Dialogue, diplomacy, backchannel talks & challenges in India-Pakistan relations

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024

Комментарии • 56

  • @bulthaosen1169
    @bulthaosen1169 Год назад +38

    Having dialogue with them is like having dialogue with a mad person.

  • @ven41618
    @ven41618 Год назад +31

    Pak is the greatest democracy on earth. They provide full security and 4 wives each to all their citizens. I encourage all muslims wordwide to move there and lead happy lives.

    • @IndiaTides
      @IndiaTides Год назад

      Comment sections, few riots with political motive made you what you are. I pity people like you who hate based on religion.

    • @Gopimenon123
      @Gopimenon123 Год назад

      Later 72. So I heard

  • @nishantketu7996
    @nishantketu7996 Год назад +15

    Handing over the POK to India is the only way we can initiate talks between India and Pakistan.

  • @tapemaj
    @tapemaj Год назад +11

    I don’t think within my lifetime shall there be a peace accord with our western neighbour …

  • @adityarane2877
    @adityarane2877 Год назад +18

    Aman ki asha gang must stop this nonsense now. We youth don't want to do any kind of talks with an aatanki state

  • @mohitanand1844
    @mohitanand1844 Год назад +18

    Why would any self respecting ppl will have dialogues with them ??

  • @Peaceforall10
    @Peaceforall10 Год назад +6

    As PM Modi recently said, India has wasted lot of time and energy focusing on Pakistan and resolution of the its issues with the neighbour country. This resulted in India ignoring the threat from China.

    • @Peaceforall10
      @Peaceforall10 Год назад

      @A143 very recently somewhere. Cannot remember where but I saw the speech that said India needs to stop wasting and discussing Pak.
      Regarding China, George Fernanades was the first one to say so

  • @navneet8269
    @navneet8269 Год назад +1

    I am very poor in English but I could understand simple English
    This time I delighted to see this great conversation with c Raja Mohan the veteran along with Mr parthasarathp another distinguish guest
    Rest comment after listening

  • @nmg1443
    @nmg1443 Год назад +5

    The best relationship is no relationship. All trade and travel must immediately be stopped. Gilgit Baltistan back to India, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to Afghanistan, and independence for our Baloch brothers and sisters. There's no other objective.

  • @DRVIKASJOSHI
    @DRVIKASJOSHI Год назад +3

    Let’s forget Pakistan and work to strengthen India and improve life of our citizens

  • @PANKAJKUMAR-qn4uf
    @PANKAJKUMAR-qn4uf Год назад +6

    India should cut water supply to paxtan

  • @actioergosum5193
    @actioergosum5193 Год назад +5

    It might be worth conjecturing that Pakistan's policies towards India have been putatively spawned and shaped in Beijing. The China angle in Indo-Pak relations could have been explored or at least touched upon.

  • @aperson2730
    @aperson2730 Год назад

    Very interesting

  • @ranjithkumar3480
    @ranjithkumar3480 Год назад +3

    People to people relationship with Pakistan is also a bad idea. If people of Pakistan really wants it, they will overthrow the establishment and take political control to deal with India. Truth is Pakistan is largely islamised and they do believe jihad against Hindus. So normalising relations with them is a bad idea. We move in our way and they move in their way.

  • @shailendrawalia5551
    @shailendrawalia5551 Год назад +4

    Same old nonsense…..these people never learn

  • @मगरमच्छ
    @मगरमच्छ Год назад +3

    Aap apna dekhe .. hum apna dekhte hai. .. ab hame maaf kare.. 🙏🙏

  • @sourabhkumar1338
    @sourabhkumar1338 Год назад +4

    Who cares about Pakistan

  • @Indus720
    @Indus720 Год назад +1

    New Blood and thinking is needed to deal with a rogue state, as the main victim of terrorism thats common people of India who died in local trains, markets and butchered by Pakistani Jihaadi at railway station, hotels sponsored by Pakistani Army would not accept normalisation of VISA regime and seeing the drama of Aman Ki Aisha again until perpetrator are delivered to India and Justice served.

  • @prietya9906
    @prietya9906 Год назад

    Pursuit of peace with Pak is like flogging a dead horse.

  • @beluga9596
    @beluga9596 Год назад +1

    Aman ki asha gang

  • @shailendrawalia5551
    @shailendrawalia5551 Год назад +2

    You cannot make sustained peace with an ideological society…..that includes common people ….stop spouting this nonsense that common Pakistanis love Hindus

  • @VishalKumar-g6k5n
    @VishalKumar-g6k5n 7 месяцев назад

    If india can,t find bagha border transport corridor through pakistan is the first condition to talk otherwise waste time to talk to pakistan😂

  • @manilkumar73
    @manilkumar73 Год назад +2

    Aman ka asha brigade.... move away...we don't need u

  • @vherlekar
    @vherlekar 7 месяцев назад

    The only "minimal agreement" possible betw the countries is "Live and Let Live" ..but that TOO much seems increasingly Mission Impossible 😕
    And all that nonsense abt "Borders made irrelevant" -- arre bhai for that you have to FIRST agree exactly WHERE the borders are (!)
    The Jihadis have ALREADY made the borders "irrelevant" 😀

  • @IndiaTides
    @IndiaTides Год назад +5

    People who oppose dialogue with Pakistan forgets that all PMs in India tried to dialogue with them. Why? Because it is in our interest to minimize hostility. The aim is to global player. Fighting with Pakistan is beneath us.

    • @prateekdeoli1552
      @prateekdeoli1552 Год назад +12

      "We want a better relation with them or they will become hostile" doesn't it seem like a hostage situation and how will you be a global player when you are controlled by a smaller neighbours hostility? Maal mara hai kya? Where has the hostility gone for last 4 years? These strategic circles in India is run by bunch of emotional fools and now when a hardcore strategy is unfolding they want to undo it!

    • @adityarane2877
      @adityarane2877 Год назад +10

      its in our interest to break it into smaller pieces. Engaging with them will bring them into mainstream

    • @nmg1443
      @nmg1443 Год назад

      ​@@prateekdeoli1552 Well okay, as long as we work to break Pakistan into pieces, that's the only correct policy.

    • @ranjithkumar3480
      @ranjithkumar3480 Год назад

      Till Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Pakistan was better economically. They were aligned with USA. Peaceful border is must for India as we can't afford to spend on defence.Peace with Pakistan is now a burden. With the rise of Hindu Nationalism, the Indian Muslim is anxious. They can easily weaponise that anxiety. It will be a disaster for India. Let's grow in our own way and let them be. India should concentrate on China right now. As china is a rational nation, it is easier to deal with them. If we normalise relations with Pakistan, China will use Pakistan to do it's dirty work. Peace with Pakistan was a necessity once but it is irrevalent now as long as we can protect our borders.

    • @userre85
      @userre85 Год назад

      ​@@adityarane2877 agreed but refugee crisis ka kya karenge