I feel so bad for her...... Kpop stans esp girl group stans were constantly bullying her, calling her really disgusting names and whenever their fan accounts tried to clarify with proof that the bully was actually the one posing as d victim and trying to ruin her majority of kpop stans didn't care to look at the facts, they just sided with the actual bully even when it came out that d girl posing as a victim was actually a bully and took pics of garam's friend undressing and sent it to some guy, kpop stans really defended the bully and now every1 just tries to shift the blame on to others. Also I see some hating on their fandom and hybe and trying to shift the blame toward them now but honestly even though I didn't say anything when all these was going on, I noticed then that who ever tried to clarify about the situation, they were bullied and garam ended up getting bullied more. I don't care abt companies but when hybe defended her, kpop stans just labeled hybe as a shameless company still harbouring a bully, they gave clarifications about the situation and the case about it yet nobody cared about it even with proof and when hybe notified on Twitter asking people not to spread misinformations and that they would sue people if they did that and also that garam was being bullied and needed time to recover cus she was going through a lot of mental stress, kpop stans just wrote more hateful stuff about garam and called the company shameless for defending her... Garam truly deserve an apology from kpop fans esp gg stans!!
Couldn’t have said it better myself. Everyone owes her the biggest apology. You’d think they’d have learned from what happened with Jimin & Soojin but alas… Kpop Stan’s can’t function without hating on someone, specifically a talented female.
They should have at least waited for hybe statement and be neutral but they straight up jumped to conclusions and kept saying the documentary proof and that she got punished like innocent people aren’t punished before ?? Garam totally deserves better she was so young and finally debuted after working so hard only for people to bully her and finding out she wasn’t the bully
Well I'm a MY but I rlly liked Garam she seems so nice to me and yeah u are right those toxic gg stans exaggerated too much, they were just hating on her bcs she is so pretty nothing else
Garam was my bias, she just caught my eye right away. Truth be told, I was very scared when the rumors started going around, because I didn't know what to believe. Because I've been bullied before it made me angry at first and I decided to read up on some articles about her as a bully. However I didn't spread any hate about her, I wanted to remain neutral, but I know I failed cuz I really believed she had been a harsh bully at some point... Now I'm just extremely sad about her whole situation.. I wish she could come back or debut somewhere else if it's still her dream.
Frr thank you for making a comment and saying this i stayed neutral in that situation tho i still want to apologise i wasn't even their stan at that time but......it's just hurts.....garam I'm really sorry please stay happy wherever you are I'm really sorry really very sorry
“She was only there for two weeks, it’s not a big deal” imagine what it was like for her, she had her whole future ahead of her and it was ruined. I always wonder what it would be like if she was still in the group.
@@fatimahheh3195 yeah. And their concepts would've been better. I mean, ever since Easy era, their songs and concept have become weird. Ever since their webtoon series ended they started releasing musics that don't make sense. (At least to me they don't) NO HATE TO THE GROUP.
It's funny how the whole group is acting like she's never there. I hate hybe for making them do this and for not taking garam in the group again. Now I no longer like lee seerafim but not hate them.
@@Fatemajannat57they're not really allowed to speak about her since she's not part of the group and her contract is terminated, also they have to keep going even if she is gone because they're still a group
@@Fatemajannat57they cant do anything for that. They must be missing her presence in the group behind the cameras but they can't show remorse or sadness on camera because she is not part of the group anymore
I feel like an idiot bcz I actually believed that I regret it I should just stay neutral next time I didn't write hate comments tho but still...I shouldn't believe it the one who started this rumor might actually be the real bully that bullied and ruined her career hope she can debut
Well you know there are so many out there who just support the ones who are more in number without thinking about situations on their own. That's why a lot earlier were against her and are now suddenly feeling sorry for her. Bad humans 😒
Me who always supported her the beginning... Still supported her.. When most of the people were criticizing her.. I always believed her ❤ i hope she's going well and being strong
I'm a pre debut FEARNOT and I feel empty while watching them as five and she was my first bias of LE SSERAFIM. I literally cry whenever someone posts a video of her. Miss u Garam 💔💔 OT6 forever ♾️
Same manh.. just can't look at them the same. Its impossible for me to move on. I remember seeing all those videos making fun of her, calling her names, dragging her down, putting out even more false information to put more fuel to fire. Literal bullies calling her a bully
I never once commented on garam , I can proudly say that.. why ? Because she’s a teen an there wasn’t any solid proof .. love or hate we should stop the cycle of hatred and bullying as we are all apart of the K-pop community . Garams 2 weeks of fame was all she could’ve asked for . Though fans didn’t like her even when she debuted . Maybe this was meant to be . Edit : Everyone is entitled to their opinion , but hating and breaking down a minor does not sit right with me ! It’s makes you just as bad as those other people :( .
im geniunely asking, i love garam a lot as well, but there was this piece of evidence saying she got grade 5 bullying or smth and her name was written there, was that like fake evidence?
@@sunsunjayki It was real but not for the reason ppl thought (which was that she severely threatened and bullied the alleged victim). The documents were finally released and it showed that all garam did was curse at the “victim” because of some stupid teenage drama that the victim started cuz she was spreading rumors and having her male friends target garam’s friends. This resulted in the punishment she got with the victim getting a more severe one.
@@sunsunjayki 1) in korea and also in a lot of countries there is not a single person that is not sharing the same name as someone else 2) The "evidence" only showed a Name and a grade punishment, but you literally can fake a document like that, even more if you are just showing smth that simple. I wish i could turn the time back, and do whatever were in my hands to defend her, even if i already did it, but i wish i would have had more 😭
That breaks my heart. She was so excited to have support, and her dreams were just ripped away from her because of lies and a poorly functioning company...
poorly functioning company? they stayed on her side, released a statement that they will sue anyone who continues to spread misinfo. and was also getting alot of hate for "harbouring a bully"
@@sweetpea8155 Stayed on her side? No, they didn't; they literally removed her. Getting hate for "harboring a bully" means nothing when they're right and could have proven it. But they couldn't stand up to netizens and so-called journalists, the ones they would be able to sue, and instead of standing firm, they put her on hiatus, didn't make any clarifying statements about promotional materials that came out including her during her hiatus, and removed her in two months, *after* calls to bring her back. Even after getting the information and releasing statements, they still chose to terminate her contract fter knowing the truth. That's not staying on her side; that's not protecting their artist.
@@Nia-Day at that point it's too late, Garam's image which is her market was already destroyed that's how it works in Korea. It's just funny how y'all act as if the company did nothing when in fact they did, downplaying kpop community's toxicity and shifting all the blame to the company.
@@sweetpea8155 Literally never downplayed the bloody community. Her image was not beyond "saving", as evidenced by the trending hashtags to end her hiatus back in July, and by how the vast majority of content about her over the last several months has been neutral or positive. LESSERAFIM was brand new, HYBE first girl group, and the same idiotic netizens that cared would bloody forget within months anyway. What's actually funny is how you raised a counter, I responsed, then you moved the goal post. I don't ignore the borderline criminal nature of netizens, never have and never will. That doesn't mean HYBE carries no blame
@@Nia-DayHYBE did everything they could to defend to her, but everything was blown out of proportion and went way too far, so at one point they had to make the choice between removing her from the group or letting the entire group fail because of her ruined image. They chose to let go of 1 to save 5, instead of saving 1 who will bring down the other 5 with her. (Obviously I’m not blaming Garam at all, but at that point her reputation was ruined beyond repair and it wouldn’t be fair to the other girls if HYBE let her stay in the group and drag their image down)
No not only the Fandom it is also/mainly those random good for nothing keyboard warriors (cowards)... They never deserve good things in their lives for ruining a teenage girl's dream (she even proven innocent morally)
Bro ofc ppl r going to believe wts shown to them Its the company. Hybe DID NOT handle the matter properly at all. Have u seen garam's statement after she was kicked, it was so simple. Hybe couldn't release smthng so simple? That company literally sucks.
@@singularity_5177 when HYBE protected GARAM "HYBE is the worst company protecting a bully" "kick her out of the group she is ruining the group's reputation" When HYBE let go of GARAM because she has to she can't handle these many disgusting hates and it's even difficult for her to rebuild her reputation plus if she continues to stay in this industry that gonna hurt GARAM's mental health heavily, Lesserafim's growth as a group would fall and HYBE as a company knows what they want.. Still the people blame on HYBE saying they are the worst they shouldn't have let her go... Seriously? What they supposed to do when damage is already happened??
Those people who commented on garam, bashed her, demanded her to leave the group are now feeling sympathetic and missing her. This is just so hypocrite. Y'all are so fast on reaching to a judgement which is made by yourself without knowing literally ANYTHING about it. This is not the 1st time and Garam is not the 1st idol to face bullying accusations yet everyone reacted in the same typical way not taking any lessons from past.
It just feels awful. And people kept saying "when are they going to kick her out it's already been 2 months" 2 MONTHS IS NOTHING. Soojin was kicked out after 5 months and April disbanded after 11 months. 2 months is not enough to determine if she was right or wrong, even for Soojin it took 1,6 years to clear her name, and 1,3 years for AOA Jimin to clear her name.
@@ellanote2260 That I agree as well. Even if she bullied someone, people did the same thing to her. Even wayy worse. There is no difference between the right and wrong now. She could have been punished legally or the two parties could have resolved among them. Even after she was removed from the group, they should let her live now at the least. Her getting cursed at school by friends is nothing but blatant bullying.
Garam was simply standing up for a friend of hers. I don’t understand why she and Soojin of G Idle can’t be idols anymore. Besides those people calling for her to be removed have probably been a bully themselves. Feel really bad for her.
@@Primprim.rosie.She was accused of bullying at school, people criticize her before the case was over, she left the group. Well, apparently she proven innocent :"(
@@secondlov3959Soojin (g-idle) and Garam (Le Serafim) was accused of bullying when they weren’t. Soojin was falsely accused by the actress Seo Shin Ae of bullying her, but Soojin stated that they never knew each other nor were they acquainted because they were on different floors and that Soojin already left the friend group that bullied Seo Shin Ae when she joined their school because she doesn’t want to be involved with bad kids so they never intermingled. Seo Shin Ae then said she wasn’t sure if Soojin really bullied her and later stated that she didn’t know that Soojin was already an outcast of that group and that she never actually spoke to Soojin at all. Her claims and accusations were based off on what she heard from other people and assumed Soojin was a part of it, she destroyed Soojin’s career and many people argued that maybe she used Soojin to boost her fame as a victim since she’s not really a well known actress but Seo Shin Ae denied those accusations. On Garam’s end, it was all full of bs accusations that’s pretty obvious that they were just framing her. All Garam did was defend her friend from a bully who uploaded a photo of her friend who was only dressed in underwear. She confronted the bully which is Yoo Eun Seo and ended up cursing at her in the heat of the moment out of anger. She was only defending her friend but she recognized that her methods was wrong and immature. In fact, Garam was also the one being bullied as a photo of her desk covered in hate and kys notes was leaked in twitter. HYBE threw lots of evidences that proved Garam was innocent yet immature people and haters never stopped bashing her and turned blind to the truth. They ruined a 16 year old teenage girl’s life and took away her career from her just because they all believed the accusations without hearing her side of the story.
Yeah i miss soojin. I was so sad when she got kicked out cause she just became my bias after stanning g idle for a few months..now I just became a fearnot..and well just found out a member got kicked out because of bullying accusations too. Why 2 of my favorite gg's 😢 PS soojin just created her ig like a few weeks ago iirc
You guys never learn. This happened to soojin too. And soojin never even got a fighting chance, it’s so sad that despite the fact this has happened once too many times people are still so eager to hop on the next “woke” train to seem like they actually care about victims or know 90% of the BS they preach about.
She got a chance of fighting yet ppl who thinks they know the truth and claimed she is a real bully discredited her saying she is lying instead of apologizing and even bullied the accused victim once again....
amen. a rumor starts about an idol doing something and people automatically define that idol because of something that may not even be true. it’s disgusting how we are so quick to condemn and slow to forgive or even just do a little research when we ourselves are far from perfect.
I still love the two groups, but I honestly listen to their songs and watch their music videos like "oh that would have been soojins line" "ooohh garam would have made that shot so pretty"
@@revachitnis9948 that’s the point. all the people even her agency didn’t even hear her explanation. for me, that sounds very clear when garam made clarification on her instagram, but no one even cares about that
I was neutral the whole time. The first time I heard of Garam was from my cousin. She told me she was a bully and I ask her how she knew all this. She told me she saw on internet and I straight away told her that not all things in Internet espically of what they talk about someone is not true. After I told her this she think of what i said and told me that maybe she was wrong. And the thing is one of the main reason Garam left was because people just believe what one person said and even before thinking of the other way,they just come into conclusion and decided to hate her. And later after she left the group they started feeling sorry for her again, and blame others for their mistakes. At least learn from this issue and not let this happen in kpop again. Most of us really miss her and dont want this to happen to anyone, I mean how will you feel if you were her? (Sorry the comment is so long)
Just like soojin's case 😭except that hybe actually helped garam but the haters were too strong. Soojin's one cube didn't even help her and kicked her out like what😭both of them don't deserve this
Though I advocate your desire for change, let's be real here, nothing is going to change. No matter how much we want to, unless the problem is not something that could legitimately move the companies and the "fans" to action. To actually make a change. The thing that happened with GARAM can very well happen again.
Yes same .. This is basic manners and logic but people nowadays don’t have a brain instead they choose to join any hate trend they see for no valid reason
Here to spread the message. @ John Jackson for credit Garam is declared innocent of bullying and violence in the official school disciplinary report; therefore, she should have stayed in Le Sserafim. Garam defended a friend verbally who pleaded for help when Eunsoo took hidden photos of Garam's friend in her underwear and hacked a facebook account to post them online under another name to incriminate an innocent student. Eunsoo's rich father used his influence to push through a disciplinary committee that was biased against Garam. Yet, the level 5 offense that Garam received for defending her friend with a cuss word or two carried 0 severity points for violence and was the most common one given at her school, while Eunsoo's very rare level 8 offense carried 16-20 points in severity of violence which was beyond suspension. Yet, the rich father used his influence to get Eunsoo to transfer schools before the punishment could be implemented and jealous Eunsoo bullied Garam at the new school by getting boys in online chat rooms to threaten violence against her and keep inviting her so she couldn't leave the chats. Garam also had insults and obscenities written on her desk at school. Eunsoo's intense jealousy of Garam debuting in her favorite kpop company was one of the primary driving forces for the lies and corruption to drive Garam out, but another pivotal reason the powers in kpop and South Korea were so rabid in going after Garam is that she stood up to the rich elite's perverted "right" to post child porn online, use blackmail to control girls' lives, and incriminate others by stealing their identity to post it so they don't get caught. In their demented minds, this is what they call a perpetrator of crimes. As a result, Eunsoo's rich father purchased a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career since it coincided with Garam's debut in Le Sserafim and had nothing to do with the stated intent which was accusing Garam of bullying, since the school incident happened four years before and was caused by the violent actions of sexual harassment and theft of a facebook account by Eunsoo. According to the Korean Broadcasting System (KBS), Garam was by far the hardest hit target by Kakao Organization affiliated with Starship with 336 slanderous articles written to destroy her reputation. Kakao is currently under investigation by the FTC for reverse viral marketing. Kakao falsely claimed that Garam was an ex Starship trainee who was removed for bullying other members which was a lie. Furthermore, Kakao is responsible for the slanderous picture and article claiming that Garam had written down with Ive and other famous kpop groups on a blackboard, even though Garam is not seen in the picture and even though she hadn't attended that school since 2018 which was long before the group IVE even formed. Finally, they are responsible for lies about Garam bullying other Le Sserafim members. it is obvious that there was a coordinated conspiracy to cancel Garam, especially with the fake evidence and fabricated photos spread all over the internet by the fake victim, Eunsoo, her rich father's purchase of a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career, and Kakao's viral flooding of the internet with negative and slanderous articles against Garam who was innocent of the false allegations. While Hybe appeared to defend Garam in a superficial sense by putting out an official statement that recounted Garam's version of the story, it was done in an impersonal way with statements like According to Garam. Furthermore, it was issued too late, since it also announced that she was being placed on hiatus. However, the real incompetence and undermining by Hybe came from their refusal to let Garam make the public statement she requested in mid-April and their refusal to let her release the official school disciplinary report which she also had available in mid-April. Even worse, Hybe's complete betrayed of Garam came when they refused to release this critical information even after Eunsoo's side released a cropped and marked on part of the school disciplinary document which only indicated Garam's offense. Furthermore, they didn't release the testimonies of the many students that supported Garam's innocence. Hybe also never filed lawsuits for libel or slander against all the false information and incriminating faked photos posted by the fake victim (real bully) or against the death or sexual assault threats that were posted online which badly damaged Garam's reputation and traumatized her psychologically, especially since she rarely left her dorm room during the time of her hiatus because of anxiety and depression. This downcast condition and isolation persisted for an extended period even after Garam left Hybe and went home. This cyber witch hunt fueled with malicious lies didn't give Garam's side of the story which would have been based, if it had been allowed to take place, on official school evidence, direct testimony and the emotional resonance of Garam's personal appeal. The effect was to create great hype at the moment of debut but to destroy the mental health of Garam who was falsely accused and served as the scapegoat for the group. There is even a haunting scene in an ad in which Garam falls really hard on a car which suggests that she is Hybe's fallen sixth angel, since Le Sseragim means six angels. Then after a long hiatus and a period of silence, Hybe dumped Garam with no attempt made to clear her name, even though they had all the evidence to do so and even though they had used the excuse of an upcoming trial against Eunsoo as the reason not to reveal the evidence to exonerate Garam. The defender against sexual exploitation, Garam, was severely punished and Eunsoo, the sexual offender of Garam's friend and facebook hacker was rewarded. Therefore after Garam's unjust cancellation and while sunk in the depths of depression, it was left up to Garam with the help of her faithful friend Yudimi to muster up the strength to clear her name by releasing the official school disciplinary report and Garam's explanatory statement in August, in which Garam refuted many of the falsehoods by saying she never drank or smoked, never bullied or ordered anyone around, never transferred schools and never used violence. She also had the honesty to admit that she would have handled the defense of her friend a bit differently now that she had the perspective of more maturity but was adamant that in principle she had done the right thing because her parents had taught her the importance of defending a friend in a time of adversity. But honestly, Garam's actions seem really honorable and reasonable considering the severity of the offense: yelling and saying a couple of cuss words at Eunsoo for posting half nude photos of her friend as a profile pic online and hacking a facebook account to incriminate another student. Better yet, I thought of Garam's actions as a wise lesson posed as a question: If every member of a group and its fandom had the guts to defend a targeted member the way Garam defended her friend against a powerful and perverted enemy like Eunsoo, wouldn't all these unjust bullying cancellations like of Jimin, Soojin and Garam come to an end? In Garam's closing address in her letter, she thanked her fans with a harbinger of hope, GaramDream. And the strength of Garam's and Yudimi's efforts freed from Hybe's draconian restrictions turned the tide of public opinion in Garam's favor. Presently, there are some hopeful signs such as Garam giving thanks to her fans on her birthday for her video banner in Seoul on November 16, and 6 days later the first beautiful photos of Garam in her yellow school uniform appeared on twitter. My hope is that if Garam wishes to return to music that she will go into jpop in Japan, as I think it would be safer and give her far more freedom of expression and action. Garam is also quite popular there, comments are more positive for her there than in South Korea, there are far fewer risks, and Japanese songs are longer with storylines that include acting in the videos, which is a great fit since she is currently studying acting at the School of Performing Arts. Plus, the big money influences and propaganda and cancellation campaigns waged against her in kpop will have far less influence in Japan and she will have better protection in Japan from the depravity of lies, misogyny, jealousy and hypocrisy. However, I will support her in whatever she decides to do especially if it is kpop or kdrama because she will need a lot more protection then. Garam is one of my very favorites because of her great beauty and charisma on stage and her fabulous singing, dancing, and her strong integrity of character at such a young age. Her soothing sweet vocals with a touch of sassiness in Blue Flame and Sour Grapes are like a delightful dream and her beautiful ferocity in Fearless is captivating. Her heartbreaking story and efforts to rise again from great persecution are a true inspiration and remind me of an epic movie, so it is certainly no coincidence that she is studying to be an actress. I just wish her the best of success, happiness with love and trust from family and friends, and warmth and understanding from all over the world.
Garam honestly had what it takes. She could of been the next IT girl alongside Yeji, Karina, Sullyoon, & Wonyoung. I also could of seen her becoming one of the most popular (maybe even the most) of Le Sserafim. She just had so much potential. Now that she was proven innocent by court I feel awful for her. I hope she is healing & getting the love & support she needs.
@@0l1v3.-wonyoung was made into am "it" girl. It was completely manufactured. Her original personality did not did not fit thie manufactured vibe they created. She seemed playful and goofy before.
It’s so annoying how they can’t re-join the group when they’re proved innocent. They literally worked so hard and stupid 13-15 year olds are allowed to ruin a persons life and just continue on like nothing happened. I wish I could find the people who jumped to conclusions before anything was confirmed.
@@namjoonsleftdimpletrue but you need to know that korea is different even when she was proven innocent they cancelled her and whenever you see someone post about her on any site the comments are all hate in all honesty her case was very severe she should be thankful she wasn't blacklisted like even the ministery of education got involved
I am proud to say i never hated garam it's my habit to like the people that gets hate most of the time like wonyoung when she debuted i adored her and garam i just felt she was really good and i defended her when the rumors were going i knew there was something wrong going on and than when she was proven innocent i felt real bad for her and i can never even see lesserefim ever again because of her leaving..
I can't imagine the depression, anxiety, and trauma that she must have felt☹️ God bless this poor girl she did nothing to deserve this... she was just a poor young girl trying to achieve her dream. But sadly we lived in a judgemental shameless world, people do not have brains in this generation they are hypocrites SHAME ON THEM FOR RUINING THIS GIRL'S LIFE! she could've had a bright future if it weren't for that damn bully or whatever her name is that i could careless😒 I hope that girl gets her karma
She is so precious knowing that someone shouted her name makes her so happy and those little things already means a lot to her.. God, please help this girl find her way to be successful again. She doesn't deserve this my heart still aches for this young woman including Seo Soojin...
The fact that I came to know her after she left but still got attached to her. She is so talented and hope to see her debut in future. Once again, a loss of talented queen! Love you garamiee~♡
I feel so genuinely bad for her... The way some of yall attacked her with absolutely no solid proof was just disgusting, I really hope she can return to the industry one day, or at least she can find something else that makes her happy. That poor girl worked her ass off as a trainee and finally debuted, and it was all over after just a couple weeks...
@@ellanote2260 where is your proof ?? the accuser doesn't even have a proof herself, she just wrote an anonymous article and you'll believe it before she could respond
@@ellanote2260 so your proof start with a 'if' wla wla bla bla bla,, they'd probably thinks it will calm down very but unexpectedly things got out of hands, and with all that happening in a sudden, the truth isn't important anymore, , it's the company's fault staying quiet for too long
@@ellanote2260 read the full svc doc… she could’ve handled the situation better but she’s not a bully. Hybe did defend her. Everything they said in their statements was proven in the svc doc. The very same doc that Eunseo said she’d post the full Ver of if Hybe didn’t change their stance & yet for a whole month after… radio silence. Wanna know why, cause the svc showed Garam was telling the truth while Eunseo was lying.
@@ellanote2260 Yeah, this is why people should stay neutral until ALL the facts come out. Ruined a 16 year old girls dream because an ex-friend is a petty, narcissistic bully.
omg? wtf, she ruined other ppl's lifes since they are still young age as a kid at school, she's proved by company and victimss by bullying classmates, what are you saying
@@Haerinx87 ok so hope when your kids faced bullying to serious level and want to suicide then you react like god to say ok that’s fine , thank you for treating my kids like this , I forgive you , lkkk you are MR god
How cruel. Now people are loving her after she is gone. Don't Judge a book by a cover. People really turned their colours after she is gone and showing love to her. At first they were wild towards her.
True they should do more research about garam but they didn't they keep hating garam at that time now they loving her. hope but still people keep hating her :(
Still breaks my heart everytime I get reminded of Garam. I can only wish that wherever she is right now, I hope she is happy and not living in regret. What she went through in her short time as an idol is just too much. Lesserafim will always be a constant reminder to her of what she could have been and people around her will definitely always have that in the back of their heads. And that's just too much to take on a daily life. I really hope she has completely moved on and found her new passion and is now living a happy life.
Garam’s departure is literally the reason why I can’t bring myself to stan Le Sserafim anymore… as much as I completely ate up their debut I don’t think I’ll ever be able to look at them the same way anymore. I know none of the LS girls are responsible for Garam’s departure. That’s not what I’m saying. What I’m saying is that I cannot accept being part of a fandom that bullied and harassed a member who was the second youngest of her group and have potentially ruined her entire life. Not just her reputation, but also her mental health. I’ve witnessed so many bullying accusations since 2020 and I really have to say… this was truly the worst one. There were more people not believing her and trashing her online than there were fans defending her. I went to every single Garam video I could find and everyone was commenting about how much they hate her and called her names. You’d think that after so many scandals last year, and especially after what happened to Soojin, kpop fans would learn something. But they didn’t. They never will. Garam won’t be the last idol who’ll be accused of bullying and then end up being harassed by fans, and that’s the scary part of it. My heart hurts every day thinking about how it would be if LS was still six. People may not want to admit it but the group looks so incomplete without Garam and she had such a unique and necessary presence in the group. And that’s missing now that she’s gone. I could cry thinking about how much I would be stanning them and laugh at their content if they were still six. But I just can’t bring myself to watch OT5 content and see Fearnots celebrate only them. I miss her so much and I don’t care how much hate I’ll get for commenting this. At least I wasn’t part of the people who ruthlessly destroyed a 16 year old’s dream and are now acting like they miss and love her, when in reality, they’re proud of themselves for making her leave.
I'm with you. You pretty much said all the things I've been thinking about. It's really sad because a lot of bullying scandals are just meant to destroy and defame idols. They are almost always the real victims in these but many kpop fans still never learn. It would be the biggest plot twist in kpop history if Garam returns to Le Sserafim because Hybe had already ended her contract.
Yeah after I saw Fearless I was like omg I love this group already. I still listen to their music but it’s hard becoming a full time stan when u know ones missing bc of people that are so into cancel culture and have nothing better to do than sit on the couch and hate on people they don’t even know, especially the ones that don’t even live in Korea. Like wtf. I still really like them all and I didn’t even really hear their music until like towards the end or the end of the accusations but it’s still weird that it’s not OT6
Precious girl🥺♡ Will never forgive anyone who ever hated on her if she k*l1 herself. No one in her age can handle what she's going through right now. I hope she's doing well and aren't on social media reading stuff people are saying about her. She's so precious and everything. She deserves everything good in this world. I wish I could give her that sb:(
I was going to be a hardcore Lesserafim fan but I hate things like this, taking away someone from her hard worked spot from mere accusations from her past when she was a teenager. Just like I was a fan of Idle until soojin was erased from the group. I love both Soojin and Garam and hope they find their way back to where they deserve.
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans they’re not bullies. Its proved so many times everywhere that Soojin and Garam are innocent. All idols that got accused of bullying scandal, were proved innocent so shut up
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans people can change. And one bad action/mistake from the past shouldn't follow you the rest of your life. If she did something wrong (that still isn't clear if she did) she should get her punishment at the right time. Even big crimes like stealing and murdered prescribed after years past!
she wasnt even a teenager, she was 12...the people out here saying "karma did its job" are embarrassing, like karma didnt do shit, a bunch of people held her to adult standards for shit that happened as a child. thats not karma, thats climbing up on your pedestal while conveniently forgetting any mistakes or mean shit that you did as a kid. like did nobody consider that middle school is literally just a bunch of children trying to pretend theyre older than they are? i wouldnt even consider somebodys behavior in middle school when determining what kind of person they are, i basically just forget middle school ever happened anyway. it was an awkward and embarrassing time where nobody had any life experience or life skills to properly deal w any type of social situations or issues
Hope we’ll see her someday in a better condition. Teenagers like her doesn’t have to go through like this. It’s the unfair of life. Never hate someone even if you know they are guilty. Just forgive them because it’s the main, even more it’s god’s job, not ours. He’ll decide how he has to punish the exact person.
No. Her issue is bullying dude. Bullying ain't a joke. No one will spread such a "rumors" abt her if there is no reason. We don't even know if it's really a "rumor". A victim is associated here. I don't hate her cuz i don't even stan, i just listen to their songs (that time she left the group haha), but who knows, she's loaded and has power to control people around her in her high school days. We can't just forgive someone who is a bully. A bully is always a bully, that's it. If she have done that, well then well deserved.
@@wonucantseewithouthisglasses The fuck is this logic. A bully will not always stay as bully. This happened when she was 12, 5 years ago. She has matured. You're telling me you think all the kids that were bullies deserve to had a bad rest of their life despite maturing??
@@asunnayos yk what karma is? that's what it is. good for her. + and the fact that you admitted it, you just admitted he had bullied someone before. so gurl, if she really matured, then she must have apologized to her victim/s and didn't stayed quite (good for her if she did matured). that's it. and i do not fvcking care abt your reasonings cuz she's still a bully. she was a bully and always a bully no matter how hard she try to be mature or whatsoever. she just matured and changed, but it can't never erase the fact that she bullied someone/people before.
“I’m so happy even though my dream lasted only 2 weeks” -Kim Garam/I really wished ur dream wasn’t ruined by these toxic ppl in ur life Garam I was always on ur side and I’m proud of it I wish for you to come back stronger and more charismatic then ever❤
I'm a fan of lesserafim and I was neutral the whole time and I'm proud to say that I did not partake in any cyber bullying towards her. It's okay to stop supporting her or be an ot5 but to attack and bully her? people are hypocrites because they are doing the same thing which she was being accused of which is "bullying"
Poor Garam, can’t you imagine how long she prepared and trained to become a K-pop idol, just to be bullied and removed from the group. It’s heartbreaking because these people don’t look in to the facts of the situation more
This makes me so sad. I hope she has a chance to build her career back. This isn’t fair. She’s so young and didn’t deserve the hate and bullying she revived.
Even before le sserafim debut, I already made garam as my bias even if there isn’t anything about the group yet. And when they had their debut, I feel no regregts since I stan the talent, not a bully or whatever they call her. People should always look at the present, not in the past.
My bias was Kim Garam, how sad that she kicked out of the Le sserafirm Group. She is still my favorite ❤️ I love u Kim Garam! You are so beautiful, cute and so gorgeous! 🎀 You have so beautiful hair ❤ I just wish that u come back and meet your 5 Members 🎀
She'll never forget what happened with her ... i feel so bad for her .... from beginning i was saying that she is not bully but every time i say that they always start screaming and fighting me They didn't understand that she was so young to be a bully☹💔
She was a little soul we make mistakes we learn we improve , not everyone is very understanding and open minded from birth we don't know everything We lean little by little Past don't represent who you are at present ( Such a stupidity to hate on anyone based one their past ) Edit : We also lost soojin because of that
@@hazelpark9190 No one died because of Garam. However, Yoo Eun-seo (the one who accused Garam as a bully) committed attempted suicide because of the backlash she received from Garam's defenders for "revealing" that Garam is a "bully".
She really was so happy that she achieved her big dream. She worked so hard. And then, a fan called her name. She was so happy. And all this just to be taken away from her. My poor girl does not deserve this. She worked so hard, is so talented, so beautiful. #justiceforgaram
Actually I really hated Garam when the news exploded. Everyone around me talked about her and her scandal too. But when she tried to say the truth for herself, I realized that she was just a kid at that time. She was like 11 or 12 and tried to protect her friend. If I have a friend who protected me from bullying at primary school I would be appreciated so much. And being punished at 5 level, that is the lowest punishment for students at Korean. That was not so serious as people said.
People hype it so much like it really a bad things. But it just a normal way when we want to defend our friends plus she's only 12 at that time. I really feel bad at her. Lesson i get is to not believe any hype rumor like this again.
Wait a minute? She was only 11 years old? That's the big scandal everyone was screaming about? And I actually thought this shit was serious, this is just pathetic.
@@serenitysubs933 she was in 6th grade at that time so maybe 11 or 12. A Korean friend told me everyone thought her issue was big because of mass media, her company and many unconfirmed rumours.
The fact that she was the only member that caught my eye and suddenly just kicks her out bc of a bully that faked To getting bullied to garam and then hybe found out the truth but still didnt add her again i miss her so much🤧🤧🤧😭
Her contract with them has been terminated so they can't really bring her back to the group anymore. And why would she anyway?? Since they have already proved that they're incompetent and incapable of protecting her, they don't deserve her at all. Even Korea also don't deserve her since Knetz kept on acting blind despite proofs are already out that she's not a bully. Hope she finds opportunities outside that country and become an international idol
I'm proud to say that I never said/commented anything bad about her & stayed neutral. I'm just so sad for Garam, she trained & worked hard so that she can debut.
I miss her. She's so pretty, very talented and well behave; a very rare gem indeed. Actually what I'm missing is the real Le Sserafim group; the 6 members. In my heart, the group is already disbanded.
keep supporting them, yes a member left but at the same time she wasn’t there for too long either, we get the sympathy for her cause it WAS unfair but don’t go saying stuff like “to me they’re disbanded” because you’re just not accepting what’s going on when you should, i believe garam will be ok in the future but keep supporting them as 5 and love them as 5 meanwhile.
I really miss her. She was my bias in le sserafim and she really didn’t deserve all the hate she got. She was so sweet and she really could have been one of the most famous members of le sserafim and it really hurts to see that her dreams got crushed in only a span of a few days because of people who were jealous of her after she worked so hard. It’s really not fair. I hope she’s healing and that she is happy. I will always support her. Kim garam❤❤❤
I feel bad for her. I’m not a fan of the group so I was late in this issue. After researching and read a lot about this, I felt so disgusted by the disgusting fans. Take care always Garam, you’ll shine wherever you are! Hold on and your time will come. ♥️
I dont wanna compare idols. But this situation reminded me so much of what happened with Soojin. I hope I can see Garam shine again... She deserved so much better.
I will never forget Garam, she was my bias and I feel bad, I always miss her but I know that it's over and there's no turning back... I hope she debuts later. my princess garami 😭🩷
I hope the internet can feel proud of themselves for bullying a literal teenage girl out of something that she worked hard for. I’m around the same age as her and I remember when people were calling her a bully and boycotting her and whatnot I thought, “But she’s so young and when we’re young we don’t usually think about things this seriously. She might not even be a bully but sadly people lack critical thinking skills and are always ready to jump on bandwagon hating.” She wasn’t even a bully in the end smh her voice was the best in lesserafim along with Yunjin and ugh I wish she could still be living her dream. I’m sure it wasn’t just handed to her, she must’ve worked hard for it but people in this world are quick to shame others and never look at themselves and think about their actions in the critical way that they should. Remember guys, in this world nothing is how it seems, in this internet age it is so easy to manipulate people pls always keep a critical and informed view on things and don’t do things just to feed your own ego and just to feel morally righteous. Your trivial actions may ruin another person’s life.
What happened to her is literally like the song "I did nothing at all". Netizens crushed her dream for which she worked so hard. She deserved to be in the group. Hybe didn't back her up and just used her to bring the group more popularity. Garam seems like a very kind person. The writings on her desk when she went back to school after getting kicked out were so cruel. I hope she comes back in the industry. We all will always wait for Garam
People really bashed and ruined a 16 year old girl’s not only reputation but life and yet have the guts to pretend to be sympathetic afterwards is beyond me.
This is the reason why I stan K-POP casually and most of the time on my own. Fandoms are sick as fuck. Place for harboring toxicity in which affects the artists/idols. I hate K-POP fans.
it breaks my heart how genuine that smile was & the music fits her so well, makes me rethink that if she had not been kicked out she probably would’ve made le sserafim way better
I don't understand why people always cry after idols are kicked out of their groups while this is their fault if they are ejected. People are always complaining but they continue to spread hate and it will continue because I have the feeling that they never learn from their mistakes. (I say people but I'm not putting everyone in this word, only those who have bullied her and have denigrated her without proofs and reasons).
I’m so sorry Garam for everything you endured, it wasn’t fair and it shouldn’t have happened. I will forever resent Hybe, netizens, and the bullies who started these rumors for their actions regarding the whole ordeal :/ I only pray they didn’t kill your hopes of fulfilling your dreams. We are waiting for you with open arms if you decide to return 🫶🏻 So much peace to you Angel
Omggg what’s up with you garam fans blaming hybe it’s good they kicked her out do you really did they are finna risk the reputation for ONE PERSON I doubt and her own mother had say in it miss girl was there for 2 weeks
How can fans treat someone like that from the same group they like 😢 fans dont deserve her and she deserves alot 🪐💗 i will always support her she is so nice and cute i love you garam✨
I want another company to recruit her in a girlgroup 😭😭 girl was so talented like i was listening to sour grapes yesterday and was like ahhh man… miss this kid :(
Garam is the type of person that takes care if other but she never gets taken care of she is always trying to help others but when she needs help she doesn't get it i love lesserfim and i miss her so much
Not really a fan of lesserafim cuz I mostly listen to boy group songs. But glad to hear she was actually defending her friend from getting bullied. She did verbally fought the bullies with her friends, but that’s cuz the “supposed victim” (actually a bully) posted an INAPPROPRIATE PICTURE OF HER FRIEND. One day, karma’s gonna get that “victim”.
Nobody defended her. And even when someone tried to prove her innocence NO ONE listened. I still remember how fans gave her silent treatment when they were performing when she wasn't even proven guilty. Nobody defended her and now that she's proven innocent everyone is sympathizing her
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
I feel so bad for her...... Kpop stans esp girl group stans were constantly bullying her, calling her really disgusting names and whenever their fan accounts tried to clarify with proof that the bully was actually the one posing as d victim and trying to ruin her majority of kpop stans didn't care to look at the facts, they just sided with the actual bully even when it came out that d girl posing as a victim was actually a bully and took pics of garam's friend undressing and sent it to some guy, kpop stans really defended the bully and now every1 just tries to shift the blame on to others. Also I see some hating on their fandom and hybe and trying to shift the blame toward them now but honestly even though I didn't say anything when all these was going on, I noticed then that who ever tried to clarify about the situation, they were bullied and garam ended up getting bullied more. I don't care abt companies but when hybe defended her, kpop stans just labeled hybe as a shameless company still harbouring a bully, they gave clarifications about the situation and the case about it yet nobody cared about it even with proof and when hybe notified on Twitter asking people not to spread misinformations and that they would sue people if they did that and also that garam was being bullied and needed time to recover cus she was going through a lot of mental stress, kpop stans just wrote more hateful stuff about garam and called the company shameless for defending her... Garam truly deserve an apology from kpop fans esp gg stans!!
Couldn’t have said it better myself. Everyone owes her the biggest apology. You’d think they’d have learned from what happened with Jimin & Soojin but alas… Kpop Stan’s can’t function without hating on someone, specifically a talented female.
They should have at least waited for hybe statement and be neutral but they straight up jumped to conclusions and kept saying the documentary proof and that she got punished like innocent people aren’t punished before ?? Garam totally deserves better she was so young and finally debuted after working so hard only for people to bully her and finding out she wasn’t the bully
Well I'm a MY but I rlly liked Garam she seems so nice to me and yeah u are right those toxic gg stans exaggerated too much, they were just hating on her bcs she is so pretty nothing else
Garam was my bias, she just caught my eye right away. Truth be told, I was very scared when the rumors started going around, because I didn't know what to believe. Because I've been bullied before it made me angry at first and I decided to read up on some articles about her as a bully. However I didn't spread any hate about her, I wanted to remain neutral, but I know I failed cuz I really believed she had been a harsh bully at some point... Now I'm just extremely sad about her whole situation.. I wish she could come back or debut somewhere else if it's still her dream.
Frr thank you for making a comment and saying this i stayed neutral in that situation tho i still want to apologise i wasn't even their stan at that time but......it's just hurts.....garam I'm really sorry please stay happy wherever you are I'm really sorry really very sorry
“She was only there for two weeks, it’s not a big deal” imagine what it was like for her, she had her whole future ahead of her and it was ruined. I always wonder what it would be like if she was still in the group.
She probably could’ve saved them at Coachella lol
Lmao @@justincastillo5156
@@justincastillo5156not only that but like garam and chaewon’s voices complement each other so much I feel like their songs would be soo much better
@@fatimahheh3195 yeah. And their concepts would've been better. I mean, ever since Easy era, their songs and concept have become weird. Ever since their webtoon series ended they started releasing musics that don't make sense. (At least to me they don't)
NO HATE TO THE GROUP.
@@_Insane_CARATI agree with that even though I am fearnot 👍
'my dream came true for 14 days, ill cherish those days forever.' - Kim Garam
That hit hard. I really miss her
It's funny how the whole group is acting like she's never there. I hate hybe for making them do this and for not taking garam in the group again. Now I no longer like lee seerafim but not hate them.
@@Fatemajannat57they're not really allowed to speak about her since she's not part of the group and her contract is terminated, also they have to keep going even if she is gone because they're still a group
@@Fatemajannat57you can’t blame them
They don’t have a choice
@@Fatemajannat57they cant do anything for that. They must be missing her presence in the group behind the cameras but they can't show remorse or sadness on camera because she is not part of the group anymore
She didn’t deserve to leave the group
the fact that she is so happy with just a mere action like calling her name
ikr :((
Probably because it's only her first time
@@winneristrueartists5357 and last maybe 😭
@@bluespider6538 wasn't she kicked out? Then it's her last
@@icxuna Well Jimin came back with her second chance ( When it wasn't even her fault) who knows if Garam comes back.
First people bash at her, tell her to leave the group, criticize her and now they feel sorry for her. Pathetic.
I feel like an idiot bcz I actually believed that
I regret it
I should just stay neutral next time
I didn't write hate comments tho
but still...I shouldn't believe it
the one who started this rumor might actually be the real bully that bullied and ruined her career
hope she can debut
NOT EVERYONE BASHED HER
Well you know there are so many out there who just support the ones who are more in number without thinking about situations on their own. That's why a lot earlier were against her and are now suddenly feeling sorry for her. Bad humans 😒
@@vimladevi4830 But most did
Me who always supported her the beginning... Still supported her.. When most of the people were criticizing her.. I always believed her ❤ i hope she's going well and being strong
I'm a pre debut FEARNOT and I feel empty while watching them as five and she was my first bias of LE SSERAFIM. I literally cry whenever someone posts a video of her.
Miss u Garam 💔💔
OT6 forever ♾️
she become my first bias in a first sight but SHE WILL BE MY BIAS WRECKER ALWAYS nd my bias is yunjin❤❤❤ but i miss garam too
Same manh.. just can't look at them the same. Its impossible for me to move on.
I remember seeing all those videos making fun of her, calling her names, dragging her down, putting out even more false information to put more fuel to fire. Literal bullies calling her a bully
She became my First Bias too!! ❤😢
I totally with you on that😢
Don't watch those for your own sake 🙂
I never once commented on garam , I can proudly say that.. why ? Because she’s a teen an there wasn’t any solid proof .. love or hate we should stop the cycle of hatred and bullying as we are all apart of the K-pop community . Garams 2 weeks of fame was all she could’ve asked for . Though fans didn’t like her even when she debuted . Maybe this was meant to be .
Edit : Everyone is entitled to their opinion , but hating and breaking down a minor does not sit right with me ! It’s makes you just as bad as those other people :( .
im geniunely asking, i love garam a lot as well, but there was this piece of evidence saying she got grade 5 bullying or smth and her name was written there, was that like fake evidence?
@@sunsunjayki it surely was but then the "victim" also had 8th level punishment
@@sunsunjayki It was real but not for the reason ppl thought (which was that she severely threatened and bullied the alleged victim). The documents were finally released and it showed that all garam did was curse at the “victim” because of some stupid teenage drama that the victim started cuz she was spreading rumors and having her male friends target garam’s friends. This resulted in the punishment she got with the victim getting a more severe one.
@@sunsunjayki 1) in korea and also in a lot of countries there is not a single person that is not sharing the same name as someone else 2) The "evidence" only showed a Name and a grade punishment, but you literally can fake a document like that, even more if you are just showing smth that simple.
I wish i could turn the time back, and do whatever were in my hands to defend her, even if i already did it, but i wish i would have had more 😭
same bestie i didn't regret defending her
That breaks my heart. She was so excited to have support, and her dreams were just ripped away from her because of lies and a poorly functioning company...
poorly functioning company? they stayed on her side, released a statement that they will sue anyone who continues to spread misinfo. and was also getting alot of hate for "harbouring a bully"
@@sweetpea8155 Stayed on her side? No, they didn't; they literally removed her. Getting hate for "harboring a bully" means nothing when they're right and could have proven it. But they couldn't stand up to netizens and so-called journalists, the ones they would be able to sue, and instead of standing firm, they put her on hiatus, didn't make any clarifying statements about promotional materials that came out including her during her hiatus, and removed her in two months, *after* calls to bring her back. Even after getting the information and releasing statements, they still chose to terminate her contract fter knowing the truth. That's not staying on her side; that's not protecting their artist.
@@Nia-Day at that point it's too late, Garam's image which is her market was already destroyed that's how it works in Korea. It's just funny how y'all act as if the company did nothing when in fact they did, downplaying kpop community's toxicity and shifting all the blame to the company.
@@sweetpea8155 Literally never downplayed the bloody community. Her image was not beyond "saving", as evidenced by the trending hashtags to end her hiatus back in July, and by how the vast majority of content about her over the last several months has been neutral or positive. LESSERAFIM was brand new, HYBE first girl group, and the same idiotic netizens that cared would bloody forget within months anyway. What's actually funny is how you raised a counter, I responsed, then you moved the goal post. I don't ignore the borderline criminal nature of netizens, never have and never will. That doesn't mean HYBE carries no blame
@@Nia-DayHYBE did everything they could to defend to her, but everything was blown out of proportion and went way too far, so at one point they had to make the choice between removing her from the group or letting the entire group fail because of her ruined image. They chose to let go of 1 to save 5, instead of saving 1 who will bring down the other 5 with her. (Obviously I’m not blaming Garam at all, but at that point her reputation was ruined beyond repair and it wouldn’t be fair to the other girls if HYBE let her stay in the group and drag their image down)
It was all because of the fandom and ONLY the fandom. That happens when we let little toxic kids to decide the future of an human person. Terrible...
No it’s not…even most of the fandom was against garam and they were more haters than defenders
@@zuhaswifeee yes you are right but we will never stop being with her side
No not only the Fandom it is also/mainly those random good for nothing keyboard warriors (cowards)... They never deserve good things in their lives for ruining a teenage girl's dream (she even proven innocent morally)
Bro ofc ppl r going to believe wts shown to them
Its the company. Hybe DID NOT handle the matter properly at all.
Have u seen garam's statement after she was kicked, it was so simple. Hybe couldn't release smthng so simple? That company literally sucks.
@@singularity_5177 when HYBE protected GARAM "HYBE is the worst company protecting a bully" "kick her out of the group she is ruining the group's reputation"
When HYBE let go of GARAM because she has to she can't handle these many disgusting hates and it's even difficult for her to rebuild her reputation plus if she continues to stay in this industry that gonna hurt GARAM's mental health heavily, Lesserafim's growth as a group would fall and HYBE as a company knows what they want.. Still the people blame on HYBE saying they are the worst they shouldn't have let her go... Seriously? What they supposed to do when damage is already happened??
She's a type of person who needs to be loved but never gets it... Love u garam
I wish she never left lesserafim😢 she didn’t deserved that
Those people who commented on garam, bashed her, demanded her to leave the group are now feeling sympathetic and missing her. This is just so hypocrite. Y'all are so fast on reaching to a judgement which is made by yourself without knowing literally ANYTHING about it. This is not the 1st time and Garam is not the 1st idol to face bullying accusations yet everyone reacted in the same typical way not taking any lessons from past.
It just feels awful. And people kept saying "when are they going to kick her out it's already been 2 months" 2 MONTHS IS NOTHING. Soojin was kicked out after 5 months and April disbanded after 11 months. 2 months is not enough to determine if she was right or wrong, even for Soojin it took 1,6 years to clear her name, and 1,3 years for AOA Jimin to clear her name.
I am not much updated about this issue. Has it been revealed that those accusations were baseless or it wasn't much of a big issue?
@@aasthaj31 there is proof, but its just that the hate she received was pretty big and still shes getting bullied at her own school
@@ellanote2260 That I agree as well. Even if she bullied someone, people did the same thing to her. Even wayy worse. There is no difference between the right and wrong now. She could have been punished legally or the two parties could have resolved among them. Even after she was removed from the group, they should let her live now at the least. Her getting cursed at school by friends is nothing but blatant bullying.
@@aasthaj31 yeah with that i do agree
Garam was simply standing up for a friend of hers. I don’t understand why she and Soojin of G Idle can’t be idols anymore. Besides those people calling for her to be removed have probably been a bully themselves. Feel really bad for her.
I dont get it what happened?
@@Primprim.rosie.She was accused of bullying at school, people criticize her before the case was over, she left the group. Well, apparently she proven innocent :"(
@@secondlov3959 that's so sad :(
@@secondlov3959Soojin (g-idle) and Garam (Le Serafim) was accused of bullying when they weren’t. Soojin was falsely accused by the actress Seo Shin Ae of bullying her, but Soojin stated that they never knew each other nor were they acquainted because they were on different floors and that Soojin already left the friend group that bullied Seo Shin Ae when she joined their school because she doesn’t want to be involved with bad kids so they never intermingled. Seo Shin Ae then said she wasn’t sure if Soojin really bullied her and later stated that she didn’t know that Soojin was already an outcast of that group and that she never actually spoke to Soojin at all. Her claims and accusations were based off on what she heard from other people and assumed Soojin was a part of it, she destroyed Soojin’s career and many people argued that maybe she used Soojin to boost her fame as a victim since she’s not really a well known actress but Seo Shin Ae denied those accusations. On Garam’s end, it was all full of bs accusations that’s pretty obvious that they were just framing her. All Garam did was defend her friend from a bully who uploaded a photo of her friend who was only dressed in underwear. She confronted the bully which is Yoo Eun Seo and ended up cursing at her in the heat of the moment out of anger. She was only defending her friend but she recognized that her methods was wrong and immature. In fact, Garam was also the one being bullied as a photo of her desk covered in hate and kys notes was leaked in twitter. HYBE threw lots of evidences that proved Garam was innocent yet immature people and haters never stopped bashing her and turned blind to the truth. They ruined a 16 year old teenage girl’s life and took away her career from her just because they all believed the accusations without hearing her side of the story.
Yeah i miss soojin. I was so sad when she got kicked out cause she just became my bias after stanning g idle for a few months..now I just became a fearnot..and well just found out a member got kicked out because of bullying accusations too. Why 2 of my favorite gg's 😢
PS soojin just created her ig like a few weeks ago iirc
her pure smile when fans calling his name >>>>>
You guys never learn. This happened to soojin too. And soojin never even got a fighting chance, it’s so sad that despite the fact this has happened once too many times people are still so eager to hop on the next “woke” train to seem like they actually care about victims or know 90% of the BS they preach about.
Literally im tired repeating this issue
She got a chance of fighting yet ppl who thinks they know the truth and claimed she is a real bully discredited her saying she is lying instead of apologizing and even bullied the accused victim once again....
amen. a rumor starts about an idol doing something and people automatically define that idol because of something that may not even be true. it’s disgusting how we are so quick to condemn and slow to forgive or even just do a little research when we ourselves are far from perfect.
yeah and with hyunjin ppl just don’t give up
I still love the two groups, but I honestly listen to their songs and watch their music videos like "oh that would have been soojins line" "ooohh garam would have made that shot so pretty"
~My dream only lasted for 2 week, but I'll appreciate that moment
-Kim Garam😭😭
only if people have been neutral she would still be there with them. They didn't even give her chance to explain herself.
:(
@@revachitnis9948 that’s the point. all the people even her agency didn’t even hear her explanation. for me, that sounds very clear when garam made clarification on her instagram, but no one even cares about that
Idk u guys somehow are taking bullying a little too lightly.
@@xmanarx2614 what do you mean by taking bullying lightly
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 garamiee miss youu
I was neutral the whole time. The first time I heard of Garam was from my cousin. She told me she was a bully and I ask her how she knew all this. She told me she saw on internet and I straight away told her that not all things in Internet espically of what they talk about someone is not true. After I told her this she think of what i said and told me that maybe she was wrong. And the thing is one of the main reason Garam left was because people just believe what one person said and even before thinking of the other way,they just come into conclusion and decided to hate her. And later after she left the group they started feeling sorry for her again, and blame others for their mistakes. At least learn from this issue and not let this happen in kpop again. Most of us really miss her and dont want this to happen to anyone, I mean how will you feel if you were her?
(Sorry the comment is so long)
Garam wasn't the first victim of the kpop internet thugs and unfortunately I highly doubt she'll be the last. Smh 😔
Just like soojin's case 😭except that hybe actually helped garam but the haters were too strong. Soojin's one cube didn't even help her and kicked her out like what😭both of them don't deserve this
Though I advocate your desire for change, let's be real here, nothing is going to change.
No matter how much we want to, unless the problem is not something that could legitimately move the companies and the "fans" to action. To actually make a change. The thing that happened with GARAM can very well happen again.
The fact that people believed a dropped report that only showed Garams name 😭 how more quick to judge can people be
what kind of echo chamber I've landed on? are there still people that believe she's innocent? then what was the level 5 punishment for? lmao
I am proud of the fact that I've never done cyber attack on her by writing comments without knowing the whole story
Same
Same I will defended her from others who talk shit
Yes same .. This is basic manners and logic but people nowadays don’t have a brain instead they choose to join any hate trend they see for no valid reason
yea knets are just dumbfuvk
Yeah
Here to spread the message. @ John Jackson for credit
Garam is declared innocent of bullying and violence in the official school disciplinary report; therefore, she should have stayed in Le Sserafim. Garam defended a friend verbally who pleaded for help when Eunsoo took hidden photos of Garam's friend in her underwear and hacked a facebook account to post them online under another name to incriminate an innocent student. Eunsoo's rich father used his influence to push through a disciplinary committee that was biased against Garam. Yet, the level 5 offense that Garam received for defending her friend with a cuss word or two carried 0 severity points for violence and was the most common one given at her school, while Eunsoo's very rare level 8 offense carried 16-20 points in severity of violence which was beyond suspension. Yet, the rich father used his influence to get Eunsoo to transfer schools before the punishment could be implemented and jealous Eunsoo bullied Garam at the new school by getting boys in online chat rooms to threaten violence against her and keep inviting her so she couldn't leave the chats. Garam also had insults and obscenities written on her desk at school.
Eunsoo's intense jealousy of Garam debuting in her favorite kpop company was one of the primary driving forces for the lies and corruption to drive Garam out, but another pivotal reason the powers in kpop and South Korea were so rabid in going after Garam is that she stood up to the rich elite's perverted "right" to post child porn online, use blackmail to control girls' lives, and incriminate others by stealing their identity to post it so they don't get caught. In their demented minds, this is what they call a perpetrator of crimes. As a result, Eunsoo's rich father purchased a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career since it coincided with Garam's debut in Le Sserafim and had nothing to do with the stated intent which was accusing Garam of bullying, since the school incident happened four years before and was caused by the violent actions of sexual harassment and theft of a facebook account by Eunsoo.
According to the Korean Broadcasting System (KBS), Garam was by far the hardest hit target by Kakao Organization affiliated with Starship with 336 slanderous articles written to destroy her reputation. Kakao is currently under investigation by the FTC for reverse viral marketing. Kakao falsely claimed that Garam was an ex Starship trainee who was removed for bullying other members which was a lie. Furthermore, Kakao is responsible for the slanderous picture and article claiming that Garam had written down with Ive and other famous kpop groups on a blackboard, even though Garam is not seen in the picture and even though she hadn't attended that school since 2018 which was long before the group IVE even formed. Finally, they are responsible for lies about Garam bullying other Le Sserafim members. it is obvious that there was a coordinated conspiracy to cancel Garam, especially with the fake evidence and fabricated photos spread all over the internet by the fake victim, Eunsoo, her rich father's purchase of a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career, and Kakao's viral flooding of the internet with negative and slanderous articles against Garam who was innocent of the false allegations.
While Hybe appeared to defend Garam in a superficial sense by putting out an official statement that recounted Garam's version of the story, it was done in an impersonal way with statements like According to Garam. Furthermore, it was issued too late, since it also announced that she was being placed on hiatus. However, the real incompetence and undermining by Hybe came from their refusal to let Garam make the public statement she requested in mid-April and their refusal to let her release the official school disciplinary report which she also had available in mid-April. Even worse, Hybe's complete betrayed of Garam came when they refused to release this critical information even after Eunsoo's side released a cropped and marked on part of the school disciplinary document which only indicated Garam's offense. Furthermore, they didn't release the testimonies of the many students that supported Garam's innocence. Hybe also never filed lawsuits for libel or slander against all the false information and incriminating faked photos posted by the fake victim (real bully) or against the death or sexual assault threats that were posted online which badly damaged Garam's reputation and traumatized her psychologically, especially since she rarely left her dorm room during the time of her hiatus because of anxiety and depression. This downcast condition and isolation persisted for an extended period even after Garam left Hybe and went home.
This cyber witch hunt fueled with malicious lies didn't give Garam's side of the story which would have been based, if it had been allowed to take place, on official school evidence, direct testimony and the emotional resonance of Garam's personal appeal. The effect was to create great hype at the moment of debut but to destroy the mental health of Garam who was falsely accused and served as the scapegoat for the group. There is even a haunting scene in an ad in which Garam falls really hard on a car which suggests that she is Hybe's fallen sixth angel, since Le Sseragim means six angels. Then after a long hiatus and a period of silence, Hybe dumped Garam with no attempt made to clear her name, even though they had all the evidence to do so and even though they had used the excuse of an upcoming trial against Eunsoo as the reason not to reveal the evidence to exonerate Garam. The defender against sexual exploitation, Garam, was severely punished and Eunsoo, the sexual offender of Garam's friend and facebook hacker was rewarded.
Therefore after Garam's unjust cancellation and while sunk in the depths of depression, it was left up to Garam with the help of her faithful friend Yudimi to muster up the strength to clear her name by releasing the official school disciplinary report and Garam's explanatory statement in August, in which Garam refuted many of the falsehoods by saying she never drank or smoked, never bullied or ordered anyone around, never transferred schools and never used violence. She also had the honesty to admit that she would have handled the defense of her friend a bit differently now that she had the perspective of more maturity but was adamant that in principle she had done the right thing because her parents had taught her the importance of defending a friend in a time of adversity. But honestly, Garam's actions seem really honorable and reasonable considering the severity of the offense: yelling and saying a couple of cuss words at Eunsoo for posting half nude photos of her friend as a profile pic online and hacking a facebook account to incriminate another student. Better yet, I thought of Garam's actions as a wise lesson posed as a question: If every member of a group and its fandom had the guts to defend a targeted member the way Garam defended her friend against a powerful and perverted enemy like Eunsoo, wouldn't all these unjust bullying cancellations like of Jimin, Soojin and Garam come to an end? In Garam's closing address in her letter, she thanked her fans with a harbinger of hope, GaramDream. And the strength of Garam's and Yudimi's efforts freed from Hybe's draconian restrictions turned the tide of public opinion in Garam's favor.
Presently, there are some hopeful signs such as Garam giving thanks to her fans on her birthday for her video banner in Seoul on November 16, and 6 days later the first beautiful photos of Garam in her yellow school uniform appeared on twitter. My hope is that if Garam wishes to return to music that she will go into jpop in Japan, as I think it would be safer and give her far more freedom of expression and action. Garam is also quite popular there, comments are more positive for her there than in South Korea, there are far fewer risks, and Japanese songs are longer with storylines that include acting in the videos, which is a great fit since she is currently studying acting at the School of Performing Arts. Plus, the big money influences and propaganda and cancellation campaigns waged against her in kpop will have far less influence in Japan and she will have better protection in Japan from the depravity of lies, misogyny, jealousy and hypocrisy. However, I will support her in whatever she decides to do especially if it is kpop or kdrama because she will need a lot more protection then. Garam is one of my very favorites because of her great beauty and charisma on stage and her fabulous singing, dancing, and her strong integrity of character at such a young age. Her soothing sweet vocals with a touch of sassiness in Blue Flame and Sour Grapes are like a delightful dream and her beautiful ferocity in Fearless is captivating. Her heartbreaking story and efforts to rise again from great persecution are a true inspiration and remind me of an epic movie, so it is certainly no coincidence that she is studying to be an actress. I just wish her the best of success, happiness with love and trust from family and friends, and warmth and understanding from all over the world.
It's simply hybe goes also for money
Wtf
uhm...aaa..aaa...aaaa...aaa
i donno what to say
well said.
Wow
Garam honestly had what it takes. She could of been the next IT girl alongside Yeji, Karina, Sullyoon, & Wonyoung. I also could of seen her becoming one of the most popular (maybe even the most) of Le Sserafim. She just had so much potential. Now that she was proven innocent by court I feel awful for her. I hope she is healing & getting the love & support she needs.
+ Shen Xiaoting
i agree, but sullyoons not an it girl tbh
@@0l1v3.- i also feel like karina, bc she does seem to have that impact yk?
@@0l1v3.-wonyoung was made into am "it" girl. It was completely manufactured. Her original personality did not did not fit thie manufactured vibe they created. She seemed playful and goofy before.
@@0l1v3.-i’m pretty sure yeji is 4th gen it girl or smth
WE WANT GARAM BACKK THERE ARE MANY PROOFS THAT SHE'S INNOCENT HYBE I BEG YOU PLEASE BRING GARAM BACK 😭
Sadly... she is terminated. But lets hope she will debut and gain more confidence
It’s so annoying how they can’t re-join the group when they’re proved innocent. They literally worked so hard and stupid 13-15 year olds are allowed to ruin a persons life and just continue on like nothing happened. I wish I could find the people who jumped to conclusions before anything was confirmed.
@@namjoonsleftdimpletrue but you need to know that korea is different even when she was proven innocent they cancelled her and whenever you see someone post about her on any site the comments are all hate in all honesty her case was very severe she should be thankful she wasn't blacklisted like even the ministery of education got involved
I am proud to say i never hated garam it's my habit to like the people that gets hate most of the time like wonyoung when she debuted i adored her and garam i just felt she was really good and i defended her when the rumors were going i knew there was something wrong going on and than when she was proven innocent i felt real bad for her and i can never even see lesserefim ever again because of her leaving..
I can't imagine the depression, anxiety, and trauma that she must have felt☹️
God bless this poor girl she did nothing to deserve this... she was just a poor young girl trying to achieve her dream.
But sadly we lived in a judgemental shameless world, people do not have brains in this generation they are hypocrites SHAME ON THEM FOR RUINING THIS GIRL'S LIFE!
she could've had a bright future if it weren't for that damn bully or whatever her name is that i could careless😒
I hope that girl gets her karma
She is so precious knowing that someone shouted her name makes her so happy and those little things already means a lot to her.. God, please help this girl find her way to be successful again. She doesn't deserve this my heart still aches for this young woman including Seo Soojin...
The fact that I came to know her after she left but still got attached to her. She is so talented and hope to see her debut in future. Once again, a loss of talented queen! Love you garamiee~♡
I feel so genuinely bad for her... The way some of yall attacked her with absolutely no solid proof was just disgusting, I really hope she can return to the industry one day, or at least she can find something else that makes her happy. That poor girl worked her ass off as a trainee and finally debuted, and it was all over after just a couple weeks...
@@ellanote2260 where is your proof ?? the accuser doesn't even have a proof herself, she just wrote an anonymous article and you'll believe it before she could respond
@@ellanote2260 so your proof start with a 'if' wla wla bla bla bla,, they'd probably thinks it will calm down very but unexpectedly things got out of hands, and with all that happening in a sudden, the truth isn't important anymore, , it's the company's fault staying quiet for too long
@@ellanote2260 read the full svc doc… she could’ve handled the situation better but she’s not a bully. Hybe did defend her. Everything they said in their statements was proven in the svc doc. The very same doc that Eunseo said she’d post the full Ver of if Hybe didn’t change their stance & yet for a whole month after… radio silence. Wanna know why, cause the svc showed Garam was telling the truth while Eunseo was lying.
@@arib371 of well too bad now
@@ellanote2260 Yeah, this is why people should stay neutral until ALL the facts come out. Ruined a 16 year old girls dream because an ex-friend is a petty, narcissistic bully.
poor girl, she was so happy to become a kpop idol but these cruel people ruined her and her career. she deserves so much better :(
omg? wtf, she ruined other ppl's lifes since they are still young age as a kid at school, she's proved by company and victimss by bullying classmates, what are you saying
@@tiffanychen110 she is INNOCENT go do some research’s before talking
@@tiffanychen110
even "if" Garam was a bully. bullying a bully is NOT RIGHT. How can you be against bullying, then go bully the bully. it's hypocrisy
@@springluvs she’s innocent then the company kicked her out by she’s innocent ? What’s your evidence tho ? Kkkk so funny
@@Haerinx87 ok so hope when your kids faced bullying to serious level and want to suicide then you react like god to say ok that’s fine , thank you for treating my kids like this , I forgive you , lkkk you are MR god
I remember how everyone was bullying her so badly im so glad i stayed neutral at that time she didn't deserve this treatment
Yah
Same, most of my comments at that time were like “even if she is a bully, bullying her is not any better and is so hypocritical of netizens”
I hope she is recovering her wounds.. I hope she finds something motivating really soon..
How cruel. Now people are loving her after she is gone. Don't Judge a book by a cover. People really turned their colours after she is gone and showing love to her. At first they were wild towards her.
True they should do more research about garam but they didn't they keep hating garam at that time now they loving her. hope but still people keep hating her :(
Well I hated her bc I heard she was a bully but I regret it now I fell really bad I’m a bad, Dint judge a book by it’s a cover 😭😭😭😭😭❤
I'm glad she was able to recover her image somewhat in the end, at least
'Cuz she turned out to be innocent *after* getting kicked out
Not everyone hated her or bullied her! It was the few immature gullible idiots 🤦🏻♀️
Still breaks my heart everytime I get reminded of Garam. I can only wish that wherever she is right now, I hope she is happy and not living in regret. What she went through in her short time as an idol is just too much. Lesserafim will always be a constant reminder to her of what she could have been and people around her will definitely always have that in the back of their heads. And that's just too much to take on a daily life. I really hope she has completely moved on and found her new passion and is now living a happy life.
Garam’s departure is literally the reason why I can’t bring myself to stan Le Sserafim anymore… as much as I completely ate up their debut I don’t think I’ll ever be able to look at them the same way anymore. I know none of the LS girls are responsible for Garam’s departure. That’s not what I’m saying. What I’m saying is that I cannot accept being part of a fandom that bullied and harassed a member who was the second youngest of her group and have potentially ruined her entire life. Not just her reputation, but also her mental health. I’ve witnessed so many bullying accusations since 2020 and I really have to say… this was truly the worst one. There were more people not believing her and trashing her online than there were fans defending her. I went to every single Garam video I could find and everyone was commenting about how much they hate her and called her names. You’d think that after so many scandals last year, and especially after what happened to Soojin, kpop fans would learn something. But they didn’t. They never will. Garam won’t be the last idol who’ll be accused of bullying and then end up being harassed by fans, and that’s the scary part of it.
My heart hurts every day thinking about how it would be if LS was still six. People may not want to admit it but the group looks so incomplete without Garam and she had such a unique and necessary presence in the group. And that’s missing now that she’s gone. I could cry thinking about how much I would be stanning them and laugh at their content if they were still six. But I just can’t bring myself to watch OT5 content and see Fearnots celebrate only them. I miss her so much and I don’t care how much hate I’ll get for commenting this. At least I wasn’t part of the people who ruthlessly destroyed a 16 year old’s dream and are now acting like they miss and love her, when in reality, they’re proud of themselves for making her leave.
same she was my bias😭😭
I'm with you. You pretty much said all the things I've been thinking about. It's really sad because a lot of bullying scandals are just meant to destroy and defame idols. They are almost always the real victims in these but many kpop fans still never learn. It would be the biggest plot twist in kpop history if Garam returns to Le Sserafim because Hybe had already ended her contract.
Yeah after I saw Fearless I was like omg I love this group already. I still listen to their music but it’s hard becoming a full time stan when u know ones missing bc of people that are so into cancel culture and have nothing better to do than sit on the couch and hate on people they don’t even know, especially the ones that don’t even live in Korea. Like wtf. I still really like them all and I didn’t even really hear their music until like towards the end or the end of the accusations but it’s still weird that it’s not OT6
a whole book
I feel the same way 😭😭😔
Precious girl🥺♡
Will never forgive anyone who ever hated on her if she k*l1 herself. No one in her age can handle what she's going through right now. I hope she's doing well and aren't on social media reading stuff people are saying about her.
She's so precious and everything. She deserves everything good in this world. I wish I could give her that sb:(
Sometime people may forget, they have emotions and up and down days like all of us.
Yeaaa my girl is doing well according to her classmates n she has so many friends
@@fatememolla6049 that's not true. No one have heard anything about her
you said it. 'No one in her age can handle what she's going through right now"
babe, she was bullying people wtf r u guys on ???
@@priyankasardesai7198 hope you going through something worse than her. Well deserved🫱🏼🫲🏼
My bias will always be Garam, no matter what❤
A fellow Serene I see💖💕ಇ
I was going to be a hardcore Lesserafim fan but I hate things like this, taking away someone from her hard worked spot from mere accusations from her past when she was a teenager. Just like I was a fan of Idle until soojin was erased from the group. I love both Soojin and Garam and hope they find their way back to where they deserve.
Bullies deserve everything that's coming to them. Don't act so disappointed when karma do its job💅 Embarassing
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans they’re not bullies. Its proved so many times everywhere that Soojin and Garam are innocent. All idols that got accused of bullying scandal, were proved innocent so shut up
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans people can change. And one bad action/mistake from the past shouldn't follow you the rest of your life. If she did something wrong (that still isn't clear if she did) she should get her punishment at the right time. Even big crimes like stealing and murdered prescribed after years past!
she wasnt even a teenager, she was 12...the people out here saying "karma did its job" are embarrassing, like karma didnt do shit, a bunch of people held her to adult standards for shit that happened as a child. thats not karma, thats climbing up on your pedestal while conveniently forgetting any mistakes or mean shit that you did as a kid. like did nobody consider that middle school is literally just a bunch of children trying to pretend theyre older than they are? i wouldnt even consider somebodys behavior in middle school when determining what kind of person they are, i basically just forget middle school ever happened anyway. it was an awkward and embarrassing time where nobody had any life experience or life skills to properly deal w any type of social situations or issues
Hope we’ll see her someday in a better condition. Teenagers like her doesn’t have to go through like this. It’s the unfair of life. Never hate someone even if you know they are guilty. Just forgive them because it’s the main, even more it’s god’s job, not ours. He’ll decide how he has to punish the exact person.
Agreed!
Fully agreed!
No. Her issue is bullying dude. Bullying ain't a joke. No one will spread such a "rumors" abt her if there is no reason. We don't even know if it's really a "rumor". A victim is associated here. I don't hate her cuz i don't even stan, i just listen to their songs (that time she left the group haha), but who knows, she's loaded and has power to control people around her in her high school days. We can't just forgive someone who is a bully. A bully is always a bully, that's it. If she have done that, well then well deserved.
@@wonucantseewithouthisglasses The fuck is this logic. A bully will not always stay as bully. This happened when she was 12, 5 years ago. She has matured. You're telling me you think all the kids that were bullies deserve to had a bad rest of their life despite maturing??
@@asunnayos yk what karma is? that's what it is. good for her.
+ and the fact that you admitted it, you just admitted he had bullied someone before. so gurl, if she really matured, then she must have apologized to her victim/s and didn't stayed quite (good for her if she did matured). that's it. and i do not fvcking care abt your reasonings cuz she's still a bully. she was a bully and always a bully no matter how hard she try to be mature or whatsoever. she just matured and changed, but it can't never erase the fact that she bullied someone/people before.
My heart goes out to her. I wish they would bring her back.
not a stan but when i saw her cute reaction it genuinely made me tear up, like she deserved so much better💔
“I’m so happy even though my dream lasted only 2 weeks” -Kim Garam/I really wished ur dream wasn’t ruined by these toxic ppl in ur life Garam I was always on ur side and I’m proud of it I wish for you to come back stronger and more charismatic then ever❤
I WILL ALWAYS WAIT FOR HER TO MAKE A COMEBACK IN THE INDUSTRY AND I WILL BE HER BIGGEST FAN AND ROOT FOR GARAM BABAY FOREVER
I'm a fan of lesserafim and I was neutral the whole time and I'm proud to say that I did not partake in any cyber bullying towards her. It's okay to stop supporting her or be an ot5 but to attack and bully her? people are hypocrites because they are doing the same thing which she was being accused of which is "bullying"
Poor Garam, can’t you imagine how long she prepared and trained to become a K-pop idol, just to be bullied and removed from the group. It’s heartbreaking because these people don’t look in to the facts of the situation more
Whoever share that rumor, I hope they live a hardlife, now, future, and even afterlife😊
Yoo eunseo, was the alleged victim
Shes rich so she's living good, thats the worst part
This makes me so sad. I hope she has a chance to build her career back. This isn’t fair. She’s so young and didn’t deserve the hate and bullying she revived.
I think she will not gonna build her career back for now but we still hoping
Kpop stans should realize at this point that publicly accusing an idol of bullying should be the biggest red flag in kpop
She's so adorable i love her
Even before le sserafim debut, I already made garam as my bias even if there isn’t anything about the group yet. And when they had their debut, I feel no regregts since I stan the talent, not a bully or whatever they call her. People should always look at the present, not in the past.
i will love garam forever. she didnt deserve to be kicked out 💔
🥹💗
My bias was Kim Garam, how sad that she kicked out of the Le sserafirm Group. She is still my favorite ❤️ I love u Kim Garam! You are so beautiful, cute and so gorgeous! 🎀 You have so beautiful hair ❤ I just wish that u come back and meet your 5 Members 🎀
The fact that shes so happy even just one person is calling her nameis just..SHE DESERVES MORE
She'll never forget what happened with her ... i feel so bad for her .... from beginning i was saying that she is not bully but every time i say that they always start screaming and fighting me
They didn't understand that she was so young to be a bully☹💔
my biggest achievement was I NEVER hated her
Samee glad you support garam till the end 💗
She was a little soul
we make mistakes we learn we improve , not everyone is very understanding and open minded from birth we don't know everything
We lean little by little
Past don't represent who you are at present
( Such a stupidity to hate on anyone based one their past )
Edit : We also lost soojin because of that
So what about the student who died because of her?
@@hazelpark9190 No one died because of Garam. However, Yoo Eun-seo (the one who accused Garam as a bully) committed attempted suicide because of the backlash she received from Garam's defenders for "revealing" that Garam is a "bully".
@@hazelpark9190 no one died because of Garam. Oh God….
@@hazelpark9190 wtf? Where did u get these FAKE NEWS?! 💀😭
@@hazelpark9190 pov: you're still trying to justify hating, and cyberbullying garam by making up more bullshit
Sakura cheering her on is so sweet
She really was so happy that she achieved her big dream. She worked so hard. And then, a fan called her name. She was so happy. And all this just to be taken away from her. My poor girl does not deserve this. She worked so hard, is so talented, so beautiful. #justiceforgaram
OT6 forever in our hearts 🩵😭
I love the way she smiled it makes my day now no one can…
Actually I really hated Garam when the news exploded. Everyone around me talked about her and her scandal too. But when she tried to say the truth for herself, I realized that she was just a kid at that time. She was like 11 or 12 and tried to protect her friend. If I have a friend who protected me from bullying at primary school I would be appreciated so much. And being punished at 5 level, that is the lowest punishment for students at Korean. That was not so serious as people said.
People hype it so much like it really a bad things. But it just a normal way when we want to defend our friends plus she's only 12 at that time. I really feel bad at her. Lesson i get is to not believe any hype rumor like this again.
Wait a minute? She was only 11 years old? That's the big scandal everyone was screaming about? And I actually thought this shit was serious, this is just pathetic.
@@serenitysubs933 she was in 6th grade at that time so maybe 11 or 12. A Korean friend told me everyone thought her issue was big because of mass media, her company and many unconfirmed rumours.
She was 11 in normal age
I just want to say '' Garam, hopefully you will be alright😢💓 ''
Noted: She still my bias, and I can say what I want.
one of the saddest moment in kpop. you lost your member not long since your debut😢
The fact that she was the only member that caught my eye and suddenly just kicks her out bc of a bully that faked To getting bullied to garam and then hybe found out the truth but still didnt add her again i miss her so much🤧🤧🤧😭
The only member that caught your eye?
You're obviously blind, go visit a doctor.
Her contract with them has been terminated so they can't really bring her back to the group anymore. And why would she anyway?? Since they have already proved that they're incompetent and incapable of protecting her, they don't deserve her at all. Even Korea also don't deserve her since Knetz kept on acting blind despite proofs are already out that she's not a bully. Hope she finds opportunities outside that country and become an international idol
I'm proud to say that I never said/commented anything bad about her & stayed neutral. I'm just so sad for Garam, she trained & worked hard so that she can debut.
we miss you garam…. and we hope that your doing well please never lose your smile. we will support and lovee you forever❤️
I miss her. She's so pretty, very talented and well behave; a very rare gem indeed.
Actually what I'm missing is the real Le Sserafim group; the 6 members. In my heart, the group is already disbanded.
Well behave loool
@@lithreea387 well she is
keep supporting them, yes a member left but at the same time she wasn’t there for too long either, we get the sympathy for her cause it WAS unfair but don’t go saying stuff like “to me they’re disbanded” because you’re just not accepting what’s going on when you should, i believe garam will be ok in the future but keep supporting them as 5 and love them as 5 meanwhile.
Garam is so pretty🎀✨
I really miss her. She was my bias in le sserafim and she really didn’t deserve all the hate she got. She was so sweet and she really could have been one of the most famous members of le sserafim and it really hurts to see that her dreams got crushed in only a span of a few days because of people who were jealous of her after she worked so hard. It’s really not fair. I hope she’s healing and that she is happy. I will always support her. Kim garam❤❤❤
I feel bad for her. I’m not a fan of the group so I was late in this issue. After researching and read a lot about this, I felt so disgusted by the disgusting fans.
Take care always Garam, you’ll shine wherever you are! Hold on and your time will come. ♥️
I dont wanna compare idols. But this situation reminded me so much of what happened with Soojin. I hope I can see Garam shine again... She deserved so much better.
She is so beautiful😍😍 I love her so much
This breaks my heart😢💔 Poor girl received so much hate for what??
I'll never forgive those people who falsely accused her.💔
will never forget
I will never forget Garam, she was my bias and I feel bad, I always miss her but I know that it's over and there's no turning back... I hope she debuts later. my princess garami 😭🩷
That reaction was so genuine you can literally see how her eyes lighted up
I hope the internet can feel proud of themselves for bullying a literal teenage girl out of something that she worked hard for. I’m around the same age as her and I remember when people were calling her a bully and boycotting her and whatnot I thought, “But she’s so young and when we’re young we don’t usually think about things this seriously. She might not even be a bully but sadly people lack critical thinking skills and are always ready to jump on bandwagon hating.” She wasn’t even a bully in the end smh her voice was the best in lesserafim along with Yunjin and ugh I wish she could still be living her dream. I’m sure it wasn’t just handed to her, she must’ve worked hard for it but people in this world are quick to shame others and never look at themselves and think about their actions in the critical way that they should. Remember guys, in this world nothing is how it seems, in this internet age it is so easy to manipulate people pls always keep a critical and informed view on things and don’t do things just to feed your own ego and just to feel morally righteous. Your trivial actions may ruin another person’s life.
she could be easily a new it girl, she has that natural and feminine beauty that korean loves
She is innocent😢
I want her back to the group😢😢
Dude she was my bias 😭😭😭😭
She was genuinely excited someone recognized her
What happened to her is literally like the song "I did nothing at all". Netizens crushed her dream for which she worked so hard. She deserved to be in the group. Hybe didn't back her up and just used her to bring the group more popularity. Garam seems like a very kind person. The writings on her desk when she went back to school after getting kicked out were so cruel. I hope she comes back in the industry. We all will always wait for Garam
She deserves better❤
Garam was my bias but since she left now my bias is Kazuha ❤
People really bashed and ruined a 16 year old girl’s not only reputation but life and yet have the guts to pretend to be sympathetic afterwards is beyond me.
For real 😢
This is the reason why I stan K-POP casually and most of the time on my own. Fandoms are sick as fuck. Place for harboring toxicity in which affects the artists/idols. I hate K-POP fans.
im so grateful to the person who called her name... just a small action can have such an impact
it breaks my heart how genuine that smile was & the music fits her so well, makes me rethink that if she had not been kicked out she probably would’ve made le sserafim way better
I miss her so much :( always hoping that she'll back to le sserafim but it soooo impossible 😞
I don't understand why people always cry after idols are kicked out of their groups while this is their fault if they are ejected.
People are always complaining but they continue to spread hate and it will continue because I have the feeling that they never learn from their mistakes.
(I say people but I'm not putting everyone in this word, only those who have bullied her and have denigrated her without proofs and reasons).
She looks beautiful ❤
I’m so sorry Garam for everything you endured, it wasn’t fair and it shouldn’t have happened. I will forever resent Hybe, netizens, and the bullies who started these rumors for their actions regarding the whole ordeal :/ I only pray they didn’t kill your hopes of fulfilling your dreams. We are waiting for you with open arms if you decide to return 🫶🏻 So much peace to you Angel
Omggg what’s up with you garam fans blaming hybe it’s good they kicked her out do you really did they are finna risk the reputation for ONE PERSON I doubt and her own mother had say in it miss girl was there for 2 weeks
@@Anna_587 why’re you being aggressive 🤨 do you have many friends
@@LUN4321 lol yes I have friends unlike ppl who are crying over a girl they don’t know what so ever 🤷🏾♀️
@@Anna_587 ok well please don’t speak to them like that 🫶🏻
@@LUN4321 who said I talked to my friends like that 😂😂
God she was my favorite before debuting and it was such a shame she’s not in the group anymore
How can fans treat someone like that from the same group they like 😢 fans dont deserve her and she deserves alot 🪐💗 i will always support her she is so nice and cute i love you garam✨
I love her genuine reaction. She resembles yeji for me.
I want another company to recruit her in a girlgroup 😭😭 girl was so talented like i was listening to sour grapes yesterday and was like ahhh man… miss this kid :(
Garam is the type of person that takes care if other but she never gets taken care of she is always trying to help others but when she needs help she doesn't get it i love lesserfim and i miss her so much
i love you garam you wer one of my favarits love you garam
Not really a fan of lesserafim cuz I mostly listen to boy group songs. But glad to hear she was actually defending her friend from getting bullied. She did verbally fought the bullies with her friends, but that’s cuz the “supposed victim” (actually a bully) posted an INAPPROPRIATE PICTURE OF HER FRIEND.
One day, karma’s gonna get that “victim”.
This made me smile and sad 😢
She was my bias in lesserafim but now is KAZUHA😢😢
Same
Nobody defended her. And even when someone tried to prove her innocence NO ONE listened. I still remember how fans gave her silent treatment when they were performing when she wasn't even proven guilty. Nobody defended her and now that she's proven innocent everyone is sympathizing her