Sabaton - STALINGRAD. Reaction/Analysis.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 81

  • @willghezzi
    @willghezzi 3 года назад +47

    Nice reaction as always, what I love the most about this song is the fact that the lines in which they describe the battle aren't written from Joakim, but are actually taken from the diary of a soviet soldier and simply twisted a bit to fit into the lyrics. This shows just how much sabaton loves history and how hard they try to be as accurate as possible

  • @ryndrasoffical
    @ryndrasoffical 3 года назад +32

    The father of my grandma was a soldier of the 6th german army and fell in Stalingrad. We don´t know where his grave is. One day, I will visit the city. Thanks for this video :)

    • @thomasdonadt227
      @thomasdonadt227 Год назад +2

      Have you already used the online grave search from the Volksbund Deutsche Kriegsgräberfürsorge? My grandfather was also in Stalingrad and is still missing today

    • @ryndrasoffical
      @ryndrasoffical Год назад +1

      @@thomasdonadt227 Good idea Thomas, danke!

    • @solarmacharius4577
      @solarmacharius4577 7 месяцев назад +2

      Volgograd is the biggest city on Earth. Ask you greatgrandfather, he tried to cross 1 street for 2 months.

    • @andreikornilov6967
      @andreikornilov6967 4 месяца назад +2

      @@thomasdonadt227 ребята я живу в Росси если что сейчас город называется Волгоград и погибших Немецких и Советских солдат находят и сейчас поиск затрудняется тем что карт позиций того времени почти не осталось и неизвестно где они могут быть так же неизвестно что с ними стало после плена многие погибали в дороге до лагеря и их не успевали хронить потому что пленных из Сталинграда было очень много у некоторых даже не было с собой никаких документов или даже жетона

  • @NeeceLoneWolf
    @NeeceLoneWolf 3 года назад +17

    Same with Gallipoli, Aussies got taught our side of it but the Sabaton History Channel, showed what Turkey went through. They had it as bad as we did. I love watching that RUclips channel because Indie is such a great story teller. You should watch the Seven Pillars of Wisdom episode. Poor Indie lol. He played Lawrence of Arabia in that video and his camel story, so funny because i know that would happen to me for sure lol.

  • @32a34a
    @32a34a 2 года назад +4

    The savagery of this battle was above and beyond most of the battles in World War II. The fight for the Grain Elevator
    alone was extremely vicious. 50 Russian soldier defended it for 3 days against a German division and basically defended
    it to the death. Then there was Pavlov's house and on and on and on with these little little battles within such a big battle.
    Incredible heroism from the Russian soldier during this time.

  • @Sabundy
    @Sabundy 3 года назад +17

    It's not just Russia's role that gets entirely overlooked by the US so that they can claim they won it single handedly. It's also every other allied country....in particular the colonies (South Africa, New Zealand, India etc..) that get entirely overlooked and never mentioned by the US. And anyone who is intellectually honest will admit that Russia's victory on the Eastern front is almost certainly what allowed the Allies to win.

    • @lisafoster4468
      @lisafoster4468 2 года назад +3

      America is, unfortunately, pervasively egocentric....even down to the individual level...with some notable exceptions.

    • @American-Orthodox-Christian
      @American-Orthodox-Christian 2 года назад

      Not all Americans are like that. I know how much the soviets lost during ww2.

    • @panzerlord2486
      @panzerlord2486 Год назад

      @@American-Orthodox-Christian yes. Most of the losses during WWII were in the Russian front. But to completely deprive us of the credit we deserve is annoying

    • @American-Orthodox-Christian
      @American-Orthodox-Christian Год назад

      @@panzerlord2486 well yea I know about the aid we sent and it was alot, and loosing 400,000 men when we wasn’t invaded is alot. But alot of americans don’t understand that the soviet union lost at least 20,000,000 people and up to 27,000,000.

    • @panzerlord2486
      @panzerlord2486 Год назад

      @@American-Orthodox-Christian yes. Because they were pawns of war. Stalin just threw his men at hitler and hitler did the same. It was a slaughter. I don’t call that sacrifice. And technically we did get invaded. What do you think brought us into the war. And her mentioning freeing the world…what are they teaching in Russia??? That Stalin was a standup guy? Communism was hell for the satellite states and Russia itself. It was only good for Stalin and the others in power. And yes it is sad that so many young Russian men died but what about the stuff we went through? The brutal island hoping campaign? Normandy? Pearl Harbor? Guadalcanal? Midway? The ships destroyed by the Japanese? Ships Sank by German U-Boats? Everything we went through is just discredited. And it’s annoying

  • @obamna7734
    @obamna7734 2 года назад +3

    Panzerkampf is a song I think you'll love it's by Sabaton and despite it's German name it's about ww2 when Germany attacked the Soviet Union where both sides presented over 1 million soldiers to fight it's great and gets you pumped up for Russia.

  • @chrisumana7644
    @chrisumana7644 3 года назад +12

    They have a new single out now called Steel Commanders ft Tina Guo and are going to release the new single Christmas Truce from the new album they're going to be released called the War to end all Wars
    P.S Babymetal Oh Majinai ft Joakim Broden of Sabaton

    • @lovecraft8639
      @lovecraft8639 3 года назад

      Babymetal and Joakim? How could he sink down so much like you are a King and dinner with the Pigs in the mud. Babymetal is bullshit and america should nuke them!

    • @HankHill11
      @HankHill11 3 года назад

      @@lovecraft8639 what

  • @admiralkeelhauled42
    @admiralkeelhauled42 2 года назад +1

    Stalingrad was the deadliest battle in all of human history, so it was literally hell on earth

  • @jonashansson2320
    @jonashansson2320 3 года назад +5

    And also.. I think in most cases, the Sabaton fans are happy with you choosing the live performances, but they have a couple of videos that it's just a sin to miss. That's the case with "Night witches" and "No bullets fly", the story videos are just so good. And also "Bismarck" and "Steel commanders" that are of a quality that could only be described as epic.
    They have a few others that are really good too, "To hell and back", "Fields of Verdun", "Uprising" and probably some more that I have forgotten, but they are not on the level of the big 4.

  • @devinerwin4842
    @devinerwin4842 2 года назад +2

    In the US, it was the Cold War following WWII that caused us to down play the role of the USSR in the conflict. With the immanent threat of war it was not politically advantages to recognize the sacrifice and heroism of the political adversary.
    It is not right, but it is what happened.

  • @Werty19_88
    @Werty19_88 3 года назад +3

    Спрашивает внук деда воевавшего в Вермахте,дед, мол, какой самый большой город в России ты видел?Сталинград,250 дней мы не могли пройти одну улицу.

  • @mudshark5393
    @mudshark5393 3 года назад +8

    Since there doesn't seem to exist any official video (other than audio only), I think you found a pretty decent fan-made video. :)

    • @jacksmith-vs4ct
      @jacksmith-vs4ct 3 года назад +1

      yeah hehe the stuff is from the stalingrad movie from 2013

  • @SomeKrieger
    @SomeKrieger 2 года назад

    Two things,
    1. Mratnimiat reversed is “Ta i min tarm” which is Swedish Take my guts” referring to the courage and bravery the Russians had during the fight.
    2. “Play the score of the Damned. Know the devil within.” is referring to Order No. 227 ‘Not one step back’ that Stalin declared. Speaking of Stalin, the devil is Stalin in this song cause of course Stalin was an avid atheist.

  • @LunarisArts
    @LunarisArts 2 года назад +2

    3 or so minutes in as the music starts, and I'm sitting here preparing to cry from an overload of empathy. Yes, I'm Finnish. Yes, my grandfather fought in the
    Winter wars (he refused to tell about it because it was a horrible time nd he did things he never wanted to remember, and actually looked down on those who told stories as "people who never truly experienced hell"), but as Sabaton portrays it from a soldiers or civilians point of view, I'm not biased by the governmental bs sending men and women to the front like meatshields to defend their ideology. I feel the fear, sorrow, anger and hopeless denial of every one who died in vain for the sake of the priviliged few.
    Edit: I, some times, want to find a desolate place where I can scream until my voice is nno longer there, because I often feel the screams of the past demanding their voice.

  • @PetterVessel
    @PetterVessel 3 года назад +2

    I like how Joakim use the voice in this song. And now they're out with Christmas Truce! :D :D :D

    • @PetterVessel
      @PetterVessel 2 года назад

      And by friday : Soldier of Heaven! :D

  • @jonashansson2320
    @jonashansson2320 3 года назад +6

    While you are absolutely correct in that it was Russia who did the heavy lifting against the germans, I'm not so sure that the poles, hungarians, romanians and so on was so happy about the russians "saving" them..

    • @MAGNATEO
      @MAGNATEO 2 года назад +2

      I need to say that Romania and Hungary were a AXIS power same like Bulgaria, only Poland and Czechoslovakia need that "saving" from USSR.

    • @kevramsey4733
      @kevramsey4733 Год назад

      ⁠​⁠​⁠@@MAGNATEOCzechoslovakia was as much a part of the axis as the others

  • @ВиталийСавченко-у5з
    @ВиталийСавченко-у5з 2 года назад +2

    I subscribe simply because you are a competent, fact-analyzing person. So also loving rock and Dimasha. PS, I'm from Russia...

  • @Sannoz
    @Sannoz 3 года назад +1

    Love that you pointed out that 🤟 . Hitler's mistake was going in to Russia when his general's told him stay focused on West and take UK. But he made the fatel move to push in to Russia and the downfall for Germany in ww2 was the battle of Stalingrad. Russia turned the ww2, specialy at Stalingrad where they sent in people in to the front where 1 out of 3 had a rifle, 1 fall the other 1 picked up the gun! Love from 🇸🇪

  • @blodekont5458
    @blodekont5458 2 года назад

    America wanted from Normandy race to Berlin... They left The Netherlands, to their own... overestimated themselves in Operation Marketgarden, left Netherlands to be liberated by Canada. It forgetd a everlasting relation between both countries, where the Liberation is annually celebrated, flying the living Canadians over to re-celebrate, one year before covid it stopped, whereas almost all veterans of Canada where deceised, but still the Canadian cemetaries are kept pristine by schoolkids.

  • @irshat30
    @irshat30 Год назад

    Sabaton took a video from the Russian film "Stalingrad". There is also a German film "Stalingrad " , you need to watch two films

  • @fenrisulfur842
    @fenrisulfur842 2 года назад +2

    if i remember right, the actual Scenes are from a german movie "Stalingrad", about the Battle of Stalingrad. Its from the early 90s but still in the same league like Private Ryan. Its such a horrible movie, in a authenticity they showed the atrocity

  • @joey_556
    @joey_556 2 года назад +1

    Now you gotta react to Bismarck and A Christmas truce by sabaton

  • @pikzl_ghost7770
    @pikzl_ghost7770 Год назад

    Despite what people may say, I believe that every single soldier deserves to be remembered, allied and axis, not the SS, they were a “government agency” filled with cowards, but aside from that. Even the Wehrmacht had aside some pretty impressive feats and honorable moments

  • @HankHill11
    @HankHill11 3 года назад +2

    please react to more sabaton. love the songs and the videos. and all though its true here in the US we probably do not give the russian people the credit they deserve in WW2, those of us who didn't stop learning after school know the truth

  • @melkor3496
    @melkor3496 3 года назад +1

    More sabaton reactions plz. :) regards from Sweden

  • @dgantzbass
    @dgantzbass 3 года назад +3

    Did you watch the live version of Attack of the Dead Men with Radio Tapok from the Moscow show yet? I'm going to guess yes!!

  • @jensenmekk
    @jensenmekk 3 года назад

    I mean i had read somewhere that after the battle of stalingrad those german refugies was given prunes pudding,juice,raw prunes and only that for days,so the russian take them out on the streets for an kilometers walk,than after comes back with the refugies to make them clean up their mess

  • @sujetovacio1213
    @sujetovacio1213 2 года назад +1

    You should try Stalingrad by Accept too. Trust me.

  • @geertjanssen8455
    @geertjanssen8455 3 года назад

    .... and a phenomenal singer of course. Keep up the good stuff ❤️

  • @qully1047
    @qully1047 3 года назад +1

    Hello!
    I'm looking forward to it.
    Please react to the song "dissension" by Japanese female band nemophila.

  • @miroslavkocic9918
    @miroslavkocic9918 2 года назад +1

    Please react to last dying breath. The song is about the heroic feat of the Serbian army in the WW1. Serbs and Russians are brothers.

  • @alexs7189
    @alexs7189 3 года назад +2

    As an Italian I am sorry that our countries were at war, in the battle of Stalingrad there were also the Italians.
    According to the most recent estimates, the USSR lost 28 million people during the war, including 11 million soldiers, all other civilians.
    Axis nations, in particular Nazi Germany, wanted to exterminate the Slavic people, for them they were like Jews, they already had plans to exterminate 70% of the Russian population, the Soviets fought to defeat a genocidal dictatorship that wanted to annihilate them .
    We can say that your grandfather also fought for your right to exist in a certain sense.
    Greetings from Palermo in Sicily.
    P.S. In Italy we have streets dedicated to Stalin, Lenin, Stalingrad, Leningrad etc ... especially in northern Italy.

    • @vtsoi4413
      @vtsoi4413 3 года назад +1

      oh damn, i didn't know Italians fought on the eastern front! and i didn't know about the streetnames aswell!, as a mongolian, this facinates me!

    • @alexs7189
      @alexs7189 3 года назад +2

      @@vtsoi4413 You never stop learning, like the fact that you Mongols have created the second largest empire ever, damn you have come as far as Poland, Genghis Khan was truly an exceptional conqueror.

    • @vtsoi4413
      @vtsoi4413 3 года назад +1

      @@alexs7189 true, genghis is seen as the savoir of mongolia. His leadership united the mongolian tribes and brought peace to our country, he shaped our country. And the Italian history is also very fascinating, from the roman times to the late medieval times. You guys were really advanced in the early medieval times. Alot of structures and infrastructure is STILL here and alive.
      PS: history is really fascinating, im gonna start a historian career, not easy but worth it. And sorry for the really late reply btw. I didnt get any notification about this.

  • @ПавелНедев-р1ч
    @ПавелНедев-р1ч 3 года назад

    If you wanna check out Nicola Sedda. He has bigger vocal range than Dimash. Actually his highest note is F10. That makes him the singer with the biggest voice in the world. Because his vocal range is (C1-F10). Scientists even say that the highest note that an ordinary person can make is up to F10. If you don't believe me, watch the video on his RUclips channel, where he demonstrates his entire vocal range. Initially, start with the song "The Miracle". You will ask why I tell you all this, because you are a fan of rock music, and he himself is a rock star, because sometimes in some of his videos he makes the devil horn sign, and in all of his songs you will hear incredible heavy guitar playing, but sometimes his voice changes from rock singing to high classical or opera singing. which even goes beyond the limit of normal singing. The music he makes is the style of bands like Rush, Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Dream Theater and others. I hope you like and enjoy Nicola Sedda vocal range.

  • @connorward2400
    @connorward2400 3 года назад

    The famous quote about the war being won with British brains, American brawn, Russian blood. It was the Russians who turned the tide of the European theatre before the Americans had even mobilised. Britain had won in the sky and were beating the Italians in Africa but didn't really have a way of going on the offensive after the fall of France at the start of the war.

  • @AGDinCA
    @AGDinCA 3 года назад +4

    Anastasia - I promise you, there are plenty of Americans who have taken the responsibility of learning the _actual_ history of the world. We know who really did the brunt of the work... and who suffered losses more than all others _combined._

    • @jacksmith-vs4ct
      @jacksmith-vs4ct 3 года назад

      agreed though it was definitely a team effort as America supplied Russia and Britain with equipment and food and such well before we joined the war. If America never got involved even with supplies at all I truly think the Russians would have stopped them eventually but it would have been much much worse.

    • @AGDinCA
      @AGDinCA 3 года назад +5

      @@jacksmith-vs4ct Of course! American efforts in WWII were very important, no doubt! But, we were not quite the saviors as some of us were taught. Know what I mean? 😉

  • @dorlonelliott9368
    @dorlonelliott9368 2 года назад

    Christmas Truce? Floor on the ending credits...

  • @КонстантинГоломозов
    @КонстантинГоломозов 3 года назад +1

    Потрясающее произношение. Хотя я прям с первых минут понял, наша)

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  2 года назад

      Конечно ваша:)

  • @gorbog1
    @gorbog1 2 года назад

    I love how you react and I’d love to see you react to Shiroyama by Sabaton

  • @travisnoffsinger1703
    @travisnoffsinger1703 3 года назад

    Great reaction! Love Sabaton! You should definitely check out Sabaton’s new song “Christmas Truce”. It’s amazing and beautifully done. 👍🏻

  • @ПавелНедев-р1ч
    @ПавелНедев-р1ч 3 года назад

    And I almost forgot Nicola Sedda can sing in very metal rock range, that is true.

  • @Arathorn29
    @Arathorn29 8 месяцев назад

    Ты большой молодец.Продолжай!!!!!!!!!!я подписан

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  8 месяцев назад +1

      большое спасибо

  • @lisafoster4468
    @lisafoster4468 2 года назад

    You should see the Night Witches story video, seriously ruclips.net/video/5YPo8zDkvy4/видео.html you'd love the representation. Also, check out Attack of the Dead Men ruclips.net/video/-AFdwoyNT24/видео.html As a Russian, I think it'd make you proud.

  • @thomaskohl7210
    @thomaskohl7210 2 года назад

    My grandfather fell in Stalingrad

  • @panzerlord2486
    @panzerlord2486 Год назад

    2:09 Oh wow…i didn’t know the Russians bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I didn’t know the Russians charged the beaches of Normandy :/

  • @user-svetliy1963
    @user-svetliy1963 3 года назад +2

    Спасибо за реакцию!
    Коль речь зашла о Великой Отечественной Войне, есть у группы "Кипелов" песня "Непокорённый о блокаде Ленинграда. Пожалуйста, сделайте реакцию на эту песню.
    ruclips.net/video/MDS1f6ne1tA/видео.html

  • @yosch1994
    @yosch1994 3 года назад

    Please react to Faouzia - Tears of Gold (Stripped)

  • @dorlonelliott9368
    @dorlonelliott9368 3 года назад

    11 albums to go...

  • @andreasgaming9765
    @andreasgaming9765 3 года назад

    Could you react to sabaton talvisota?

  • @steveclarke4542
    @steveclarke4542 2 года назад

    Everybody but the losers think they won WWII. Russia sacrificed the most ppl against the Germans (as an American, Russian soldiers are honored and never forgotten). The US Navy sank every single Japanese warship from aircraft carriers to battleships, down to corvettes. Every trade ship and most of their fishing boats. US Army, Marines, Brits, Ausssies and Kiwis took every island in the Pacific and pushed the Imperials back to the Home Islands. My Da was first wave, Okinawa. No Russians. He and his buddies took it. Thank God for the Bombs afterward.
    Everybody did their part. For lack of one, everything would have fallen apart.

  • @sylvainvanduyl6143
    @sylvainvanduyl6143 2 года назад

    Привет Анастасия.
    Not a history channal...
    But Sabaton is not close to their history correctness ...
    Like the song 'Uprising'. What a load of myths and 'western' lies.
    I love to watch the youtuber called TIC. He is making the longest documentairy about a single Battle, the battle of Stalingrad.
    Soviet (propaganda) wasn't always right. But the post war American (and western Europe) stories weren't true eather.
    Like TIC said, the truth is in the debate.
    I Always loved Sabaton. But their songs are just simple Wikipedia songs with no research.
    And that is wrong!
    Have a nice day.
    Пока пока.