Understanding the Many Game of Thrones Books

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024

Комментарии • 324

  • @TunezCottage
    @TunezCottage 5 лет назад +462

    here's hoping cd projekt red comes in and makes a game in this incredible world George created.

    • @studiocigsplain8588
      @studiocigsplain8588 5 лет назад +10

      Why they already have the witcher to work with.

    • @TunezCottage
      @TunezCottage 5 лет назад +30

      ​@@studiocigsplain8588 As a company grows so too does their workload. No company can just keep making games once every five to ten years without doing anything else, it's just not feasible. That's why they're making Cyberpunk 2077 as well. Investors need to see the company's revenue increase annually, which means you have to sell more, which means you have to make more. Eventually, they'll have to embark somewhere else so why not have that be ASOIAF's wonderful world of Westeros.

    • @studiocigsplain8588
      @studiocigsplain8588 5 лет назад +12

      @@TunezCottage I agree with what your saying, but quality games take time just look at rockstar,the reason why CDPR takes so long is because they are a relatively small company with a smaller work force say then ubisoft which has multiple studios working and has the luxury of working on 4 to 5 projects at any given time. But the more I think about it a game set in Weateros would be pretty sweet.

    • @awwsalah
      @awwsalah 5 лет назад +1

      Game of thrones pc game exist.

    • @mjisurdad
      @mjisurdad 5 лет назад +2

      awwsalah a shit game. All got games are either mods or trash.

  • @whycreate
    @whycreate  6 лет назад +69

    I had to improvise a little with the Princess and Rogue Prince books covers

    • @UlfhedinnNorsk
      @UlfhedinnNorsk 6 лет назад +1

      whycreate Hey man. When I stumbled on this channel, I watched all of your "TSOIAF" videos within a day and can't get enough! Being a Joe Abercrombie fan myself (as they say "the younger George RRRR Martin") I have a lot of respect for your work and wanted to commend you on amazing job you have done!
      THANK YOU SIR! And remember! Thought is material.

    • @Scaronable
      @Scaronable 5 лет назад +1

      Do you know if these stories, 'The Princess and the Queen' and 'The Rogue Prince' are fully included in 'Blood and Fire'. I have seen that one of the first chapters is called 'The Sons of the Dragons', however I could not find the names of the others. But as the first Volume of 'Blood and Fire' contains the Dance of the Dragons it would make sense if the two other stories would be included as well, maybe under different chapter names. Do you know anything more specifically? I do not really want to purchase two collection books with over 40 short stories, just to have these two from G.R.R. Martin. Thanks!

    • @stefanvladstanciu771
      @stefanvladstanciu771 5 лет назад

      Ok but what is the chronological order

  • @Gambio15
    @Gambio15 6 лет назад +380

    The World of Ice and Fire is amazing. I think it is advertised a bit poorly, since one might assume it only compiles all the Information that is already in the Main Series into one nice package. Nothing could be further from the Truth. This truly feels like a History Book and yeah the Artwork in it is stunning.
    I'm really looking forward to Fire and Blood as well. You already get a pretty detailed description of the life of all the Targaryen Kings in The World of Ice and Fire, so getting an even more in depth look should be interesting

    • @hitrapperandartistdababy
      @hitrapperandartistdababy 5 лет назад

      I really like how it is written by archmaester gyldayn and so a bit biased in certain areas

    • @turtleanton6539
      @turtleanton6539 5 лет назад

      Wow how did that workout for you

    • @Detective_L
      @Detective_L 7 месяцев назад +1

      I come from the future over 5 years later to tell you that there’s no new book still lol

  • @LucianC137
    @LucianC137 5 лет назад +268

    A Song of Ice and Fire
    A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms
    The World of Ice and Fire
    Fire and Blood

    • @sujeidyalvarez
      @sujeidyalvarez 5 лет назад +3

      So are all three of the Targaryen short stories in a world of ice and fire? Does that mean I could buy World of Ice and fire and not buy the three separately

    • @chrissalinas17
      @chrissalinas17 4 года назад +1

      Iam confused bit yeah the books are better

    • @isacharjones
      @isacharjones 4 года назад +7

      @Leaker Yes, that's the order I would recommend reading them in, despite that not being the order in which they were released

    • @brandonmunson9781
      @brandonmunson9781 4 года назад +1

      @Leaker I'd read a World of Ice and Fire before ASOIAF

    • @brandonmunson9781
      @brandonmunson9781 4 года назад

      Leaker Yea, it contains lore from all around the asoiaf world.

  • @christianradcliff8239
    @christianradcliff8239 2 года назад +11

    i love how there’s a huge spoiler in this video now 3 years later for people who haven’t read and are just watching HotD and watching this to catch up🤣

  • @Bar21297
    @Bar21297 5 лет назад +144

    "this is for people interested in either reading the books or watching the series" goes straight to spoiling the end of the 6th book. nice one bro

    • @nicholas.wblanchard8513
      @nicholas.wblanchard8513 5 лет назад +13

      Bro stop whining, every one knows that.

    • @Bar21297
      @Bar21297 5 лет назад +1

      @@nicholas.wblanchard8513 👍

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад +1

      5 book

    • @disorientedkiwi7984
      @disorientedkiwi7984 5 лет назад +6

      Brale I wouldn’t recommend it. Fire and Blood and A World of Ice and Fire are just history books - it’s not written like the novels. It tends to help if you’re already invested in the world when you go into them.
      You could start with Dunk and Egg novellas, I suppose, as they’re pretty independent from the main series. You’ll miss a bit of dramatic irony but otherwise you’re good to go

  • @sg_1541
    @sg_1541 5 лет назад +138

    I beg... Somebody please make some video games out of this interesting world... So many maps and places... God it will be far better than pubj that's for sure... 😩

    • @Zacon2mlg
      @Zacon2mlg 5 лет назад +11

      Before the show was made, The Song of Ice and Fire people approached Bethesda to make an open world RPG like Oblivion in this world but they said no and started making Skyrim. Play Skyrim and you'll see why. It is also very lore driven. They opted to make a show after that knowing that no other company could capture this vast world.

    • @avery.s7681
      @avery.s7681 5 лет назад

      they just made a shitty game for it. play skyrim instead lol

    • @mjisurdad
      @mjisurdad 5 лет назад

      Skyrim seems close. Even has white walker pretty much and dragons.

    • @Roseyfinchartworks
      @Roseyfinchartworks 5 лет назад +1

      There is a game, by telltale.

    • @muhammedjunaid3804
      @muhammedjunaid3804 4 года назад

      @@Roseyfinchartworks yeah ..i used to play that but its now nowhere to be found .Could u hwlp me with its link of all epispdes or something.I just played the 1st season years ago

  • @camilauribenorena8665
    @camilauribenorena8665 5 лет назад +167

    I would love a book about the children of the forest, brandon the builder and the long night!

    • @Sadge6
      @Sadge6 5 лет назад +5

      That will be covered in the upcoming prequel

    • @amanullah1707
      @amanullah1707 5 лет назад +3

      Read The World or Ice and Fire

    • @camilauribenorena8665
      @camilauribenorena8665 5 лет назад +1

      @@amanullah1707 already read it , not enough

    • @rdwinter1115
      @rdwinter1115 2 года назад +1

      So like fire and blood but about the age of heroes? Or earlier? I dunno, as all the information we get about the world is from the point of view of westerosi maesters I don't think it could be very in-depth without George suddenly deciding to write as an omnipresent narrator. I don't think we will get a book like that or learn anything else set around those times except if it's important to the plot and Bran learns about it in the cave with bloodraven

  • @StreetArtillery
    @StreetArtillery 5 лет назад +31

    Where in the books does Dora Stark The Explorer first of her name jumps on a ship to discover America??

    • @Kunumbah1
      @Kunumbah1 5 лет назад +2

      Arya sailing west actually has some precedent in the history. King Brandon the Shipwright sailed west 1000’s of years prior.

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад +1

      @@Kunumbah1 dont forget elissa farman,her ship reach asshai

  • @gianb3952
    @gianb3952 5 лет назад +116

    Very useful. I am not particularly keen on reading, but after the disappointment that was season 8 I'm going to read the books, I NEED a better ending

    • @saintpaulkirch7274
      @saintpaulkirch7274 5 лет назад +9

      We are two.

    • @zakariyaabdullahi5669
      @zakariyaabdullahi5669 5 лет назад +4

      @@saintpaulkirch7274 And now a third

    • @curtisnagy5091
      @curtisnagy5091 5 лет назад +1

      Dude same here

    • @Treasuure
      @Treasuure 5 лет назад +21

      I'm pretty sure the ending in the book will be similar to the show, but the road, if we ever get there will be way better and the ending will make more sense

    • @gianb3952
      @gianb3952 5 лет назад +6

      @@Treasuure that's enough for me, I know Martin said the ending would be similar, but until the last book comes out he might change his mind and change the ending completely idk

  • @howhigh0521
    @howhigh0521 6 лет назад +68

    We'll looks like I have like 10 more books to read XD

  • @Brandonhayhew
    @Brandonhayhew 5 лет назад +25

    Dunk and Egg had a comic book adaptations. Sons of Dragons and the other Short stories should be adapted into comic books.

    • @andrewforte3852
      @andrewforte3852 5 лет назад

      They should make a TV show out this ASAP!

    • @Brandonhayhew
      @Brandonhayhew 5 лет назад

      @@andrewforte3852 you mean a spinoff off, no they should make a dance of dragons as a movie and Robert's Rebellions.

    • @andrewforte3852
      @andrewforte3852 5 лет назад

      @@Brandonhayhew Dunk and Egg would be more like a prequel TV show which takes place ninety years before the events of Game of Thrones.
      They should most definitely make a movie or movies of Dance of Dragons or Aegon's Conquest.
      Now Robert's Rebellion would be more of a TV mini-series.

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад

      @@andrewforte3852 dance of dragons together with aegon III regency has material for 4 seasons at least,aegon conquest with the sons of dragons 2 seasons,and roberts rebellion wouldnt work unless we saw the mad king turn mad

  • @rickkreinheder281
    @rickkreinheder281 4 года назад +1

    Never disappointed with the quality of your videos

  • @zahryiapaul1188
    @zahryiapaul1188 5 лет назад +5

    I really want to get.
    The world of Ice and Fire
    The Princess and Queen
    Fire and Blood
    And when the Winds of Winter is finished that aswell( i just pray that that the the amazing man who created all of this, the man we call George RR.Martin lives to see many more years cause he has an amazing talent

  • @sam1hg644
    @sam1hg644 Год назад

    thank you you're the only one who explains this correctly

  • @darkkhof
    @darkkhof 6 лет назад +6

    It is hard and great work what the author done in the lat two decades but if i where in his place i would rather join forces with other good authors whom can detailed the work more and fast up the writing process.

    • @Ratchet4647
      @Ratchet4647 6 лет назад +4

      Muheeb Kassawat I've read books where a famous author pays other authors to do part or all of their job before. In my experience there's a steep decline in quality, with the story feeling disjointed, or aimlessly wandering, etc.
      I wouldn't want for that to happen to this great series. I may be wrong, but I'd hate to find out.

    • @darkkhof
      @darkkhof 6 лет назад

      Ratchet4647 maybe you are wright but JRRM didn’t use other authors until feast for crows, in this book he just want the reader to understand what did happened to westros because of the civil war (Danny’s visions in the house of the undying) and they only take care of few minor characters such as Braine of Tarth and Uran Grayjoy.
      For sure there is a better ways to give better work but if our beloved author didn’t finish the story (and you have to conceder this as the books take him know more than 5 years to be done) we might be in suspended situation where we can’t guess the ending by ourselves

  • @Willskull
    @Willskull 5 лет назад +10

    There is alot of interesting good material to use, I hope future adaptations can capture such legends! Good to know that all the hbo show was just a part of franchise!

  • @justinhowse7590
    @justinhowse7590 3 года назад +2

    Ok so im still lost in what order should i read the books

  • @mariMar808
    @mariMar808 2 месяца назад

    That’s me! I looove the shows and I am ready to read the books but don’t know where to begin… Fire and Blood?

    • @pinto9779
      @pinto9779 Месяц назад +1

      Read the main series first, at least a game of thrones. Then you can read fire and blood and the hedge knight and wathever you want, but it's way easier to get on the series by the main books first, since they establish the reader in that world very well.

  • @elisonbonell2584
    @elisonbonell2584 3 года назад +2

    So are the targaryen short stories separate from "Fire and Blood" or is "Fire and Blood" a complication book containing all the short stories (Like "A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms")??

  • @Tee5
    @Tee5 4 года назад +3

    I started watching game of thrones and now I NEED TO READ THE BOOKS OR ILL DIEE!!!

  • @BackCapBlog
    @BackCapBlog Месяц назад

    a spoiler alert for egg wouldve been appreciated

  • @BMXK-jx1bi
    @BMXK-jx1bi 5 лет назад +3

    So The World of Ice and Fire combines the three Targaryen short stories together and Fire and Blood has new Targaryen history and some indie from the short stories?

  • @etnoballium4516
    @etnoballium4516 6 лет назад +7

    Thanks for doing this, I have read a song of ice and fire series but didn’t know about most of the others. Now I have a bunch of new books to read and interest me intill season 8 and winds of winter come out!!

    • @switchclaw
      @switchclaw 5 лет назад +10

      I'm from the future, and I got bad news. Season 8 sucked.

    • @Detective_L
      @Detective_L 7 месяцев назад +1

      I’m from the future and Winds still isn’t out

  • @korygrey6170
    @korygrey6170 6 лет назад +8

    I appreciate you bro 👊🏿

  • @alexpatrick2522
    @alexpatrick2522 6 лет назад +6

    You do a great job with these videos. Look forward to each new one.

  • @Fahad-bd2pl
    @Fahad-bd2pl 4 года назад +3

    Would I need to buy the Targaryen short stories separately, or are they contained in “Fire and Blood”?

  • @wileyschmitt
    @wileyschmitt 6 лет назад +12

    Thanx, I have just got into the books this year and have read the 5 books and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. I'm awaiting on my bookstore to get a used copy of 'The World of Ice and Fire' (but did not know that they were available separately), and looking forward to 'Fire and Blood' later this year. I got super lucky and found an advanced reading copy of the original 'A Game of Thrones' which is an uncorrected proof of the book which was issued to some people and with a letter from the president of Bantam Publishing begging the reader to give the book a chance despite it being a fantasy novel (he was very much right to insist). It turns out that it is extremely rare and worth a lot, so all my rummaging at my local bookstore's warehouse sales finally paid off big time with this find, and surprised that they didn't realize what they had when they took it in, or the person who brought it there for that matter. I have it up for sale on eBay, but fishing for a steep price as I figure it will likely increase in value over time, or at least when the new book is finally released. If anyone wants to see pictures of it and/or the publisher's note that was included with you'll find it on eBay with a proper search, and there are only a few copies of it there so it's easy to locate, but mine is listed for $775.00 and is sold by 'thecaliforniacoyote' or the store name 'Coyote Book Lots'. Let me know if any of you think if this is more worth holding on to, but my eventual intent will likely be to sell it at some point.

  • @johngulotta7951
    @johngulotta7951 6 лет назад +4

    I got all them waiting on fire and blood cant wait

  • @danielshuter3737
    @danielshuter3737 5 лет назад

    My name Daniel my souppt work tell about I joying game thrones I date game thrones vary day and night and racing in txat and I Redding louch time redding lot I love it good to me think you Daniel

  • @BRADU5
    @BRADU5 5 лет назад +3

    Thanks for vid. Time to get my credit card

  • @NiNa-vs6hb
    @NiNa-vs6hb 5 лет назад +15

    Remeber how we prayed the book readers to not spoil anything?
    Fun times

    • @johnvazakas970
      @johnvazakas970 5 лет назад +4

      Yes...and now the show spoiled the end for the readers. I know that's why they are upset at the ending...lol

    • @Ignisan_66
      @Ignisan_66 3 года назад +2

      ​@@johnvazakas970 the show didnt spoil anything because it is just a crappy fanfiction. The ending of the books WILL BE different.

    • @johnvazakas970
      @johnvazakas970 3 года назад +1

      @@Ignisan_66 no, they won't....GRRM has said Bran will be king, Dany goes mad queen, All that

    • @Ignisan_66
      @Ignisan_66 3 года назад

      @@johnvazakas970 source?

    • @johnvazakas970
      @johnvazakas970 3 года назад +1

      @@Ignisan_66 GRRM' s not a blog page...interviews by GRRM...and disappointed GoT RUclipsrs that covered GRRM saying it

  • @RhysRTW
    @RhysRTW 5 лет назад +2

    Is the Targaryen short stories the same as the ones in Fire and Blood? Or are they completely different?

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад +1

      they are the same,but in fire and blood has more detail

  • @samershadi4150
    @samershadi4150 2 года назад +1

    So many House Of Dragon Spoilers

    • @Dillydilly9903
      @Dillydilly9903 22 дня назад

      Like there isn't spoilers all over the internet/books

  • @vorthora
    @vorthora 6 лет назад +4

    This definitely helps! Thank you! I have the 5 ASOIAF books, The World of Ice and Fire history books and the maps, but I didn't know in what order to read the Dunk and Egg books, so, thanks!!!

  • @KOCChristian
    @KOCChristian 6 лет назад +3

    I want be Game of Thrones reader but book is huge I finish the first and half on second by audible

    • @zakksmith5557
      @zakksmith5557 5 лет назад

      I'm almost done with the first book. I listened to it for free on here lol I'm so excited

  • @MimyBambino
    @MimyBambino 5 лет назад +1

    The targaryen short stories is like the new book Fire and blood its completly diferent? Cuse both talk about de targaryen dinasties. Should i buy targaryen Short stories too? Cuse i already have Fire and blood. Thanks and GJ

  • @vitocorleone2413
    @vitocorleone2413 4 года назад +1

    i didn't watch the show and just came here to know where to read and now i got spoiled

  • @roppor4151
    @roppor4151 6 лет назад +3

    Thank for such a video and I have the mean series books and I wish get the others

  • @remphey
    @remphey 3 года назад +7

    There needs to be a game of thrones videogame. Yes, I know about the shitty RPG, the Telltale game, and Skyrim. The RPG (as mentioned) was shit. The Telltale game looks cool but isn't what I want. Skyrim is a wonderful game but I'd like to have a game in the actual universe of ASOIAF. You know with Targaryens, House Stark, all the important locations like Winterfell and Kings Landing. Also with White Walkers, Wargs, and all the different races and creatures of the series/universe.
    I'd instantly fall in love with a new RPG for the next generation of consoles and PC. With nice graphics and all. Open World with all the major locations. Well, a map with every location from the game of thrones series would be huge, maybe first the north and then each kingdom as a later DLC, I don't know. You have a preset protagonist but can change almost everything about the protagonist such as clothes hairstyle etc. You have quests (main and sidequests) but you do not know which quest is a main or a sidequest. Similar to Skyrim or RDR2 there are people around the map giving you random quests. Maybe you can even build your own army and attack castles (that feature would be huge but, I use that word rarely, *epic*). You can learn abilities like warging into animals. Maybe you could even become a white walker and do missions for them. What about owning a dragon? Just imagine going mad and destroying Kings Landing with a dragon, just like Daenerys did (btw that scene in the show made no sense but seems fun in a videogame, call me mad). Also, it would be nice if there was destruction such as buildings getting destroyed if you burn them down with a dragon.
    I know such a game will never happen but let me dream. I believe there will be GOT games especially since HBO is beginning to milk the franchise with new shows. It will still take years just like the Harry Potter franchise is just getting a big RPG next year (A whole decade after the last movie).
    Have a great day!

  • @robertcooper4th259
    @robertcooper4th259 3 месяца назад

    Someone explain how this qualifies as a ya fantasy when there’s mg fantasy that’s super dark

  • @russlasky6162
    @russlasky6162 5 дней назад

    Are princess & queen, rouge Prince, and sons of dragons all in Fire&blood or just pieces?

  • @ernestouribe9494
    @ernestouribe9494 5 лет назад

    I haven't read any of the books at all. Which one would you suggest I start reading first?

  • @diemchauoanthi9161
    @diemchauoanthi9161 5 лет назад +2

    So there are 9 books right?

  • @peytonbaker839
    @peytonbaker839 5 лет назад +7

    So i need to read the regular 7 books of ice and fire,A knight of the seven kingdoms, The world of ice and fire, and fire and blood? right?

  • @emmanuelokechukwu9911
    @emmanuelokechukwu9911 2 года назад +1

    Beautiful. More grace and knowledge

  • @MiniDonut69
    @MiniDonut69 5 лет назад +2

    I just want to read the books so I could get an ending that makes sence

    • @Divinemakyr
      @Divinemakyr 5 лет назад +1

      You don't want to read it because it is quite possibly the greatest Fantasy Series ever written?

  • @alexandrasstudio5308
    @alexandrasstudio5308 5 лет назад +2

    Your video was in my recommendations, very nice and detailed video... I recently finished Fire and Blood and would 💯 recommend it gives a lot of details that the book series references to and I felt like I knew more of the world and the houses... I’m in the middle of the World of Ice and Fire book and planning on rereading A night of the Seven Kingdoms... I love the history of this world it’s amazing... the World of Ice and Fire has awesome illustrations and it reads like a history book it’s perfect for a nerd like me lol
    Great video looking forward to see more about ASOIAF

  • @jasonsteinfeld9493
    @jasonsteinfeld9493 3 года назад

    Thanks man I’m a reluctant reader but this helps

  • @princeprocrastinate6485
    @princeprocrastinate6485 6 лет назад +2

    Great video man, most of it was old news for me but not all, now I know where to find everything, cheers.

  • @sucio6972
    @sucio6972 5 лет назад +1

    Should I get the 3 Dunk & Egg short stories & then A knight of the 7 kingdoms? Or can I just get A knight of the 7 kingdoms and not miss anything from the 3 short stories?

    • @jynskywalker501
      @jynskywalker501 5 лет назад +2

      Sucio a knight of the 7 kingdoms is a compilation of the 3 dunk & egg short stories, it contains all 3 of them and you wouldn’t miss anything by getting a knight of a the 7 kingdoms

  • @JiggaMan1297
    @JiggaMan1297 6 лет назад +3

    Where are the Blackfyre rebellions from then? Aegon the Unworthy and all that?

    • @temptationofmemories
      @temptationofmemories 5 лет назад

      @Troy Crayson wouldn't the blackfyre's be in Fire and Blood PT2 because Daemon, Daeron, Bittersteel and BloodRaven are all sons of Aegon the IV unworthy, and he comes after Aegon the III's reign, which is the reign the book is supposed to end on, so the Blackfyre's will take up a large portion of part 2

  • @alialyousuf1585
    @alialyousuf1585 3 года назад +1

    “Since they were definitely qualified” 😂

  • @suede9072
    @suede9072 3 года назад +1

    Thanks!

  • @marshallhamelin4609
    @marshallhamelin4609 5 лет назад +1

    So if I want to learn and read more about the Targaryen family and history should I start reading the book, The World of Fire and Ice and then continue with Fire and blood?

    • @mattronimus
      @mattronimus 5 лет назад

      if you haven't read the main series, start there...if so I say just go in order.

  • @AlbertvdBerg
    @AlbertvdBerg 5 лет назад +2

    I hope those books are big

  • @vibangigan5336
    @vibangigan5336 5 лет назад +1

    Damn lol he said he’s not gonna do another dunk and egg till he finishes winds of winter so that’s just another series we never gonna get the end to 💩💩💩💩💩

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад

      you never know,i wouldnt be suprised that after he finish dream,we have 1 dunk and egg novel each year,they are novel with less of 200 pages each,its much easier to write

    • @vibangigan5336
      @vibangigan5336 5 лет назад

      ALPHA GAMER maybe but that also means he has to put a real ending to what happened at summer hall. And this dude just not about finishing these stories it seems lolol

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад

      @@vibangigan5336 if what i said,happens,we will know what happened there

  • @oluwanifemiolagunju8967
    @oluwanifemiolagunju8967 6 лет назад +7

    Dude I really love your voice! You single? Oh and good video.

  • @vinnyavalanche
    @vinnyavalanche 2 года назад

    sick of these damn prequels can we finish the fucking story

  • @yayeet9889
    @yayeet9889 Год назад

    What about the short stories Blood of the Dragon, Path of the Dragon and Arms of the Kraken? Are they different than in the novels

  • @matilda0hofling
    @matilda0hofling 3 года назад +1

    I have a question.
    Is the Targaryen short stories exactly the same in "the world of ice and fire" as in for example the novella compilation "Dangerous women"?
    ...Becourse I have read somewhere that "the original" is different. Is there anybody that have compared them to see if they are identical or not?

    • @TheTricktracktruck
      @TheTricktracktruck 2 года назад

      it is how you put it apparently, i just read on the wikipedia page

  • @ΣτέφανοςΑλεξόπουλος-μ3χ

    this proves that martin will keep making money off every opportunity, so he will keep us on hold to take the most out of the series

  • @allisterquinteros3165
    @allisterquinteros3165 4 года назад

    One question, i have to buy the 3 short targaryan stories or the World of ice and fire. I find every thing of the shorts stories in the World of ice and fire?

  • @abigailknox-leet6949
    @abigailknox-leet6949 Год назад

    I'm currently reading book 5, part 2. It's difficult to get through.
    He should have finished the story before the tv series.
    I'm not sure if I want to continue reading the books

  • @jonashediger182
    @jonashediger182 5 лет назад +1

    2 important questions!
    1. Does it matter in wich order you read these five books?
    2. Is a dance with dragons the story of a dance of dragons (the battle) ??
    Thanks for answering

    • @G_Kchrst
      @G_Kchrst 5 лет назад +4

      The 5 main novels are the same story so yeah it matters how you read.
      Don't confuse the 5th novel: A Dance with Dragons with the Targaryen civil War which is called: Dance of The Dragons.
      The A Song of Ice and Fire series consists of 7 books:
      -A Game Of Thrones
      -A Clash of Kings
      -A Storm of Swords
      -A Feast for Crows
      -A Dance with Dragons
      -The Winds of Winter (pending)
      -A Dream of Spring (pendind)
      The prequel series of Dunk & Egg is published all together as:
      -A Night of The Seven Kingdoms
      The History of Westeros is contained in the book:
      -The World of Ice and FIre (the whole history from the ancient times till the events of ASOIAF). This is written like a Maester of the Citadel has written it.
      The History of Targaryen Dynasty specifically is now released in 2 Fire & Blood volumes (this has more info in the Targaryen Era than The World of Ice and Fire):
      -Fire & Blood part 1
      -Fire & Blood part 2 (pending)
      That's it.

    • @loveyourselfxx5137
      @loveyourselfxx5137 5 лет назад +3

      You read it like that:
      1. A Game of Thrones
      2. A clash of kings
      3. A storm of swords
      4. A feast for crows
      5. A dance with dragons
      The prequels:
      1. Fire and blood part 1
      2. Fire and blood part 2
      And then there is a huge book about the history of the world of ice and fire but also some other nice prequels

  • @dachiiiii
    @dachiiiii 5 лет назад +6

    if i want to start from the beginning which one should i read first? can you tell me list of books which i should read first?

    • @griffith7153
      @griffith7153 5 лет назад +2

      Start with the original, book 1 Game of Thrones

    • @tsadler0925
      @tsadler0925 5 лет назад

      Might want to start with the back stories and history before the main series. They make refrences in the main series that are hard to understand the weight if what they mewn unless you already know some of the history. I read the main series first and didnt relize all the other histories were out until about 2 years after i finished the main series.

  • @barnabalogh56
    @barnabalogh56 5 лет назад +2

    " the ice dragon " novel also sets in the same world just like these but it is written for children but despite that it's a brilliant story

    • @mattronimus
      @mattronimus 5 лет назад

      it's never said that they're in the same world...it seem that way, but it doesn't fit with the history.

    • @mjisurdad
      @mjisurdad 5 лет назад +3

      George said himself it’s not in the same universe at all. Not lore or part of the story whatsoever.

  • @AzikuraProductions
    @AzikuraProductions 5 лет назад +1

    Maan I got a lot of books to get..

  • @mhatre1611
    @mhatre1611 5 лет назад +3

    The map plug was really smooth!!!

  • @Ratchet4647
    @Ratchet4647 6 лет назад +7

    I read the main series more or less concurrently with the show, at first I overtook the shows pace by a wide margin, but as I got busier at school the show caught up and passed me, so busy that I have to re-read books 4 and 5 because I was barely able to read and nothing made sense as a result of the extended dry periods. I haven't done so yet. Since then I found the book containing all 3 dunk and egg novelas and the world of ice and fire in the *new* section of my library and immediately checked them out. I'd love to read the rest of the material, but I've found it hard to find and to know what's what and what's been released. So thank you for this video.

    • @Detective_L
      @Detective_L 7 месяцев назад

      You’ll probably have to re read the entire series once the new book comes out since it’s been nearly a decade, with no release date in sight

  • @allos343
    @allos343 6 лет назад +43

    There’s only 1 Game of Thrones book

    • @johannesstrom497
      @johannesstrom497 5 лет назад

      ?

    • @theM4R4T
      @theM4R4T 5 лет назад +32

      @@johannesstrom497 Only the first book is called "A Game of Thrones". The series is called "A Song of Ice and Fire" not "Game of Thrones Books", that's what he meant.

    • @wayofthebosssauce3713
      @wayofthebosssauce3713 5 лет назад +8

      Oh really sherlock

    • @AnasIrfanAhmed
      @AnasIrfanAhmed 5 лет назад +2

      Kogerokmeget No Shit.

  • @rostislavlazarevic3850
    @rostislavlazarevic3850 5 лет назад +1

    Want book about starks

  • @isabellegapper3212
    @isabellegapper3212 3 месяца назад

    just checking if anything has changed since this video as its now 5 years old?

    • @LCG1.
      @LCG1. 2 месяца назад +1

      Me too 😅

  • @souhaibboukadjar3884
    @souhaibboukadjar3884 2 года назад +1

    Great video ❤️🙏

  • @surajkedarsrk
    @surajkedarsrk 5 лет назад +22

    What will happen to the story if suddenly writer dies.?! It shouldn't be happen but if it does!!! Valhar Morghulis...

    • @markpagtama7954
      @markpagtama7954 5 лет назад +1

      He said that he told other writers the plot.

    • @oniondesu9633
      @oniondesu9633 5 лет назад +3

      Winds of Winter is essentially done just not properley cut down and edited, within a couple of years the basic framework for Dream of Spring will be done so can be completed by his team if needed.

    • @hanyu_dada
      @hanyu_dada 5 лет назад +3

      @@markpagtama7954 No, he said that if he dies nobody is allowed to end his books

    • @mattronimus
      @mattronimus 5 лет назад +4

      I would guess that winds of winter is done and will be released after the show ends...a dream of spring could be done as well for all we know.

    • @ghabbadi1
      @ghabbadi1 5 лет назад +3

      in the world of ice and fire, anyone can die at anytime

  • @jamesbroughton7870
    @jamesbroughton7870 11 месяцев назад

    Is there a particular reading order that you would recommend?

  • @Sjrick
    @Sjrick 5 лет назад +1

    i gave up halfway thru

  • @bebos1262
    @bebos1262 5 лет назад +5

    Fire & Blood is too epic!
    Can't wait to read about Daeron The Good and his descendants, Aegon V definitely.

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад +1

      i want the second vol to read the blackfyre rebellions,bloodraven is such a badass,plus robert rebellion

  • @jackyoung2388
    @jackyoung2388 5 лет назад +1

    Got them all!!

  • @kandre7619
    @kandre7619 6 лет назад +1

    Can we pre-order Fire & Blood now? If not, when?
    Thanks in advance!

    • @nahmean7045
      @nahmean7045 6 лет назад

      Dyson West
      You can pre-order it here;
      www.bookdepository.com/Fire-Blood-George-R-R-Martin/9780008307738?ref=grid-view&qid=1538056276396&sr=1-1

  • @eduard476
    @eduard476 5 лет назад +2

    Turns out ,,Targaryen short stories” represents half of Fire and Blood vol 1.

    • @eduard476
      @eduard476 3 года назад +1

      ​@@td202beats7 All those short Targaryens stories ”The Princess and the Queen” 2013, ”The Rogue Prince” 2014 and ”The Sons of the Dragons” 2017 are included, copy-pasted, in ”Fire and Blood Vol 1” 2018.

    • @eduard476
      @eduard476 3 года назад

      @@td202beats7 Fire and Blood is only about the Targaryens, starting with Aegon The Conquerer, It has dialogue and it”s focused on characters.
      The World of Ice and Fire is like a history book, it starts with the time period when there were no humans in Westeros. It talks about all the Kingdoms, all the important Houses, including a summary of the Targaryen rule (spoiling Fire and Blood). Then it goes beyond that, and presents almost all the regions in Essos and beyond, places that were only mentioned in the Main Series (There is even a third continent in the south)
      Fire and Blood takes a small part from The World of Ice and Fire, The Targaryen rule, and expands on it. For me, it”s the most exciting part from Westeros history.

    • @eduard476
      @eduard476 3 года назад

      @@td202beats7 Both White Walkers and the Doom are mentioned in World of Ice and Fire but their origins are unknown. Roberts Rebellion is just summarized in 2 pages, most of the information is scattered in the main series, Ned, Bran,Jaime and Barristan chapters I think. There is also a cool video on yt about Roberts Rebellion: ruclips.net/video/k1zsvHusfPQ/видео.html&ab_channel=BazBattles

  • @anthonygiuliano6574
    @anthonygiuliano6574 5 лет назад +1

    I haven’t read any of the books.. should I start with The World of Ice and fire or fire and blood.. than the main series?
    Also which book has Roberts Rebellion in it??

    • @canoni1013
      @canoni1013 5 лет назад +3

      main series first definitely, and it kinda fills in roberts rebellion through stories and stuff as it goes

    • @mattronimus
      @mattronimus 5 лет назад +2

      definitely the main series...if you started with a world of ice and fire you would be lost.

    • @mjisurdad
      @mjisurdad 5 лет назад

      Roberts rebellion is boring af. It was all explained in got.

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад

      the main series,roberts rebellion is explained there,but if you really want to read more about that,read the world of ice anf fire,there you have roberts rebellion

  • @taesifkabir2643
    @taesifkabir2643 5 лет назад

    Im in 3rd grades and im reading book 5

  • @我无法抗拒玖貳
    @我无法抗拒玖貳 Год назад

    Can anyone tell me in which order I should read?

  • @golammorshed2007
    @golammorshed2007 6 лет назад +2

    Great video bro!

  • @tinytanot7514
    @tinytanot7514 5 месяцев назад

    Wow it really help

  • @aguasmokee7329
    @aguasmokee7329 5 лет назад

    Great video

  • @fyoutube10.24
    @fyoutube10.24 6 месяцев назад

    Ur voice is dope

  • @Zubair001able
    @Zubair001able 5 лет назад

    Human is a needle which builts his own haystack to get lost in it

  • @mostresticator5
    @mostresticator5 5 лет назад +1

    as far as chronology fire and blood occurs before the world of ice and fire?

    • @mjisurdad
      @mjisurdad 5 лет назад

      It’s the same just more in depth and only half of the targs history.

    • @alphagamer9505
      @alphagamer9505 5 лет назад

      the world of ice and fire its like a enciclopedia,there you have everything related to the world,everything that happened,from 12000bc until 283ac,fire and blood its the targaryen history in much more detail,but the first vol go from 2bc until 150ac i think

  • @thomasalexanian927
    @thomasalexanian927 5 лет назад

    The only thing I see are spinoff ideas

  • @vytautasmatulionis3723
    @vytautasmatulionis3723 4 года назад

    Hope book will better than tv show

  • @kovu1530
    @kovu1530 6 лет назад +1

    I listen the audible on yt.

  • @itsmaxieb0044
    @itsmaxieb0044 5 лет назад

    No he wasn’t stabbed by his friends. It was only 4 guys who didn’t like Jon so they jumped him during a commotion they caused by making a giant kill a guy.

  • @3rdandzen97
    @3rdandzen97 6 лет назад +1

    Great video! Thank you!

  • @ivoneray1472
    @ivoneray1472 5 лет назад +1

    That's really cool !

  • @ScottSullivanTV
    @ScottSullivanTV 3 года назад

    Not only were Books 4 & 5 supposed to be one novel, Books 1 & 2 were supposed to be one as well.

  • @jacki8211
    @jacki8211 Год назад

    bad review

  • @fredriccilbrith1995
    @fredriccilbrith1995 5 лет назад +3

    So basically got is like kingdom hearts

  • @stefanvladstanciu771
    @stefanvladstanciu771 5 лет назад

    So what is the chronological order?