Interesting that your discussion was on balance, separation, distractions, shapes, color,, and not rule of thirds, golden ratio, and the other old tired rules. I appreciate that.
On a workshop, I learned that the while the rule of thirds might be useful to learn to stand away from bull's eye composition, what actually really does matter is balance. Even most examples given to support the "rule of thirds" actually don't support it, with strong elements not on a third. Not to mention the golden ratio, with examples that are even bigger approximations... Balance has become my "rule".
Thats something I picked up on, that and Visual Weight (part of balance I suppose), so much more useful thought process to help you decompose/deconstruct a composition rather than structural considerations like rule of thirds which you might use to assemble/build a composition.
@@daveeagle1559 yep, I would include visual weight in what I call balance. The position of the element in the composition changes its visual weight, even if you don't change its actual size. So you might need something smaller or bigger or placed differently in the composition to balance it.
I mean you’ll also notice that many of these photos follow the rule of thirds by default. The balance is then factored in around the rule to make the rest of the image work, but the rules often still provide the backbone.
It's the detail that photography requires you to see that makes it such a great hobby. It slows you down & gets you to really see. Then, if you're lucky, something unexpected may happen too. The photo is just a record of the experience, which is the real gift.
What I mostly appreciate about your videos is that not only you explain why a composition works, but you also go through shots that you weren't satisfied with. Keep that going, it really helps a lot
It's always refreshing to understand why some compositions don't work instead of just learning why the good ones do work. Thanks for sharing Nigel lots of food for thought in this video
Seeing your thought process is really opened my eyes. I was wondering what's wrong about a photo I took, there was something bothering me. Now I am able to analyze better. Cheers Nigel.
ladscape photography is such an ongoing exercise. Even after 4 years I'm still learning how to compose photos, where the best lighting is, what I want as foreground, subject etc. Your videos are always so helpful
What I find so challenging in landscape photography is composing for a clear figure / ground relationship. Keep up sharing your work, both the successes and the near successes.
It’s such an education seeing you commenting on what worked and what did not and why. Some stunning shots and humbling to see how much thought and effort you put into your photography. Thank you.
I really enjoy the self critiques because they show thought process and details in a clearer way than just showing things that work. Really good video.
Something in your last seascape photograph that caught my eye that you didn't mention, was the tide rushing out exposed some smaller rocks that weren't visible in the other shots. These smaller rocks created a natural leading line that drew my eye up toward the crashing wave and sea stacks. Great video. It's always a pleasure watching your videos and listening to your detailed explanations.
I struggle with simplifying my images. I want people to see it ALL! Which is not the way to get really powerful images, as you’ve beautifully shown in your video. I went on a weekend trip this fall to the mountains and really tried to focus on simplifying my images and putting on my zoom lense to cut out the extra stuff. It worked!
Your photos are extraordinary! I am an amateur watercolor painter and have watched so many artist videos about composition. Your videos have helped more than all others combined. Thank you so much! I have subscribed to your channel and will continue to watch and learn.
I really like the fence in the snowy picture - I think it adds to the dimension, especially as it is almost on a diagonal with the slope where the tree is sitting on... another fab video - thank you
I just love your discussion of why compositions didn’t work for certain shots. You come to a beautiful scene, it’s so enamored with it, and you forget the little details that might make or break a shot. Your description helps us to see that.
I could make this a long description of why I like you Nigel, but I'll content myself (and you) with just mentioning that I really like your channel, so informative and educational. And besides that, you really are a great photographer. Thank you for taking the time to share your inspiring and informative videos, it is highly appreciated.
What I like about your videos, Nigel, is the honesty, as you go through explaining each shot’s good points and bad, through your own eyes, which in my mind, keeps the integrity of your images shining through the photos you show. Thank you
I truly appreciate your explanation of the subtleties that you took in order to capture exactly the photo you intended. Also, showing photos that didn't work and explaining exactly why, only enhances the importance of composition. Your photos are exquisite and those trees are simply magical looking. Thank you so very much for your professional advice.
Felt good to hear you also think something is going to work but get home to realize it doesn't. Great tips, hopefully can remember when I'm out and about.
G’day Nigel. It’s great to follow your comp. ideas and it gives us more to think about our own ideas and helps in planning my shots. Always great ideas Nigel. Thank you. Stay safe.
Nigel, one of the best bits of advice you have ever offered is this: Print your shots and annotate them. I started doing this and it has made an amazing difference in my photography.
Wonderful video Nigel, thanks. I've read many books on composition but this video really hit the spot for me and made me realise where I have often been going wrong in good locations. You have been very generous taking the time to show and talk through shots that worked and shots that didn't - and detailing exactly why that was so. One of your best ever !
Your video is so insightful! The discussion about how you arrived at the final composition is exactly what I’m looking for. I learn so much “getting into” the professional photographers head. Thanks for a great video.
You'r really teaching the art of photography and not taking good pictures. Like a painter artist you give great attentions to details that add up and create a good composition. This thorough work on the scene is a precondition for a 10/10 as no post production could fix it. It is often said that one can learn most from mistakes and I think this is very much true in photography. It's always a real pleasure to watch your videos as your admirable personality shines through.
I've sort of been in a creative rut with photography for the past year. I put off watching this video because I just wasn't into the idea of it. But after watching this it's really got me (for now) back into it. It's easy to forget how fun the little things can be if you let them. All the little things you need to get just right to get the perfect photo, and the total joy you get when it all comes together.
Great video on composition! Been shooting for about 25 years and still find getting a well composed image the most difficult part of photography. Trying to simplify an image and cutting out distraction in the field is a never ending battle for me. Always working on getting the eye of the viewer to move the image in a Way that creates some emotion in the viewer. Lots of disappointing shots but very rewarding when you get a great image. I find it very frustrating and elusive. Subtle changes can have a big impact. Really enjoyed walking thru different images and what didn’t work and what finally did. Very helpful. Would love to see more videos like this on composition. Thanks. Beautiful images!
This is so helpful! I often get the feelings that professional photographers just have the right composition in their blood and immediately know how and where to take THE photo. Seeing and hearing you explain the "faults" on several of your photos and mentioning that there are lots of "fails" for one photo that is "the one", is a relief! :D
Funny that you called the one photo "The Fennell Family" with the description of the toddler, teenagers and mom and dad because as soon as I saw it my first thought was that they were Ents.
Regarding the snowy landscape image with the tree and the fence curving off to the right, the one I that series you thought came closest to working whilst questioning the inclusion of the fence: I didn’t think the fence cluttered the image nor detracted fro the tree. For me, my eyes and thoughts first went to the tree, but then were invited by the fence to follow the curve of the path. The presence of the fence both raised my curiosity about where the path led as well added to the sense that the overall image was suggesting the presence of a “story.” The enjoyment of an admittedly wonderful capture of Nature’s beauty was enhanced by the feeling that there was a narrative waiting to be discovered. Love your channel.
A composition of a photos that details what it takes for a great composition. You are now my favorite landscape photographer. My favorite photo is at the 4:25 mark which is the fairy tale background. The one you edited and cropped out. Its a testament of how subjective we are about our photos. Great video. Loved it.
This video is a great example of something that I think you taught me unintentionally, earlier. That is, that just because something doesn't look perfect in frame at the time doesn't mean there isnt a great photo in there. A huge part of me was completely disregarding some shots that maybe had something I didn't like in it. And I didn't really know how acceptable it was to just crop something out or edit it out. I'm excited to see someone talking honestly about what was right, what wasn't. It's nice to see pro talking about things they're happy with and what they wished was better and not being judgemental about the editing process.
Great, thanks, Nigel! Learning more by hearing comments re: what works in an image helps a lot. I'm trying to take woodland photos in Massachusetts in the US and more difficult because many areas old growth or contain buildings, etc. However, now I pay more attention to the little things like space between trees, breathing room in the image and what do I see in the viewfinder. Once I get home I try to critique images and many never see the light of day.
I found your channel recently, and am so glad for how you show the process and what does work and what doesn't! Also appreciated how you said how many pictures you take and how few of them are 'good' - makes me feel better about my giant unusable collection!
I’m quite grateful for your explanations! You manage to explain and show it in a way that’s easier to digest than many others or books do. Thanks!! I hope I can apply at least some of your composition rules!!
Loved it! A very clear study of what works and what doesn't. I keep telling people around me they should look at as much work by others as possible and try and understand why they like what they do and why they don't what they don't. But studying our own work is very important as well indeed. Thanks for sharing this one with us!
Very helpful, Nigel! What a great idea to show what works and what doesn't. It does help me to look at my compositions more critically in the field. Thanks.
Thanks so much for doing this. Analyzing photos, good and especially bad (less good) helps with the thinking process when we are out there on the front line. It's the thinking, not the gear, that matters most.
Thank you Nigel, one of your best and most informative videos. Being objectively self-critical is hard, but knowing why an image does or does not work is really important. In terms of composition, I find that ‘asking’ every element in the image why it is there or what its purpose is, really helps to drill down into a composition that may work.
Excellent video Nigel!! RUclips is filled with videos on the best compositions/gears etc. BUt seeing a video of comparison of what worked and what didn't is very refreshing! Thanks!
Wow, really appreciate you going over what works and what doesn't. Totally agree with what works and what doesn't, although you explaining it makes it more obvious.
This was very helpful, to hear you talk through your thought process and the work that went into each shot, both the great and the not so great. I would really appreciate more of these.
Quite inspirational !!!Soooo appreciated that you elaborated the process of shoting and what you think of these images . It is much more helpful than just seeing the master pieces after Photoshoped. Thank you so much！
I’ve been photographing since 2013, Just opposed of you I started portraits and are now very interested to start land/sea scapes. I have been watching your videos for quite some time and am very excited to start this new journey. Thank you for all your advice.
Great video.I really enjoyed your compositions and pointing out what , in your opinion works and what doesn’t work. As regards the last photo in the video. I think what really makes the shot great is the wave crashing over the rock. It shows the movement of the sea and makes the photo dynamic.
Thank you! This is the most helpful blog you have made so far, for my concern! Allowing us into to your way of thoughts, and revealing your judgement of the result is priceless. Thumbs up!
I always appreciate you detailing your thoughts on why certain images work and others don’t. Great video and explanations, as always. For the shot at 11:00, to my eye I wonder if you could salvage it by cropping out the right hand 20-25% or so of the image so that the tree frames the low lying cloud in the background as the central focal point, closer to a 4:5 or square crop. Then the tree trunk works as a leading line to the center from the corner, and mostly eliminates the darker spot with the brown fern in the lower right. From there the complicated elements you mentioned that were bothering you just help frame the central negative space of the clouds.
Great video Nigel. I really appreciate how you step through photos from the same location to illustrate the factors that make a great composition. Thanks
Hi! My first time at the channel. My most challenging condition is usually the background, as a sports photographer. There are numerous aspects that I can improve and the way you demand from yourself is really driven by a great expertise. Thank You and glad that I crossed over! Cheers
For me all the visual weight of the final shot is focused by the leading lines created by the double row of rocks in the center. They seem to be screaming “Look at the action of that wave!”. Add to that the line created by the light central foreground rock leading to the dark boulder and stack to the back, all the attention wants to rest there on those lines of rock and the the boulder the wave is crashing over. Thirdly, the dark boulder and rows of rock stand out in contrast to the white of the water to the left and right. There is so much visual gravity there. I hope I explained why my eyes just focus at that point in the image.
It takes courage to show some B-photos, but it shows that you are a true teacher and that you care not only about your growth but also about us viewers! Much appreciated! and btw. I think Fanal can be pretty frustrating, without fog it is actually so hard to take good photos, so much interesting twisted trees, but getting the composition right without the fog was nearly impossible for me...but I am glad you managed, the photos are stunningly beautiful!
My musings for today... Your photos are magical and hint at a hidden story, they are 3 dimensional, and they show movement and can be exciting as well. Is there something else that a great photo can create? Oh yes, evoking a mood, and you nailed that one too! Now if I were asked to explain why I chose one photo over the other... I would say it just felt right..... Musings over.
I think the snow shot with the fence that you feel is nearly there is actually really interesting Nigel. The fence gives an interest balance to the tree and takes your eye through the scene.
Beautifully done presentation, Nigel! Really enjoyed it. It is much more informative if a photographer gives a specific illustration of his/her struggles in deciding what works and what does not. It is that struggle that defines the hard work behind those hours of taking photos and post-processing. My personal struggle is to actually decide what works in my images. I guess I am not there yet when I can comfortably say that it works for me, but the question still remains whether it works for others. So I need to attain that level of knowledge and confidence to do that despite years of photography as a hobby. So your videos do help to understand the thought process, which helps other photographers improve their craft. Thanks!
My brain at 18:42 - "I like that boulder...that's a nice boulder". Seriously though, great video. I've only seen a few of your videos but still they've helped me no end in improving my photography.
I love how you go into detail about your composition decisions, all the details that made you go for one composition or another ond how meticulously you're setting up your shots. Thos tree branches not intersecting with the horizon line is a small detail it seems, but I'm sure it makes a huge difference! Boy I've still got so much to learn and get into my brain until it's second nature...
Very interesting topic, my thoughts are that you have great eye and are a perfectionist, this is why your work narrows down producing awesome images. Your constant research of the perfect balance between personal preferences and technique is what makes you a great photographer! Thank you for going through your lovely work with us and sharing your thoughts, a big thumbs up!
Nigel, this is a very useful presentation about the reasons for careful composition. Showing us what doesn't work and why is more useful than showing us just good compositions. Thanks.
Some stunning photography and the photos you are critical of is something we don’t see very much, It really helps us become better photographers, thanks Nigel!
Very very useful video, thanks for the honesty it takes to go through things that "didn´t work". However the takes that "do work" leave me almost speechless 👏
Thanks Nigel, another great informative and inspirational video. I seem to have a problem with composition. I never know what will work and what won't, so this video is really helpful. Thanks again Jack
Really appreciate your explanations of space and separating the elements- too many times I have loved a scene but not been able to break it into the elements that captured me- now I have some ideas!
Thanks for another great video, so good to hear a world class photographer talk about coming home and realizing what he had thought was a great composition just didn't work happens so often to me
Very good to see how you look at the pictures and your explanation. Sometimes i would love to see information on the lens, shutter speed, diaphragm etc.
I just uploaded a video regarding actively looking to improve photo composition a few hours after you uploaded this and funny enough, yours showed up in the suggested feed on the side when I was previewing mine. I'm thankful because I might not have found your video otherwise. Nice work!!
This was quit helpful. It’s gave me some perspective on composing and simplifying things. Hope you enjoyed Madeira. Greetings from Portugal 🇵🇹 and Madeira
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Interesting that your discussion was on balance, separation, distractions, shapes, color,, and not rule of thirds, golden ratio, and the other old tired rules. I appreciate that.
On a workshop, I learned that the while the rule of thirds might be useful to learn to stand away from bull's eye composition, what actually really does matter is balance. Even most examples given to support the "rule of thirds" actually don't support it, with strong elements not on a third. Not to mention the golden ratio, with examples that are even bigger approximations... Balance has become my "rule".
Yeah, but you got to get to the point where the golden ratio etc. become tired. I wouldn't recommend people skip that stuff when learning.
Thats something I picked up on, that and Visual Weight (part of balance I suppose), so much more useful thought process to help you decompose/deconstruct a composition rather than structural considerations like rule of thirds which you might use to assemble/build a composition.
@@daveeagle1559 yep, I would include visual weight in what I call balance. The position of the element in the composition changes its visual weight, even if you don't change its actual size. So you might need something smaller or bigger or placed differently in the composition to balance it.
I mean you’ll also notice that many of these photos follow the rule of thirds by default. The balance is then factored in around the rule to make the rest of the image work, but the rules often still provide the backbone.
Seeing what doesn't work in a composition helps me see what does work, a lot more than just seeing a photographer's good photos.
Yes, exactly. I couldn't agree more. Thanks to Mr. Danson for taking this approach.
That's so true, it's nice when photographers don't just show their good photos.
Definitely agree with you on that. Also helps beginners like me to hear that pros don't always get the perfect shot all the time.
Totally agree. It’s also inspiring in a way, to know that oh, yeah...most shots don’t work!
its just his opinion though someone else could take what he`d call a bad composition and still sell it.....
It's the detail that photography requires you to see that makes it such a great hobby. It slows you down & gets you to really see. Then, if you're lucky, something unexpected may happen too. The photo is just a record of the experience, which is the real gift.
beautifully written
So true!
Beautifully said!
What I mostly appreciate about your videos is that not only you explain why a composition works, but you also go through shots that you weren't satisfied with. Keep that going, it really helps a lot
Being true to yourself and critical of your own work is a gift which is too often never explored. Kudos to you Nigel, executed flawlessly.
It's always refreshing to understand why some compositions don't work instead of just learning why the good ones do work. Thanks for sharing Nigel lots of food for thought in this video
Seeing your thought process is really opened my eyes. I was wondering what's wrong about a photo I took, there was something bothering me. Now I am able to analyze better. Cheers Nigel.
I love how hard you are on yourself, some of these photos that didn't work for you are amazing. but that's why you're so good because you don't settle
ladscape photography is such an ongoing exercise. Even after 4 years I'm still learning how to compose photos, where the best lighting is, what I want as foreground, subject etc. Your videos are always so helpful
don't worry; this is how I feel like after 40 years :(
Love this as always. My wife was like, "is it over already". We enjoy are Sunday morning coffee and video with Nigel time.
Glad you enjoyed it
What I find so challenging in landscape photography is composing for a clear figure / ground relationship. Keep up sharing your work, both the successes and the near successes.
It’s such an education seeing you commenting on what worked and what did not and why. Some stunning shots and humbling to see how much thought and effort you put into your photography. Thank you.
You're not just a good photographer but also a very good story teller. Love to see your tips and explanation. Great work. Thumbs up from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I really enjoy the self critiques because they show thought process and details in a clearer way than just showing things that work. Really good video.
Something in your last seascape photograph that caught my eye that you didn't mention, was the tide rushing out exposed some smaller rocks that weren't visible in the other shots. These smaller rocks created a natural leading line that drew my eye up toward the crashing wave and sea stacks.
Great video. It's always a pleasure watching your videos and listening to your detailed explanations.
Nicely pointed out. Excellent comment
I struggle with simplifying my images. I want people to see it ALL! Which is not the way to get really powerful images, as you’ve beautifully shown in your video. I went on a weekend trip this fall to the mountains and really tried to focus on simplifying my images and putting on my zoom lense to cut out the extra stuff. It worked!
Your photos are extraordinary! I am an amateur watercolor painter and have watched so many artist videos about composition. Your videos have helped more than all others combined. Thank you so much! I have subscribed to your channel and will continue to watch and learn.
As a beginner landscape photographer, I love listening to you explain and talk about your images. Top quality content. Thank you.
I really like the fence in the snowy picture - I think it adds to the dimension, especially as it is almost on a diagonal with the slope where the tree is sitting on... another fab video - thank you
Yes, I agree.
one of the best on youtube! Real talking, no bla bla. Amazing helpful! Thank you!
I just love your discussion of why compositions didn’t work for certain shots. You come to a beautiful scene, it’s so enamored with it, and you forget the little details that might make or break a shot. Your description helps us to see that.
I could make this a long description of why I like you Nigel, but I'll content myself (and you) with just mentioning that I really like your channel, so informative and educational. And besides that, you really are a great photographer.
Thank you for taking the time to share your inspiring and informative videos, it is highly appreciated.
What I like about your videos, Nigel, is the honesty, as you go through explaining each shot’s good points and bad, through your own eyes, which in my mind, keeps the integrity of your images shining through the photos you show.
Thank you
I find it super helpful to hear your thoughts on why an image does on doesn’t work! Thank you
I truly appreciate your explanation of the subtleties that you took in order to capture exactly the photo you intended. Also, showing photos that didn't work and explaining exactly why, only enhances the importance of composition. Your photos are exquisite and those trees are simply magical looking. Thank you so very much for your professional advice.
Felt good to hear you also think something is going to work but get home to realize it doesn't. Great tips, hopefully can remember when I'm out and about.
You are so good in details and distances to get great pics and video again. Nice to see your passion too and thanks for sharing everything to us🙏🙏
G’day Nigel. It’s great to follow your comp. ideas and it gives us more to think about our own ideas and helps in planning my shots. Always great ideas Nigel. Thank you. Stay safe.
Nigel, one of the best bits of advice you have ever offered is this: Print your shots and annotate them. I started doing this and it has made an amazing difference in my photography.
Wonderful video Nigel, thanks. I've read many books on composition but this video really hit the spot for me and made me realise where I have often been going wrong in good locations. You have been very generous taking the time to show and talk through shots that worked and shots that didn't - and detailing exactly why that was so. One of your best ever !
Your video is so insightful! The discussion about how you arrived at the final composition is exactly what I’m looking for. I learn so much “getting into” the professional photographers head. Thanks for a great video.
You'r really teaching the art of photography and not taking good pictures. Like a painter artist you give great attentions to details that add up and create a good composition. This thorough work on the scene is a precondition for a 10/10 as no post production could fix it. It is often said that one can learn most from mistakes and I think this is very much true in photography. It's always a real pleasure to watch your videos as your admirable personality shines through.
Great job on your critiquing. It is nice to get the camera specks/time of day/time it took. Enjoy watching !!!
Love you have the prints.
I've sort of been in a creative rut with photography for the past year. I put off watching this video because I just wasn't into the idea of it. But after watching this it's really got me (for now) back into it. It's easy to forget how fun the little things can be if you let them. All the little things you need to get just right to get the perfect photo, and the total joy you get when it all comes together.
I really appreciate to hear your thinking, the story telling and the critique of your photography. Cool learning, thanks for sharing.
Your discussion on the 1st Madeira photo was brilliant. I learned a lot. Hadn’t even thought of some of those things.
Great video on composition! Been shooting for about 25 years and still find getting a well composed image the most difficult part of photography. Trying to simplify an image and cutting out distraction in the field is a never ending battle for me. Always working on getting the eye of the viewer to move the image in a Way that creates some emotion in the viewer. Lots of disappointing shots but very rewarding when you get a great image. I find it very frustrating and elusive. Subtle changes can have a big impact. Really enjoyed walking thru different images and what didn’t work and what finally did. Very helpful. Would love to see more videos like this on composition. Thanks. Beautiful images!
This is so helpful! I often get the feelings that professional photographers just have the right composition in their blood and immediately know how and where to take THE photo. Seeing and hearing you explain the "faults" on several of your photos and mentioning that there are lots of "fails" for one photo that is "the one", is a relief! :D
Funny that you called the one photo "The Fennell Family" with the description of the toddler, teenagers and mom and dad because as soon as I saw it my first thought was that they were Ents.
Regarding the snowy landscape image with the tree and the fence curving off to the right, the one I that series you thought came closest to working whilst questioning the inclusion of the fence: I didn’t think the fence cluttered the image nor detracted fro the tree. For me, my eyes and thoughts first went to the tree, but then were invited by the fence to follow the curve of the path. The presence of the fence both raised my curiosity about where the path led as well added to the sense that the overall image was suggesting the presence of a “story.” The enjoyment of an admittedly wonderful capture of Nature’s beauty was enhanced by the feeling that there was a narrative waiting to be discovered. Love your channel.
I love watching critiques! It is sooooooo helpful. Thank you Nigel!
This is an extremely useful approach to teaching and explaining your approach to composition, it's way more helpful than seeing only what worked.
Even a year later, this is still a very informative watch! Thank you Nigel!
I love your work, you're the only I found, who is speaking like that of what makes a great landscape photography !!!
This type of video is so helpful. Understanding your thought process of works and doesn't is priceless. Thank you Nigel. 👍🏻
A composition of a photos that details what it takes for a great composition. You are now my favorite landscape photographer. My favorite photo is at the 4:25 mark which is the fairy tale background. The one you edited and cropped out. Its a testament of how subjective we are about our photos. Great video. Loved it.
Nigel everytime I look at that picture at the 4:25 mark it looks like the lone tree is awaiting the encroachment of the back forest to consume it.
thanks for sharing all of this information Nigel. A joy to hear your share your thoughts on composition. Cheers
This video is a great example of something that I think you taught me unintentionally, earlier. That is, that just because something doesn't look perfect in frame at the time doesn't mean there isnt a great photo in there. A huge part of me was completely disregarding some shots that maybe had something I didn't like in it. And I didn't really know how acceptable it was to just crop something out or edit it out. I'm excited to see someone talking honestly about what was right, what wasn't. It's nice to see pro talking about things they're happy with and what they wished was better and not being judgemental about the editing process.
Great, thanks, Nigel! Learning more by hearing comments re: what works in an image helps a lot. I'm trying to take woodland photos in Massachusetts in the US and more difficult because many areas old growth or contain buildings, etc. However, now I pay more attention to the little things like space between trees, breathing room in the image and what do I see in the viewfinder. Once I get home I try to critique images and many never see the light of day.
I found your channel recently, and am so glad for how you show the process and what does work and what doesn't! Also appreciated how you said how many pictures you take and how few of them are 'good' - makes me feel better about my giant unusable collection!
Like the fence on the 4' pic ! It drives your look to the open space on the right side just to help you to pass through the massive tree.
I’m quite grateful for your explanations! You manage to explain and show it in a way that’s easier to digest than many others or books do. Thanks!! I hope I can apply at least some of your composition rules!!
Loved it! A very clear study of what works and what doesn't. I keep telling people around me they should look at as much work by others as possible and try and understand why they like what they do and why they don't what they don't. But studying our own work is very important as well indeed. Thanks for sharing this one with us!
Very helpful, Nigel! What a great idea to show what works and what doesn't. It does help me to look at my compositions more critically in the field. Thanks.
Thanks so much for doing this. Analyzing photos, good and especially bad (less good) helps with the thinking process when we are out there on the front line. It's the thinking, not the gear, that matters most.
This video has helped my composition so much, together with James Popsys' advice to ask yourself what it's about. Thank you.
Thank you for this video. Your spot scouting, motive finding and composition reviews are the most important steps to gain fotografic levels.
Thank you Nigel, one of your best and most informative videos. Being objectively self-critical is hard, but knowing why an image does or does not work is really important.
In terms of composition, I find that ‘asking’ every element in the image why it is there or what its purpose is, really helps to drill down into a composition that may work.
Excellent video Nigel!! RUclips is filled with videos on the best compositions/gears etc. BUt seeing a video of comparison of what worked and what didn't is very refreshing! Thanks!
Wow, really appreciate you going over what works and what doesn't. Totally agree with what works and what doesn't, although you explaining it makes it more obvious.
This was very helpful, to hear you talk through your thought process and the work that went into each shot, both the great and the not so great. I would really appreciate more of these.
Quite inspirational !!!Soooo appreciated that you elaborated the process of shoting and what you think of these images . It is much more helpful than just seeing the master pieces after Photoshoped. Thank you so much！
I’ve been photographing since 2013, Just opposed of you I started portraits and are now very interested to start land/sea scapes. I have been watching your videos for quite some time and am very excited to start this new journey. Thank you for all your advice.
Thank you very helpful. Love that you love taking pictures of woodlands.
Great video.I really enjoyed your compositions and pointing out what , in your opinion works and what doesn’t work. As regards the last photo in the video. I think what really makes the shot great is the wave crashing over the rock. It shows the movement of the sea and makes the photo dynamic.
Thank you! This is the most helpful blog you have made so far, for my concern! Allowing us into to your way of thoughts, and revealing your judgement of the result is priceless. Thumbs up!
I always appreciate you detailing your thoughts on why certain images work and others don’t. Great video and explanations, as always.
For the shot at 11:00, to my eye I wonder if you could salvage it by cropping out the right hand 20-25% or so of the image so that the tree frames the low lying cloud in the background as the central focal point, closer to a 4:5 or square crop. Then the tree trunk works as a leading line to the center from the corner, and mostly eliminates the darker spot with the brown fern in the lower right. From there the complicated elements you mentioned that were bothering you just help frame the central negative space of the clouds.
Absolutely amazing video and great insight into you thought process behind each composition. Looking forward to more videos like this. Thank you!
Great video Nigel. I really appreciate how you step through photos from the same location to illustrate the factors that make a great composition. Thanks
Hi! My first time at the channel. My most challenging condition is usually the background, as a sports photographer. There are numerous aspects that I can improve and the way you demand from yourself is really driven by a great expertise. Thank You and glad that I crossed over! Cheers
Thanks for watching
@@NigelDanson actually, Thank You for sharing. :)
4:40 That shot is fantastic. Play with some alignment and crop, then dodge and burn a touch to draw the eye to that tree.
For me all the visual weight of the final shot is focused by the leading lines created by the double row of rocks in the center. They seem to be screaming “Look at the action of that wave!”. Add to that the line created by the light central foreground rock leading to the dark boulder and stack to the back, all the attention wants to rest there on those lines of rock and the the boulder the wave is crashing over. Thirdly, the dark boulder and rows of rock stand out in contrast to the white of the water to the left and right. There is so much visual gravity there. I hope I explained why my eyes just focus at that point in the image.
It takes courage to show some B-photos, but it shows that you are a true teacher and that you care not only about your growth but also about us viewers! Much appreciated!
and btw. I think Fanal can be pretty frustrating, without fog it is actually so hard to take good photos, so much interesting twisted trees, but getting the composition right without the fog was nearly impossible for me...but I am glad you managed, the photos are stunningly beautiful!
Really like the composition in the "hook" tree around 14min mark. Love how it points down at the tree in the background fog. Wonderfully composed.
My musings for today... Your photos are magical and hint at a hidden story, they are 3 dimensional, and they show movement and can be exciting as well. Is there something else that a great photo can create? Oh yes, evoking a mood, and you nailed that one too! Now if I were asked to explain why I chose one photo over the other... I would say it just felt right..... Musings over.
One of the best explanations on the thought process around composition I have seen.
I think the snow shot with the fence that you feel is nearly there is actually really interesting Nigel. The fence gives an interest balance to the tree and takes your eye through the scene.
I enjoyed hearing / seeing your thought process.... thanks for sharing Nigel
Beautifully done presentation, Nigel! Really enjoyed it. It is much more informative if a photographer gives a specific illustration of his/her struggles in deciding what works and what does not. It is that struggle that defines the hard work behind those hours of taking photos and post-processing. My personal struggle is to actually decide what works in my images. I guess I am not there yet when I can comfortably say that it works for me, but the question still remains whether it works for others. So I need to attain that level of knowledge and confidence to do that despite years of photography as a hobby. So your videos do help to understand the thought process, which helps other photographers improve their craft. Thanks!
My brain at 18:42 - "I like that boulder...that's a nice boulder".
Seriously though, great video. I've only seen a few of your videos but still they've helped me no end in improving my photography.
I love how you go into detail about your composition decisions, all the details that made you go for one composition or another ond how meticulously you're setting up your shots. Thos tree branches not intersecting with the horizon line is a small detail it seems, but I'm sure it makes a huge difference!
Boy I've still got so much to learn and get into my brain until it's second nature...
Very interesting topic, my thoughts are that you have great eye and are a perfectionist, this is why your work narrows down producing awesome images. Your constant research of the perfect balance between personal preferences and technique is what makes you a great photographer! Thank you for going through your lovely work with us and sharing your thoughts, a big thumbs up!
Once again a very educational video Nigel, you really explained the essentials of Composition, Thank you.
Nigel, this is a very useful presentation about the reasons for careful composition. Showing us what doesn't work and why is more useful than showing us just good compositions. Thanks.
Some stunning photography and the photos you are critical of is something we don’t see very much, It really helps us become better photographers, thanks Nigel!
Very very useful video, thanks for the honesty it takes to go through things that "didn´t work". However the takes that "do work" leave me almost speechless 👏
Once again Nigel, excellent, thought provoking posting. I so appreciate your efforts!
Thanks Nigel, another great informative and inspirational video. I seem to have a problem with composition. I never know what will work and what won't, so this video is really helpful.
Thanks again
Jack
I love the example with the rock/seascape. When you show them one after each other it's so evident and point drives home instantly.
Thank you :).
I really enjoyed this episode, Nigel. Lots of great points and tips. And, of course, beautiful photos. Thank you.
Love your thought process workflow. Really helpful.
Really appreciate your explanations of space and separating the elements- too many times I have loved a scene but not been able to break it into the elements that captured me- now I have some ideas!
Thanks for another great video, so good to hear a world class photographer talk about coming home and realizing what he had thought was a great composition just didn't work happens so often to me
Very good to see how you look at the pictures and your explanation. Sometimes i would love to see information on the lens, shutter speed, diaphragm etc.
Thank you so much. Excellent discussion seeing what doesn’t work and why. So very helpful. Perfect.
I just uploaded a video regarding actively looking to improve photo composition a few hours after you uploaded this and funny enough, yours showed up in the suggested feed on the side when I was previewing mine. I'm thankful because I might not have found your video otherwise. Nice work!!
THX FOR THIS video. I am new to photography and compassion is a very hard work. I am glad I can lern it from guys like u. THX
Really awesome images Nigel!
The subtlety in your photos is very understated. Stripped to their essence. Every one draws an emotion. Nice.
This was quit helpful. It’s gave me some perspective on composing and simplifying things. Hope you enjoyed Madeira. Greetings from Portugal 🇵🇹 and Madeira
going to Madeira was right. Your biggest mistake: you also bought a return ticket :)