Producer Reacts to ASTRO "Always You"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июл 2024
- In this episode the Producer checks out a brand new mature side of ASTRO in their music video "Always You"!
SEND US STUFF!
FOT MEDIA
PO BOX 552
LOS ALAMITOS
CA 90720
Help support Form of Therapy by subscribing to us on Patreon! / formoftherapy
Subscribe to Form of Therapy for more future Reaction videos & let us know in the comments down below what else you'd like to see!
#ASTRO #Rise_Up #너잖아 #Always_You #아스트로
Follow us & stay up to date
Facebook: / formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
Follow the cast
@formoftherapy
![[C.C.] A certain girl idol tried to flirt with Eunwoo!?😳 #CHAEUNWOO #ASTRO](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CkW-VEdk2wY/mqdefault.jpg)
It's not so much that they had to grow up, it's that they were forced to. The song is a commentary on their situation with Fantagio and the helplessness they felt, drowning in bureaucracy. The rest of the mini album harkens back to their cute concepts and speaks both to Arohas (the fandom) that left during their hiatus and those that stayed; This is probably the most personal comeback they've ever had.
Lauren Miller what situation? What was going on?
Fantagio fired their CEO a couple of months ago, and this is illegal, so the company was, maybe is still in risk of being dissolved
Mint look into it. this is all because of JC group who bought all their stocks, then proceeded draining money from the company, making the managers and staff pay for everything by themselves, then they fired fantagio and fantagio music CEOs and well... nothing has been going great since then, but it seems that fantagio music got a CEO who has a licence and they can operate legally for now...
if you go on twitter @WMENTFANTAGIO there is a full explanation of what happened with Fantagio and Artist and Actors up until July 29th.
Well said. I broke down sobbing when I first read the translation because the lyrics were so unrelentingly raw. The whole song is pure heartbreak... I’m thankful they were able to get through the hiatus alright, but it hurts to know that they felt such a searing level of emotional pain during it.
Tbh I feel like those lyrics relate a lot to the fantagio situation
They're describing what they feel if they have to disband one day
And it's really tearing me up
Mark Rswsk why ya gotta do this to me man
Jen Milan cause it's true ?
Yea jinwoo felt like he would never perform for us again and he helped write alot of it
it's not about fearing disbandment (there are a lot of rumors flying around which aren't true, so please don't spread such talks), it's about missing fans and being sorry. it's about fearing fans leaving, because they have had to wait so long for a comeback
thats because it is i really hope it gets better and they don't disband :(
" *oof there he is, with the white hair* " LMFAO
same PD. same
people are trying to come for the mv, but look at pdnim, A WHOLE PRODUCER, going on about this mv. astro and the producers did an AMAZING job considering the fact that fantagio is still in a mess. the whole message of the rise up mini album is about how scared they were about fantagio going under, hence the ‘drowning’ concept in the mv, about how scared they were of possibly having to disband due to the company’s financial and legal issues. fantagio could still be operating illegally, fantagio could still possibly go under, but astro really came back hard with rise up. that’s also why i think they DIDN’T do a cute concept; the message they wanted to get across in this is really serious and they couldn’t do that with a cute cb. i’m really proud of astro and i hope they keep fighting !!
except fantagio produced the album, not astro. it's all just marketing strategy lmao fanmu took advantage of their own situation and exploited it
thank you for explaining this nicely
I feel like this is a song that grows on you the more you listen to it
Definitely!
Emilie Davenport agree,i didnt feel it for the first time but damn after i listen to it for like 100 times,it got me
Shanezze Scifandzia same
Emilie Davenport YASS
thats how i feel! at first i was like hmm, okay not bad and NOW IM FREAKIN HOOKED. it sunk into my pores
I will never get over Jinjin's Joker hair from this era
this is a mature comeback bc of the fantagio situation, it shows how the members are feeling. i’m going to explain the best i can so sorry if this comment is really long, also sorry for any typos i may make!
to make a long story short there’s some issues with who is in charge of fantagio at the moment and they have to be really careful with what they do in case they violate any rules, etc etc. for the longest time astro were threatened with disbandment and they still are a small bit but not as much.
astro wrote the lyrics to this song, and when you put it into context of the fantagio situation the song is so powerful. english translations to some of the parts are (translations from color coded lyrics):
- “i shed tears out of fear that we won’t see each other anymore”
- “with the faith of you waiting for me though it was hard, i swallowed my tears and went to you”
- “you told me not to worry no matter what happens”
- “are you still there? in these times that were hard to endure”
- “though i’m late, i came to you”
- “my heart ached because i couldn’t hold you”
- “i know you’ve waited for me too, my heart ached because we couldn’t touch”
the “you” in the song is aroha (astro’s fans): so many of the lyrics show their fear of not being able to make music and see the fans anymore. the lyrics also show the fear of the boys that they will have lost a lot of fans due to the long hiatus between crazy sexy cool and always you. it’s truly heartbreaking but this song is so powerful especially when put into context of everything that’s going on with their company.
okay, enough gushing about the song! please support this comeback so we can show the boys that even though we had to wait for the new song it’s okay and we still love them :D
I'VE BEEN WAITING AROHAS WHERE Y'ALL AT?
Yuki HERE GIRL😀😁
HERE
hel yea
Someone called me? :v
Here😁
how fast his facial expression changed once myungjuns part started LMFAOAOA
ASTRO just uploaded the dance cut from the mv! It's 30 seconds long and it was choreographed mainly by Rocky with JinJin and Moonbin helping, it looks dope indeed ^^
not to mention they came up with it in 2hours....FREAKING GENIUSES
ASTRO ASTRO ASTRO ASTRO ASTRO ASTRO KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS
I've listened to this song like 10 times and can't remember the melody
i agree and i don't know why
Lazy Ace Dia sameeee
They make you want to listen to it again to find the melody thus streaming
SAME DUDE but I fall in love with the song again and again
Because like PD said, it’s just kind of another slow edm song. It’s good but not anything special.
The song really gets into you after a few listens
Jigsawwolf it's a typical feel good song i guess
seol city it’s definitely not a feel good song if you check out the lyrics...
Jigsawwolf i do realise that, i really like astro and seeing that fantagio is dying bit by bit every day really gets me emotional. but what i meant by 'feel good' is the overall vibe of this style of music, when you don't take the lyrics into context
PD, there's already a dance cut! Look at ASTRO's RUclips channel!
We had the same reaction! The song was okay, but the MV was really good!
the whole point of the song was to explain the sitution with fantigo it really has a deeper meaning than any other song youve probably ever listened to
im sure im not the first to say this but astros comeback was super super important to aroha! after the issues with their company this was their first comeback. astro lost a lot of fans because they couldnt be there for aroha. they wrote lyrics and did their best in the new album and it is for aroha :) it feels really lovely to have them back... they wrote many of their feelings about missing aroha (and maybe youll think i and other aroha are silly but i think there is truly a very special bond between astro and aroha). anyway, they did post the performance cut today just a few hours before you posted this and it is just as amazing as it is in the mv (plus another scene)! its on their youtube channel so definitely check it out if you get the chance! keep being awesome ♡
Thanks for reacting!This MV and the whole feel of Astro's "Rise Up" album is very unique for the group in that they've tackled a more serious concept compared to their previous comeback. That's mostly due to the fact that Astro (and JinJin in particular) actually worked with the producers to write the lyrics for this album during their long hiatus when their future as Astro was uncertain. Their company went through a lot of financial and managerial difficulties (which still aren't fully resolved), and for a time there were concerns about the label collapsing and the groups under it being forced to disband. The song is both an apology for being away for so long, a reassurance that they still want to be Astro, and a lament for the fans they lost or disappointed along the way.
Astro recently explained in their own words that this song in particular was a confession of how they felt during that time, "It was so hard"/ "I wasn't okay", and the fear they felt over losing fans due to not being able to release music "Are you still there?".
ASTRO is so underrated, each one of the members are unique and has their own stand out talent and characteristic. They deserve more recognitions.
This song had one of the BEST distributions in lines. Stan talent. Stan ASTRO.
The first time I heard this song. I felt so sad. Its like they are telling me a sad story. And when I found the english translation, that’s when I fully understand that they are longing.
PD, thanks for reacting to ASTRO - Always You, as Aroha I can tell this comeback is so different from the other comebacks, I totally loved music and video, and as you say, camera works on the dance scenes are clearly well made. So, I invite you to see Astro - Always You performance CUT, with the dance line of Astro, it’s the full shot of the three members dancing in the white room, I’m sure you will love this~ Thank you for react to Astro
considering that they were able to produce this after the whole mess is enough. a lot of us weren't really expecting anything and so it's really sentimental to us,,, it might not be the greatest but it's more than a song to us^^
I am so proud of #ASTRO they did an amazing job despite everything that's happening to them. #Eunwoo filming his drama and preparing for a comeback, that man is overworked!
#Jinjin made 60% of the lyrics, #Rocky creating that epic choreo with #Moonbin and Jinjin, #Sanha and #Mj's vocals are always legendary .The whole ASTRO preparing for a comeback and preparing for their solo concert in Japan while Fantagio is in disarray, they are fucking legends for overcoming all that!
I LOVE ASTRO!
I understand your comments about the song, originally I felt that way too, but it’s starting to grow on me a bit, I really liked your reaction
The more you listen to it. The more you will fall inlove to it. Just like me. Like Ive been listening to it 10 times. Its not really a song that will stuck on you head but its a song that you will not get tired of it
Aroha feels
I swear is it my favorite MV Astro has released. It was all so aesthetically pleasing.
I'm a die hard Aroha and the song had to grow on me a little bit but I still like it a lot because I love their vocals and JinJin got a chance to shine as a rapper and Rocky as a vocalist
this song is about their current situation at fantagio. the fact that they even managed to have a comeback and make it look good with what little money is left is outstanding. this song and music video is the rawest thing they’ve ever done and all the arohas really appreciate it and are grateful for them staying.
Hey Pdmim, ABOUT THE CONSTANT NEVER ENDING LIGHT CIRCLING AND MOVING AND GOING ON AND ON MEANS: THE PASSING DAYS THAT ASTRO WAITED UNTIL THEIR FINAL COMEBACK. THEY SAT AND WAITED. AND IF YOU WOULD LISTEN INTENTLY YOU COULD HEAR THE SOUND OF THE CLOCK. SOMEWHAT LIKE THE LIGHT YOU SAW THAT WAS REVOLVING AROUND MJ. ITS A CLOCK'S HAND. THE PASSING DAYS AND TIME.
Definitely my favorite ASTRO comback after Crazy, Sexy Cool
I have never been this fast 😂😅 anyways astro fighting!??
You know what I find even more amazing, they had 3 weeks to make this song, choreography, and basically everything before releasing it to the public. I think the choreography was made the day before the video ( although if that's wrong, somebody please correct me ).
Thank you for always reacting to ASTRO 💜
The MV was really pleasing to me too and wow I never noticed that circulating blue light lol how cool
Honestly I love the song, but I think they could've make the chorus more impactful (?) idk anyways thanks for reacting to this yay
Astros whole concept was to go from being SUPER cute to eventually get to the point when they do a sexy comeback but only over time
I fell in love with this song within the first few seconds of hearing it, and I'm still obsessed with it honestly. I think it might be because it was something different from ASTRO, they've had kind of darker songs in the past a few times, but there was something that felt very raw and personal, especially with the situation with their company. Vocally, it was different, with Rocky singing this time around, which I also really enjoyed, and I loved the chorus a lot. It may not be the most unique song, but I'm so glad they were able to put out something so good under so much stress regardless!
Rocky did that amazing choreography! He said so in his audio Vlive - he also said the other 2 helped him a lot 💜💜💜
Now that you mentioned it, I feel like the constant moving lights could symbolize time passing by (somewhat like how the light of the sun rises and falls) since they've been on hiatus for a long time and there is nothing they can do about it. At some parts, they were even looking up, as if longing for something or reminiscing past memories with their loved one (a.k.a arohas).
I feel like I finally understood the music video, with your help.
They're all always in slow motion, but the light keeps changing, it's like time is going by but they're not progressing at all.
Sanha is in a car and it already has so much foliage inside because he's been stuck there for too long.
The hall with arches, it feels like a loop or a never ending hallway almost that you can't get out of but Rocky tried to run from it, but it just pulled him back to where he started/rewinded him back.
The dance part, is like their dream, it's inside of them, it's very very powerful but they can't let it out because they're all helplessly stuck from where they are.
That room where they're just waiting while days pass.
And the opening scene where it looks like he's drowning in deep water. Yup helpless.
Oh also, when Eunwoo, started to play the music on the phonograph, Rocky ran, it's like music is their escape from the loneliness of being sort of abandoned, and then the dance line started dancing intensely, but also with a blank face. I just think that's really cool.
Dang, thinking about what happened then with Fantagio, this makes so much sense.
Astro was my first kpop group, without them I wouldn't be part of anything kpop related...that being said. This song and every song on the album was everything for myself and many other Aroha. The lyrics are so beautiful. It truly is their song to Aroha (excluding You & Me).
Alot of Aroha did leave but for those who stayed...this was everything for us.
I'VE BEEN SO OBSESSED WITH BTS I DIDNT EVEN KNOW ASTRO CAME BACK I FEEL ASHAMED! Seriously though this MV was gorgeous and the emotional impact was strong.
I do miss their cutesy music though. :'( Hopefully it's not totally gone and they will still be cute sometimes.
The more you listen to this song, the more you love this song
I so love ALWAYS YOU. Really love.
THAT TURNING STAG JUMP BY ROCKY IS ART
thank you for this reaction video for ASTRO's "Always You" MV. I hope that you also make a reaction video to their latest song "One" thank you so much!!!
I think that given the current Fantagio situation, it makes sense that the song sounds like this... But I agree that it is a little underwhelming because of their previous concept. I like it like this too, but I would prefer something along the lines of their previous works.
I totally agree about the song, and those lights are so epic in the mv
Yes Astro reaction
I love how the pd notices the little stuffs and details.
I was so excited for that comeback since it's my first as an aroha and like the song but what stood up to me was the MV itself, especially the dancing shots. I totally fell in love with the part when Rocky, JinJin and Moonbin are dancind in the black and white outfit : the lightning and the camera work oh my god 😍😍
This is one of my favorite songs because this is made especially for Aroha.
I almost cried when I saw the MV with the lyrics. Astro is my healer but this songs hurts me Everytime I hear this.
great video! Always You is my favourite Astro song and I never picked up on the subtler aspects of the video the way you did. This was fascinating and made me enjoy the mv much more!
I really enjoy this era, and it’s such a shame that they aren’t promoting this on music shows at all. But I’m glad they can all work on solo stuff. I’m glad they put something out because it’s been too long 😭💛
I've thought that too...like I stan Astro, but this song isn't like...a song I'd like to listen to on repeat[compared to Crazy Sexy Cool & Baby] but the vocals & the maturity of the concept really caught me in.
As soon as I watched this music video I really wanted to hear your thoughts on it. It’s simple but the execution is INCREDIBLE, I haven’t seen camerawork and lighting and a set that so perfectly accentuates emotion and really creates a mood like in this music video, in a long time. It’s not just about the aesthetics. The shifting light, running in slow motion, the use of repetition in patterns creates this feeling of moving and trying to get somewhere but you don’t, you just repeat the same things over and over. I LOVE IT SO MUCH.
As for the song, I can see why it would be like any other EDM song but I guess bc Astro haven’t done it before, they bring a new flavour for me :D I loved the song from the first notes, maybe because for me even if it’s EDM i love dramatic cinematic songs. And since CSC was already heading in a more mature route, I was anticipating a not-so-cute song and so I love this comeback (every other song on their album is dope too)
They just released the performance cut ver, if you have time just watch it! You won't regret it they're so cool
I used to sing quite a lot and somehow this is Astro's song with the most fascinating vocal arrangement for me. Almost all vocal/rap parts are multi-layered, with some surprising notes on some parts. I think the mixing/mastering are pretty good too as these voices blend nicely. I'd probably buy one if they made the choir music sheet for this one. Would love to try singing it. Haha
this MV was what got me into Astro, still very new to the fandom but I'm just blown away by how talented they are
LEO - Touch & Sketch
This song honestly reminds me of Again of of their Winter special album which they didnt have a mv for (its also the other album they didnt promote on music shows). I feel like the albums they promote on music shows have the cute concepts.
Astro...this songs gets better and better the more you listen to it.
I liked the song..the music.. the choreography..their vocals.. their rap.. the MV concept & effects ❤❤❤ all of this song is my style exactly
This song gives me chills omg
I am glad they are moving on from cute, they will always be able to do it, but I enjoy that they are trying new things.
There is one. It came out today! It's amazing esp that shot! It took my breath away!
I love this comeback by them
This mv it's so beautiful. That light around MJ was the coolest effect.
The song grows on you and i hope Astro and arohas will be just fine for many many years 💜
I feel like a lot of people feel let down by the song, but considering the time frame they had to produce this it's actually rly higj quality. Most of it was finalised in a couple weeks, with the dance being totally completed only a couple days before the mv filming!! That + the lyrics (and the mini album as a whole) has a much deeper meaning relating to Astro and Aroha. For us, this comeback means so much bc we 'lost' our boys for a bit, we're just grateful we can meet again, that's the most important point
Yes yes yes yes thank you!
The mv has so much hidden meaning and metaphors for their crisis. The lyrics are heartbreaking and full of emotion but once you break down the mv it only adds salt to the wound
I absolutely love the song and the mv
YES YES YES IM SO HAPPY YOU DECIDED TO WATCH THIS
Well, PD they just released a dance cut of that shot you liked earlier...
i just wish they showed more of the choreography in the music video, cause it looks beautiful
Watching it again makes me feel an excitement for their comeback.. 😍😍😍😍
please react to sorry for my english by in2it !!!!
tuuli yes pls !!
OH YES, or Snapshot!
OMG YESS!! that would be so so great!! I wish he would also react to their previous comeback "Snapshot" cause that was gold
He needs to react to every IN2IT MV lol.
They aren't promoting this song so hopefully in their next comeback they'll show more of their identity and go back to their cute, refreshing selves with dreamlike music videos! Have hope PD! ^^ Still really happy you reacted to this!~
I really like the way PD is making the videos lately, when he's commenting on interesting aspects of the mv the part he's talking about plays, so we can see what he noticed, it helps a lot and makes this commentary section of the reaction easier to watch.
As always, it was an amazing vídeo, thanks PD-nim. 😊
thx for your reaction, I LOVE ASTRO!
I love Astro and although this comeback isn’t my favourite because the song is kind of generic and doesn’t have something about it so it doesn’t get stuck in my head, the video was shot well and they look great and I hope they continue to grow and get better everytime even tho it is bittersweet seeing them develop out of their ‘cuter’ concepts such as Baby(aka bop of the century).
The thing about this song, is that it's in the style of quite a lot of their b side songs; they've done songs like this before but they've always been b side songs
MY KINGS BEING APPRECIATED
I personally LOVE this song, especially the second part of the chorus. It just gives me the feeling that my heart gets liftet up (?) and I immediately imagine myself on top of a mountain and I want to start ice dancing (even tho I don't know who to do that xD). On the other hand the music video was kind boring to me, I noticed the thing with the light but it didn't really stood out to me. But that's probably because I'm not that into visual effects.
hi! i just want to say that this comeback is a special album for arohas, which includes songs that portray their struggles during the hiatus because of their company's issue, thus the mature concept of it. the lyrics actually tell their feelings about being away for so long and about losing fans so yeah, it's heavy stuff. they have another song in the album titled "call out", which the members actually agreed would have made a good title song. it has brighter sound despite the somehow melancholic lyrics, so i guess they are still planning to do fresh concept in their future comebacks. they just want to share their emotions and thoughts with their fans with this album.
thanks for the review btw! been waiting for it :)
Loved your commentary! It was right on point! I can’t wait to see the dance also! Thanks PD!
Pd: I like the mv way more than the music
Also Pd in blue flame reaction: Always you is actually the best Astro song ever 😂
Don’t worry Pd nim astro still does cute!! Check out when you call my name!!
This song is like another song if you talk about the composer. You can understand why it's song is very special for aroha if you see the lyric. :)
I get what you are saying with the cute concept i miss it too! But the song is about how even when they were ia and a lot of the fandom left.. so its like a thanks for the fans that stayed and since their company is kinda in trouble right now they try hard to keep up with their fans on twitter so its like a big thank you to the fans :)
👍 I thought the same, the camera 🎥 work is really 👌. They never are together until the end of the video. I really love the song, at Spotify the quality is so high, that I feel chills everytime. You should react to the video of their performance at Mcountdown. That performance is P E R F E C T. And it is truth, the song is about their situation... grow up in such a harsh environment is not easy, but... what don’t kill you, makes you stronger. If they endure this, I think, they will shine even more.
i love this comeback so much. My fav comeback of this year. Stan Astro💗
*Moonbin appears on screen*
"Ooo there he is"
😂
...a very precious comeback that wont be promoted.....when i thought astro was disbanding oh gahd i was soo scared and thought it was actually gonna happen. Then they released teasers and made me hella confused....i hope things dont go lower from here...
I needed a reaction to this from you. AND YOU PROVIDED IM HAPPY
Woow they are just amazing
Thanks for this video!! This MV is fucking amazing, the colors and the lights are so beautiful. The music is good, but the MV os even better.
ASTRP and Aroha fighting!
I love your reactions 💞💞💞
It's all about the second meanings!!!!!
IVE BEEN WAITING THANK YOU
YES FINALLY, THANK U SO MUCH
there actually is a dance cut posted! it has two dance scenes in it (same choreo sequence, but different sets)