#CourtTV What do YOU think? Is this justice? MS v. #CarlyGregg #DeadlyDaughterMurderTrial *TRIAL NOTES:* 00:14:55 ON THE RECORD - Judge Dewey Arthur 00:23:29 JURY INSTRUCTIONS 00:37:47 STATE CLOSING ARGUMENT - ADA Michael White 00:59:58 DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT Part 1 - Bridget Todd 01:23:25 DEFENSE CLOSING Part 2 - Kevin Camp 01:51:43 STATE FINAL ARGUMENT - ADA Katherine White Newman 02:16:26 VERDICT WATCH 04:10:02 JURY REACHES A VERDICT 04:19:29 Judge Arthur Reads the Verdict 04:26:43 Penalty Phase 05:39:08 Verdict Penalty Phase MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/carly-gregg/?
Like all unaware kids do. I remember scolding my son for crying because of his direct consequences rather than the indirect consequences caused by his actions. The little girl has much to learn, obviously.
she was crying when videos were being replayed? you are def unaware of certain mental illnesses, you have no idea what that girl has, imo i think she should spend a long time in prison & then be able to get out eventually into a mental institution & be watched for awhile until she is healthy & able to turn her life around for the better
That’s sad, she’s only 15, something was obviously wrong and it her age they don’t know how to look for help or understand that anything is wrong but they grow up with they think is normal
Wait. I thought she was a "genius". She wasn't too smart to think she'd get away with it. She's not a genius. She's an arrogant psychopath who continues to show no remorse. She was just caught early and young. That was justice for Ashley 🕊
@@ceeem5720 I’m sure her mother would not want this outcome for her child … she knew she had mental issues .. even the stepfather knew.. I am sickened from all the ignorants comments she’s a child.. her brain isn’t even fully developed .. the state lawyer and jury should be ashamed of their choices her step dad loses both .. you heard him says her eyes were black in wasn’t Carly a lot of people need to educate themselves before being on a jury or commenting these sad comments .. she will never survive in jail 😞
Being a teenager isn’t a defense for murder and attempted murder. What I heard during the trial, is that she was going through some tough hormonal moodiness of a teenager and simply didn’t like the rules of her normal loving home. 🤷🏻♀️ ….Again, not a plausible defense for murder ma’am. 🤦🏻♀️
I have watched several trials, I’ve just got to say this… this is the strangest family, I’ve ever seen! From the stepdad, grandpa, grandma, Carly’s friends.What a odd group of people! Guilty! ⚖️
What your witnessing is called a trauma response otherwise known as cptsd. He still partially in shock, and the trauma bond is from a sort of entrainment we parallel to something called Stockholm syndrome. This is where the victim protects the abuser because they're not in a cognitive logical State due to the trauma.
cuz if you love someone it doesn't just disappear when they do something crazy like this. I'd still love my father even if he did something crazy. These things are super complicated.
I don't know how can she smile at her relatives in the audience. I would have been so ashamed in that age and still would if I killed someone, especially my parent, that I wouldn't dare to look at my relatives at all.
That was the biggest turnoff for me. They should have let her dress like a teen. It would have been more relatable than forcing her into an ill fitting school girl uniform. JMHO
The best part about this is she rejected the plea deal that would have been 40 years in jail (25 with good behavior). Now she’s stuck in jail for the rest of her life. Good riddance!!
That’s not quite how that works. They gave her life with parole, she will most likely be paroled after 10-25 years although her getting paroled will depend on her behavior and if she’s actually shown positive change. Although behavior can be faked like gypsy for instance
It’s literally their job. Like it or not, every single American has the right to a defense and has the right to a fair trial. She deserves to go to prison, but you’re so wrong to disparage the defense attorneys for trying to give her a proper defense and part of their job is at least pretending to care about their client. Do you really think it’s easy for defense attorneys to defend some of the cases they defend? They are human too.
It’s crazy that she thinks she’s going to get any other outcome. I said it before the trial and I’ll say it again. Once the jury saw those videos of her sneaking around the house with a gun in her back waist and running to where her mother was, she was going to be guilty. Period. She wasn’t having a break down, she did what she did knowingly.
I think her motive was that she was sick of disappointing her mother. She may have done a lot more, " a lot worse things" that she feared her mother was going to find out about.
@@Mooshkie50able I don’t know what her motive was, I think she was a brat that will appreciate how good of a mother she had when she matures. I think the DA was spot on when she said it’s even scarier that nobody knows what her motive was!
She was coddled all the way to prison by everyone she came into contact with. People need to stop this and start disciplining their kids bc without discipline kids turn out confused and terrible things could happen.
Hallelujah! Justice for Ashley. RIP regardless of her sentence, society has spoken and drawn a line. You can't commit murder just because you are a whiny, little basket case.
What are you watching? The child started bawling the moment she sat down she was a blubbering mess and only just slightly calmed before they came in, then seemed to go through a bit of shock before returning to crying! She was 14 years old!!
@@meganbessenbacher7107 when they first sit down after being called in for the verdict, she's laughing and smiling with the male attorney, only when the jury comes in does she decided to take it seriously
@@meganbessenbacher7107 The only time she cried was realizing she wasn't the smartest person in the room and this evil charade is done. No soup for her. RIP Ashley. She's a cold blooded killer, age is insignificant in psychopaths. Literally zero emotion watching/listening to the video, 911 call and testimony about her mom.
Jury got it RIGHT! I believe she actually thought she was going home today with zero consequences. Also, she sure was happier when returning. She either thought it was LWPP, or they told her, don’t worry, we’ll appeal and win. 🙄 RIP Ashley!
Until the jury came back in 2 hours and her self pity water works came on. She just knew she was too smart to get convicted. Jury let her kbwk know just how wrong she had it!!
There was a movie and a true story about a girl who killed by her boyfriend with a gun that was left on top of the fridge. She got life. About 3 years into her sentence she said her dad killed her boyfriend and asked her to take the blame. Nobody believed her. This could be the same case here.
I feel horrible for the survivor. He still feels that he has to support and love this demon out of the memory of his deceased wife. Yet, he has to live the rest of his life with knowing that the demon tried to take him out.
Carly is a very smart girl she love to read all the notes that her lawyer takes always looking over their shoulder so rude. I’m glad that the Jury made the correct decision this young lady is very dangerous, RIP MRS ASHLEY
@justmeinhere5905 me either! My mom was actually very mean to me. She would call me names, and mentally abuse me all the time, she never showed love towards me, she told me if abortions were legal when she was pregnant with me I wouldn't be here, she would constantly tell me I wouldn't amount to anything and if I wanted anything in life I better marry a man for money, not love. I went through that and more and I NEVER thought of killing my mom...not even hurting her, at all! I have not one ounce of sadness for Carly!
@MartaGarcia-j1x The GENTLE PARENTING that is being done is what is causing these kids to be not able to deal with issues.....AND NOT TEACHING THEM ABOUT OUR HEAVENLY FATHER GOD JEHOVAH JIREH.....plain and simple. We can't do this life without Jesus Yeshua and the Holy Spirit in our heart as our guide.
IDK, BUT...Carly was having PANIC ATTACKS and NOT SLEEPING for sometime before the event...and from Personal experience I assure you I BLAME MY MOTHER FOR THE MOLESTING BABYSITTER! and for NEVER following thru after. He sitting in that courtroom smiling at her AND having "DAILY" phone contact!
As a schizophrenic I am so tired of people trying to claim psychosis induced memory loss as a defense to do horrible things, I’m so glad that it’s so hard to fake a psychotic mind from people that have no idea, she says her dad has schizophrenia so I truly hope she gets to know what it’s like but she needs to at least reach the onset age of it first. Idiots
I noticed the stepfather mouth to her. We will nothing ever set right with me with that stepfather. Secondly, the grandparents showing no emotion. What is with that family?
Anyone who kills someone then calls their friend to come over and see what they did is not crazy or insane. Their just pathetically ridiculous. Thank God these jurors and judge see her for what she truly is. Justice is finally served !!
Folks, Carly is NOT Crying. She is trying hard to make herself look like she's crying. Drool is not tears. Pretend to blow her nose is not tears. She is not crying once during this day 5 .
Месяц назад+1
Maybe you have the wrong glasses. I see her crying there. 😡
I think the dad loves her and her mother. He really doesn't know how to react to this situation. Maybe at first he'll feel angry towards his daughter, but after many months and trials, he might feel sorry for her. As a father, he really doesn't know what to think anymore.
Agreed with this. Everyone calling him weird in the comments… I don’t think any of us can judge how he acts because she literally attempted to kill him and killed his wife… I can’t really expect anyone to act normal after that.
@GeneralCouncilCommunication She has a good chance of appealing her sentence because life without parole for juveniles has been deemed unconstitutional by the supreme court.
@sybstaf3496 my life is AMAZING!! I've NEVER committed a crime and neither have my children!!! Question YOUR own miserable life if you think this MONSTER shouldn't be in prison for killing her mother and attempting to kill the step-dad!!! If she'd killed your loved one, would you want her out living next door to you?! I surely wouldn't...
I thought that but I suppose as her step dad he loved her, I suppose you can’t just turn that off regardless of what they’ve done. He’s lost his family and will probably never get his head round why ? Until you’re in someone’s shoes you just don’t know how you’ll react
I agree. Carly thought she was going to be set free. She was more upset at the guilty verdict than anything, imo. Is she a cold blooded killer? She seemed very cold and untouched the day she shot her mother 3 times in the face/neck. Her mother faintly cried "help me" twice, 5:32:30 while Carly sat in kitchen texting step dad, and Carly "sang" "NooOoo". This girl has issues. Having a gun readliy accessable in your home with children is dangerous. I am sure the parents never could have imagined this outcome with their child! But this happens all too often. Who is at fault? Did Carly knowingly go and get the gun, knowingly ambush her mother with 3 shots to the face? Did Carly knowingly text her step dad pretending to be mom? Did Carly knowingly wait for step dad to come home so she could shoot him as well? Yes, yes Carly knew what she was going to do and what she did. She needs to go to prison for life.
How can the stepfather sit there and say your going to be alright if that was my stepdaughter I wouldn't even be looking at her after killing her mother and his wife,Wt
Yeah in such a numb, out of body "state of mind" She still knew to hide that weapon behind her back at all times. 🙄 Her attorneys really should have persuaded her to take that plea deal
Yes, he's so sick because he saw what Carly did to her mother, His wife get over it, this only happened 6 months ago! he's suffering from PTSD give it a rest Stepdad had nothing to do with Carly being a cold-blooded killer!
I thunk he knowshow much that mother loved her and would never give up on her no matter what and wouldn't want anyone else to give up on her and leave her alone even tho she killed her. I think its an obligation and he believes his wife would want him to be supportive
It's embarrassing that you're praising your state for sentencing a juvenile to life without parole. She has a history of mental illness not to mention she is a literal child and does not have a fully formed frontal lobe. Prison is meant to reform and instead we use it as a punishment tool with no hope of leaving. This sentencing for juveniles has been ruled as cruel and unusual punishment in a majority of states for a reason.
@hayleygreen2121 I don't live in Mississippi but what I do know is that what she did was heinous and cruel is it not? Therefore in my opinion life in prison is exactly what she deserves. She terminated the life of the very person that gave her life. And not satisfied with that she attempted to take the life of another human being. I don't care if she was 11 life in prison is where murders belong. Unless they are actually mentally ill and were unaware of what they were doing then they should be institutionalized for life as well. Letting killers be free on parole is only teaching people that they can get away with murder. This kid chose fire fire is evil and may imply hell or devil. She chose that. And now she has to live with the consequences of her evil deeds.
@@bambina320 g'day mate from coggee beach ⛱️ Fremantle western Australia 🦘.great comment.correct with everything.i was reading about Brenda Spencer recently who went to prison in 1979 for a shooting at a school.have a look at he now if you can she went to prison about the same as as Carla gregg.what a look 44 years in jail gives you
The way the stepfather looks at her, the way he mouths “it’s okay” and “I love you”. It is disturbing on s many levels. Also how she always looks to him…something is off.
The female prosecutor is my heroine, she didn't let herself being influenced by the killer face and age... This killer teen deserves life in prison without parole...
She was literally on camera. Called friends to come look. Tried killing the step dad. She was completely calm throughout. Did she not know there was a camera in the house? While in court smiling w the stepdad, zero tears until she was sentenced. Just so blatant about it all and somehow she said no to 40 yrs? Who helped her decide that?! They said she was smart. Apparently not.
@NoWireHangerz she did know. After murd£ring her mother, and before trying to murd£r her stepfather, she hid the kitchen camera in the refrigerator (thus the tampering with evidence charge). She knew exactly what she was doing.
Absolutely zero crying and even smiling after coming back for sentencing smh. I'm surprised they didn't blow kisses at each other. Something seriously wrong going on there. Evil kid.
That defense attorney was hella annoying! When you know that you have to spend an hour plus to talk in circles, you know it’s over for you. The judge said two minutes like ten times and she still went on! 😂
It's interesting seeing someone her age do what she did and get the time she got when we see almost every day full grown adult public servents committing the same thing and getting zero accountability, parole, or slaps on the wrist... when they are suppose to be held to a higher standard, especially since they are trained and trusted to do their job.
Anybody else find is so bizarre the way the stepfather and Carly sort of just look and smile at one another? And the way she's just smiling up there I don't know. It just feels so off and creepy to me
Kinda suspicious how she aimed and shot her mother to kill her, but shot him once and non fatally. The strange behaviors and his looks and mouthing things to her...Reminds me of another case where an adopted daughter murdered her mother for the father because she was a minor and he made her believe she'd get away with it.
I don’t believe the stepdad was involved, although I will agree he did seem a little off - *but* I am offering him grace, as he has very recently just lost his wife in the most horrific way and his stepdaughter was her murderer, who then tried to murder him as well. I believe him innocent, but still in the depths of grief, shock and very traumatized by it all and perhaps believes his wife would want him to support and offer forgiveness. Of course I’m just guessing, but I do believe Ms Gregg’s actions were by her hand alone. Rest peacefully Ashely. My condolence and my empathy for all who were touched by this horrible tragedy. Btw, I am a retired Gramma and would have not been smiling coming in to hear my sentence and I don’t have nearly the years left to put into a life sentence that Ms Gregg has. The mere thought of prison, would make me peeing-my-pants petrified. At the podium, while the Judge read her sentence, she nodded and shrugged it off like he had said, “No ice cream for you after dinner!!”
"Stockholm syndrome" was the words that came to mind when seeing the stepdad supporting Carly. He knew her as being a good kid so it was very hard for him to believe what she did or even that she intended to really kill him to. He lost his wife, he loved his wife and Carly was all he had left to hold on to, as she was a part of his wife. Sound strange but it does happen.
she didnt seem to upset by the death of her mother or trying to kill her step father. only when she is found the verdict. that to me says cold homicidal killer.
Yes it’s bizarre. The whole family is strange. I guess it was easier to just charge the murderer than to prove an inappropriate relationship and or a collaboration. More clean to just lock up the bigger threat. I bet she will claim he put her up to it.
I think it's weird how everyone is imagining their child killing their wife, and thinking "yeah, this is how I'd respond instead". I'm autistic, but I bow and present to you my crown because that's simply got me beat.
Well, he is an adult, who, as an anesthesiologist, also has access to drugs that make people highly suggestable and dissociative. With those love looks, there's a chance there's something else going on between them. If true, given all that , I'd call it part of grooming.
For anyone who's confused, she got two whole of life sentences (no possibility of parole) plus 10 years with all sentences to run concurrently, (which is a moot point anyway). Edit: To add further clarity, minors can still be sentenced to life without parole in the US. The 2012 ruling made it that minors could not be sentenced to mandatory life without parole. This was not a mandatory sentence. It was determined by a jury.
I was going to ask what are ‘life sentences’ in this state? He didn’t say without parole. I thought they just made a new law that you couldn’t sentence minors to no parole?
The biggest thing I hate is when the accused says they can't remember or blacked out. From the Jodi Arias case to this case. We all know they remember every single thing that happened, so using the I cant remember or that they blacked out just proves to me they knew exactly what they were doing and remember every single moment of their actions!
@@namastea It was beyond odd. I think she either misunderstood and thinks she got life WITH parole, or between the guilty verdict and the sentencing verdict, she has put her hopes on an appeal for a new trial and thinks she’ll still get away with it because of her age… which will be DENIED!
She didn't want to follow house rules.i remember being told of hundreds of times by my mum as a teenager.boundaries need to be followed.or if you don't this is the worst case scenario.
She is not insane, she is evil. Can we highlight this judge and the prosecution? They did an amazing job. Can we also bring to light, this step dad??! He is just odd! This girl murdered his wife and tried to kill him!? Why is he so supportive and cutesy with this little girl? It’s odd! She got what she deserved, she’s evil and a murderer!
So glad they threw the book at her! So sick of these teens getting off with these extremely light sentences just because they're kids. Pure evil can be in any age n she's evil
Thank You! Just Bc she was 14 at the time doesn’t make her Special. In my opinion he’s dumb for even feeling sorry for her. She wanted To Get rid of him. She TRIED
What is going on with the youth of the world thinking it's ok to shoot people. It's like they're being born without a soul. Absolutely no respect or compassion for anyone. So sad
Its American kids, perfectly reflecting the collective aggression and violent culture that is contemporary American culture and weapon fetishism. No other country in the world has these problems with middle class kids murdering or masshootings. None.
really sickening how they kept smiling back at each other, when he tires of her she will turn on him and implicate him, he's living on borrowed time in the land of the free. I see chains, bars, and shackles in his future.
@@soude85 i'm sorry when did he state he's seen someone and they diagnosed him with those things? A bit armchair psychologist of you over someone you've never spoken to lol
![ATEEZ(에이티즈) - [GOLDEN HOUR : Part.2] Preview](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X4PfgRPBUVo/mqdefault.jpg)
#CourtTV What do YOU think? Is this justice? MS v. #CarlyGregg #DeadlyDaughterMurderTrial
*TRIAL NOTES:*
00:14:55 ON THE RECORD - Judge Dewey Arthur
00:23:29 JURY INSTRUCTIONS
00:37:47 STATE CLOSING ARGUMENT - ADA Michael White
00:59:58 DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT Part 1 - Bridget Todd
01:23:25 DEFENSE CLOSING Part 2 - Kevin Camp
01:51:43 STATE FINAL ARGUMENT - ADA Katherine White Newman
02:16:26 VERDICT WATCH
04:10:02 JURY REACHES A VERDICT
04:19:29 Judge Arthur Reads the Verdict
04:26:43 Penalty Phase
05:39:08 Verdict Penalty Phase
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/carly-gregg/?
It is justice! She killed her poor mom in cold blood!!
@@CourtTV Justice!
The sound quality in parts was bad. A warning would have been nice
Justice
She did a mistake it got to be something behind it the lawyer is evil you should give another chance at least parole the lawyer is evil😢
She wasn’t crying because she did it. She’s crying because she’s being held accountable.
Exactly
Always!!!! 🎯
Like all unaware kids do. I remember scolding my son for crying because of his direct consequences rather than the indirect consequences caused by his actions. The little girl has much to learn, obviously.
Well young "Lady" grab your bag lunch and head back to your cell. You'll be doing a lot and I mean a lot of bag lunches.
she was crying when videos were being replayed? you are def unaware of certain mental illnesses, you have no idea what that girl has, imo i think she should spend a long time in prison & then be able to get out eventually into a mental institution & be watched for awhile until she is healthy & able to turn her life around for the better
I LOVE this judge!
No BS ! Down to earth.
Don't or NEVER have I seen such a REAL person in the legal system.
REFRESHING!
Judge Everett is awesome too
I think the judge in the Sarah Boone case tops all the judges I have ever seen.
Great to see the jury made a quick and decisive decision. They got this one 100% right.
I can't see nothing on my screen....
@@CHRISSISPITALIOTIS Why not?.
@@CHRISSISPITALIOTIS skip forward til U do, .
@@missbee3618Lmfao smh🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤣🤣🤣
Said no to a 40 year deal only to get life - good
Damn
Interesting....I didn't know that. Bet she regrets that now.
Exactly 💯I'm glad
That’s sad, she’s only 15, something was obviously wrong and it her age they don’t know how to look for help or understand that anything is wrong but they grow up with they think is normal
@@LisaChambers-nt9zvThat's no excuse for MURDER
Wait. I thought she was a "genius". She wasn't too smart to think she'd get away with it. She's not a genius. She's an arrogant psychopath who continues to show no remorse. She was just caught early and young. That was justice for Ashley 🕊
She lied about being Val Victorian
Agree. She is arrogant.
Book smart doesn't equate to common sense
@@GeneralCouncilCommunication It’s Valedictorian, just so you know. Not being a smarta$$. ☮️
@@ceeem5720 I’m sure her mother would not want this outcome for her child … she knew she had mental issues .. even the stepfather knew.. I am sickened from all the ignorants comments she’s a child.. her brain isn’t even fully developed .. the state lawyer and jury should be ashamed of their choices her step dad loses both .. you heard him says her eyes were black in wasn’t Carly a lot of people need to educate themselves before being on a jury or commenting these sad comments .. she will never survive in jail 😞
The audacity of her to stare so shocked and dumbfounded as he polls the jury AS IF THIS WASNT THE DIRECT RESULT OF HER OWN ACTIONS
Miss Gregg, you may be released on parole when your mother steps out of her grave alive.
😂😂😂
That woulda been a cold mic drop moment by the judge sheesh 🥶
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼best comment!!
Crazy😞 but true
This judge has my name, Arthur Dewey Givens that's so strange 😢 his first name Dewey last name Arthur 🤔
The State’s closing rebuttal was BRILLIANT!
She never cried after shooting her mom! The tears are for her.
She was heavily medicated
@@S1OFly No, she wasn’t! 5mg is not “heavily medicated”.🙄
@@debibundtzen8628 yes!
@@S1OFly Not her, but sure you!
@@S1OFlycrap
So sad. They got it right. These kids need to learn that there are consequences to your actions.
Yes ! I'm so glad u said this.
This Judge does not play I love him actually
Being a teenager isn’t a defense for murder and attempted murder.
What I heard during the trial, is that she was going through some tough hormonal moodiness of a teenager and simply didn’t like the rules of her normal loving home. 🤷🏻♀️
….Again, not a plausible defense for murder ma’am. 🤦🏻♀️
@@SeattleRaindrop206 I agree 👍
I have watched several trials, I’ve just got to say this… this is the strangest family, I’ve ever seen! From the stepdad, grandpa, grandma, Carly’s friends.What a odd group of people!
Guilty! ⚖️
If that step dad watched the same video we all did, how can he support her?? That sickens me for his wife even further.
The guy probably groomed her. He needs to be investigated. I'd bet money he has some criminal content on his devices
What your witnessing is called a trauma response otherwise known as cptsd. He still partially in shock, and the trauma bond is from a sort of entrainment we parallel to something called Stockholm syndrome. This is where the victim protects the abuser because they're not in a cognitive logical State due to the trauma.
@nancyknape770 He and Carly smiling at each other and Carly put his wife six feet under. I couldn't believe what I was watching.
@@nancyknape770 Heath Smiley refused to watch the video of the day of the murder. To this day he hasn't seen it.
cuz if you love someone it doesn't just disappear when they do something crazy like this. I'd still love my father even if he did something crazy. These things are super complicated.
I don't know how can she smile at her relatives in the audience. I would have been so ashamed in that age and still would if I killed someone, especially my parent, that I wouldn't dare to look at my relatives at all.
Trying to dress and fix her hair like an 8 year old to garner sympathy and appear innocent. Didn’t work
That was the biggest turnoff for me. They should have let her dress like a teen. It would have been more relatable than forcing her into an ill fitting school girl uniform. JMHO
@@aliciareyna4342 yep it seemed manipulative
@@glitter7777 Which is on brand for Carly…
Why I everyone have the very same opinion about this case. @@aliciareyna4342
The best part about this is she rejected the plea deal that would have been 40 years in jail (25 with good behavior). Now she’s stuck in jail for the rest of her life. Good riddance!!
That’s not quite how that works. They gave her life with parole, she will most likely be paroled after 10-25 years although her getting paroled will depend on her behavior and if she’s actually shown positive change. Although behavior can be faked like gypsy for instance
Yup she shd hv tkn that deal. Not as smart as she thought she was
How many years does she have to be In jail ? 25 ?
@@docdynamix LIFE NOW BECAUSE SHE DIDNT TOOK THE PLEA DEAL
Amen. She’s EXTREMELY dangerous to society.
That female lawyer trying to manipulate the jury by coddling the murderer is disgusting.
It's their job 🤦
Damn it worked on me real well
It’s literally their job. Like it or not, every single American has the right to a defense and has the right to a fair trial. She deserves to go to prison, but you’re so wrong to disparage the defense attorneys for trying to give her a proper defense and part of their job is at least pretending to care about their client. Do you really think it’s easy for defense attorneys to defend some of the cases they defend? They are human too.
@@autumnrene807Even so, it's still disgusting 😔
@@pw191164 go read what lawyers are and what their job is....
I'm so glad that the jury didn't fall for the "innocent little girl" look.
It’s crazy that she thinks she’s going to get any other outcome. I said it before the trial and I’ll say it again. Once the jury saw those videos of her sneaking around the house with a gun in her back waist and running to where her mother was, she was going to be guilty. Period. She wasn’t having a break down, she did what she did knowingly.
I think her motive was that she was sick of disappointing her mother. She may have done a lot more, " a lot worse things" that she feared her mother was going to find out about.
@@Mooshkie50able I don’t know what her motive was, I think she was a brat that will appreciate how good of a mother she had when she matures. I think the DA was spot on when she said it’s even scarier that nobody knows what her motive was!
She was coddled all the way to prison by everyone she came into contact with. People need to stop this and start disciplining their kids bc without discipline kids turn out confused and terrible things could happen.
Hallelujah! Justice for Ashley. RIP regardless of her sentence, society has spoken and drawn a line. You can't commit murder just because you are a whiny, little basket case.
She didn't think she was going home are you not paying attention?
@@ladycasey1717 😂 LOL
Watching her sob into her lawyer is justice enough. She will never have her mother’s shoulder to cry on again cos she blew her head off! Monster.
Nobody was crying for her, they know… Now they can start to heal. RIP Ashley!
I thought the same thing no one cried. I know what she did was horrible but I find that sad and telling 😕
@@soude85 step dad made me sick kept on telling her he loved her...im sorry but if my step child killed my spouse there would be no love for her
Step dad is Jenn Soto in reverse.
@@someoneusa that’s a good description and sad too
@@CoffeeMakesMeHappy3 very sad and infuriating at the same time.
She was smiling and laughing right before the jury came in, but justice being served wiped that smirk away. Good job jurors.
What are you watching? The child started bawling the moment she sat down she was a blubbering mess and only just slightly calmed before they came in, then seemed to go through a bit of shock before returning to crying! She was 14 years old!!
@@meganbessenbacher7107 when they first sit down after being called in for the verdict, she's laughing and smiling with the male attorney, only when the jury comes in does she decided to take it seriously
@@ruckbarbie sure did. She realized real quick times up.
@@meganbessenbacher7107 The only time she cried was realizing she wasn't the smartest person in the room and this evil charade is done. No soup for her. RIP Ashley. She's a cold blooded killer, age is insignificant in psychopaths. Literally zero emotion watching/listening to the video, 911 call and testimony about her mom.
Absolutely! That's when FAFO set in, reality hits quick when you're as arrogant as that little lady.
Justice for her poor mama. And I pray that man, her stepfather, gets the help he needs to heal.
I feel like the mom’s parents are fooled by this girl’s antics. She’s clearly one of those children that kill.
This Judge is PHENOMENAL!!! Could watch him all day. This time the justice system worked. Good job 12 🙏🏻
Good Job Jury!!
Defense attorneys knew they had lost . The last evaluation summed her up perfectly! It was all over.
Dr Pickett explained best. 👌
@@wolke1955 He sure did, he saw through her lies.
Yup agree. It was an excellent break down
@@wolke1955
What day was that on please, so that I can go back and watch or rewatch if I caught the shorter video testimonies. Thanks!
@@RLFinTX Guess day 4?
...let's just say it. There is no defense for what she did. none. 🎉
@@noturbiz633 None at all.
Jury got it RIGHT! I believe she actually thought she was going home today with zero consequences. Also, she sure was happier when returning. She either thought it was LWPP, or they told her, don’t worry, we’ll appeal and win. 🙄 RIP Ashley!
@@holylandfan3275 she did.
Like most teenagers, that think they can get away with anything.
Yes she did get LWOP@@sugardaddydave3577
@@holylandfan3275 they won’t win appeal. She’s done
Until the jury came back in 2 hours and her self pity water works came on. She just knew she was too smart to get convicted. Jury let her kbwk know just how wrong she had it!!
that stepfather. I don't know.
He's almost as weird as her.
There was a movie and a true story about a girl who killed by her boyfriend with a gun that was left on top of the fridge. She got life. About 3 years into her sentence she said her dad killed her boyfriend and asked her to take the blame. Nobody believed her. This could be the same case here.
Creepy af
He is strange but I think he’s just a geek. Idk
@@mmay6621Maybe, but something seems really odd.
A threat to the society, lock her up for the rest of her life.
Done 👍
Get rid of the guns you bloody fools.
I feel horrible for the survivor. He still feels that he has to support and love this demon out of the memory of his deceased wife. Yet, he has to live the rest of his life with knowing that the demon tried to take him out.
I was shocked with the defense and their theory. Make that make sense.
She smiled every time he told this story.
Kudos to the jury!
Carly is a very smart girl she love to read all the notes that her lawyer takes always looking over their shoulder so rude. I’m glad that the Jury made the correct decision this young lady is very dangerous, RIP MRS ASHLEY
I didn't have a mother daughter relationship with my mom, never in my wildest dreams would I think to harm my parents or siblings.
@justmeinhere5905 me either! My mom was actually very mean to me. She would call me names, and mentally abuse me all the time, she never showed love towards me, she told me if abortions were legal when she was pregnant with me I wouldn't be here, she would constantly tell me I wouldn't amount to anything and if I wanted anything in life I better marry a man for money, not love. I went through that and more and I NEVER thought of killing my mom...not even hurting her, at all! I have not one ounce of sadness for Carly!
@MartaGarcia-j1x The GENTLE PARENTING that is being done is what is causing these kids to be not able to deal with issues.....AND NOT TEACHING THEM ABOUT OUR HEAVENLY FATHER GOD JEHOVAH JIREH.....plain and simple. We can't do this life without Jesus Yeshua and the Holy Spirit in our heart as our guide.
She's actually smiling and laughing with her attorney as she waits for her sentencing phase....a true psychopath
I wonder about that step dad . How could he be smiling at Carly who murdered his wife.
Seems like some type of trauma bonding happened.
IDK, BUT...Carly was having PANIC ATTACKS and NOT SLEEPING for sometime before the event...and from Personal experience I assure you I BLAME MY MOTHER FOR THE MOLESTING BABYSITTER! and for NEVER following thru after. He sitting in that courtroom smiling at her AND having "DAILY" phone contact!
@@lisalawrence5026your personal projection isn’t facts in this case. You’re wild lol. Sorry you were molested but not everyone gets molested. 🤷♀️
@@lisalawrence5026 what are you talking about? This isn't about you.
@@60toodlesright? There’s always one out here that try and make it about them and relate to the story. lol
As a schizophrenic I am so tired of people trying to claim psychosis induced memory loss as a defense to do horrible things, I’m so glad that it’s so hard to fake a psychotic mind from people that have no idea, she says her dad has schizophrenia so I truly hope she gets to know what it’s like but she needs to at least reach the onset age of it first. Idiots
No emotions at all after being sentenced to life in prison, she’s the true definition of a psychopath
I saw her crying
@@KAHLILOFFICIAL worse than that, she was trying to cry
Absolute psychopath
Is life with parole or without parole?
@@KAHLILOFFICIAL did you guys see her smiling and laughing at the end?
I noticed the stepfather mouth to her. We will nothing ever set right with me with that stepfather. Secondly, the grandparents showing no emotion. What is with that family?
Anyone who kills someone then calls their friend to come over and see what they did is not crazy or insane. Their just pathetically ridiculous. Thank God these jurors and judge see her for what she truly is. Justice is finally served !!
That isn't necessarily true. They could be crazy. It depends on the situation and case.
Folks, Carly is NOT Crying. She is trying hard to make herself look like she's crying. Drool is not tears. Pretend to blow her nose is not tears. She is not crying once during this day 5 .
Maybe you have the wrong glasses. I see her crying there. 😡
I think the dad loves her and her mother. He really doesn't know how to react to this situation. Maybe at first he'll feel angry towards his daughter, but after many months and trials, he might feel sorry for her. As a father, he really doesn't know what to think anymore.
Agreed with this. Everyone calling him weird in the comments… I don’t think any of us can judge how he acts because she literally attempted to kill him and killed his wife… I can’t really expect anyone to act normal after that.
I think the love he feels for her is it's the wrong king of * love *
@@nachita0819ya it’s def giving pedo made stepdaughter un alive his wife aka her mom
This verdict and sentence made me happy!!! She really thought she was gonna get off!!! No one she'd a tear for her..
They probably believe she has a chance of appeal
@GeneralCouncilCommunication She has a good chance of appealing her sentence because life without parole for juveniles has been deemed unconstitutional by the supreme court.
@hayleygreen2121 good!
Ms.j9693….The verdict made you happy wow!!!! Just how miserable is your life
@sybstaf3496 my life is AMAZING!! I've NEVER committed a crime and neither have my children!!! Question YOUR own miserable life if you think this MONSTER shouldn't be in prison for killing her mother and attempting to kill the step-dad!!! If she'd killed your loved one, would you want her out living next door to you?! I surely wouldn't...
What the in home camera showed is hard to forget, much less to explain.
Those 2 doggies were so scared 😢
Her step dead is weird the way he interacts with her during trial
He was in on it no doubt
Agreed. Creepy
I thought that but I suppose as her step dad he loved her, I suppose you can’t just turn that off regardless of what they’ve done. He’s lost his family and will probably never get his head round why ? Until you’re in someone’s shoes you just don’t know how you’ll react
Step dad!!
He's clueless..The mother is the one who disciplined her daughter really knew her daughter..
I agree. Carly thought she was going to be set free. She was more upset at the guilty verdict than anything, imo. Is she a cold blooded killer? She seemed very cold and untouched the day she shot her mother 3 times in the face/neck. Her mother faintly cried "help me" twice, 5:32:30 while Carly sat in kitchen texting step dad, and Carly "sang"
"NooOoo". This girl has issues. Having a gun readliy accessable in your home with children is dangerous. I am sure the parents never could have imagined this outcome with their child! But this happens all too often. Who is at fault? Did Carly knowingly go and get the gun, knowingly ambush her mother with 3 shots to the face? Did Carly knowingly text her step dad pretending to be mom? Did Carly knowingly wait for step dad to come home so she could shoot him as well? Yes, yes Carly knew what she was going to do and what she did. She needs to go to prison for life.
If it wasn’t the gun it would have been a knife, she knew what she was doing and would have found a way - she is evil and the jury got it right!!
How can the stepfather sit there and say your going to be alright if that was my stepdaughter I wouldn't even be looking at her after killing her mother and his wife,Wt
Yeah in such a numb, out of body "state of mind" She still knew to hide that weapon behind her back at all times. 🙄 Her attorneys really should have persuaded her to take that plea deal
The step dad is sick, you gone whisper I love you to her after she killed your wife and then shot and tried to kill you as well, oh hell nah
Yes, he's so sick because he saw what Carly did to her mother, His wife get over it, this only happened 6 months ago! he's suffering from PTSD give it a rest Stepdad had nothing to do with Carly being a cold-blooded
killer!
in which part of this video does that happen
@@conniejitooooAbout 4:59:05.
I thunk he knowshow much that mother loved her and would never give up on her no matter what and wouldn't want anyone else to give up on her and leave her alone even tho she killed her. I think its an obligation and he believes his wife would want him to be supportive
Thank you Honorable Judge Arthur.
Nobody in that family is facing reality.
It's a tough reality to have to face! Takes time. Years!
That’s the quickest deliberation of a jury I’ve ever seen. She’s never going to see the light of day again
They don’t waste no time man they cut right to the chase and do sentencing We Mississippi a state you want to mess with
Also g'day mate from coggee beach ⛱️ Fremantle western Australia 🦘
It's embarrassing that you're praising your state for sentencing a juvenile to life without parole. She has a history of mental illness not to mention she is a literal child and does not have a fully formed frontal lobe. Prison is meant to reform and instead we use it as a punishment tool with no hope of leaving. This sentencing for juveniles has been ruled as cruel and unusual punishment in a majority of states for a reason.
@hayleygreen2121 I don't live in Mississippi but what I do know is that what she did was heinous and cruel is it not? Therefore in my opinion life in prison is exactly what she deserves. She terminated the life of the very person that gave her life. And not satisfied with that she attempted to take the life of another human being. I don't care if she was 11 life in prison is where murders belong.
Unless they are actually mentally ill and were unaware of what they were doing then they should be institutionalized for life as well. Letting killers be free on parole is only teaching people that they can get away with murder. This kid chose fire fire is evil and may imply hell or devil. She chose that. And now she has to live with the consequences of her evil deeds.
@@bambina320 g'day mate from coggee beach ⛱️ Fremantle western Australia 🦘.great comment.correct with everything.i was reading about Brenda Spencer recently who went to prison in 1979 for a shooting at a school.have a look at he now if you can she went to prison about the same as as Carla gregg.what a look 44 years in jail gives you
R.I.P Ashley
Only if Jesus Christ was her Lord and Saviour.
I believe I only saw her cry for herself
They got it right ⚖️🙌🏻
The way the stepfather looks at her, the way he mouths “it’s okay” and “I love you”. It is disturbing on s many levels. Also how she always looks to him…something is off.
The female prosecutor is my heroine, she didn't let herself being influenced by the killer face and age... This killer teen deserves life in prison without parole...
Clearly, the girl has issues.. but there was no way the jury was going to allow her any chance at release in the future. Good on them!
She was literally on camera. Called friends to come look. Tried killing the step dad. She was completely calm throughout. Did she not know there was a camera in the house? While in court smiling w the stepdad, zero tears until she was sentenced. Just so blatant about it all and somehow she said no to 40 yrs? Who helped her decide that?! They said she was smart. Apparently not.
@NoWireHangerz she did know. After murd£ring her mother, and before trying to murd£r her stepfather, she hid the kitchen camera in the refrigerator (thus the tampering with evidence charge). She knew exactly what she was doing.
Was the stepfather abusive?
I’m sure the parents said no. As a mom, you wouldn’t want to wish that on your baby
(Love your handle, Joan / Faye. ~C)
Absolutely zero crying and even smiling after coming back for sentencing smh. I'm surprised they didn't blow kisses at each other. Something seriously wrong going on there. Evil kid.
THE DEFENSE is 🤡 just as crazy as their client 😂😂
That defense attorney was hella annoying! When you know that you have to spend an hour plus to talk in circles, you know it’s over for you. The judge said two minutes like ten times and she still went on! 😂
Bet she wishes she took the plea deal now
The arrogance of a self-claimed genius.
She’s probably wishing even harder she didn’t even do it.
It's interesting seeing someone her age do what she did and get the time she got when we see almost every day full grown adult public servents committing the same thing and getting zero accountability, parole, or slaps on the wrist... when they are suppose to be held to a higher standard, especially since they are trained and trusted to do their job.
I think the jury got it right unfortunately so sad for everyone involved.
Anybody else find is so bizarre the way the stepfather and Carly sort of just look and smile at one another? And the way she's just smiling up there I don't know. It just feels so off and creepy to me
Kinda suspicious how she aimed and shot her mother to kill her, but shot him once and non fatally.
The strange behaviors and his looks and mouthing things to her...Reminds me of another case where an adopted daughter murdered her mother for the father because she was a minor and he made her believe she'd get away with it.
I don’t believe the stepdad was involved, although I will agree he did seem a little off - *but* I am offering him grace, as he has very recently just lost his wife in the most horrific way and his stepdaughter was her murderer, who then tried to murder him as well. I believe him innocent, but still in the depths of grief, shock and very traumatized by it all and perhaps believes his wife would want him to support and offer forgiveness. Of course I’m just guessing, but I do believe Ms Gregg’s actions were by her hand alone.
Rest peacefully Ashely. My condolence and my empathy for all who were touched by this horrible tragedy.
Btw, I am a retired Gramma and would have not been smiling coming in to hear my sentence and I don’t have nearly the years left to put into a life sentence that Ms Gregg has. The mere thought of prison, would make me peeing-my-pants petrified. At the podium, while the Judge read her sentence, she nodded and shrugged it off like he had said, “No ice cream for you after dinner!!”
"Stockholm syndrome" was the words that came to mind when seeing the stepdad supporting Carly. He knew her as being a good kid so it was very hard for him to believe what she did or even that she intended to really kill him to. He lost his wife, he loved his wife and Carly was all he had left to hold on to, as she was a part of his wife. Sound strange but it does happen.
she didnt seem to upset by the death of her mother or trying to kill her step father. only when she is found the verdict. that to me says cold homicidal killer.
Stepdad is as creepy as can be. The way he looks at her. It's just weird.
And the way when she looked over at him he mouthed "it's ok"
Yes it’s bizarre. The whole family is strange. I guess it was easier to just charge the murderer than to prove an inappropriate relationship and or a collaboration. More clean to just lock up the bigger threat. I bet she will claim he put her up to it.
I think it's weird how everyone is imagining their child killing their wife, and thinking "yeah, this is how I'd respond instead". I'm autistic, but I bow and present to you my crown because that's simply got me beat.
You can tell their two dogs are well-behaved. Hate to see them have to go through that.
I also love this judge!!
The relationship between her and her stepdad doesn't sit well with me.Why is she smirking
She went from bawling to smiling real fast....disgusting
@@inyourdreams3263 They must have told her she’ll win an appeal… wrong!
Carrying on conversations with grand parents…how come this is allowed?????
Hopefully it helped to sway the jury showing them what a monster she truly is
No matter how you look at this it's sad my heart goes out to every one of these people and families. This child as well
Thank you jury. 100% correct verdicts and sentences.
If she was manipulated into doing this, what would be the right thing to do?
Well, he is an adult, who, as an anesthesiologist, also has access to drugs that make people highly suggestable and dissociative. With those love looks, there's a chance there's something else going on between them. If true, given all that , I'd call it part of grooming.
they got it right
For anyone who's confused, she got two whole of life sentences (no possibility of parole) plus 10 years with all sentences to run concurrently, (which is a moot point anyway).
Edit: To add further clarity, minors can still be sentenced to life without parole in the US. The 2012 ruling made it that minors could not be sentenced to mandatory life without parole. This was not a mandatory sentence. It was determined by a jury.
Yes. The 10 years was for count 3.
Thanks! I was wondering what the actual sentence was since it wasn't stipulated.
Life is 60 years in Mississippi. Concurrent means they are served at the same time. So theoretically she could get out at 75. Did they say no parole?
I was going to ask what are ‘life sentences’ in this state? He didn’t say without parole. I thought they just made a new law that you couldn’t sentence minors to no parole?
@@lynner18870!then, right?
Eventually the stepdad will move on with his life and visits with Carly at prison will be less and less
The biggest thing I hate is when the accused says they can't remember or blacked out. From the Jodi Arias case to this case. We all know they remember every single thing that happened, so using the I cant remember or that they blacked out just proves to me they knew exactly what they were doing and remember every single moment of their actions!
I really get an uneasy sense about the stepdad.
I do too. I have said that from the beginning. They definitely need to look into him.
@@aliciareyna4342you think they didn't?
She got life in prison and zero reaction. She's there stretching her neck with that pokerface, blank face, and eyes combo. So weird.
Are you blind? The child is distraught!
@@namastea because it was the second or third time she heard it. the first time, she cried 4:29:51
She's so creepy.
@@namastea It was beyond odd. I think she either misunderstood and thinks she got life WITH parole, or between the guilty verdict and the sentencing verdict, she has put her hopes on an appeal for a new trial and thinks she’ll still get away with it because of her age… which will be DENIED!
@@LawnBunny777 She a baby!
I hope she can get the help she needs.
It’s clear she thought she would get away with it. But no…she was in her right mind…I applaud the jury.
Wow, today's events went quickly.
She didn't want to follow house rules.i remember being told of hundreds of times by my mum as a teenager.boundaries need to be followed.or if you don't this is the worst case scenario.
They need to investigate the stepdad he smiles to her something is going on for sure
She is not insane, she is evil. Can we highlight this judge and the prosecution? They did an amazing job. Can we also bring to light, this step dad??! He is just odd! This girl murdered his wife and tried to kill him!? Why is he so supportive and cutesy with this little girl? It’s odd! She got what she deserved, she’s evil and a murderer!
So glad they threw the book at her! So sick of these teens getting off with these extremely light sentences just because they're kids. Pure evil can be in any age n she's evil
Thank You! Just Bc she was 14 at the time doesn’t make her Special. In my opinion he’s dumb for even feeling sorry for her. She wanted To Get rid of him. She TRIED
Well done jurors.
What is going on with the youth of the world thinking it's ok to shoot people. It's like they're being born without a soul. Absolutely no respect or compassion for anyone. So sad
@@rhondaflink9469 it's usa
Its American kids, perfectly reflecting the collective aggression and violent culture that is contemporary American culture and weapon fetishism. No other country in the world has these problems with middle class kids murdering or masshootings. None.
Did the stepdad get investigated? Something don't seem right with him. I haven't heard of this case.
Why can nobody see that step dad is a creep that was in on this
Because you are talking out of your behind, no evidence the stepdad had anything to do with this!
really sickening how they kept smiling back at each other, when he tires of her she will turn on him and implicate him, he's living on borrowed time in the land of the free. I see chains, bars, and shackles in his future.
I can’t handle the recording of this case it’s completely horrendous 😡
The quality of it or the fact of it or what?
How can the stepdad be so apathetic after murder attempt and wifes murder --in dictioary his picture is nexty to WIMP !!
It’s called depression and ptsd.
I think he's a stoner
@@soude85 i'm sorry when did he state he's seen someone and they diagnosed him with those things? A bit armchair psychologist of you over someone you've never spoken to lol
@@truthfirst2983 You are a complete muppet.