when every frame in a film is perfect
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июн 2024
- #Dune #duneparttwo #videoessay
Thanks to editor Joe Walker for narration provided.
Timestamps
00:00 - 02:49 Intro
02:49 - 05:49 Context
05:49 - 06:56 Sound design
06:56 - 09:39 Visual precision
09:39 - 10:53 The little things
Music used:
Track: "Celestial Calling (Original Mix)", Fog Temple
Music provided by slip.stream
Download / Stream: get.slip.stream/WbFf5V
Other music provided by artlist.io
Thomas Flight video essay: • Why This Scene From Du... 
Развлечения
An eclipse actually occurring during the production is the coolest thing ever
Very cool, and completely expected.
Yeah, but the VFX production still didn't understand how the eclipse looks.
EXPLANATION: In the total phase, the corona gets brighter, not darker, as the phase progresses. It's completely the opposite of how they made it.
@@mysibratus huh? why would the corona get brighter when obstructed by a moon? Are you talking about exposure compensation from the camera in real-life conditions?
@@hundredfireify during a total eclipse you are able to see the ghostly corona around the sun because normally you can’t see it, the actual sun is too bright. I didn’t see a corona in this movie. I just saw the diamond ring effect which is pretty obvious, when it looks like a diamond ring. I mean, even if a total eclipse while happened filming this, it’s still pretty silly because we don’t have two suns like on Arrikis. So maybe a total eclipse happened to occur, but it was a total coincidence, this is not likely what was captured by the visual effects people. That would require two suns.
@@hundredfireifyI got to experience a totally solar eclipse and it was awesome. I doubt they would risk damaging those types of expensive film cameras.
This film is just pure eye candy
It's visually nice, but too minimalist, and the rest of the elements are not hugely good.
@@saattlebrutaz agree to disagree there buddy. I found it to be a masterpiece. Saw it 8 times in total at imax over the course of a couple months, and every time was a feast for the senses and the soul :) . It's okay not to like it, but i find it difficult to understand how anyone could call it not good.
And ear candy too! That Zimmer OST...
@@rosiek1990 oh absolutely! Probably my favorite Hans Zimmer compositions to date
seriously and nothing else
It blew my mind when the Harkonnen's started flying
Sounds like it does not take a lot to blow Your mind 😅
Why? Genuinely curious
@@music_enjoyer8 The cinematography & music
It really is hard to describe how striking it was watching them gracefully float up the mountain. Especially in a real imax theater. Especially with the juxtaposition of them gracefully going up and thunderous crashing back to the ground.
There's something magical about that particular shot.
Hollywood really just needs to write Denis Villeneuve a blank check to make whatever the hell he wants. The man is incapable of making a bad movie.
I really hope his name recognition with the Dune trilogy allows him to delve back into a little bit more experimental filmmaking. Dune 2 is undoubtedly a great film, but it feels more generically "epic" than anything he's yet done. I hope he can bring a more auteurial style to the mainstream without big studio strings attached going forward.
@@K.C-2049you sound like you didnt read the books. 😂
@@MonographicSingleheadedM-sp2wk we’re talking about filmmaking ? The funny thing is you thought you had a got em moment but just made yourself look like a jackass lol
He's allegedly working on a Rendezvous with Rama movie. I say we should just let him adapt every great sci-fi novel he wants until the end of time.
Give him rights to film Gateway. Out of the Silent Planet could also be good....
this is fantastic. I felt the exact same way watching the Harkonnen take off in that first scene. It's like you just knew immediately "I'm seeing something special".
Also so cool that Joe Walker recorded that voiceover for you! 👏
Yeah from that very specific moment I knew it was going to be an incredible movie without a doubt. It’s just one of those details that shows the director cares about making this movie as good as it possibly can be
This is why I don't like this guy's movies.
He goes all in the technical stuff, but lacks emotion. It's like AI made these movies, which is the direction we're heading towards anyway.
I was left in awe when this went down that's when i knew its going to be a visual masterpiece.
@@scratchy996AI movies are more akin to Disney souless recent productions (Dreamworks too btw)
To ditch Villeneuve this hard is like ditching Del Toro or Nolan, you might not like but they're masters of their craft
@@scratchy996 That's just utterly ridiculous, shut up
I went to see this movie in IMAX. When the sardaukar "climbed" and that bass dropped we were just in awe. The way it's shot, scored and how unsettling the wire work for that shot was where the unnatural way they fly off one of the Dunes just added more to the mythos of this world.
Those are haarkonens, not sardaukars
@@jakubw.2779 Oh right... Why did I write Sardaukars? Meh f*ck it.
Yep same. I was fully in from this moment. Stunning. IMAX was like a religious experience. The dude next to me cried multiple times.
Aye.
lol even I thought they were Sardaukar when I first watched. But I felt the same about the scene.
It's "just" wire work, but it's so unbelievably well-done.
Wire work well used and well executed. It’s an ancient technique, but still so relevant and useful.
I'm not sure that's wire work. They all leaped perfectly the same way. The only variation is their leg positioning once airborne. Speaking of leg positioning, with wire work, there is ALWAYS a swing. Whether lifting upwards or, like in this shot, upward AND forwards there's some sort of leg swing either forwards or backwards. In this case, there is neither. Uniformed launch, lift, and body positioning. I would say this is CGI. There is a video called Hollywood stunt robot. Look how perfect it launches. No leg swing.
@@20Avalanche06 Hmm, not knowing the exact behind-the-scenes, this could be the case. But it may be some other form of rig, we don't see. A combination between wirework / rigging and CGI is of course always an option.
@@flippert0 No doubt. It's HOLLYWOOD.
I think its a combination, filmed in studio, but still a practical stunt. The lighting on the Harkonnens definitely reminds me of stage lighting a bit, so I think they're real actors, just not on location.
That’s so cool that Joe did the voice over!! What a great guy!
Wait, Joe Walker actually did the narration for you?? Mad lad! I assumed it was some AI and was kind of impressed by how close to his voice it was. Props to you for having the courage to reach out and ask, and to Joe for being a great sport! A tiny fragment of my faith in humanity has been restored.
It isnt AI? 😮
its AI
@@Nasser-bp6qf You didn't watch the video did you?
Great video, I can't believe the eclipse was real footage
Slow down there slick. There was a 30% eclipse during weeks of shooting. Nobody said the footage seen here was shot during an eclipse.
The scene catches our mind because that's how many of us flies in our dreams : not too far from the ground and smoothly.
Yes, exactly, just like dreaming
For me it was very reminiscent of scuba diving or free diving, which is probably the closest a human can get to gliding
His FX team must have studied motion, because unike most even high budget films, the flying seemed so freaking natural and the absolute correct motion.
so many moments in this film made me think "this is the coolest thing i've ever seen in a theater" especially the sandworm scenes.
This is my favorite scene of the movie, it has been since the first time I saw it (on IMAX of course). The music when the troops took off, the sound of the lasguns, how Paul went straight for the sword and didn't think twice to kill. It was perfection
That's so dope of Joe to record the snippet at the start! His voice is so distinct and soothing. The first time I heard him in an interview I immediately recognised him from the filmbooks in part 1. Great video essay!
7:45 "maybe that is just me over analyzing it" Honestly, I can't impress on you enough how important your analysis is! I so deeply appreciate your critical thinking lens, we truly and genuinely need more of this in the world. This was actually something that I did not even think of, but it makes absolute perfect sense and just added another layer to one of my favorite sequences in movies, ever. So thank you! Amazing video!
Thank you for your kind words 🤝
I rewatched that shot probably ten times - there's something breathtaking in there
yeah eclipse scene is like the visuals we experienced iRL
i cannot believe how well made *this* video is. I clicked on this almost numb from having seen too many Dune 2 videos in the past, but the editing, the sound, the content, everything is so exceedingly well made it blew me away... And being able to get that voiceover from Joe is unbelievable, I loved that narration in part 1 and in fact had a screen-capture of that scene printed out in my dorm room, it's crazy awesome we have more of him narrating like that and the rest of the video is just as wonderful. Great job, this was a brilliant video! 🤠
DUDE i just saw you also have a video essay on Mr Inbetween, that's been my favourite show for a long while that people rarely talk about. Your channel is awesome
Joe the legend. It's amazing how invested everyone who was part of the production is in their work of art and how months after it releasing we are still talking about how brilliant of a movie it is.
If dune part 2 doesnt get an Oscar I dont know what will.
I loved all these elements in the film. Having the complexities explained so well, made the film more enjoyable.
This movie was a huge success, and yet, I still feel like this movie (and franchise) is criminally underrated.
absolutely agree, if this movie won't gether all the Oscars like Lotr
Why can't we get Star Wars with this kind of effort and quality put in?
Ugh, Disney.
rant add: generic American Directors or more likely companies (understandable)... Film isnt art in Hollywood
playing things too safe and/or no need to do novel things in cinematography or storytelling wise to win at the box office
We don't deserve it. We are fools and will pay for anything Star Wars.
two people: Tanya LaPointe and Denis Villenueve. powerhouse producer/director combo that haven’t failed since they started working together on Arrival.
Get people who care about the craft as much as they do, and Disney might put together something worth watching. Dune is art, Star Wars is sterile bland made for everybody bore fest
Came here from my RUclips recommendations. Thanks for reminding me why I love this film so much. Subscribed!
PS. Joe Walker is such a nice guy, so cool of him to voice that intro for you. He shared my IG story of your video, too!
I had the same feeling at that same moment with the guys taking off. Super cool stuff.
Me too. I think the music played a big part too
this is genuinely one of the most fitting video essays i’ve ever seen, the way you chose the scenes and when to show them really made me remember a lot of what i loved about dune 2. great video, i hope you keep doing these!
Your on the front page of reddit, your going viral. Congrats
I love this.
Buddy you’re
this video started off very well just like the film. you have a huge road ahead brother.
I've not seen the film yet, but you've tipped me toward moving it up on my to-see list. I've been feeling very rushed lately for a lot of reasons, and I thank you for somehow slowing time long enough to get me to appreciate how beautifully these details come together. Really wonderful video. Love your work. 💜
It's definitely worth checking it out if you have an appreciation for film. Wishing you all the best in your own projects, and thank you for your kind words!
Watch. The film.
you are talking about how well this movies is filmed, and i fully agree, but at the same time i am amazed at how your own video is edited, very simple but striking and creative, which, for me at least, improves this video a lot
This might be my favourite film ever and this my favourite scene. When the Harkonens started flying up the side of the hill, with the lighting and sound all coming together, it had that feeling of seeing something amazing which I haven't had for a long time. Agree on all the points, the sound design was so dynamic. There were times you could hear a pin drop, other times it was borderline overwhelming. For quite a long film, it never sagged. Love it so much.
This film is raw, unadulterated cinema. As a book fan who adored Part One, Part Two was just beyond anything I imagined was possible.
New favorite movie, and thank you greatly for this essay!
I don’t say this lightly, and I’ve never thought highly enough of a movie to bother thinking this, but I think Dune 2 is literally the greatest movie ever made. Every feature, from tiny details to major themes and characters is absolute perfection.
Nice video. Glad that you focused on one scene in particular and explored it thoroughly, rather than poining out the scenes that feel the same way as the eclipse sequence.
Wasn't expecting such a high quality video from such a small channel. Great work. Glad to subscribe
I have always said that Kubrick’s greatness was that every frame looked like it could be a piece of art that you hang on your wall. Villeneuve is the heir of that legacy.
wow, well made vid. I love the visual indications you make :)
amazing video! you talk about the editing and sound design of the movie but your own editing and sound design is extremely well done
Thank you for highlighting the brilliance of this scene!
fantastic video, you have earned a subscriber - this is spot on content wise and clearly made with love and admiration. keep it up!
the eclipse sequence specifically when the harconnen's floating is the most scene i remember,the sound and the visual
Incredible breakdown, rarely see this level of both creative and technical insights for film reviews. THANK YOU
Very cool video, it feels like it's inspired by Dune even in the way you edited it, please keep posting more!
Fantastic video! Great idea with the subtitles at the beginning as well as the original narrator from the dune. A lot of attention to detail :)
this video is just as good, as the scene your talking about. Good job man.
The eclipse scene is probably the most "wow" moment I´ve had in cinemas for a really long long long time. It is simple in concept yet so beautifully crafted.
Condolences
as guy said really condolences
I don't like or subscribe very often, but you deserve it. This was one of the most breathtaking scene I saw in a movie aswell, and you described it perfectly :D
This is what eclipses are for...!
Thanks to Joe - if you're good enough for an Oscar winner, then you've certainly earned my sub. Looking forward to the next video!
Great job man! Just started making video essays of my own, so I especially love how you're crafting your argument with clips and clever editing!
Great video essay man! Can't believe you got Joe Walker to do a cameo LMFAOO
I was surprised to see such few likes, I thought this was definitely a million + subs channel. Your quality is impeccable keep up the great work!!!
Man! This analysis is of top quality. exceptional quality and presentation. Keep it up!
Your earnest sincerity and attention to detail are strong points.
The video editing in this is spectacular.
your editing is so satisfying fr!
just had to boost the algorithm, one of the best video essays i’ve seen for awhile
A video essay talking about a perfect shot; which is actually perfect.
Kudos!
Beautifully made eulogy to a scene . Very nicely done sir!
felt the saameeee! glad that i got this suggested to me by YT and glad you made it!
An incredibly well-made video, I don't doubt this channel is going to start growing very quickly if this is standard level of quality!
Great analysis! I agree, its all the small things that help us immerse ourselves in a world. Honestly I've begun to realize that the difference between something great and mediocre is just the little things more often than not, and the detail and care is what truly makes something so great. Thanks for uploading!
Awesome and high production video!!
Your excitement about understanding a complex context is exciting.
Really well done video, keep doing this style.
Same. That scene just confirmed that i was watching a genuine sci-fi masterpiece.
Fantastic video. Real quality analysis and narration on your part. I was shocked you only have 5k subscribers. It’s +1 now😊
I have lost count of how many times I have watched this movie since it first dropped…Great video my dude! 😊
Thank you for the walk through. This was enlightening.
Nicely done. Denis Villeneuve's shot composition is always so well executed, with every frame a delight to see.
This was a great video essay!! I loved it! I hit the subscribe button instantly! I can't wait to see more
Awesome video man, excited to see you continue to build your abilities- cant even believe youve only got 4k
Keep it up!
Man! What a video!
Congratulations you are very good at this.
I've seen it in IMAX in Bangkok and few weeks later back home and I discovered so *many* scenes during the second watch where I've just been in total awe in IMAX. The whole Giedi Prime sequence alone was so mesmerizing it zapped my brain completely.
Bro, your video is a masterpiece itself.
Well done take.🤙
As a concept, artist and illustrator, I am always super fascinated with tight little scenes that express so much in every aspect artistically.
My favorite part of this insane and incredible film is the first 10 mins. The sound is easily half the experience. The music and choreograpy upon liftoff epic.
Very good video! Joe’s voice is beautiful
Can’t believe you just have 5k subs. This video was so well done. Thanks
This video made me subscribe! Good job man.
Hey, so the video you put together, was so well done. I even noticed initially that it was the same narrator from the holotapes (Fallout?) in the beginning of your video. So neat you had him record that. Your choice of music, the FX elements you added - the little cues audibly to assist in your findings were awesome. Just a great, enjoyable little review of the film. Well done, mate.
Amazing work dude 👍
Amazing..I share your admiration for this particular shot..its top tier film making welcoming us back to Dune
Great video about a great film, and super cool to get the voiceover!
Great vid. I've had a re-occurring dream for 50 years of running, then jumping and never landing. Just floating along a foot off the ground. We all have a desire to fly, so it captured that childlike part of me. Jaw drop scene.
Great job on this video. Insightful and enjoyable. I'd be interested in more of what you have to say on either Dune 1 or Dune 2.
Amaaaaazing video! I am incredibly passionate about the art and composition within film-making. I recently got round to watching Dune 2 (life's just been busy). I watched with a friend who is extremely passionate about the Dune series. It was so cool to be able to pause the film and talk about it while watching without either of us getting frustrated.
4k subscribers and you put out something like this. Enjoy your millions of subs by next year!
"talk about the stars aligning" class
Absolutely love this video mate you must have spent ages putting it together
J
the magnetic landmines was such big brain idea, i loved it.
Really nice man
Dude good to see you here
This has to be one of my favorite movie shots of all time. Its also one that really stuck with me after watching the movie and i remembered it vividly. I completely get what the dune editor was trying to say even though its hard to grasp. There is something about these shots that just does something special to the brain and its so awesome
are you 11 years old?
That scene will endure for years to come as a prime example of great film making. It will stand by anything in the SC-FI genre including 2001.
When they flew it made me feel that any superhero film showing flying has a lot to live up to.
great video man!
Amazing video, thank for sharing. Is the only film I have ever seen at imax and took my breath away.
Brilliant video essay, earned my subscription
Sensational commentary, well done
Great work mate. ❤
Love that you got Joe to do a voice over
such a thoughtful, informative breakdown earned you a sub from me!!
Awesome video man! Subbed!
the narration intro, so cool!
I had the same reaction when I saw that scene in the cinema. Well analyzed!