@@chloeliu3844 they keep the back track on to make it convenient for dancing choreo like that. But it get dimmed when the singers start to sing. It's an automated mix of both. When they sing using mic, it's what we hear mostly, when they don't the back track automatically match the singers last note and volume and that's what we listen. Literally every single group use it now as everyone has good choreo instead of old school mostly singing choreo. IT'S THE NORM.
@@soapbubbles_1523 live with backtrack. Stop living in the past of live only. Aespa has already performed full live many times and proved their worth. So a going with backtrack in a festival is the right choice
wish the backtrack lower than this, never tired of hearing Aespa's live stage. Winter stage presence getting improve better and better. Ningning facial expression always on point. Main Slayer! Giselle charisma and stage presence 2:15 cute here Karina main dancer stand out in every performance.
😂 people commenting they aren’t singing live.. the playback in the background is to help assist or add so there aren’t any breaks in their vocals. So if they don’t sing or utter one word it’s not the end of the world. You can obviously hear they are singing live. I’ve been to 2 aespa concerts in Texas.. they can definitely sing live ❤
@@lexouboo in some fancam videos sound like live, but I agree official video sound like played pre recorded track, pretty confusing. But their live vocal had been proved many times before anyway🫶
Soooo goood to watch their live! All of them are gorgeous, their voice also didn't shaky at all. Ningning is so cuteeee, watching how she tried to communicate with audiens, she works haard!
Being a MY since their debut this makes me sooooooo proud of the girls. Their Hyperline experience is really showing. You can really see how they have grown. Their confidence, aura, how they carry themselves and yes they have always sang live. This time its more evident. I love that they are more comfortable singing with handmics. can’t wait for Drama Comeback!
There is always people that arguing so loud about aespa performing live or not, even tho those people just watch it from screen than my's that really went to enjoy aespa performances there. Just gonna say, if you people haven't go to aespa concert or anything, you better stay silent. aespa big girls making money.
Su presencia ha mejorado mucho, igual que los estilistas jajaja, siento que ahora de verdad arreglan a Giselle de forma que le favorece, se ve hermosa. PD: Su vocal es wow
Aespa has huge fan following in Pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰. We love their music, their vocals, choreography, and videos. And their popularity is increasing day by day. Pakistan loves Aespa💜🇵🇰💙🇵🇰❤🇵🤩🤩🤩
I believe this is pre recorded live version backtrack. Don’t get me wrong. The girls sing live heavenly. I dunno who made this decision. But you can tell the vocals have been produced In a studio with a trained ear. They smoothed things out and pitch corrected here and there. When Aespa actually sings live, which again, they do very well, they sound different than this. Still good, but rawer and more soulful almost.
@@EpicKieranprobably cause they lip synced since debue. Mostly to just play it Safe, if this is cause the group wasnt/isnt confident in thier skill or the Company isnt confident in them, i dont know. Either way they hold Status quo for to long and now they are probably afraid to change it, cause of potential backlash. They also could be just not good enough for live voclas, i dont know.
It's so interesting. I met Blackpink in April 2019 and then met a few other girl groups that already existed. Through the fans I heard "there will be a new group" it was aespa... it was the first group I was part of from the beginning, every member and debut song. I wasn't that convinced and even today I'm not a huge fan of all the songs, because it's just a matter of taste! But I really like the girls. It's crazy how they have become a GROUP on STAGE! They are now ONE! understand each other blindly. One can only praise it. Lesserafim has now also become a group. It's really cool when you can see how groups develop right from the start.
They slayed vocals, choreography and charm! Aespa always on top! Pd: kbs you owe us that jiminjeong hug from the music bank festival back in December, we will never forget!
My girls, I am so proud of you! I mean, look how much you've improved during this 3 years, I'm so happy that I was always here to see it and to cheer for you girls! I'm always be a MY! Thank you, Aespa! ❤ Fighting!
We can see that everybody in public is filming. That's so sad. ENJOY THIS MOMENT, YOU HAVE THE CHANCE TO SEE THEM FOR REAL SO PUT YOUR PHONES BACK IN YOUR POCKETS AND ENJOY A SHOW THAT YOU'LL SEE ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. THANK YOU
Not a fan but ive recently seen them in person and Ningning,imo, is the prettiest and the most natural looking. Too bad she seemed a bit snob, even their fans didn't get any acknowledgment from her. Karina is really pretty too. She looks tall on screen but not in person. Winter looks sooo different with minimal makeup. Lol Giselle,imo,is the least when it comes to the looks dept. Not saying she's ugly, just not as pretty as the others.
AESPA💜💜💜💜 Thank you for everything, for being these four brilliant and talented girls who saved my life, you are incredible artists who deserve the whole world, you always remind me that I have to move forward, and never let anyone or anything shake me or make me sad , I admire you a lot because I know how hard you work and have worked spreading the incredible talent and art that you have, always remember to move forward and stay strong, I will always support you. I will always be by your side, fighting and defending you from everything and everyone, never let anyone take away this shine that you have💜💜💜
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
📌The full video and behind-the-scenes will be released on the 23rd at 8:50PM (Seoul, UTC+9/KST).
In 4k please
Don't push it, at least we got something. Just raise your quality of the video.
we'll be waiting
thank you
Thank you!! And are so happy this comes with Eng subtitles!!!
Where is it? can't find it
Singing first and last title track BLACK MAMBA & SPICY is a statement that Aespa was, is and will be the queens of 4th gen! 👑
@pruitv3 bae its a youtube comment.. its not that serious
@pruitv3 what are you talking about..?? i don't even know who aedark is?
@pruitv3 sorry that i’m not like you and i don’t live on youtube to know who they are? i still don’t know what’s going on 💀
@@wooygiflol i dont know who she is either but she’s literally on every single aespa video. you can check lol
You can tell they got more confident and comfortable onstage after touring
Their confidence and vocals have just gotten so incredible. They’re mothers.
😮😮
Their live vocals are no joke. Vocal powerhouse group.
it´s not live
@@Hello-dc6hzit clearly is, you can easily tell their live vocals from the backtrack lol couldn’t be any more obvious
@@vampr3751it's not live 2:13 look at giselle's mic
@@canarayasinjii looked its mixed live and backing track
Only black mamba was live
Aespa's LIVE VOCALS are so beautiful like their studio vocals; AESPA HAS 4 MAIN VOCALIST! 😇
All can pass as main rappers too 😳
baby... those are not live vocals
@@alli4559it’s a compliment that you think their live vocals are not live.. it shows how good aespa’s vocals are
@@dara_stoyanova2037 its kind of sad how kpop fans cannot tell the difference between a prerecorded backtrack and live vocals..
This isn’t live check 2:14
Yeongdongdaero AESPA is for history books! From their stage presence, solid dance, divine beauty to lovely fan services; THEY WERE FLAMBOYANT! 🔥
4/4 being 10/10 is really something, what a group
Aespa is one of the only perfect girl group in 4th generation ❤
Love how AESPA SILENCED ALL THE HATERS who accused them of lip sync only and their LIVE VOCAL IS HEAVENLY! 💫
I’m not hater or a fan, but how you explain what happened in 2:15~2:16 ?
@@chloeliu3844 they keep the back track on to make it convenient for dancing choreo like that. But it get dimmed when the singers start to sing. It's an automated mix of both. When they sing using mic, it's what we hear mostly, when they don't the back track automatically match the singers last note and volume and that's what we listen.
Literally every single group use it now as everyone has good choreo instead of old school mostly singing choreo. IT'S THE NORM.
they are definitely great singers, but honey, it's not a live performance, and you know it too...
@@soapbubbles_1523 live with backtrack. Stop living in the past of live only. Aespa has already performed full live many times and proved their worth. So a going with backtrack in a festival is the right choice
@@aeD4RK yes everyone knows they can perform live very well but this specific one isn't like... it's very obvious
their stage presences is really powerful now! totally unmatched from their debut! So proud of my girls 😭😭💗💗💗
wish the backtrack lower than this, never tired of hearing Aespa's live stage.
Winter stage presence getting improve better and better.
Ningning facial expression always on point. Main Slayer!
Giselle charisma and stage presence 2:15 cute here
Karina main dancer stand out in every performance.
이 날은 진짜 모두 레전드인 날로 평생 기억되지 않을까하는
Can't believe they kept the best vocal girl group of this generation singing playback for so long! Aespa is showing, they really are THE girls!
Karina never disappoint me she always make sure to slay every stage
true
Aespa keep proving they are ONE OF THE STRONGEST vocal group of all time and IT'S 100% TRUE! 💯🌟
girl shut up ❤
winter is getting better and better and better each day
Aespa's live vocal is BLESSINGLY BEAUTIFUL, keep singing our proud Aespa! 🙏
its 100% lip synced, not a single breath was heard... delusional
Sadly the vocals aren't live, Giselle even puts her mic away from her mouth but her voice is still loud 2:15 (no hate to aespa i'm a MY)
@pruitv3 OH i'm sorry, i didn't know some people could be that bored in their life.. but thank you for telling me
@@citrusoojin not a single breath heard? Yall need new ears or something?
@@lexoubooso I wasnt the only one noticing that
😂 people commenting they aren’t singing live.. the playback in the background is to help assist or add so there aren’t any breaks in their vocals. So if they don’t sing or utter one word it’s not the end of the world. You can obviously hear they are singing live. I’ve been to 2 aespa concerts in Texas.. they can definitely sing live ❤
their vocal and visual are insane
aespa live voice is even better than CD
It's not live vocals, i wish it was though :(
@@lexouboo in some fancam videos sound like live, but I agree official video sound like played pre recorded track, pretty confusing. But their live vocal had been proved many times before anyway🫶
@@ytw8304 Well I’m going to take a better look to fancams 😁, and yes of course their live performances are amazing !! They know how to sing for sure
the fits, the stage presence, the visuals, the vocals likeee asjdkdkdkdkd 😫
My favourite aespa's performance so far because everything is so perfect. The visual, energy, vocal and the confidence. LOVE IT!😆😍
I love how other members try to promote and put the shine on each other.
Finally live vocals🙏 they seem to enjoy the stage away more when singing live
Soooo goood to watch their live! All of them are gorgeous, their voice also didn't shaky at all. Ningning is so cuteeee, watching how she tried to communicate with audiens, she works haard!
ningning slayed 🔥🔥🔥
Aespa is such a lovely, wonderful group! They are all indeed so very charming
Karina is that idol who fit long wavey black hair, the most.That hair is her style
Being a MY since their debut this makes me sooooooo proud of the girls. Their Hyperline experience is really showing. You can really see how they have grown. Their confidence, aura, how they carry themselves and yes they have always sang live. This time its more evident. I love that they are more comfortable singing with handmics. can’t wait for Drama Comeback!
There is always people that arguing so loud about aespa performing live or not, even tho those people just watch it from screen than my's that really went to enjoy aespa performances there.
Just gonna say, if you people haven't go to aespa concert or anything, you better stay silent. aespa big girls making money.
1:45 Giselle laughing in the background, so cute 😂❤
Winter Visuals are very Shining and Stunning. She is Always Beautiful and Cute at The Same Time.
Winter Best Girl 🌟
mics are AWNNN, slay aespa
Love seeing Karina with non-smokey makeup once in a while
They look really good during this event.
I miss this introvert Winter so much, ever since she dyed her hair blonde she has been so extroverted.
The live vocals??!?! OMG THEY'RE SO STABLE
Prerecorded but yeah sounds good 😊
it's not live lmao
they never sing live lol
@@jpk895 no loll they sing live in many times lolll, u dont know anything bout them
Even they speak with the same mic after perfomance and people still question it if they are sing live or not.. haters always haterrsss..
00:50 애리 웃는거 보러 옴…
I like her style so beautiful all of members
Su presencia ha mejorado mucho, igual que los estilistas jajaja, siento que ahora de verdad arreglan a Giselle de forma que le favorece, se ve hermosa.
PD: Su vocal es wow
Their makeup looks so good omg
Aespa has huge fan following in Pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰. We love their music, their vocals, choreography, and videos. And their popularity is increasing day by day. Pakistan loves Aespa💜🇵🇰💙🇵🇰❤🇵🤩🤩🤩
their live vocal sound so just like the studio vocal, that is why people still not sure whether they sing live or not lol 🤧🥹
I’m sorry but I’m a my and I’m pretty sure this isn’t live. I know when aespa sings live and this is def not live. Check 2:14 if u dont believe me
@@cs8935no it's live performance
They're live vocals as always amazinggg
Their best performance to date. Everything was perfect! 🥰
sm artists are so good
I believe this is pre recorded live version backtrack. Don’t get me wrong. The girls sing live heavenly. I dunno who made this decision. But you can tell the vocals have been produced In a studio with a trained ear. They smoothed things out and pitch corrected here and there. When Aespa actually sings live, which again, they do very well, they sound different than this. Still good, but rawer and more soulful almost.
What a beautiful voices they have! fighting Aespa ❤️
Aespa best kpop group live!Best sp in gen4
The immense number of mys who says this is live is immaculate, i am a My, lets not tolerate delusional My's.
Group full of visual and vocalist
se ven tan cómodas y felices en el escenario, después del tour obtuvieron gran confianza, hermosos vocales, las tqm aespa
winter looks so confident here! i hope she continues improving her stage presence like this, she´s amazing 💗
확실히 외모는 sm이 최고다.
この時のスタイリング本当に天才すぎ
Evertime NingNing sings high notes i get goosebumps
why haters always ask if aespa sings live? Can they ask leserrafim, newjeans, and etc? hahahaha
haters are always ugly and dumb :D
에스파 아 진짜 나 미친다고오고옥ㄲㄱ 걍 찢음 이 언니들 위험한 사람들이야 진짜로…
aespa no visual or vocal loopholes 💓
Ning main slayer🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
so hot so pretty❤❤❤
0:48 Not Karina and Giselle being smiley to their dancers. I'm JEALOUS
Giselle so adorable, 2:14 her voice still loud without her mic on 😂
Vocal Goddesses’s 🙌🏼👑🔥🔥😍❤️
2:44 WAHHH THEY SOUND THE SAME FROM THE RECORDINGGSSSS
Their live vocals are great. All the more reason why they should sing live more often.
and yes they sing live very often now
so thanks SM💙
It’s not live vocals. They recorded the vocals and are lipping to it. I wonder why they never sing live.
@@EpicKieranprobably cause they lip synced since debue.
Mostly to just play it Safe, if this is cause the group wasnt/isnt confident in thier skill or the Company isnt confident in them, i dont know.
Either way they hold Status quo for to long and now they are probably afraid to change it, cause of potential backlash.
They also could be just not good enough for live voclas, i dont know.
@@EpicKieran MR이 조금 깔렸지만 라이브 맞다 ... 니가 빠는 걸그룹이나 신경써
@@MasiMerong keep dreaming, it’s not live and that’s the truth.
It's so interesting. I met Blackpink in April 2019 and then met a few other girl groups that already existed. Through the fans I heard "there will be a new group" it was aespa... it was the first group I was part of from the beginning, every member and debut song. I wasn't that convinced and even today I'm not a huge fan of all the songs, because it's just a matter of taste! But I really like the girls. It's crazy how they have become a GROUP on STAGE! They are now ONE! understand each other blindly. One can only praise it.
Lesserafim has now also become a group.
It's really cool when you can see how groups develop right from the start.
I'm loving to be a MY. Greetings to y'all from México
90% obsessed with filming them instead of properly taking in their performance and enjoying the atmospere
KARINA U HAVE MY HEART!!!
MANO BLACK MAMBA É TÃO BOOOA, QUE SAUDADE DESSA MÚSICA DESSA ERA, QUE NOSTALGIA DE 2020!!
They slayed vocals, choreography and charm! Aespa always on top!
Pd: kbs you owe us that jiminjeong hug from the music bank festival back in December, we will never forget!
they 4 are in their beauty era, stunning
Whenever I hear Black Mamba to this day, I still get hyped :) I still jam to that song ~
TALENTED AND PRETTY what can y’all ask more?
Aespa is my one of a kind
this is insane🔥
Ning what a powerful voice❤
I love when the idols issue microphone 🎤 on the way.
Their vokal so so powerfull and gratfull ❤
They are always jumping to the next level 🔥
BARU NYADAR ADA FYP TIKTOK LEWAT KONSER DIPINGGIR JALAN, TERNYATA INI TOH 😭
My girls, I am so proud of you! I mean, look how much you've improved during this 3 years, I'm so happy that I was always here to see it and to cheer for you girls!
I'm always be a MY!
Thank you, Aespa! ❤
Fighting!
썸네일 진짜 여신이다
Giselle is definetely a 10 of 10💋😍
Singing this without a backtrack is insane, they are insane, exceptional talent, atp i think they are robots😂love the vocals❤
Black Mamba + Spicy −aespa
This song is amazing i love it 👍👍👍
👁👄👁
We can see that everybody in public is filming. That's so sad. ENJOY THIS MOMENT, YOU HAVE THE CHANCE TO SEE THEM FOR REAL SO PUT YOUR PHONES BACK IN YOUR POCKETS AND ENJOY A SHOW THAT YOU'LL SEE ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. THANK YOU
Ningning ❤❤
aespa so beautiful.
여기에서 호시가 혼자서 호랑이 무대한 거잖아……미쳤네….권순영 당신은 참
the girls are so beautiful
Winter never disappoints ❤
Another phenomenal performance from aespa
Giselle is Beautyful and Ning Ning very sensual. I love them so much.
Thank you AESPA for putting on great live performance.
Not a fan but ive recently seen them in person and Ningning,imo, is the prettiest and the most natural looking.
Too bad she seemed a bit snob, even their fans didn't get any acknowledgment from her. Karina is really pretty too. She looks tall on screen but not in person.
Winter looks sooo different with minimal makeup. Lol
Giselle,imo,is the least when it comes to the looks dept. Not saying she's ugly, just not as pretty as the others.
AESPA💜💜💜💜
Thank you for everything, for being these four brilliant and talented girls who saved my life, you are incredible artists who deserve the whole world, you always remind me that I have to move forward, and never let anyone or anything shake me or make me sad , I admire you a lot because I know how hard you work and have worked spreading the incredible talent and art that you have, always remember to move forward and stay strong, I will always support you. I will always be by your side, fighting and defending you from everything and everyone, never let anyone take away this shine that you have💜💜💜
Wow winter is so beautiful 😮❤ 0:57