I'll be hosting a live webinar where you'll discover how you can beat the markets and earn an extra 10%, 20%, or even 40% a year-without studying chart patterns or analyzing financial reports. Claim your free ticket here: www.tradingwithrayner.com/sts/
Tons of thanks to the master rayner.... Saved my life... No words to describe.. MACD saved me from huge loss and helped me to make a consistent profit with minor losses.. I have paid huge amount to the trading institutes they never thought me like u do.. U R A SELFLESS MAN WITH KIND HEART.. SAVED MANY TRADERS FROM HEART ATTACK... ONCE AGAIN THANKS A LOT... GOD BLESS U ...
Watching your videos have really help me to become a much better trader. I'm not trading blindly anymore. The MACD line is the number 1 indicator that I use in my trading strategy. My profits have doubled and my losses are much lower thanks to Rayner's teachings!!! 👍🏿👍🏿
a beginning trader should never say "I going to trust you" ..but, you seem to give the most comprehensive tutorials and advice....i subscribed and will start my demo trading soon!
Thank you Rayner for all the amazing videos. Yet, I have a question. I'm a newbie to forex trading. Very new! I am using metatrader4 mobile platform. Yet I still don't understand how it works. For example, those lines that u have don't show at all. Which platform is best for trading? And do the lines show when you set MACD, or is there sth u have to do for them to show. Thanks in advance.
This is true, there is no one who was born with knowledge, we all learnt how to trade and we all were beginners don't hesitate to connect to *Lukasz Wilhelm's* live training on forex and cryptos, teaching *IQD momentum strategy* . if you have questions or you need help. search for website (Iqdtrades.com) on google, exactly what is needed....don't mix trend play with momentum.....thanks
I have been watching your videos since last month and today I have noticed that your videos are ads free. You are doing a great job and I love the way you explain. Any Newbie can easily learn from your content. ✌🏻✌🏻
As a long-time trader and well versed in Tradestation coding, I just want to compliment Rayner as being very sharp and very knowledgable about the MACD and its uses.
Rayner, I'm at the very start of my trading journey so I'm at a stage where I try to soak up as much knowledge as possible but I find your videos one of the most helpful. You have a very good way of breaking down "difficult to get at first" concepts. Thank you.
Hello Rayner, You’re courses are so valuable that it’s hard to find anyone who gives these classes so interesting. With the others I always fall asleep because they talk so boring. No energy ,no charisma,no feeling. Man I really love your energy and consistency. For me your the best 🥇🤝👌
Rayner, you are an amazing teacher. Normally, traders talk with a heavy vocabulary and teaches in a very tough way. But you teach in a way that even a kid can understand. It feels that one can ask any question to you and you will answer in a very clear and simplest way. I cant tell you what a difference you are making in this crypto community. Thank you so much for your videos and book.
I find it difficult to watch videos exceeding 10mins but somehow I don't even know when i finish a whole 30mins course in your channel because its always interesting and makes a whole lot of sense. Very relatable. Weldone my friend!
This dude explained for free what I paid thousands to learn from gurus. Thats an instant drawdown before even starting trading. Ffs. Thanks for the vid!
I was very sceptical about you telling me to subscribe just all the other youtubers but about 40% way through your video I had learnt so much ... i suscribed.
The best tutorial I have come across . It is worth it and I find it very informative ,you have touched the subject in detail . So many people mention MACD in passing but never really explain it the way you did
You mentioned you were a bit of a slow learner. I know the feeling. Lol until I realized....There’s nothing slow about my learning, I simply just pay attention to detail. Great stuff Rayner Teo!!! ✨
I started using macd yesterday but it was used wrongly hence I blew up my account in less than 8 hrs. Now with what I’ve learnt from you I will go back and review the trades. Thank you.
This is the most detailed and best MACD video all the way from basics to strategies. Your explanation in simple to understand and very detailed. Thank u so much man!🤩
Me at 2:00: sweating and frowning Me at 2:06: smiling knowing that I can always count on Rayner for making everything easy to understand Love how he looked at the camera directly with a reassuring face when he says "crystal clear"
@@tradingwithrayner Hi Rayner I'm from India, I've learnt so much from you. Now i want to trade in Binary options, kindly teach me how to trade in Binary options. Waiting for your reply 😇
Tbh, you are so underrated. your videos are amongst the best I've come across. I'd actually place them up to top one 🤗🥱 people need to see just how easy it gets when you explain these things
ur so awesome man, hope to have meet you long before when i was in sg! i got my trading style from you! and it really works! continue helping people! cheers!
Do you know that you're the FIRST one EVER on RUclips to have me Subscribe and Like the content because he asked me to do it !!! I NEVER subscribe to someone who asks for it !!! You're the first one man !
Hey Rayner 😊 Just wanted to say thanks for all your great and educational videos. After studying trading for about 20 days now, and testing stuff out on a demo account I think I'm begining put the pieces of the puzzle together, much thanks to you! You're the best....much of the other stuff I've read and watched are full of bullshit and many just want to sell their worthless strategy's. Thanks again for being the real deal!
Amazingly described. I traded a loss of Rs.3000 by using MACD without noticing histogram lines, so i bumped in here to correct my technicals and tada i got the answers for wrong trade...Keep the good work up bro
Still very new to trading but find all your videos so informative, clear to follow and helpful when looking at the markets. Still learning so much but these videos are great
Hello sir ,i am from india 🇮🇳 i liked your way of explaining i have been doing intraday trading for last few months and i always get hit with stop loss. today after watching your video i got profit for the first time
I have started my Trading Journey. One of my colleagues who is a profitable trader said he studied you and ICT day and night which is why he is as profitable as he is. I see why. Im hooked.
Thank you Rayner for all your videos. I'm having a hard time being profitable in all my trades but your videos help me along the way. Good job in making this video. God Bless you!
Rayner you are a little Jinne with big heart, your videos are very informative and I gained lot of knowledge from them. Keep sharing your experience help us small traders from making losses. Thanks buddy
this is exacly oposite to what i have been told through multiple other videos. And its Exacly what I've been doing wrong.What you are doing feels WAY BETTER. WAY BETTER. THX
Perfect example at the right time. I just made some adjustments and I was headed into what I shouldn't do. I think a market reversal is about to happen when I was going short I had your video up as I was in a trade. I got stopped out, happy that happened, it saved me from making a mistake. Although I'm in the simulator, I still treat these like real trades. Great content as always. Thanks, Rayner!
Me trying to understand a basic trading concept: Before watching first yt-video: "??" 10 min spent on first video: "???!?!?, you're rambling about other shit..!" 10 min spent on second video: "?!?!, maybe this makes a bit sense" 10 min into third video: "??????????, I'm lost, wtf are these people talking about.." 1 min into Rayner Teo: " yeaa, this is the spot" 3rd time in a row I end up at this channel knowing I'm at the right place within the first minute. Simple, spot on, and repeated explanations every time, thank you, Subbed!
I must add to the long list of praises you got. And you deserve it. I should say that you've touched upon some very important observation on MACD which I've never come across. Hey bro this will certainly help me in my trading. A big hug and thank you.
Thank you for this great video!!! The MACD always seemed way too confusing to me, but this explained it perfectly and the examples helped immensely. Thank you for sharing your knowledge. The heartbeat/hospital analogy made me LOL. Subscribed! 👍
Trading can be mentally tasking so if you can't deal with the emotions and discipline involved it's better you invest with a professional or signal provider like Rutherford and remain profitable + 1 9 0 8 5 2 0 6 8 6 2
Thanks, Rainer! You are the BEST!!! I was expecting at 19 minutes to show some clue candlestick pattern etc which direction most probable for crude oil
Respected sir when I started watching your valuable videos I knew how wrong I was towards the trading system and whatever you are teaching us its amazing content ❤❤ i want to touch your feet
excellent rayner... so many important tips about MACD... thank you very much... one query i have... in case of tread filter strategy , what will be the stop loss...
Forex trading can be very addictive and can become very unhealthy, not just in terms of your performance but also in regard to your physical and mental health there is no reason to deny this. The point here is this. How bad is your trading addiction really? What is in your power that you can control and change? Do you need any sort of assistance? if you want to learn in depth , i highly recommend you to Blended Model Strategy developed by Dmitry Vladislav, you can search for it and learn to study how these technique works. A strategy that covers one of the mos effective trading methods in market history.
THANKS .GREAT HUG.GREAT SMILE ON MY FACE.BECAUSE NO ONE TELL THE TRUTH AS LIKE YOU.EVERBODY IS FOCUSING ON MONEY EVEN IN THESE KIND OF STUFFS I MEAN TEACHING THE TRUTH.BUT YOU GIVE IT FREE FOR US.GREAT.WORTH MILLION DOLLARS.IM GETTING STRONGER THANKS BROTHER YOU SHOULD DO MORE.HAPPY TRADING.HAVE A SMILE:)
@@TheDark-Knut this methods do work... But what i found more important is to find a balance between all those knowledge.... You know.. Market never gives you the exact scenario thought in this video... There are lot of aspects going on each and every trade.. But this videos are true gems.. Undoubtedly
@@DippySippy É basicamente dinheiro digital e tem varias corretoras que funcionam do mesmo jeito que a forex pra fazeres trade mas aconselho a veres videos e pesquisares mais sobre se estiveres mais interessado
I'll be hosting a live webinar where you'll discover how you can beat the markets and earn an extra 10%, 20%, or even 40% a year-without studying chart patterns or analyzing financial reports.
Claim your free ticket here: www.tradingwithrayner.com/sts/
Tons of thanks to the master rayner.... Saved my life... No words to describe.. MACD saved me from huge loss and helped me to make a consistent profit with minor losses.. I have paid huge amount to the trading institutes they never thought me like u do.. U R A SELFLESS MAN WITH KIND HEART.. SAVED MANY TRADERS FROM HEART ATTACK... ONCE AGAIN THANKS A LOT... GOD BLESS U ...
When you say ur a slow learner.. i felt the humility!
Thank you for making ur explanation personal and simple!
Watching your videos have really help me to become a much better trader. I'm not trading blindly anymore. The MACD line is the number 1 indicator that I use in my trading strategy. My profits have doubled and my losses are much lower thanks to Rayner's teachings!!! 👍🏿👍🏿
Great to hear. Earn a fortune my friend. Best of wishes.
a beginning trader should never say "I going to trust you" ..but, you seem to give the most comprehensive tutorials and advice....i subscribed and will start my demo trading soon!
You're the only learning RUclips channel i don't speed to x2 because it's awesome
Thank you, Mohamad Walieddine. I appreciate it!
Thank you Rayner for all the amazing videos. Yet, I have a question. I'm a newbie to forex trading. Very new! I am using metatrader4 mobile platform. Yet I still don't understand how it works. For example, those lines that u have don't show at all. Which platform is best for trading? And do the lines show when you set MACD, or is there sth u have to do for them to show. Thanks in advance.
Should I say, this is the Singaporean edge! ;)
This is true, there is no one who was born with knowledge, we all learnt how to trade and we all were beginners don't hesitate to connect to *Lukasz Wilhelm's* live training on forex and cryptos, teaching *IQD momentum strategy* . if you have questions or you need help. search for website (Iqdtrades.com) on google, exactly what is needed....don't mix trend play with momentum.....thanks
This is true ,
This content is too valuable to watch it with 2x .
I have been watching your videos since last month and today I have noticed that your videos are ads free. You are doing a great job and I love the way you explain. Any Newbie can easily learn from your content. ✌🏻✌🏻
As a long-time trader and well versed in Tradestation coding, I just want to compliment Rayner as being very sharp and very knowledgable about the MACD and its uses.
Rayner, I'm at the very start of my trading journey so I'm at a stage where I try to soak up as much knowledge as possible but I find your videos one of the most helpful. You have a very good way of breaking down "difficult to get at first" concepts. Thank you.
How has your journey been so far?
I'm at the start of my journey as well. Curious how much have you progressed.
@@LibertyFirst1789 and how about u are u still trading
Hello Rayner,
You’re courses are so valuable that it’s hard to find anyone who gives these classes so interesting.
With the others I always fall asleep because they talk so boring. No energy ,no charisma,no feeling. Man I really love your energy and consistency. For me your the best 🥇🤝👌
Rayner, you are an amazing teacher. Normally, traders talk with a heavy vocabulary and teaches in a very tough way. But you teach in a way that even a kid can understand. It feels that one can ask any question to you and you will answer in a very clear and simplest way. I cant tell you what a difference you are making in this crypto community. Thank you so much for your videos and book.
I find it difficult to watch videos exceeding 10mins but somehow I don't even know when i finish a whole 30mins course in your channel because its always interesting and makes a whole lot of sense. Very relatable. Weldone my friend!
This dude explained for free what I paid thousands to learn from gurus. Thats an instant drawdown before even starting trading. Ffs.
Thanks for the vid!
Kum Kie Choong gurus will not tell everything because they got paid by you...
So much free value 😊
Same here.
Your channel is a gold mine with infinite gold. Literally, so many videos that would take me months to finish studying
I was very sceptical about you telling me to subscribe just all the other youtubers but about 40% way through your video I had learnt so much ... i suscribed.
The best tutorial I have come across . It is worth it and I find it very informative ,you have touched the subject in detail . So many people mention MACD in passing but never really explain it the way you did
Awesome to hear that, Tasisio Mamina!
This seriously has to be the best video on MACD trading. Thank you, I finally understand the concept of this indicator.
You mentioned you were a bit of a slow learner. I know the feeling. Lol until I realized....There’s nothing slow about my learning, I simply just pay attention to detail. Great stuff Rayner Teo!!! ✨
I can see this is 3yrs ago but still being watched. I love how you explain bit by bit .
I started using macd yesterday but it was used wrongly hence I blew up my account in less than 8 hrs. Now with what I’ve learnt from you I will go back and review the trades. Thank you.
Why not do demo until you know what you're doing
I learned Bollinger bands from you. And now MACD. So much valuable information. Your channel is gold.
Rayner, I honestly think you should officially be granted the title of Genius
I have watched a lot of videos about MACD, but none of them explained these techniques. Thank you very much Ray, you are amazing!
I like the way you teach. You always give many example while teaching which is excellent it helps to understand easily.
Such a knowlege cannot be obtained even after paying hefty money. Great!
This is the most detailed and best MACD video all the way from basics to strategies. Your explanation in simple to understand and very detailed. Thank u so much man!🤩
Beautiful explanation with charts as example you are a life changing teacher
Me at 2:00: sweating and frowning
Me at 2:06: smiling knowing that I can always count on Rayner for making everything easy to understand
Love how he looked at the camera directly with a reassuring face when he says "crystal clear"
earlier, i was confused on MACD. But now i have learnt more. Thanks for making this wonderful video
Thanks so much Rayner, this is gold mine of information about MACD.ESPECIALLY ON THE TREND FILTER AND HISTOGRAM BREAKOUT STRATEGY
You're welcome, ANYADIKE JOHN!
@@tradingwithrayner Hi Rayner I'm from India, I've learnt so much from you. Now i want to trade in Binary options, kindly teach me how to trade in Binary options. Waiting for your reply 😇
@@TimeLapseX r u tamilnadu
@@kanishka4939 United Kingdom
*This is great but i think The Lukka Binomial Strategy works better check the internet for it*
Tbh, you are so underrated. your videos are amongst the best I've come across. I'd actually place them up to top one 🤗🥱 people need to see just how easy it gets when you explain these things
ur so awesome man, hope to have meet you long before when i was in sg! i got my trading style from you! and it really works! continue helping people! cheers!
I've never loved an explanation on an indicator like this..the part of momentum at key levels is a very important point ....thanks alot rayner
No one explained MACD before like you did. 👍
Do you know that you're the FIRST one EVER on RUclips to have me Subscribe and Like the content because he asked me to do it !!! I NEVER subscribe to someone who asks for it !!! You're the first one man !
Hey Rayner 😊 Just wanted to say thanks for all your great and educational videos. After studying trading for about 20 days now, and testing stuff out on a demo account I think I'm begining put the pieces of the puzzle together, much thanks to you!
You're the best....much of the other stuff I've read and watched are full of bullshit and many just want to sell their worthless strategy's. Thanks again for being the real deal!
After watching many videos on RUclips about Macd from many trading gurus, I found this really useful 🥰🥰🥰
Super tutorial on MACD. Never seen before. Thanks a lot Rayner.
My pleasure, Rajeev Thakur!
I am new to this market and I have watched 2 videos related to MACD and RSI, It was great learning from you, Keep posting new videos...👍
You're the best Rayner. Thanks so much for giving us the Clark Kent of tutorials on MACD. It was a Superman lesson.
Amazingly described. I traded a loss of Rs.3000 by using MACD without noticing histogram lines, so i bumped in here to correct my technicals and tada i got the answers for wrong trade...Keep the good work up bro
Amazing! Thanks Rayner! I can not believe I have been trading the MACD wrong this whole time.
Better late than never!
*This is great but i think The Lukka Binomial Strategy works better check the internet for it*
wow! this is huge.. if I had known this before I would have been winning my trades probably most of the time! Thanks very much Rayner! you're the best
Still very new to trading but find all your videos so informative, clear to follow and helpful when looking at the markets. Still learning so much but these videos are great
Hello sir ,i am from india 🇮🇳 i liked your way of explaining i have been doing intraday trading for last few months and i always get hit with stop loss. today after watching your video i got profit for the first time
The way you explain helps me understand, this channel has tremendous value. I appreciate you.
Subbed and liked. Keep it up.
Good work always shine
I have started my Trading Journey. One of my colleagues who is a profitable trader said he studied you and ICT day and night which is why he is as profitable as he is. I see why. Im hooked.
Thank you Rayner for all your videos. I'm having a hard time being profitable in all my trades but your videos help me along the way. Good job in making this video. God Bless you!
Awesome to hear that, cess euq!
Are you succeeding now? I am in desperate need of a mentor
I never saw any other channel explain things with such clarity and knowledge base! Thank you So much
I love the dead patient analogies and sound effects :)
Dark, but i liked it too.
You really do have the best and most in-depth (and easy to understand) way of teaching!!! Thank you!!!
This is one of the most important vids on youtube. Thank you
Just wanted to say thanks for all your great and educational videos.
Finally someone broke the code I’m using for a long time 🤗 cheers 👍
I agree...
Rayner you are a little Jinne with big heart, your videos are very informative and I gained lot of knowledge from them. Keep sharing your experience help us small traders from making losses. Thanks buddy
Thanks Boss, u are among the best fx trader, your tutorial has made me become a forex guru
this is exacly oposite to what i have been told through multiple other videos. And its Exacly what I've been doing wrong.What you are doing feels WAY BETTER. WAY BETTER. THX
You’re a great teacher. You relay the information so well. Thank you
You explain so well. I love your accent. I love your channel. You are the best
Thank you so much Rayner Teo, you're such a wonderful teacher.!
Perfect example at the right time. I just made some adjustments and I was headed into what I shouldn't do. I think a market reversal is about to happen when I was going short I had your video up as I was in a trade. I got stopped out, happy that happened, it saved me from making a mistake. Although I'm in the simulator, I still treat these like real trades. Great content as always. Thanks, Rayner!
one of the best tips for MACD. Thank you Rayner again. Can you please have secret tips for using RSI too ? thank you
Me trying to understand a basic trading concept:
Before watching first yt-video: "??"
10 min spent on first video: "???!?!?, you're rambling about other shit..!"
10 min spent on second video: "?!?!, maybe this makes a bit sense"
10 min into third video: "??????????, I'm lost, wtf are these people talking about.."
1 min into Rayner Teo: " yeaa, this is the spot"
3rd time in a row I end up at this channel knowing I'm at the right place within the first minute.
Simple, spot on, and repeated explanations every time, thank you, Subbed!
I just got into trading this year, and how lucky I am to have found the best guide to educate me on Indicator. You're a God'sent bruh
Dude you explain everything great! Love it finally learn MACD histo
I must add to the long list of praises you got. And you deserve it. I should say that you've touched upon some very important observation on MACD which I've never come across. Hey bro this will certainly help me in my trading. A big hug and thank you.
You are Fantastic Rayner! You’re a great teacher and doing an awesome job
Explicitly explained .. Awesome.. Thanks Rayner. You are my guru now.
Thank you, I got the e books down loaded free.🙏
I love your videos. I made so many stupid mistakes trading, lost some money following WSB. Your videos are helping me get the confidence back.
Thank you for this great video!!! The MACD always seemed way too confusing to me, but this explained it perfectly and the examples helped immensely. Thank you for sharing your knowledge. The heartbeat/hospital analogy made me LOL. Subscribed! 👍
Trading can be mentally tasking so if you can't deal with the emotions and discipline involved it's better you invest with a professional or signal provider like Rutherford and remain profitable
+ 1 9 0 8 5 2 0 6 8 6 2
I know you ain't still getting it
The little I can do is this
Thanks, Rainer! You are the BEST!!! I was expecting at 19 minutes to show some clue candlestick pattern etc which direction most probable for crude oil
My thousand likes just for the histogram explanation, amazing info
*This is great but i think The Lukka Binomial Strategy works better check the internet for it*
woow. first person to ever see doing a recap of what he has taught online. Salute Sir.
Excellent video
Glad you liked it
I am a slow leaner and I found your tutorials are very informative, and useful. Thanks.
Damn he was right about Bitcoin. It did have a recent breakthrough
twitter.com/Crypto_Buzz_247?s=09
Respected sir when I started watching your valuable videos I knew how wrong I was towards the trading system and whatever you are teaching us its amazing content ❤❤ i want to touch your feet
0:56 This is the first time I liked and subscribed at the same time
Me too
You are an amazing teacher. Your teaching skills are as good as your trading skills. Keep up the good work.
excellent rayner... so many important tips about MACD... thank you very much... one query i have... in case of tread filter strategy , what will be the stop loss...
Forex trading can be very addictive and can become very unhealthy, not just in terms of your performance but also in regard to your physical and mental health there is no reason to deny this.
The point here is this. How bad is your trading addiction really? What is in your power that you can control and
change? Do you need any sort of assistance? if you want to learn in depth , i highly recommend you to Blended Model Strategy developed by Dmitry Vladislav, you can search for it and learn to study how these technique works. A strategy that covers one of the mos effective trading methods in market history.
underrated channel. been looking to add macd histograms to my trades, excellent video
Thanks for making this video. You are my inspiration, I am learning lots from you.
Thanks.
Thank you, Arpit Maheshwari. I appreciate it!
RT you are a genius. Recently I have purchased one book and your book is like a breakout for me. In the future, I'll buy your another book.
I wish I had watched this earlier, much respect!
Your videos will rock in India , no one can explain like you from basic.
THANKS .GREAT HUG.GREAT SMILE ON MY FACE.BECAUSE NO ONE TELL THE TRUTH AS LIKE YOU.EVERBODY IS FOCUSING ON MONEY EVEN IN THESE KIND OF STUFFS I MEAN TEACHING THE TRUTH.BUT YOU GIVE IT FREE FOR US.GREAT.WORTH MILLION DOLLARS.IM GETTING STRONGER THANKS BROTHER YOU SHOULD DO MORE.HAPPY TRADING.HAVE A SMILE:)
Took me 15 minutes to subscribe, such a clear explanation for MACD. Thanks Rayner =)
MODE : binge watching
TIME SPENT : 11+ hours straight
😁
prepGUIDE U think ur a better trader now? Have u reaped any profits using his methods?
@@TheDark-Knut this methods do work... But what i found more important is to find a balance between all those knowledge.... You know.. Market never gives you the exact scenario thought in this video... There are lot of aspects going on each and every trade..
But this videos are true gems.. Undoubtedly
@@cryptofxindia Hmm interesting. Thanks! 😁
Great tips for using the MACD I have not heard before. You are an excellent presenter. Thanks!
hi Rayner,how come my mt4 brings me a MACD that has only thwe histogram and the macd line but no signal line or how should i go about it
The long time waiting for macd definite this is the best answer I ever had
Great video. I will be watching it again. However, your picture is covering up much of what you are trying to show us on the charts.
you got the concept right?
Rayner Teo is absolutely amazing guys. This man is GIVING AWAY the game (FOR FREE). Dude is an incredible soul.
Wow, you just made my day. Greeting from Luanda, Angola.
Oh um camarada da banda
Hey familia. Voces ai tambem usam forex ? Angola
@@DippySippy Nada estou mais nas criptomoedas
@@joaodiniz3481 ya? Esplica.
@@DippySippy É basicamente dinheiro digital e tem varias corretoras que funcionam do mesmo jeito que a forex pra fazeres trade mas aconselho a veres videos e pesquisares mais sobre se estiveres mais interessado
I'm gaining confidence to get back into my trading career after seeing your videos. Much respect.
"the meat of the move."
Great Teo'sir - I just loved the way you explained MACD Line & Signal line crossing! Thank you!
Why don't you talk about divergence which is the most integral part of any indicator be it MACD or RSI.
Thanks bro you are one of the smartest young man in Wall Street
It would be easy for you to work for the big managers in NY