For me it's the opposite, I feel like fearless has this mysterious vibe that Yujin has. But otherwise, you're totally right! Sometimes, I have to remind myself that she's not in le sserafim
@@idontknowwhatnametoput8748yessss I also agree with you. Yujin would kill fearless. Fearless gives such “supermodel” vibes to me if that makes sense. And yujin exudes super model with her gorgeous visuals and tall height. I think she would eat the fearless concept!
As someone who has been a fan of Yujin since produce 48, I honestly can’t see it. Definitely not antifragile, maybe fearless? I’ve never visioned her in that kind of style or concept before even though they had done something somewhat similar in IZONE (rumor?ayaya?sequence?). However, I can see yujin in songs like blue flame and impurities so i guess?
@@f.w.2473 I also watched produce so definitely see where you’re coming from, but tbh I feel like Yujin has grown so much as an artist from produce. I feel like there’s no doubt in my mind that she couldn’t pull off these concepts. But you are so right about impurities and blue flame. Those would be her era!!🤩🤩
Yujin fits IVE perfectly with her elegance but my heart aches when I think of the what-if, like Yujin would do so well in Le Sserafim it pains me that she's not in fact with them.
xiaoting would do sooooo well in aespa or gidle imo she have such a cube artist vibe but imagine xiaoting and ningning in a stage together, stage presence explosion.
NOT AESPA their stage presence is not up to par with her. I want her in lesserafim But here I my dilemma. she would eat with lesserafim cuz they have the same stage presence level and shes tall but I don't want lesserafim as 6 cuz then someone is gonna be the shadow in the choreo. so I want her and yujin to be in lesserafim together to be 7 but then that means sakura and eunchae get less lines cuz I know they arent gonna take them away from chaewon and yunjin. so I don't want bad line distribution. I wish they would be like billie. like even enough or like XG who is pretty decently even . or like stayc where each member gets designated parts and stand out.
I can picture her dancing Black Mamba, but also Antrifragle. So, I agree with her saying she would suit Aespa but I also thought on Le Seraffime. But then she mentioned Yujin in Le Seraffime and I think that makes more sense... I think both Xiaoting and Yujin would do great as Le Seraffim memberss :)
yall hear me out, doyeon from weki meki would fit in SO well in lesserafim, cmon. She fits their supermodel, chic badass concept SO WELL, like i can see her in the center of the fearless choreo biuhebjsdvf
I think Kaeun from After School is also another perfect fit. She even was with Yunjin, Chaewon and Sakura in produce 48 and was originally gonna debut with IZ*ONE if it was not for the rigging.
jeongin in txt is a genius decision ngl. i've never thought of it but now i can imagine how txt's concept would open a whole new side of jeongin. they need to feature him in a song and a mv asap
omg, something i have firmly believed in for so long now is that liz from ive would be PERFECT in billlie. i love billlie's current lineup and i love ive's current lineup, and i also think that liz does suit ive's elegant and classy concept. but i also think she would really excel in the expressive and variegated concepts that billlie does. billlie's concepts also have a lot of power and energy behind them and i think liz would be amazing at executing that based on what we see from her in ive, and her skills are also on par with the other billlie members!
i thought about it for a couple minutes and i ABSOLUTELY see this!! i feel like her vocals even are really similar to the billlie members. i'm very much on board with this
Actually i think that Eunchae of le sserafim would also fit in newjeans like EVERYTHING is perfect like the concept, age, visual, vocal, dance like ugh she would just be so amazing in newjeans
Eunchae kinda reminds me of Yeri or Red Velvet, they look so different from the entire groups visual. Eunchae in New Jeans and Yeri in Nmixx would have been a better fit both visually and vocally
omg wait the I.N TXT one is actually sooooo genius!!! it's too accurate. Xiaoting would've been perfect in Aespa 😭 and same with Yujin in Le Sserafim. Like Imagine Fearless Yujin!? I'd be dead. I love her in ive, but I definitely feel like she's suited more for Le Sserafim tbh. Her charisma is just so strong and it would've matched them perfectly. Also Kyujin dancing to Hype Boy SHE ATE THAT. I loved the video!!! Looking forward to more of your content :)
Never have I thought about Jeongin being in a different group but now that you said it I can totally understand where you are coming from with this! Like I need him to cover a TXT song now!! hahah
@@serikeu I also think IN's humor would fit so well with txt (I can already see him and gyu irritating the hell out of yeonjun lol) and could you imagine him singing sugar rush ride?? Im levitating.
I agree with all but maybe kyujin is a bit too much for newjeans. Ik she has the age, visuals and all, but she's more of a rapper and strong dancer compared to newjeans . like I feel eunchae would probably work better in newjeans, but that's my opinion.
@@soobins.bread143 I don't think so just because she would be an already established famous idol who'd been known as 'An Yujin' for the whole of her career whereas yunjin was just a trainee
I agree with the Yujin one SO MUCH but you know Starship was never going to let her go. HYBE only got Chaewon bc Woolim had no clue what to do with her
starship have been preparing to REALLY push and support wonyoung and yujin's careers since 2018 so you're right, i don't think any other company could have swayed her lol. she's shaping up to be her own brand practically
I agree with all the other ones except Yujin and Kyujin. Let me try to explain. Yujin is a sensual performer and she meshes so well with IVE that it's kind of crazy to me. She also covered Cheer Up during MAMA and I think that the more mature Twice concept would fit her much better than Le Sserafim's girl crush concept right now. Just because she is an amazing dancer and has great stage presence doesn't mean that she will be able to shine in Le Sseraphim. Garam was actually the member in Le Sseraphim that brought out that sort of feminine gentleness to the group, however her aura was definitely more girly and Yujin' is more mature and elegant, so I actually think it would clash with Yunjin's and Kazuha's tomboyish energies too much. Kyujin exudes charisma and power. I think that the teen crush/cute concept would be too limiting for her. Imo if you put her in a line up with all the Newjeans girls, she will outshine them all (and I mean that in the most respectful way possible). There was even a whole discourse on Twitter about how she brought so much more energy to the Hype Boy choreography. She is a power house and Newjeans have a much more laid back sound and style, so I feel like she would have to suppress a lot of her potential. She could do well in Billie or Itzy. And those are my two cents on the topic haha.
i actually agree with every point you made! i did consider all of this while i was making this list but i took a more self-indulgent approach with yujin and kyujin instead of the most logical one lol. if i was granted some godly power to actually change member lineups i would likely do things differently
agree w kyujin, she's so powerful in her dancing that a teen fresh concept doesn't seem to suit her, she could def be in itzy if not for her age and I get billlie esp cuz of nmixx's concept alrdy being a bit quirky like gingamingayo
7dream is so big in the fandom that sm even started referring to them that way. If Sungchan joined I’d honestly be scared for him bc dreamzens could be very over protective of the current line up, especially bc they’re already been through many changes
Someone once mentioned this in a comment section: Jinsoul of Loona in Dreamcatcher. Her dancing might not be on par with them yet, but her visuals, her tone and her stage presence all suit the group so well!
I rarely meet any Jeongin stans so what you said about him being really first love material is so relatable and true!! I’ve never thought of it before but I think he’d fit really well with TXT!! But skz wouldn’t be the same without their favorite maknae, he balances and adds flavor to skz’s mostly dark/strong voices with the sweetness of his tone imo (same with seungmin) although I might be biased bc skz is my ult group :P You really did him dirty with the height thing tho LMAO
It’s so crazy how I also think Jeongin would fit in so well in TXT or even Monsta X! He’s great in Skz but he has so much potential to do even more! I’m surprised he isn’t one of the more popular members.
I.N in TXT omg I agree soooo much with you!!! I also have such a big crush on him since the beginning and I think he should be as popular as Falix and Hyunjin...
GIRL I LOVE SKZ AND JEONGIN HAS BEEN MY CRUSH FOR YEARS AND I TOTALLY GET HIM BEING IN TXT. HE WOULD SHINE LIKE IDK HOW TO EXPLAIN BUT HIS STYLE OF PERFORMING MATCHES THEIR CHOREOS AND MUSIC SO MUCH LIKE AHH
-Xiaoting in AESPA i never think about that but why not she could fit well with them . but yes i know than vocalist she could maybe struggle to catch the other members . -for Yujin first i was an absolute fans of IZ*ONE to me they look like a dream kpop dream team and now i'am a huge fans of LESSERAFIM and IVE so both group are great like they are now . but if in another world Yujin as join LESSERAFIM of course that could be amazing to be fun lets just interchange YUJIN with EUNCHAE IVE could have all the cute girls with an elegant and dreamy concept with Wonyoung as a leader or Gaeul and Eunchae could fit well with liz , leeseo and rei . and in Lesserafim we can make Yujin leader with Chaewon , Zuha ,Kkura and Yunjin they can stoud out with a very fierce concept .
To be fair most SM vocalists are this good because they get great vocal training, not necessarily bc they were born amazing singers (talking abt lead and sub vocals here, from what I've seen most of their main vocals are naturally talented) so it's not like her weak vocals would be a bother considering they could easily train her
this vid idea is so good! i’m obsessed with xiaoting being in aespa 😭 idk how to explain it but her visuals would fit so well into their kwangya concept
Me too. The way she carries herself so elegantly reminds me of Aespa as a group, plus she could rock their concept also. I just know she would help balance out the visual weight in Aespa soooo well. She could even be Karina’s rival as a second visual or center but that’s just my opinion.
speaking of kep1er, i honestly think hiyyih could be a good fit for stayc. though i’m not a huge stan of either groups (i more so stan kep1er), something about hiyyih with them just makes sense to me! as a txt ult, i think jeongin fits practically perfect with txt! especially with their earlier concepts 😊
Okay but now that you’ve mentioned it, I can definitely see it for everyone. And I definitely understand I.N in TXT. Like the second you said it I was like woah
The way you described Jeongin is exactly how I see him & feel about him so you're not alone. He's my bias & literally my first reason to stan skz. Also, Jeongin is so smilie 😭 like, I barely seen him not smiling & I just know that if he were to perform txt songs like can't you see me or Blue hour he would just look so damn happy performing. ♡
Mine is Jisoo in Red Velvet. I've had dreams about it. She's got the SM visual, the vocals, she's elegant and I will never forgive YG for the missed opportunity. Debuting Jisoo with a concept I think she's never been fully comfortable with is the top 2 most outrageous things YG has ever done.
@@SoggyMuffin007 no but being real, it's not about her vocal technique, it's how her voice in general is just so irritating to listen to, imo. there's smtg abt it that... D:
Jeongin + TXT WOW how have I not thought of that.Hear me out, I love seeing him with stray kids who love him so much, thinking about it, with a group like TXT along with their concepts, style and everything, I.N could be at his full potential. I.N is working really hard and doing amazing where he is right now, but him with TXT would put him at his peak in my opinion.
I can somehow see jeongin sharing the same vibe with txt but i actually think he's only able to develop his vocals and song writing ability this much because he is in skz. I love txt but the creative freedom they get in skz is insaneeee. Also, he wouldn't be maknae on top if he wasn't the maknae hahaha.
I agree with you on this so much. Like I wish he covers one of txt's songs because they share a similar vibe but there are so many things about him that make him shine and become more experienced in skz and although he matches both vibes I love him too much in skz to dwell on the potential he could have in any other group.
i think she has a slightly different vibe from the le sserafim members themselves but the thought of xiaoting doing a high class runway concept or their choreographies... CRAZY
I disagree with last one kyujin and new jeans? kyujin will shine something like more energetic and noisy songs I personally think she is member that fits most nmixx
Ohh yeah, i agree with you. For me, in nmixx, bae would suit newjeans more. Like vocally, and her with long hair and 90s fashion would look good in newjeans
@@irianna8232 I actually think Sullyoon would fit new jeans the most she has powerful but Soft vocals which would give a difference and a fresh youthful appearance
Yeonjun (txt) in ateez! When i was first introduced to ateez i was like, i feel like yeonjun could fit in with this concept really well and the dance focus as well
I totally get where you are coming from with Jeongin and you described his whole aura so well but I can't see him in any group other than skz- but I can 100% see how he would fit in txt
omg the xiaoting one!! i have been disappointed in her criminal underuse basically since the beginning of kepler and now that you mention it the xiaoting-aespa combo would totally slap. i need it to happen now
- Yujin in Le Sserafim would be fitting well I think, but I will be confused about the names, YUNJIN and YUJIN👁️👄👁️ - Kyujin in New Jeans, OMG yes ofc - I.N‘ Visuals will fit very well in TxT and his Talent too, this Group will be more chaotic with him too! - Xiaoting in Aespa, W O W yessss the Visuals, the talent, yess. Only the Vocals are not that high as the other members. But you can improve litteraly everything
I loooveee the xiaoting idea, but also what lots of people don’t know is that xiaoting actually has main vocal potential, I saw a video of her hitting a Bb5, I’ll drop the link too
I take your Sungchan suggestion and raise you Shotaro. I on God think Mark should have stayed out of NCT Dream because after he left they had no where to go but up. It also allowed members like Jeno to take the front in the rap parts. Jeno and Jaemin also got to write more. I think it was a large mishandling on SM's part. However, I do 1000% agree with you on giving Sungchan acting roles. He is an actor through and through.
I second this. That was the initial idea with NCT right, feels like Dream members was supposed to keep renewing and adding younger members as a group concept. But it kinda backfires because the original members bond really well and we kinda really watch them grew from pre teen together. Mark and Haechan is really tired tbh it’s too much with 127 and the yearly projects and kinda awkward when Dream promote minus the 2 most of the time outside music shows and yt content.
Especially with Haechan's recent health issues, him and Mark are overworked. Plus they almost never show up to Dream's events if if conflicts with 127's schedule. SM should've thought about logistics more
Um.. sorry but real nctzens know how close 7Dream are and how happy the members are when Haechan and Mark are with Dream. They literally cried when Mark have to “leave” the group and now when he is officially back they all are so happy bcuz they love each other so much since they literally grow up together.
@@dara_stoyanova2037 Ok no one thinks they should leave "just because". They are VERY overworked to the point of hospitalization and if you were a "real nctzen" you wouldn't act so selfishly and choose to ignore the clear conflicts with being in 2 fixed groups.
I love IVE, but I honestly think they all would've been better in different groups. like HEAR ME OUT Yujin: Lesserafim. She fits the fierce vibe, and she's also very elegant. Her voice is super powerful and her tone would fit perfectly with their music, she gives a similar vibe to Yunjin, and she's an amazing dancer. Liz: StayC. She's so damn adorable and her voice would work so nice with the other members. Like if her and J harmonized it would be SO BEAUTIFULLLL. Leeseo: New Jeans. When I saw her on the collab stage, it honestly looked like she was having such a good time, and I think her look, age, and voice would blend nicely together with the rest of the group. They would literally have a a perfectly ascending age range (14-15-16-17-18) lol. I honestly don't like her vibe that much when she's around the other IVE members, but when I saw her performing with Minji and Hyein in the Love like Oxygen cover I was literally thinking "Leeseo would fit right in with New Jeans". Wonyoung: I honestly think Wonyoung fits well in IVE, but since in this universe there would be no IVE, I'd say although she is not S tier in everything, I think she'd do well as a soloist because of her reputation and beauty. And although her voice isn't OMG SO GOOD SUPER AMAZING STUNNING, I still personally really love her voice and I think she could make catchy songs. If I were to put her in a group though, I'd say maybe Itzy, Aespa, or G-Idle because I think she'd look good with them. Rei: After seeing the collab stage, I think Rei would be so cute with Kep1er only because she seemed so freaking adorable when she was dancing. Nmixx I think would be good as well because I think she could fit their vibe. Gaeul: No hate to Gaeul because she actually sings some of my fav parts in some of IVE's songs, but I personally don't care for her vocals. I think she's an amazing dancer though so I'd say she'd be good with ITZY, Nmixx or Lesserafim because they can all dance pretty good and I think she'd be more appealing with a fiercer concept.
no, but I got you for jeongin!! I have had that inkling for awhile, but I haven't been quite able to pinpoint it properly until you did 😭☺️, so thank you for doing so!! jeongin is absolutely skz's maknae on top and forever baby, but him and his characteristics just checked out txt's boxes very well, it's a good fit in image and concept. especially his vocals (it suits the refreshing and more vocally oriented tones of txt's music) and that boy-next-door or first love kind of vibes that the members give off.
You gotta believe me when I say *Yujin and Yunjin gives similar vibes* Fierce but in an elegant way Ps girl I saw your first and only video and gonna subscribe now you're so my type
If the timeline and debuts aligned I would have loved to see Xioting in Lsf. I mean apart from just the aesthetics of it all- a ballerina, a ballroom dancer and an opera trained singer in one group? Cmon
Wow! I just discovered your channel and I really like the way you approached everything!! I think you could definitely do well as a k-tuber if continue like this! I can't wait for your next video! Fighting!!
They would, but i think eunchae is best in lesserafim. She really adds that cuteness to the group and lesserafim would be a lot more empty without her (not saying the other members are bad i just think the group wouldn’t be AS perfect without her)
New comment because I hadn’t finished the video yet before 😂 - I really find your assessment of Kyujin being in New Jeans *fascinating*. She absolutely would fit right in with the aesthetic and vibe Ador is marketing NWJNS with, but a part of me feels a little off with her placement there. It’s mainly because of the persona and theme NMIXX has already introduced her with. All these idols are coached pre-debut to fit the role and theme their group is planned for, so if she had debuted in New Jeans I’m sure I wouldn’t have thought twice. She would fit no problem; but, because JYP has put so much time and resources in promoting her as a monster rookie with so many different ranges, skills, and talents seeing her in New Jeans feels limiting in my mind. All the girls in New Jeans are extremely talented, don’t get me wrong, but the way they’re being marketed is a lot softer, while being very vocal and aesthetic focused (at least for now). Whereas, no matter how messy NMIXX’s comeback and concepts may be, the edginess of their genre and marketing seems like it allows for Kyujin to have more opportunities to shine individually. Hopefully one day she and some of the New Jeans girls do a collab or a TikTok or something. That would make my day. Either way, I really loved your take on all these idols and where they could also shine. Keep up the great work. Such a fun watch!
I haven’t watched the video but as a casual, Chaeyoung needs to do her own thing alongside Twice or be in a group like Lesserafim or G-Idle. That girl has powerful talent in abundance.
Kyujin is the best KPOP star ever imo. Her energy is unmatched. I think she fits in with NMIXX very well though because that group has a lot of different sounding vocalists, so when she sings her voice really shines.
As a Jeongin stan yes. Just yes. I imagined the same thing, so you are not alone with that thought. Jeongin would fit so much in txt concepts. Now i wanna hear him covering sugar rush ride fr or crown
Also sullyoon from nmixx also fit in IVE I mean she got very feminine, girly and cute vibes so imo she would be perfectly fited in IVE ,her voice is also sounds something just like IVE songs
Gaeul from IVE in literally any other group. From day one of Ives debut, I completely threw my Wiz*one brain out the window when I saw and heard Gaeul, she’s genuinely really talented with dance and her vocal tone is so unique. I hate to say it but I don’t think Gaeul fits Ives concept either, and in honesty, I have no clue what concept she’d go well with, but I’m just waiting for Starship to give her a chance with a dance break or more than one line in a song(where she sings).
Ahhhhhh when you say sungchan I felt like butterflies in my stomach I love him sooooooo much and he is so talented but SM don’t deserve him I feel so sorry for him cuz he is my fav idol ever 😭😭😭🫂
I'm so frustrated with SM's lack of ability to actually place Sungchan and Shotaro in a group already, like damn, they debuted for this? 💀 I sometimes even forget that they are in NCT bc we don't see them outside their reality shows
I think this is quite unpopular but I feel Yuna will fit Ive. Her visuals and height match that of Ive's and I feel she can absolutely be the main dancer and maybe main rapper along with Rei or lead rapper. There was a stage a few years ago where Yuna was dancing on stage along with other maknaes including Wonyoung (when she was still in iz*one), and they were doing an elegant concept and I feel Yuna was absolutely killing it. Don't get me wrong, Yuna definitely suits Itzy's image, she is incredibly versatile and I feel like she can do any concept
no but like, you are so right about i.n in txt, like- wow. he would fit so so so well in all their songs!!! I can specially see him in runaway and lovesong (frost and puma too ahhhhhhhhh)
other than sungchan in dream this is so genius and correct like xiaoting in aespa? yes please the problem with sungchan in dream is that a, dream have a kind of bond that adding someone to it would feel a bit off even though he's close with them. also the thought of sung taro not being together in a unit pains me a bit so I could just be biased
I really like your videos! Your editing style, your voice, your tempo and how nice you are. For your picks, I think all your girls are spot on, really wanna see the Kepler girl in aespa styling now. I have never considered IN in TXT, but I think I see it. He's a little rascal, and TXT is full of rascals with that very high teasing/loving energy. I think he'd work well with Soobin's leader style, and really enjoy having a makane to care for. He's got the dancing skills and the hard working nature, and he has a distinct vocal color that would fit well. He's on the short side though, and while he looks amazing his visuals are pretty different from TXT. Nothing styling can't cover, but I think it would be noticable since everyone in TXT, except for Yeonjun, has the same visual charcteristics. I'd say the look of the group standing together is the only thing holding him back, but as I was writing that I realize he would absolutely RULE in TXT styling. Imagine him in the Loser Lover era? In Blue Hour? In SUGAR RUSH RIDE?!! Especially the Studio Choom outfits, god. Save IN from Stray Kids leather astethics, put him in TXT!
I.N. having a matching element with TxT is understandable! I get it all, trust me! I see those IG posts and I truly understand. At the same time, you've to understand that...that is not how all groups are formed. Especially SKZ, Chan formed the group much like RM formed BTS (no comparison) and when that happens its always more about the heart of the group and less about logic, analytics or technicality. The real question is, would I.N. be better in txt or in skz, and you've to think about I.N. the person not just the artist, which i think is lacking in this analysis, and its very obvious, its SKZ...No one can deny that for things like - his energy or vibe or his element! They are a family not a company-created group, he's their "maknae on top". And they are perfect the way they are. There is a reason why it's a four leaf clover!
Xiaoting would fit right into Aespa in my opinion!!! The way she carries herself so elegantly reminds me of Aespa as a group, plus she could rock their concept also. I just know that she would help balance out the visual weight in Aespa soooo well. She could even become Karina’s rival as a second visual or center but that’s just my personal thoughts. Vocally, it’s not much of an issue since she could easily become a sub rapper or a lead dancer, maybe even compete to become the face of the group. Heck, maybe her and Karina could release a duo project like Seulgi and Irene did, I just know the whole industry would go nuts over that. The power Aespa would hold if SM just took her in, gosh I can’t help but think about it lol 😭👏
I actually never thought about this but I LOVE your suggestions and explanations (yujin and xiaoting especially) How do I stop to unsee this now every time I see these idols 😭
ok so since im a kep1ian imma put the girls into other groups i could see them in yujin - fromis_9 (im a casual fan, but i think their quirky sound/look would fit yujin rlly well) xiaoting - le sserafim or ive (if ive had an older group of girls, i think xiaoting would fit in rlly well & everybody & their mamas already talked abt her being in lessera) mashiro - (g)-idle or fromis_9 chaehyun - gwsn or stayc (she would fit perfectly in an elegant group, but she also has this down to earth vibe that would fit stayc rlly well) dayeon - everglow or nmixx hikaru - billlie bahiyyih - stayc youngeun - loona or billlie yeseo - csr (she fits the elegant concept rlly well +she’s an 05 liner)
okay so like when i first heard of jeongin in txt it literally made my brain twist- it was such a weird idea to fathom, BUT I GET UR POINT- he has that cute yet boyfie attractive vibe about him that literally ALL of the txt boys have, and I can see him in their concepts. I now need jeongin to cover a txt song asap-
Love how you truly put in thought for everyone’s suggestions in the comments and your own opinions from the video are well justified too- also side note your voice is so relaxing you could be talking about worms (the boring kind) and I’d listen
I.N. SO TRUEEE. Never thought of it but it couldn’t be more accurate. If chosing between new jeans and NMIXX, Kyujin would suit NMIXX more. But i get where your coming from. Love THIS video!
I've never thought about this topic before but I could totally see the vision with each one. I wasn't very convinced with jeongin and kyujin at first but after you elaborated in it I kinda got it. I totally would like a part two of this
The second I saw the teasers for le sserafim I immediately thought Loona's Yves would fit perfectly! Like the whole chic badass vibe is totally her thing :)
tbh I agree with basically each opinion (especially loved the idea of xiaoting in aespa, she would fit SO WELL) except for shotaro in dream. even though he has the skills and the charisma, I don't think he would fit with dream's backstory. the members started training together when they were kids and have a really strong bond from overcoming so many hardships together. shotaro would just look weird in the whole picture and he would be so much better off in an unit of his own
i actually started the jeongin train of thought because i thought of the possibility of him in enhypen! enhypen would make SO much sense but i decided that i liked the idea of txt better
the song in the intro is signs by iiso!
pls make a part 2 i loved this omgg
ive been streaming tf outta this song im so excited to see another fan of it omg!!!!
@@katieundercover same
Finally i found someone else :D!!!!
The intro song is IMMACULATE ^__^
i can definitely see yujin having strong lesserafim vibes. i didnt see it much in fearless but whew the vibes are STRONG in antifragile
For me it's the opposite, I feel like fearless has this mysterious vibe that Yujin has. But otherwise, you're totally right! Sometimes, I have to remind myself that she's not in le sserafim
@@idontknowwhatnametoput8748yessss I also agree with you. Yujin would kill fearless. Fearless gives such “supermodel” vibes to me if that makes sense. And yujin exudes super model with her gorgeous visuals and tall height. I think she would eat the fearless concept!
As someone who has been a fan of Yujin since produce 48, I honestly can’t see it. Definitely not antifragile, maybe fearless? I’ve never visioned her in that kind of style or concept before even though they had done something somewhat similar in IZONE (rumor?ayaya?sequence?). However, I can see yujin in songs like blue flame and impurities so i guess?
@@f.w.2473 I also watched produce so definitely see where you’re coming from, but tbh I feel like Yujin has grown so much as an artist from produce. I feel like there’s no doubt in my mind that she couldn’t pull off these concepts. But you are so right about impurities and blue flame. Those would be her era!!🤩🤩
yujin doing the fearless stage at mama gave so much le sserafim vibes with her whole attitude and presence
Yujin fits Lesserafim so well it's not even funny
Great, now we have Yu(n)Jin's
@@blacktosca3201 And they both have deep voice 😂
Yujin fits IVE perfectly with her elegance but my heart aches when I think of the what-if, like Yujin would do so well in Le Sserafim it pains me that she's not in fact with them.
xiaoting would do sooooo well in aespa or gidle imo she have such a cube artist vibe but imagine xiaoting and ningning in a stage together, stage presence explosion.
She does have cube vibes, but let's not subject this poor girl to go from a shitty company to an even shittier one 😭
aespa would definitely benefit from having another member that is like xiaoting
NOT AESPA their stage presence is not up to par with her. I want her in lesserafim
But here I my dilemma. she would eat with lesserafim cuz they have the same stage presence level and shes tall but I don't want lesserafim as 6 cuz then someone is gonna be the shadow in the choreo. so I want her and yujin to be in lesserafim together to be 7 but then that means sakura and eunchae get less lines cuz I know they arent gonna take them away from chaewon and yunjin. so I don't want bad line distribution. I wish they would be like billie. like even enough or like XG who is pretty decently even . or like stayc where each member gets designated parts and stand out.
I can picture her dancing Black Mamba, but also Antrifragle. So, I agree with her saying she would suit Aespa but I also thought on Le Seraffime. But then she mentioned Yujin in Le Seraffime and I think that makes more sense... I think both Xiaoting and Yujin would do great as Le Seraffim memberss :)
@@lalyasmr336 she would slay fearless
yall hear me out, doyeon from weki meki would fit in SO well in lesserafim, cmon. She fits their supermodel, chic badass concept SO WELL, like i can see her in the center of the fearless choreo biuhebjsdvf
OH MY GOD...
OMG THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT
ME TOOO
OHMYGOSH YESSSSS
I think Kaeun from After School is also another perfect fit. She even was with Yunjin, Chaewon and Sakura in produce 48 and was originally gonna debut with IZ*ONE if it was not for the rigging.
jeongin in txt is a genius decision ngl. i've never thought of it but now i can imagine how txt's concept would open a whole new side of jeongin. they need to feature him in a song and a mv asap
yes i think so too!
That’s prolly never gonna happen
@@DrillOnABeat a woman is allowed to dreams😔
after this video I'm literally going to spend the whole week imagining how amazing he would look in 'run away' concept 🥺
I would love this too but I can imagine how bad the fan wars gonna be 🙄
omg, something i have firmly believed in for so long now is that liz from ive would be PERFECT in billlie. i love billlie's current lineup and i love ive's current lineup, and i also think that liz does suit ive's elegant and classy concept. but i also think she would really excel in the expressive and variegated concepts that billlie does. billlie's concepts also have a lot of power and energy behind them and i think liz would be amazing at executing that based on what we see from her in ive, and her skills are also on par with the other billlie members!
i thought about it for a couple minutes and i ABSOLUTELY see this!! i feel like her vocals even are really similar to the billlie members. i'm very much on board with this
she would be appreciated there.
i think she will be treated like a real member in another group at least
Omg she would eat “Ring x Ring” with her vocals i want to see her cover
@@ploryz they did not say she didnt suit ive tho
Actually i think that Eunchae of le sserafim would also fit in newjeans like EVERYTHING is perfect like the concept, age, visual, vocal, dance like ugh she would just be so amazing in newjeans
Eunchae, Kyujin, and Jiwoo. They fits so well.
fr
Eunchae kinda reminds me of Yeri or Red Velvet, they look so different from the entire groups visual.
Eunchae in New Jeans and Yeri in Nmixx would have been a better fit both visually and vocally
@@KpopUnniesUwU nah only eunchae & kyujin
@@KpopUnniesUwU arent Kyujin and Jiwoo too big for New Jeans? lol
omg wait the I.N TXT one is actually sooooo genius!!! it's too accurate. Xiaoting would've been perfect in Aespa 😭 and same with Yujin in Le Sserafim. Like Imagine Fearless Yujin!? I'd be dead. I love her in ive, but I definitely feel like she's suited more for Le Sserafim tbh. Her charisma is just so strong and it would've matched them perfectly. Also Kyujin dancing to Hype Boy SHE ATE THAT. I loved the video!!! Looking forward to more of your content :)
thank you!! :)
@@serikeu ofc!! :)
I love JEONGIN so much and also spend waaaayyy too much time thinking about him. So i completely understand ❤
Never have I thought about Jeongin being in a different group
but now that you said it I can totally understand where you are coming from with this! Like I need him to cover a TXT song now!! hahah
i'm so glad you get it 😭 i need to see him do run away and good boy gone bad desperately
During the jeongin part of the video all I was doing was imagining him performing blue hour or crown!
@@Alex0196 oh man i need to see that so bad
@@Alex0196 he would look so good in the blue hour styling too 🥲
@@serikeu I also think IN's humor would fit so well with txt (I can already see him and gyu irritating the hell out of yeonjun lol) and could you imagine him singing sugar rush ride?? Im levitating.
I agree with all but maybe kyujin is a bit too much for newjeans. Ik she has the age, visuals and all, but she's more of a rapper and strong dancer compared to newjeans . like I feel eunchae would probably work better in newjeans, but that's my opinion.
i definitely see where you're coming from. eunchae would be sooo adorable in newjeans, besides kyujin i also thought she would be such a great fit
Only mark against Yujin is that being in a group with Yunjin would be too confusing.
Although it would be funny, so maybe it's actually another plus
i thought about that and they're the same height and look kind of similar too lol 😭 but we'll work with it!
Yunjin would have to become Jennifer permanently
they could always call Yunjin Jennifer or use a stage name for her
@@jihancafe or give yujin a stage name
@@soobins.bread143 I don't think so just because she would be an already established famous idol who'd been known as 'An Yujin' for the whole of her career whereas yunjin was just a trainee
I agree with the Yujin one SO MUCH but you know Starship was never going to let her go. HYBE only got Chaewon bc Woolim had no clue what to do with her
starship have been preparing to REALLY push and support wonyoung and yujin's careers since 2018 so you're right, i don't think any other company could have swayed her lol. she's shaping up to be her own brand practically
I agree with all the other ones except Yujin and Kyujin. Let me try to explain.
Yujin is a sensual performer and she meshes so well with IVE that it's kind of crazy to me. She also covered Cheer Up during MAMA and I think that the more mature Twice concept would fit her much better than Le Sserafim's girl crush concept right now. Just because she is an amazing dancer and has great stage presence doesn't mean that she will be able to shine in Le Sseraphim. Garam was actually the member in Le Sseraphim that brought out that sort of feminine gentleness to the group, however her aura was definitely more girly and Yujin' is more mature and elegant, so I actually think it would clash with Yunjin's and Kazuha's tomboyish energies too much.
Kyujin exudes charisma and power. I think that the teen crush/cute concept would be too limiting for her. Imo if you put her in a line up with all the Newjeans girls, she will outshine them all (and I mean that in the most respectful way possible). There was even a whole discourse on Twitter about how she brought so much more energy to the Hype Boy choreography. She is a power house and Newjeans have a much more laid back sound and style, so I feel like she would have to suppress a lot of her potential. She could do well in Billie or Itzy.
And those are my two cents on the topic haha.
i actually agree with every point you made! i did consider all of this while i was making this list but i took a more self-indulgent approach with yujin and kyujin instead of the most logical one lol. if i was granted some godly power to actually change member lineups i would likely do things differently
@@serikeu yeah, it's all for fun in the end ♥️
agree w kyujin, she's so powerful in her dancing that a teen fresh concept doesn't seem to suit her, she could def be in itzy if not for her age and I get billlie esp cuz of nmixx's concept alrdy being a bit quirky like gingamingayo
OMG BILLLIE.. low key i want her to be there
I mean Yujin would bring the balance of Lesserafims personalities
7dream is so big in the fandom that sm even started referring to them that way. If Sungchan joined I’d honestly be scared for him bc dreamzens could be very over protective of the current line up, especially bc they’re already been through many changes
this + adding another rapper to the line-up doesn’t really make sense.
Me personally I need yeojin to redebut BADDD
yeojin 💔💔 we need to pull some strings for her
Someone once mentioned this in a comment section: Jinsoul of Loona in Dreamcatcher. Her dancing might not be on par with them yet, but her visuals, her tone and her stage presence all suit the group so well!
i agree! she reminds me of Jiu a bit heh
Kim Lip too idk why i get that vibe
But am I only one thinks that her voice just to claming and beautiful?
are you talking about me??? thank you so much 😭❤
@@serikeu of course
Fr it’s so calming and even though she wasn’t talking quietly it was like asmr and I had a bunch of tingles listening to her talk
I rarely meet any Jeongin stans so what you said about him being really first love material is so relatable and true!! I’ve never thought of it before but I think he’d fit really well with TXT!! But skz wouldn’t be the same without their favorite maknae, he balances and adds flavor to skz’s mostly dark/strong voices with the sweetness of his tone imo (same with seungmin) although I might be biased bc skz is my ult group :P You really did him dirty with the height thing tho LMAO
It’s so crazy how I also think Jeongin would fit in so well in TXT or even Monsta X! He’s great in Skz but he has so much potential to do even more! I’m surprised he isn’t one of the more popular members.
I.N in TXT omg I agree soooo much with you!!! I also have such a big crush on him since the beginning and I think he should be as popular as Falix and Hyunjin...
OMGGG CAN YOU IMAGINE IN ANOTHER UNIVERSE YUJIN AND XIAOTING DEBUTING IN AESPA AND LE SSERAFIM
GIRL I LOVE SKZ AND JEONGIN HAS BEEN MY CRUSH FOR YEARS AND I TOTALLY GET HIM BEING IN TXT. HE WOULD SHINE LIKE IDK HOW TO EXPLAIN BUT HIS STYLE OF PERFORMING MATCHES THEIR CHOREOS AND MUSIC SO MUCH LIKE AHH
-Xiaoting in AESPA i never think about that but why not she could fit well with them . but yes i know than vocalist she could maybe struggle to catch the other members .
-for Yujin first i was an absolute fans of IZ*ONE to me they look like a dream kpop dream team and now i'am a huge fans of LESSERAFIM and IVE so both group are great like they are now . but if in another world Yujin as join LESSERAFIM of course that could be amazing to be fun lets just interchange YUJIN with EUNCHAE IVE could have all the cute girls with an elegant and dreamy concept with Wonyoung as a leader or Gaeul and Eunchae could fit well with liz , leeseo and rei . and in Lesserafim we can make Yujin leader with Chaewon , Zuha ,Kkura and Yunjin they can stoud out with a very fierce concept .
i've never thought about eunchae in ive but i could DEFINITELY see that!
@@serikeu NO WAY
@@ಠಿ_ಠ-ತ7ಭ what does that mean ???
Please no. Just no.
To be fair most SM vocalists are this good because they get great vocal training, not necessarily bc they were born amazing singers (talking abt lead and sub vocals here, from what I've seen most of their main vocals are naturally talented) so it's not like her weak vocals would be a bother considering they could easily train her
this vid idea is so good! i’m obsessed with xiaoting being in aespa 😭 idk how to explain it but her visuals would fit so well into their kwangya concept
Me too. The way she carries herself so elegantly reminds me of Aespa as a group, plus she could rock their concept also. I just know she would help balance out the visual weight in Aespa soooo well. She could even be Karina’s rival as a second visual or center but that’s just my opinion.
another idol i think can join new jeans is Eunchae! idk why but she has those young type visuals that goes well with the other members
speaking of kep1er, i honestly think hiyyih could be a good fit for stayc. though i’m not a huge stan of either groups (i more so stan kep1er), something about hiyyih with them just makes sense to me! as a txt ult, i think jeongin fits practically perfect with txt! especially with their earlier concepts 😊
i think about hiyyih in stayc a lot. A WHOLE LOT. she would slay so bad. her voice, the color of her personality, her beauty, everything.
Okay but now that you’ve mentioned it, I can definitely see it for everyone. And I definitely understand I.N in TXT. Like the second you said it I was like woah
The way you described Jeongin is exactly how I see him & feel about him so you're not alone. He's my bias & literally my first reason to stan skz. Also, Jeongin is so smilie 😭 like, I barely seen him not smiling & I just know that if he were to perform txt songs like can't you see me or Blue hour he would just look so damn happy performing. ♡
Mine is Jisoo in Red Velvet. I've had dreams about it. She's got the SM visual, the vocals, she's elegant and I will never forgive YG for the missed opportunity. Debuting Jisoo with a concept I think she's never been fully comfortable with is the top 2 most outrageous things YG has ever done.
Vocals debatable
@@DrillOnABeat they could train her anyways??? If she got the SM vocal training she would become a monster….honestly I see her potential.
@@SoggyMuffin007 no but being real, it's not about her vocal technique, it's how her voice in general is just so irritating to listen to, imo. there's smtg abt it that... D:
@@letsalllovelein i agree so much
@@letsalllovelein Samee i just don't like her voice
Jeongin + TXT WOW how have I not thought of that.Hear me out, I love seeing him with stray kids who love him so much, thinking about it, with a group like TXT along with their concepts, style and everything, I.N could be at his full potential. I.N is working really hard and doing amazing where he is right now, but him with TXT would put him at his peak in my opinion.
i think jeongin is like soooo fitting in TxT like wth
I can somehow see jeongin sharing the same vibe with txt but i actually think he's only able to develop his vocals and song writing ability this much because he is in skz. I love txt but the creative freedom they get in skz is insaneeee. Also, he wouldn't be maknae on top if he wasn't the maknae hahaha.
I agree with you on this so much. Like I wish he covers one of txt's songs because they share a similar vibe but there are so many things about him that make him shine and become more experienced in skz and although he matches both vibes I love him too much in skz to dwell on the potential he could have in any other group.
txt does develop their vocal and song ability as well. and with supervision. personality wise, skz works way better for him.
@@hrtsfrmnsg whoever works with a team of singers knows what part to give which singer. it’s the same with txt.
a part of me is convinved that if xiaoting were to join lesserafim, it would be over for the other 4th gen girlies.
i think she has a slightly different vibe from the le sserafim members themselves but the thought of xiaoting doing a high class runway concept or their choreographies... CRAZY
😱😱😱
I completely agree with you! She gives me Le Sserafim vibes and her talent would definitely match well.
jeongin is literally if cat & dog by txt was a human
YEP
I disagree with last one kyujin and new jeans? kyujin will shine something like more energetic and noisy songs I personally think she is member that fits most nmixx
i do see where you're coming from
Ohh yeah, i agree with you. For me, in nmixx, bae would suit newjeans more. Like vocally, and her with long hair and 90s fashion would look good in newjeans
@@irianna8232 I actually think Sullyoon would fit new jeans the most she has powerful but Soft vocals which would give a difference and a fresh youthful appearance
Yeonjun (txt) in ateez! When i was first introduced to ateez i was like, i feel like yeonjun could fit in with this concept really well and the dance focus as well
OMG yeah, though I feel like Yeonjun could fit in almost every concept fr 😭
I totally get where you are coming from with Jeongin and you described his whole aura so well but I can't see him in any group other than skz- but I can 100% see how he would fit in txt
omg the xiaoting one!! i have been disappointed in her criminal underuse basically since the beginning of kepler and now that you mention it the xiaoting-aespa combo would totally slap. i need it to happen now
Girl the algorithm loves you 😭 I can’t believe this is your first video
i was stuck at like 20 views for a few days i don't know what happened lol 😭
- Yujin in Le Sserafim would be fitting well I think, but I will be confused about the names, YUNJIN and YUJIN👁️👄👁️
- Kyujin in New Jeans, OMG yes ofc
- I.N‘ Visuals will fit very well in TxT and his Talent too, this Group will be more chaotic with him too!
- Xiaoting in Aespa, W O W yessss the Visuals, the talent, yess. Only the Vocals are not that high as the other members. But you can improve litteraly everything
you explained everything so beautifully :) i love your ideas!!
thank you!! ❤
I loooveee the xiaoting idea, but also what lots of people don’t know is that xiaoting actually has main vocal potential, I saw a video of her hitting a Bb5, I’ll drop the link too
ruclips.net/video/3uO3T55h77A/видео.html here is the Bb5 Ting video
omg, please make a part 2 to this video!! everything about this video was so interesting to watch and i would love more!!
I take your Sungchan suggestion and raise you Shotaro. I on God think Mark should have stayed out of NCT Dream because after he left they had no where to go but up. It also allowed members like Jeno to take the front in the rap parts. Jeno and Jaemin also got to write more. I think it was a large mishandling on SM's part. However, I do 1000% agree with you on giving Sungchan acting roles. He is an actor through and through.
i see what you mean!! i think shotaro's role in dream would clash a lot with both mark and jisung but i would loooove to see him on their songs 🥲
I second this. That was the initial idea with NCT right, feels like Dream members was supposed to keep renewing and adding younger members as a group concept. But it kinda backfires because the original members bond really well and we kinda really watch them grew from pre teen together. Mark and Haechan is really tired tbh it’s too much with 127 and the yearly projects and kinda awkward when Dream promote minus the 2 most of the time outside music shows and yt content.
Especially with Haechan's recent health issues, him and Mark are overworked. Plus they almost never show up to Dream's events if if conflicts with 127's schedule. SM should've thought about logistics more
Um.. sorry but real nctzens know how close 7Dream are and how happy the members are when Haechan and Mark are with Dream. They literally cried when Mark have to “leave” the group and now when he is officially back they all are so happy bcuz they love each other so much since they literally grow up together.
@@dara_stoyanova2037 Ok no one thinks they should leave "just because". They are VERY overworked to the point of hospitalization and if you were a "real nctzen" you wouldn't act so selfishly and choose to ignore the clear conflicts with being in 2 fixed groups.
I love IVE, but I honestly think they all would've been better in different groups.
like HEAR ME OUT
Yujin: Lesserafim. She fits the fierce vibe, and she's also very elegant. Her voice is super powerful and her tone would fit perfectly with their music, she gives a similar vibe to Yunjin, and she's an amazing dancer.
Liz: StayC. She's so damn adorable and her voice would work so nice with the other members. Like if her and J harmonized it would be SO BEAUTIFULLLL.
Leeseo: New Jeans. When I saw her on the collab stage, it honestly looked like she was having such a good time, and I think her look, age, and voice would blend nicely together with the rest of the group. They would literally have a a perfectly ascending age range (14-15-16-17-18) lol. I honestly don't like her vibe that much when she's around the other IVE members, but when I saw her performing with Minji and Hyein in the Love like Oxygen cover I was literally thinking "Leeseo would fit right in with New Jeans".
Wonyoung: I honestly think Wonyoung fits well in IVE, but since in this universe there would be no IVE, I'd say although she is not S tier in everything, I think she'd do well as a soloist because of her reputation and beauty. And although her voice isn't OMG SO GOOD SUPER AMAZING STUNNING, I still personally really love her voice and I think she could make catchy songs. If I were to put her in a group though, I'd say maybe Itzy, Aespa, or G-Idle because I think she'd look good with them.
Rei: After seeing the collab stage, I think Rei would be so cute with Kep1er only because she seemed so freaking adorable when she was dancing. Nmixx I think would be good as well because I think she could fit their vibe.
Gaeul: No hate to Gaeul because she actually sings some of my fav parts in some of IVE's songs, but I personally don't care for her vocals. I think she's an amazing dancer though so I'd say she'd be good with ITZY, Nmixx or Lesserafim because they can all dance pretty good and I think she'd be more appealing with a fiercer concept.
idk why, but gaeul gives off everglow vibes
no, but I got you for jeongin!! I have had that inkling for awhile, but I haven't been quite able to pinpoint it properly until you did 😭☺️, so thank you for doing so!! jeongin is absolutely skz's maknae on top and forever baby, but him and his characteristics just checked out txt's boxes very well, it's a good fit in image and concept.
especially his vocals (it suits the refreshing and more vocally oriented tones of txt's music) and that boy-next-door or first love kind of vibes that the members give off.
I was just watching snake and I can definitely see Xiaoting in AESPA. They would look so cool and out of this world together.
You gotta believe me when I say *Yujin and Yunjin gives similar vibes*
Fierce but in an elegant way
Ps girl I saw your first and only video and gonna subscribe now you're so my type
i totally agree, i've thought they had a similar vibe since they were on the same team in produce 48!!
If the timeline and debuts aligned I would have loved to see Xioting in Lsf. I mean apart from just the aesthetics of it all- a ballerina, a ballroom dancer and an opera trained singer in one group? Cmon
Wow! I just discovered your channel and I really like the way you approached everything!! I think you could definitely do well as a k-tuber if continue like this! I can't wait for your next video! Fighting!!
thank you so much!!
Personally but Eunchae and Kyujin would work in New Jean's
They would, but i think eunchae is best in lesserafim. She really adds that cuteness to the group and lesserafim would be a lot more empty without her (not saying the other members are bad i just think the group wouldn’t be AS perfect without her)
no because the jeongin txt concept explanation did make so much sense
New comment because I hadn’t finished the video yet before 😂 -
I really find your assessment of Kyujin being in New Jeans *fascinating*.
She absolutely would fit right in with the aesthetic and vibe Ador is marketing NWJNS with, but a part of me feels a little off with her placement there.
It’s mainly because of the persona and theme NMIXX has already introduced her with. All these idols are coached pre-debut to fit the role and theme their group is planned for, so if she had debuted in New Jeans I’m sure I wouldn’t have thought twice. She would fit no problem; but, because JYP has put so much time and resources in promoting her as a monster rookie with so many different ranges, skills, and talents seeing her in New Jeans feels limiting in my mind.
All the girls in New Jeans are extremely talented, don’t get me wrong, but the way they’re being marketed is a lot softer, while being very vocal and aesthetic focused (at least for now). Whereas, no matter how messy NMIXX’s comeback and concepts may be, the edginess of their genre and marketing seems like it allows for Kyujin to have more opportunities to shine individually.
Hopefully one day she and some of the New Jeans girls do a collab or a TikTok or something. That would make my day.
Either way, I really loved your take on all these idols and where they could also shine. Keep up the great work. Such a fun watch!
i totally get this and i honestly agree, i'm just being self-indulgent 😭 thank you so much!!
I haven’t watched the video but as a casual, Chaeyoung needs to do her own thing alongside Twice or be in a group like Lesserafim or G-Idle. That girl has powerful talent in abundance.
omg jeongin would really mesh well with txt, you just opened my third eye now I'm imagining him with the members performing .
Kyujin is the best KPOP star ever imo. Her energy is unmatched. I think she fits in with NMIXX very well though because that group has a lot of different sounding vocalists, so when she sings her voice really shines.
As a Jeongin stan
yes. Just yes. I imagined the same thing, so you are not alone with that thought. Jeongin would fit so much in txt concepts.
Now i wanna hear him covering sugar rush ride fr or crown
Also sullyoon from nmixx also fit in IVE I mean she got very feminine, girly and cute vibes so imo she would be perfectly fited in IVE ,her voice is also sounds something just like IVE songs
I totally see Jeongin in TXT and I get the college-first love aura you talked about, thanks...🙃Now I'm gotta go and cry about it 😫🤧
You actually opened my mind to an alternative universe with Jeongin. It suits so well I'm shocked I never thought about it
Gaeul from IVE in literally any other group. From day one of Ives debut, I completely threw my Wiz*one brain out the window when I saw and heard Gaeul, she’s genuinely really talented with dance and her vocal tone is so unique. I hate to say it but I don’t think Gaeul fits Ives concept either, and in honesty, I have no clue what concept she’d go well with, but I’m just waiting for Starship to give her a chance with a dance break or more than one line in a song(where she sings).
I TOTALLY get you on the Jeongin one…I actually thought about this too a couple weeks ago lol
when i first saw xiaoting on stage with red hair, i immediately thought she belonged in aespa.
ok please do a part 2 this was so interesting to watch!!
Xiaoting in Aespa is literally what I thought the second I saw her in their debut
Ahhhhhh when you say sungchan I felt like butterflies in my stomach I love him sooooooo much and he is so talented but SM don’t deserve him I feel so sorry for him cuz he is my fav idol ever 😭😭😭🫂
OMG THE INTRO I LOVE YOU FOR USING THIS SONG!
I'm so frustrated with SM's lack of ability to actually place Sungchan and Shotaro in a group already, like damn, they debuted for this? 💀 I sometimes even forget that they are in NCT bc we don't see them outside their reality shows
Now I want Xiaoting in AESPA
I think this is quite unpopular but I feel Yuna will fit Ive. Her visuals and height match that of Ive's and I feel she can absolutely be the main dancer and maybe main rapper along with Rei or lead rapper. There was a stage a few years ago where Yuna was dancing on stage along with other maknaes including Wonyoung (when she was still in iz*one), and they were doing an elegant concept and I feel Yuna was absolutely killing it. Don't get me wrong, Yuna definitely suits Itzy's image, she is incredibly versatile and I feel like she can do any concept
omg i love your channel, also as a stay i get exactly what you're saying about jeongin fitting txt's image
no but like, you are so right about i.n in txt, like- wow. he would fit so so so well in all their songs!!! I can specially see him in runaway and lovesong (frost and puma too ahhhhhhhhh)
i totally agree w the girlgroup ones, and also love the fact that ur not using the robot voice, please do a part 2 :)
other than sungchan in dream this is so genius and correct like xiaoting in aespa? yes please
the problem with sungchan in dream is that a, dream have a kind of bond that adding someone to it would feel a bit off even though he's close with them. also the thought of sung taro not being together in a unit pains me a bit so I could just be biased
can we just talk about how calming her voice is
I actually agree with you on all your picks
When you used iiso signs as your intro I was freaking out!!! I was Soo happy that my girl is getting discovered!!!!
I’ve always been more of a Xiaoting for Lessetafim kinda person, but I get your reasoning for aespa too!
I never thought of xiaoting being in aespa but now that u mention it gosh she does rlly fit
the way i screamed yes for jeongin for txt
omg i never thought of jeongin in txt, but you're rightttt. He always did seem to have a softer aura than stray kids
the jeongin one surprised me but it makes so much sense and now i need a jeongin to cover literally any txt tt rn
I really like your videos! Your editing style, your voice, your tempo and how nice you are.
For your picks, I think all your girls are spot on, really wanna see the Kepler girl in aespa styling now.
I have never considered IN in TXT, but I think I see it. He's a little rascal, and TXT is full of rascals with that very high teasing/loving energy. I think he'd work well with Soobin's leader style, and really enjoy having a makane to care for. He's got the dancing skills and the hard working nature, and he has a distinct vocal color that would fit well. He's on the short side though, and while he looks amazing his visuals are pretty different from TXT. Nothing styling can't cover, but I think it would be noticable since everyone in TXT, except for Yeonjun, has the same visual charcteristics. I'd say the look of the group standing together is the only thing holding him back, but as I was writing that I realize he would absolutely RULE in TXT styling. Imagine him in the Loser Lover era? In Blue Hour? In SUGAR RUSH RIDE?!! Especially the Studio Choom outfits, god. Save IN from Stray Kids leather astethics, put him in TXT!
Totally agree with you about all, but especially about Xiaoting and Yujin
I.N. having a matching element with TxT is understandable! I get it all, trust me! I see those IG posts and I truly understand. At the same time, you've to understand that...that is not how all groups are formed. Especially SKZ, Chan formed the group much like RM formed BTS (no comparison) and when that happens its always more about the heart of the group and less about logic, analytics or technicality.
The real question is, would I.N. be better in txt or in skz, and you've to think about I.N. the person not just the artist, which i think is lacking in this analysis, and its very obvious, its SKZ...No one can deny that for things like - his energy or vibe or his element!
They are a family not a company-created group, he's their "maknae on top". And they are perfect the way they are. There is a reason why it's a four leaf clover!
LITERALLY THE FIRST TIME IVE SEEN SOMEONE ARTICULATE MY THOUGHTS ABT JEONGIN AND TXT LOVE U FOR THIS
Don’t come for me, but I feel like Garam would’ve fit NewJeans really well. She has the visuals and vocals to fit in with them.
Xiaoting would fit right into Aespa in my opinion!!! The way she carries herself so elegantly reminds me of Aespa as a group, plus she could rock their concept also. I just know that she would help balance out the visual weight in Aespa soooo well. She could even become Karina’s rival as a second visual or center but that’s just my personal thoughts. Vocally, it’s not much of an issue since she could easily become a sub rapper or a lead dancer, maybe even compete to become the face of the group. Heck, maybe her and Karina could release a duo project like Seulgi and Irene did, I just know the whole industry would go nuts over that. The power Aespa would hold if SM just took her in, gosh I can’t help but think about it lol 😭👏
JEONGIN TXT OH UR SO RIGHT... especially with temptation just released i really think with a song like farewell neverland our innie would THRIVE
I actually never thought about this but I LOVE your suggestions and explanations (yujin and xiaoting especially) How do I stop to unsee this now every time I see these idols 😭
ok so since im a kep1ian imma put the girls into other groups i could see them in
yujin - fromis_9 (im a casual fan, but i think their quirky sound/look would fit yujin rlly well)
xiaoting - le sserafim or ive (if ive had an older group of girls, i think xiaoting would fit in rlly well & everybody & their mamas already talked abt her being in lessera)
mashiro - (g)-idle or fromis_9
chaehyun - gwsn or stayc (she would fit perfectly in an elegant group, but she also has this down to earth vibe that would fit stayc rlly well)
dayeon - everglow or nmixx
hikaru - billlie
bahiyyih - stayc
youngeun - loona or billlie
yeseo - csr (she fits the elegant concept rlly well +she’s an 05 liner)
okay so like when i first heard of jeongin in txt it literally made my brain twist- it was such a weird idea to fathom, BUT I GET UR POINT- he has that cute yet boyfie attractive vibe about him that literally ALL of the txt boys have, and I can see him in their concepts. I now need jeongin to cover a txt song asap-
i can actually understand the jeongin one, i never thought about it (and i am a stay) but when you mentioned it does make sense
Love how you truly put in thought for everyone’s suggestions in the comments and your own opinions from the video are well justified too- also side note your voice is so relaxing you could be talking about worms (the boring kind) and I’d listen
I.N. SO TRUEEE. Never thought of it but it couldn’t be more accurate. If chosing between new jeans and NMIXX, Kyujin would suit NMIXX more. But i get where your coming from. Love THIS video!
I've never thought about this topic before but I could totally see the vision with each one. I wasn't very convinced with jeongin and kyujin at first but after you elaborated in it I kinda got it. I totally would like a part two of this
The second I saw the teasers for le sserafim I immediately thought Loona's Yves would fit perfectly! Like the whole chic badass vibe is totally her thing :)
tbh I agree with basically each opinion (especially loved the idea of xiaoting in aespa, she would fit SO WELL) except for shotaro in dream. even though he has the skills and the charisma, I don't think he would fit with dream's backstory. the members started training together when they were kids and have a really strong bond from overcoming so many hardships together. shotaro would just look weird in the whole picture and he would be so much better off in an unit of his own
No but I kinda wanna see eunchae in billlie
AND CHAEHYUN IN AESPA I WOULD DIE
jeongin in enhypen?
my brain is exploding
i actually started the jeongin train of thought because i thought of the possibility of him in enhypen! enhypen would make SO much sense but i decided that i liked the idea of txt better