A big salute to Raftaar for speaking out on this topic. I have tried my best to raise awareness among my friends about this broken Islamic education system. I’ve talked to Masjid Qari Sahabs and commented on a few major Islamic channels, but all of these channels focused on countering atheism and feminism and presenting how logical and scientific Islam is (which of course it is and I am not an atheist nor a feminist). However, they completely ignore this issue and turn a blind eye to the fact that children in these institutions are treated worse than animals. I am a Hafiz myself, and in these institutions, the idea of building critical thinking is nonexistent. Students aren’t even taught basic manners. Most of my Hafiz friends have stopped reading the Quran because of the way they were taught, including myself. However, Allah guided me, and now I try my best to understand the verses rather than mindlessly reciting them. May Allah reward you and keep you steadfast on true Islamic values. May Allah guide us all.
similar experience tbh, I'm becoming a Hafiz and if Allah Almighty hadn't guided me, I would have gone astray. But now I try to learn the meaning of the verses rather than blindly reciting them. Thanks to Abu Ala Al Maudidi R.A, Dr Israr and other great scholars of Islam..!
It is a dilemma which has befell on our society, and the whole culture of muslim sub continent, as a hafiz e Quran and someone who "Graduated" from a madrasah, i think our religious institutions need big reforms, we need to include scientific studies, philosophy, engineering and other 21st century education contents ASAP, turning a blind eye to these issues won't solve them, in a time when our colleges and universities have become a hub of neo atheism and radical liberalism, it is time to turn around, otherwise i fear the thing ibn e khaldun talked about in his "Al Muqaddimah" will fell upon this hollow empire of madaris
@@raochauhan7060 bulkul Allah da ga lakin Kyo mardarsa sa parha hua bacha government job ya it ya doctor naih ban pata Deen or Dunia 2no taleem Dani chia aista mardarsa ka bacha Dunia ke har field ma aa jaya ga ya lo bhottt zabardast insaan ho ga Kyo ka inka pass 2no ilam ho ga wo Bater teriqa sa Dunia ko guide Kara ga ak office hai is main 10 log Kam karta hai 8 log Jin ko Deen or Dunia 2no ka ilam hai wo baqi 2no logo ko guide Kara ga inka fida ho ga
میں نے یہ پوری ویڈیو دیکھی ہے اور اس میں صرف ایک مدرسے کو ڈسکس کیا جا رہا ہے اور اسی بیس پر کچھ بھی بولا جا رہا ہے۔ میں نے 9 سال مدرسے پڑھا کے دنیاوی تعلیم پرائمری ہے لیکن مجھے مدارس نے گرافک ڈیزائننگ ، ویڈیو ایڈیٹنگ اور اے آئی کے سینکڑوں ٹول سے سکھائے ہیں۔ میں یہ بات دعوے سے کہ سکتا ہوں کہ جتنے اے آئی ٹولز مجھے آتے ہیں شاید اس ویڈیو بنانے والے کو بھی نہ آتے ہوں۔ بہر حال مدارس زندہ باد❤
@Tayyab_Ali_Official_2 آپ کی اطلاع کے لئے میں نے الحمدللہ سات سے آٹھ مدارس میں پڑھا ہے اور رہی بات یہ کہ میں نے ایک مدرسے کو بنیاد بنایا تو جناب یہ بات تو آپ نے سمجھی ہے اور الحمدللہ اس وقت بھی 200 سے 250 ہے قریب مدارس میں جان پہچان اور تعلقات والے ہیں اور ان میں سے کئی تو باہر کے ممالک بھی ہیں ۔ لہذا جتنا میں مدارس کو جانتا ہوں شاید یہ ویڈیو بنانے والا اس کا 0.1 فیصد بھی نہ جانتا ہو۔ یہ ڈائریکٹ اسلام پہ نہیں بول سکتے تو دینی درسگاہوں کو نشانہ بناتے ہیں اور ویووز کماتے ہیں۔
I felt this documentary as I went through this torture in my childhood, spent 5 precious childhood years of mine in Madrassah where I was subject to torture and brutality from jangli molvis. Finally when I came out of it, I made sure that no one in my family goes through this torture ever again. For 5 years I memorized Quran without knowing a single thing inside it. After 30 years I have finally started my journey of understanding of Quran, thanks to Dr Israr RA and now I know what our Quran teaches us. That 5 year torture made such a big impact on my life that I started hating every man who was associated with madrassah
@@tahagul5256 same here.....ma na b apna 5 saal mdrssa mn lgayn 3 saal mn hifz Kiya Jo yad hi Nahi or 2 Saal Arabic or English language mn .......in salon Ka yahi asar huwa Ka ma har us shakhs SA nafrat Karna laga Jo mdrssa SA relate krta ho
@@hiddenboy32بھائی صاحب اپ حفظ کر رہے تھے نا تو حفظ میں اپ کو مطلب کیوں سمجھائیں گے اگر قران کا مطلب سمجھنا ہے تو اپ کو عالم بننا پڑے گا اس کے لیے عربی کورس ہوگا اس کے لیے عربی کی چیزیں ہوں گی گرامر ہوگی اس کی مثال اپ کو میں اس طریقے سے دیتا ہوں کہ اپ bio کے کلاس میں جا کر کمپیوٹر سمجھنا چاہتے ہیں عقل سے کام لیں اللہ اپ کو ہدایت دے
It’s commendable that Raftaar has openly addressed this critical issue. Problems that push people toward darkness, whether societal, spiritual, or cultural, are universal and transcend religious boundaries. By bringing them to light, we can foster awareness, understanding, and meaningful dialogue across communities. lots of love from India
@@fharoon2011 My comment was never about comparing science and the Religion or suggesting that one represents light while the other represents darkness. The phrase 'bringing to light' refers to raising awareness about important issues that affect individuals and communities. It does not diminish the value of spiritual or religious guidance, including the Quran, which holds a revered place in addressing moral, ethical, and spiritual matters. Science helps us understand the physical world, while the Quran provides guidance on how to live a purposeful and meaningful life. Both have their unique roles and can coexist harmoniously, inspiring us to seek truth and betterment in all aspects of life. Much love and respect to everyone."
مدارس کو غربت،دقیانوسی اور پرانے خیالات سے جوڑنے کے لیے دیہات کے ایک مدرسہ اور طلبہ کو ڈاکومنٹری کا حصہ بنایا گیا حالانکہ وہاں کے اسکولوں کا بھی یہی حال ہے۔
madaris aaj kal k muashray mein aik aisa cancer hain jis mein har buaraaye sikhaye jate ha. Munafqat, badkarian aur intiha pasandi. Aik waqt tha madaris jin mein tamam uloom ka mutalia ibadat samjh k kerwaya jata tha ab us mein sirf Islam k apni pasand ka aqeeda thonsa jaraha ha.
to kya schools kay aisay halat hona madrasay kay halat ko justify krta hai? dono he major issues hain, agar video mai wo itnay major topic pr baat kr rahay hain to comparison or keeray nikalnay sai acha hai context smjha jya
In madaris ko shut down ker daina chahiyah jahan sirf ratta lagaya jata hai...pata nahi kabhi in ko kisi nay nahi bataya kay hadees say alfaz per gor karo....ratay laganay say jannat nahi milti. Amal aur deen, aur quran ko samajhana zaroori hai
I’m also a Hafiz, but my journey wasn’t easy. During my Hifz-e-Quran, I struggled with learning and was beaten brutally almost every day for three years by my Qari Sahib. 1. Despite the hardship, I eventually finished memorizing the Quran. 2. However, I realized I didn’t understand the meaning of what I had memorized, and that left me feeling empty. 3. Memorization without understanding isn’t as impactful as truly grasping the message of the Quran. After five years in this field (three years for Hifz and two years in Dars-e-Nizami), I made a difficult decision to give up. The experience left me traumatized, and I’ve come to resent that kind of approach to teaching. Now, I’ve shifted my focus to learning technologies, and I’m still on that journey. I hope my story can help others: - Focus on understanding the Quran’s message, not just memorizing it. - Support teaching with kindness and patience. - Keep learning, even if it means choosing a different direction.
@@WarisTanwari468 I don't think you are telling your story. Coz this is 100💯 thousand percent same like my story, I left study after becoming Hafiz e quran and in 2nd year of aalim ( arabi doum ) during early Covid year . Since then I moved to learning philosophy, science, technology, etc that chanes my perspective of observing the world
Jihalat he ye, khid jakr madaris me tehqeeq kr lo! Aik hi madrsa me khas jakr video bnaney ki waja kia he? Karachi me hotey he Raftaar waley Karachi me madaris km he jo wha gai! Baqwas ugal rahey he Raftaar
مدارس میں دینی تعلیم کے ساتھ دنیاوی تعلیم بھی دینی چاہیے اور بہت زیادہ مدارس میں دی جاتی ہے اب آپ ایک پسماندہ علاقے کے مدرسے میں جا کر اس کی ویڈیو بنا کر اسے سب سے نہیں ملا سکتے یہاں لوگ سیلری نہیں دیتے مدرسے سے تعاون بھی اس طرح نہیں کرتے پھر برا بھلا بھی مدرسے کو کہتے ہیں باقی مدرسے میں بہت کچھ تبدیل کرنے والے ہے کچھ لوگوں نے اس نظام کو برا کر دیا ہے مگر آپ کے ایک سوال نے بہت دکھ دیا کہ حفظ کر کے کیا ملے گا 😢
@@Muhammad-Ali94 بالکل درست بات ہے۔ غربت زدہ ماحول میں مدرسوں نے بچوں کو سمیٹ کر رکھا ہوا ہے۔ ان کو قران کی تعلیم بھی دے رہے ہیں، چھت بھی اور کھانا بھی۔ اور یہ سب بغیر حکومتی سرپرستی میں۔ ہونا تو یہ چاہیے تھا کہ اتنی بڑی خدمت کو سراہا جاتا اور اگر کوئی خرابی ہے تو اس کا حل تلاش کیا جاتا۔ لیکن مدارس کو ایسے پیش کیا گیا گویا معاشرے کی تمام خرابیوں کی جڑ ہی مدارس ہیں۔ بہت افسوس۔ نہ جانے کس کس کو خوش کیا ہے یہ ویڈیو بنا کر رفتار نے۔
بلکل درست فرمایا آپ نے ان کو تو سب معلوم ہونے کے باوجود اس طرح کی باتیں کرتے ہیں ان سے عرض ہے کہ جب سانس روک جائے گی تب پتہ چلے گا کہ حافظ قرآن کی کیا قدر ہے
@raftar I truly appreciate the work you do. As a fan, I must say that I genuinely care about your channel and your team. Your efforts, the unique voice you bring, and the sensitive topics you address whether political or religious are truly commendable. Unfortunately, our collective mindset often leans towards extremes. When it comes to political issues, the reaction is often “silence them,” while for religious matters, it can escalate to labeling others as heretics or worse. This reflects how deeply ingrained and polarized our thinking has become, with development and progress viewed in extremes either entirely right-wing or left-wing.I appreciate your courage and dedication.. Keep up the great work
علیکم اپ نے یہ بات بالکل صحیح کہی کہ ہمارے علماء میں بہت زیادہ غلطیاں ہیں لیکن میری ایک گزارش ہے کہ اگر اپ اپنا یہ تبصرہ کسی بھی تجزیہ نگار کو دکھا دیں جو ذرا سا بھی انفارمیشن یا جانکاری رکھتا ہو تو بتا دے گا کہ یہ ایک انتہائی جانبدارانہ تبصرہ یا رائے تھی اپ نے تمام مکاتب فکر پر تنقید کی لیکن کسی سے بھی رائے لینے کی زحمت گوارا نہیں کی بلکہ اس کی جگہ غامدی صاحب کے فرقہ کے ایک صاحب کو اپ نے یہ موقع دیا جب کہ تمام حضرات جانتے ہیں کہ ان کا نقطہ نظر کیا ہے بہتر ہوتا کہ اپ ان کے ساتھ دوسرے علماء کرام یا کم از کم اوریا مقبول جان صاحب یا قیصر احمد راجہ یا جامعۃ الرشید جن کا دعوی ہے کہ ان کے سٹوڈنٹ بیوروکریسی میں بھی جاتے ہیں عدالتوں میں بھی جاتے ہیں جج بھی بنتے ہیں انہیں بھی اظہار رائے کا موقع دیتے شاید اس میں اپ کا بھی کوئی قصور نہیں جس طرح پاکستان کا ہر ادارہ گراوٹ کا شکار ہے اسی طرح ہماری تحقیقات بھی لولی لنگڑی ہوتی ہیں شکریہ
رفتار کی ٹیم نے اس بار جس مافیا کو ہاتھ ڈالا ہے جس کو کم سے کم پاکستان میں رہ کر تو سوال بھی نہیں کیا جا سکتا۔ اللہ پاک آپ کو اپنے حفظ و امان میں رکھے۔ آمین
Religious mafia ki taaqat ko itna barrhane ke peechay hath h Gen Zia ul haq ,Gen Akhter abdur rehman aur Gen Hameedgul doosray lafzon main military 🪖 establishment aur aaj bhi yeh establishment he hai jiski wajah se TTP , TLP , Lashkar e Jhangvi ,hizbultahreer , lal masjid aur na janay kitne tarah tarah ke ye khatarnak religious seminaries control s bahir ho rahi hn In sub ko check-in balance main laane k liye military elite isi ko lagam dallni hogi aur sath he ek aisa environment paida krna hoga k log apne bachon ko inn se inke shar se dur rakhna he sahih samjhain
بہت زبردست ویڈیو ❤ ابھی مزید اس طرح کے حقائق نہ صرف دیکھانے چاہئیے بلکہ ان قاری قرآء حضرات کے لئے حل بھی بہت ضروری ہے جس میں خود ایک استاد کو کچھ دنیاوی معلومات کا ہونا ضروری ہے کہ جس میں اپنی قرآن یا کسی بھی مضمون کی تعلیم اپنے موبائل اور انٹرنیٹ کی مدد سے آنلائن بھی پڑھا سکیں تا کہ کم از کم ایک فائنینشلی ٹینشن نہ ہو سکے ۔ انشاءاللّٰہ ہم خود بھی اس کوشش میں لگے ہیں کہ ہر قاری قرآء حضرات کو یہ ہنر سیکھایا جائے کہ جو کام آپ مدرسے میں بیٹھ کر کر رہے ہیں یہی آنلائن بھی کریں تاکہ آنلائن پڑھا کر آنلائن پوری دنیا میں ثواب اور تبلیغ کے ساتھ ساتھ ڈالرز میں کما سکیں ۔ جزاک اللّٰہ خیر Keep it up RAFTAR 🔥
thank you entire team of Raftar for making wonderful documentary on this burning issue . The core problem is admit the mistakes by religious establishment , blind faiths on hand made things , Syllabus and stereotypes , major reforms in the syllabus of madaris (darse nizami) but nevertheless there are so many madaris now adays are adopting technology and modern education we should also encourage them i.e ( saylani , baitu salam , etc etc . you should discuss them and encourage them as token of appreciation Raftar Team should also make video on suggestion and recommendations of reforming this system and should also address the religious establishment to take corrective action .. ( amal karein na karein un ki marzi hai ) thanks and keep it up
Madrassh should be under the control of the government in which Science should be taught,and through this way they can also be safe from spreading firqa and extremism.
Raftar Team! A big salute to you guys, it's not just about this video or topic or any other you talked about. But the true definition of journalism. Whether it's politics, current affairs, religious debate or general details. Although " hr baat k darjanoun pehlu hotay hain, or hr insaan apni sooch, tareeqat or practicality k according topic mold krta hai" but i truly appreciate your efforts. I would love to see if you unveil the facts why Pakistan consider as a "Dark State". The role of establishment and army. It might be challenging but delivering the facts is your work of art. Do it guys 👍 Best of luck.
For the past two days, I have been continuously watching Raftaar's videos. I truly realize how much effort you all are putting in to enlighten the minds of the youth, who have been distracted by recent events happening in the country.❤
@Raftar hats off to you guys . The work you are doing in Pakistan have no words equivalent to glorify you guys . Please consider making a documentary of darbars and the shirk going on there in the name of Islam.❤❤❤
Great presentation with bold questions and logical presentation. The single line in this video has deep meaning with concern. This boss and his team are teaching something new. Hats off sir to you and the entire team.
After the completion of hifiz i left madrasa and I am proud of it. The reason is they suffer all the way from their childhood to the rest of their lives.
Big mistake at 34:30. Darse Nizami wasnt initiated by Nizam ul Mulk (1018-1092). It was founded by Nizamuddin Sihalivi Ansari (1677-1748). 700 year difference.
bhai bilkul sahi bataya app me ne 8 years tak mudrisse me phara ha waha pharai kam aur mar zayada ha sare mudrise almost same business model ko follow kar rahe he chanda lo aur bache jama karo 99% log sirf apne bache ke ghalti samajte he aur mudrisse ke qari ke khalif koi nahi bolta me ne 90% sirf gareeb bache he mudrise me dekhe he jin ko pharne ka koi shok nahi sirf apni zindgi guzar rahe he mudrise ke chande pe is ke illawaa aur bhe bhot masail he mudrisoo me jin par koi bat nahi karta abb agar me yahe batao to log to fir mudrisse ka nam hi kharab ho ga jo bache mudrisse me rehte he un se puch lena kabhi mudrisse ka hal
مفتی شفیع صاحب نے اگر مدارس کو ختم کرنے کی بات کی تھی اس کا مطلب تھا کہ اب الگ مدارس کی ضرورت نہیں رہی جو انگریز دور میں تھی اب پاکستان وجود میں آچکا ہے لہذا قومی اداروں میں دینی و دنیاوی تعلیم ایک ساتھ ہو گی لیکن افسوس ایسا نہیں ہو سکا سرکاری تعلیمی ادارے دینی تعلیم نہیں دے سکے اور مدارس کو دینی تعلیم کے لیے مدارس قائم کرنے کی ضرورت پیش آئی
No doubt, all of this is happening. I am thankful to Raftaar for making this very insightful video. However, you should also highlight the latest Islamic institutes that are addressing these core problems, such as Youth Club, Hikmah Institute, Ribat, Naseeha Institute, IBA CEIF, and others.
Im also hafize Quraan Alhamdulillah...or aj hifz k 19 saal baad bhee mein ny jo hifz kia hai usy samajhny ki koshish kar rha hun or uska faida mri zaat ko aj ho rha hai..Mery khayal m quraan pak hifz karny se ziada faida quraan pak ko samajh kr parhny se hoga..agar quraan yad krwany se ziada smjhany py zor dia jai to yad krna ziada asaan hoga or insan ki apni zaat pe bhee isky bht musbat asraat hongy zindagi k har shoby mein..hum yad krwany par itna zor dety hn k jb samajhny ka waqt ata hai to ziada tar bachay us qabil he ni rehty...or madrasson m gher ikhlaqi waqiat ki waja bhee yhi hai k hmen pata he ni hota k Allah pak hmen kia farma rhy hn...agar quraan pak k sath school ki taleem bhee di jai to hr bacha deen or dunia dono sath le k chal skta hai or kamyab bhee ho skta hai..Allah pak hum sb ko deen or dunia mein kamyab kren..ameen
Topic Acha hai , lekin aik sawal hai Hamari konsi university ne koi bada karnama kiya hai Koi invention Madraso wale to phir be akhlaq aur waldain ka ihteram karte hai hamare university walo mai to ye be nahi hota Siraf madaris ko nahi hamre mulk mai sab he ulta or kharab hai
I appreciate to Raftar Team , very good topic , there is very necessary to highlight theses issues continues basis, because very important to knows our peoples, how can used these organisation
A child, who wants to become a doctor, but couldn't due to lack of resources. Some are orphans; all are tied with the chain of poverty. The society doesn't respect the poor, socially and economically deprived class. An empty belly can lead towards compromising positions, where wild wolves are ready to tear a young soul. Who cares? Nobody. At least their religion is giving those children a temporary shelter, security, food, and education. And, most importantly, the respect from the society due to religion. Or else who respects the poor class? The so-called educated people can disregard the madrasa education, calling it outdated, but who is going to change the root cause within the larger section of society that is poverty? Just merely overshadowing madrasa education and being intellectual doesn't solve the ground realities of the deprived class of society. At last, religion and science stand both face to face. One is with the deprived section of society, and the other has moved so ahead with time that the so-called sophisticated piece of educated shits can just use technical jargons to sound intelligent, but in hindsight, they don't know real shit about science and technology. Leave aside the former aspect. That's the irony. For the entire documentary team, I have one word that is RESPECT. 👍
Yes i think there is no need of madaris but in finland in norway in korea where everyone have equally access to the school to the University. But in pakistan if someone teach a single alphabet to a single street child is a great blessing.
You should do a thorough documentary on the rise and fall of our educational system and what are private schools doing to our children why they are promoting secularism etc.
Secularism ? They are not teaching anything , secularism liberalism they all get this from social media . Private school colleges are just a business and government school is a place of uncivilized people .
The purpose of this video, as I understand it, is to discuss these issues and explain them in detail to find a solution to these problems. I believe this is the main objective of the video. The aim of this video is certainly not to degrade Islam or madrasas, but to acknowledge our mistakes and, by looking at the current situation, find a solution to these problems.
RAFTAR ! The most sensitive issue deal in every So-called Ummah of Indian Sub-Continent 😂unfortunately hijacked by TEAM mullah's Mufti's Moullana's Hypocrites politicians....GooD noble WorK ! RaftaR Keep it Up ❤
Salute to Raftar you are doing Real Journalism. I pray for Sir Aftab Iqbal who talked about this channel in one of his show and I discovered you guys earlier on. More power to all the team of Raftaar. You are really working for betterment of Pakistan and Pakistanis. KUDOS
41:20 اللہ پاک ہمارے عظیم محسنوں خیرخواہوں سائنسدانوں طبیب علماءحق اور تمام اچھے انسانیت دوست ہمدرد کرداروں اور مجاہدین حق کی حفاظت فرمائے اور ہمیں ان سے ترقی و فائدہ لینے کی توفیق و مواقع عطافرمائے۔ آمین
Beshak! Afsose yeh he ke - Yahan India me bhi Madrasaaon k yahee haal he - specially Urdu & Dakhni also hindi Speaking lands muslims (mostly here turkic curriculum is followed) , Malayam madarasa's situation is little better I think (they follow little different curriculum- some of them also include biology and cleaness - I got known about these resently - am impressed). & Mentality of most of the people is also same -( Madaras is mostly for backwards - less encouraged towards critical thinking - Rigid religious beliefs - creates aalims or hafiz who are not Actually )
کیا بات ہے رفتار کی ماشاﷲ، بہت خوب ایک ایک سیکینڈ بہت پراثر تھا۔ سونے پر سوہاگہ احسن سبز بھائی کی داستان گوئی کا تو کوئی جواب ہی نہیں۔ پلیز احسن بھائی کو زیادہ سے زیادہ ویڈیوز میں رکھا کریں۔
I agreed with this Me khud wifaq ul madaris ka student hun aur molana Hanif jhalandri bilkul ghalat BAAT ker rahy Hain Jab tak hum galti to accept Nahi karengy hum khud ko kesy sahi ker saktay Hain?
A big salute to Raftaar for speaking out on this topic. I have tried my best to raise awareness among my friends about this broken Islamic education system. I’ve talked to Masjid Qari Sahabs and commented on a few major Islamic channels, but all of these channels focused on countering atheism and feminism and presenting how logical and scientific Islam is (which of course it is and I am not an atheist nor a feminist). However, they completely ignore this issue and turn a blind eye to the fact that children in these institutions are treated worse than animals.
I am a Hafiz myself, and in these institutions, the idea of building critical thinking is nonexistent. Students aren’t even taught basic manners. Most of my Hafiz friends have stopped reading the Quran because of the way they were taught, including myself. However, Allah guided me, and now I try my best to understand the verses rather than mindlessly reciting them.
May Allah reward you and keep you steadfast on true Islamic values. May Allah guide us all.
100% agreed. I also have similar experience.
100% agreed. I also have similar experience.
similar experience tbh, I'm becoming a Hafiz and if Allah Almighty hadn't guided me, I would have gone astray. But now I try to learn the meaning of the verses rather than blindly reciting them.
Thanks to Abu Ala Al Maudidi R.A, Dr Israr and other great scholars of Islam..!
Rad Feminism for the win ❤
It is a dilemma which has befell on our society, and the whole culture of muslim sub continent, as a hafiz e Quran and someone who "Graduated" from a madrasah, i think our religious institutions need big reforms, we need to include scientific studies, philosophy, engineering and other 21st century education contents ASAP, turning a blind eye to these issues won't solve them, in a time when our colleges and universities have become a hub of neo atheism and radical liberalism, it is time to turn around, otherwise i fear the thing ibn e khaldun talked about in his "Al Muqaddimah" will fell upon this hollow empire of madaris
As a Hafiz e Quran i really felt the pain of Mudrassa
Student😭
Allah se mango wo sb dega, asli duniya wo he ye nahi
@@raochauhan7060bo bs térro rism violence hi krwaega
@@raochauhan7060 bulkul Allah da ga lakin Kyo mardarsa sa parha hua bacha government job ya it ya doctor naih ban pata Deen or Dunia 2no taleem Dani chia aista mardarsa ka bacha Dunia ke har field ma aa jaya ga ya lo bhottt zabardast insaan ho ga Kyo ka inka pass 2no ilam ho ga wo Bater teriqa sa Dunia ko guide Kara ga ak office hai is main 10 log Kam karta hai 8 log Jin ko Deen or Dunia 2no ka ilam hai wo baqi 2no logo ko guide Kara ga inka fida ho ga
@@raochauhan7060 Bhai ne kia kaha hai or ap kia keh rhe ho?
Bhai asal wazah hai jayada bachhe paida mat kro
میں نے یہ پوری ویڈیو دیکھی ہے اور اس میں صرف ایک مدرسے کو ڈسکس کیا جا رہا ہے اور اسی بیس پر کچھ بھی بولا جا رہا ہے۔
میں نے 9 سال مدرسے پڑھا کے دنیاوی تعلیم پرائمری ہے لیکن مجھے مدارس نے گرافک ڈیزائننگ ، ویڈیو ایڈیٹنگ اور اے آئی کے سینکڑوں ٹول سے سکھائے ہیں۔ میں یہ بات دعوے سے کہ سکتا ہوں کہ جتنے اے آئی ٹولز مجھے آتے ہیں شاید اس ویڈیو بنانے والے کو بھی نہ آتے ہوں۔
بہر حال مدارس زندہ باد❤
@Tayyab_Ali_Official_2 آپ کی اطلاع کے لئے میں نے الحمدللہ سات سے آٹھ مدارس میں پڑھا ہے
اور رہی بات یہ کہ میں نے ایک مدرسے کو بنیاد بنایا تو جناب یہ بات تو آپ نے سمجھی ہے
اور الحمدللہ اس وقت بھی 200 سے 250 ہے قریب مدارس میں جان پہچان اور تعلقات والے ہیں اور ان میں سے کئی تو باہر کے ممالک بھی ہیں ۔
لہذا جتنا میں مدارس کو جانتا ہوں شاید یہ ویڈیو بنانے والا اس کا 0.1 فیصد بھی نہ جانتا ہو۔
یہ ڈائریکٹ اسلام پہ نہیں بول سکتے تو دینی درسگاہوں کو نشانہ بناتے ہیں اور ویووز کماتے ہیں۔
@@hadigaming048 why do you write OOLTA
Ese madrase zara gin ke bataye kitne ha
@@Muhammad7770 Exactly. There’s not many.
I felt this documentary as I went through this torture in my childhood, spent 5 precious childhood years of mine in Madrassah where I was subject to torture and brutality from jangli molvis. Finally when I came out of it, I made sure that no one in my family goes through this torture ever again. For 5 years I memorized Quran without knowing a single thing inside it. After 30 years I have finally started my journey of understanding of Quran, thanks to Dr Israr RA and now I know what our Quran teaches us. That 5 year torture made such a big impact on my life that I started hating every man who was associated with madrassah
based
Mdrasa are biggest source of térro rism
❤
@@tahagul5256 same here.....ma na b apna 5 saal mdrssa mn lgayn 3 saal mn hifz Kiya Jo yad hi Nahi or 2 Saal Arabic or English language mn .......in salon Ka yahi asar huwa Ka ma har us shakhs SA nafrat Karna laga Jo mdrssa SA relate krta ho
@@hiddenboy32بھائی صاحب اپ حفظ کر رہے تھے نا تو حفظ میں اپ کو مطلب کیوں سمجھائیں گے
اگر قران کا مطلب سمجھنا ہے تو اپ کو عالم بننا پڑے گا اس کے لیے عربی کورس ہوگا اس کے لیے عربی کی چیزیں ہوں گی گرامر ہوگی
اس کی مثال اپ کو میں اس طریقے سے دیتا ہوں کہ اپ bio کے کلاس میں جا کر کمپیوٹر سمجھنا چاہتے ہیں
عقل سے کام لیں اللہ اپ کو ہدایت دے
This Documentary should be shown all over National platform ❤
It’s commendable that Raftaar has openly addressed this critical issue. Problems that push people toward darkness, whether societal, spiritual, or cultural, are universal and transcend religious boundaries. By bringing them to light, we can foster awareness, understanding, and meaningful dialogue across communities. lots of love from India
So science is light and Nauzubillah Quran is darkness?
@@fharoon2011 My comment was never about comparing science and the Religion or suggesting that one represents light while the other represents darkness. The phrase 'bringing to light' refers to raising awareness about important issues that affect individuals and communities. It does not diminish the value of spiritual or religious guidance, including the Quran, which holds a revered place in addressing moral, ethical, and spiritual matters.
Science helps us understand the physical world, while the Quran provides guidance on how to live a purposeful and meaningful life. Both have their unique roles and can coexist harmoniously, inspiring us to seek truth and betterment in all aspects of life. Much love and respect to everyone."
Mdrasa are biggest source of térro rism
@@roshangorule5440 Jazak Allah for being calm on such a reply
❤❤
مدارس کو غربت،دقیانوسی اور پرانے خیالات سے جوڑنے کے لیے دیہات کے ایک مدرسہ اور طلبہ کو ڈاکومنٹری کا حصہ بنایا گیا حالانکہ وہاں کے اسکولوں کا بھی یہی حال ہے۔
madaris aaj kal k muashray mein aik aisa cancer hain jis mein har buaraaye sikhaye jate ha. Munafqat, badkarian aur intiha pasandi. Aik waqt tha madaris jin mein tamam uloom ka mutalia ibadat samjh k kerwaya jata tha ab us mein sirf Islam k apni pasand ka aqeeda thonsa jaraha ha.
to kya schools kay aisay halat hona madrasay kay halat ko justify krta hai?
dono he major issues hain, agar video mai wo itnay major topic pr baat kr rahay hain to comparison or keeray nikalnay sai acha hai context smjha jya
Ye jo video saath saath dikha rahe hai, vo bhi vaha ki hai😅
In madaris ko shut down ker daina chahiyah jahan sirf ratta lagaya jata hai...pata nahi kabhi in ko kisi nay nahi bataya kay hadees say alfaz per gor karo....ratay laganay say jannat nahi milti. Amal aur deen, aur quran ko samajhana zaroori hai
Hence peoved, dono ka update hona lazmi he ab.
میں یونیورسٹی سے پوسٹ گریجویٹ ہوں مگر دین کی کم سے کم ضروری بنیادی تعلیم مجھے مدرسہ سے ہی حاصل ہوا۔
I’m also a Hafiz, but my journey wasn’t easy. During my Hifz-e-Quran, I struggled with learning and was beaten brutally almost every day for three years by my Qari Sahib.
1. Despite the hardship, I eventually finished memorizing the Quran.
2. However, I realized I didn’t understand the meaning of what I had memorized, and that left me feeling empty.
3. Memorization without understanding isn’t as impactful as truly grasping the message of the Quran.
After five years in this field (three years for Hifz and two years in Dars-e-Nizami), I made a difficult decision to give up. The experience left me traumatized, and I’ve come to resent that kind of approach to teaching.
Now, I’ve shifted my focus to learning technologies, and I’m still on that journey. I hope my story can help others:
- Focus on understanding the Quran’s message, not just memorizing it.
- Support teaching with kindness and patience.
- Keep learning, even if it means choosing a different direction.
@@WarisTanwari468 I don't think you are telling your story. Coz this is 100💯 thousand percent same like my story, I left study after becoming Hafiz e quran and in 2nd year of aalim ( arabi doum ) during early Covid year . Since then I moved to learning philosophy, science, technology, etc that chanes my perspective of observing the world
MashaAllah ❤
@@municlipMashaAllah ❤️❤️
ye series mazeed chlna chaiye.............. Allah karay aap logon ki aesi Documentaries sy Madaris Islahat krny pr majboor ho sakain
to shiya hay kiya
Jihalat he ye, khid jakr madaris me tehqeeq kr lo!
Aik hi madrsa me khas jakr video bnaney ki waja kia he?
Karachi me hotey he Raftaar waley Karachi me madaris km he jo wha gai!
Baqwas ugal rahey he Raftaar
مدارس میں دینی تعلیم کے ساتھ دنیاوی تعلیم بھی دینی چاہیے اور بہت زیادہ مدارس میں دی جاتی ہے اب آپ ایک پسماندہ علاقے کے مدرسے میں جا کر اس کی ویڈیو بنا کر اسے سب سے نہیں ملا سکتے یہاں لوگ سیلری نہیں دیتے مدرسے سے تعاون بھی اس طرح نہیں کرتے پھر برا بھلا بھی مدرسے کو کہتے ہیں باقی مدرسے میں بہت کچھ تبدیل کرنے والے ہے کچھ لوگوں نے اس نظام کو برا کر دیا ہے مگر آپ کے ایک سوال نے بہت دکھ دیا کہ حفظ کر کے کیا ملے گا 😢
@@Muhammad-Ali94 بالکل درست بات ہے۔ غربت زدہ ماحول میں مدرسوں نے بچوں کو سمیٹ کر رکھا ہوا ہے۔ ان کو قران کی تعلیم بھی دے رہے ہیں، چھت بھی اور کھانا بھی۔ اور یہ سب بغیر حکومتی سرپرستی میں۔ ہونا تو یہ چاہیے تھا کہ اتنی بڑی خدمت کو سراہا جاتا اور اگر کوئی خرابی ہے تو اس کا حل تلاش کیا جاتا۔ لیکن مدارس کو ایسے پیش کیا گیا گویا معاشرے کی تمام خرابیوں کی جڑ ہی مدارس ہیں۔ بہت افسوس۔ نہ جانے کس کس کو خوش کیا ہے یہ ویڈیو بنا کر رفتار نے۔
بلکل درست فرمایا آپ نے ان کو تو سب معلوم ہونے کے باوجود اس طرح کی باتیں کرتے ہیں ان سے عرض ہے کہ جب سانس روک جائے گی تب پتہ چلے گا کہ حافظ قرآن کی کیا قدر ہے
@@Muhammad-Ali94 جی بالکل صحیح کہا آپ نے
@@KashifBaloch-dq5jjلبرل ایجنڈا پھیلانے کی کوشش ہے یہ
@@shahryarahmad8236 If Pakistani’s dislike secular & liberal societies, they shouldn’t be running to the West…..
Wow.... One of the best videos for our society
Thank you raftaar for doing this effort this effort is priceless in this time for our society 😮 this effort is Very much appreciatable
One of the finest episode presented by Raftar....Thank you
@raftar
I truly appreciate the work you do. As a fan, I must say that I genuinely care about your channel and your team. Your efforts, the unique voice you bring, and the sensitive topics you address whether political or religious are truly commendable.
Unfortunately, our collective mindset often leans towards extremes. When it comes to political issues, the reaction is often “silence them,” while for religious matters, it can escalate to labeling others as heretics or worse. This reflects how deeply ingrained and polarized our thinking has become, with development and progress viewed in extremes either entirely right-wing or left-wing.I appreciate your courage and dedication.. Keep up the great work
Thanks for your kind words! We need more people like you!
@@raftartvیعنی مدرسے کے خلاف
@@raftartvاپ کی پوری ویڈیو مدرسے کے خلاف ہے
@@deinnaseehachannel172entertain a thought without accepting it !
Sign of educated mindset
This channel is a gem , never expected the existence of such a platform in Pakistan
علیکم
اپ نے یہ بات بالکل صحیح کہی کہ ہمارے علماء میں بہت زیادہ غلطیاں ہیں لیکن میری ایک گزارش ہے کہ اگر اپ اپنا یہ تبصرہ کسی بھی تجزیہ نگار کو دکھا دیں جو ذرا سا بھی انفارمیشن یا جانکاری رکھتا ہو تو بتا دے گا کہ یہ ایک انتہائی جانبدارانہ تبصرہ یا رائے تھی اپ نے تمام مکاتب فکر پر تنقید کی لیکن کسی سے بھی رائے لینے کی زحمت گوارا نہیں کی بلکہ اس کی جگہ غامدی صاحب کے فرقہ کے ایک صاحب کو اپ نے یہ موقع دیا جب کہ تمام حضرات جانتے ہیں کہ ان کا نقطہ نظر کیا ہے بہتر ہوتا کہ اپ ان کے ساتھ دوسرے علماء کرام یا کم از کم اوریا مقبول جان صاحب یا قیصر احمد راجہ یا جامعۃ الرشید جن کا دعوی ہے کہ ان کے سٹوڈنٹ بیوروکریسی میں بھی جاتے ہیں عدالتوں میں بھی جاتے ہیں جج بھی بنتے ہیں انہیں بھی اظہار رائے کا موقع دیتے
شاید اس میں اپ کا بھی کوئی قصور نہیں جس طرح پاکستان کا ہر ادارہ گراوٹ کا شکار ہے اسی طرح ہماری تحقیقات بھی لولی لنگڑی ہوتی ہیں
شکریہ
@@muhammadhassanafzal7135its second part
@@muhammadhassanafzal7135 بالکل صحیح فرمایا
Exactly 💯
Exactly
Buhut khoob janaab . I agree with you
رفتار کی ٹیم نے اس بار جس مافیا کو ہاتھ ڈالا ہے جس کو کم سے کم پاکستان میں رہ کر تو سوال بھی نہیں کیا جا سکتا۔ اللہ پاک آپ کو اپنے حفظ و امان میں رکھے۔ آمین
Religious mafia ki taaqat ko itna barrhane ke peechay hath h Gen Zia ul haq ,Gen Akhter abdur rehman aur Gen Hameedgul doosray lafzon main military 🪖 establishment aur aaj bhi yeh establishment he hai jiski wajah se TTP , TLP , Lashkar e Jhangvi ,hizbultahreer , lal masjid aur na janay kitne tarah tarah ke ye khatarnak religious seminaries control s bahir ho rahi hn
In sub ko check-in balance main laane k liye military elite isi ko lagam dallni hogi aur sath he ek aisa environment paida krna hoga k log apne bachon ko inn se inke shar se dur rakhna he sahih samjhain
بہت زبردست ویڈیو ❤ ابھی مزید اس طرح کے حقائق نہ صرف دیکھانے چاہئیے بلکہ ان قاری قرآء حضرات کے لئے حل بھی بہت ضروری ہے جس میں خود ایک استاد کو کچھ دنیاوی معلومات کا ہونا ضروری ہے کہ جس میں اپنی قرآن یا کسی بھی مضمون کی تعلیم اپنے موبائل اور انٹرنیٹ کی مدد سے آنلائن بھی پڑھا سکیں تا کہ کم از کم ایک فائنینشلی ٹینشن نہ ہو سکے ۔ انشاءاللّٰہ ہم خود بھی اس کوشش میں لگے ہیں کہ ہر قاری قرآء حضرات کو یہ ہنر سیکھایا جائے کہ جو کام آپ مدرسے میں بیٹھ کر کر رہے ہیں یہی آنلائن بھی کریں تاکہ آنلائن پڑھا کر آنلائن پوری دنیا میں ثواب اور تبلیغ کے ساتھ ساتھ ڈالرز میں کما سکیں ۔
جزاک اللّٰہ خیر
Keep it up RAFTAR 🔥
All muslims should watch these channels
1. Adam seeker
2. Zafar heretic
3. Ex muslim saahil
4. Nabi Asli
5. Harris sultan
thank you entire team of Raftar for making wonderful documentary on this burning issue .
The core problem is admit the mistakes by religious establishment , blind faiths on hand made things , Syllabus and stereotypes , major reforms in the syllabus of madaris (darse nizami)
but nevertheless there are so many madaris now adays are adopting technology and modern education we should also encourage them i.e ( saylani , baitu salam , etc etc .
you should discuss them and encourage them as token of appreciation
Raftar Team should also make video on suggestion and recommendations of reforming this system and should also address the religious establishment to take corrective action .. ( amal karein na karein un ki marzi hai )
thanks and keep it up
Finally someone is talking about this from long time me soch rha hn is mozo par koi kyn bat nhe karta
Madrassh should be under the control of the government in which Science should be taught,and through this way they can also be safe from spreading firqa and extremism.
BUT NOT UNDER THE TYPE OF GOVERNMENT AND ESTABLISHMENT WE ARE FACING RIGHT NOW....
@limeclassic578 Exactly,the current are the biggest fitna and extremist.I am taking about those which has the actual mandate
Hafiz Sayed became successful without the knowledge of science
That's the dream I don't think that's gonna happen . They cannot coexist .
The RAFTAR is among most impactful channels. Keep going ❤❤❤.
The girl saying doctor in a repressed voice just breaks my heart
BEST DOCCUMENTARY I HAVE EVER SEEN ! HATS OFF
افسوس کی بات یہ مولوی حضرات حضرت عمر فاروق سے کرتے کے کپڑے زیادہ ہونے کے سوال کو تو بتاتے ہیں لیکن اگر کوئی ان سے سوال کرلے تو ناراض ہو جاتے ہیں
آپ کتنے کروڑ دیتے ہیں مدارس کو؟
@@badshahzada5649 کیا نبی کے زمانے میں عالم چندے کرتے
@@youiswho ہہہہہہ بھائی اس وقت میں ریاست کے امیر مفتی اعظم ہوا کرتا تا
لیکن ابتدائی دور میں چندے ہی ہو تے تھے خاص کر جھاد کے لئے
@@badshahzada5649 Hazrat Muhammad S.A imamat krny ki kitni fees laity ya baad main kitni feeses hoti thi
السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللّٰہ وبرکاتہ
بھائی آپ نے کتنے علماء کرام سے سوال کرلیے ؟
Just an exceptional work
Literally i have no words
I just listened a small clip of molana moududi and he was literally saying the same things
bhut khub video h..muslim samaj ke bedari ke liye..
This is very important that our education system should be change immediately.
Raftar Team! A big salute to you guys, it's not just about this video or topic or any other you talked about. But the true definition of journalism. Whether it's politics, current affairs, religious debate or general details. Although " hr baat k darjanoun pehlu hotay hain, or hr insaan apni sooch, tareeqat or practicality k according topic mold krta hai" but i truly appreciate your efforts. I would love to see if you unveil the facts why Pakistan consider as a "Dark State". The role of establishment and army. It might be challenging but delivering the facts is your work of art. Do it guys 👍 Best of luck.
For the past two days, I have been continuously watching Raftaar's videos. I truly realize how much effort you all are putting in to enlighten the minds of the youth, who have been distracted by recent events happening in the country.❤
Very informative and transformative episode, Raftar is getting better everyday!
I hope Raftar becomes the Legacy.
@Raftar hats off to you guys .
The work you are doing in Pakistan have no words equivalent to glorify you guys .
Please consider making a documentary of darbars and the shirk going on there in the name of Islam.❤❤❤
Very well elaborated, Raftar is on the Track ❤
As a Hafiz e Quran i really felt the pain of Mudrassa
Student😭
Great presentation with bold questions and logical presentation. The single line in this video has deep meaning with concern. This boss and his team are teaching something new. Hats off sir to you and the entire team.
After the completion of hifiz i left madrasa and I am proud of it. The reason is they suffer all the way from their childhood to the rest of their lives.
مدارس کے مثبت پہلوؤں کو نظر انداز کر کے کمزور پہلوؤں پر خوب خوب "تحقیق" کی گئی
Big mistake at 34:30. Darse Nizami wasnt initiated by Nizam ul Mulk (1018-1092). It was founded by Nizamuddin Sihalivi Ansari (1677-1748). 700 year difference.
bhai bilkul sahi bataya app me ne 8 years tak mudrisse me phara ha waha pharai kam aur mar zayada ha sare mudrise almost same business model ko follow kar rahe he chanda lo aur bache jama karo 99% log sirf apne bache ke ghalti samajte he aur mudrisse ke qari ke khalif koi nahi bolta me ne 90% sirf gareeb bache he mudrise me dekhe he jin ko pharne ka koi shok nahi sirf apni zindgi guzar rahe he mudrise ke chande pe is ke illawaa aur bhe bhot masail he mudrisoo me jin par koi bat nahi karta abb agar me yahe batao to log to fir mudrisse ka nam hi kharab ho ga jo bache mudrisse me rehte he un se puch lena kabhi mudrisse ka hal
Kia hota hy rat ko
Thanks for writing this comment .
مفتی شفیع صاحب نے اگر مدارس کو ختم کرنے کی بات کی تھی اس کا مطلب تھا کہ اب الگ مدارس کی ضرورت نہیں رہی جو انگریز دور میں تھی اب پاکستان وجود میں آچکا ہے لہذا قومی اداروں میں دینی و دنیاوی تعلیم ایک ساتھ ہو گی لیکن افسوس ایسا نہیں ہو سکا سرکاری تعلیمی ادارے دینی تعلیم نہیں دے سکے اور مدارس کو دینی تعلیم کے لیے مدارس قائم کرنے کی ضرورت پیش آئی
No doubt, all of this is happening.
I am thankful to Raftaar for making this very insightful video.
However, you should also highlight the latest Islamic institutes that are addressing these core problems, such as Youth Club, Hikmah Institute, Ribat, Naseeha Institute, IBA CEIF, and others.
Im also hafize Quraan Alhamdulillah...or aj hifz k 19 saal baad bhee mein ny jo hifz kia hai usy samajhny ki koshish kar rha hun or uska faida mri zaat ko aj ho rha hai..Mery khayal m quraan pak hifz karny se ziada faida quraan pak ko samajh kr parhny se hoga..agar quraan yad krwany se ziada smjhany py zor dia jai to yad krna ziada asaan hoga or insan ki apni zaat pe bhee isky bht musbat asraat hongy zindagi k har shoby mein..hum yad krwany par itna zor dety hn k jb samajhny ka waqt ata hai to ziada tar bachay us qabil he ni rehty...or madrasson m gher ikhlaqi waqiat ki waja bhee yhi hai k hmen pata he ni hota k Allah pak hmen kia farma rhy hn...agar quraan pak k sath school ki taleem bhee di jai to hr bacha deen or dunia dono sath le k chal skta hai or kamyab bhee ho skta hai..Allah pak hum sb ko deen or dunia mein kamyab kren..ameen
Raftar is the only platform that focus and point the most important issues in society ❤❤
Topic Acha hai , lekin aik sawal hai
Hamari konsi university ne koi bada karnama kiya hai
Koi invention
Madraso wale to phir be akhlaq aur waldain ka ihteram karte hai hamare university walo mai to ye be nahi hota
Siraf madaris ko nahi hamre mulk mai sab he ulta or kharab hai
bohat umda boht hi umda documentary Raftar Team... Appriciated 💞
Very heart touching topic god bless to inocent and poor people
2023 Islamabad ma madrassa k student ny uni k students ko defeat kia or 1st position li robotics ma
Program kafi informative hai,
برین واش ہونی والی ویڈیو
یک طرفہ ویڈیو
I appreciate to Raftar Team , very good topic , there is very necessary to highlight theses issues continues basis, because very important to knows our peoples, how can used these organisation
Rafter is one of the few channels that i watch regularly. And definitely it is one of the best channels on youtube
A child, who wants to become a doctor, but couldn't due to lack of resources. Some are orphans; all are tied with the chain of poverty. The society doesn't respect the poor, socially and economically deprived class. An empty belly can lead towards compromising positions, where wild wolves are ready to tear a young soul. Who cares? Nobody. At least their religion is giving those children a temporary shelter, security, food, and education. And, most importantly, the respect from the society due to religion. Or else who respects the poor class? The so-called educated people can disregard the madrasa education, calling it outdated, but who is going to change the root cause within the larger section of society that is poverty? Just merely overshadowing madrasa education and being intellectual doesn't solve the ground realities of the deprived class of society. At last, religion and science stand both face to face. One is with the deprived section of society, and the other has moved so ahead with time that the so-called sophisticated piece of educated shits can just use technical jargons to sound intelligent, but in hindsight, they don't know real shit about science and technology. Leave aside the former aspect. That's the irony.
For the entire documentary team, I have one word that is RESPECT. 👍
Thank you
Yes i think there is no need of madaris but in finland in norway in korea where everyone have equally access to the school to the University. But in pakistan if someone teach a single alphabet to a single street child is a great blessing.
respect for raftaar
Such a critical issue you have highlighted, please highlight more issues like this
You should do a thorough documentary on the rise and fall of our educational system and what are private schools doing to our children why they are promoting secularism etc.
Agr ap is channel ko proper dekhty hoty to ye question na krty
Secularism ?
They are not teaching anything , secularism liberalism they all get this from social media .
Private school colleges are just a business and government school is a place of uncivilized people .
They are not teaching anything about secularism or liberalism .
Private school colleges are just a business and government schools are worst .
The purpose of this video, as I understand it, is to discuss these issues and explain them in detail to find a solution to these problems. I believe this is the main objective of the video. The aim of this video is certainly not to degrade Islam or madrasas, but to acknowledge our mistakes and, by looking at the current situation, find a solution to these problems.
Salute to your efforts ❤
RAFTAR ! The most sensitive issue deal in every So-called Ummah of Indian Sub-Continent 😂unfortunately hijacked by TEAM mullah's Mufti's Moullana's Hypocrites politicians....GooD noble WorK ! RaftaR Keep it Up ❤
Murtad
Sub continent múslím are cónvér téd only
You have mistaken in few things but I appreciate your work because your intentions are purely positive.
What else u can expect in A state created on the basis of religion. The role of Zia was missed out. It was during his rule the no. Increased manifold.
I spent more than 7 years in madrassa i know this is reality of why madrasa education in down fall and this firqa system
Great information based on true facts. Totally agree sir💯
It breaks heart to see these kids languishing in these places 😢
i love raftar, i just love it, lots of regards
ماشاءاللہ آپ نے بہت اچھا مضمون چنا ہے ۔اس ویڈیو بہت سے لوگوں پر اثر ہو گا۔
Appreciate honest approach and content by Raftar…… all the best from India
💋
brave content, @raftar
Salute to Raftar you are doing Real Journalism. I pray for Sir Aftab Iqbal who talked about this channel in one of his show and I discovered you guys earlier on.
More power to all the team of Raftaar. You are really working for betterment of Pakistan and Pakistanis. KUDOS
Keep making these documentaries . They are perfect . We love these more than podcast .
Prayers for whole team ❤❤❤
42 minutes utilitiized so efficiently 😊
*Wellcome back yaar*
Bhut miss kia apki powerful voice ko
41:20 اللہ پاک ہمارے عظیم محسنوں خیرخواہوں سائنسدانوں طبیب علماءحق اور تمام اچھے انسانیت دوست ہمدرد کرداروں اور مجاہدین حق کی حفاظت فرمائے اور ہمیں ان سے ترقی و فائدہ لینے کی توفیق و مواقع عطافرمائے۔ آمین
Raftar is the message of Our Bright Future.
Beshak! Afsose yeh he ke - Yahan India me bhi Madrasaaon k yahee haal he - specially Urdu & Dakhni also hindi Speaking lands muslims (mostly here turkic curriculum is followed) , Malayam madarasa's situation is little better I think (they follow little different curriculum- some of them also include biology and cleaness - I got known about these resently - am impressed). & Mentality of most of the people is also same -( Madaras is mostly for backwards - less encouraged towards critical thinking - Rigid religious beliefs - creates aalims or hafiz who are not Actually )
کیا بات ہے رفتار کی ماشاﷲ، بہت خوب ایک ایک سیکینڈ بہت پراثر تھا۔ سونے پر سوہاگہ احسن سبز بھائی کی داستان گوئی کا تو کوئی جواب ہی نہیں۔ پلیز احسن بھائی کو زیادہ سے زیادہ ویڈیوز میں رکھا کریں۔
Love and respect for Raftar,❤ 🙌🙌🙌
Brave one
Please give reference 7:42
@@muhammadtaha9999 yes
Bohat khoob our society need that kind of man critical anaylsis ❤
Yes😢😢😢
Pakistani content ❤
I totally agree but Dr israr ahmed is best . They have many academic in karachi islamabad ... and they do not have any fee .
I agreed with this
Me khud wifaq ul madaris ka student hun aur molana Hanif jhalandri bilkul ghalat BAAT ker rahy Hain
Jab tak hum galti to accept Nahi karengy hum khud ko kesy sahi ker saktay Hain?
Deep analysis of madrasa
Lamha ye fikria.......
This video force me to subscribe Raftar. Good job
JazakAllah thanks for speaking the truth. Mai tho kabi soch b nai sakta ke apnay bachu ko madrasa mai bej du.
RAFTAR ❤
دینوی اور دنیاوی علم کا فرق ختم کرنا ہو گا۔ سب علم دینی علم ہے۔
Buhat khob raftar ap hamary masail ki tarjumani krty hain ❤
MashaAllah very intellectually establish documentary at righteous time and this kind of establishment all we need in our country
Also make a video on the reality of 16 years of formal education, and expose it please
It's the best channel in Pakistan. Please create expose videos on influencers or daily vloggers
@raftartv
Jite ji jindagi jahannum hay. Jannat main kya hai? Kisne bataya?
@@positivethoughts8461 video calling ka systen nahi hai kya jannat se? Sare problem solve ho jayenge
Arey kehna kiya chahte ho??
7:40 please give reference
Good video