Agree. Pride will not help ; especially, some of this official who just do talking points. File also not just the ship damage but also the destruction of the corrals and start collecting rent from the island they stole. Finally, Philippines build ships immediately which they should priorities building war ship and not useless boat that can not defend the territory. This is a matter of top national security. The weak will always be bullied. Get stronger by upgrading better military ship.
Mag file na uli sa arbitral court ng panigong case para s sabina shoal dahil 140 kilometers lang ang layu sa Palawan.mag change tactic na ang AFP at wag masyadong malambot sa china at armasan narin nv 76 mm naval cannon ang dalawang bagong PCG.
The philipines should accept the help of the USA. It's easy for China to bully small Philipines fishermen vesels, but against the US Navy, they will run away with their tails inbetween their legs.
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
Dapat ang Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Philippines, Indonesia, Timor Leste, New Guinea, New Zealand, Brunei, Malaysia, Myanmar, Thailand at Vietnam magkaisang magtatag ng Joint Maritime Defense Treaty para panlaban sa malupit na CCP-PLA.
@@c.c.1207 Don't count the chickens before they're hatched. NMC's Alexander Lopez said there is a need to review the Mutual Defense Treaty. Be sure to let us know when the MDT is revised.
China’s covert strategy to dominate a key waterway in the Indo-Pacific region has become an urgent international issue. The Philippines is now frequently hosting naval visits from other countries, demonstrating support for UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea).
Kasohan si gen brawner ng anti-graft & corrupt practice R.A 3019 for refusing to the U.S offer to escort to bring food & water to the government soldiers technically killing them from deprivation of basic neccessities from fear of the chinese coast guards. Grave abuse of discretion as a gov’t official to feed gov’t troops & officers deployed to guard sabina shoal and ayungin shoal.
Amor Propio! If it's all about that we will lose all of our EEZ in WPS. If the government doesn't want to ask favor not just yet, here's an alternate solution that I'd like to suggest--- In civil aviation, we got WET LEASE. Vessels changes will be just Registration Number and Flag. Crew, operation and maintenance will be the responsibility of the Lessor Government, while Philippines will pay a monthly very high rent per vessel. Amor Propio? I don't think we can afford that, really.
of course Philippines will continue to refuse ....no one died yet.....until such time we lost all our coastguard vessel...we lost all our navy... maybe our govt.will ponder whether we need US help....
I am sorry Atty. Carpio but I don't agree with your idea Sir. A US navy warship escorting a PCG vessel en route to its post in the WPS is an act of levelling up a civilian mission of the PCG to a military level because of the presence of a US warship thus escalating the current situation to possibly initiate a pre-mature war for PH as it is yet unprepared. One thing sure is the Philippines and its allies will not make a first strike policy to drive China outside of WPS. Despite the Mutual Defense treaty between US and PH, the US can only be partially involved as the US congress is yet to determine the country's position through its legal and political processes before giving the green light to an all-out-war with China. It will always be China to start a war and it can happen with your idea Sir. Let's consider for a lesson the destruction and great loss of lives that happens in Ukraine being partially supported by its allies. I don't want that for PH. Moreover, history of nations has taught us that war is concluded by who captures the mainland. China wants to take all of Taiwan and why not Luzon and Visayas if it can take WPS? In a consensus with allies, a battle plan to counter China's aggression creates the opportunity to analyze what type of military hardware PH needs for the PCG, AFP, PNP and civilians should acquire. The US plays the main role when it comes to deterrence but not in a way of escorting a PCG vessel to its post.
Yan ang tama...hindi puro pride
Agree. Pride will not help ; especially, some of this official who just do talking points. File also not just the ship damage but also the destruction of the corrals and start collecting rent from the island they stole.
Finally, Philippines build ships immediately which they should priorities building war ship and not useless boat that can not defend the territory. This is a matter of top national security. The weak will always be bullied. Get stronger by upgrading better military ship.
Mag file na uli sa arbitral court ng panigong case para s sabina shoal dahil 140 kilometers lang ang layu sa Palawan.mag change tactic na ang AFP at wag masyadong malambot sa china at armasan narin nv 76 mm naval cannon ang dalawang bagong PCG.
The philipines should accept the help of the USA. It's easy for China to bully small Philipines fishermen vesels, but against the US Navy, they will run away with their tails inbetween their legs.
ACCEPT the US OFFERS
Kailangan talaga natin ng tulong sa U.S. para hindi mawala ang ating karapatan sa west Philippine sea.
KAILANGAN daw humingi Muna NG permiso k senator boy sili..
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea:
- parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭,
- the rest of it is the international water,
- no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
I agree to Sir Carpio opinyon regarding an assistance from the US and other Allied forces. That would be the last resort.
Dapat nating i encourage mga kapitbahay na bumuo ng ASEAN Defence Treaty+ USA
Dapat ang Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Philippines, Indonesia, Timor Leste, New Guinea, New Zealand, Brunei, Malaysia, Myanmar, Thailand at Vietnam magkaisang magtatag ng Joint Maritime Defense Treaty para panlaban sa malupit na CCP-PLA.
Our AFP Prioritize PRIDE than Country Territorial Interest
Tama po Yan sir tanggapin na Ang offer na escort Ng U.S sa WPS ndi nman natin kayang mag Isa laban sa CHINA Marami clang gamit
Correct, ang tulong ng america
I don't understand why the PH gov don't act about these suggestion by the people who fought the arbitral ruling
We should also allow placement of more US weapons in Philippines.
Mataas Kasi pride ng Pinoy kahit Hindi na Kay Hindi parin magpapatulong sa mga kumakampe na mga bansa kahit bogbogna pride parin eeral
ang ibang nag cocoment dito ay parang Chinese SPY too..halata yan..he does not using his analogy...
There is no worry about the MDT to invoke because the UN should have had Armed Forces to enforce the UNCLOS. Just my opinion .
i salute u sir associate justice carpio...
ang talino ng news caster...
Its not pride.. its negotiation
naku...sir carpio...magagalit sa u c senator boy palpak...
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Carpio must remember this by heart - “the MDT commitments do not apply in event of attack on Spratlys”.
Wrong. As of now MDT has broadened definition.
But it does cover the EEZ of the Philippines
@@c.c.1207 Don't count the chickens before they're hatched.
NMC's Alexander Lopez said there is a need to review the Mutual Defense Treaty. Be sure to let us know when the MDT is revised.
@@wangchung7599 kindly check about "Fact Sheet: U. S. - Philippines bilateral defense guidelines".
I'm starting to doubt about our AFP, Are they really ready? are they just saying that they are ready to protect this country?
China’s covert strategy to dominate a key waterway in the Indo-Pacific region has become an urgent international issue. The Philippines is now frequently hosting naval visits from other countries, demonstrating support for UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea).
Paano na accept Ang tulong ng US eh ayaw ni Gen Brawner gusto nya sya Lang.
Dapat noon pa yang suggestion na yan,pinalala nio pa.
Kasohan si gen brawner ng anti-graft & corrupt practice R.A 3019 for refusing to the U.S offer to escort to bring food & water to the government soldiers technically killing them from deprivation of basic neccessities from fear of the chinese coast guards. Grave abuse of discretion as a gov’t official to feed gov’t troops & officers deployed to guard sabina shoal and ayungin shoal.
Amor Propio! If it's all about that we will lose all of our EEZ in WPS. If the government doesn't want to ask favor not just yet, here's an alternate solution that I'd like to suggest--- In civil aviation, we got WET LEASE. Vessels changes will be just Registration Number and Flag. Crew, operation and maintenance will be the responsibility of the Lessor Government, while Philippines will pay a monthly very high rent per vessel. Amor Propio? I don't think we can afford that, really.
It’s not only time but over due that you should ask Us to escort your coast guards that were obviously castrated men !
of course Philippines will continue to refuse ....no one died yet.....until such time we lost all our coastguard vessel...we lost all our navy... maybe our govt.will ponder whether we need US help....
Kasalanan ng tsina nanira siya ng barko natin ngayon mapipilitan tayo humingi ng tulong!
KAYABANGAN NA YATA NG DALAWA MY COUNTRYMEN
I am sorry Atty. Carpio but I don't agree with your idea Sir. A US navy warship escorting a PCG vessel en route to its post in the WPS is an act of levelling up a civilian mission of the PCG to a military level because of the presence of a US warship thus escalating the current situation to possibly initiate a pre-mature war for PH as it is yet unprepared. One thing sure is the Philippines and its allies will not make a first strike policy to drive China outside of WPS. Despite the Mutual Defense treaty between US and PH, the US can only be partially involved as the US congress is yet to determine the country's position through its legal and political processes before giving the green light to an all-out-war with China. It will always be China to start a war and it can happen with your idea Sir. Let's consider for a lesson the destruction and great loss of lives that happens in Ukraine being partially supported by its allies. I don't want that for PH. Moreover, history of nations has taught us that war is concluded by who captures the mainland. China wants to take all of Taiwan and why not Luzon and Visayas if it can take WPS? In a consensus with allies, a battle plan to counter China's aggression creates the opportunity to analyze what type of military hardware PH needs for the PCG, AFP, PNP and civilians should acquire. The US plays the main role when it comes to deterrence but not in a way of escorting a PCG vessel to its post.
How do you know that? Your analogy will makes Pilipinos in bien...I am not in favor from you...
Ukraine position is different from Philippines...
Bakit palagi nalang hingi tulong sa US..
Ayaw ni brawner Yan!!
maPride pa kc ang Pilipino. nag ooffer na ng tulong ang US. sinisira na nga ung mga barko ntin kakabangga eh. ewan ko sanyu.
Change your tactic old furt! Declaring war is the last option , you have your MDT with US you have the upper hand ,what are you afraid of??