This is so raw. It is the first modern K-pop girl group I have seen in a concert with such good RAW vocals while dancing with REAL energy. I hope that they will not change over the years.
@@a0917919018 okay because i heard it and i was like is that breath. Since one time ive even seen le serrafim do fearless and you could hear their breath
@@Dani_Alexis i think it’s giselle’s mic bc it’s so close to her nose so when she exhaled through there, the air hits the mic. everyone else adjusted at some point except her and you can hear the noise stop when she sings
Giselle sounded like the studio version yet more powerful live. Her live vocals really stable too, she never missed a lyric and tune, until the last song. And her vocals in thirsty? Especially the adlibs, so good. I can’t take my eyes off of her too. She’s incredible !!
Giselle's is really that GOOD. People just need to pay a little more attention to her and SM should have given her more opportunities to showcase her talent.
Ningning vocal is literally insane, Gigi welcome back!!! Winter looks so gorgeous in the red dress, and Karina is so charismatic!! Aespa never disappoints
Ning so chill even hitting high notes but aldo exudes so mycb confidence and resence. She is a treat to watch every single time. Plus the prettiest girl❤
@@kihara4244 i think 99.9% of us are not toxic, but those that are toxic i don't think they are really fans.. maybe antis pretending to be fans so that they care scare away any new comers.
I think this is my favorite live stage of them because you can see how they miss performing as OT4. They genuinely enjoying the stage with the audience and that's make their performance look more confident and powerful🔥🔥🔥
@@Chichi11186 Yeah! They really work so hard to improved that part. They not only focus on their visual but they focus on how they improved their idols career, hope SM treat them well in the future Couz the girls already gave their everything💖😊
NingNing's legendary supermodel walk and despite being main vocalist, NingNing always give her 300% efforts and exitement in every stage. Truly pro diva among Aespa (beside Karina)
i cannot take my eyes off of ningning, she looks enjoying this stage so much, and im so glad giselle is back!! their whole stage and live vocals are no jokes 🤯
Giselle’s voice is loud, clear, and STABLE! Like she is the most stable in the group and with good energy. She sounded like their recorded song. How good is that? Ofc, Ningning is such a performer. Vocals, Dance, and stage presence, all in one. Aespa did great especially their Next Level performance. They sounded so great!
This is definitely one of the best if not the best aespa's performances ever! They really sang live for all 5 songs with minimal to no backtrack vocals & they sound amazing! What's more impressive is that they managed to maintain their energy throughout those 20 minutes while singing live & dancing! I also love their confidence, stage presence, the way they communicated/hyped the audience & most importantly, they're having fun on stage as well! I'm so proud of these girls! Karina, Giselle, Winter & Ningning, you girls did so well!
You can really tell that Ningning has a very good singing technique. She can maintain the same volume whether she's singing low or high. She'll never be caught straining her throat ❤
Aespa is one of the group that keep improving from day 1. From dancing to sp, each member improving making their group all rounder. Giselle improved with her dancing skill, winter with sp (although i think she’s great from the start), ningning as a main vocal showcase her rap, karina being extremely stable. They might be aces on upcoming journey. ❤
Aespa Really Proving that they are one of the best Vocal groups of 4th Gen. Really happy to see them finally singing live. Also did they mess the Thirsty choreography? Why were they laughing xD
they are the best... and who'snthe other one? say it and i wont believe you. there's only one Queen in a Queendom... blackpink? i swear im gonna beat you up if its those pinky girlies.. always tired. making mistakes in stages they're on, cursing and ultimately having a monotonous member.
@@WanderingJovan Chill Out and read the comment properly first. I Clearly said 4th Gen. Secondly I said one of the best because there are other groups who are stable aswell. For example take Nmixx there vocals are sooo good for a one year old group. There are also alot of groups who have a good vocal line. And For your Comments about Blackpink. Hate as much as you want no one gives a F. Thats why I ain't gonna talk about them. Love 😘
@@WanderingJovan they said 4th gen, while bp is from 3rd gen (yes ik it seems like theyre just debut not long ago, but bp is 3rd gen the same with exo, twice and bts)
2:03 their adlibs are amazing! and ningning lengthen her notes in 2:50 is incredible! sometimes iam questioning why sm not allowing them live in prior time in their debut era, its because their incredible live vocal are very rare, and so that the previous song can still be perform until know💗 nothing but for their best!
aaakkk suka deh sama performance mereka yg ini, ❤ entah knp perhatian gw cenderung ke jijel kali ini, suaranya stabil, dia jg keliatan confidence, improve bgt !
I love hearing them breathe lol, like, it's so........ real. Can I just say, I'm so jealous of them being able to KEEP dancing and KEEP singing and when it's not their part and they have "break" (used VERY loosely), they still come back to it when it is their part... sometimes I can't talk while walking and if I take a break that's it, not getting up to continue for a while :').
Wow, I really liked it! It's nice to listen to a band whose members can sing. You get what you pay for. The girls are incredible. Ningning and Winter carry the group's vocals with firmness and complement each other well. Karina and Giselle do well vocally too, and on the rap side they're great and complement each other well too. I also noticed Karina's talent as a dancer, especially in the lower body, where her footwork is superior to that of the other members. What a great show, I wish I'd been there!
![(ENG SUB) Black Mamba + Spicy - aespa [영동대로 K-POP Concert] | KBS WORLD TV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tC-iYQ6cldU/mqdefault.jpg)
This is so raw. It is the first modern K-pop girl group I have seen in a concert with such good RAW vocals while dancing with REAL energy. I hope that they will not change over the years.
(G)idle and BABYMONSTER both sound like studio live, idle was like a year and half before Aespa though
They’re live performance so insane…the sound of the mic is really loud...i love aespa so much🩷🩷🩷🩷
there was an extra noise, was that them breathing? I also ask because it kind of sounds like t hat
@@Dani_Alexis Yes !! It's so obvious . And , these are almost the LIVE MR(only music recorded).
@@a0917919018 okay because i heard it and i was like is that breath. Since one time ive even seen le serrafim do fearless and you could hear their breath
@@Dani_Alexis i think it’s giselle’s mic bc it’s so close to her nose so when she exhaled through there, the air hits the mic. everyone else adjusted at some point except her and you can hear the noise stop when she sings
@@jennifertan the breathing sound still can hear when giselle's part
닝닝이 보컬 미쳤네 개잘하네
Aespaaaa ❤❤👏
aespa killing it with live vocals 🎉
Giselle sounded like the studio version yet more powerful live. Her live vocals really stable too, she never missed a lyric and tune, until the last song. And her vocals in thirsty? Especially the adlibs, so good. I can’t take my eyes off of her too. She’s incredible !!
Yup
Giselle's is really that GOOD. People just need to pay a little more attention to her and SM should have given her more opportunities to showcase her talent.
Ningning vocal is literally insane, Gigi welcome back!!! Winter looks so gorgeous in the red dress, and Karina is so charismatic!! Aespa never disappoints
Ning so chill even hitting high notes but aldo exudes so mycb confidence and resence. She is a treat to watch every single time. Plus the prettiest girl❤
진짜 이날 애리는 레전드다…. 헤메코 걍 완벽… 뭔가.. 사연있는 여자같음 ㅠ
They definitely made me a fan with this performance. I love the rawness and i wish more groups took vocal risks like this. ❤
Thanks for appreciating them especially them for having vocally demanding songs!! 💗
Thank you for wanting to be a part of our fandom❤ik many people say we are toxic but most of us are not❤
trust me you won't regret
Thank you for the appreciation of the girlies ! And welcome !
@@kihara4244 i think 99.9% of us are not toxic, but those that are toxic i don't think they are really fans.. maybe antis pretending to be fans so that they care scare away any new comers.
They all complement each other, that's why they are a great group.
yess
I think this is my favorite live stage of them because you can see how they miss performing as OT4. They genuinely enjoying the stage with the audience and that's make their performance look more confident and powerful🔥🔥🔥
It’s also interesting to see these groups that debut during Covid become more confident, considering they didn’t have an audience for a long time.
@@Chichi11186 Yeah! They really work so hard to improved that part. They not only focus on their visual but they focus on how they improved their idols career, hope SM treat them well in the future Couz the girls already gave their everything💖😊
Gua juga, mikir ini penampilan terbaik mereka dimanapun
Ningning's live vocal is incredible... And Giselle's confidence shines the most! ❤
NingNing's legendary supermodel walk and despite being main vocalist, NingNing always give her 300% efforts and exitement in every stage. Truly pro diva among Aespa (beside Karina)
Giselle just recovered from illness but she is so confident. I love her loud and clear vocals, raps and stage presence. She nails it no doubt!
The live vocals, stage presence, dance everything is perfect
I love ningning so much, her vocals, dance and stage presence were so good 💯🔥
i cannot take my eyes off of ningning, she looks enjoying this stage so much, and im so glad giselle is back!! their whole stage and live vocals are no jokes 🤯
winter looks incredible in that dress
Giselle’s voice is loud, clear, and STABLE! Like she is the most stable in the group and with good energy. She sounded like their recorded song. How good is that?
Ofc, Ningning is such a performer. Vocals, Dance, and stage presence, all in one.
Aespa did great especially their Next Level performance. They sounded so great!
Fr!!
maybe is because her mic was closer?
I even can hear her breath
More stable? She barbely have a lot vocal challeng😭
@@goatku2gokusolo bet ure one of those people who cant stand it when non-fans compliment members other than your bias 🥱
This is definitely one of the best if not the best aespa's performances ever! They really sang live for all 5 songs with minimal to no backtrack vocals & they sound amazing! What's more impressive is that they managed to maintain their energy throughout those 20 minutes while singing live & dancing! I also love their confidence, stage presence, the way they communicated/hyped the audience & most importantly, they're having fun on stage as well! I'm so proud of these girls! Karina, Giselle, Winter & Ningning, you girls did so well!
loving Giselle's energy in these performances
She has the best stage presence and confidence
You can really tell that Ningning has a very good singing technique. She can maintain the same volume whether she's singing low or high. She'll never be caught straining her throat ❤
notice that too ❤
I love Ning's hair flip, reminds me to her sunbae, Sooyoung wkwkwk.
they're always make me goosebumps with they're live performances.
love you guyss, keep healthy.
They have incredible live vocals and it's so nice to see the crowd appreciates them❤
Aespa is one of the group that keep improving from day 1. From dancing to sp, each member improving making their group all rounder. Giselle improved with her dancing skill, winter with sp (although i think she’s great from the start), ningning as a main vocal showcase her rap, karina being extremely stable. They might be aces on upcoming journey. ❤
Proud with giselle, so love with aespa
라이브 너무 맘에 든다.... 음향 안좋는데도 열심히 부르는 에스파 항상 응원한다
aespa's best and most comfortable live performance
aespa did amazing and look so gorgeous with that styling 😍
Aespa Really Proving that they are one of the best Vocal groups of 4th Gen. Really happy to see them finally singing live. Also did they mess the Thirsty choreography? Why were they laughing xD
I think because karina touch winter hair
@@nitasuminarni89wow yeah,karina flipped Winter's hair back by accident in the bridge
they are the best... and who'snthe other one? say it and i wont believe you. there's only one Queen in a Queendom... blackpink? i swear im gonna beat you up if its those pinky girlies.. always tired. making mistakes in stages they're on, cursing and ultimately having a monotonous member.
@@WanderingJovan Chill Out and read the comment properly first. I Clearly said 4th Gen. Secondly I said one of the best because there are other groups who are stable aswell. For example take Nmixx there vocals are sooo good for a one year old group. There are also alot of groups who have a good vocal line.
And For your Comments about Blackpink. Hate as much as you want no one gives a F. Thats why I ain't gonna talk about them. Love 😘
@@WanderingJovan they said 4th gen, while bp is from 3rd gen (yes ik it seems like theyre just debut not long ago, but bp is 3rd gen the same with exo, twice and bts)
ningning's voice is so clear, we love a vocalist 🫶
they killed it per usual!! so glad giselle is back
It was so sweet when giselle and winter started laughing during thirsty 😭
NINGNING'S VOCALS IS SO DAMN CLEAR AND STABLE SHE REALLY IS THEE 4TH GEN MAIN VOCAL 🥺🤍
Devouring the stage as usual my Queens💕
Giselle gila. Dia mvp nya kali ini suaranya jelas banget!!!!! Love u jijel
i always love their live vocal performance, it's just sooo amazing
this is my fav video of aespa, u can see they are all so close and having fun
I'm so proud of you Giselle, stay healthy girl
They are so talent aespa 4th gen leaders ❤!!! Amazing voice and sp love them forever 💜💜💜💜
Gigi DEFINATELY leads the rap in illusion in the second verse
난 에스파의 Heh! 의 이 파워풀한 추임새가 너무 좋음..
너무나도 에스파 그 자체 시그니처임
This is such a wnderful LIVE performance !! It's definitely a good practice to rock the Tokyo Dome in Japan soon :)
8:47 NINGNING SOOOO STABLE, I cant...
Amazing as always 💙🌙⭐️🦋
Gilakk keren bgt live semua 5 lagu, dance jg semangat bgt, mereka enjoy performance bgt jugaa happy bgt ekspresi nya pada.. aakk.. Love u aespa
aespa live so amazing
I can even hear their breathe 😮😮😮😮
애리가 진짜 잘웃는구나... 너무 예쁘다 보기좋아
ㅇㅈ 완전이뻐요
애리가 누구에어
애리가누구예여?
@@김은혜-t7p9v 지젤이용
@@Youijoy
지젤 이야🙂
AESPA LIVE VOCALS IS INSANE 🤯🤯
I want this performance clear version, not fancam because they're singing LIVE here and I love it.
YASSS OT4 IS BACK!! SLAYYY QUEENS!
Ps: the way they laughing during thirsty is so cute 😂
They really enjoy performing there all look happy and satisfied proud mys here!
They sound so good 🥰
다른말이 필요없다 정말 최고다!
ningning's so stable ugh main vocal for a reason!!! 👏🏻
Ning Ning - a student of Choi Soo "Hair"
never doubt about aespa’s vocal, i think they’re the best one among the other 4th generation group
amo esse vídeo, dá pra ver que elas tão cantando ao vivo e que elas realmente estão se divertindo, e eu me divirto assistindo 💓
let's make it go viral, so many people know that aespa is the best in live performance
BM will always be their best opening song
2:03 their adlibs are amazing! and ningning lengthen her notes in 2:50 is incredible!
sometimes iam questioning why sm not allowing them live in prior time in their debut era, its because their incredible live vocal are very rare, and so that the previous song can still be perform until know💗 nothing but for their best!
My girl Giselle has such a soothing voice 🥰 Great job aespa!! ☺️🩷
윈터 성량 미쳤고 라이브도 미쳤다.. 라이브 실력 춤 비쥬얼 비율 다 가진 그녀.. 진짜 전체적인걸로 봐서 "내 기준" 탑임..
여러분 이거 완전 에이알 하나도 안깔린 라이브에욤... 라이브 너무 잘한듯😢😢😢❤❤❤
AESPA STAGE PRESENSE AND ENERGY IS INSANE Y'ALL🤯🤯
So stable and clear on live vocals❤️❤️❤️ amazing!
i love aespa live perfomance❤
GISELLEEEEEEEEEE😍😍😍 SHES KILLING ITTTTTTT❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥
I love that you can really see how they are enjoying the performance! Insane!
14:04 this part up until Kariselle's rap will always be iconic 😭
aespa vocal never fail
Wow Giselle vocals so stable
IT WAS SERIOUS FOR THE GIRLIES!!!! they all performed so well!
wow.. they vocal so good...
MIC IS ONNNNNN YEOROBUN❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 badasssss
aaakkk suka deh sama performance mereka yg ini, ❤ entah knp perhatian gw cenderung ke jijel kali ini, suaranya stabil, dia jg keliatan confidence, improve bgt !
지젤이 춤출때 손을 예쁘게 잘씀..
The way people screamed when Thirsty started playing, like yes bside of the year.
wow aespa really on another level👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
8:14 soo goood❤
their vocals are so stableeee !!
Shes so amazing vocalist vocks really great song and dance! parfect scampering!!🎶💖⚡☝🏻🤘🏼👍🎉✨🌠🌟
Everyone looked so hype up!!!!!! Giselle energy is out of the world!!!!
The 5:30 little mistake was so cute 😻😻😻😻 I love them so much!
This is the most live they've sung. Even the coachella still had lots of help. I am happy watching this.
Vocals ❤❤❤
I love hearing them breathe lol, like, it's so........ real. Can I just say, I'm so jealous of them being able to KEEP dancing and KEEP singing and when it's not their part and they have "break" (used VERY loosely), they still come back to it when it is their part... sometimes I can't talk while walking and if I take a break that's it, not getting up to continue for a while :').
also Giselle is so good and so underrated T_T
Aa ss ku!
Suami ku aakiri!
giselle live vocal ate so much🎉
Winter in red dress ❤ she looked so gorgeous
Ningning's walk at 0:14. The body, the hair, the walk, the clothing!!
Best performance ive watched of Aespa!
Ari was back❤!!!
Wow, I really liked it! It's nice to listen to a band whose members can sing. You get what you pay for. The girls are incredible. Ningning and Winter carry the group's vocals with firmness and complement each other well. Karina and Giselle do well vocally too, and on the rap side they're great and complement each other well too. I also noticed Karina's talent as a dancer, especially in the lower body, where her footwork is superior to that of the other members. What a great show, I wish I'd been there!
Ningning is the best ❤
This is how idols should perform
their vocalllll 😍😍
9:29 ning omg