Yup, except the left is STILL infected with tds and hung up on trump and Elon. At least the right wing has moved onto actual debates and discussions. They’re literally forcing the centrists over to the right
@@FranklinSalazar-u2s all middle class are in top 20. 150k after tax for family doesn’t do much now days specially in big cities unless you own house which is almost impossible.
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Looks like by Americans you understand only White Anglo Sexon Whites. Apart from the Native Americans all Americans are immegrants.
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Agree. But American citizens have to be brought up in terms of education. Culture also means morality and value systems. No need to teach religion in schools but one could have a subject called moral science. Where good values are taught through stories. The education system is lacking in all these aspects.
There’s only one way to test this theory. Require that foreign workers be paid as much as you’d have paid an American, and protect them from deportation. Then, we’ll find out whether they were hired for their skills or hired to be indentured servants.
It is already required but companies skirt it. There is no shortage of workers and H1b also serves to provide more labor which in the long term does reduce salaries, it is a simple surply and demand issue. The problem is that these H1b types prefer to hire their own hence the more we allow them in the more we push out Americans; it is not a level playing field. Anyone who goes to grad school with them can tell you that the playing field is uneven from the jump
@@benji-t7v how can h1bs hire their own? can you explain? It has to be company policy to sponsor an h1b visa. you do realize that for tech jobs, one has to get through 6-7 rounds of interviews. how can one single h1b make a hiring decision unless other 6 also say ‘Yes’?
@@siddave549 they get promoted into roles with hiring capabilities, or sometimes are hired directly into those roles. then they hire other h1bs even more aggressively than before.
The fact that you did not know already that this is a requirement set already to began with just goes to show how low iq you are and why elite needs more expats to compensate for you.
It's cheap labour. My Indian neighbours here in Ireland lost their jobs once our government agreed to issue thousands of visas. They're working for next to nothing. They can't get permanent jobs & because theres so many arriving, they're driving rents through the roof. Local businesses won't hire them now. Once big groups move into an area driving up rents, people stop spending €€ & businesses close. Even our left wing politicians, like 🇨🇦, have called for an end to Indian visa's & mass deportations. It's exploitation, plain & simple.
I’m from Canada and same thing happened here . Canada accepted so many now they’re driving down wages for lower wage jobs, directly impacting the unemployment rate for folks between 16-22 because they’re taking all the low wage jobs youths normally do as their first time jobs..and they also drove up rents
Folks from Ireland and Canada, you have no idea of what’s going on in US and what is H1B program that US congress created to serve its national interest. Keep your racist view to yourself.
@@atix50 my parents moved into a almost rural area outside of Atlanta some years ago. Of course all whites there. I think they had the first Indian neighbors lol. They must have brought all their relatives over, because that whole area outside of Atlanta now, is filled with Indians and maybe Pakistanis. You feel like you're walking around a foreign country when you go to the mall or something. And this is rural Atlanta, where like the KKK used to live lol. So I can imagine what's happening in other areas around the country.
@@atix50 that's a big fat lie. Immigration is great for landlords because immigrants are far richer than the poor working class conservatives and immigrants pay more taxes to subsidise the poor uneducated conservative's social security costs. To achieve a onservative society Trump's cronies will only accept rich people and kick out poor Americans for being a drag on the economy and an anchor to corporate productivity. For companies, it is better for them to employ cheaper and smarter people than the trump supporter talent pool.
Jack Ma advocated for a Change in culture in China a few years back to succeed in the 21st century. It was called the 996 movement - 9am-to-9pm/6 days a week(72 hr). In India, tech leader Narayan Murthy has also advocated for a 70hr work week as the path to growth and innovation in India. Vivek Ramaswamy is doing the same thing in his long tirade against US culture and receiving the same response like Jack and Murthy got in their countries.
@@iaf010 the problem is no one wants that kind of culture. I worked my share of 6am to 12am work culture. But I want to be the one who controls MY schedule to do it. I WILL NOT tolerate anyone trying to influence others to do what I did. The only thing I agree with Ramaswamy is that the often movie depicted jock americana culture is trash., but that's just in the movies. Real Americans can work as hard and as smart when the need arises, but there is no need to celebrate that because we work hard so we don't have to in the future. Thats why conservatives always get this wrong
He uh... steals credit from his employees... and uh... he made a company that makes its money off of fees from transactions... and uh.. Oh wait, he isn't smart.
There is more than enough talent in the US to fill the tech space. With the mass layoffs in tech, Elon wants cheap labor while Ramaswamy wants Indian workers here to help his people out!
@@Jase9 That’s just an assumption. Baby boomers were smart and hard working. Since then the youth aren’t that good. Also you need to count the number of heads. It’s not just people within USA, but the people working remotely from several countries is 15 times larger than H1b holders. If you kick them out, they can easily go back to their own country and work from there. Kick out all the companies in the USA who are using Foreign workers and then you will not have any fortune company left behind.
@@bsj4790 You must be out of touch with reality, and are clearly out of your mind! Anyone with any type of sense can see what Elon and Ramaswamy wants! I know you want to reap the benefits of entering this country with your H-1B, Nope! America First!
Does he not know the success of the American culture around the world'? All that Jazz, Blues, Rock, Pop, HipHop, Films, fashion, sports, and T V culture when America could have given the world the fawning clawing climber culture of the automaton bore instead. Just think if what that could've been like?
He’s trying to confuse people. Teen American culture is mediocre and fabricated by Hollywood writers that never liked academia or STEM, which then causes problems in some adults who mistakenly thought they were too cool for school. Real American culture on the other hand is innovative and creative.
@@rickm6076 Dude, get your numbers straight. It’s not millions., it’s barely 100,000. India produces 2.2 million engineers each year. The vast majority stay in India. You guys keep this shit up and you will have not just China but India also to compete with in the next 15 years.
@@yogeshkmrful The Europeans did not attempt to deny the obvious unlike the Indians. In addition, the Europeans sacrificed their lives in wars for freedom unlike the Indians who just want to profit economically.
@@cutehumor President Musk will likely reach trillionaire status by the time he and Trump finish screwing Americans. Again, this is who you voted for. 😅
Rama Swamy parents ran away from Olympiad celebrations from india….now Rama Swamy criticizes prom queen celebrations?? Why would Ramaswamy not go back india and celebrate more Olympiad? And who cooks at restaurants, who serves , who build building and bridges if we only give jobs to math Olympiads ? USA culture not build by people like Ramaswamy. But this guy want to destroy.
@@stazorm1 If H1b visa holders are called cheap labour then Indian immigrants to Canada are much much lower quality. People who can’t make it to US opt for Canada. 😂. Don’t even compare.
If Indian culture was better than American work ethic culture, then they would have built India into a superpower and not look for work outside of India. These two guys, Vivek and Elon, are weird.
You kinda mistake culture with opportunity. Culture is definitely different, not one is better than the other. But opportunity is better in the states based on pay grade etc
@@ilwindcunha3296 Create your own damn Opportunities! Just like Vivek told American Blacks. Stop blaming others. Your culture is older than America's. Americans beat this shit out of the British. Why could you not with 800 billion people. You were too busy worshiping cows.
Instead of being argumentive you are being derogatory. It's been almost 250 years since usa got independence but has been only 75 since India did! I know it's not the best but It's one of the fastest growing economy. I am against immigration just like you guys because we don't want brain drain....
Not just H1B visa from India also 5 million illegal migrants from India will be given greencard cause they have close connections with both the parties and majority are backed by Indian leader who is backed with extremist RSS and have close connections with all western politicians, they and AIPAC have common interest and brought most of the politicians. Immigration have certain limit and quota, somehow that limit exceeded tens and thousands of times specifically from one country that is India
@@amols101 an average trump supporter. don't expect any credibility from them. when the leader himself makes imaginary claims about migrants eating cats and dogs, its too much to expect any better from his supporters
In my 36 year career as a software developer in the US I had to train employees from foreign countries to take my job back to those foreign countries over and over the last 20 years of my career. My boss even had the audacity to order me to write the letter to request the visa for Chinese workers to come to the US and then have me train them to take my job. It was an endless series of musical chairs for 20 years for my job to be moved out of the US and I would get another job inside the company until finally they moved my job to Romania and forced me into early retirement.
Please investigate and do a segment on VISA (the credit card company). They laid off and are laying of thousands of IT staff in favor of outsourcing those jobs to India. And as it is more than 80% of those jobs in US are filled already by workers from India who came here on H1b. So what are we Americans supposed to do and go?
There should be a tax on every company and billionaire to groom and hire local talent with a pre defined ratio for revenue/ net worth gain, and every visa based hire.
They didn't outsource to india but indians who would have been working for india if you guys wouldn't have elected billionaires. We don't want brain drain and you don't want immigrants, I think we have a common ground
Our whole country was sold to Indians and wealthy chinese immigtrants. My kids can never own a home now or start a family. Will Pierre help fix it? No he'll bring in more for his corporate backers.
H1B is for mid skill labor at best. No GPA requirement, no advanced degree requirement, no min years experience requirement. Also, their culture evidently isn't so great because it produced a place they run from.
@@yogeshkmrful There is no shortage of Americans getting Bachelor's or Master's. We don't need to import people so our oligarchs can maximize their profits. Also why are the majority of h1b visa recipients Indian? Why not Germans or Swedes? Is it because, like Americans, Germans and Swedes would want higher pay?
strategy is simple, step 1 come in as a cheap and good worker step 2 bring in more friends and family to work together and lastly step 3 outsource the work to their motherland with more friends and family
@@bobbytay167 wow, if it was so simple why does it take more 15 years to get permanent residency in the US for Indians when it barely takes at most 3 years for every other country. You guys are not even interested in understanding the issue before exhibiting your bias.
Sore loser. Even Indian students doing their Masters in US in highly specialised majors are issued H1B only. Its not cheap labour they earn 65 to 75k per year out of university.
I'm from Kenya who works for Microsoft remotely. I get paid $40k per year, which is not much in the US, but since I'm in Kenya, that's a lot of money, makes me top 1% earner, there are many Africans who also work for Google and Microsoft remotely. It's cheap labor. Sorry, Americans.
, no, you're just a paid information terrorist who supports a rapist's's party. The scamservative scampreneur heritage mafia is the foundation of all America's problems
@@Artus1845-gh9pd no they want cheap labor, and it's going to end in a disaster because most aren't all that smart, they want slaves with basic coding skills, but these are the people who are supposed to become management and innovators some day, you aren't getting that from a 90 IQ coder
@Artus1845-gh9pd , no, it's what you call self interest, competition, and entrepreneurship. Others call it expropriation, colonialism, or exploitation .
Why not make America a socialist. Capitalism isn't working, I guess. Canadian asked a similar question as you did. We got Trudeau, and look what happened to us. Please learn from us
In a capitalist country/society there are open markets and you should compete with anyone including immigrants, why should a rich person prefer you? When he can hire someone else for less pay? If you want handouts from the govt because you were born in a certain country or belong to a certain race then move to a socialist one!@@libtardh8er
As an IT manager we don’t like this either. Unfortunately we need to tow the corporate line in order to keep our own jobs. How do we fix this on a national level? This must be addressed and we need to hold these large corporations responsible. This is something Trump will never do I fear.
Foreigners replacing American workers resonates across party lines. It’s been something going on for years now and American IT workers are tired of it. IT is the new sweatshop.
Low skilled migrants have been replacing American workers and suppressing wages for decades now without anyone caring. But now that it’s people in the middle class being replaced everyone is suddenly freaking out 😂 The lack of class consciousness and solidarity is the problem in this country
American students are getting degrees in psychology and liberal arts. Foreign students are getting degrees in engineering and comp science. Guess who got a better chance at high paying jobs?
@@yogeshkmrful i think the foreign students would love those degrees too, just as much as our guys love the tech stuff. We have more than enuf smart people here & should be putting America first in every way we can right now. There’s goin to be a snapping point.
Yep, Millions of Chinese and Indians and others heading to the US for a better life because their culture is so great bahaha. That makes a lot of sense. Vivek single-handedly disproves meritocracy.
@@bestvideos35 You have to understand the issue a little deeper. If you talk to any well informed H1b visa holder for India they will be able to tell you exactly where the problems lie. The H1b visa itself doesn’t create the problem. The big 7 tech giants don’t hire H1b for lower pay., it usually the consulting companies that pay them lower because they take part of the pay as their comission. And the reason the people are stuck with these consultancies is also not because of the H1b visa itself but the artificially imposed country cap on Green Cards (permanent residency). It’s a crappy system no one wants to change (both Republicans and Democrats) but just talk about once every 4 year cycle.
I am an Indian and I don’t agree with Vivek’s comment of American culture. American’s are the most hardworking people on earth. Americans are friendly, polite and genuine people. Vivek’s comment doesn’t make any sense. It is a class and system issue that some Americans are struggling to get a master degree. College education is affordable to particular class in the society. Also, as an Indian I love that Americans respect all jobs and views dignity in all class of workers. American culture is the best in the world. That’s the reason people come to this land. God bless America. 🇺🇸
We need more H1B’s in fields like medicine where there are shortages (I.e. doctors and nurses). There are not enough US medical school or nursing school graduates to meet the growing demand for healtjcare. America is an aging society with falling birth rates. We need more young immigrants for future growth. Might as well get the best and brightest where there are deficits in fields like medicine.
If I was a recent university graduate and applied at one of these tech companies and didn't get hired, I would investigate if there are any H-1B visa employees. If so, I'd sue the FCK out of that company for unfair hiring practices.
3 дня назад+2
The get away with it all the time and nothing can be done about it.
There's a legal case now that Musk, Vivek and Trump publicly acknowledged they support H1B visas. American workers should be prioritized before foreigners.
Fascism is the marriage between the state and corporation coupled with extreme "nationalism" , racism and militarism . In america, profits preceeds everything.
Well, I am against pompus foreigners. I am hateful of overly familiar ones thinking they can tell old families what to do. Show respect or rip up your citizenship. He basically admited to not really being American....which is honest, I have no problem with it, but the disrespect is infuriating.
I have worked with many indians that have working visas and they don’t work harder than us. We show up earlier and always got to fix what they do wrong. I have been in the manufacturing industry for the last 8 years i have seen this with my own eyes. Not only that sometimes they lie on their resumes or they’re not willing to do some dirty jobs. Trust me they are not smarter or work harder than us although vivek thinks the opposite.
My friend knew some Americans in past who migrated to India. They all worked in same organization. They don't know anything about Indian Culture or our language. My friend used to say they don't anything about work, but yet they were treated better than my friend just because they were good in speaking English. My friend said that he was sad, that English is a parameter on which people are judged nowadays. Not on our skill. Also he told me that they made fun of him his accent. Although it might be joke. But it creates sense of inferiority complex. So what your point is?? Our personal experiences does not reflect the reality in broader aspect. I can judge every American on basis of this. But I will not, again my above statements stand.
My bachelors in biology didnt get me the type of job I wanted so I went back and got another 80k in debt to become a software engineer. I work hard and continually learn new skills gaining new certifications even decades into my field. They don't like the idea of treating highly skilled labor as highly skilled labor. They think they earned their spots but those of us studying non stop for decades on our own time in addition to our 9-5 act entitled rather than accomplished...? Im done with Vivek if this is what he's pushing for.
Conservative leading folks have been saying this for a while. I don't know why they so mad.. they've been saying this about black people, Immigrants Americans for years. I don't know what they are complaining about now.
We have over 5 million here already, elon just wants foreign Indians that don't know they will be forced to work horrible hours for shit pay. Elon is unwilling to cultivate from the 5 million here, he wants the benefit that another foreign company spent the time already to train those individuals
The main problem is not the H1b visas, it is the H2v visas. That is the one that lets them have all the construction jobs, hotel jobs, 7-11 jobs etc. And it a lie that their pay is so low. It is lower than regular but not that much. It is really about replacing Americans.
Both cultures are great in their own way. The bad side if Anericans is to easily trying to rxplot vulnerability in the name if H1b. The vad side of India is to try and Anerica all the tome because the oerception in India is tjay Americans are stupid rich people and can be fooled and rextorted easily.
@@keitha.1888 depends on which aspect, in India there are fewer opportunities, hence working hard is a must to secure a good life. This is why Indian parents focus more on academics then American parents.
@@keitha.1888 There is no comparison at all. India and Indian culture existed 5000 years before Christ was born. America was unknown even to the Europeans untill 1492. India did not go looking for America. Europen whites went looking for the sea route to India and by mistake Columbus discovered North America. Then they all rushed to this newly "discovered" land. And what did the whites do here? Killed all the natives and grabbed their lands. They erased a complete race from the face of the planet. What did the white Christian Europeans do in Africa. Captured Africans by force and then sold them like animals. When White Christians Portuguese landed in India what did they do similar things. The GDP of India was 27% of the world GDP when British reached India. By the time they left, India was the poorest country in the world. Brits looted equivalent of 450 trillion dollars from India. What happened in America? The white Christians fought among themselves for supermecy. The Brits fought with French for seven years till they got control of the 13 colonies. White Christians kept killings Natives, enslaving blacks and killing each other. Even massacred each otjer. Then again the the same white Christians fought against British White Christians and drive them out. With the treaty of Paris, America was born. On the contrary, India got its independance in a non violent struggle in 1947. By the time Brits left India, it had been divided India into Afghanistan, Burma, Pakistan and Bangladesh. When millions of Indians were dying of hunger, Churchill was sending food grains from India to the United Forces. More Indians died during British rule than Jews in Nazi Germany. Even then Indian soilders shoulder to shoulder with the United Forces. From the richest Nation on Earth where Vasco Da Gama wanted to reach Columbus wanted to reach became the country of poor dying of hunger. Thanks to the White Christians - the Brits. In 1947 India got independance and in 75 years they are the worlds fourt largest economy and this year it would become world third largest economy. For Indians, America is a role model. America is not even 250 years old but their achievements are tremendous. India does not even dream of competing with America. Forget America, even China's Economy is six times bigger than India. Indians don't live under any falce notion. They are simple, hardworking and law abiding people. They have been traders, businessmen, skilled workers and never limited themselves to their own lands. For them World is a Family. History is witness that all the places from where India's were removed, the country hit the dust. It could be Afghanistan, Pakistan, Burma, Uganda, Zimbabwe are some example. If troubled, Indians would not fight back, they will not creat civil unrest, they would simply go. Indians don't even make 1.5% of the American Population but they pay 6-7% of the total income tax. They are highly qualified and very smart people. If they leave it would be a great loss to America. No they are not cheap labour, they are innovative thinkers. Don't forget that the number system we use today was invented by Indians.
This is brilliant: even a FoxNews anchorwoman can clearly see that these corporations aren't seeking the brightest and best around the world, but rather are lowering wages! The reason corporations look overseas for workers is to PAY LESS for labor. This is about cheaper labor reserves, and has absolutely nothing to do with Asians being smarter or having a better work ethic. Vivek Ramiswamy is a Brahmin, a privileged caste Indian who was born on a silver platter, and he's going to judge our culture? What a joke! Frankly, I'm sick of hearing about how "lazy" American workers are. It just isn't true. The good news is, even the far-Right is sick of this corporate BS and are pushing back. I welcome them in this fight.
To be honest, I don't often agree with Vivek Ramaswamy or Elon Musk, but they are not wrong. Based on my upbringing from the beautiful continent of Africa, we place a much higher emphasis mathematical and scientific education than Those in North America because University education in STEM is often seen as a sure means of success. Africans and Asians both believe that.
@@carah4958 sure you are correct, no doubt about it. However, eventually, the tools that Engineers build will be doing the vast majority of work for the occupations you mentioned.
Thank God I worked in IT since when it was really good. After 2010, I felt I am living in India inside usa 😅. I'm glad I only have few years before I retire. I feel sorry for the new coming IT generation. They have nothing promising left. Not only H1B is corrupt but also corporations are outsourcing everything to India. Total bleeding
I work in a company in India. Im Indian living in India. My duty time is about 13 hours and travel time 3 hours up and down. Legally it's only 8 hours working time but unless we do overtime we will be kicked out. Im getting a monthly salary about 250 USD dollars. Im a reasonably educated person. Hard work doesn't automatically translate to better life in India. People who works as street vendors, taxi drivers works more than me but their wages are less than mine. Indians will go to any nation for better wages. There is no point in complaining. Indians are doing this out of certain desperation. The only way you can stop indians is through Government.
India mostly had a Trudeau kind of government since it's Independence in 1947... Their current government (from 2014) has done wonders in Uplifting the country like you won't believe! Now it's only a matter of time when it's back to it's full potential 🤷
Patrick Bet-David, multi-millionaire, social media influencer, and CEO of Valutainment LLC recently posted a compelling video arguing for bringing in STEM geniuses. However, many of the commenters noted his company currently has a job posting for a graphic designer - through the H1B visa program! Graphic design is an arts degree, not a STEM degree. I think the job is paying $42K -in the Ft. Lauderdale or Miami area. Notable are the many comments from people who report that the jobs being filled by visa holders are NOT ones that only STEM geniuses can fill. I’ve heard similar from a few programmer friends. The work visa program is being abused, and American workers are paying the price. And Musk wants to further loosen regulations.
@ it is illegal for anyone on a student or h1b visa to do that. They will be deported immediately. You guys are really coming up with wild stories now.
Alternatively, instead of looking for a job you can graduate from college with an idea, zero business competency, HR experience, or even the basics balancing a checkbook and build it into one of the largest companies in the world. Yeah right. All these folks (tech bros) had their hands held by 'mentors' with piles cash. They were chosen.
As a US immigration attorney, I can tell you this is some really clueless commentary. The H1B visa has a procedure called a prevailing wage determination to make sure the foreign worker isn't depressing US wages. The prevailing wage determination is often higher than what a US worker would be paid! Then there is the EB2 NIW program when there is a shortage of an occupation such as nurses or pilots, which Ana seems to think is what the H1B visa program is for. There is only 65,000 H1B visas available worldwide and they are extremely difficult to get. Foreign workers can only stay for a maximum of 6 years total on a H1B visa, so there is that too. Clue up Young Dorks!
Democrats have no problem with slavery - they’re the party of slavery during this country’s darkest hours, and push for slavery today with bailouts, wars, and student loan forgiveness.
I have experienced outsourcing twice and it always involves H1B1 holders because it is the only way to save money because the long term American labor is always better than the Indian labor on a 1 to 1 basis. They are more experienced and hold the institutional knowledge. It is a total scam and a disgrace.
Actually Vivek …FYI America produces the best engineers in the world…because America has the best engineering schools in the world….I suggest you visit the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Boston and seat in the math and science lectures …and try to solve the “problem sets” that the American engineers have to solve there….to even have the chance to pass the courses…Another fantastic American engineering schools are: California Institute of Technology in Pasadena, Stanford University, University of California at Berkeley, Georgia Institute of Technology, School of Engineering at University of Washington, Seattle, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, Columbia University….etc etc and the list goes on and on..
@ I am talking about American educated engineers…American PhDs foreign or not are a different class of professionals that in many cases go to do high level scientific research at American Institutions and abroad…
you are just ignorant. here American culture didn't mean culture as entirety but culture of not celebrating student who achieve something big such as winning math Olympiad.
He is bringing the Indian Caste system to the USA LOL Who they can marry Who they can be close friends with What jobs they can do Their access to wealth, power, and privilege MIGA LOL
@shubham40901 you can't leave your house, come to my house because it's better and then after a while, start bringing all your relatives to my house so as to run my house "better"! Dude, stay in your house (India) and make it great, if you can! My house, my rules
@@bang8534 your great grand parents came to some others house, slayed them and stayed which is why you are here calling this your home. So don't preach to us about houses.
@Sai-gv6sk that's where you get it wrong with your whitewashed version of "history". Many of us were here before anybody, though some were forcefully brought over later. So, dude, this is my house and my point still stands. My house, my rules. You don't like them, back to India
Get out of ur echo chamber and take a moment to listen fully to what V & E are saying. That is precisely why they are calling for a complete overhaul and reform to the h1b visa system so that it no longer can be taken advantage of and instead bring in only those top-tier candidates that qualify.
Being an Indian, I agree with you. H1 B visa is to replace American with cheaper Indian slaves who can work longer hours and weekends so that these business man can enjoy profits. Why can’t they simply list down a solid criteria for taking best in class people 1) have an American elite entrance exam 2) pay like executives 3) make sure they leave on time. 4) no policy to allow dependent to settle. That’s it. So that it also help the other countries to keep their people within their home country
Black Americans tried to tell you lol. Y'all are the new slave and you don't even know it. You think it's a flex that wyt say you work hard while you're making them rich.
Exactly 😊😊I agree definitely 💯. Tech CEOs want cheap labor (foreign workers who are willing to work 60-80 hrs/week and without good benefits,)Honestly I don’t trust $9.00/ hr foreign software engineers whom work for Boeing . What happened to Boeing 373 Max ???😂😂😂😂. According to reports , the software for Boeing 737 Max was primarily developed by Boeing engineers,but parts of the code particularly related to the companies like HCL Technologies and Cyient ,where Indian engineers were reportedly paid as low as $9.00/hr. It’s total b.s. 😂😂😂😂
Actually he wanted good for Americans, he did so speaking some strong truths, but it is going undigested and unacceptable to a lot. The quality of being able to self critical is the 1st part for any progress. I believe his intentions to re-direct priorities. Which of the American leaders takes such stand the way he did. Rather they worry on vote bank. I think he knowing that it won't go right he spoke it. Imagine the positive effect that America will change its education system towards producing more engineers as well.
Didn't we see this before? About 40 years ago, didn't we see Japanese and Vietnamese entrepreneurs do informercials and say directly to Americans that we're fat and lazy? Shortly after that, isn't that about when we saw good manufacturing jobs leave the country for the sake of cheaper and more obedient labor? I get that capitalism has always required an underclass of laborers willing to do shittier and shittier jobs for less pay and less protection, but at some point we fat and lazy Americans need to stop listening to the people at the top of the pyramid who benefit the most and lose the least amount of their lifetimes doing menial tasks, and start listening to those who actually do the work and fight for those who do the work! The WORST thing the Democratic Party ever did was rig their last three primaries merely for the sake of electability, because even if Bernie Sanders lost the election as the Dem's nominee, at least the party would have dug itself in as THE party for the working class, and the Republican billionaires who now run this country would be seen as the fascists they truly are. Vivek would have been laughed out of the country for saying the things his Asian predecessors said 40 years ago!
We are all worried about immigrants takimg good payimg jobs away from Americans when we should be worried about AI and Robotocs replacing us in the work force.
This is a no win situation for America. Companies hiring H1B visa workers will close in America and take it off shore or outsource activities to bring back profit for themselves. Only other countries will benefit with this move unless US lawmakers change regulations.
It's quite hilarious that Trump and Musk joked about laying off 30k workers because they wanted a union which is extremely alarming. This is the norm for my country, slavery.
There is no shortage of tech talent in America anymore. There are hundreds of thousands of tech workers who have been laid off in recent years, both native and foreign. Most are finding it very hard to get jobs in this economy
Not $9.00/ hr foreign engineers. Only American engineers can’t find Jobs because Tech CEOs only want to hire $9.00/hr engineers 😂😂😂😂 as low as possible 😂😂😂😂Fuc@ you Elon Mao 😂😂😂😂😂
Right vs left is not cutting it anymore. The ultimate battle of top 1% vs everyone else is becoming clearer each days.
@@MdSaifurRahmansifting the top 20% is closer to the mark.
Yup, except the left is STILL infected with tds and hung up on trump and Elon. At least the right wing has moved onto actual debates and discussions. They’re literally forcing the centrists over to the right
@@FranklinSalazar-u2s all middle class are in top 20. 150k after tax for family doesn’t do much now days specially in big cities unless you own house which is almost impossible.
90% of Americans only own 30% of the wealth. 3% of wealth for bottom 50% Americans.
Saifur rahman 😂
America first means American citizens first, not American multinational corporations first.
America is a corporation
@@yogeshkmrful so America is not a country?
@@christiansgrignoli3351 so American multinational are not American?
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Looks like by Americans you understand only White Anglo Sexon Whites. Apart from the Native Americans all Americans are immegrants.
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Agree. But American citizens have to be brought up in terms of education. Culture also means morality and value systems. No need to teach religion in schools but one could have a subject called moral science. Where good values are taught through stories. The education system is lacking in all these aspects.
Vivek let out what he really feels about America; resentful
Something tells me that Elon musk and Vivek don't celebrate 4th of July .🤔
@@elizandropedraza1286 why should they not? At least Vivek is a born American
Take it from me, most of the H-1B visa immigrants don't have experience as made to believe. It's all about cheap labor.
There’s only one way to test this theory.
Require that foreign workers be paid as much as you’d have paid an American, and protect them from deportation.
Then, we’ll find out whether they were hired for their skills or hired to be indentured servants.
It is already required but companies skirt it. There is no shortage of workers and H1b also serves to provide more labor which in the long term does reduce salaries, it is a simple surply and demand issue. The problem is that these H1b types prefer to hire their own hence the more we allow them in the more we push out Americans; it is not a level playing field. Anyone who goes to grad school with them can tell you that the playing field is uneven from the jump
To be fair, Campos really gets me going if you know what I mean 🚀🥴
@@benji-t7v how can h1bs hire their own? can you explain? It has to be company policy to sponsor an h1b visa. you do realize that for tech jobs, one has to get through 6-7 rounds of interviews. how can one single h1b make a hiring decision unless other 6 also say ‘Yes’?
@@siddave549 they get promoted into roles with hiring capabilities, or sometimes are hired directly into those roles. then they hire other h1bs even more aggressively than before.
The fact that you did not know already that this is a requirement set already to began with just goes to show how low iq you are and why elite needs more expats to compensate for you.
It's cheap labour. My Indian neighbours here in Ireland lost their jobs once our government agreed to issue thousands of visas. They're working for next to nothing. They can't get permanent jobs & because theres so many arriving, they're driving rents through the roof.
Local businesses won't hire them now. Once big groups move into an area driving up rents, people stop spending €€ & businesses close. Even our left wing politicians, like 🇨🇦, have called for an end to Indian visa's & mass deportations.
It's exploitation, plain & simple.
I’m from Canada and same thing happened here . Canada accepted so many now they’re driving down wages for lower wage jobs, directly impacting the unemployment rate for folks between 16-22 because they’re taking all the low wage jobs youths normally do as their first time jobs..and they also drove up rents
@@atix50 none of that has anything to do with h1b
Folks from Ireland and Canada, you have no idea of what’s going on in US and what is H1B program that US congress created to serve its national interest. Keep your racist view to yourself.
@@atix50 my parents moved into a almost rural area outside of Atlanta some years ago. Of course all whites there. I think they had the first Indian neighbors lol. They must have brought all their relatives over, because that whole area outside of Atlanta now, is filled with Indians and maybe Pakistanis. You feel like you're walking around a foreign country when you go to the mall or something. And this is rural Atlanta, where like the KKK used to live lol. So I can imagine what's happening in other areas around the country.
@@atix50 that's a big fat lie. Immigration is great for landlords because immigrants are far richer than the poor working class conservatives and immigrants pay more taxes to subsidise the poor uneducated conservative's social security costs. To achieve a onservative society Trump's cronies will only accept rich people and kick out poor Americans for being a drag on the economy and an anchor to corporate productivity. For companies, it is better for them to employ cheaper and smarter people than the trump supporter talent pool.
Jack Ma advocated for a Change in culture in China a few years back to succeed in the 21st century. It was called the 996 movement - 9am-to-9pm/6 days a week(72 hr).
In India, tech leader Narayan Murthy has also advocated for a 70hr work week as the path to growth and innovation in India.
Vivek Ramaswamy is doing the same thing in his long tirade against US culture and receiving the same response like Jack and Murthy got in their countries.
So the rich want indentured servants, what else is new?
@@eh567 I have found influencers who want the same thing.
Vivek is a douchebag.
@iaf010 actually let China and India do that. It would definitely alter their population. Look at Japan.
@@iaf010 the problem is no one wants that kind of culture. I worked my share of 6am to 12am work culture. But I want to be the one who controls MY schedule to do it. I WILL NOT tolerate anyone trying to influence others to do what I did. The only thing I agree with Ramaswamy is that the often movie depicted jock americana culture is trash., but that's just in the movies. Real Americans can work as hard and as smart when the need arises, but there is no need to celebrate that because we work hard so we don't have to in the future. Thats why conservatives always get this wrong
Somebody has to explain to me how Elon musk is brilliant
He uh... steals credit from his employees... and uh... he made a company that makes its money off of fees from transactions... and uh.. Oh wait, he isn't smart.
😂😂😂 damn
He made Tesla without brilliant lol
There is more than enough talent in the US to fill the tech space. With the mass layoffs in tech, Elon wants cheap labor while Ramaswamy wants Indian workers here to help his people out!
@@Jase9
Obviously you seem to be on some stuff. You don't know what you are talking. Get some rest. This debate is not for druggies.
@@Jase9 That’s just an assumption. Baby boomers were smart and hard working. Since then the youth aren’t that good. Also you need to count the number of heads. It’s not just people within USA, but the people working remotely from several countries is 15 times larger than H1b holders. If you kick them out, they can easily go back to their own country and work from there. Kick out all the companies in the USA who are using Foreign workers and then you will not have any fortune company left behind.
Do you need DEI for your mediocre ass ?
@@bsj4790 You must be out of touch with reality, and are clearly out of your mind! Anyone with any type of sense can see what Elon and Ramaswamy wants! I know you want to reap the benefits of entering this country with your H-1B, Nope! America First!
Vivek comment ensures that he will never be president if he ever run for president this comment will haunt him .
ofc. truth hurts and racists tend have very fragile egos
That's a good thing though. 😊
He shouldn't be. He is loyal to India not America.
Does he not know the success of the American culture around the world'?
All that Jazz, Blues, Rock, Pop, HipHop, Films, fashion, sports, and T V culture when America could have given the world the fawning clawing climber culture of the automaton bore instead.
Just think if what that could've been like?
You know he would have never been because of his colour despite the fact that he had made that comment or not
Duh, Ramaswamy is absolutely full of more of the same ole Doublespeak as Trump and his cronies are on a regular basis! What's new?
The visa holders are so high skilled that they need to be trained 😆
@@miker1414 by the unqualified people they are replacing. make it make sense!
By us 😂😂😂 make it make sense
Don't confuse training a business process with training technical skills. Most of them come here with technical skills.
@@industrialrevolution2884 I high technical skills, you mean the three weeks bootcamp training is the technical skills?
And the fake resumes?
H1B is exploitative but importing from other countries is more exploitative.
Americans say that the wages have not gone up. This is why. 😎🇨🇦
The culture is so great? Why so many millions of them running away to come here? vivek sucks at lying haha
He’s trying to confuse people. Teen American culture is mediocre and fabricated by Hollywood writers that never liked academia or STEM, which then causes problems in some adults who mistakenly thought they were too cool for school. Real American culture on the other hand is innovative and creative.
I guess we can ask the same question to all the Europeans in 1800s, why did they all come running here ?
@@rickm6076 Dude, get your numbers straight. It’s not millions., it’s barely 100,000. India produces 2.2 million engineers each year. The vast majority stay in India. You guys keep this shit up and you will have not just China but India also to compete with in the next 15 years.
@@yogeshkmrful The Europeans did not attempt to deny the obvious unlike the Indians. In addition, the Europeans sacrificed their lives in wars for freedom unlike the Indians who just want to profit economically.
@@yogeshkmrful they escaped warfare and famine. And some cases imported warfare as well.
Greed will be the downfall of the Trump administration, and maybe the US honestly.
@imperialstrategies6065 Wrong. That's all they have been doing with no consequences. Greed will be their downfall.
Elon Musk is far from a genius
An evil genius. You see how he conned the democrats to buy his teslas?
@@cutehumor He conned the republicans to vote for him. 😂
@@jamesparker3622 thanks democrats for making Elon musk the world’s richest man
@@cutehumor President Musk will likely reach trillionaire status by the time he and Trump finish screwing Americans. Again, this is who you voted for. 😅
Rama Swamy parents ran away from Olympiad celebrations from india….now Rama Swamy criticizes prom queen celebrations?? Why would Ramaswamy not go back india and celebrate more Olympiad? And who cooks at restaurants, who serves , who build building and bridges if we only give jobs to math Olympiads ? USA culture not build by people like Ramaswamy. But this guy want to destroy.
Sure sounds like Ramaswamy has an ax to grind for not have any friends or dates when he was younger.
Agreed, he was too busy using his time productively and reading books.
@@PVPMontages-mc1vfboooring
If you have to train your replacement, you should get 50% of your replacement’s earnings
Shredded, destroyed, slammed, owned, and calmly refuted
This is the same thing that trudeau is doing to canada right now.
Canada is ruined...😢
Canada is ruined because white canadian are lazy ,,illiterate ...don't blame immigrants..canadian don't want work in many sectors
@@stazorm1 If H1b visa holders are called cheap labour then Indian immigrants to Canada are much much lower quality. People who can’t make it to US opt for Canada. 😂. Don’t even compare.
If Indian culture was better than American work ethic culture, then they would have built India into a superpower and not look for work outside of India. These two guys, Vivek and Elon, are weird.
You kinda mistake culture with opportunity. Culture is definitely different, not one is better than the other. But opportunity is better in the states based on pay grade etc
@@abdulmw Totally agree with you we are also victims of this indians as our land under there occupation and totally feel the pain
@@ilwindcunha3296 Create your own damn Opportunities! Just like Vivek told American Blacks. Stop blaming others. Your culture is older than America's. Americans beat this shit out of the British. Why could you not with 800 billion people. You were too busy worshiping cows.
Colonisation??
Instead of being argumentive you are being derogatory.
It's been almost 250 years since usa got independence but has been only 75 since India did!
I know it's not the best but It's one of the fastest growing economy. I am against immigration just like you guys because we don't want brain drain....
Maybe the U.S. finally reached a level of corporate greed where everyone is about to wake up. Let’s hope so!
Vivek sounded like he was butt hurt from his time in HS, probably picked on and this was his moment to shine. Revenge of the Nerds 😂
Not just H1B visa from India also 5 million illegal migrants from India will be given greencard cause they have close connections with both the parties and majority are backed by Indian leader who is backed with extremist RSS and have close connections with all western politicians, they and AIPAC have common interest and brought most of the politicians. Immigration have certain limit and quota, somehow that limit exceeded tens and thousands of times specifically from one country that is India
5 million illegal from India? Lol. Source?
What is your source and why are more ons liking your post without a source, making bizzare claims?
@@Zeus11223 This has to be a troll account. 😂
@@amols101 an average trump supporter. don't expect any credibility from them. when the leader himself makes imaginary claims about migrants eating cats and dogs, its too much to expect any better from his supporters
r u a mu jeet
In my 36 year career as a software developer in the US I had to train employees from foreign countries to take my job back to those foreign countries over and over the last 20 years of my career. My boss even had the audacity to order me to write the letter to request the visa for Chinese workers to come to the US and then have me train them to take my job. It was an endless series of musical chairs for 20 years for my job to be moved out of the US and I would get another job inside the company until finally they moved my job to Romania and forced me into early retirement.
Please investigate and do a segment on VISA (the credit card company). They laid off and are laying of thousands of IT staff in favor of outsourcing those jobs to India. And as it is more than 80% of those jobs in US are filled already by workers from India who came here on H1b. So what are we Americans supposed to do and go?
There should be a tax on every company and billionaire to groom and hire local talent with a pre defined ratio for revenue/ net worth gain, and every visa based hire.
They didn't outsource to india but indians who would have been working for india if you guys wouldn't have elected billionaires.
We don't want brain drain and you don't want immigrants, I think we have a common ground
starbucks
Canada is about 10 years ahead on this.
Spoiler: It ends in total disaster.
Wore mary worshiper cry more😂😂
Dumb redneck do you also believe Jesus was there giving blow jobs to dinosaurs
That's not the fault of the concept, that's the fault of their very capable politicians... 51st state anyone?? LOL
Our whole country was sold to Indians and wealthy chinese immigtrants. My kids can never own a home now or start a family. Will Pierre help fix it? No he'll bring in more for his corporate backers.
H1B is for mid skill labor at best. No GPA requirement, no advanced degree requirement, no min years experience requirement. Also, their culture evidently isn't so great because it produced a place they run from.
H1B was meant for seasonal workers to pick strawberries then go back home. It was never meant for tech work or any skilled work.
Err..you actually require a minimum bachelor's or masters to get qualified for H1B. Please get educated on the issue
20,000 of these visas are given to graduates of US universities who have masters degrees. It seems you're clueless to even what an advanced degree is.
@@SomeUserNameBlahBlahIt is H1A for seasonal agricultural work.
@@yogeshkmrful There is no shortage of Americans getting Bachelor's or Master's. We don't need to import people so our oligarchs can maximize their profits.
Also why are the majority of h1b visa recipients Indian? Why not Germans or Swedes? Is it because, like Americans, Germans and Swedes would want higher pay?
strategy is simple, step 1 come in as a cheap and good worker step 2 bring in more friends and family to work together and lastly step 3 outsource the work to their motherland with more friends and family
120k median is a cheap worker in USA?
Please inform the readers as well on which can you bring a family member except a spouse, let alone bringing a friend. This is incredibly stu pid.
@@bobbytay167 wow, if it was so simple why does it take more 15 years to get permanent residency in the US for Indians when it barely takes at most 3 years for every other country. You guys are not even interested in understanding the issue before exhibiting your bias.
You are stupid 😂😂😂😂😂
Sore loser. Even Indian students doing their Masters in US in highly specialised majors are issued H1B only. Its not cheap labour they earn 65 to 75k per year out of university.
Vivek should move to India
I'm from Kenya who works for Microsoft remotely. I get paid $40k per year, which is not much in the US, but since I'm in Kenya, that's a lot of money, makes me top 1% earner, there are many Africans who also work for Google and Microsoft remotely. It's cheap labor. Sorry, Americans.
, no, you're just a paid information terrorist who supports a rapist's's party. The scamservative scampreneur heritage mafia is the foundation of all America's problems
There are many reasons why america does that - they want talent to work for america , but not for corporations outside the west.
@@Artus1845-gh9pd no they want cheap labor, and it's going to end in a disaster because most aren't all that smart, they want slaves with basic coding skills, but these are the people who are supposed to become management and innovators some day, you aren't getting that from a 90 IQ coder
@Artus1845-gh9pd , no, it's what you call self interest, competition, and entrepreneurship. Others call it expropriation, colonialism, or exploitation .
We give away the most valuable thing we have - US Citizenship.
Why is it the most valuable thing? People are falling for that misunderstanding..
Vivek Ramaswampy.
Why not make America a socialist. Capitalism isn't working, I guess. Canadian asked a similar question as you did. We got Trudeau, and look what happened to us. Please learn from us
how bout you move to Canada and the stfu
None of the govt work, and for the same reason. Socialism has the same corruption and greed as any other type of govt. They all fail
In a capitalist country/society there are open markets and you should compete with anyone including immigrants, why should a rich person prefer you? When he can hire someone else for less pay? If you want handouts from the govt because you were born in a certain country or belong to a certain race then move to a socialist one!@@libtardh8er
As an IT manager we don’t like this either. Unfortunately we need to tow the corporate line in order to keep our own jobs. How do we fix this on a national level? This must be addressed and we need to hold these large corporations responsible. This is something Trump will never do I fear.
Stop letting brown people into America. Wow, solved every problem in America. Weird how that works.
Foreigners replacing American workers resonates across party lines. It’s been something going on for years now and American IT workers are tired of it. IT is the new sweatshop.
Low skilled migrants have been replacing American workers and suppressing wages for decades now without anyone caring. But now that it’s people in the middle class being replaced everyone is suddenly freaking out 😂 The lack of class consciousness and solidarity is the problem in this country
460,000 visas for foreign students coming here to study. Why aren’t we giving these guys & our American graduates these jobs?
Because there's no American Top-Notch graduates, go to UCLA, the best students are from other countries, also USC.
American students are getting degrees in psychology and liberal arts. Foreign students are getting degrees in engineering and comp science. Guess who got a better chance at high paying jobs?
@@Gallo2023that doesn’t really makes sense the smarter people come here for their studies. U know what i mean?
@@yogeshkmrful i think the foreign students would love those degrees too, just as much as our guys love the tech stuff. We have more than enuf smart people here & should be putting America first in every way we can right now. There’s goin to be a snapping point.
So no América first!! It's just a slogan for the sheeps to jump on the wagon!!@@Gallo2023
Yep, Millions of Chinese and Indians and others heading to the US for a better life because their culture is so great bahaha. That makes a lot of sense. Vivek single-handedly disproves meritocracy.
The latest data showed around 72% of H-1B visas were issued to Indian nationals,
You think economics and culture are co related.
33% startups in silicon valley are by these same foreign workers. Must be doing something better?
@yogeshkmrful they are competent people equally and sometime more than Americans but have to work on lower wages.
@@bestvideos35 You have to understand the issue a little deeper. If you talk to any well informed H1b visa holder for India they will be able to tell you exactly where the problems lie.
The H1b visa itself doesn’t create the problem. The big 7 tech giants don’t hire H1b for lower pay., it usually the consulting companies that pay them lower because they take part of the pay as their comission. And the reason the people are stuck with these consultancies is also not because of the H1b visa itself but the artificially imposed country cap on Green Cards (permanent residency).
It’s a crappy system no one wants to change (both Republicans and Democrats) but just talk about once every 4 year cycle.
I am an Indian and I don’t agree with Vivek’s comment of American culture. American’s are the most hardworking people on earth. Americans are friendly, polite and genuine people. Vivek’s comment doesn’t make any sense. It is a class and system issue that some Americans are struggling to get a master degree. College education is affordable to particular class in the society. Also, as an Indian I love that Americans respect all jobs and views dignity in all class of workers. American culture is the best in the world. That’s the reason people come to this land. God bless America. 🇺🇸
You think bending over backwards will save you from the wrath of jealous angry racists? Pathetic.
Are you really..I don’t see any counter argument with substance
We need more H1B’s in fields like medicine where there are shortages (I.e. doctors and nurses). There are not enough US medical school or nursing school graduates to meet the growing demand for healtjcare. America is an aging society with falling birth rates. We need more young immigrants for future growth. Might as well get the best and brightest where there are deficits in fields like medicine.
@@derekf7772 honestly, most americans never cared about tech much. All of a sudden, they all care about tech LMAO
this guy has his face deep in americas rear.. and he uses tongue too at times
Woz, bullying Vivek for being a nerd proves his point about intellect not being valued here.
Its not problem for only TRUMP or BIDEN. Its a huge problem for all American citizens.. Solve this problem together.
If I was a recent university graduate and applied at one of these tech companies and didn't get hired, I would investigate if there are any H-1B visa employees. If so, I'd sue the FCK out of that company for unfair hiring practices.
The get away with it all the time and nothing can be done about it.
There's a legal case now that Musk, Vivek and Trump publicly acknowledged they support H1B visas. American workers should be prioritized before foreigners.
@@benarizola8453I know it sucks but your suit would go nowhere.
@@benarizola8453 lmao no one would prioritize idiots over workers
Sue? With what money? your a recent grad with student debt and no job, you think the system doesnt have that base covered😂
just goes to show you all rich people think they are better than you, whether their right or left
The class war is real.
Fascism is the marriage between the state and corporation coupled with extreme "nationalism" , racism and militarism .
In america, profits preceeds everything.
So China's fascist then, right?
This country is definitely fascist if that's what it is
Not allowing H1B would not give the jobs to the Americans, the businesses would just move to India
Let them move to India then
Don't let the door hit ya azz on the way out.
@@sylodui8896they will just like manufacturing jobs it is even easier to do
Wrong. They're already moving jobs to India with the increased H1B
@@kipdr Don't care , let them move, we won't buy their products, they can sell to India.
Its great that Vivek acknowledges the grotesque inferiority of his own culture and embraces the superior American culture where anything is possible.
He doesn't explain why most Indians would gladly migrate from their superior culture to ours.
@@jimbo7577 they immigration cuz america is run by billionaires who want cheap wages lol
It’s not the culture but the opportunities/living conditions.
@hihowareyouhihowareyou3688 yes that's the culture of potentia vs the inferior culture you came from
One hospital bill and you are homeless. Please don't say that's a superior culture.
Well, I am against pompus foreigners. I am hateful of overly familiar ones thinking they can tell old families what to do. Show respect or rip up your citizenship. He basically admited to not really being American....which is honest, I have no problem with it, but the disrespect is infuriating.
The layoff of Americans - and train Indians is nothing NEW. It's been going on for 20 years. Nothing new.
Ok...time to put a lid on it
I have worked with many indians that have working visas and they don’t work harder than us. We show up earlier and always got to fix what they do wrong. I have been in the manufacturing industry for the last 8 years i have seen this with my own eyes. Not only that sometimes they lie on their resumes or they’re not willing to do some dirty jobs. Trust me they are not smarter or work harder than us although vivek thinks the opposite.
My friend knew some Americans in past who migrated to India. They all worked in same organization. They don't know anything about Indian Culture or our language. My friend used to say they don't anything about work, but yet they were treated better than my friend just because they were good in speaking English. My friend said that he was sad, that English is a parameter on which people are judged nowadays. Not on our skill. Also he told me that they made fun of him his accent. Although it might be joke. But it creates sense of inferiority complex. So what your point is?? Our personal experiences does not reflect the reality in broader aspect. I can judge every American on basis of this. But I will not, again my above statements stand.
So I’m laid off BUT to get my severance package i have to keep working and train the person to replace me. What kind of country do we live in
One run by people like Ramascammy and Trump.
So much for americans first, the guy is a master con artist, didn’t think he would pedal back so quick though, hasn’t even been inaugurated yet. Smh!
My bachelors in biology didnt get me the type of job I wanted so I went back and got another 80k in debt to become a software engineer. I work hard and continually learn new skills gaining new certifications even decades into my field. They don't like the idea of treating highly skilled labor as highly skilled labor. They think they earned their spots but those of us studying non stop for decades on our own time in addition to our 9-5 act entitled rather than accomplished...? Im done with Vivek if this is what he's pushing for.
Never would see the day I would see liberals be more patriotic than the right and I’m here for it
Conservative leading folks have been saying this for a while. I don't know why they so mad.. they've been saying this about black people, Immigrants Americans for years. I don't know what they are complaining about now.
Do we need Indian immigrants doing work Americans can do ?
We have over 5 million here already, elon just wants foreign Indians that don't know they will be forced to work horrible hours for shit pay. Elon is unwilling to cultivate from the 5 million here, he wants the benefit that another foreign company spent the time already to train those individuals
In 2022 and 2023 elon had tens of thousands of h1b approvals
HELL NO
hell no
You need them to tell you how to live life, how to eat food, what to eat, how to dress, and obviously how to work.
The main problem is not the H1b visas, it is the H2v visas. That is the one that lets them have all the construction jobs, hotel jobs, 7-11 jobs etc. And it a lie that their pay is so low. It is lower than regular but not that much. It is really about replacing Americans.
Which is better, American culture or Indian culture?
Both cultures are great in their own way. The bad side if Anericans is to easily trying to rxplot vulnerability in the name if H1b. The vad side of India is to try and Anerica all the tome because the oerception in India is tjay Americans are stupid rich people and can be fooled and rextorted easily.
Vivek chose to speak something stupid at the worst possible time. Indian culture has lots of problems, it's far from good.
@@keitha.1888 depends on which aspect, in India there are fewer opportunities, hence working hard is a must to secure a good life. This is why Indian parents focus more on academics then American parents.
@@keitha.1888 There is no comparison at all. India and Indian culture existed 5000 years before Christ was born. America was unknown even to the Europeans untill 1492.
India did not go looking for America. Europen whites went looking for the sea route to India and by mistake Columbus discovered North America. Then they all rushed to this newly "discovered" land. And what did the whites do here? Killed all the natives and grabbed their lands. They erased a complete race from the face of the planet.
What did the white Christian Europeans do in Africa. Captured Africans by force and then sold them like animals.
When White Christians Portuguese landed in India what did they do similar things.
The GDP of India was 27% of the world GDP when British reached India. By the time they left, India was the poorest country in the world. Brits looted equivalent of 450 trillion dollars from India.
What happened in America? The white Christians fought among themselves for supermecy. The Brits fought with French for seven years till they got control of the 13 colonies. White Christians kept killings Natives, enslaving blacks and killing each other. Even massacred each otjer. Then again the the same white Christians fought against British White Christians and drive them out. With the treaty of Paris, America was born. On the contrary, India got its independance in a non violent struggle in 1947. By the time Brits left India, it had been divided India into Afghanistan, Burma, Pakistan and Bangladesh. When millions of Indians were dying of hunger, Churchill was sending food grains from India to the United Forces. More Indians died during British rule than Jews in Nazi Germany. Even then Indian soilders shoulder to shoulder with the United Forces.
From the richest Nation on Earth where Vasco Da Gama wanted to reach Columbus wanted to reach became the country of poor dying of hunger. Thanks to the White Christians - the Brits.
In 1947 India got independance and in 75 years they are the worlds fourt largest economy and this year it would become world third largest economy.
For Indians, America is a role model. America is not even 250 years old but their achievements are tremendous. India does not even dream of competing with America. Forget America, even China's Economy is six times bigger than India. Indians don't live under any falce notion. They are simple, hardworking and law abiding people. They have been traders, businessmen, skilled workers and never limited themselves to their own lands. For them World is a Family. History is witness that all the places from where India's were removed, the country hit the dust. It could be Afghanistan, Pakistan, Burma, Uganda, Zimbabwe are some example. If troubled, Indians would not fight back, they will not creat civil unrest, they would simply go.
Indians don't even make 1.5% of the American Population but they pay 6-7% of the total income tax. They are highly qualified and very smart people. If they leave it would be a great loss to America. No they are not cheap labour, they are innovative thinkers. Don't forget that the number system we use today was invented by Indians.
When it comes to education, Indian culture is better, when it comes to innovations, American culture is better. So both are better in their own ways.
Shredded Ramaswamy isn't that a new salad served at Indian restaurants?
Yep, fav racist dish.
Let's make a correction on her statement.She says Eli's a genius.No he's a guy with a lot of money who hires smart people and he takes to credit
Indian national
This is brilliant: even a FoxNews anchorwoman can clearly see that these corporations aren't seeking the brightest and best around the world, but rather are lowering wages! The reason corporations look overseas for workers is to PAY LESS for labor. This is about cheaper labor reserves, and has absolutely nothing to do with Asians being smarter or having a better work ethic. Vivek Ramiswamy is a Brahmin, a privileged caste Indian who was born on a silver platter, and he's going to judge our culture? What a joke! Frankly, I'm sick of hearing about how "lazy" American workers are. It just isn't true. The good news is, even the far-Right is sick of this corporate BS and are pushing back. I welcome them in this fight.
To be honest, I don't often agree with Vivek Ramaswamy or Elon Musk, but they are not wrong.
Based on my upbringing from the beautiful continent of Africa, we place a much higher emphasis mathematical and scientific education than Those in North America because University education in STEM is often seen as a sure means of success. Africans and Asians both believe that.
You need more than engineers to have a successful country. We still need farmers, truck drivers and nurses etc…..
@@carah4958 sure you are correct, no doubt about it. However, eventually, the tools that Engineers build will be doing the vast majority of work for the occupations you mentioned.
be specific, the foreign workers are Indians, period
Thank God I worked in IT since when it was really good. After 2010, I felt I am living in India inside usa 😅. I'm glad I only have few years before I retire. I feel sorry for the new coming IT generation. They have nothing promising left. Not only H1B is corrupt but also corporations are outsourcing everything to India. Total bleeding
How come their hard work doesn’t work for them in India? To achieve their dreams they have to come to America.
I work in a company in India. Im Indian living in India. My duty time is about 13 hours and travel time 3 hours up and down. Legally it's only 8 hours working time but unless we do overtime we will be kicked out. Im getting a monthly salary about 250 USD dollars. Im a reasonably educated person. Hard work doesn't automatically translate to better life in India. People who works as street vendors, taxi drivers works more than me but their wages are less than mine. Indians will go to any nation for better wages. There is no point in complaining. Indians are doing this out of certain desperation. The only way you can stop indians is through Government.
Indians earn more than all other ethnicities here. These people are stupid to think that Indians get paid less.
India mostly had a Trudeau kind of government since it's Independence in 1947... Their current government (from 2014) has done wonders in Uplifting the country like you won't believe!
Now it's only a matter of time when it's back to it's full potential 🤷
The attraction of H-1B candidates is not their greater competence. Rather, it is their greater compliance.
I can't believe Ana when a whole session without blaming the Democratics
Patrick Bet-David, multi-millionaire, social media influencer, and CEO of Valutainment LLC recently posted a compelling video arguing for bringing in STEM geniuses. However, many of the commenters noted his company currently has a job posting for a graphic designer - through the H1B visa program! Graphic design is an arts degree, not a STEM degree. I think the job is paying $42K -in the Ft. Lauderdale or Miami area.
Notable are the many comments from people who report that the jobs being filled by visa holders are NOT ones that only STEM geniuses can fill. I’ve heard similar from a few programmer friends. The work visa program is being abused, and American workers are paying the price. And Musk wants to further loosen regulations.
@@mitchrodee you can’t pay an h1b less than 60k. that must be a different visa.
A lot of these people on skilled and student visas end up driving uber and delivering DoorDash 😂 They’re taking every type of jobs from Americans
@ it is illegal for anyone on a student or h1b visa to do that. They will be deported immediately. You guys are really coming up with wild stories now.
Alternatively, instead of looking for a job you can graduate from college with an idea, zero business competency, HR experience, or even the basics balancing a checkbook and build it into one of the largest companies in the world. Yeah right. All these folks (tech bros) had their hands held by 'mentors' with piles cash. They were chosen.
2022: 73% !!!!!! Of H1 B visas went to Indian nationals
EXACTLY WHY the country shouldn’t be run like a company. It’s a completely different goal.
As a US immigration attorney, I can tell you this is some really clueless commentary. The H1B visa has a procedure called a prevailing wage determination to make sure the foreign worker isn't depressing US wages. The prevailing wage determination is often higher than what a US worker would be paid! Then there is the EB2 NIW program when there is a shortage of an occupation such as nurses or pilots, which Ana seems to think is what the H1B visa program is for. There is only 65,000 H1B visas available worldwide and they are extremely difficult to get. Foreign workers can only stay for a maximum of 6 years total on a H1B visa, so there is that too. Clue up Young Dorks!
Even if this were true it’s not how it’s being implemented and this is widely reported ya obvious liar and dweeb
They can still have children.
@@cpinckard3702 very convincing argument for an illit. 🤣
@@SupergirlsBF what's wrong with children? 🤡
i'm divorcing my wife, but before she leaves I insist she must train my new girlfriend how to cook and clean my house.
😂
I hear ya bro, lower maintenance cost, better compliance and greater output.
That h1b program's great, eh? 🤣🤣
H1B isn't only about cheap labour: this visa is a binding with one company, the one that requested it. So it is also slavery.
Democrats have no problem with slavery - they’re the party of slavery during this country’s darkest hours, and push for slavery today with bailouts, wars, and student loan forgiveness.
I have experienced outsourcing twice and it always involves H1B1 holders because it is the only way to save money because the long term American labor is always better than the Indian labor on a 1 to 1 basis. They are more experienced and hold the institutional knowledge. It is a total scam and a disgrace.
Tell Rammy to piss off, yeah Americans are lil lazy these days but who the hell is Rammy to replace you.
The American people better wake up
Actually Vivek …FYI America produces the best engineers in the world…because America has the best engineering schools in the world….I suggest you visit the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Boston and seat in the math and science lectures …and try to solve the “problem sets” that the American engineers have to solve there….to even have the chance to pass the courses…Another fantastic American engineering schools are: California Institute of Technology in Pasadena, Stanford University, University of California at Berkeley, Georgia Institute of Technology, School of Engineering at University of Washington, Seattle, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, Columbia University….etc etc and the list goes on and on..
Yes but 90% of the PhD students in America are foreign born...
Lol I suggest you to go and see what student population looks like .. they literally have to dumb it down so it’s not just Asians in these schools
@ I am talking about American educated engineers…American PhDs foreign or not are a different class of professionals that in many cases go to do high level scientific research at American Institutions and abroad…
Europeans work less than Americans and have paid family leave and get more vacation time. The Europeans seem to be doing fine.
Bruh there’s nothing else worse than being called a dork as a billionaire lol
If American culture is wack, why didn't his parents remain in India?
you are just ignorant. here American culture didn't mean culture as entirety but culture of not celebrating student who achieve something big such as winning math Olympiad.
He is bringing the Indian Caste system to the USA LOL
Who they can marry
Who they can be close friends with
What jobs they can do
Their access to wealth, power, and privilege
MIGA LOL
@shubham40901 you can't leave your house, come to my house because it's better and then after a while, start bringing all your relatives to my house so as to run my house "better"! Dude, stay in your house (India) and make it great, if you can! My house, my rules
@@bang8534 your great grand parents came to some others house, slayed them and stayed which is why you are here calling this your home. So don't preach to us about houses.
@Sai-gv6sk that's where you get it wrong with your whitewashed version of "history". Many of us were here before anybody, though some were forcefully brought over later. So, dude, this is my house and my point still stands. My house, my rules. You don't like them, back to India
60Minutes did a piece on a company that did this to an entire department
Get out of ur echo chamber and take a moment to listen fully to what V & E are saying. That is precisely why they are calling for a complete overhaul and reform to the h1b visa system so that it no longer can be taken advantage of and instead bring in only those top-tier candidates that qualify.
Anne coulter deserves an apology
🎯🎯 THIS!!
Interesting that mainstream right wing media criticizes their politicians but on the left on small channels like this have the balls to do the same
If Trump destroys Elon Musk and Vivek I have to admit, I will kind of like him for that. ❤
Being an Indian, I agree with you. H1 B visa is to replace American with cheaper Indian slaves who can work longer hours and weekends so that these business man can enjoy profits. Why can’t they simply list down a solid criteria for taking best in class people 1) have an American elite entrance exam 2) pay like executives 3) make sure they leave on time. 4) no policy to allow dependent to settle. That’s it. So that it also help the other countries to keep their people within their home country
You are Pakistani
Black Americans tried to tell you lol. Y'all are the new slave and you don't even know it. You think it's a flex that wyt say you work hard while you're making them rich.
janab, atta aur chawal ka intezam ho gaya ?
@@ZuhaBuba tujhe bheek nahi milega.. aage bad
Exactly 😊😊I agree definitely 💯. Tech CEOs want cheap labor (foreign workers who are willing to work 60-80 hrs/week and without good benefits,)Honestly I don’t trust $9.00/ hr foreign software engineers whom work for Boeing . What happened to Boeing 373 Max ???😂😂😂😂. According to reports , the software for Boeing 737 Max was primarily developed by Boeing engineers,but parts of the code particularly related to the companies like HCL Technologies and Cyient ,where Indian engineers were reportedly paid as low as $9.00/hr. It’s total b.s. 😂😂😂😂
Elon and Vivek never said they were against legal immigration.
Neither did Trump.
@@NashLaoShiTrump did several times. That's what his whole "eating the dogs" tirade was about. Legal immigrants.
@@heatherpayne1995 He was referring to Illegal Haitian immigrants.
@@Rapture77 No. He was refering to legal ones. The entire town was legal.
@@heatherpayne1995that was against black immigrants. Black people sadly are detested so much in America that lies have to be told about them.
Vivek and Elon wants you go for a STEM career so they can replace you with a cheaper worker from abroad.
Truely, great men they are.
If Elon were a genius he wouldn't be supporting Trump, he would see through him.
Vivek spoke like he was sitting in his living room speaking to a group of his closest Indian family and friends.
Actually he wanted good for Americans, he did so speaking some strong truths, but it is going undigested and unacceptable to a lot. The quality of being able to self critical is the 1st part for any progress. I believe his intentions to re-direct priorities. Which of the American leaders takes such stand the way he did. Rather they worry on vote bank. I think he knowing that it won't go right he spoke it. Imagine the positive effect that America will change its education system towards producing more engineers as well.
Didn't we see this before? About 40 years ago, didn't we see Japanese and Vietnamese entrepreneurs do informercials and say directly to Americans that we're fat and lazy? Shortly after that, isn't that about when we saw good manufacturing jobs leave the country for the sake of cheaper and more obedient labor? I get that capitalism has always required an underclass of laborers willing to do shittier and shittier jobs for less pay and less protection, but at some point we fat and lazy Americans need to stop listening to the people at the top of the pyramid who benefit the most and lose the least amount of their lifetimes doing menial tasks, and start listening to those who actually do the work and fight for those who do the work! The WORST thing the Democratic Party ever did was rig their last three primaries merely for the sake of electability, because even if Bernie Sanders lost the election as the Dem's nominee, at least the party would have dug itself in as THE party for the working class, and the Republican billionaires who now run this country would be seen as the fascists they truly are. Vivek would have been laughed out of the country for saying the things his Asian predecessors said 40 years ago!
We are all worried about immigrants takimg good payimg jobs away from Americans when we should be worried about AI and Robotocs replacing us in the work force.
100%. These corporates are making unnecessary inventions that optimizes life only for corporates and not humans to have a livelihood.
This is a no win situation for America. Companies hiring H1B visa workers will close in America and take it off shore or outsource activities to bring back profit for themselves. Only other countries will benefit with this move unless US lawmakers change regulations.
It's quite hilarious that Trump and Musk joked about laying off 30k workers because they wanted a union which is extremely alarming. This is the norm for my country, slavery.
Why not address the elephant in the room, stop all H1B visa's and make them hire American first!
America isn't opposed to bringing in more GENIUSES like Elon Musk is where i stopped listening.
Anna keeps slipping. It's like she has a secret fetish for guys on the far right.
That would be a O-1 Visa NOT H1b. Vivik is propagandizing . Intellyally confusing the public on X
There is no shortage of tech talent in America anymore. There are hundreds of thousands of tech workers who have been laid off in recent years, both native and foreign. Most are finding it very hard to get jobs in this economy
Not $9.00/ hr foreign engineers. Only American engineers can’t find Jobs because Tech CEOs only want to hire $9.00/hr engineers 😂😂😂😂 as low as possible 😂😂😂😂Fuc@ you Elon Mao 😂😂😂😂😂