the east and the west like a fiddle.

    • @AkiraNakamoto
      @AkiraNakamoto 7 дней назад +1

      Every socialist is a disguised dictator. --- Ludwig von Mises
      FDR was a dictator. Just like every lifelong dictator, he died BEFORE releasing his presidential power.

  • @Dionysus-gv9lz
    @Dionysus-gv9lz 11 дней назад +4

    I feel that excessive government overreach always leads to some form and degree of socialism. Whether it be national socialism, communism, “democratic socialism” etc. And times of austerity and war seem to accelerate the process. Roosevelts reforms in the US, or socialisms expansion in Western Europe following WWII.

    • @sdrc92126
      @sdrc92126 7 дней назад

      It's called the gnostic impulse. Probably the thing that is described, without naming, in the story of Genesis

  • @dafyduck79
    @dafyduck79 10 дней назад +4

    he nailed it with JFK :)))
    every politician is statist, the question is just how far is he willing to go

    • @sdrc92126
      @sdrc92126 7 дней назад

      Utopias are worth any cost. That's why they are always associated with mass atrocities

  • @ayanamireizero
    @ayanamireizero 10 дней назад +4

    Socialism, communism, national socialism and fascism are suprising all kult/religion.

    • @sdrc92126
      @sdrc92126 7 дней назад

      _Science Politics and Gnosticism_ goes into the details of this. Excellent and very short book, about 95 pages by an academic who studied totalitarian governments.

  • @MisterOceanCity
    @MisterOceanCity 9 часов назад

    A really good book you all can read which kind of a mirror's what this guy is saying is Inside the Third Reich by Albert Speer

  • @jeffkay1977
    @jeffkay1977 11 дней назад +3

    National Capitalism is good. That's what I got out of it. I think.

    • @nateamstutz2
      @nateamstutz2 8 дней назад

      Capitalism is completely anti nation and anti labor
      Money gives man (worker) and labor value which should be the opposite where man (who’s the worker of the nation and of his people) value to labor and currency

    • @sdrc92126
      @sdrc92126 7 дней назад

      National Capitalism is Oxymoronic

    • @PerPress
      @PerPress 4 дня назад +1

      That might be, but capitalism and communism are international.

    • @PerPress
      @PerPress 4 дня назад +1

      @@nateamstutz2 The workers were exploited and suppressed by the ruling class (the government) in
      the former Soviet Union too.
      The main problem is overpopulation. In an underpopulated world the workers can require more -
      if they are not suppressed by the government and others.
      In a free underpopulated world, the companies cannot get workers - if they underpay.