The INSANE world of National Socialism’s Aryan Religion
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- This history video discusses the origins of National Socialism, going back to prehistory to look at the Ancient Aryans (the Proto-Indo-Europeans), the rise of nationalism in Germany and Austria-Hungary, the views of numerous völkisch writers like Guido von List, Jörg Lanz von Liebenfels, and Hans Günther (the Race Pope). And we'll tie that all together by discussing how their beliefs in Hyperboreans, Atlantis, and Fohat played into Hitler's and Himmler's beliefs in race, Lebensraum (living space) and a supposed Aryan enclave in Tibet...
Dear RUclips censors: I'm NOT a National Socialism or anything similar. This video is discussing events or concepts that are academic, educational and historical in nature. This video is for informational purposes and was created so we may better understand the past and learn from the mistakes others have made.
My video on Hitler's Socialism • Hitler's Socialism | D...
Follow me on Instagram / tikhistory
⏲️ Videos EVERY Monday at 5pm GMT (depending on season, check for British Summer Time).
The thumbnail for this video was created by Terri Young. Need awesome graphics? Check out her website www.terriyoung...
- - - - -
📚 BIBLIOGRAPHY / SOURCES 📚
Anthony, D. “The Horse, The Wheel, and Language: Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World.” Princeton University Press, Kindle 2007.
Bormann, M. "Hitler's Table Talk." Ostara Publications, 2016.
Goodrick-Clarke, N. “The Occult Roots of Nazism: Secret Aryan Cults and Their Influence on Nazi Ideology.” New York University Press, 2004 (originally 1985). ISBN 0-8147-3060-4
Hale, C. “Himmler’s Crusade.” Transworld Publishers, Ebook 2004.
Hitler, A. "Mein Kampf." Jaico Publishing House, 2017.
Manvell, R. Fraenkel, P. “Heinrich Himmler: The Sinister Life of the Head fo the SS and Gestapo.” Kindle 2017.
Full list of all my sources docs.google.co...
- - - - -
⭐ SUPPORT TIK ⭐
This video isn't sponsored. My income comes purely from my Patreons and SubscribeStars, and from RUclips ad revenue. So, if you'd like to support this channel and make these videos possible, please consider becoming a Patreon or SubscribeStar. All supporters who pledge $1 or more will have their names listed in the videos. There are higher tiers too with additional perks, so check out the links below for more details.
/ tikhistory
www.subscribes...
Thank you to my current supporters! You're AWESOME!
- - - - -
ABOUT TIK 📝
History isn’t as boring as some people think, and my goal is to get people talking about it. I also want to dispel the myths and distortions that ruin our perception of the past by asking a simple question - “But is this really the case?”. I have a 2:1 Degree in History and a passion for early 20th Century conflicts (mainly WW2). I’m therefore approaching this like I would an academic essay. Lots of sources, quotes, references and so on. Only the truth will do.
A couple of notes:
First, if you’ve read books on this topic from the 1960s and 70s that contradict what I mentioned in this video, you should know that many of the books from that era were flat out wrong. In fact, historian Goodrick-Clarke states this in the opening of his book (The Occult Roots of Nazism). He states while there are a couple of exceptions, most of the authors were writing sensational nonsense just to sell books, so I would disregard them and read a more up-to-date book instead.
And this leads to my second point. I would like to clarify my book recommendation that I stated at the end of the video. Most of the references in the video were from Goodrick-Clarke’s “The Occult Roots of Nazism” and that’s with good reason! It’s a great book on the topic, and while it is academic in nature (which might put people off), I still think it should be your first choice unless you really insist on reading something lighter. If you prefer an easier read, then Hale’s “Himmler’s Crusade” is the book you should get. And Anthony’s “The Horse, the Wheel, and Language” is only on the Proto-Indo-European history NOT the Nazis, but is really interesting in its own right if you want to dive into the Ancient Aryans.
Finally, I should point out that this is not a sponsored video or post; I’ll only ever recommend books for people to do their own follow-up reading if I genuinely think the book is worth picking up, and in this case I think these three are. This video is also not monetized and doesn’t have adverts on it because RUclips’s “Community” Guidelines are deliberately vague on what “controversial topics” are or aren’t. So this video could only have been made possible thanks to my Patreons and SubscribeStars. Therefore I’d like to say a BIG THANK YOU once again to all of your who have chosen to support my work. You guys are awesome!
@@sabhishek9289 I'll be honest, I don't know enough about Darwin personally to really comment on that. I do know that "Social Darwinism" was a twisted version of what Darwin's evolution theory was actually about, and that's not the same thing. You can't conflate what Darwin wrote to "Social Darwinism" because they're not the same theory.
@@TheImperatorKnight Actually Darwin was a social Darwinist although he was not as radical as his followers. He did believe that his theory has applications in human societies. I recommend that you read Darwin's book "Descent of Man" considering you read books a lot. And i recommend that you watch the video of Discovery Science that I cited in my comments because it explains better than i ever could.
Very well presented. I will have to look in on those three books.
As long as we realize evolution in nature is accidental response to chemistry and environment and people take specific steps, I can hang with most other explanations of how it works out in societies.
@@TheImperatorKnight Let me quote Charles Darwin for you from "The Descent of Man":
"At some future period, not very distant as measured by centuries, the civilized races man will almost certainly exterminate and place throughout the world the savage races,
Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man
The story of Hitler worrying that the Italians were secretly laughing at the Nazi party because Himmler was getting excited every time he found clay pottery as evidence of the "ancient Ayran civilization" will never not be funny.
Thats ok, its not as funny as the Nazis laughing at the Italians whenever they had to save their pasta eating asses from Greece and also from the allies
Nice double negative
@@meanbeats I'm confused. What was a double-negative?
@@andyfriederichsen A negation that negates itself, therefore turning into an affirmative.
Will never not be funny = Will always be funny
@@TheFi0r3 Thanks for the clarification.
I came for the invasion of Stalingrad, but stayed for the historical context behind the Nazi's rise to power.
Good! Stalingrad will hopefully be next week
@@TheImperatorKnight Very cool. Im looking forward to it. Funny thing, I showed some of your videos to my dad and he thought you were a college professor and this was a lecture series for a university history course.
Don’t worry we will have another January 6th. The American Beer Hall Putsch is coming.
I'd suggest that you get a second opinion on that Sir 👍
the Germans never called themselves Nat sees..it was coined by the Due wish led communist party in the 1020s long before AH came to power
I always believed people when they said that Hitler not existing would still see the Nazis come to power, but I didn't realise how much of its core came from completely unrelated places from him and those around him.
If Marx didn't exist
100's of millions of people would not have died
Very true. Hitler was just figurehead who was also a very charismatic speaker. Back when I was in school my history teacher was a WW2 vet and told us how Hitler use to spend hours practicing his speech’s in a mirror, and even had acting coach that taught him how to get people to believe everything he was telling them. I hate what Hitler did, but I can also say even though I don’t speak or understand German. When watching his speech’s he has a way of drawing you in and feeling the hype. An I’m sure it was even more powerful when your in the crowd with 100,000 plus people cheering on that it’ll draw you in. I’m just glad that his vision wasn’t carried out.
@S Rice
Don't believe the hype
The truly blood thirsty villains of the 20th century are never talked-about
Lenin Stalin Mao
@@fortunatomartino9797what are you smoking and can I have some? People talk about them all the time you dipshit, just saying nobody talks about them doesn't make it true
@@fortunatomartino9797 They share the junkyard at the end of the universe with Hitler.
Honestly this is an answer I have been searching for since I was 11 (im 22 now). All I wanted to know as a kid was why did they think those things and I knew no one giving me a satisfactory answer. What an exquisite piece of work. Thank you
Many are fake news
I learned this 24 years ago when I had to fight upright walking German shepherd dogs armed with StG 44s in the secret SS castle Wewelsburg in Medal of Honor: Underground.
because they knew there was a civilization in China of white people, in fact there were two, the Tocharians who were Greek Settlers and the much older one who we don't have a name but they found mommies of in China, those peoples might have inspired their mythos obviously they didn't have back then the technology nor the knowledge to proof the theory.
Kim Il Sung, the founder of North Korea, was from a Presbyterian family, too. He started his own political religion based on Korean nationalism, communism and himself being a messianic figure. His name was originally Kim song-Ju, but he changed it to “Il Sung” because that means “sun.”
ARE YOU JUCHE KIDDING OR WAT
Il Sung (일성) is two words. Because a Korean word may have many homophones, we need to look at the Sino-Korean logograms for the roots. They are 日 (il, 일) which is sun (but much more often used for the word day) and 成 (sung, 성) which is to make / to achieve.
I should point out that both il and sung are common enough male forenames (though not together due to Kim) and sung is also a surname in Korea.
If i was going to become the supreme leader of sum country like his i would make my own religion cult to keep my people loyal and would have my own personal hareem just like him and so would most of you in his position.
I think that idea came from the Party, but he certainly embraced it.
Moon Sun Myoung, the founder of the "Unification Church" also commonly known as the Moonies,
was born Moon Young Myoung, but changed his name to Moon Sun Myoung.
Myoung 明 means bright, and the Chinese character 明 is composed of Sun 日 and Moon 月.
Myoung 明 is pronounced "Ming" in China, as in "Ming Dynasty"
Correction: proto Indo European never died out, rather it split apart into many different language, at no point was there a proto Indo European spoken that had no changes while others with changes existed, a language dies out when it stops being spoken, but when it just evolves into many different languages that's more like splitting apart rather than dying out
It's actually the most spoken language family today
Latin is a dead language for that very reason.
@tacticalmattfoley latin is kinda just like indo european, isn't it? It evolved into italian and spanish.
Ever heard of the tower of Babel,have a read,also where the descendants of Shem,Ham and Japeth the sons of Noah are shown to have migrated to,you might be surprised and enlightened, cheers.
“If I looked like Himmler, I wouldn’t talk about race.”
-Albert Forster, Gauleiter of Danzig
Forster made that comment in response to criticism that he was making it too easy for Poles in his region to claim German citizenship. Forster was one of the more pragmatic Nazis, who could see the stupidity of deporting Poles from their farms and replacing them with supposedly ethnic Germans, who often knew little, or nothing, about farming.
@@glennlgg6871 Albert Forster survived the war but was hanged later by the Poles.
None of the Nazi officials looked much like their ideal of strong blonde haired, blue eyed Germans. Hitler was short, had dark hair, had a kiloton of medical problems, and wasn't even German! Moreover Hitler was relatively short. Himmler looked slightly more like the Nazi ideal, but he was severely near-sighted and thus always wore glasses. Goebbels was relatively short and had brown hair. Etc!
What a brilliant video. Ive watched 70% of your videoes Tik, and got to say this is one of the greatest. You are getting better and better.
"When men cease to believe in God, the problem is not they will believe in nothing, the problem is they are ready to believe in ANYTHING!!' G.K. Chesterton (British Catholic philosopher)
That is exactly what happened...
That explains Europe now, we believe in nothing except for what’s on telly
nah
Are you the same guy I see in guitar videos??
@@EdmundoAyarzagoitia No.
Wow
6:45 Minor correction. There was a copper age in central Europe, at least, as demonstrated by "Ötzi, the Iceman", the mummified man found in the Alps in 1991. Ötzi was carrying a copper axe.
Id moreso call it an age of metalurgy, things like tin lead copper gold and so on were being experimented with and used to make tokens and jewlery and so on.
Except Ötzi had mostly southern european dna, which means he was migrating from the south
@@esti-od1mz humans dont migrate /s
@@esti-od1mz I think they traced a lot of the goods he was carrying to an area north of the alps, though. So he appears to have been travelling south when he died.
Copper is part of Bronze
this was more entertaining than i could have imagined.
Atlanteans, hyperborans, they forgot poor conan, and the cimmerians.
Lovecraft and his friends got those ideas from somewhere. I shall give you three guesses as to where.
Some crazy imaginations from the past. We're the original tale tellers on Black Lotus or Hagga?
Great cities, ancient and wicked.
Cimmerians really existed and they were remnants of ancient proto indo aryans
@@paulrevere2379 CTHULHU FHTAGN!
@@Sarke2 SUMARYAN
Great presentation. I am so fascinated by this topic, particularly how so many of us seem to be instantly captivated by mysterious origin stories and occultism and how it often leads horrifically to extremism.
I think, we even today do not know all of that thema with a reason. We must wait 2044. Maybe, after that year we will know more about Arian race and arian religion, and church. We will see?!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh Why 2044?
@@trishgreen2892 Because, when the Third Reich crushed in May, 1945, american troops founded something in the mountains, in Alpes, near Berchtesgaden. It was 4th of May, 1945. There was hidden the last artefacts and documents about conection of Arian race and Atlantis. And what last nazi expeditions found about that in the late 1930s, all around the world. Because that was proved by the science and archeological proves, that was hidden from winners of the ww2, after 1945. That proves sugested that white race ( Arians ) is a masterace and Atantis was a home of that race, before 12 000 years. Also, swastika comes from that lost continent. And that was also reason why Hitler put that accient simbol on german flag, after 1935 to 1945. PS: That is all what I know about that and I was spend 33 years to find that censured informations of our race. All that what winners of ww2 said about races after ww2 is false. Especially about european race or Arians.
@@trishgreen2892 Because, after that year finished censure about something what were winners of ww2 discovered in Alpes, after ww2. That is proved by the science. I was tryied to send you more informations about that, but was brushed from the censors from this page. Sorry! Just after a few minutes after I send my message to you.
@@trishgreen2892 You asked me very hot question,about 2044. I am afraid you will must investigate about that alone. Sorry!
Didn't expect a lesson in the fascinating history of pre-historic languages but your content is often surprising.
Keep up the good work.
The Crecganford YT channel covers the Proto-indo-european mythology extensively. It's well worth checking out. Also, Tik pushes the "The Horse, The Language, and The Wheel" book, but I don't recommend it. It's quite boring and filled with hundreds of pages of talking about archeological digs. It barely mentions the mythology.
@@the_mowron so called proto Indo europeans never exis ted.
@@the_mowron oldest language is Sanskrit which is reality there is nothing called proto indi eurpian thats fantasy n falsehood likr ur jebus who supossedly born from virgin mary pu.ssy lol
@@greenleafies5177yeah neither the R1 haplogroup, the sintashta culture, the corded ware culture, the yamna culture existed... More the time advance and more we discover pieces to add to the mystery of ancient forsaken history, I'm not talking about anything mystic here, just pointing out that we know, with archeological sources. How do you explain the presence of R1a haplogroup in northern indians then? And why is it the same haplogroup we find in northern/eastern europe ?
A number of years ago I came across a book written by a Russian author Valery Shambarov called “The Occult Roots of the October Revolution”. As far as I know, it’s only available in the Russian language. However, the parallels between what you said in this video, TIK, and some of the things he says, are startling. And guess what? He also mentions the Theosophical Society and it’s influences.
Hegel's mysticism has deeply infect the modern "left"
(which is actually centrist between individual freedom liberals and collective authority monarchists)
Look up Richard Wurmbrand’s Marx and Satanism. He was tortured by the Romanians for many years, in solitary confinement. He wrote this book documenting Theosophical influences on Marx’s ideas. It’s not blatant satanism as people dismissing him seem to suggest, but rather Paganism/Theosophical influences. He being a Christian called it satanic, but call it what you will, you’ll find some similarities.
They won't discuss the greatest mass murderer of all time Marx and what communism did to the world
Or it's ideological descendants feminism, "civil" rights, Homophobia Xenophobia
Pedophilia
@@AnUnhappyBusiness watafak, Blavastsky never said positive something about communism
And all these authors, obsessed with religion, funny clowns)))
If you think about it, socialism/communism can also be regarded as religions. They come complete with secular saints, rituals, dogma, indulgences, devils, and eternal enemies.
reddit brain
This guy made a video on that too
@@surv3994exactly.
"Uh I think our economic system has some faults, maybe govt. involvement would help."
"SO YOU'RE RELIGIOUS, HUH? NICE DOGMA BUDDY. YOU BELIEVE NOTHING HAHAHA!"
Major error about the Swastika. The right facing one is the original, sacred to Hinduism, and it is a positive symbol. The Nazis appropriated it, and rotated it a little.
The left facing one is used by some Buddhists in my experience but it is not commonly seen in Hindu contexts. It is also a sacred symbol to those who use it.
Neither version signifies decline or anything like that.
I have read that the swastika was rotated counterclockwise to make it appear dynamic.
Go to India,you see the Hindu Swastika everywhere.
Left vs Right swasticka facing could be a southern vs northern hemisphere viewing of the swasticka stars progression in sky.
i love how he sprinkled a bit of random misinformation just like that lol.
Also it was a very common symbol in romanised and pagan europe BC. When I was in NL I saw many on display which dug up in the NL from the Roman and pre-roman era. There's a heap on display at the Culture Museum in Leiden.
In our time it's curageous to name the mad "political" streams of the last century as RELEGION. Because our "zeitgeist" is exactly as religious - no science, just a uncountable beliefs and outmost bossiness. Dogma comes before argument. But if you name it, you'll get indexed. But Tik you're so right. That's why I love every one of your episodes. Keep on doing the good stuff.
lol you act like calling social movements a religion is a kin to naming the big nose tribe, something that actually does take courage and will "get you indexed"...
@Hard Right Turn
Did a Jew fuck your mother or what
like vaxer or masker? it's a cult. it's the opposite of science.
If you mean wokeness, intersectionality and such... I'm with you
@@chinocracy Further including the dogmas of man made climate change and of WHO supremacy.
Hi TIK, I'm from Nigeria and I find virtually all your videos very interesting. This one was informative and filled a lot of gaps in my knowledge of the background beliefs of these people. Thanks and well done 👍🏿
@Bogda Nov why are you stupid?
Biafra
@@Martin_Hayes I love your reply 🤣
I'm from Southern Nigeria..We ate 2 white people and a Korean a week ago
@@OtaBengaBokongo Wich one tasted better?
Catholic society: (Invents guilds)
Catholic society: (loses power)
Neo-pagans: (laments the loss of guilds while complaining about Catholics)
Catholics: Hold on, this whole operation was our idea.
Lol
'Filling a political vacuüm' eerily implies something empty about human nature. A God-sized emptiness.
I'm somehow vaguely reminded of Islamism, and similar theocratic ideologies. The synthesis of religion and politics, and the dedication of society totally to some bizarre- but almost certainly horrific- sacred vision
Possibly the best lecture ever on the subject. It's not just about reading the written material on the subject, but it's interpretation and delivery. Actually, this work is amazing. 👍🇦🇺
I think Heinrich Himmler was as smart as Bernard Montgomery. On the other hand, Freddie de Guingand was smarter than Himmler. Authoritarian leaders fear talented individuals, which often leads to micromanaging and mistakes.
The info on my channel tears him a new one.
Brainwashed 😂😂😂😂 believing in lies 😂😂😂Lol 😂
@@Channel-sp3fp suuuuure
This video is erroneously misinformed. The data has been available for a while. Corded Ware is the origin, not the Yamnaya. These are the hard facts, genetics do not lie.
If you spend enough time studying the nazis its inevitable for Nicholas Goodrick-Clarke to come up at some point. He's one of the what you would call required historians. You don't need to know every last detail about the invasion of Norway but once you learn the basics about the nazi worldview a lot of things suddenly make sense and this is where Clarke comes in.
Nietzsche and the Nazis is a fantastic audiobook/book that directly evaluates that precise relationship.
@@andrewhinson4323 Nietzsche is one of the most misrepresented people as it is - I’d be interested in the connections people draw.
@@-John-Doe- he did say that he wrote to be misinterpreted if I'm not mistaken, and his sister was a Nazi believer. Apparently, she had many of his postumus publications edited to align with Nazi philosophy. This is all hearsay
@@-John-Doe- I agree he is misrepresented, and most likely would have despised the Nazi party, he did have influence on their world view. His concept of "Strong-willed men above morality and oppression that impose the values they want to see in the world" with his ubermensch has given Nazis intellectual justice to impose what they believe is "right" on the world for the sheer fact of their strength to impose such values. This can also be seen in some post-modern thinking (another Nietzsche influenced theory). Especially in his political theory, he thought that the highest form of society lead by a small, aristocratic group of men that lead the weaker-willed society to their own higher values that go beyond moral justification.
But again, what I'm describing is just 1 interpretation of Nietzsche that does ignore a lot of his other text, but still has had it's influence non the less.
@@-John-Doe- also, he was very critical of Jewish morality and psychology, seeing it as the philosophical origin of the "master-slave" mentality which he sees as the ultimate regressor of western culture
You're actually wrong about the Swastika. The right facing swastika represents the sun, prosperity and good luck whilst the left facing swastika actually represents the tantric aspects of the goddess Kali. In history and religion the left hand is almost universally associated with offbeat or even evil elements.
@Pete Testube No it doesn't, this is what I mean when I say right vs left facing: (卐) (卍)
That depends on the context. You are speaking of the Hindu context. In other contexts the left-facing swastika represents the wheel of the sun rotating clockwise and the right-facing is an inversion of this.
Even the Romans used right-facing swastikas on their shields... not from Hindu
@@brucetucker4847 what other contexts? Can you be more specific?
@@108lvl I don't remember exactly what I was referring to when I wrote that, but IIRC in Buddhist usage the left-facing swastika is usually considered more auspicious, and in cultures like the prehistoric Celts and sometimes Slavs where it was a sun symbol the left-facing one had a more positive context because if you visualize it rolling along a surface you would expect it to roll clockwise (sun-wise), from left to right, like the sun does if you're watching it in the northern hemisphere, while the right-facing one would roll counter-sunwise, which is unlucky.
This is incredible! Thank you so much for your research and for explaining it so thoroughly.
Indoeuropean linguistics and what they sparked in the minds of some crazy people are some of my favorite topics, well done! Also the Horse, the Wheel and the Language is a great book, thanks!
You're welcome! And I'd love to hear your perspective on this. Did I get it right in the video?
@@TheImperatorKnight Honestly yes, the information presented about the Indoeuropeans was correct.
The distinction you made between linguistics and "race" is very important, though often misunderstood.
Pinpointing the PIE homeland has sparked a lot of debate in the past, the linguistic approach used in the video is fascinating, and as you most probably know the pontic-caspian steppes have been indeed recently confirmed through genetical analysis as the correct location.
If I can add something I know that in some Veda passages noble aryan peoples are described by some uncertain translations as blonde, of course this doesn't prove they were actually blonde, but this inspired many baseless hypothesis that traced them back to Germany or some Nordic location. This plays a role in the "corruption of the blood" idea: as the original aryan people from Germany mixed with the lesser local peoples unpure populations were born.
Another very interesting fact is that actually naz1 propaganda and Hitler in his speeches usually emphasized more the concept of the "nordic race" compared to the aryan one, in fact german supremacist intellectuals had to cope with the fact that also Latins, Slavs and others spoke "Aryan" (indoeuropean) languages, so they came up with an internal division that saw the "nordic" peoples of scandinavia as the top and originally the most aryan one.
I can confirm thid based on the references Hitler makes about race I read, he speaks more often about "Nordic" or "Germanic" peoples rather than Aryan ones.
It should be kept in mind that these ideas were not homogeneous and different thinkers had different hypotheses over the course of decades.
It's very interesting nonetheless that a real discovery in the field in linguistics inspired so many baseless ideas that had a great impact in world history, I feel this is almost a forgotten story today and this confirms you try to go deeper than what conventionally taught.
Keep up with the great work!
There is nothing crazy about certain group of people migrating, even conquering and spreading its language(s) in new territory. Actually, it is only natural way language would spread . For example, English would never arrive in territory of modern US without English people (with their genetic makeup) also arriving and conquering this territory.
@@aleksazunjic9672 There is nothing crazy about that, those are actual facts, but the ideas that these discoveries sparked in some people's minds are quite insane, refer to the video to discover them
@@aleksazunjic9672 True, but the idea of tying language groups to racial groups IS crazy.
Now I understand why Pope Pius XI condemned this ideology as "neo-pagan"
Yes, my surname which means wheeler in Latvian comes from Rat (or Rad in German and Rota in Latin) and derives ultimately from the proto-European word Ratha from about four thousand years ago which means "spoked-wheeled chariot". On another matter but still relevant to this interesting video, my father said he asked those who bore the SS runes on their uniforms after they arrived in July 1941 in Latvia what they meant- and they told him they meant 55. Obviously, they thought he was dopey or they were just having a laugh.
Rath word still exists and is widely used in conversations in India. Probably a Sanskrit term .
How do you suppose that German town halls became known as Rathäuse?
Why would common SS troopers, with little or no education about this historical topic knew what it really meant ? They knew only about SchutzStaffel, but those at the top had better education and understood things on a deeper level .
@@yashvardhanojha6796 hi dude where you from?
Dont make me splain Ratshaus dats whar dem dare nazis at
Hi Louis. Great video. The only thing I might add is that although the internet has many immediate sources saying the Rig Veda is the oldest canon of Hinduism ( c 1,500 BC) if you look deeper you'll find this is not exactly correc and I have no idea why the internet is littered with this claimt. A more accurate estimate for the oldest Hindu texts Vedas/Upanishads go back to 3,500 BCE to 4,000 BCE making it the worlds oldest religion still practiced at around 6,00 years of age, The word 'Aryan' is a Sanskrit word meaning 'Spiritual Being.' History/Anthropology has attributed the migration of the Aryans, who brought/started Hinduism to India and refers to the proto Indo/Europeans Migrating to and from the regions of Iran - Northern Europe. The name of the country 'Iran' is actually translates to 'Aryan' I have read thoudh I lack a good enough source to verify. Anthropology until recently has attributed all sophisticated culture and even population itself as having been brought into India around 7,000 years ago, however there is a new school of Indian Anthropologists who are challenging this previously accepted idea. Anyway, I hope you find this information useful. Some of this info was taken from my University studies in Eastern Phil, some however was from the net as well and -for that reason-it is very likely is possibly not 100% certain but I hope it helps.
India was known as aryavarta ie the land of aryas before iranions. Study some original sanskrit texts.
Hi David, actually the Sanskrit word "arya" refers to someone who upholds vedic traditions, worships right gods(as per vedic Aryans) and speaks Sanskrit.
Secondly, ancient name of India was " aryavarta" meaning abode of Aryans.
You never fail in coming up with thought provoking videos. This one is going to take me some time to review and digest. Thanks TIK.
Our vedic culture definitely makes us proud of our great ancestors who spoke Sanskrit
As a Hindu, the reason you won't find a race or group who can be called Aryan or Arya as we Hindus would say it is because a group cannot be Arya. Because Arya is a designation for individual. It means noble. The reason that only Aryas could speak sanskrit is because it is a hard language to master and therefore individuals who can master it and write and converse in it are noble and therefore these individuals of are Aryan. They can be of any race or sex. What matters are qualities.
Great topic TIK! As a follow-up you should maybe look into more modern iterations of this in “Esoteric Hitlerism”; Savitri Devi, Serrrano etc.
I did mention that people still believe this stuff today at the end of the video, but yes it's something I could do in the future
Hah. I paused the vid at 14 seconds thinking "oh god, is this about the esoteric lot that all of the *actual* nazis - including Hitler - thought were crazy?"
@@TheImperatorKnight Goodrick-Clarke wrote a follow-up on that very topic called Black Sun, check it out if you decide to do your own follow-up.
@@theeccentrictripper3863 Great book indeed!
“Savitri devi” is some Italian ret-ard, please call her dumb pasta woman instead of a Hindu goddesses name even though the b desperately wanted everyone to call her Savitri
I just want to thank you for all your hard work you spend on these videos. As a youtuber myself I understand how long and difficult the process is with research editing and etc. So please never stop! You have taught me so much about history and especially during WW2. Thank you for not being a sheep and listening to main stream sources but actually doing the due diligence to research the literature and piecing together the actual truth. You are a God send my friend and may God bless you!
....U lost me on the first minute at your poor attempt to explain the swastika.
Love your work mate. You're one of the few historians who goes into a deep dive yet who is able to wrap up that which he finds down there into the subject matter at hand. You readily avoid the prototypical rabbit holes. Bravo Zulu to you!
This is beyond words. I'm normally impatient but I was totally captivated for 40+ minutes. Thank you!
Been subscribed for a few years but have always wanted you to do a video on this topic! You have not disappointed Tik. Thank you for your videos and I'm sorry for the loss of your family member. Look after yourself!
You call these people mad? Yet we live in an age where we are taught men who wear womens clothing are Women, and that theres multiple genders? As for "Aryans" isn't it racist to deny people calling them selves Aryans or anything else they may identify with?
Most sane homophobe.
@@adwaitnaravane5285 no such thing
@Jadwiga it’s a goofy and corny cultural Marxist term that makes no sense. It’s honestly laughable that anyone takes that word seriously. Rational disgust ≠ phobia.
I came to history late and am finally catching up. I wish to God I'd had a history teacher in school who wasn't a football coach. I never knew history is more fascinating than fiction. Thank you for this. I had a theology professor in college telling the class "If you don't know history, you don't know nothin'! ( I see the double negative)
Hey TIK, have you ever thought of covering the Japanese/Pacific theater of WW2? I’d love it because I love your coverage and your thoughts on topics I’ve heard 10 times over. Thanks!
This is an awesome username lmao 🤣
Yes I suport you about that! And will be very interested to know how japanese people, during ww2, got perception about Arian race?! It was the same like today or different? Please, let me know?! Dalibor!
Sus name and pfp.
@@Web720 What you mean?
I can tell you part of it. Burma road 🛣️ turned it around for the Brits and Chinese and that's when Japan started getting their ass whooped in WW2.
the fact that TIK says all of this with a very straight face turns this into a comedy episode
I agree! Is not all of that thema a comedy. A lots of that can be or not be a true. We need exploire that with sirious actions in our life education.
Love it when you cover topics like this, great work TIK.
I actually prefer this stuff to the "tank" stuff, although I like them too. However, I think the majority prefer the "tank" stuff.
I have to assume that you not only agree with Mr Tik but are swallowing his theories espoused courtesy of the smattering of books he's opened..
@@TheImperatorKnight I studied history, especially military history since I was old enough to read. I generally know the "tank" stuff , which you do so well but I love it when you digress into philosophy and economics.
@@DaveSCameron you're commenting everywhere here saying TIK is wrong. What exactly do you disagree with him about?
Its fills my heart with glee to see these videos get over 400 thousand views...
When going on holiday, TIK only uses one piece of luggage. But is that really the case?
Jokes on you, I don't have time for holidays!
@@TheImperatorKnightI've found a kindred spirit
Kinda crazy how this is the first time I've seen anyone lay this out. Once again I come to realize that I know nothing about what happened in 20th century Europe. Or rather, I can tell you *what* happened, but I can't tell you *why* it happened. People, their thoughts and motivations; it's all blank or filled with rubbish. Things just happen for no reason. Lots of madmen.
Of all the things one could potentially know, every human has the ability to learn only the smallest fraction of a single percent.
Based on all known physics and quantum physics, literally everything that ever happened was an accident and free will doesn't exist. Have fun being aware of a meat puppet doing things with you along for the ride.
@@bobjohnson1633 How does a universe with free will differ from a universe without free will? What experiment can I do to differentiate between the two?
"In this world, is man controlled by some transcendental entity or law? Is it like the hand of God, hovering above? At least it is true that man has no control, even over his own will."
There is always a reason. You're here to learn why
What is the law of Cause and Effect?
The reason why we get the word "hundred" from the same root as "centum" isn't so much that the "c-" was dropped. It's a sound shift known as Grimm's Law that happened in the Germanic branch of Indo-European that English and German descended from.
It is easy for the consonant sounds K, Ch (as in Bach or loch), and H to cycle from one to the other over time.
This is amazing. Thank you for this great, and surprisingly topical, content.
You have become my favorite RUclips channel for the past few weeks. Always looking forward to your videos, keep up the good work.
> Concerned about Slavic culture undermining the German one
> Proceeds to fall for theory rooting from a random Russian woman
I haven’t even watched till the end and am already awestruck by your documentary. A-class material without any doubt.
"this land used to be ours thousands of years ago, and we want it back"
Hmmm...I wonder what ideology that lead to the founding of a modern state sounds exactly like that...
When I root I root for the zionists!
He 100% won't go there
I've always wanted to know more about nazi mysticism, always seemed wild to me. Guess I was right
Look further than this sensationalist utoob channel. 📚🙏🏻
Wildness usually has some rhyme or reason; Hodge podge national socialist mysticism not so much. Just saying.
@@DaveSCameron do you believe in the ice world?
This is not all, there is a lot of related occult literature.
@@overdose8329 you believe in mrna vaxines and climate change, whats the difference? Both those and the outlandish ice world theory are just fads of their times that cost lots of lives.
Haha , we Indians just want to be left alone on this matter.
Arya , a simple term for someone who's noble made into something like this.
This is a very important topic. It's important for people to understand what made the Nazis what they were.
Too many people have a mistaken idea of what they were.
He has a pretty narrow definition of Nazis. I consider Catholic Kurt Waldheim to be at least a neo-Nazi.
@@jussim.konttinen4981 Well, I don't think he is saying that individual Catholics can't be Nazis. I don't think he is saying that all Nazis have to believe all aspects of this mystical religion, just that it was a significant factor in creating the Nazi movement. Kurt was an actual Nazi so he definitely can't be excluded.
@Jadwiga No one said Catholicism was a big factor. THIS religion was referring to the religion being discussed in the video.
@Jadwiga did you watch the video? The whole thing is about the Nazis religion.
Yes! Even today!
Has Mein Kampf really been heavily edited and missing parts after translation? Or do you think it is accurate to its original form?
The Stalag edition is accurate. It was given to British prisoners of war, and is the only official English version
Get the Thomas dalton version, best one not been changed etc
This is a prime topic. I think even TIK can't cover this in full. I would highly recommend looking into genetic migration and symbology. As well as lost history; which is the most difficult of info pools to extrapolate from.
Insane is the word that leaps to mind. I’m German, looking around me these days, seeing how psychotic people already turn at the mere chance of fuel and gas prices moving up a couple of notches, it scares the living shit out of me. We’re certainly not the only mad fucks around, but I deeply mistrust us with regard to sober perspective and a let go’ish Laisser-faire approach to life. I still hope to make it outa here and end the remainder of my years hidden somewhere far away.
Great video, I really like how you look at the source material with an open mind and then give us a different view of the past.
not quite an open mind....
Hi Tik,
I admire your work on history. 2:58 the Vedas were not 2000 years old. 2000 years back the language Sanskrit only was not there.
Thanks, TIK. Nice coverage of the topic of Aryanism. Please do a video on the differences of Biological and Social Darwinism, and how the latter affected the ideas of Germany, Great Britain, and the United States. James Burke touched upon the topic in his series that he produced, but I thought you might be able to clarify the 3 paths that Social Darwinism took in the 20th Century.
Well it’s all social Darwinism. It’s like what Marx said about Darwin’s theory when it was first made public. “He just so happened to recreate the British class system”.
I suport your sugestion about a new videos.
Now if you’re courageous, use that same condescending tone about free massons myths and practices. Not to mention jewish ones. Instead of hitting on a dead body who happened to lose an ideological war.
This dude’s desperately trying to stem the tide of noticing
this guy is ridiculous as his neck is pencil like
What's your favorite picture of Hitler to jack off to?
Highly interesting, TIK! You're one of the few youtubers to dive so deeply into the the thought process of the Nazis. You're doing highly important work here, as only by understanding their ideology can we effectively oppose it today.
Personally, I think that the world is in far more danger of repeating the mistakes of the communists than it is the Nazis. Communist ideology is every bit as insane as Nazi ideology but far more people today give those ridiculous and dangerous ideas credit than adhere to Nazi ideas.
@@Pete-tq6in Authoritarian socialism means a dictatorial government that violates basic freedoms and a shitty economic system that likely will collapse when put under stress. Nazism means the same, plus genocide of entire ethnicities. Nazism is definitely worse and more insane.
Yeah good luck with that bud
why do we need to oppose it?
what you think a fourth reich is coming, l think you have more to fear from the rise of the socialist left in the west because socialism = communism and look how well communism has worked in the world oh not in 1 country ever
The most articulate, accurate and digestible documentary I've seen in a very long time. Thank you from Australia, subscribed
Occult Roots and Crusade are fantastic books. I've always been fascinated by the Nazi World View. Great video.
Nazi basically means National or Nationalist in short
National in Italian is Nazionale
@@je-freenorman7787 Nazi is a World from Jews for all Germans. Hitler and his Politics was for the Reich, not for Nationalstates. Nazis has nothing to do with little States, those People has only worked for the huge Reich, that was without little States. U has no Plan and writing nonsense.
@@je-freenorman7787 It means National Socialist
@@sunwheels No it doesnt. It means Nationalist.
Nazionale is National in Italian and Nazi is short form, or a nick name.
Capitalism is is the same thing as Socialism. It makes no difference
@@sunwheels Capitalism and socialism are not forms of government. They are religious orders of an economic structure. Hitler was a capitalist. He needed capital do to what he did and he got it from the Royals and USand other Corporate capitalists. He had all the $ support he needed and Russia was Socialist. Not Germany. Hitler spoke out against socialism in Russia, all the time. Germany and Russia were both ruled by the same people as the UK. They were all in the same family and part of the same Holy Roman Empire. WW2 was a scam. The Royals set everyone up for their own wealth and rule. Covid is also a Royal Scam. Corona means Crown in Italian also. The Royals and the Church are the real Nazis scam artists.
Now do “Wokeism”
cope fascist
@K X
Cringe.
@@nunceccemortiferiscultu7826 cry
Go watch James Lindsay’s podcast for that one.
Bro it's just the philosophy of do the toxic reverse of nazism
Important to note is that as always a lot of this religious behaviour and beliefs comes from the filosofical and political views of each individual, not every member of the nazi party (and specially common people) just believed in exactly everything, even if there was an "official guide"(Mein Kampf).
At the same time the political views of every person are influenced by some filosofies, more "emotional stuff" (which aren't necessarily bad) and the economic, social, demographic changes in their respective period in history, in this case the industrial and french revolutions: The concepts of nations, advanced means of transport comunications and administrative methods.
We live in the Holy Roman Empire
Government is all Roman and its a religious cult, basically
They get all their authority from the masses and their religious beliefs
MonArchy means OneMaster
and the church has always been part of the MonArchy
The clergy was once called Arian
Christianity and Islam come from the Hebrew scripture
and a gospel is a god spell
The world was polytheistic and was converted to mono, starting around zero
at the last Great Reset, every 2000 years at the new Age
Novus Ordu Seclorum
The word Nazi comes from Nazionale, which is Italian for National
They too display the Imperial Eagle for the Holy Roman Empire
What a great overview. Binge watching your channel, great work Tik!
This is the first video from your channel that I watched and wow you are an amazing teacher. I love that you cite your sources and your visible passion for history. Sub earned
The Nazis fell for the classic trap of not asking 'But is this really the case?'.
There were people who questioned those beliefs but they were executed.
The swastika is also a nordic symbol of a wheel from a gods wagon
The Navajo and a few other natives in North America used the swastika as well
It's a universal symbol.
@Jadwiga just because the oldest one was found in ukraine it doesnt mean it is uniquely slavic, just like gunpowder
@Jadwiga just because the oldest was found in ukraine it doesnt mean its pure slavic,just like gunpowder
@Jadwiga you all shut up it's only indian
Very good treatment. One footnote: in Mein Kampf, Hitler starts with a long analysis of the political conditions in his youth, spent of course in Austria, at that time part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Although the anti-semitism is already there ('There were some Jews living there, but at that time I mistook them for human beings') his main political problem was with the Czechs. Czech intellectuals, in imitation of German nationalism, had adopted a pan-Slavist ideology, for the first time seeking to identify with the mighty Russians, who seemed to be a safe distance away. This would eventually come back to bite them hard when Soviet tanks rolled into Prague in 1968. But in the Austro-Hungarian Empire of Hitler's youth, this ideology created the basis for political demands, and Hitler interpreted this as removing German rights in the Austrian half of the Empire. So from a political point of view, he was more anti-Czech and anti-Slav than anti-Jewish, there being no equivalent political movement for Jewish political rights in Vienna.
These are the people talking about "dead k**e on a stick", "sky daddy", and "Jewish mysticism" on pol.
Nazis made a clear distinction between volk and race. This video has a mistake.
Persian history is one of my hobbies, and I used to teach college classes to prison inmates. Oh! The joy of teaching them what TRUE Aryans are, that "Iran" is actually derived from "Aryanem," why people started mistaking Germanic/Nordic people for "Aryans," etc... The expressions on the so-called "Aryan Nation" members' faces were matched only by the expressions on the Nation of Islam members' faces! XD
Before the term "Indo European" was coined, Aryan used to refer to all indo-european speakers when the European adopted the term.
If they wanted to be consistent they would latch onto a traditionalist but non-nazi theory that aryans were spiritual beings, and you can be spiritually aryan.
I am pretty sure they dismiss your teachings as "Jewish propaganda". Also, aren't they the most horrific and violent prison gangs? You are lucky you didn't get stabbed yet
Eireann (Ireland) is cognate with Aryanam, and with Iran.
Aryan= Noble "I am Aryan, my father was Aryan, his father's father was Aryan" as Cyrus I said, "proving" he was fit to rule.
I'm not sure where I heard this quote, so it could be apocryphal, but I heard somewhere that Hitler himself regarded Himmler's obsession with digging up old tribal Germanic sites as an annoying embarrassment, a reminder that the Germans had been (metaphorically) banging rocks together when the Romans were building empires.
To be honest, the Germans were also literally beating rocks, so we're the Romans.
Flint napping is still done to this day.
Yeah because Romans had far more slaves. Not much of an accomplishment if you think about it.
@@non-whitesareevil.9090 They could write how down and keep record of said slaves and plan out how much stone thet required to build an Aquaduct. Some improvement.
Yeah it's true.
@@non-whitesareevil.9090 Having slaves doesn't means that you can build monumental structures and bring your culture to 4 corners of known world.
Hey TIK I just wanted to say that I really appreciate the effort you put into your videos.
Great video mate. Great research and very fascinating and worthwhile reflections interspersed throughout, and especially at the end.
The only group who called themselves Aryans were indians(Hindus) and Iranians. No European ancestors called themselves Aryan. These racist theories developed by hitler and other europeans were based on lies, rather than facts. Secondly, the ancient name of India was " aryavarta" meaning abode of Aryans.
@@Louernos true, all Aryans were indo-european, but not all the indo-europeans were Aryans. And this is a fact. They spilt up , in ancient times. And actually the vedic Aryans were quite critical of non-aryans, i.e europeans like Greeks etc. derogatory words like "maleecha" (godless barbarians)were used for them.
@@Louernos and there was a german historian who told them they are wrong, and all theories were nonsense. They threw him our of the country. forgot his name though .
@@daizyflower272either you are coping or you live in denial. the indo aryan dna is found throughout india. arya itself is a sanskrit word. its literally the same people. its not rocket science either. same people wrote the rigveda, and passed it to their children. literally the same people
@@daizyflower272r1a haplogroup is the most diverse in india. in europe , its not as diverse in india. its the same people, genetically aswell. its not rocket science. its not like they vanished into thin air, they literally are the ancestors of northern indians, and no amount of coping will change that
@@daizyflower272what you say is even genetically incorrect . r1a is common in india, and is most diverse. india has called "Aryavarta" , i.e, land of aryans, for thousands of years,even in medival times. still called today.
38:00 "Yes! Madman Evola was out-madmaned by madman Willigut". Dude, I died!
Also: Is there a detailed record of Williguts formidable... "insights"? Perhaps a book or something? Sounds like it would make for an awesome read!
Hello TIK. In a previous video you mentioned that later in his life George Orwell ceased to be a socialist. Could you make a more detailed video exploring the shift in his political attitudes, since many leftists still use the "but orwell was a socialist" argument
I'm guessing because he realized it was a lost cause and that he was already conflicted about it when he was and learned about Nazism and Stalinism, but I'd like to know myself
I'd much rather like to hear a more scholarly piece on the etymology of Germany and its absorption of the Aryan concept instead of this cherry chosen nonsense that is pseudo professorial in intent but Beano and Dandy in practice.
@Buster Crabbe He did yes but why does he need to be labelled either?
@Buster Crabbe Please!
@Buster Crabbe Excuse me, what are you saying here?
“Himmler was a living argument for why nerds should be bullied at school.”
-Roger Cheeto, probably, maybe, possibly
Haha stop the bullying!
(I need to ask you: did you enjoy last week's video?)
Nah , Sun Tzu said this in his famous "Aladin and the 40 thieves"
@@TheImperatorKnight*Gigachad face*
Yes
Wow i had no idea about that Blavatsky connection. The way what you are presenting ties in with everything I've been learning about Aryans, Gnosticism and many other topics is very fascinating to me.
They got the hyperborean idea from Bal Gangadhar Tilak in his book ‘ The Arctic Home in the Vedas’, not Blavatsky
You would love Robert sephre
When your D&D larp group starts a globe spanning war.
Great video as always! But of course it's BC/AD and not BCE/CE. If people don't like it then they can invent their own calender.
You've been holding out on us TIK! We thought the Nazis invaded the Caucasus for oil when it was really to cross their "swords" with Wotan's "spear".
There's actually some truth to that. The Nazis had some rational war aims but their overall policy can only really be understood if you understand their fundamentally irrational, romantic world-view.
When they talk about “Blood”, they were actually referring to genetics which was later discovered. It’s now been proven that the quality of people is derived from their genetic ancestry.
First time watcher here, and new subscriber! This is AWESOME historical context, thank you. I love your subtle levity as well.
This is the best, most comprehensive, and well-organized presentation on this very esoteric subject yet. Thanks very much, @TIK. I would like your thoughts on influences on Himmler from his uncle and father's Jesuit connections. Please comment on Schellenberg's associating Himmler with Jesuitry, and the literature surrounding that idea.
One of the finest lectures I have ever hear Prof. Copious thanks for all you do. 👨🎓
Am I the only man who shed a tear when he said we would never know about these ancient eurasian super saiyan race 🥲 and the fact is that history is just a majority accepted view of things because most accounts were from people who were biased and would throw some razzle dazzle in the story.
We waz tribes n sheet
Here, I'm plugging something too. "The Ancient City" a book about the Indo-European religion.
Great video. I would like to point out that the only group of Indo-Europeans to call themselves Arya, are the Indo-Iranians and the Indo-Aryans. Therefore I do not think we could label the other IE groups under that name. It is unfortunate Hitler lived in pre-genomic era because now we know that the Yamnaya(PIE) who were a mix of Caucasus hunter gatherers and Early European farmers looked far from what Hitler fantasized them to be.(They were predominantly Brown-Eyed/Dark-Haired.
Genetically blue eyes and blonde hair is a recessive trait. Having both is lucky I suppose.
That's actually untrue. Celts had ario- as a prefix for names (meaning noble, like avestan ariya). Greeks had arete and aristo (same root), see aristocrat. Irish people had aire (meaning lord). Germans had something like arjuna if Im not mistaken, same meaning. Hittite had ara meaning tribesfolk. Aryan is just the sanskrit version of a universally indoeuropean term for nobility, used with the same meaning all across the indoeuropean lands.
@@statenthusiast3382 I didn't say aryan wasn't used by northern indians, on the contrary, I said its a sanskrit word. However, to say that only indo-aryans called themselves aryan is wrong. All indo-europeans did.
@@RoderickVI it even has cognates with hittite language(the oldest proto indo european language). And in most indo european languages it means free man/noble
Being Aryan is my pride, I'm not referring to that racist idealogy but Aryans have some great culture. Born Indian and Aryan.
I am always so appreciative of the way you broach topics such as these. You do a great job of analyzing the facts as they are yet when talking about topics such as faith and religion, you maintain a respectful (not an attitude of disdain and arrogance) stance and do not try to make people feel bad for believing in something by faith alone. However, at the same time, you call things as they are, especially in relation to these Nazi ideologies that tried to ground their beliefs in a veil of quasi science/history. I don't know.. I'm probably not conveying what I wanted to say very well but ultimately, I guess I'm just saying you're doing a great job and I really appreciate your content. Thanks!
Thank you for another one! Love watching these while I smoke my evening cigar.
Sounds badass.
Racism isn't a part of national socialism. The Nazis nationalism was not German nationalism. A German national socialism wouldn't have had anything to do with Aryans. The Nazis were race nationalists. The nation was the Aryan nation. Hence the gang name. It was a nation of a certain group of people, but that group wasn't German. It was all Aryans in all countries.
Hitler didn't want a united German socialism. He wanted a united European socialism ruled by Aryans. Hitler was not pro-german. He was pro-european and a white supremacist.
Nationalism and national socialism do NOT equate to race nationalism. That is only one type of nationalism, just like spaghetti is a pasta, but it only refers to one type of pasta.
The Nazis were absolutely Aryan nationalists, and they were absolutely socialists. Jews and other non-aryans we're not a part of their socialist system.
When Hitler came to power as a "national socialist," the other parties were euro-socialists or communists. They were technically all a kind of socialism, which is a synonym of communism, but the only difference is their preference for certain groups. Euro-socialists were the establishment of the time, which was a bad time for Germany. Communists we're a horrible scourge across Asia. Hitler talked up about Germany and that is what Germans wanted. Free bullcrap they couldn't afford from a pro-german government.
Calling them socialists outs you as completely politically illiterate. nazi sympathy.
nazi spotted
also you got litterally 0 idea what you are going off about
@Jadwiga Another liar I see. You know, nazis disagree pretty hard with that lol. They like the fact that you lie in their favour though.
It is socialism though
Hey TIK, since you mentioned Tolkien off-hand in this video, I was tempted to ask: Is there anything in The Silmarillion, The Lord Of The Rings, or any of Tolkien's notes or letters, that you'd interpret as him making social commentary (indirectly, considering his explicit hatred of allegory) on the politics and culture of his time?
I was shocked somebody from the UK would say something was "more entertaining" than Tolkien even if (hopefully) said in jest...
Good question.
I am currently reading LOTR again for maybe the 8th or 10th time and also watching videos from an exceptionally true to the book Tolkien geek.
There are one or two videos very high on my 'watch later' list which deal with Tolkien's moral lessons, allegory, etc.
Maybe you have already seen them, but if not let me know. It may be a couple days before I get to the right one (some are short and others 1hr+)
I like to carefully watch and sometimes rewatch a video before making a specific recommendation, but if you are generally interested in Tolkein, then I can readily pass on the geek's RUclips name if you like. Just let me know.
Apostolic Majesty made some interesting videos in his Ardaranye series on the possible historical and mythological inspirations in Tolkien's works. However, I would be very hesitant to call any of it social commentary especially on current events. Tolkien was primarily focused on the creation of a 'real' world and taking elements that already exist in our very much real world whether in ancient mythology or concrete historical record makes that goal much easier to achieve.
@@Alex_Fahey I think I'm fully with you on that, but I don't claim to be an expert other than knowing that people like to spin everything and anything that supports whatever agenda they have chosen that makes them special, sometimes with "special insight" that is meant to astound us.
Tolkein Lore
everytime you post a non Stalingrad video, the day gets insanely better
This propaganda needs to end. This entire documentary was riddles with false narratives, propaganda, and conspiracy theories.
Okay. I'm open. What exactly is wrong and why?
That book sounds like a great add to my winter reading list. I really loved this video, you linked so many different aspects of this topic beautifully. And I'm old enough to remember some of those 69's and 70's books. All kinds of books came out then where imagination triumphed over scholarship.
Utz utermann /Von Daniken