The Wasted Potential of DC Comics Earth One
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 май 2024
- SUBSCRIBE for weekly comic book videos! ▶▶ ruclips.net/user/owenlikescomi...
WATCH NEXT ▶ 'Why The World Still Needs Superman' • Why the World Still Ne...
▶ Support the Channel: / owenlikescomics
▶ Make a one-time donation at Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/owenlikescomics
Throughout the history of DC Comics, there has been no shortage of reboots, relaunches and alternate continuities. Now, we’ve already touched on a number of these so far, namely The New 52 and the failed ‘All Star’ series of comics, but there’s another standalone universe that I want to touch on in this video: DC’s Earth-One. For those of you who might be unaware, DC Comics has often used a multiverse in their storytelling, with a varied number of parallel realities existing, often labelled as Earth-1, Earth-2 and so on. And, traditionally, Earth-1 was often designated as the ‘Prime’ reality, as in the place where our versions of the DC heroes exist. However, by the late 2000’s, following the Infinite Crisis mini-series, the company had altered their multiverse, with the prime reality now being designated as Earth-0. As a result, in late 2009, DC formally announced that they would be creating a new line of publishing, entitled Earth-One. This new universe, they stated, would be a complete clean slate, allowing writers and artists to tell brand new and unique stories with established DC heroes, free to reinvent and reinterpret them in bold new ways. In a sense, the company sought to capture the success that Marvel had found with their Ultimate universe (which, at this point, had been going strong for close to a decade). But, could they? Today, in late 2019, the Earth-One universe does still exist today, though I think it’s fair to say that the series, despite some strong moments, never quite lived up to its potential or expectations. But the question is why? What happened to Earth-One? In this video, we’re going to explore the origins and the ideas behind DC’s Earth-One series, examine the early successes and failures of the books, and attempt to uncover the reasons as to why it seemed to fall by the wayside, forgotten about by both its publisher and its fans, and ultimately never got the levels of success and recognition that it arguably deserves.
▶ Follow Owen Likes Comics:
Website: www.owenlikescomics.com
Twitter: / owenlikescomics
Instagram: / owenlikescomics
Soundcloud: / owenlikescomics
▶ ▶ Watch More Owen Likes Comics:
Comic Case Studies: • Comic Case Studies
Latest Videos: • Latest Videos
Marvel Videos: • Marvel Videos
DC Videos: • DC Videos
▶ Music Used:
/ spacesuits
/ lindecis-soulful
/ 4tane-yes-please-render-1
/ falls-echos
/ aso-caught-in-the-rain
• ♩♫ Sad and Emotional M...
/ sugiwa-memories
#DC #EarthOne #ComicBooks 
Развлечения
▶ If you enjoyed this video, consider supporting Owen Likes Comics on Patreon: www.patreon.com/owenlikescomics
@Owen Likes Comics Well, all the internet rumors are saying that Batman: Earth One will be a main inspiration for Matt Reeves in his Batman movie, so... Maybe things can change. Also, Vol. 3 of Bman: Earth One is about to come out.
Yes
I don’t really like it when people try to “modernize” Superman. Most of the time he’s turned into Batman when they’re supposed to represent completely different sides of the everyday American. Batman represents the city kid who grew up with 1 or neither parent and took a very cynical view of the world thinking no one could be trusted but they still worked hard to leave their mark on the world. Superman represents the country boy that grew up with 2 loving parents and he sees the world in a very light way. He thinks that there’s good in everyone and just wants to do his part to help the world.
except earth-one is about clark trying to figure out who he wants to be and finding his place in the world. Its probably one of the best modernizations of superman.
Generic assessment of modernising superman is generic
Newsflash superman has been modernised for coming up on 80yrs now.. from Byrne to Moore to the death of superman guys &more.
Yeah this is a misguided interpretation of modernizing Superman. Earth One Superman was still very much Superman but in this case was a kid who was trying to figure himself out and find his place in the world. No different from Byrne (keeping Clark’s parents alive, and emphasizing the Human aspects), Birthright (showcasing a silver/Bronze Age inspired Superman in a post 9/11 world), Smallville or even Morrison’s take on the New 52 (A Golden Age Superman in 2011 )
What does that have to do with him being modernized? There are still orphans who live in cities, and country folk who have two loving parents in todays time. Your comment really makes no sense.
Batman is a billionaire not an everyday kid
It’s a shame DC hasn’t really made Earth One a real priority. I would love to see the Earth One heroes crossover for a Justice League graphic novel
I don’t want them to make a Justice League title, considering part of the appeal of Earth One is these characters exist wholly in their own spheres. While I would like the development of a meeting of the characters, I think it should be framed as a crisis instead, and if Earth One were to become an legitimate imprint then have these crises which unite the heroes happen every year or so. That way the characters and stories never get bogged down by continuity the way the Ultimate Marvel universe did. Rather have crossovers never happen, almost never reference events of other books except in these crisis crossovers. That being said yes Earth One definitely should’ve been a priority for DC.
@TheVirusSoftware Same, I think what makes it special is the differentiation of the worlds and styles of the characters
Giovanni Martin then what's the point of having them be on the same earth?
They can still tell amazing stories if they have a justice league book
I think seeing a more inexperienced justice league would be interesting
@@giovannimartin3239 what if they Titaned it, shake it up a bit since it has a real world vibe can see the team roster getting twist. Use the alternative JL from the 80s you know Fire, Ice, Martian Manhunter etc etc
I for one actually like the Earth One Universe but it feels like DC just brushed it off to the side and never went back to it again. Its kinda sad since the stories were very interesting. Also the fact that they didnt really connect each heroes was interesting and kinda disappointing.
@Sofá Perdido I guess I missed it what were the titles?
@@ArtiicBlizzard The last 2 earth 1 books were released in 2018 those are Wonder Woman earth 1 vol 2 and green lantern earth 1
@@hexbug9737 I read those and Green Lantern was one of my favorites
@Bea r Yea it wouldve been great seeing them all together
No wonder they abandoned the project, since they turned our DC universe into a huge elseworld with the Few52.
I could totally go for a Green Lantern “horror” movie based on Earth One. Green Lantern is all about conquering fear, so I think it’d work pretty well.
Could adapt earth 1 to one series type Smallville
...Green Lantern Earth One is rad though
Hell yeah, that book is absolutely incredible.
never seen it and but I always liked the idea of reinventing Green Lantern/Hal as an astronaut. It makes so much sense.
Agreed. Maybe the best GL book since the John's run.
and it's coming back.
Easily the one I’m most invested in.
My problem with Earth One (and some of the modern interpretations of Superman)...why does Clark Kent always look so sad? He doesn't smile. Not everyone is sad and dark...and neither should Superman be. Superman isn't shy and unsure of himself. He can be a goofball but he's not a nerd either. He's an average corny guy that likes American human things. He's built like an NFL defensive tackle but once you meet him he's no serious athlete. People assume his build is just a genetic accident and from being raised doing hard work on the farm. Clark might go out to the pub with his pals. Though he cant get drunk, he is amused by their drunken stories and enjoys the company of people! Bring back the Superman I grew up reading and not a reinvention of Bruce Wayne.
I think the point is that he's figuring himself out, learning who he's gonna be, which is very relatable to many people, but with the twist of him being an alien.
@@projekttaku1 Exactly
This isn’t a Batman copy but a Superman finding his place in the world.
I love that idea of a blue collar Batman that still is some how a billionaire, brilliant.
Well Batman is obviously a Billionair in the story it's just that he isn't an impossibly skilled fighter/detective/ninja and his tech is much more grounded in reality.
@@enotsnavdier6867 "impossibly"
Anti-HyperLink I mean yeah...batman while having no powers is still quite rooted in fantasy.
@@slothful2039 He was pointing out the spelling error.
@@slothful2039 batman is gwenpool equavalent of dc
It’s been years and I’m still waiting on Batman: Earth One, Volume 3. Dammit, Doomsday Clock!
Hmm I wonder what this Earth One’s designation is post Doomsday Clock...or was this the only Earth to use One rather than 1? 🤔
I like all timelines being back but with so many with the same name it’s gonna get confusing...
@@deadpool3982 think it's still Earth-One the main universe (formally Prime-Earth who was formally New Earth) is now Earth One. It's the little dash that makes the difference.
Volume 3 is coming summer 2021 😊
But in this book my question is :
where's all his training for years & travelling all around the world ,in the comics didn't he travel all around the world laerning all the martial arts + training with Raas Al Ghoul, becoming the best of the best both PHYSICALLY & TECHNICALLY ?!!! He even travelled & mastered FLYING before , bruce didn't just throw himself to batman directly ! he travelled ,became a *freak of nature* then came back to become the batman , ...... Where's all his preparations ? ?... In this one he is just Reckless & unprepared .... this one is not faithful to batman's true core and mindset... though it's nice.
@@goodson91 Well, in the comics he didn't train with Ra's. He trained with Henri Ducard, but it's in Batman Begins that they combined the two characters. The fact that he didn't trained around the world before becoming Batman is a little bit disarming at first, but I find Earth One is the place to put this idea to the test. It makes him a little more brave to go without ninja training (and more crazy). I find it's like a modernized and a darker version of Adam West's Batman, and what Batman was before every writer turned him into the best ninja and best detective of all time.
The books take forever to come out and DC forgets about it, they have so much potential and they have genuinely good stories. They have actually good rewrites of a characters, like making Hal an astronaut and making Batman a lousy billionaire with no training.
As someone who doesn't really like having to follow comics every month or two and would rather read a single story, the format is so appealing to me. It is a pity they didn't dive further in to this; we could have had a different style of comic book story telling, as different as a TV show is to a film.
Yeah, its very sequential and easy to follow.
Earth one isn't done, at least the batman one isn't. Geoff Johns took a hiatus from it to do doomsday clock.
Johns had finished the next volume many years ago, it went on hiatus for artist Gary Frank who was 2/3rds done with the book before getting brought in for Doomsday Clock. He first showed off work from it in July 2015, two months after the release of volume 2. That had a two year delay, this one will be at least 3.
And now when Doomsday Clock has finished I think we will see volume 3 really soon
@@v-trigger6137 sike
@BasketCase 420 Jason Fabok is doing the art on 3 Jokers.
Why is Clark dressed like Alex Mercer from Prototype?
Because he's edgier then the traditional supes
Hey what's up I love your videos, specifically your arkham timeline and injustice videos :-)
@@batmanfan6207 Cheers, mate.
The4thSnake HEY WHAT UP! I was wondering are you were gonna review Jedi Fallen Order?
I guess dc was trying to be different
I feel earth one could seriously be it’s own little series as a show or something. Like it could seriously fit as a live action show.
Earth one I thought was a good idea but unfortunately like you said dc comics wasted earth one potential and that’s just sad because it could’ve been worked and been really interesting to see more earth one versions of these characters.
Tevya Smolka Earth One Green Arrow for instance.
I would love it if the writers used it to explore the PTSD that Oliver could have gotten from his time on the Island like Arrow did.
Agreed
@@Christ2010Grad i can agree with that or heck i would really love a earth one version of wally west as the flash or maybe a earth one version of the super sons with both Damian wayne robin and Jonathan Samuel Kent superboy that would be really fun and awesome in my opinion.
@@TevyaSmolka I get the vibe that DC would rather cancel the earth-one line than do that.
@@savagedarksider5934 yeah that's true and i can see that being the case
I was kinda wishing these movies would be adapted to the DCEU when Man of Steel was announced.
actually MOS is based on a bunch of Superman stories, including this. But my man Zack Snyder really can't help himself but to "reinterpret" Superman in a modern society when this book clearly excelled it.
Man of Steel is basically Earth One influenced. Did you actually read it and watch the movie?
I can't help but think that the movie was based on earth one even though "Superman: Birthright" is credited as the main influenced book for the movie
@@v-trigger6137 Man of steel is more influenced by Earth one and BvS is more by Birthright, For Tommorow, and Morrison.
@@wilsonwijaya.design dude Mos is Literally superman earth one. There might be slight references from past movies and here and there other stuff but from end to finish it's Literally man of Steel plot.
Even to the point where he wears glasses at the end.
All Star Superman was campy and a huge epic. Imagine that treatment to the other classic heroes. All Star Superman somehow manage to show me a weird huge world with the interviews in Poseidonis, Quantum in the moon, Dinosaur Men from the dephs, The Fortress, The Supermen of The Future. It was laid out in a so natural way, with the dialogue and visual ques. Amazing.
My thoughts on the Earth One books and the Ultimates as well: When you want to tell stories about "new and fresh" versions of characters that are "unencumbered by continuity", such stories can never hope to last very long. There's a flaw with the very concept. Once you start telling more stories about these characters, they are no longer "new and fresh" and suddenly they become encumbered by continuity. Even if the Ultimates universe wasn't destroyed, it would be hard to tell stories set in that universe anymore because there's so much that new readers would have to be caught up on (Reed Richards is the Maker, Peter Parker is dead, Spiderwoman is a female clone of Peter Parker, lots of major characters are dead, etc). The Ultimates universe could never continue because it has collapsed under its own continuity, the very thing that it was created not to have. Even if the Earth One books were able to be continued, they would soon run into the same problem. And even the new 52, which sort of tried to do the same thing, has ultimately failed, leading to the new 52 Superman being replaced by (a version of ) the previous Superman, and "everything is true" so that all of the new 52 stuff can be ignored when desired.
It's always easy to write the "first" Superman story. Or the "first" Batman story. Or the "first" Green Lantern story. But you can't sustain "first" stories forever. Yes, you can do the "first" Lex Luthor story and then the "first" Brainiac story, but eventually, continuity will catch up with you. And you'll have to start over again, and do ANOTHER "first" Superman, and then ANOTHER "first" Superman, and on and on forever and ever without end.
It's just so pointless.
That’s so true. That’s why I prefer stories with the start and the end. Like invincible. Like fables. Continuity really kills the joy.
Sad that ultimate died though.
Or how about western comic books taking inspiration from manga by having a story that have a beginning, middle and *conclusion*
It’s not pointless if you get good stories and new readers out of it
@@wicq2586 But those stories had continuity
@@frog6054 There are books like that
As a sci-fi fan I loved Green Lantern Earth One! I also love Batman Earth One and I appreciate Superman Earth One.
Confused, I thought the All Star Line of DC was DC’s Answer to Marvel’s Ultmate Marvel life.
EDIT: You mention that. Thank You.
I honestly LOVE Batman earth one. Both volumes blew me away and I’m really looking forward to the next one. I love what they did with Bruce and Alfred’s relationship and I love the new interpretations of the villains. I think the story is doing a good job of actually progressing with every volume too. Nothing ever stays the same and the characters actually grow and change. Oh and people actually die and don’t have to come back because of other comic book runs needed the characters. The art has been amazing as well. I hope they keep the book standalone and never cross over into the other earth one books because this series is so good on its own. Also, I’m always looking for a great riddler story and volume 2 of earth one finally gave me one. I LOVED what they did with the riddler. He’s never been so scary in my opinion. Anyway, good video.
i really liked it to
same, but for superman. I love watching this clark grow and figure himself out.
I love the Earth One books, but yeah: all the books take forever to come out. lol
I have been working on my own Earth one take for Shazam with billy batson being the reincarnation of king tut who would of been killed by his uncle Teth-Adam for taking Egypt from him and at the same time would work for the school news report program with his friends freddy and Theo Adam with Theo being a descendant of Teth-adam
comic book reviewer where can we read it
@@jadenbryant9283 I have already started writing it will try and post it when i can so far i have added in some easter eggs to the 1st vol of superman earth one with the alien invasion and have been going more into shazam to get everything down with a few takes
comic book reviewer so where are you going to realize it to
@@comicbookreviewer4856 is it done yet?
One thing I enjoyed about Batman: Earth One is DC updating the batphone
I would love to see DC do a proper Ultimate universe keep the graphic novel format they've done with Earth One but do one volume for each of their titles yearly and this universe would need the hottest creators working on it right now in order to succeed (all of which are at Marvel), Like imagine:
Donny Cates = Batman, + Justice League
Chip Zdarsky = Superman + Flash
Kelly Thompson = Wonder Woman + Aquaman
Al Ewing = Green Lantern(give usJOHN STEWART), and Martian Manhunter
and begin from there, maybe even start this universe in the late 40's after world war 2 with the baby boom and go through the 50s and 60s in order to differentiate it from the regular universe.
THANK YOU! FINALLY SOMEONE REMEMBERS IT EXISTS!!!
I got the Batman earth one first book it was good
Just read Batman Earth One vol. 3 which came out last month and it is amazing!
@@AdamTPersonette It has been way too long indeed
I really liked Superman Earth One when it first came out while I was in high school. If it had stuck to some sort of consistent schedule, I would've loved that. Didn't read the Wonder Woman or Green Lantern ones but Superman and Teen Titans were my favorites of the Earth One stuff I did read (don't remember Batman much but I own it and read it at some point).
same. Earth 1 superman is so easy and fun to follow.
The irony of seeing this video back when it premiered then seeing Earth-One GL vol 2 dropped shortly after. Wouldn't worry who could've predict that besides the video is still full of entertaining info.
Also weird to think but anyone notice that the Earth-One stories pair well with Immortal Hulk when you're in that kind of reading mood. Same way NEW52 Superman pairs well with Ultimate Spider-Man.
I read the superman one because i found it on sale in my local comic shop once, and i really liked it, felt like a better version of man of steel
Ahmed Abdalla Thats what I always say about that book. Lol. I just wish there was we got more stories from that universe.
I feel if superman earth one got made into a animated film series for the villains i could see sam Witwer for Tyrell nathan kress for parasite david kaye for general zod and Lily rabe for lex luthor
exactly. I very much liked man of steel, but this feels more like a superman who's figuring himself out, wondering what man he is gonna be.
I like Alfred being an ex royal marine idk why
Earth-1 is among the things abandoned next to the All Star series.
I feel like DC is doing this sort of thing with Black Label now. I also read an interview where Frank said he had resumed working on Earth One Batman, and Morrison is going to finish Earth One after his GL run concludes.
I actually own a pre-release review copy of Superman Earth 1 in TPB. I found it at a used bookstore for the grand sum of $1.
I think ongoing earth 1 titles would have been cool. It would have been like pre crisis dc with earth one and two running alongside each other. Missed opportunity.
I’ve read all the Earth One books and I’ve viewed it as some of the best DC has done. I’d put GL as the best with Batman and Superman interchangeable for 2nd and 3rd with the same being for TT and WW for the 3rd and 4th. DC really should be doing more with Earth One
They need to continue Green Lantern earth one
@@gabbar51ngh Totally agree. That's been the best "reboot" I've seen DC do. Kind of want that to be the next movie
@@BucketThinkTank14657Nerd I like the idea of Hal being astronaut but for Movie they should retain some of the story arcs from main Universe.
Basically a mesh of these two would be great if they ever make love action green lantern again.
@@gabbar51ngh I think that's the best way to do it honestly. Air Force to NASA makes sense I think Hal can still meet Abin Sur, the question is where do we go from there in terms of story? The Manhunters are the best choice still you could still use the idea of the corp being in dissaray because of them, which is why in the current DCCU there isn't an Earth Lantern, it's Abin and he's been keeping the Manhunters away from Earth.
@@BucketThinkTank14657Nerd we can use that.
Rather than corps being completely destroyed let's say they are in extremely fewer numbers now & most don't know how to rebuild it. Abin Sur in his attempt to rebuild it gets wounded & ring goes to Hal Jordan where Abin Sur puts the responsibility of rebuilding the corps on to him while giving exposition to what Green Lantern is before he dies. As for villain I would say it could be Atrocitus who killed Abin Sur & Later took control of Manhunters & turned them against Green Lanterns. Attacking them as he holds guardians responsible for the destruction of his people. Hal not only gathers the rest of the Lanterns to rebuild the corps but ends up defeating Manhunters & Atrocitus.
Atrocitus gets arrested but he mentions the prophecy here & saying how Hal is part of it or a catalyst to it & it's inevitable. This also gives a reason to Atrocitus to make a Lantern corps of his own when he gets freed. Leading to red Lanterns while Manhunters might not be completely Destroyed, we can later introduced hank Henshaw who takes over Manhunters & upgrades them.
From this point we can easily transition into main Universe storytelling of Geoff Johns style like Sinestro working alongside Hal but later creating yellow Lantern corps and Carol Ferris later becoming star sapphire. Once established we can easily introduce other Lanterns like guy gardener, John Stewart or Jessica cruz.
I'm still looking forward to Batman vol3. I think it's a great balance of realism and comic book fantasy with really interesting changes.
Comics aren't supposed to be realistic. If you want realism, then why are you reading about aliens and gods from other worlds coming to save us?
@@poopjeans1135 I'm not asking for super realism in comics but this series does bring in that element with good well defined characters that have deep motives and back story like Bruce and Alfred. Alfred sees the world as an unforgiving place while Bruce is enveloped by rage and wants to do everything on his own and he learns and grows by the end of the first volume.
@@poopjeans1135 it means having characters feel and have real responses in a strange world but yet feels similar to our own.
@@althentik you said it better
@@kwayneboy1524 Thanks man
Very interesting! The varied release schedule and relatively small number of books always made me think the Earth One line was some sort of experiment or minor project on DC's part. I had no idea it started out as DC's attempt to create their own Ultimate-style line of books.
Owen is kinda tired of comics
I still like them, I just want more good ones🤷🏻♂️
New channel name
@Owen Likes Comics Truer words have never been said
Owen Likes Comics ahh I agree so much... just worn out rn
@@OwenLikesComics comics love owen? Is it one side love?
The failure of the earth one books comes down to the writers. JMS doesn’t get the character of Superman; as his “grounded” storyline in the main Superman title demonstrated at the time.
Plus, since we’ve now had the new 52, the only real difference that the earth one books offers is its graphic novel format.
In what way is new 52 like Earth One? N52 is not nearly as easy to follow or a fresh start
Fernando Giubilei you’re right. The new 52 was a mess to follow outside of Synder’s Batman, because as Owen mentioned in a previous video, The relaunch had NO preemptive planning put into it at all.
But the issue was that it was marketed as fresh start and new reader friendly, just like the earth one books. So the comparison between the two initiatives is unavoidable because they serve the same purpose, and only differ in execution and format( single monthly issues series that cross over with each other vs character orientated graphic novels that seem to be stand alone despite taking place in same “universe”).
Umm Superman earth one imo is freaking great
@@carlosocano2826 it is
@@carlosocano2826 Dude, those two volumes are my favorite comics, I'd say they got me to understand Man Of Steel better
Thanks Owen : never read them, but you've inspired me to check out "Earth One : Green Lantern"
I loved both the Earth One Superman and Batman first volumes. But after a while I honestly thought they were stand alone books despite Vol. 1 being written on the cover. It’s only after seeing the second volumes years later that I realized it’s indeed meant to be an actual series.
I really loved Superman Earth One Volume One. It is one of the best Superman stories I have ever read. I loved the interaction between Clark and his parents and the overall storyline was awesome. I still prefer such stories as "All-Star Superman" and "Whatever happened Yo The Man of Tomorrow". The latter is my personal favorite., but Superman Earth One was a special book and I wish the Earth One universe could have survived and we could have gotten a crossover event with these heroes interacting with each other.
Still think if superman earth one got made into an animated movie i hope they get Tom Welling
to be the voice for clark kent the sameway i want to see David kaye for genereal zod Lilly rabe for lex and kelsey grammer for her husband
same. Wish they made the earth 1 books the main continuity after flashpoint instead of the new 52. I even have a timeline for when they could release the books:
Superman: Earth 1
Batman: Earth 1
Wonder Woman: Earth 1
Green Lantern: Earth 1
Flash: Earth 1
Aquaman: Earth 1
Justice League: Earth 1
Teen Titans: Earth 1
Elseworlds (not titled earth 1 because it has out of continuity stories)
Constantine: Earth 1
Martian Manhunter: Earth 1
Young justice: Earth 1
Then they could release animated series that directly adapt these books (with very minor changes). And the dceu would be mainly based on them aswell.
I must say, as a Wonder Woman fan, I really loved Wonder Woman Earth One. I appreciated how Morrison and Paquette bring back the strangeness, for modern eyes, of Diana's first stories with a updated sensibility.
Teen Titans Earth One reminded more of Gen 13 than Runaways.
That's also a fair comparison, it's extremely Gen 13.
Kinda felt If Teen titans earth one got made into an animated series on HBO max for season one i could see for the cast genesis rodriguez for Raven Marcus Scribner for Cyborg Jason ritter for Jericho Molly quinn for Terra and Atticus Shaffer for beast boy
Thank you for doing this.Ive been wanting this for too long!
I really fell bad for this line of books, so much potential. Squandered by greed.
But I don't see a Orange Lantern around
@@slothbaby2104 They could be, but. we should blame the new 52 for squandring the potential. Dan Didio is runing creativity and only cares about the woke agenda, the man has to go!
@@daviddyster4145 yeah I miss the days when a Superhero can be human and a real hero
leyen So do I. It’s time we rose up and took this into our own hands if the big companies won’t give us the entertainment we want then will take it all for ourselves!
@@daviddyster4145 Thats the best thing to do, if they won't make the comics you want just make them yourself my brother and I have been brainstorming for days about stories and Superheroes to make its been really fun
Superman: Earth One vol. 1’s story is deadass Man of Steel lol
But better
Nah Man of Steel is great too
The animated movies perhaps making their own Earth Ones would be interesting. While being new takes and new stories might put people off, it’d be worth exploring and open up to a bigger audience than just as a graphic novel. One thing about the graphic novel format that is good is that a whole storyline is released in one go, avoiding the risk of issues being delayed or simply vanishing from the schedules altogether.
I think them directly adapting (with some minor changes) the volumes into series would be the best. I'm actually surprised this hasn't been done. Instead of all those weird disconnected animated movies, they could've made a unofficial successor to the dcau by making superman, batman, and wonder woman series all based on the earth 1 books.
Ummm I sort of just think Earth one is kinda great?
Green lantern, batman, teen titans, Wonder Woman and superman earth one r great.
I don't think this was meant to be DC's answer to Marvel's Ultimate Universe.
Earth One books are still being made, they're just not on the forefront. I guess no one remembers that Green Lantern Earth One and WW vol 2 didn't come out that long ago.
I do know, and I'm still looking forward to get them, are there any new titles in development?
REALLY hope Matt Reeves takes inspiration from Batman Earth One storyline for his film, as what has been revealed about it feels very much in line with what was done here. Also, it would be good to take elements from newer stories, like this, instead of once again taking inspiration from the great Long Halloween, which Nolan already took elements from. Fingers crossed
That being said (what I said below)...I still enjoyed the Earth One comics and buy them whenever they come out. They are still great quality books and most importantly interesting. They just need to bring Superman back to his true personality that's all.
"IGN didn't like Earth One: Superman because he was an angsty boy," probably explains why I loved Earth One: Superman lol.
But also you nailed it on the head when you talked about the release schedule of the Earth One lineup.
Kinda why I love Earth One Clark also, reminds me of Peter Parker.
Same, but hey, its just criticisms
Honestly he’s not actually that angsty, sure he’s not as much of a Boy Scout but he’s still far from the Superman we see in man of steel or other Superman reimaginings. He’s basically just the original Clark with a few character flaws. Trust me, there are a lot more angsty characters than this Clark.
I loved all three volumes of Superman.
I liked the Batman volumes for the most part.
I have very mixed feelings about the Wonder Woman and Teen Titans releases.
I never knew there was a Green Lantern volume until this video.
Gonna track it down now!
Good stuff, not too many ads.
The fact that they weren't series and only graphic novels was definitely a mistake. Ultimate was successful because it did everything that Earth One did but far more consistently through having their line consist of ongoing series. That means that every issue the reader was brought to light a new interpretation or twist on the mythos, which was part of the appeal for sure was that "what's going to happen?" Factor. Earth One still has that element of surprise with the reinvention of continuity but I feel like they failed in having the reader wait. At the end of Batman Earth One, I was very excited about this universe's Riddler. But then time passed... and I stopped caring and then was reminded that "oh yea, Earth One Universe is still a thing?"
If DC were to ever do another Ultimate like line of books (which I would love) they should have it consist of ongoing series
or give it a consistent release date, but with the volume format.
Oh thank u for doing Earth One. I was talking about this for a couple years now. I picked up Earth One Batman vol 1 and 2 for my bday in 2016 nd loved the hell out of them. I never checked out Superman cuz I think its wring to assume Superman has to b dark every time they want a new take on him. I checked out Teen Titans vol 1 nd 2 and was not happy about them. I LOVE WW earth1 both volumes and still have to get GL. I thought the seriese was a great idea. Whole stories out in 1 go, it felt like a much better way of handling it then New 52 & Ultimate.
Superman: Earth One actually has a light color palette and a charming sense of humor. Its just Clarks angsty personality and mannerisms that makes it seem dark.
I feel if superman Earth one got made into an animated movie i could see Lilly rabe for Lex david kaye for Zod and Liam O'Brien For Parasite
batman earth1 is my 1st batman gn. glad doomsday clock used the same writer artist team.
Superman Earth 1 was one of my favorite books
I can't remember which volume it was, but that drug addicted guy who KNEW Clark was Superman, the panel when he dies and he and Lois go into his apartment with Superman homages everywhere and SAVE ME written on the wall....first time I've ever cried reading a comic book....fucking love Earth One Superman.
Damn i need more earth one. Glad to see somebody else see man of steel taking influence from superman v1
Good news, GL Earth One is returning.
@Matthew J. R’amour yes. Can't wait
@@gabbar51ngh What? When?
@@gabbar51ngh when
Three Jokers is gonna be sooo good
Excellent summary
Great video I for one was excited when green lantern earth one vol was released followed by wonder woman vol 2. Heres hoping Batman vol 3 gets made.
I’ve gotten more enjoyment out of the Earth one books than I’ve gotten upset or disappointed with it’s. I really enjoy Batman and Green Lantern E-1. I’d love to see them expand on it more and write more books. I want a more grounded universe.i LOVE reinventions and darker more realistic takes. I think it’s why I’m drawn to some of Zack Snyder’s work with the characters. Anyway, of course you are right and have some good insights, I think that people would noice it more if they continued to write more for it and bring the characters together,
yeah. Flashpoint was really a missed opportunity. The could've delayed earth 1 superman and batman to come out after flashpoint, then release them instead of the new 52 with consistent schedules. Then release a wonder woman book, then green lantern, flash and aquaman books. Then have them team up with a justice league book. Then release a titans book. Then a elseworlds book for out of continuity, self contained stories. Then constantine and martain manhunter books. And in 2021, release a young justice book. And then you could make dc animated series based on superman, batman, wonder woman, green lantern, flash, aquaman, justice league, teen titans, elseworlds, constantine, martain manhunter and young justice to create synergy between the animated series and books.
Keep ‘me coming! (Owen and DC)
Thank you, I definitely will be releasing more videos before Earth One gets another book haha.
I loved all of these series. Particularly Superman, Batman, and Green Lantern. I need parts two of Teen Titans and Wonder Woman as I felt both of those stories only felt partly done. There were shades of Earth One in Man of Steel, as well as bits of Birthright. I really liked what they did with Green Lantern, giving us a Ridley Scott like world to play in. I'd love to finally see a Justice League with these characters. Also GL volume 2 is coming later this year.
Isn't there going to be a Joker in Batman: Earth 1 Vol 3
Lets hope so
It seems the villain is more likely to be Two Face or maybe Catwoman
@@ItsButterBean1020 Female Two-Face being precise
Even though Catwoman was teased in the end of vol 2 but I think it's very likely Jessica Dent (aka female Two Face) will be the villain
I hope he isn't in it, I want Scarecrow personally, I just think Joker is really overdone. Scarecrow could be used as a chemist that was a former addict.
They can use the green lantern story in the new green lantern movie, whenever web decides to work on it.
Can you talk about static shock & the checkered history it has with DC?
I really wish this had worked out, I think that there were quiet a few things wrong with the execution, but philosophically I'm very invested in more graphic novel releases of mainline characters.
DC comics has been wasting potential since Dan DiDio started making a mess of the company.
Dan Dididiot
@@virgilbarrios3174 good one
I remember reading both Teen Titans books but not really liking them. And I’m a hardcore Teen Titans fan. Sorry but it just feels strange doing a Titans project without any of the original five in the lineup. I know they eventually tied it into some of them, but it was just off. I think they actually made Aqualad a literal half fish sort character didn’t they?
With the exception of the plotted-on-a-napkin WWE1, I would love an imprint of these. Hell. Release them as 22 page issues, each bimonthly, leap frogging each other for quality purposes. I would buy them. Especially GL and Batman.
Superman earth one practically was what Man of Steel wanted to be.
Earth One would be great if they’d cross the books over. Get us a Justice League Earth One using these alternate versions of the characters.
Or just focusing on them and giving them consistent schedules. Like, forget all that new 52, rebirth whatever's going on crap, and focus on these books and their version of these characters by making them the definitive version.
I do agree that it needs some work, but I liked some earth one titles and I want a superman vol. 4 to wrap up his story.
I liked the idea of the Earth One books, even if the execution was flawed for the most part (I wasn't crazy about JMS' Superman books and didn't care for Riddler as a murderer in Batman). I really like Morrison's Wonder Woman, if only because it makes for interesting discussion on whether returning to the bondage roots of the character is wise. It's not perfect, but I liked the attempt. Oddly enough, of any of them, I enjoyed Teen Titans quite a bit. But then, I'm a big Jeff Lemire fan.
Being a proponent for trades and graphic novels, I do see your point about the time in between each book, but that's really no different than your average novel series. DEFINITELY agree that the New 52 relaunch made this whole line feel redundant. That's a great point.
Also, your point about IGN's review scores makes me feel that it wasn't the same reviewer. I've never liked how reviews are dehumanized because it's always an individual who gives those scores, not the website as a whole.
Love the Earth One books. Shame DC treats it with such distance but at least (allegedly) Batman Earth One vol 3 will be out soon
I'll be glad Earth One exists always because of Superman burying his cat on the moon. So beautiful.
I knew there was supposed to be a Flash: Earth One but I didn't know it was supposed to be by JMS. Now I'm sad that we haven't gotten it.
I have a question for you Owen likes comics do you think the new 52 was sort of dc's answer to Marvel's Ultimate Universe or was that Heroes Reborn
I think that if dc did a new series that was to cover past years, starting from the earliest super hero year unrepresented in thos earth one comics, up to the last year represented in those comics, tracing some kind of general outline of those years, featuring anywhere from dozens to hundreds of heroes, say in a 12 issue to 24 issue mini series, it could cover some events in time gaps between issues, as between batman earth one volumes 1 and 2.
They could put out a monthly "earth one presents", and do more in depth character sketches for time periods those characters have not had covered in this continuity yet.
There could be some event written just for earth 1, whose main characters are inside a secret organization, with various super heroes being shown to often deal with setbacks sent by them, as well as with some of them starting to follow trails to this organization.
When I worked on my idea for a animated earth one movie universe I could see for the voice roles of having Tom Welling for the voice of superman and Roger Craig Smith for batman' Erica Luttrell for wonder woman and Sam Worthington for the voice of green lantern
And sadly Geoff Johns thought it was more important to give us crap like Doomsday Clock and Three Jokers instead of Batman: Earth One Vol. 3
Agreed, it was such a huge disappointment that both the Earth One and All-Star lines failed. Because at least All-Star Superman and his Earth One 3 volume series were at least finished somewhat! Whereas the others didn't even finish not too long after their firs volumes came out. Today's generation of comic artists and writers lacked the discipline of deadlines. And completing books which are promised to audiences!
I really think earth one could have been something special, especially with a lot of the new takes on characters and storylines. It could have made for an interesting foil to the main universes we are used to seeing. Sometimes I wish media in general wasn't all based around money so stories could continue and develop but that's just reality I suppose.
Good video!
Batman earth one was pretty good but its release schedule kinda screwed it from the start. That and the new 52.
I think Earth One could have worked if they were ongoing series
I got all three Superman Earth One graphic novels and would buy more if they made them.
It would be cool if DC made an animated movie or something of that nature of the Green Lantern Earth One story. Because that sounds awesome. Space Horror Superhero Comic Book. Like c'mon that should be the Green Lantern Movie!! It would be totally different then Marvels cosmic universe. Just an idea 😅
Thank you for this video. I love Batman: Earth One
You're welcome, glad you liked it! And same here, it's one of my favourites
I had the fortune of reading the Batman earth one vol 1 and 2, I remember enjoying them both. The feeling after this was that we would get a third volume that would introduce Selina Kyle as the last panel of the previous volume showed her. However that was four years ago and I find my interest has decreased quite a bit. The Green lantern book was a very interesting read...I actually did that in one sitting. I enjoyed the idea but with all the promises of Flash and Aquaman series not mention no third bat man volume I would say that this Earth one idea got lost lost in the shuffle, especially when a lot of energy was poured into the new 52, then the re birth line and some of those writers being reshuffled around to films (geoff johns).
They take so long to come out every time I hear news about a new book releasing I’m like “OH yeahhhh, earth one...”
My personal love for the Superman Earth One comics brought me to this video
I'm kinda sad. I was excited to see what else they would've done with earth one. I would've loved to of seen a justice league earth one or a world's finest earth one.
Earth One's Riddler is one of my least favourite, he's just a sadistic killer.
@TheVirusSoftware I said he's my least favourite, I hate him too, pal.
I've literally read almost all of them just didn't read the Teen Titans ones I love the Earth One line I just really wish they'd do more with it it's awesome hopefully we'll get more sooner than later
Batman Earth 1 Vol 1 and 2 are awesome. Still noodling on to hope that Vol 3 might release someday.