Why Volkswagen Is Beating Tesla In Europe
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 ноя 2021
- In the U.S., Tesla dominates the conversation around electric vehicles, but in Europe, it’s a different story. Germany-based Volkswagen Group has risen from the ashes of its 2015 emissions scandal to become the EV market leader in Europe, where it has an edge thanks to local manufacturing, brand familiarity, and cheaper price points. But whether Volkswagen can broaden its appeal to become the global EV leader remains to be seen.
Germany-based Volkswagen Group has risen from the ashes of its 2015 emissions scandal to become the EV market leader in Europe, where the company reported that it had 26% market share in the first half of 2021. While Tesla’s Model 3 has been selling well in the region, Volkswagen’s local manufacturing, brand familiarity and cheaper price points have helped give it an edge over Tesla.
But as Elon Musk aims to start production at the Berlin Gigafactory by year’s end, Volkswagen’s lead could be short-lived.
In the rapidly growing EV market, analysts say the Volkswagen Group benefits from its wide array of brands, which includes luxury marques like Audi, Bentley and Porsche. VW’s most popular EV in Europe is the more affordable ID.3, a hatchback that starts at around $40,000. And in September 2020, Volkswagen released the ID.4, an SUV aimed at the global market that has since become Volkswagen’s top-selling EV overall.
However, Volkswagen still lags behind Tesla globally. Tesla delivered more than 627,000 EVs in the first three quarters of 2021, while Volkswagen sold about 293,000 cars. But Volkswagen, along with other traditional automakers and EV startups, plans to release an abundance of new all-electric models in the next decade.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
» Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
Subscribe to CNBC PRO: cnb.cx/2NLi9AN
#CNBC
Why Volkswagen Is Beating Tesla In Europe
I am living in Europe and had to decide on an EV as company car. I testdrived a Model Y and an Skoda Enyaq. Both are compareable in size. The Tesla was 20k more expensive. But that was not really important being a company car. My conclusions had been that Tesla is ahead in Software and charging (Supercharger network). And the VW/Skoda was ahead on comfort, Interaction design (due to physical buttons), space, security (Tesla did not even have a cover for the trunk, so everything would be flying around in case of an accident). service network and brand trust.
We decided for the VW/Skoda and it is a phantastic car. The software is inferior. No doubt about that. But after all it is a car and not a toy.
20k is not a negligible difference.
@@zkdd23 it was on the company's dime, so no budget issues
It might seem that Tesla has increased prices to match production capacity. The price of a new model 3 has increased about 8000 USD since we got ours.
I came to the same conclusion basically and ordered the Enyaq. I must add that the leasing factor is 0.7 and thus really good. However, i ordered the car in July and still have no delivery date, not even an estimate. How long was the delivery time for your car? Greetings from Germany
What company do you work for ? VW
Can't wait to come back to this video in a year and read the comments. 😂
why wait, come back now and read this comment..........................pleassseee!!!!!
@@colmcoakley3916 😂
I don’t know who is in denial here, VW or CNBC. The most sold vehicle in Europe in September was the Tesla model 3 - not the most sold EV, the most sold vehicle! That’s without counting Giga Berlin.
CNBC still holds a grudge against Tesla... the channel still acts like a spoiled irritated kid. For that last documentary they did about (the succes of )Tesla, they talked to people who have at least a mild negative view on Tesla and Elon... it was so obvious what they were doing. CNBC can be very unprofessional
They count total sales. Not only per unit.
VW has many electric car types.
thougt the same 😂 vw (diess where is he) is f’d. also the other 2 🏴☠️
@@KaypangAsli I think that also shows Teslas problem. It is hard to make one model that everyone likes. VW group must have over a dozen entirely different models on offer now. So everyone can pick what they want.
@@andreasvelten476 This is not a problem (yet). When you sell everything you can possible produce of the current models, those become high volume products where you can drive down cost of materials and optimize production expenses. When Tesla starts to produce their own batteries in higher volumes, I'm sure we will start seing more models. But for now it does not make much sense economically.
I'm still amazed that when speaking of diesel emissions cheating the part that is always left out is the rest of the auto makers who had similar cheat software for the diesels like BMW FCA Chrysler.... the information is out but it's hushed that anyone else was doing the same thing
Or the fact that no company but vw got hit with as heavy of fines and penalties
I think VW selling deisels in much higher numbers, thanks to heavily marketing their lies is the main driver for them being the main target. But yes, they all should have gotten enormous fines... but not equal fines
@@veganpotterthevegan I think it was because VW just bested Toyota and Chevrolet that same year in production numbers.... months later the diesel scandal hit and it was focused on Volkswagen
@@johnmoser2689 neither of those companies are nearly as big in Europe. And both sell a fraction of the diesel passenger cars in the US. Nearly all the diesel non-trucks sold in the US before that were from VW and their subsidiaries. WV's fine was fair. Everyone else should get fined too but per car, it would be a small consequence
@@johnmoser2689 No, it was because VW aggressively marketed their cars as Clean Diesel and then actively covered it up when they were busted.
It wasn't just some rouge engineers, the CEO of VW is going to jail for it. It was a cheating and fraud decision from the top of the company down. They are lucky they weren't sued into bankruptcy.
They were also the first to get busted and had the largest amount of cheating, and therefore were made an example of, and rightly so.
Who was funding the research to find these sophisticated cheating methods and why the EPA had already approved the cars
Virginia Tech had to get in touch with the CARB COMMISSION in California to further push the investigation
I would like to see side by side comparison numbers for all cars and trucks listed I can't believe a little VW turbo diesel pollutes anywhere close to what average turbo diesel trucks do
Before I watched this piece, I was worried about whether VW would still be in business in 5 years time. Now I share the same concern about CNBC.
Savage
Oh, VW will still be here. Immensely popular in the US.
@@FlowerGirl.MN50 Where obviously people do not care if a company with all the morals of the Mafia is their car company.
Tesla is the best car brand. Period. I'm just worried a bit, because in terms of most sold cars, they are still only ranked 12th place in the US, 18th in Europe. And now the new full-self-driving feature (FSD) barely got level 2 approved by US authorities. Elon promised it would be level 5 and fully robotaxi-ready in 2018. I mean Mercedes now already has level 3 rated vehicles on the road and Tesla barely manages to get the level 2 rating. The Mercedes also have 100 miles more range than the best Tesla, i.e. 500 miles vs only 370 miles on the Model S. I really want Tesla to bring this home, but it looks kinda bad imo. Base Model 3 costs 40K, but you can get VW, Skoda, Hyundai etc.. with same range, features, better quality for 30K already. And now I read that Tesla is opening up its supercharger network to give public access to all car brands, even though these charging stations are famously unprofitable. Damn... now I'm a kinda depressed, where did it all go so wrong???? :(:(:(
Me too, half of these videos show that not even a basic google search on the subject was done. They tackle interesting topics (which is why I click them) but always come up with half truths or obsolete data and give the wrong conclusions. I guess it's the american standard of information *shrugs*.
I'll revisit this video in a year after Giga Berlin is up and running.
I doubt it will change much, Teslas are much more expensive and most new cars (atleast in Germany) are sold as company cars. The company i work for doesnt have teslas as company cars because they dont get a good enough price for them.
Correct!!!
You Americans don’t understand how stuff works in Europe
What cars are sold as company cars mostly? Estate cars! Tesla isn´t making them because they think nobody want´s them. The others are not making them to not not cannibalize their ICE cars. I think the first real, elegant looking and technically advanced electric estate car without SUV optics will be a great success.
This factory is going to create a whirlwind on the European car market.
I’m not necessarily a fan of Musk but his level on commitment to the EV cause is extraordinary. He dragged the entire industry forward by at least 15 years and forced every other manufacturer to re think and recalibrate their EV timeline.
that how it seems on the surface if you dont know the laws in the EU that were put into place in 2010 before Tesla had even sold a single model S.
Every single EV you can buy today has been in development for years because everyone knew since 2010 that they need an EV to meet their fleet emissions limits in the EU starting from 2020 on.
This video also fails to understand that entirely, its all thanks to regulations and not related to Dieselgate.
It's more government policy than Elon. Multiple countries have substantial EV policy and investments
Yeah he’s a real generous guy pah, he wants to be the biggest battery supplier in the world he doesn’t care at all about the cars, just more of them so they buy his batteries.
@@johnnyfounder951 thats a real funny take on this considering Tesla is not producing any batteries right now let alone selling any to car manufacturers.
@@Pixelplanet5 Tesla (through its partnership with Panasonic inside the Tesla factory) are the worlds largest manufacturer of auto batteries in, a JV is not a supplier relationship, you might want to do a bit more research.
It does help that Volkswagen has a flexible dedicated platform, MEB, that allows VW to produce a large number of models fairly quickly (ID.3 and ID.4 now, ID.5 and ID.6 soon). Volkswagen is also developing a modified MEB platform for smaller cars that will replace something like the Polo model.
I concur. I am living in Europe and had to decide on an EV as company car. I testdrived a Model Y and an Skoda Enyaq. Both are compareable in size. The Tesla was 20k more expensive. But that was not really important being a company car. My conclusions had been that Tesla is ahead in Software and charging (Supercharger network). And the VW/Skoda was ahead on comfort, Interaction design (due to physical buttons), space, security (Tesla did not even have a cover for the trunk, so everything would be flying around in case of an accident). service network and brand trust.
We decided for the VW/Skoda and it is a phantastic car. The software is inferior. No doubt about that. But after all it is a car and not a toy.
@@arvedludwig3584 I did hear about that. But I think it applies mostly to US production. The chinese cars are better. Most likely I tested a chinese one.
It's been reported on other EV vlogs that it takes VW on average 30 hours to build their EVs while it takes Tesla only 10 hours.
@@richardcogbill6791 It is not important how long the assembly takes because that depends largely how pre-manufactured the parts arrive in the factory. If VW takes longer then most likely because it does more assembly inhouse.
It also helps that VW build quality is much better than tesla and they have a decent dealer network. US car manufacturers have never done well in Europe
Short awnser - here in Czechia the entery level Model 3 costs as much as mercedes E class, whereas the base model ID3 can be had for the same money as a well specked Golf.
EDIT:
There have been some valid counterarguments, which I want to address:
1. Base model Tesla gives you a lot more tech than a base model ID3:
That's true, entery level ID3 doesn't have things like a heat pump, adaptive cruise controll (or vw offered a model without those, when I looked at it - they change it often). But especially the adaptive cruise controll/autopilot is one of those things that are nice to have but only useful when you drive long distances often. As they mentioned in the video, people here generaly don't drive nearly as much as you guys in the US (from my own experience I can tell you that driving 2 km to a train station, taking a train to a nearby city and moving around the city using trams, buses and trolleybuses is far more convenient and usualy quicker than driving directly where I need to go, likely because public transit vehicles have their own lanes and priority at bussy intersections; and I don't need a fancy autopilot to drive 4 km up and down a hill a day), so adaptive cruise controll/autopilot is one expensive thing that many customers can drop without remorse. Similar arguments can be found for many other software features of Teslas that VWs lack - nice to have but not really necessary for many people. VW at least gives you the option to not have what you don't need/can't afford.
2. Once the Berling factory is running Teslas will get cheaper:
Again - that’s true. Once VW builds it's battery factories VWs will get cheaper. What’s the price difference going to be in 6 years is anyone’s guess.
3. Tesla has better batteries than everyone else.
Possibly true. I don't know enough about batteries to critisize other people's work but my instict tells me it's a bit more complicated than just comparing a hadnful of possibly cherry-picked paramters like capacity and charge/discharge efficiency plus I belive VW has partnered with LG and Samsung who also make some really good batteries. However let's give Tesla the benefit of the doubt - even then superior technology is not a golden ticket to success. They also need to turn it into product the general public wants and can afford and VW has a huge andvantage there.
Yeah, i think that's the point
A Model3 is more like a Golf GTI...
@@C4H6As That's still a diffrence of around 13 000 usd between entry level Model 3 and Golf GTI / ID3.
@@C4H6As yeah the consumer group for golf gtis might be lucky and happy about that but thats like saying yeah its enough to sell the model 3 for those maybe 9% of car drivers within a nation.
@@frogg8891 There is massive depreciation and maintenance that needs to be done on the VW plus the cost of petrol is enough to eat up that $13000 in a couple of years. Bottom line is still the bottom line and this is entirely why people are moving to EV. The difference between the ID series cars and any Tesla is like comparing a yugo to a bentley( which is also owned by VW)
CNBS is hilarious. This is after the CEO already said they need to change in order to compete with tesla.
They got another call from the oil and gass-holes that they need to step up the lies or their funding will be cut. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yeah because he wants to cut jobs lmao. Nobody at VW is against EV's and the workers council actually want to transition even faster than already planned.
Hey Kony Stark, Correction on the lettes CNBC It’s actually CNBS.Just ask Steven
Yeah.. CNBS!
This article overlooks Tesla's supply constraints. Tesla is selling every car it's capable of making. This isn't a zero-sum game where only Tesla or VW can "win". We're seeing the gradual conversion of the car market to EV, and Tesla's advantage is that their balance sheet isn't carrying ICE assets that will shortly flip to become liabilities.
Because build quality and reliability mean something in Europe
Europe haven’t bought into to the overvalued hype of Tesla
Comical. Are you seriously claiming European vehicles represent anything resembling "quality"? European vehicles usually crowd the very bottom of the reliability scale, and most European cars in the USA are Lease and Dump vehicles only due to their dismal reliability and stratospheric maintenance cost after the warranty expires...
@@redbaron6805 Maybe because Muricans don't change oil
European vehicles made in Europe represent quality. Due to Americas less skilled workforce the cars produced there are also of low quality.
Also Tesla cars really are throwaway with their batteries.
@@illya3859 Not sure what you are basing that on. European cars are known to be notoriously unreliable and are considered basically leased cars you dump after 3 years.
And who would Tesla's be throwaway with their batteries and not European EV's which use inferior battery technology?
Your claims here make very little sense.
Just ask Audi E-tron owners, or Porsche Taycan how reliable these cars are... NOT REALLY.
I really hope that VW can afford to ramp up production of EVs and get positive margines one day so that the huge dept that VW has today can come down to normal size.
debt
@@anemeth9281 doubt XD
@@dragonmartijn Trust :)
VW group is corrupt inside out
VW will never go under, 25% owned by the state of Lower Saxony
I’m pretty sure the people that programmed my TDI to cheat on a test are more than capable of writing superior software for their electric cars.
ID.3’s software was full of bugs for a while from 2020 to 2021. Still needs fixing.
Hahaha! Nice one
Yes, they will probably lie about the efficiency of the cars. IMO.
superior to Tesla's software people?
HAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHA
Diess wants to move VW to EV's, but many at VW are fighting the change. VW needs Diess to survive the change.
Maybe that’s cuz no one wants to buy electric cars since their range is not enough to leave the state
VW and all the Europeans need to learn to be ethical first and they also need to earn to do honest business. They have only one god and that is MONEY.
He's going to get fired or just frustrated at their lack of willingness to convert and quit. I give him a year at most.
@@squidproquo2241 and whats different in the USA?
@@squidproquo2241 i think you meant the US there buddy
The fanboys have already arrived in masses. Lol
Most probably since Europeans value the quality of component consistency and assembly over pizzaz valued by Americans, Australians etc.
No, most Europeans value cheap and tiny cars.
@@KBS_ar Europeans cheap and tiny cars ? Audi, Bmw, Mercedes, Ferrari, Porsche, Lamborghini, McLaren, Rolls Royce, Bentley, Jaguar, Volvo, Aston Martin, Volvo, Polestar, Landrover all "cheap" and "tiny" :-)
Yeah these are very cheap cars compared to Ford, GM :-)
@@THEREALZENFORCE
When I say ‘Europeans’ I mean the masses not the top 1%.
Go look at the most sold cars in Europe, they are all cheap and tiny cars.
@@KBS_ar "Most cars in Europe cheap" ridiculous claim because the same cars in Europe cost (listing prices) more than the same cars in the USA.
The average VW Golf, Renault Megane costs more than a V6 Mustang. A BMW M3 costs way more in Europe as the same M3 in the USA.
You missed the part about Herbert Diess having significant pressure put on him from inside VW and possibly being forced out in the future for trying to push VW hard to EVs. He invited Elon Musk to a meeting of executives to discuss how to changed the culture of VW to make it more nimble. Diess has also spoken strongly about how worried he is that Tesla can build a vehicle in about 10 hours in the new versions of the factories, where it takes VW 30 hours to get through the assembly line. You also missed that the Model 3 was the best selling car in Europe in October, not just best selling EV, best selling car. Diess and the CEO of Ford have both spoken about how significant that is. This is the first time in the history of auto manufacturing when the best selling car was made outside of Europe.
Convienently missed those "Mic dropping" points. 😁
Tesla are not being blown away by VW, but VW has money behind it to be a serious competitor, especially if they are very focused on VW and take Tesla very seriously (which they do).
Also October hit many car makers very hard because of chip shortages. Something not affecting Tesla so badly. October car production in the UK for instance is the lowest since the 1950's. With not enough new cars, people have gone to buy 2nd hand cars with some 2nd hand cars apprichating by 60% in 2021 due to demand. I think Tesla may be the best selling new car but 2nd hand (1-3 year old) models of VW out sell Tesla.
Will be interesting to see if Tesla can sustain its top place once everyone else can start manufacturing cars again.
Tesla has a bad reputation on build quality something VW doesn’t have. The Tesla Model 3 starts over £ 40K in the UK far too expensive for a car of that type. The ID3 starts at a little over £ 30K so straight out of the blocks is attractive to more buyers. Tesla badly needs a small car in Europe that’s why it restarted talks with Toyota on technology sharing.
Not to mention that during the chip shortage Tesla was able to pivot to alternate supplies and their team was able to basically port the robust software to the new chip (with different instruction set) in about 2 weeks.
@@novainvicta Tesla will build its own small car...just as soon as demand for the medium sized cars decreases enough for them to care about it. Tesla is sold out for MORE than half a year on several of their models. Once the Texas and German GigaFactories come online...Tesla will dominate the EV market in Europe...just like they do in China and the US.
Personally I fear that they are treating EVs as cellphones and that means introducing obsolescence into the equation. We will no longer be able to appreciate great vehicles that are 30 or 50 years old. I recently found an article about a person who rebuilt a wrecked Tesla and since the company had deemed that particular unit as wrecked, the person can't do a fast charge on Tesla's chargers anymore. Say good bye to your trusted mechanic and look into replacing your vehicle more often than expected due to it's built in obsolescence.
Very good point, and that drastically raises the carbon footprint of these new offerings ...
But with less moving parts ev's should last longer or do more miles, although the battery will need to be replaced...
Trusted mechanic lol
That has nothing to do with planned obsolescence. Damaged batteries are deemed too dangerous to let laymen handle them or to be used again without verifiable repairs and Tesla doesn't want to get sued because of something that stupid.
@@ehtuanK - Then that means Teslas are a dangerous design ...
Looking back at this is actually hilarious.
You guys are missing, that Diess is under a lot of pressure at this moment and might get kicked off the throne at VW. His way to lead the company is not favorable for most high figures at VW.
that already changed in the last few days after internally clarifying that there is no alternative.
i think some petrolheads where a bit too vocal about their opinions. and the fear of losing a lot of jobs got some echo in the boulevard media.
i think his hard and consistent focus on EVs did not make him everyone's darling in the company. and recognizing the success of tesla with his buddy elon was a problem for others who only see enemies and no frenemy.
he will go through with his plans and no one can stop him.
@@stefanweilhartner4415 I would wish 🤞. I like his approach. Greetings from Bremen Germany
Tsla= Summon your car at your beckoning like a tech wizard.
VW=Fart to start.
Each appeals to a certain class of people. You can decide with your dollars what class of person you are. IMO one is CLEARLY the luxury brand 🤣
@@stefanweilhartner4415 "i think some petrolheads where a bit too vocal about their opinions. and the fear of losing a lot of jobs got some echo in the boulevard media."
No it's an internal thing and it has to do with the way many German businesses work. Diess, along with acknowledging they are years behind Tesla also said that the move to EVs would mean a reduction in jobs, and the union there doesn't like it. Unions have more say in Germany. So their Union is fighting against Diess. There's also a segment of the company that wants to slow the move to EVs, and this isn't VW specific, same is happening in the US. So, part of the management of VW along with the union doesn't want a transition to EVs to go as fast as Diess wants, and they could make a move to oust him.
Yeah office politics, involving other peoples interests. But why does it work in other companies but not VW?
I'd argue that VW was already bigger in Europe than in the US...so for that reason alone, it wouldn't be shocking to see VW EV's being accepted more readily in Europe than Tesla's offerings. People are more likely to accept a new technology from a company they already accept, then from one which appears new.
its also just untrue that vw has more demand than tesla, if you look at the numbers, tesla sells its entire quarterly shipment of vehicles into Europe in
Check Q3 2021 Ev Sales figures for europe... Tesla vastly outsells VW
Tesla doesn't make EVs in Europe meaning their supply is relatively low. So, even though demand is high, sales lag behind compared to places with Tesla factories. It's not complicated.
@@HopeIsFleeting You're 100% correct. Tesla currently only has supply for europe with what they decide to import from China. Despite this, they are still number one in Europe for Q3 2021 Plus number 2 in china... all from a single factory!
Plus, another significant point is that Tesla is the only EV manufacturer with any sort of profit margin on each car.. roughly 35% margin and constantly increasing. VW is basically selling EVs at a loss
This aged terribly 😂😂
I bought a Kia two years ago and i am propably going to do it again in 5 years WHEN MY WARRANTY RUNS OUT! I love my Stinger and if they had a compelling EV at the time i would have bought that.
ill safe you 14 minutes: home bias and the fact that tesla currently just cant build more cars and has so wait for more factories to be finished
@Michel Bruns Tesla can build more BEVs than VW now!!! VW will not have the capacity to build as many as Tesla. Not to mention Tesla builds their vehicles more efficiently than VW .
The software in Tesla is far more advanced than what is in VW vehicles, but more importantly Engineers would rather work for Tesla than VW. This is what most miss about Tesla going forward. Their level of innovation and nimbleness is what leaves most manufacturers in the dust. The Tesla brand is synonymous with BEVs, more importantly Tesla Model 3 is the hottest selling EV in EU, when Giga Berlin is running at full steam Model Y will be the hottest selling EV in EU.
As for Technology, Tesla is the leader in BEV technology....and that has nothing to do with autonomous driving, which Tesla is the best positioned.
A better way to look at the BEV picture going forward, is to see what the companies plans are for production. VW isn't even planning to match Tesla's production levels going forwards. Part of the problem for VW and other legacy Automakers is Work Force. BEV (especially Tesla) require fewer workers. The BEV work force needs to be better trained and more nimble in abilities. This means the Legacy auto business will be a drag on BEV advancement, especially with companies that are Union shops.
Tesla does have serious competition that will probably overtake it as the leading BEV manufacturer. BYD is probably likely to be the new Toyota / VW, Tesla will largest premium brand in the BEV market. As for the Legacy Automakers, it is going to be a difficult road. Brand loyalty will be tested with EVs because their performance is so different than ICE.
www.motorbiscuit.com/tesla-electric-vehicle-10-hours-volkswagen-production-ceo-unable-keep/
@@tonespeaks i didnt read most of your comment, but i meant that tesla cant build/ship enough cars, IN EUROPE, to outsell vw there, which is the topic of the video, we are only talking about europe
@@michelbruns Historical event in the German models ranking: the VW Golf’s down -41% year-on-year it only holds 3.5% of its home market. In contrast, the Tesla Model 3 (+146%) takes the brand’s backloading in end-of-quarters to the next level and ends the month at #2 overall, only 58 sales below the Golf and smashing its ranking, volume (6.828) and share (3.5%) records in the process.
Here comes Tesla fan boi
@@xcortians482 If the Tesla fan boi is also a Tesla stockholder (like me) then we have a LOT to be a fan about. Ka-ching
Let's revisit this piece once Tesla begins production at its Gigafactory in Berlin.
VWWolfsburg plant makes already 1 M Gold a year, can switch to e-Golf anytime hahaha
@@brunokoegler2189 no. You can’t “just switch”
@@brunokoegler2189 oh, thats why VW plans to build a new plant in Wolfsburg for EVs. You can’t just switch to EVs in ICE-plants, to be competitive you need green fields, EVs from brown fields aren’t competitive in the long term. Tesla builds a car in 10h, VW needs 30h. Longterm that’s a huge problem.
@@brunokoegler2189 Its not just like an and on & off switch dude they need new infrastructure for EVs thats why Herbert Deiss is already sounding the alarm because not just Tesla but also other start ups who is not worry hurting their ICE sales whenever they sell an EV will eat the OEMs alive.
And once people in east Germany feel reminded of Trabi built quality when they get their first TESLA.
The best new Electric vehicle from VW is from his subsidary Skoda the Skoda Enyaq IV Coupe which will compete with the model y and can be bought for an affordable price.
But if you like buy it
But don’t spend your life compareing it to a Tesla because it not
Its nearly the same price as an model y long range if you want to same amound of options so no its not cheap just the base price but you need to add like 10-15k if you want the same amount of options that that tesla has standard and the model 7 har 350hp and the enyaq coupe has like 265hp in the highest trim with awd. And the Enyaq drivetrain is outdated compared to a model y just compare the effincy between the model y and enyaq.
@@stewarthalliwell Yeah Tesla are ranked among 3 worst reliable car brands according to consumer reports, over half all the ever produced Tesla cars have been recalled, panel gaps, FSD issues and inspection by authorities, stuck at level 2 FSD for years, stuck at 2017 400 volt tech for years, yeah Tesla is pretty bad compared to Skoda cars (quality, reliable, affordable)- And for 10k les than a Model 3 and Y, people can buy the car of the year Kia EV6GT (quicker recharge, as quick accelerations, same range, better interior, better FSD, can recharge other cars or electric devices) all better than the bad Tesla cars
It’s ugly And you can’t go anywhere
Great for Luxembourg
Well, in December Tesla Model 3 was Europe’s best selling car, not just EV. With a Berlin gigafactory just opened seems Tesla are going to lead in 2022 and beyond.
In Norway you dont see many vw electric. So expensive, half distanse of what a Tesla can do. Tesla is cheap, charges fast, goes further. Always inovating.
This video is not going to age well. Giga Berlin is about to start production. Let’s see what the numbers look like in a few months.
100% of cars sold in Europe will be a Tesla. You just wait and see 😂
@@messijr5145 The fact that the model 3 was the best selling car in Europe without Giga Berlin up and running suggests otherwise. Fortunately for both of us, we can simple wait a few months and see how it plays out.
@@messijr5145 I am an european, never in my wildest dreams thought I'd buy an american car. Absolutely love my Tesla. I don't think people think of Tesla as being in the problematic american car category. Seems your president agree.
@@messijr5145 that’s why the model 3 was the best selling overall car in Europe in October? Imagine if they actually liked them!?
@@dubbelosexy That’s never gonna happen
As a Swede that just ordered my first EV and real family car cause children. I had to go with Skoda Enyaq/VW brand. I wanted to compare an Tesla model Y but for starting price at 20.000k more then an mid specced VW/Skoda it was easily out of the budget. Maybe in 3 years hopefully they can compete with the German factory!
Unlikely, Tesla will never move downmarket, they simply have to maintain their luxury margins to stay competitive.
It will be much less than three years...next year they will be pumping out Model Y's and will not have to pay transport or import taxes / fees. The supply shortage will end in the near future...and then the Model Y and Model 3 will be going back down in price to where they started. It's simply too few Tesla vehicles for the amount of demand for them right now. Giga Berlin and Giga Texas will start changing that next year.
@@xxXCromaxXxx which is ironic as wasnt the model 3 supposed to be the peoples car for 30k$?
Inte riktigt rätt att jämföra en model Y med en Skoda…
@@xxXCromaxXxx That's actually untrue. Tesla currently has a margin of >28% on the Model 3/Y, and this is being manufactured at just 2 factories currently, and expected volume will be around 900,000 vehicles for 2021.
This is important, because 2 new factories are due to begin low rate initial production of the 3 and Y in December 2021 in Berlin and Austin, TX. These factories are all new facilities designed to maximise production efficiency beyond the existing factories in Fremont, CA and Shanghai. When they hit full rate production in Q1 2023 we can expect the production numbers to go from 900K for '21 to above 2.5 Million by Q4 2023. This will enable Tesla to lower their prices significantly from the current 28% margin. The reason they are keeping prices high is because they can't keep up with demand, hence they've hiked the price by $7K on their vehicles as the order waiting time has blown out to 6 months. By 2025 we can expect a further 2 factories to be up and running which will see vehicle production increase to around 5 million vehicles per year.
This might seem incredibly ambitious, but lets remember the hard reality that the Berlin and Austin factories will have gone from an empty muddy field to producing their first vehicles in roughly 18 months, and the Shanghai factory did the same in a staggering 11 months. Tesla knows how to build their factories amazingly fast. And lets also keep in mind that the company has $16 billion in cash on hand, and only $2 billion in debt, not including their loan service to customers. Watch their revenue and earnings for Q4 2021. July to end September alone saw a net profit of $1.6 billion for the company, of which only ~$280 million was US government regulatory credits.
From January to October the sales of model 3 was at 101thousand and in a second place with 57thousand is ID3. I don’t know. Really is vw beating Tesla?
They are talking about their entire lineup but Tesla is beating them badly so much so that the CEO has had Elon speak to their leadership and the VW CEO admits they are not winning. Tesla's volume is low because they are servicing the US and EU ATM. Once gigaBerlin comes online, VW will barely be seen in the rear view mirror
The entire industry is in crisis mode, because of the changing perception of how the individual transportation of the future will look like.
To be remembered: In 2019 VW sold almost 11 million cars worldwide, operates over 100 factories all over the world, and has 600.000 employees.
That's what people think of when they refer to "economy of scale", with that alone VW will have a big advantage over Tesla.
Not to mention that they provide their workers with living wages, Government enforcement of Union participation, 30 and more days of paid vacation, bonus payments at year's end, Government subsidized retirement, * subsidized paid sick leave, * parental leave, company subsidized privat retirement plans, worker and union participation in company decisions by having seats on the company leaderboard.
@@AKAHEIZER if VW wanted to, they couldn’t sell 11 million electric cars for over a decade. Battery supply chain needs years to handle what Tesla has already ordered into. Additionally it would like VW group has some issues with batteries in their Porsche and Audi line ups. The bigger they are, the harder they fall.
Why is Tesla's charging network always singled out as such a big deal, when almost everyone just plugs their car in when they get home anyway?
It's one of the neatest things about EVs. You go outside, unplug your car, drive, do stuff, drive home, and plug it back in. It's very rare you need some other charging network or similar.
Do you travel? Doesn't seems to.
@@xavierStark84
Not in a car, no. If I'm going to another city, I'll take a train or a plane. Trains are more chill, I can sit and work and not have to care, planes are faster, so it depends on how far I'm going.
Hiya, it’s the dedicated charging network, 250 kw chargers. Vers hit and miss networks all with different cards and networks. So businesses vote for Tesla and they can use all the other networks and home charge.
That’s why they were no1.
I dream of 250 kw charging owning a leaf.
Take care M.
@@markeh1971
Either my experience or yours is localised, because 99% of the generic ones work just fine over here. IDK. Which though
@@xavierStark84 do you sleep in your car while travelling? I can always charge my car at accomodation/hotel after a day of driving.
Doesn't Tesla only ship cars to Europe a few weeks every quarter? Yet they still outsell most others companies. We'll have a better idea of the state of EVs in Europe when GigaBerlin starts production.
@@rosscomckinnon haha
@MariQ s heated seats aren’t standard?????
@@EEVOL but scratchy interior panels and cheap plastics evrywhere are :)
30k vs 40k€ lmao.
@@OG_ALviK yeah I read reviews how cheap the plastic interior looks in the ID.# models.
@@EEVOL in the VW group in general. Even on audis the quality of interior went downhill.
You can tell that this piece was written by Americans. Two points that are very important but were missed:
1) Tesla doesn't understand the European market. They're not luxurious enough to demand a premium price point and they don't produce smaller city cars that appeal to mass consumers. Their customers are all tech bros because their products don't appeal to the European market at large.
2) E-bikes are massive in Europe. They're outselling EVs left and right. And governments are focusing more on rail transit while America is still expanding its highways. It looks like the electrification of transport in Europe will be largely on two wheels and rail, not on four wheels.
Maybe true, only a train has much more wheels than 2 though!
@@JJVernig XD but the point holds.
Yea... a bigger car gives you more interior space but it's a lot more difficult to find a large enough parking spot in cities. Which is a problem for Tesla because they only sell expensive barges. In rural areas though, space is not such a constraint, however there people usually don't have either the money or the will to buy a Tesla so there is that.
Current Tesla’s are obviously designed for the American market. I highly doubt they intended for their cars to dominate in Europe. They are either working on a real European catered product, or they are content in being a niche brand in Europe. I honestly think their expansion to Europe was a bad decision. I think the company is too young to be taking such massive risk. Especially since they are building a whole factory in Europe, they really need a small car the appeals to more Europeans.
You for a word in point number 1: YET
3:07 Can we take a moment and appreciate these Batman cufflinks please
But if Tesla can build 3 cars to 1 time wise, will this not impact on VW's profitability?
Yes, so you ensure your competitors factory does not open...
@@aitorbleda8267 Ve Haff vays of stopping your production.
So? Tesla isn't the default choice for everyone. They might build them quicker, but they're built like crap. Not everybody cares about the Tesla cult.
In the video they say vw is better at scaling production but data like the speed of manufacturing says otherwise.
I’m also dumbfounded to see 50% of vehicles sold by vw in China and the us in 2030 not being electric…
@@bmw803 I don't know about their build quality, I have never examined or driven one and never will, but lots of people seem to favor buying them.
I own a VW ID3, Will buy a model 3 next time……the software aren’t even close to tesla…it drives me insane on a weekly basis
This is exactly why VW is in trouble duet to their software
Go and drive tesla and tell me about rattles. You will be grateful that you drive id3. Drove both. Software is the only thing worth in tesla together with its battery technology
Software getting major upgrade monday. Wayray is gonna announce something afterhours monday and its probably gonna be connected to metamaterials buy MMAT. Your next car is Free. Your welcome 😅😁👍🏻
@@siiNke you can tell someone is a boomer when they care more about a 3mm panel gap or a lose piece of interior causing a rattle than the software/operating system
@@siiNke VW are junk I help out at a garage and VW are one of the worse cars to own and parts are costly.
I live in U.K. I’ve seen a total of 2 EV vws in past few months. I see many teslas every day
I see no VW ev in Sydney. Tbh, I don’t anticipate any EV from VW, anyway. Hyundai and Tesla dominate the EV market here.
Maybe it’s like how it is here in the US. Most units sold are mainly in certain select cities. So not many will see them in the wild for a few years. Also, most of what’s being counted as “sold” by a legacy auto brands are actually sitting at dealership lots waiting to actually be sold to a customer.
Depends where you are Tesla higher priced so in posher areas while vw cars are everywhere plus the id cars are far newer but I see them semi regularly.
@@sallydavies9253 Fair Point
It’s all about business infrastructure, you can find a VW dealer and thus service in every major city of all EU countries. When I choose a car having the support infrastructure at a good price level is everything. Cars need maintenance and eventually break down, you need reasonably priced service that is actually available.
EVs do not require the same level of maintenance, so what you are describing is a non-issue.
@@IanHague real issue when you have to travel to another country to get an issue fixed for your Tesla. Check Tesla’s service coverage in Europe. I’m not sure you fully understand the issues those cars are having. Further more, I would not be even willing to travel to another city for fixing/ maintenance. The car is a tool and it’s sole purpose is to serve me not the other way around
not helping if "right to repair" is a thing, like an iPhone lockout.
@@IanHague they need maintainance, that should not be 300km away or part should not take 3 months to arrive..
Do you know how much maintenance an EV needs? Tyres and almost never brake pads, due to regenerative braking.
It is better to invest now. You will never be younger than you are today and there will never be a perfect time to invest. Due to compounding, which Einstein called the 8th wonder of the world, you can get rich slowly from investing if you do it from a young enough age.
Investing in cryptocurrency now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
I heard a lot about Mrs Bonnie Berville and how good she is, please how safe are the profits?
Wow I'm just shocked you mentioned and recommended Mrs,Bonnie Berville thought people don't know her..
I have also been trading with her, The profits are secured and over a 100% return on investment directly sent to your wallet. I made up to $360,000 in 2months trading with her
stock market has plenty of opportunities to earn a decent payout, with the skills and proper understanding of how the market works
Until Tesla Berlin opens Tesla is supply constrained. Silly story.
Yep… let’s talk next year when Giga Berlin is humming
The biggest advantage VW and other automakers is that I can always find a local dealer for repairs and service. Where I live I am over 5 hours away from a Tesla service center. In addition, I feel that VW and others know how to build quality cars, something Tesla is strugeling with.
Well, the repair shops is a problem partially caused by the manufacturers themselves.
As they don't like third parties having they proprietary tools, that don't need to exist, for no other good reason beside keeping owners inside of they system.
Funny enough, it promotes monopolies.
Well, you need to look at Sandy Munro's tear downs to see who makes the better EV - hint starts with a T
@@rboz4637 until you need repairs of any kind, unless you live in CA. VW and others build way better cars than Tesla. Only ONE body shop in my area can work on Tesla and if something breaks, it is 5 hours to a service center. VW is 5 min away as well as multiple Ford dealers. No thanks on that Tesla.
the scariest thing is that they still think to sell ice cars in 2030 and not go full electric...
If vw was reliable as most Japanese cars, I would buy one.
The EVs are
VW in Europe is regarded As a very reliable brand.
It's not just the cars, it's the entire infrastructure:
If I would want to buy an VW EV or if I had any trouble with it, the next dealer/workshop would be less than 10 minutes away. If I wouldn't like that specific dealer/workshop, there are 3 or 4 more within 30 minutes of travel time. The same can be said for basically any other established brand like Mercedes, BMW, and VWs own brands like Audi, or Skoda. Tesla? The next "Pop-Up" is 40 minutes away, the next service center 2 1/2 hours.
Tesla may be able to build a "gigafactory" in two years, but the kind of infrastructure big brands offer takes decades to develop - and until they are able to provide service similar to VW et al. near me, I won't be buying a new Tesla, much less a used one.
Nico I have a Nissan e-NV200 have never been to the garage in 2.5 years since I bought it. A good EV hardly needs a garage.
I have a tesla since 2019. There was a noise on my steering. They came to my house and repaired it in my driveway. In covid times, I work at home.... it´s perfect, and FAR more convenient than a dealer experience.
@@renedalmeijer8260 you have to check your car every two years. teslas are really badly built.it is good enough for americans since they do not know how to drive. but civilized people want a well built car for that price.
@@Pr0nStYle You are right it is good to periodically check your car. My experience though with Japanese cars is that they are so well built they require much less checking then what is accepted as normal. The e-NV200 I have was actually assembled in Europe/UK but it seems Nissan makes sure they are up to the same standard as Japanese built. BTW I did my first repair since I purchased the car a new windscreen wiper for the co-driver.
To be fair tesla service is impeccable but yeah it is difficult to have that kind of infrastructure.
It's all about software. Is Volkswagen the new Nokia? As a German I am not sure if they can manage to get a competitive "software company"
German engineering is on another level to American junk.
America leads the way when it comes to technology companies though.
@@TimesNewRoumen Yes sad but true. Probably because we in europe still have a bit of a anicents when it goes about computers
Unfortunely all the best ingeneurs will work on Tesla and Space X .
it might take some time, but they will get there. don't worry too much.
Meanwhile, Tesla sold twice as many EV than WV in December 2021.
Also meanwhile: CNBC desperately tries to hold on to their sponsors.
Lol I know. This is the exact opposite of reality. I don't even like Tesla but come on, their manufacturing costs and scale are lightyears ahead of VWs electric lines.
Tesla is still paying about 5000€ in import duties and probably another 5000€ for logistics costs as they have to import model 3 and y from shanghai. They also have by far the best margins in the industry, so once they can service demand the price is coming down. Give it a year of Giga Berlin ramp-up and we'll see. Right now there is just no telling.
The Berlin Gigafactory is producing bad headlines every day.
So true that different commutes, road conditions and prices built totally different markets in Euro and US
Tesla Model 3 is a large car over here, and rather expensive. (not for what it is). And then there is the perceived quality issues in the fit and finish of the Tesla's. VW's aren't perfect either. The ID3 was a software disaster end 2019, but a extensive dealernetwork makes is a better bet.
@@JJVernig but if you have driven a model Y and then a ID 4, you do start to wonder why anyone would go for the ID 4.
@@EmilKlingberg because a id4 is 20-30k cheaper. Thats why.
@@EmilKlingberg ID4 is significantly cheaper, not even including tax credits. And even then it’s built better.
@@JJVernig Tesla will blow VW away as soon as the Berlin GigaFactory Opens up an starts producing at scale. The only reason that Tesla is not currently dominating Europe, is that they don't have their factory open yet. They have to split what they make in China with Europe.
Cheers!
4:31 So Volkswagen is beating Tesla with Evs and hybrids. You do realize hybrid’s do still need gas and are not fully electric cars so you can’t put those two together the hybrid and electric cars are two separate markets lol 😂
Hybrids and EVs are frequently combined into 1 category
@@derekwood8145 which they shouldn’t but in Volkswagens case it just helps there numbers look better 🤣
You do realize that e.v.'s run on electricity generated by fossil fuels
@@weirdshibainu lol am not even talking about that what am saying is that electric cars and hybrid cars should be two separate markets cause one still needs gas and the other is full electric. They shouldn’t be categorize into the same market just to benefit other automotive companies
@@emanuelhernandez7238 you don't get it, 90% of trips are under 200 km / 130 miles, so hybrid means electric, and in case once a year for vacation, no stress end your trip on gas, maybe you'd short your TSLA stocks hahaha PER 400 ???
At the time when the ID was first produced in Zwickau, I was involved as a production assistant. They paid good money.
Why there is no mention of Tesla's self-driving EVs?
It’s their territory 😂
funniest part is, the best selling ev in Europe this year was the model 3
@@KingFinnch no, it was the best selling car in September
the TESLA European INVASION has Already begun .
Tell that to the Chinese!
@DJProject2130 that was in the UK, i was just saying that the data pulled from the article in the video was wrong less than 6 months after it was posted
This "report" is totally off. I live in Germany, and there are so many more Tesla EVs on the road than VW EVs. The total number of new Tesla EVs registered in September 2021 was 7902, and the total number of EVs registered from all VW Companies (VW, Porsche, Audi, Skoda, Seat) was at 9262. Most of the people I know who have VW EVs work either (in)directly for VW or a dealership, or are VW fans. VW lost its share of the US market due to the diesel scandal, and no amount of blowing smoke up anyones ... will fix that problem.
tesla cars usually come once a quarter. vw cars are coming every month. so, the registration numbers from only one month is misleading. also the chip shortage is disrupting the real situation. over the last two years vw alone sold more EVs in europe than tesla. that will no change after ramping up giga berlin because vw is ramping up the factory in emden and will sell the id.5 and id.buzz next year. and one year later they will open the new factory in wolfsburg.
also, the plant in chattanooga will ramp up production in a few months and the ID.4 does not need to be shipped to the US. that means more capacity for europe.
it seems to go on like in the last years. while tesla is growing an impressive +60% per year, VW is growing around +100% in EV sales per year.
EV market is changing fast with the introduction of new options.
Curious example they all seem to be struggling for high tech, high power, high price range, high...
Then Dacia (Renault) comes along with the "ugly duckling". We call Dacia Spring! A bare bones vehicle to take you from A to B. Cheap, basic, simple!
Oops moment! Who knows, the fact is that in markets where it's availability is not an issue! It simply sell like hot cakes!
Treating vehicles as high tech products, real show cases of the latest technologies. It's all fine and dandy. But it's kind of obvious there's a huge market for simple, real world vehicles! I mean, when you go to the supermarket, or commute to work. Do you really need 5 or 6 LCD monitors! And all the games, videos, etc. etc. LOL 😂
Let's get real. I'm fascinated by technology as the next guy!
@@crpth1 yes, it is enough to drive from A to B. and that is what a car is for. also VW abandoned that 'cheap' market. VW and Seat and Skoda is now practically the same - makes no sense.
For me, the Dacia Spring is not the right car, because i need or want range. But i don't have 10k€ to spend for led matrix light and an augmented reality heap-up display.
Tesla fan boy you got to wake up😂Elon himself sold $10billion worth Tesla stocks, which says something about his confidence about the company
@@Krblkn tesla stock simply hit the ceiling. and now that he moved to texas, he pays less taxes for selling the shares. that is it :-)
This is interesting, since the model 3 was the number one car sold in Europe last month. I wonder what will happen when the new plant ramps up and they aren't imports.
Source:
"FRANKFURT, Oct 25 (Reuters) - Tesla's Model 3 topped European car sales in September, marking the first time an electric vehicle has done so in monthly charts, research group JATO Dynamics said on Monday.
At 24,591 cars registered, Tesla's Model 3 recorded year-on-year growth of 58%, followed by Renault's (RENA.PA) Clio, Dacia's Sandero and Volkswagen's (VOWG_p.DE) Golf model, JATO said."
Prices for the Made-In-Germany MiG models will be lower than imported ones due to shipping costs and import duties.
Demand for Tesla's will remain super high as they ramp their local production.
This video makes a big deal about VW building a bunch of battery factories in the EU but doesn't tell you the expected output. All combined they're targeting ~240GWh by 2030. Tesla is targeting 100GWh in Berlin and ramping to ~250GWh as they build the rest of the phases. On one campus.
I'll bet money that before 2025 we see not only Berlin expanding their construction but a whole new EU factory being built by Tesla.
I wonder what happens when the rest pf the manufacturers actually can produce and are not screwed thanks to the chip shortage...
That s because Model 3 is the only model Tesla is selling in Europe. VW has for instance three main popular models and then you have the sister brands like Skoda, Audi sharing the market.
@@thomasthereal4067
They will continue to pump out many more ICE vehicles and under supply the BEVs being demanded by buyers…
Leaving more and more of a gap between the Pure BEV manufacturers and the mostly ICE manufacturers.
Tesla has deposits and / or back orders for nearly Two Million EVs.
The other automakers are failing to capitalize on the rapid transition of the industry to BEVs.
Partly because of poor planning, partly because of poor management and partly because of poor financials when it comes to BEVs.
Herbert Diess is the only major Legacy OEM automotive Exec to understand how fast things are changing…
And VW will likely fire him or try to demote him before the end of the next year. He’s telling VW the bad news and they don’t want to hear it.
Cheers
tesla has so few models, so that stat only sounds impressive
What’s the company that had the diesel gate scandal?
also love how they assume all of us in the States live on the farm and drive large dually pick up trucks for miles and miles into town to get vittles
irrelevant as EVs are 1% US market. So most people THINK that way
@@protonneutron9046 that is hilarious how you can just dismiss a demographic fact, especially since majority of electric cars can be found in metropolitan areas in the US, you could not be more wrong
@@Good-Enuff-Garage You are babbling. You didn't understand the comment because your English language skills are < 4th grader.
Tesla doesn’t have a plant opened in Europe yet … when the Berlin factory opens, what do you think is going to happen?
When the factory opens, they will build electric cars😆
one factory is gonna change the world :)))) because other companies just watch Tesla becoming bigger and bigger and not wanting a piece of the pie :))))
well i think Tesla should make a new model car rather than rely on mass produce model 3 and Y. It's pretty much boring if everyone car are Tesla model 3 or model Y
The trend mentioned in the video will continue. Ultimately as VW pushes out more EV models they are going to vastly outsell Tesla (at least in Europe). That is mainly because Tesla is a brand that offers premium cars that cost a lot of money. Meanwhile VW is going for volume products that cost considerably less. I'm sure the new European Tesla factory will be a huge success but it's unrealistic to think that Tesla will compete (in the long term) with high volume companies like VW.
The German people are doing everything they can to stop them giga Berlin was supposed to start in October bur some "environmentalist" called for review all over again to delay them when that was done they called for another again 2days ago
The number 1 thing we need in America for Ev adoption are standardized charging ports, there's currently like 3 which in my view is unacceptable
hopefully, some kind of 500kW charger will be standardized everywhere.
CCS will be the most common standard. the japanese chademo is dying and even tesla is now adding ccs to their chargers step by step. at some point, tesla will use ccs for their cars too, to let them charge on ccs chargers.
Well technically there's 2, the one everyone else uses then there's Tesla. You might think there's 3 because there's, J1772, CCS, and Tesla. But CCS is just J1772 with support for fast charging, so it's basically one plug.
Use an adapter easy peasy lemon squeasy
@@iKingRPG Spot on!
is it because VW generally makes better cars and has a much wider offering? The EV first mover advantage Tesla had is evaporating in all markets while they are still ramping up production. Tesla may have started the EV evolution but they will never dominate the car market. Its a rapidly growing transition so maybe Tesla will do just fine as a niche for the fan club.
you are funny
Still think that way?
@@thomaswilson2917 Absolutely. VW sells 8+ m cars a year and a big portion of that will slowly but gradually transition to EV as we move towards 2035 when new gasoline and diesels car sales will be banned in EU. Just look at the infrastructure investments these existing car companies are doing e.g. PowerCo as they transform their entire value chain from ICE to EV preparing for the future + they have broad governmental push and support (unlike US). Im not saying Tesla will do poorly and I appreciate everything it has done for the world but I do not believe it will ever dominate the car industry.
VW's one advantage is Tesla treats their customers who experience problems like dirt. Also, tesla has notoriously bad QC. Cars have been delivered with seats missing mounting bolts, glass roofs that have flown off cars at highway speeds and suspension components that are not torqued to required specs.
And Tesla owners have been repeatedly "punished" for complaining in the media by having their Fast-Charging rights revoked.
That certainly annoyed Tesla cultists here 😂😂😂
Their absolute faith in their great leader meeting ALL future deadlines (instead of past. past doesn't count), to control the entire world is endearingly naive.
Something wrong with supporting a company trying to make the world a little better? Imagine not breathing in all the toxic fumes every single day of your life because of Tesla.
@@khoatran415 no one is blaming any company here. But even you must admit the fact that there are some super toxic fanboys that hate anything that's not Tesla and the criticism against them.
@@khoatran415 there is def an issue with toxic fanboys as with everything toxic fanyboys are bad
You mean lying and making things up. Yep pretty annoyed
Just like the other day when Biden told GM they're leading the world in EV production.
"Besting Tesla" and "Diesel Scandal" in the same breath says it all.
Never mind that VW has been operating in Europe for almost 100 years and Tesla only 0 years. 🙄 Let’s see how things look once Giga Berlin is fully ramped.
Ford founded in 1903 sold over 10 million cars made by hand 15 years later. Tesla founded in 2003 barely sold only 2 million cars nearly 20 years later with modernday automated factories.
Nice video.
tesla has no european factory producing cars at an appealing pricepoint yet, they are still doing fairly well there. let's wait until giga berlin gets online to see where the competition is heading. As a tesla owner, the technology features on tesla cars is quite game changing, ever since i bought my model 3 in late 2019 it has received numerous new features.
Yeah cos giga Berlin was supposed to start production in October but some so called environmentalists group want another round of public discussions of the factory for the third time. All they have to do is continue calling for review just to farther delay the factory starting. Because they can sense fear
@atombrain111 meh i think my model 3 is awesome... all car companies benefits from government incentives for making evs, tesla just happens to be making 100% electric cars.. preorded a cybertruck as well, hope that ev credit passes senate
@atombrain111 if only actual tesla owners agree lol
@atombrain111 lmfao did you hear, TSLA recently reneged the 1.1B EURO incentive and said they do not need it. They are building it fully on their own expense.
@atombrain111 if your statement is true, then why is every Tesla already sold before it comes off the assembly line? There is also a waiting list for Tesla cars. Your opinion does not match the facts.
The iconic sports car brand that is part of VW is called “Porsche” not “Porsch”! 🙈
looking for who tf asked
@@Convex. ok
Don't forget Janice (Joplin) sang "My friends all drives Porscheeees, I must make amends!" w/a nice twang.
@@vintageseattle - As for Janice, she was saying Porsches, as in the plural form of “Porsch” ...
Who cares? My daily driver is an old 924S and I certainly don't.
Wait until Tesla's factory opens in Germany!! The only thing holding back Tesla is the time it takes to ship a car from the US!!!
Wait until they can be profitable car maker 🤣
Model 3 and Y use CCS, so they can use both superchargers and other chargers.
The upper part of the CCS is a type 2, so public type 2 chargers can also be used.
800 volt tech Kia EV6GT recharge time 18 minutes, old 400 volt tech Tesla cars recharge time 25 to 30 minutes for the same range. Tesla is for people who are stuck in 2017 :-)
Again, I rest assured that I as an informed retail investor I know more than the analysts.
The real answer is the same reason VW isn't selling EVs in the US. GF4 isn't up and running so not enough cars are making it to Europe. Once the factory is up and running, don't be surprised if Tesla starts selling far more cars.
I just saw a used Model Y Dual Motor at my VW dealership for $58k. I make a good salary but even I would consider spending that much a foolish financial move. The Tesla prices keep moving up and not down to actually fulfill their mission statement, I will keep looking.
@@petersachs764 Yeah! Tesla cars are insanely expensive and they're getting more and more expensive. Only Musk's dumb fans actually believes in a 25k Tesla.
@@petersachs764 all other car prices have moved up, not just Tesla
idk about the us but in canada there are id4s and mach-es everywhere
@@Tom-ep1oj Tesla's still more expensive. It's not a car for the common man. That said I don't think that's necessarily a problem. Some car companies produce cheaper cars, some produce luxury stuff, some produce all kinds of stuff.
This didn't age well, Tesla Model Y is the number one selling car in almost every market in Europe.
VW reports their sales as good, but actually, it is deliveries, as most VW EVs being delivered today are sold almost two years ago with 18 months of delivery., whereas new sales are dropping like a stone as the EVs never lived up to their expectations, software being poorly executed, the over the air updates never becoming a reality.
Volkswagen has now scrapped its EV platform and bought one from SAIC and acquired a 4.99% stake in Xpeng, most probably for manufacturing facilities making VW made in China and useless factories in Europe they ill afford to upgrade to EV production as their $189 billion USD debt and no assets of real value to offer as equity, banks or institutes are not going to be willing to lend out more money towards the development of EVs or restructuring of their business.
In India Tata is the first mover in the EV market. Each market is unique.
I would like an update on this at the end of 2022 with giga Berlin operational
They'll surely update this.
One thing not mentioned is that there is a long waiting list in Europe for Teslas and that they are sold before they even reach the continent.
Actually Tesla is the only supplier in Germany that does not have a waiting list today. You can get a Tesla right away while waiting time on other brands is between 3 and 12 mns
@@24goRillaZ intersting.
@@24goRillaZ That is because the other brands have not enough mass production like Tesla
@@TheGecko213 ahhhh, that logic kills me
@@24goRillaZ This is wrong, try ordering a Tesla model S or X now. It only shows "Pre-order" without them saying when you get it and what price. Can't get them.
I can't afford either of these brands. My state is going fully electric in 10 years. I certainly hope EVs become more affordable by then. I really would like to own one.
An electric bicycle is a possibility?
I see a bus pass in your future...and mine also. Luckily, it will probably be on an electric bus.
The U.S. really needs to work on public transportation, especially here in the west. We need more passenger trains/trams. We then wouldn't have to rely so heavily on purchasing and maintaining our own personal vehicles. Taking the bus in my medium sized city can take hours just to get to the other side (which is a 15-20 minute drive). It is inefficient and lacking. The only passenger train that I know of in my entire state is in Seattle, which is a few hundred miles away from me. It is the same throughout the west. It really has to change.
One brand stands for excellence and luxury, the other for innovation and sustainability. Priorities bring to life "money talks, BS walks.".
The Model 3 almost outsold the VW Golf in Germany in Q3. It was the number 1 car in Europe, without the Berlin factor having opened. Tesla makes higher profits and had more money. VW is definitely not beating Tesla any time soon.
Tesla makes higher profits?
I think you are right.
also when you look at how progressive VW is compared to Tesla. I see Tesla as the absolute winner here.
Yes there is some quality problem compared with VW. but this is only a question of time Tesla get´s it right.
@@chuckyfox9284 yes, soon at 30% per car
@@chuckyfox9284 telsa has 30% profit off of each car. Vw is at best 10%.
You do know the GTI is not a car? It is just a trim level of a Golf. So basically your saying Tesla might beat one trim level of a full line car line. Wow Tesla fanboys are warped with their numbers.
A more apt title: “Why is CNBC always lying against Tesla?”
You got that right!
Because of no advertising revenue. Follow the money 💰
This entire article is SO out of date that it is worthless.
Was manipulative one year ago. Today it is a joke.
What irritates me is the lies around range. Tested indoors no headwind. Nobody in the car. Nothing turned on set at its most economical speed. Just watched a program with a ev towing a caravan. Best figure they got was 100 miles before the battery was flat. And you can't charge with anything being towed. So you have to disconnect and reconnect every 100 miles. Many winter driving tests halve the range. Battery's and infrastructure have to be better.
VW carries a huge amount of debt and a dealer network that isn't necessarily onboard with Ev's.
Maybe but the dealers have received a big blow last year by removing their price negotiation ability.
If you want a VW you can order it online now and you will get the same price at every dealership. Order online and pick up at your nearest dealer.
So what do you really need a car dealer for now? For annual maintenance and repairs I prefer independent repair shops because they are cheaper and the service is better.
@@the_real_glabnurb thats not true, the vw website says that pricing excludes tax, title, and dealer fees. The dealers still control the final price.
@@the_real_glabnurb dont need to serice EVs except to change tyres change wiper blades a screen washer
@@flodjod not sure if that's strictly true, An EV will still have suspension and braking components and other wearable parts. And i'd imagine that the electric motor and battery pack requires maintenance checks every now and again.
Dealers will be onboard with anything that sells. They won't care if it is battery, ICE or nuclear powered
Would be interesting to see when Tesla could get its $25K model into the market.
Tesla is regarded as a luxury car - it should stick to bringing premium cars, not compete with Toyota.
@@ahmedzakikhan7639 They already announce it in 2020. And the report said it would be released in 2023 at the earliest.
@@ahmedzakikhan7639 Tesla is not a luxury brand and wont sell "$25K" car in Europe anytime soon.
@@jonpetter8921 thats good
yes. in the matchbox car market
Informative. Excellent !
pj
No mention of the fact that it takes Tesla 10 hours to make a model 3 and takes VW 30 hours to make a similar model? No mention of how VW has a 217 Billion dollar debt?
Keep crying
who are these people at CNBC that think they know something about cars?
This is paid for by VW propaganda
qualified journalists who conduct research and fact checking i'd imagine
@@audience2 I am European and I can tell you volks wagen is doing a great job in Europe.
Vw is behind the eight ball, and will never catch up to tesla, in fact no one can catch up to tesla, because of the Elon Musk factor.
Teslas innovation rate is something other manufacturers does not even dream of implementing, because it is something that they do not grasp
@@frederikjrgensen252 your not allowed to say such things You'll offend and trigger the
Muskovites.
Aren't you forgetting other automakers ? For now Tesla and VW are leading the sells but you can't forget that for a long time Renault ZOE dominated the EV panorama and it will be a mater of time until some other automaker hit the sweet spot. European consumers are more pragmatic , they don't want an "Apple on wheels" , they just want an under 15K car that can go for 300-400Km in a charge , and some other automakers are getting closest to that goal. And i am not even considering China automakers (like BYD) that are starting to launch some of their models in Europe.
I live here in Germany. No, they want an Audi that goes fast.
Not just the ZOE but also KIAs EV6 and Hyundais IONIQ have just been released. Kia and Hyundai have been gaining a lot of market share in Germany over the past few years (they hired big names from German Car Manufacturers) and you bet people will be glad to buy their new EV cars. The ID series is not well received by German car critics due to a lot of software issues while cars like the Kia EV6 are getting a ton of praise. VW is obviously known to charge a premium price while manufacturers like Kia/Hyundai do not. Yes, just like the video says, VW has a reputation for quality but there are still a lot of people with an open mind that will consider a ZOE, an EV6, an IONIQ if they feel like its the objectively better choice for their money. Look at german roads, sure, germans love german cars, but germans also like getting a lot for their money, so manufacturers that do offer better value cars also make good money here. so you look at german roads, its rather diverse in terms of brands.
PSA Group will eventually get on the race for market share as well of course
True, the Zoe is also around for a decade. So the statement that Tesla had the market for its own is simply wrong.
Whoever thinks that French cars can be considered as a serious contender in the automotive business has a very narrow understanding of the sector...
The thing that I am going to look at hard is the cost to repair first. Then if cost to purchase is head to head the same as a Tesla that I might be looking at then cost to repair, and cost to maintain will determine which vehicle I will purchase.
Good to hear.
Everyone is a gangster until Toyota and Honda enters the ev market.
That's the thing, Toyota does not want to enter the market for at least another 5-10 years. They are doing everything possible to delay the fully EV revolution.
Toyota want to deliver the perfect EV, with a solid state battery maybe.
I give props to tesla for leading the EV Market in a shot term, but they arent in the same level as the og cars companies
@@JxcksonSF Yeah in the long run Tesla will lose its current position and Toyota isn't convinced Lithium is the way forward.
toyota and honda are so behind in terms of technology. The only reason they’re alive is because of their reputation
@@kristians2704 Toyota just launched a prototype runing on a solid state battery, just because they arent pumping EVs doesnt mean they are behind technologicaly
Meanwhile VW is valued at 5 times P/E while Tesla is valued at 160 times P/E
Tesla's rate of innovation is orders of magnitude higher than any traditional OEM. They say well Tesla may be selling at 3X the rate of VW (when you add in hybrids and the Eup city car), but just wait unit 2030. Do they really think Tesla will fall behind LOL. Tesla will be well over 10M vehicles per year by 2030.
@@rogerheuckeroth7456 If we are heading to a world with Robotaxis, why do you expect Tesla to sell 10 million cars by 2030? Owning a car is expensive because you pay insurance, taxes, parking and charging. Most people would just get a Robotaxi subscription. Tesla wouldn't be the only Robotaxi out there either. Baidu already has Robotaxis in China. If Baidu can do it, what prevents other manufacturers of doing it aswell?
@@imranarshad7302 Because Robo taxi widespread use is still many years away IMO. Owning a car will always be a worthy luxury that those that can afford it will own their own even if it does have true Level4/5 autonomy. I have to admit I'm looking at this on a US centric basis. For my use case a robo-taxi would be way too inconvenient. I have items in my car that I need for work. Also, how would Robo taxis work for rush hour? For those who commute to a job, they would all get on the app at once and request a Robo taxi for the exact same time. You would still need one Robo taxi per person for that use case.
@@rogerheuckeroth7456 Baidu already has Robotaxi's so I don't really think it's going to be that long away. Like you said, owning a car is a luxury. Luxury is not something the masses need however, which means that sales would decline, not increase.
I don't think Tesla would be the only Robotaxi on the road either. We could see subscription based services from many EV makers, but also from third party companies like Hertz and Uber.
@@imranarshad7302 I think Baidu is still in development. They still use a person in the drivers seat monitoring the system. Think full autonomy is still a ways off. And like I said it does not fit all use cases and would be constrained unless there was one robotaxi per commuter. That makes it less financially viable. I think widespread use is still over 10 years away.
Why is this video being recommended to me in 2023? Anyway, we know how that went, Tesla is dominating in Europe. (and China & US)
Amazing how poorly this segment has held up just nine months later. Makes you wonder how smart CNBC really is?
They have no clue apparently
EV competition between companies will be good for all of us ☺ good to see
Because the cars are known for quality builds and Tesla's are known for the bumper falling off in the rain?
Really, how many Tesla's did that? 5, 10?
yea that's why model 3 became the top selling car in europe in September
Yeah chief this a cold take
out of all the cars our family has owned, none were as unreliable as vw. we would not consider a vw anymore. not even a ev vw. german engineering? hah. joke.
True story, i was driving my tesla in the rain, and even the wheels fell off
Regardless of this particular competition, I think the fact that Tesla succeeded in creating a new, desirable brand of car from out of nowhere is remarkable. Historically that hadn't happened for many decades in the USA, and all the attempts to do this failed in the past.
Teslas are the poorest built and least reliable cars in the industry.
@@deman19901 Completely false. Not even remotely accurate.
@@redbaron6805 "9Tesla vehicles are known as much for being fast as for presenting chronic issues. Water leaks, paint problems, spontaneously-breaking glasses, MCU failures, and a long etcetera are now joined by something we have never reported: rust in front reinforcement bars. In a TMC forum thread for Model S owners, at least 15 cases emerged from 2016 until December 26, 2021."
@@redbaron6805 "t now places 27th out of 28 manufacturers (the same as last year), with vehicles like the Model Y being present on CR’s list of 10 least reliable cars."
@@redbaron6805 "Tesla ranks almost dead-last on Consumer Reports reliability list
The electric car manufacturer now ranks 27th out of 28 car brands on Consumer Reports’ list, above only Ford-owned legacy luxury brand Lincoln."
AMERICAN CARS ARE JUNK
ID3 sold 70k units worldwide as of their report in early October 2021 - and Tesla sells than double that every 3 months. This is just such nonsense
Ha ha I live in Germany. No way this is true.
Look at the numbers, ist wahr
It's only true because it's harder to get a Tesla in Germany than it is a VW. Once Giga Berlin is open, sales will be insane.
@@tobias7252 tesla model 3 was the best selling car In Europe in September beating the golf, I guess true in Germany and not the rest of Europe.
Great put me on your list!!!
@@HopeIsFleeting BS hahaha VW Wolfsburg makes 950 000 Golf a year, as much as Tesla in all fabs as of 2021! AND switch to e car is easy, same body tech etc!
This clip is about hope. It’s hoping that Tesla will struggle to ramp similar to Model 3 ramp, which was not demonstrated during Giga Shanghai ramp. It hopes that VW will scale electric similar to ICE cars, which it has so far not shown any ability to do so
Spot on.
well to be fair, the ID range is less then 6 months old. The ID3 was launched in June i think, and the ID4 in July. To say nothing of the larger VW group family also providing electric vehicles. They'll scale no problem
Very good!
What was Europe's bestselling vehicle last month?