India faces unique border security challenges & needs substantial resources & planning, compared to the relatively stable environment enjoyed by Germany. Entire illegal immigrant per year into EU is just 1% compared to the vast numbers inside Africa & Asia. India has a long history of providing refuge to those in need. Its border with Bangladesh is approx. 4,096 km long. The hilly & isolated border with Myanmar is further complicated since there are civil & ethnic conflicts going on. Indian govt has fenced the border along Bangladesh & Pakistan. However, Rohingya, a persecuted minority from Myanmar, are seeking refuge in India. India's border in the east with Bangladesh is marked by difficult terrain, marshes, & seasonal flooding, making surveillance & patrol arduous. While the porous border with Nepal allows unauthorized crossings in the North. Many people from Myanmar are driven by persecution & violence, while many people from Bangladesh seek better economic opportunities. Geographical proximity to Nepal & porous borders in J&K also contribute to the problem. To the north, India shares a long, icy border with China's commiemilitary, equipped with cutting-edge weaponry. The high-altitude has seen attacks or clashes between the World's two biggest population. On the western flank, India faces the threat of Pakstate-sponsoredterrorisproxies using drones, tunnels, & riverine routes to infiltrate. The desert & forested hills along Pak border provide hiding grounds. Does Bangladesh care what India did for them in 1971 to save & protect ordinary Bangla families? Also, Europe still remembers WW2 allies by yearly commemorations. Do they care that the only nation with whom, India has given up it's land to for free, is border area to Bangladesh? No Indian govt is going to give loose opinion about any Bangladeshi govt. Why do you expect India's govt to say negative things about their (Bangladesh's) different political parties? India wants to be in good with whichever govt is in power in Bangladesh.
Meanwhile 27 Million Illegal Bangladeshi is already living in India. Now could you fetch the number of Illegal Bangladeshi immigrants living in Germany?
@@monrima190They are coming here in huge numbers and changing demography.plz understand the situation and stop entering illegally we give most visas to bangladeshi yet they choose to cross illegally this cannot be tolerated.
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder. Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB... But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them. This is deference Between BGB and BSF.... BSF is a terrorists organisation....
save Bangladeshi hindu from indian hindu😔. Justice for shorna das✊ Justice for Jayanta Kumar Singh✊ Note:Between 2009 and 2020, at least 522 Bangladeshis lost their lives in such incidents. International Court and human organisation should take action against bsf.(India border guard)
14 year old or 15 year old ,how did a teenager girl from Dhaka reach 1000 km away near Indian border? Stop playing victim card ,ask your people to not cross the border, we already have 1.4 billion people here .
@@RafsanTalukder2021 yes I can justify.. After 1947 two nation theory we are enemy countries dont cross our border, end of discussion... keep remembering 1947
Well people of India also cross Bangladesh border illegally but our BGB never shoot them directly. They attest them and hand them over to BSF as per International border security law.
Meenakshi Ganguli, its a international border...its a border between two countries. There is no friendly international border and it s NOT ARTIFICIAL BORDER. Who gave u job ?
2 days back Indian border security force (bsf) guard was allegedly kidnapped by Bangladeshi illegal entering into India. After India protest. They released them. Now govt of India gave shoot on site orders. Indian blood is not cheap. We have Every right to defend. We are not interested in bangladeshi business.
Subramanian Swamy said: "I support Nationalist voters refusing to vote for Modi in Varanasi. Why? Because Modi has allowed China to brazenly grab 4064 sq kms of Ladakh since April 2020 and told a lie " koi aaya nahin...".depriving Ladakhis of sheep grazing."
It's a man made border. There are no physical boundaries like the sea,lake, mountain or desert between them. Most of the world borders are now artificial
@@marzanatique I am talking about your current pm who already accepted about these insidens and its still going on. And about that little girl kill bsf saying its done by BGB. Also about backing hassina in a geopolitics not going to prove that we are rigging your country election. Many of BD said this case is not related to USA but its getting more clear now. Then the incident of your current pm latest speech regarding USA involment.
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder. Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB... But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them. This is deference Between BGB and BSF.... BSF is a terrorists organisation....
There are innumerable videos about Bangladeshis boasting about their ability to cross over to India at will. India is a sovereign country with territorial boundaries and we cant just watch helplessly. 20 million bangladeshis are living illegally in India and we have had enough.
No report. The BSF jawan was identified as B Arun Dilip from Jalgaon in Maharashtra get kill by gunfire from Bangladesh border.This happens in 2024 September. Where is human rights? I think they are sleeping. he has two childen very young . you can seach artical, no mention on isalim in bangaladeshi ,very bias report
@xxyz2023, Sorry. Very long comment. Yes we do care what you did for us. And Bangladesh has repaid the favour many times over. Sorry we can't be a slave anymore. We fought war and lost hundreds of thousands of lives to be free, not to be colonized by another country. Though it was not a favour at all. It was a very deliberate attempt to divide Pakistan for Indias own good. And they conspire to do it from the very start. Just like India is attempting to divide Bangladesh now into parts. Also we haven’t forgotten the looting you did during the very same war. It was part of the reason Bangladesh suffered a terrible famine after the war. Also the several attempts to undermine Bangladesh, exact some kind of revenge through border killings, withholding water from the shared international rivers to kill our rivers and livelihood. And to colonize Bangladesh through a puppet government. We have forgotten it actually, for years. But how.much history can you hide? Every bit is documented and written down by the people who suffered.
there are many smugglers and terrorists coing from bangladesh since they got indipendence about 10% population of india is filled with bangladeshi imigrants illeagal this should be stopped somewhere this anti india news agency dont tell about force conversions of hindus into islam because of the bangladeshi
@@AbdulHadi-lj2pj i dont read about that the bangladeshi hindus are killed or coverted by bangladeshis see the percentage of hindu from 1971 to 2024 in bangladesh does it because of india
@@thomasmontgomery805 it's God given right to indians for settling in north and south america As Christoffer Columbus was searching india when he found Americas accidently and named natives as red indian 😂 so you can think Jesus want indians in America
India has open boundaries with Nepal. Its not possible to have one with Bangladesh due to the demographic sensitivities in Indian north eastern region. Not to mention how terrorists often found shelter in bangladesh. I'm honestly not surprised that your panelist did not even mention this commonly understood thing.
@@JusticeNeeded-k4dkiddo listen..... During covid, only for short time Bangladesh's per capita became more than India... That was momentary due to lockdowns
So i give suggestions. Germany give visa to this person. Not give ant suggestions to me first look your own actions you try to stop free speech by removing citizenship of people which one is talking about Palestine.
It is not acceptable if a Bangladeshi is going to enter illegally, but murder is not acceptable through judicial means, it can be resolved through negotiation
border security force........ it's their duty to guard our border......they are not entering into Bangladesh and then killing people....... don't cross the border illegally.
Oh such a blatant lie..DW is this deliberate or your reporters are misleading you?..I am here in Assam in India bordering bangladesh. We have been travelling in and out of Bangladesh freely after 2014 modi govt..the new govt in Bangladesh has not just started anti India stance but also anti India through your very channel where facts ard not checked prior to publishing the world...this is not journalism..you are creating a narrative which is false.. shame DW
@@NazmulHasan-kl3swI saw on news when protest happening in bangladesh..5 bangladeshi saying infront of reporter...I am from banglades...what would you say.???
3:27 I have family relatives in USA. But I don't know why US ask me to take a visitor Visa instead of considering the fact that since my relatives in USA, its my birth right to enter ILLEGALLY. 😅😅
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder. Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB... But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them. This is deference Between BGB and BSF.... BSF is a terrorists organisation....
In recent days lots of India’s are arrested from Bangladesh side border. BGB didn’t kill anyone. BSF is killer force who kills unarmed poor people. When its about a regular force just remember 2001. Lots of BSF died in boarder by BDR (current BGB). So we know your power
@@asmrahath213 Your advice to me is that don't follow godi media because it has agenda which is disliked by you. But follow another group of media with diff agenda and it shows news favorable to your sentiments. Nice advice :) What I trust is Indian army, there are father's of my friends who are in BSF, they are upstanding citizens. So yeah I can have my faith in them. Whilst what happened to the government who trusted Bangladeshi army, they were couped. So, good fking luck mate
😆Go and ask Pakistanis what kind of treatment they receive when they try to cross the border. In China border, only few Tibetans cross the border illegally, we have no problems with Tibetans, they are friendly people.
Do not enter India illegally, if you want to enter apply for a visa and passport then come.. border security forces are being deployed to secure the border.. and they are doing good job
Illegal Bangladeshi immigration to India is a major headache in North-East India. India has the right to protect her borders and sovereignty. Bangladesh Govt should work in these border areas to educate some of these "innocent" people to avoid loss of lives !
@@asmrahath213 thats why they have a tight security in germany for international borders and when it comes to india border security it is not good thats what they think and do fullfill their agenda
@@subasthapa4839 why there is no reporting of how 20% bangladeshi hindu now only became 9 or 2 and why there is no reporting on killing of Hindus by Islamists in bangladesh
My country is Bangladesh. India has opened the barrage, Bangladesh crop production has been destroyed. Roads are broken. India media is spreading rumors in the name of Bangladesh.
it is bangladeshi propagnda we gave you independence and now you are paying your depts like this search on internet there is nothing like that happened
If you try to cross international border then definitely border guard will not welcome with garlands. How one can cross international border without visa? What is artificial border? what do you mean by friendly border. We Bengalis do no want to have open border with Bangladesh ever.
Indian BSF has been killing people violating all sorts of international border law for couple of decades ... Bangladesh showed their maximum restraints and professionalism in that case
Which international laws? Can you mention a few? If you have proper evidence do submit it through post or online to the supreme court of India as PIL. Don't mislead people with your false narrative
This lady is ashamed of hindus, where is the eye opening opinion of Bangladeshi Hindu killing, Israeli attack on Palestine Lebanon? Where is the opinion of the Russian attack on Ukraine? Talking under AC room and living High profile status and giving opinion to others is very easy..😮😮😮😮.
What non sense. It is problem of Bangladesh that they don't educate their citizens living near the borders. They should apply for visa. Border security force is just doing their job like everywhere else. If this paid human right activist who was reading from script has issues then she should force government in bangladesh to educate their public properly. It is their problem.
murder of an unarmed intruder is a crime as per your country’s law as well as international. The fact that you don’t have this common sense also shows why your country’s troop commits such vile murders. No moral or common sense found
Rampant smuggling, illegal immigrants going to hindu sthan to snatch low end jobs in Kerala, delhi ...changing demographic of each nation even in europe ... so ...what to do...😮😮😮😢😢😮😢😢
Yes, the officer who shot her should be brought to justice. I am also shocked at how India is treating Bangladeshi Hindus. She shouldn’t have crossed illegally but shooting her is far too extreme. She can be detained or sent back but this kind of thing is wrong. This doesn’t however justify how Islamists in Bangladesh are harassing Hindus and now trying to ban Durga Puja.
if two unarmed children was threat for fully armed guards, then you need to think twice about your threat. yes, crosssing border without punishment is crime, but does that crime results in murder? where is the proportonality of force? can someone shot someone who has no arms in theri hand?
Naxalites , smugglers crossed the borders illegally thats a big issue for this border it's bad for both the countries you're talking like they've killed him for fun it's and international border not a state border but rip for those who lost their lives
And it's not about arms or without arms there are many illegal immigrants too in india ofcourse we can't deport them back bangladesh don't allow that so securing a border is a better option
@@md.samsurrahaman6758 it's doesn't matter your smugglers use this children as a asset your children is your responsibility we will tolerate any illegal inflitrators.
@@SurajMandal-lj6hc so according to you if we can't take care of our Children, your country has the right to shoot them? Without giving them fair chance to go through judiciary and court process? Thank you for your amazing argument, makes sense now actually..
Average west mindset 😂😂and paid news ...y Germany and west countries not taking immigrants?? Because of that west countries colonisation so many countries now facing problem s
Minority Young Girl sharna das was crossing to meet her relative.But Indian BSF killed her and took her body inside India.😢. Her mother was lucky she was just injured..
A note to our viewers that our expert's correct name is Meenakshi Ganguly. We apologize for the misspelling in this video!
India faces unique border security challenges & needs substantial resources & planning, compared to the relatively stable environment enjoyed by Germany. Entire illegal immigrant per year into EU is just 1% compared to the vast numbers inside Africa & Asia.
India has a long history of providing refuge to those in need. Its border with Bangladesh is approx. 4,096 km long. The hilly & isolated border with Myanmar is further complicated since there are civil & ethnic conflicts going on.
Indian govt has fenced the border along Bangladesh & Pakistan. However, Rohingya, a persecuted minority from Myanmar, are seeking refuge in India.
India's border in the east with Bangladesh is marked by difficult terrain, marshes, & seasonal flooding, making surveillance & patrol arduous. While the porous border with Nepal allows unauthorized crossings in the North.
Many people from Myanmar are driven by persecution & violence, while many people from Bangladesh seek better economic opportunities. Geographical proximity to Nepal & porous borders in J&K also contribute to the problem.
To the north, India shares a long, icy border with China's commiemilitary, equipped with cutting-edge weaponry. The high-altitude has seen attacks or clashes between the World's two biggest population.
On the western flank, India faces the threat of Pakstate-sponsoredterrorisproxies using drones, tunnels, & riverine routes to infiltrate. The desert & forested hills along Pak border provide hiding grounds.
Does Bangladesh care what India did for them in 1971 to save & protect ordinary Bangla families? Also, Europe still remembers WW2 allies by yearly commemorations.
Do they care that the only nation with whom, India has given up it's land to for free, is border area to Bangladesh?
No Indian govt is going to give loose opinion about any Bangladeshi govt. Why do you expect India's govt to say negative things about their (Bangladesh's) different political parties? India wants to be in good with whichever govt is in power in Bangladesh.
You misselected her also.
How do you guys find these kinds of analysts ? Who always takes anti-ind stance 😅😂
Do apologize for your biased reportage too !
You misleading as always 😅
Germany should accept more bangladeshis
😂😂
@@koushikprem2 then bangladeshi will beg in streets of Germany
They are legal immigrants not illegal like Bangladeshis 😂@@sakibahmed2537
@@sakibahmed2537 Now it's gonna change. More BD immigrants now
@@sakibahmed2537 They are legal immigrants given visa by the German Govt itself...
Give Bangladeshis.... GERMAN citizenship.
Hahaha , to beg on Berlin streets ?
So i give suggestions.
Germany give visa to this person
@@Satyam_Yadav exactly what you are trying for but didnt get
Germany has more Bangladeshi than Indian
Then get ready for the mess in Germany
Why not India
Meanwhile 27 Million Illegal Bangladeshi is already living in India. Now could you fetch the number of Illegal Bangladeshi immigrants living in Germany?
western country will give you visa
yes indians are begging more for western country visa than any other countries
@@nikhil.k8938 Indian bsf kiling Bangladeshi citizen in border with out any judicial enquiry is a serious human rights violation
Then don't come to boder @@sakibahmed2537
@@sakibahmed2537lol illegal crossing a border is not a violation??
@@sakibahmed2537Then stop crossing the border. Is that too hard to understand?
Stay in ur borders to be safe or cross legally.
Why don’t you arrest them if they cross border?
Both sides people are relatives. If they cross the border why BSF don’t arrest them? Are they going there to occupy whole India?
Cuz we had it enough, now almost 10 million illegally bangladeshi living in india, we have to take strict action @@monrima190
Most of the children and adult who died were inside Bangladesh.
@@monrima190They are coming here in huge numbers and changing demography.plz understand the situation and stop entering illegally we give most visas to bangladeshi yet they choose to cross illegally this cannot be tolerated.
Don't cross international border without Visa.
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder.
Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB...
But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them.
This is deference Between BGB and BSF....
BSF is a terrorists organisation....
lol visa 😂 India need visa don’t make me laugh
Some people are trying to cross border illegally but reality is indian border forces illegally enter into Bangladesh and killed villagers.
@@LenaRoss-i9eIndians are the richest community in UK and 2nd richest in US. They're also the highest earning income group in US. Laugh harder 😂
@@LenaRoss-i9e then try to come without visa😂😂
save Bangladeshi hindu from indian hindu😔.
Justice for shorna das✊
Justice for Jayanta Kumar Singh✊
Note:Between 2009 and 2020, at least 522 Bangladeshis lost their lives in such incidents. International Court and human organisation should take action against bsf.(India border guard)
Swarna Das was a trespasser . This is the only truth.
Save Bangladeshi Hindus from Indiana.
How can you tell between Bangladeshi Hindu and Indian hindu
Why she cross illegally..... & She gave name plates during crossing the border.... fools
Please, save Bangladeshi from India, India is violating and killing all over Bangladesh..
Entire Assam state demogrophy is changed due illegal BDshis. Not even single word from DW. Very poor journalism.
They are legal assamese not Bangladeshi!
@@BDrevolution2.0I know you are a Bangladeshi, don't spread lies.
Bangladesh living standards is much higher then many indian states. Its a joke Bangladeshi living in assam 😂
@@NelufaMannan then why these Bdesi are trying to enter India illegally?
@@harshapatil3497 more than 2.06 million indian jobs in Bangladesh during the dictator Hasina's reigm.
Victim card activated
Bro, she was just 14 year old Hindu girl and BSF murdered her!
It's Victim Card! What
@@ytmdsiam if one is allowed than 1000s will come
@@ytmdsiam bangladesh army killed him.
you mean bangladeshi hindus play victim ???
14 year old or 15 year old ,how did a teenager girl from Dhaka reach 1000 km away near Indian border? Stop playing victim card ,ask your people to not cross the border, we already have 1.4 billion people here .
Illegal crossing is criminal offense. 😂
Really!! Jayanta Kumar was 14 and Shorna Das was 13!!
They both from Thakur-gaon district.
Can you justify killing minors?? 😶
@@RafsanTalukder2021 yes I can justify.. After 1947 two nation theory we are enemy countries dont cross our border, end of discussion... keep remembering 1947
Well people of India also cross Bangladesh border illegally but our BGB never shoot them directly. They attest them and hand them over to BSF as per International border security law.
@@dipoboyrogu9366 your logic said everything that you're a chapri from WhatsApp university
So the Indian soldiers are so scared of children so how they are going to fight against China 😂
Meenakshi Ganguli, its a international border...its a border between two countries. There is no friendly international border and it s NOT ARTIFICIAL BORDER. Who gave u job ?
she is leftist product of Ashoka university. Artificial border, what does that even mean?😂😂😂
Lol
@@SubhashishBagchi It obv means the border isnt marked or fenced properly. DUH
@@mrthundergaming7306 It has been fenced and they try to cross the fence
@@SubhashishBagchi If you had the iq to understand "artificial border", you wouldn't have asked that question in the first place.
We must have different definitions of "Friendly"
There was a question mark behind the sentence.
Why no reporting on killing of Hindus by Islamists in bangladesh
DW is funded by Qatar
😂😂😂
Yes there was , several times of the past few months
@@aroshjawhary3666 are u happy about gaza too??
because west now targeting india they will support kangladesh............
2 days back Indian border security force (bsf) guard was allegedly kidnapped by Bangladeshi illegal entering into India. After India protest. They released them. Now govt of India gave shoot on site orders. Indian blood is not cheap. We have Every right to defend. We are not interested in bangladeshi business.
Germany should learn from India how to control the national border.
Sure...
🙄
Yes😂
How to loose lands to China
@@saifulmalekkhan6869 whole west pakistan was lost lol
Subramanian Swamy said: "I support Nationalist voters refusing to vote for Modi in Varanasi. Why?
Because Modi has allowed China to
brazenly grab 4064 sq kms of Ladakh
since April 2020 and told a lie " koi aaya
nahin...".depriving Ladakhis of sheep
grazing."
@@hmmahfujur129 India has huuuuge landmass. Such petty land grabs by China don’t make any difference
Artificial border ?... what is an Artificial border between nation ? + we don't want open border with Bangladesh
Artificial means man made as in not natural the US Mexican border is an artificial border Nerd
It's a man made border.
There are no physical boundaries like the sea,lake, mountain or desert between them.
Most of the world borders are now artificial
You want open border with Pakistan?
No open border... With any country ..
Border with Nepal should also be closed
Why no report on hindu killed in bangladesh
2 Hindu kiled in Bangladesh.india also killed 2 Hindu in border in last 2 months. Score 2/2.
because they are false claims invented by indian godi media 😂
@@marzanatique
Un and your own pm is also wrong about it then.
@@iimcrandomgamer711well she has never been our pm at all. India backed her and helped firmly for continuing a illegal regime for more than a decade.
@@marzanatique
I am talking about your current pm who already accepted about these insidens and its still going on.
And about that little girl kill bsf saying its done by BGB.
Also about backing hassina in a geopolitics not going to prove that we are rigging your country election.
Many of BD said this case is not related to USA but its getting more clear now.
Then the incident of your current pm latest speech regarding USA involment.
Despite such action, there are almost 20 million illegal Bangladeshis living in India. They are pushed by the Bangladeshi border guards.
BJP wants Bangladeshi Hindu come to India.
Not only Hindus but also minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh bcoz they are facing atrocities
We have millions of Indians here too but we accepted them so why cant India accept them too.
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder.
Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB...
But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them.
This is deference Between BGB and BSF....
BSF is a terrorists organisation....
2.06 million indian has jobs in Bangladesh during the Dictator Hasina's reigm.
There are innumerable videos about Bangladeshis boasting about their ability to cross over to India at will. India is a sovereign country with territorial boundaries and we cant just watch helplessly. 20 million bangladeshis are living illegally in India and we have had enough.
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF 🙏🙏🙏
liar
No report. The BSF jawan was identified as B Arun Dilip from Jalgaon in Maharashtra get kill by gunfire from Bangladesh border.This happens in 2024 September. Where is human rights? I think they are sleeping. he has two childen very young . you can seach artical, no mention on isalim in bangaladeshi ,very bias report
andhbhakt spotted
@@rehaal07andhnamazi spotted
@@rehaal07 terror..ist spotted
Andhnamzis hypocrisy @@rehaal07
@xxyz2023, Sorry. Very long comment. Yes we do care what you did for us. And Bangladesh has repaid the favour many times over. Sorry we can't be a slave anymore. We fought war and lost hundreds of thousands of lives to be free, not to be colonized by another country.
Though it was not a favour at all. It was a very deliberate attempt to divide Pakistan for Indias own good. And they conspire to do it from the very start.
Just like India is attempting to divide Bangladesh now into parts.
Also we haven’t forgotten the looting you did during the very same war. It was part of the reason Bangladesh suffered a terrible famine after the war. Also the several attempts to undermine Bangladesh, exact some kind of revenge through border killings, withholding water from the shared international rivers to kill our rivers and livelihood. And to colonize Bangladesh through a puppet government.
We have forgotten it actually, for years. But how.much history can you hide? Every bit is documented and written down by the people who suffered.
Save Bangladeshi hindu from India bsf
Stop butchering your own citizens in Bangladesh, then they will stop trying to run away illegally
😂😂
😂😂😂😂 ফালতু কথা
saste nahshe
Your numbers wont sell in India any more. Good luck with your Yunus.
Oh my God hypocrisy of dw news🤮
For reporting about the problem at the border?
@@juhe1984Illegal Immigrants are crossing the border but they twist it to make it bad
Sorry to say. DW is not a Indian Godi media.
@@asmrahath213 Germany will not even give you visa let alone crossing their border
Truth obviously hurts😅
save Bangladeshi hindhu from indian bsf😢😢😢😢
Save allah from israel🥹
@@OlaUber-t7f Cool answer bro...... 👍👍👍
😁😁
You iars.... 🤬
You chatted your country, your community and religion too.
Shame on you.
*Conveted
Bangladesh Hindu population before 1971- 34%
Bangladesh Hindu population in 2024- 3%
Save Bangladeshi hindu from BSF India
Save Bangladeshi Hindus from Kan gludesh.
Dont care, cross legally with a visa or request for asylum from the Indian embassy.
@@NicolastheThird-h6m we do not have space 10% of india is filled by these imigrants
Why? Because Bangladesh has become so democratic that they had to leave Bangladesh. Not a single word for Bangladeshi Hindus?
Save Bangladeshi Hindus from India!
What about you country
there are many smugglers and terrorists coing from bangladesh since they got indipendence about 10% population of india is filled with bangladeshi imigrants illeagal this should be stopped somewhere this anti india news agency dont tell about force conversions of hindus into islam because of the bangladeshi
About what?
DW spreading misinformation
Your mom didn't push you out from her belly to say this 👋🏻
DW is biased media who spread propagand against India@@RUclipsNo-ng4so
It's their work bro.. please understand.. that's how views come and they pay salaries
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF 🙏🙏🙏
It is not and its well documented fact
If people illegally cross border what should Border guard do??? They are not suppose to hug them
Germany should provide Visa free entry to Bangladesh
And Bangalore indian visas??
Germany give visa to Bangladeshi Hindus who have been killed by Indian BSF
@@AbdulHadi-lj2pj Germany to give Visa to Knife attackers
@@AbdulHadi-lj2pj i dont read about that the bangladeshi hindus are killed or coverted by bangladeshis see the percentage of hindu from 1971 to 2024 in bangladesh does it because of india
What about 10-20 million illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, why they are come to India illegally without visa 😡😡😡😡❓❓❓❓❓❓
Says the indian. Your in more countries than any other culture
@@thomasmontgomery805 it's God given right to indians for settling in north and south america
As Christoffer Columbus was searching india when he found Americas accidently and named natives as red indian 😂 so you can think Jesus want indians in America
Because they are crossing the border.
But Killing unarmed Intruder is a crime according to the Indian Penal code
@@rashedbahadur21 then why crossing illegally?
@@rashedbahadur21why don't you talk about violence against Bangladeshi hindus from last two months?
@@adibaba7those 2 died recently were Bangladeshi hindu. Are telling me to talk about them? Well rn im talking about themm
@@youngsyzennlol killing minority Hindus from last 2 months and now you talk about them ?
Stop playing victim card
India has open boundaries with Nepal. Its not possible to have one with Bangladesh due to the demographic sensitivities in Indian north eastern region. Not to mention how terrorists often found shelter in bangladesh.
I'm honestly not surprised that your panelist did not even mention this commonly understood thing.
There are 27 million bangladeshi illegal immigrants in india
Our per capita income is higher than you 2784 dollar. Thik and comment
@@JusticeNeeded-k4dwhat about population.
@@JusticeNeeded-k4dkiddo listen..... During covid, only for short time Bangladesh's per capita became more than India... That was momentary due to lockdowns
😂
I heard in India 138 crore Bangladeshi lives. Only 2 crores inidan live.
These hindus were secular and choosed to live in bangladesh when india got partition so why should india let them in?
The report are over exemplified, since we don't know who those two children were and what they were doing
Ur right
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF 🙏🙏🙏
Child might have killed by Bangladesh border force
Hypocrisy
They were killed by BSF
Indian BSF killed her... her mother says
Yes the girl and the boy was killed by Bangladeshi Radicals and the body was thrown in side India to defame the Indian BORDER guards ...
then how the come body was returned after 2 days by BSF? Stop the hypocrisy please.
So i give suggestions.
Germany give visa to this person.
Not give ant suggestions to me first look your own actions you try to stop free speech by removing citizenship of people which one is talking about Palestine.
It is not acceptable if a Bangladeshi is going to enter illegally, but murder is not acceptable through judicial means, it can be resolved through negotiation
Indian BSF army are very cruel they killed many innocent children in border
border security force........ it's their duty to guard our border......they are not entering into Bangladesh and then killing people....... don't cross the border illegally.
I wonder why are your children travelling 400 km away from their home and trying to cut the border fence 🤔
@@pritsingh9766 They live in near the border
Then why people try to enter illegally?
@@md_ibrahim_fahadso? illegal border crossings is not a crime ? Security forces don't allow that
Oh such a blatant lie..DW is this deliberate or your reporters are misleading you?..I am here in Assam in India bordering bangladesh. We have been travelling in and out of Bangladesh freely after 2014 modi govt..the new govt in Bangladesh has not just started anti India stance but also anti India through your very channel where facts ard not checked prior to publishing the world...this is not journalism..you are creating a narrative which is false.. shame DW
Come with papers , dont cross illegally
Do u know how much it takes to get a visa?
@@34tsef so illegally u will enter?
@@Cricketlove.14 You didn't answer my question. Answer.
@@34tsef for which country?
@@Cricketlove.14 Which country's people India shoot on this video?
Not only Bangladeshi cross or enter border. Indian citizen come or enter Bangladeshi border but no one killed by bgb or BSF,,!!
@@sudarsansingha6233As we know many India till now live in open area. Don't even have a toilet! Why they will go?
Right, my channel based on this types of video
@@asmrahath213lol kanglu saying this😂beggers
What facilities does bd provide so that people will go to bd desh@@asmrahath213
Those are Bangladeshis already settled in India.
There was a news article recently, that bunch of Bangaladeshi men trying to apply for jobs in south of India.
Not Bangladeshi bengali hindu kolkata
Kindly research about Employment, Indians is Working in Bangladesh way more the Bangladeshi’s are working in India.
@@NazmulHasan-kl3sw that's why more of your people try to inflitrate the border.
@@NazmulHasan-kl3swI saw on news when protest happening in bangladesh..5 bangladeshi saying infront of reporter...I am from banglades...what would you say.???
Boycott India and Israel... Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇧🇩🇵🇸
Please don't apply for medical visa to India. Simple
Beggars😂😂
😂😂
First give Indian loan back & then bark here.
🤣🤣🤣
Very common incidents in the Bangladesh border.
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF 🙏🙏🙏
3:27 I have family relatives in USA. But I don't know why US ask me to take a visitor Visa instead of considering the fact that since my relatives in USA, its my birth right to enter ILLEGALLY. 😅😅
Stay safe, stay in your borders 😅
last 3 days more than 10 indian people cross bangaldesh boarder.
Infact 1 man was a solider of BSF. They arrested by BGB...
But Bangladesh Boarder Guard(BGB) didn’t killed them.
This is deference Between BGB and BSF....
BSF is a terrorists organisation....
In recent days lots of India’s are arrested from Bangladesh side border. BGB didn’t kill anyone.
BSF is killer force who kills unarmed poor people. When its about a regular force just remember 2001. Lots of BSF died in boarder by BDR (current BGB). So we know your power
@@asmrahath213 Brother you are confusing BSF with BGB and vice-versa.
@@Azad-cr4rl No. What I wrote is truth. Just google it. Your BJP godi media will not show them
@@asmrahath213 Your advice to me is that don't follow godi media because it has agenda which is disliked by you. But follow another group of media with diff agenda and it shows news favorable to your sentiments. Nice advice :)
What I trust is Indian army, there are father's of my friends who are in BSF, they are upstanding citizens. So yeah I can have my faith in them. Whilst what happened to the government who trusted Bangladeshi army, they were couped. So, good fking luck mate
India Tigers in Bangladesh border. And cat in Pakistan, China border 😂
😆Go and ask Pakistanis what kind of treatment they receive when they try to cross the border. In China border, only few Tibetans cross the border illegally, we have no problems with Tibetans, they are friendly people.
Bulao pakistan ko
This is brutal, Indian Border Guard thinks everyone is criminal and shoots without a single thought!!
And this has continued from a long time.
no it was not there thats why 25 million bangladeshis live in india illeagely right now it is changing and these serves our national interests
@@Gurukant-rt6yt bro it's more than 50million
Do not enter India illegally, if you want to enter apply for a visa and passport then come.. border security forces are being deployed to secure the border.. and they are doing good job
Cry more
@@avinashh34 on paper 25 but yes reality can be different
Let Germany be generous and take all the Bangladeshis living in India.
Many Indian people crossed border to Bangladesh 🇧🇩🙄. They are held in prison 🙄. Two Indian border guards were held for illegal crossing
Did they die though ?
Why would anyone cross to Bangladesh lol
@@TheGreatVivek7then how did the get caught in Bangladesh by BGB?
@@asmrahath213because Bangladesh is good in backstabbing😂😂
@@badlav120 your comment says you are a member of BJP IT cell. How much money you earn by these comments?
Biggest Joke : Innocent Border Cross Overs 😂 , if you aren’t carrying illegal stuff then cross through checkposts legally 🙏🏼
3:10 it's not done by India, it's done by bangladeshis it happened before.
You guys are so brainwashed 2nd isreal 😭
@@Terror__y78keep crying
Border security force India
Thank you for spreading the truth, always spread this way. Indian media does not maintain neutrality towards Bangladesh, they speak in favor of India.
What neutrality?? Cross border illegally without visa is illicit act and you have to face consequences
😂
Joker try to tell jokes 😂😂
Because Bangladesh is conducting a hybrid war against India. Cue ... various Baltic experts.
India doesn't measure Bangladeshi citizens as a human
Exactly
Yes, we do, now don't come here illegally.
Thats why millions of Bangladeshi are living in India illegally. 😂
We call mia in assam 😂
Yes bro ...take care bangladeshi rohangia in your country 😊
BGB is a friendly force but BSF is a killer force..
Because no one from India enter Bangladesh illegally
Based BSF .Now fear them and stop crossing the border illegally.
😂😂😂
Then Germany should also let Russians to cross their borders because their are innocent. 😂😂😂
Save minorities in bangladeshi 😢😢😢
Reduce majority in bangladesh
Carve out land from bangladesh for minority
Save Bangladesh from Ethnic minority.
first, save minorities in your county then tell others to save.
😂😂😂
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF 🙏🙏🙏
Illegal Bangladeshi immigration to India is a major headache in North-East India. India has the right to protect her borders and sovereignty. Bangladesh Govt should work in these border areas to educate some of these "innocent" people to avoid loss of lives !
I thank this news has a agenda
Bcz this is not a godi media
What agenda
@@asmrahath213 avg brainwashed kid by dhrv tatti
@@asmrahath213 thats why they have a tight security in germany for international borders and when it comes to india border security it is not good thats what they think and do fullfill their agenda
@@subasthapa4839 why there is no reporting of how 20% bangladeshi hindu now only became 9 or 2 and why there is no reporting on killing of Hindus by Islamists in bangladesh
My country is Bangladesh. India has opened the barrage, Bangladesh crop production has been destroyed. Roads are broken. India media is spreading rumors in the name of Bangladesh.
India has sent aliens of mars to atak bangladesh 😭😭
it is bangladeshi propagnda we gave you independence and now you are paying your depts like this search on internet there is nothing like that happened
Indian BSF Killed Bangladeshi people In Border Area, Not a Safe Bangladesh people In India Bangladesh Border Area.😢😢😭😭
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from Indian BSF.
Keep bangladeshi hindus and miya in your Dhaka
Border is no joke.
Save Bangladeshi hindus from Indian border forces
live in cuba
DW should also carry out a study on the illegal influx of Bangladeshis into India since decades !
If you try to cross international border then definitely border guard will not welcome with garlands.
How one can cross international border without visa?
What is artificial border? what do you mean by friendly border. We Bengalis do no want to have open border with Bangladesh ever.
Indian BSF has been killing people violating all sorts of international border law for couple of decades ... Bangladesh showed their maximum restraints and professionalism in that case
West think, they can manipulate facts and other will not understand. who is being dumb here 😎😎😂😂
Indian BSF doing this extra judicial killing over the decades. Please raise your voices international communities. BSF broke all international laws.
Which international laws? Can you mention a few? If you have proper evidence do submit it through post or online to the supreme court of India as PIL. Don't mislead people with your false narrative
Thanks For Showing The True Situation.
Hundreds of thousands of Indians are working in Bangladesh illegally.
If Germany want they can borrow them we are enough population.
This lady is ashamed of hindus, where is the eye opening opinion of Bangladeshi Hindu killing, Israeli attack on Palestine Lebanon? Where is the opinion of the Russian attack on Ukraine? Talking under AC room and living High profile status and giving opinion to others is very easy..😮😮😮😮.
What non sense. It is problem of Bangladesh that they don't educate their citizens living near the borders. They should apply for visa. Border security force is just doing their job like everywhere else. If this paid human right activist who was reading from script has issues then she should force government in bangladesh to educate their public properly. It is their problem.
murder of an unarmed intruder is a crime as per your country’s law as well as international. The fact that you don’t have this common sense also shows why your country’s troop commits such vile murders. No moral or common sense found
@@ananna6193name any international law and also that indian law only applies to Indians not to bangladeshis
@@ananna6193 OK FOOL,WHY ARE YOU CROSSING ILLEGEALY IN THE FIRST PLACE
This is the real face of indian BSF
OK FOOL,WHY ARE YOU CROSSING ILLEGEALY IN THE FIRST PLACE
This is called neutral reporting unlike godi media 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Lol it's far left media not neutral
😂😂😂 lol says Bangladeshi this is an anti India leftist foringe media 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Illegal rohangia talking about journalism 😊
OK FOOL,WHY ARE YOU CROSSING ILLEGEALY IN THE FIRST PLACE
This is the reality.
Rampant smuggling, illegal immigrants going to hindu sthan to snatch low end jobs in Kerala, delhi ...changing demographic of each nation even in europe ... so ...what to do...😮😮😮😢😢😮😢😢
Save Bangladeshi Hindu from BSF.
Crossing border without permission what did he expect a bouquet??
Thanks DW news❤
India 🇮🇳 killing Bangladeshi innocent civilians in the border Indian showed muscles power to the Bangladeshi citizens
Why you have to croos the boarder
@@freeman4758muslim can't cross border. Hidus cross border because there live many relative.
@@opoahammnadahammnad2342 DONT CROOS,DONT GET SHOOT,IT IS SIMPLE
We want justice and peace 🙏 Save us.
So live in your own country
Where is Indian andhbhakt.. why they barki*"ng for Bangladeshi hindu
Yes, the officer who shot her should be brought to justice. I am also shocked at how India is treating Bangladeshi Hindus. She shouldn’t have crossed illegally but shooting her is far too extreme. She can be detained or sent back but this kind of thing is wrong. This doesn’t however justify how Islamists in Bangladesh are harassing Hindus and now trying to ban Durga Puja.
We want justice 😢 😢😢
if two unarmed children was threat for fully armed guards, then you need to think twice about your threat. yes, crosssing border without punishment is crime, but does that crime results in murder? where is the proportonality of force? can someone shot someone who has no arms in theri hand?
Naxalites , smugglers crossed the borders illegally thats a big issue for this border it's bad for both the countries you're talking like they've killed him for fun it's and international border not a state border but rip for those who lost their lives
And it's not about arms or without arms there are many illegal immigrants too in india ofcourse we can't deport them back bangladesh don't allow that so securing a border is a better option
@@avinashchaudhary8545 and the security method is killing them?children under 12???
@@md.samsurrahaman6758 it's doesn't matter your smugglers use this children as a asset your children is your responsibility we will tolerate any illegal inflitrators.
@@SurajMandal-lj6hc so according to you if we can't take care of our Children, your country has the right to shoot them? Without giving them fair chance to go through judiciary and court process? Thank you for your amazing argument, makes sense now actually..
Germany should give them citizenship .😂😂
Why international media shout up about Chittagong hill tracts?
Bcoz we don’t work like you in sikim and kashmir.
@@JusticeNeeded-k4dTaqiyya.
@@toxicpanda9371indian propagandu u r.
@@abrarfaisalabir8929 Bangladeshi propogandu u r.
Beause they are well aware of indian backed separatist group who live in those hill tracts.
Average west mindset 😂😂and paid news ...y Germany and west countries not taking immigrants?? Because of that west countries colonisation so many countries now facing problem s
Thanks for reporting, dw. 🇧🇩🇧🇩
Minority Young Girl sharna das was crossing to meet her relative.But Indian BSF killed her and took her body inside India.😢. Her mother was lucky she was just injured..
zombies victim card on dw...DW ask German gov to free your border for all zombies 🤣
Thanks to DW.
Thanks DW News for looking into this
India has all right to protect its borders..... Respect the border..... ❤🇮🇳
Thanks dw news to report the truth 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤.A big respect from me
😂😂😂
I read this news bangladesh soldiers killed those hindu children of bangladesh and then started to blame indian soldiers that they killed those kids.
You need to first full research about this situation . Then make news ..
You spread Misiformation
yeah like indian godi media right? 😂😂
Thanks for the truth DW