Dictatorship, Paranoia, Famine: Welcome to North Korea!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июл 2024
- It is the most closed country in the world, the last great communist, paranoid and aggressive dictatorship. In North Korea, nothing or almost nothing has changed since the creation of the country by Kim Il-Sung in 1953. 23 million North Koreans survive in absolute misery, without any freedom, prisoners of impassable borders. It is in this distressing universe that a group of French people have decided to spend their holidays. 8500 euros for three weeks is as expensive as a stay in the Seychelles. But for this price they will have to be satisfied with rationed food, hotels without comfort, outdated buses... Not to mention the permanent surveillance of threatening guides. Claude, Henri and Jacqueline will discover cities without cars, empty shops, casinos without money. They will have to submit to mandatory visits, propaganda and forced tributes to the eternal president of North Korea. An incredible journey, as North Korea prepares for the rise to power of Kim Jong-Un, grandson of the founder of the first communist dynasty in history.
00:00 Every stranger is a potential spy
01:35 North Korea, the most closed country in the world
06:32 North Korean amusement park
09:37 1953, Korea is officially divided in two
10:27 Korean Demilitarized Zone
13:35 The War Museum
15:02 In North Korea, we are rewriting history
19:13 An old air force fighter
19:37 Trophies, weapons taken from the enemy
20:26 Mural on the Battle of Seoul
21:22 Pyongyang, the capital of the communist regime
24:47 Kim Il-Sung, the local Stalin
27:38 The only pizzeria in the country
30:13 Pyongyang Embroidery Institute
32:23 The totalitarian regime
33:55 Model schools
38:48 The North Korean army
40:46 Mount Paektu
43:50 Kim Il-Sung's birthplace
48:46 Ultra sensitive classified area
Director: Brisard JC; Spalaikovich A. 
Развлечения
Why would anyone risk a trip to North Korea where one wrong move could get you in prison and tortured for years.
Yeah. You white guys are crazy yo. If I had that much money for travel I would go to Paris or Cyprus or something.
because they themselves are socialists and LOVE being in such countries; they love being restrained and thrive on not having to decide for themselves to make any "wrong moves"
@@amc5926 euhm...there's nothing wrong with being a Socialist, just a communist socialism dictature combi is kinda killing. If you only have one or two political parties in your country theres always a risk of becoming a dictatorship. I'm lucky enough to live in a democracy but imagine being in a country wheres there's nothing more to choose than one or two sides. Doesn't matter what political philosophy you engage, it's bound to go wrong. That's why freedom and different parties are important!! The lesser parties the more indoctrination!
only for naive white people
No wrong move needed..you just have too be a White American! after all America is still at war..with N.korea...still only a cease fire.
Im gonna just say it: these tourist had me on edge the whole time. Be flippant, an asshole or careless with your words when you aren't visiting a totalatarian government. Trying to trick the guy at the end to go for a solitary walk would've gotten him in trouble. You may get to go home but the Korean people you encounter may face repercussions for your actions
I was saying the same thing. They are coming off as entitled whiney westerners. No wonder Americans are hated so much. Did you catch the one complaining about them having no snow removal?? Oh, and I am soooo disappointed I couldn't see the handmade embroidery. I'll ask for a refund, but I probably won't get one. SMUG and disgraceful. I feel bad for the operator of that facility. You know there will be punishment for no one being there to make these two biddies happy.
Not to mention, the guard seemed nice and patient enough. Meet one that is intolerant and you would be arrested there and then.
Little overdramatic aren't you?;)
Come on, you don't really think they were trying to TRICK him.. they just asked and attempted to compel him, where is the trickery in what they said? These are evidently intelligent nice people, I don't get why you're trying so hard to put them down..?
But you need to understand that these guides who get to meet foreigners are members of the North Korean Security Service, they are part of the enforcement and not victims, so if you can cause them trouble then so you should.
@@SasquachPL In such circumstances local people do have a threat on their lives, don't be so stupid.
Isso sim é um documentário e não a propaganda gratuita feita pelo Castanhari.
Perfeito! Aquele cara é o típico cidadão do "capitalismo apra mim e socialismo para você"!
No, this film is pure agitprop.
@@clever3383 Graças ao capitalismo que tem internet para mostrar como o comunismo é uma bosta 💩
@@clever3383kkkkkkkkkkkk
Castanhari merece apanhar até virar homem
This is a prison not a country 😢
Millions of people living the shit life all to keep one man happy and fat
They achievied full comunism
well that.
agree from sk 😢
Its a mistake for outsiders, because western media like this is merely western propaganda to brainwash people to hate and defame N.Korea🙂.
N. Korea is a peace and happy country, the western media just never talk about its positive sides
That woman directing imaginary traffic with precision as if any crashes were about to happen is one of the bizarre scenes of North Korean life I've ever seen.
It’s disturbing to me. She’s so good at it, she’s probably done this for years, and yet she has hardly any traffic. I’m sure she’s basically forced to to it too.
It's so wacky. Is she getting paid to do this? Is she aware that what she's doing is completely bonkers and pointless? So many questions.
@@elimcfly350 In planned economies, jobs are allocated. Even if she was paid, it is monopoly money. The only guarantee is that she would be punished for not doing the bullshit job for 6-7 days a week
Like an NPC in a game. Makes it feel really weird..
It's just the way they create "jobs". If they'd had automatic traffic lights, this women would be jobless and poor. I also suspect that they work in shifts, not for entire day... Still it is very depressing thing to look at.
The woman directing nonexistent traffic was so intensely fascinating
Although who knows how the country will improve now that the Russian bear is here.
I don’t think fascinating is the right word. More like bizarre!
A NPC in North Korea.
O pior é que têm gente defendendo essa seita e nunca foram lá pra ver a realidade🇧🇷
Gente pra defender o q não presta é o q mais tem. Deveria era agradecer a liberdade que temos pq dúvido q qualquer um aqui dê conta de viver desse jeito
@@Taai- vdd mano!
Eu fico meio chocado com isso, "tipo o hamas", só que o hamas aida é um grupo novo que se popularizou nesse século e fazendo pouco tempo, muita gente nem os conhece direito e luta em prol deles, mesmo sendo claro as ações e atitudes de terrorismo deles, agora a ditadura Norte-coreana eu fico pasmo😦 que tem muitas pessoas que defendem e aida não sabem como o governo de lá realmente fuciona; o governo deles nunca foi nem criado por eles mesmo como um país democrático ou como qualquer outro, ela foi fundada originalmente pela propia União soviética como um governo fantoche pra fins políticos nos 50, e seguiu assim até o fim das guerras do século passado.
Após o Castanhari ser desmentido pelo Thiago Braga, começou aparecer brasileiros nos comentários. 😂
@@Vida-Erudita Apareceu até norte e sul-coreanos
Felipe Castanhari do canal Nostalgia deveria assistir isso....
Up
Up
Three things saddened me in this video: the children, the woman who regulates traffic, and the people locked inside the village
Do not too naif, they known what that's foreign nation didnt know.
Believe it or not, the traffic woman job is highly sought after and there is fierce competition for the role. You also have to be within a certain age range to have this job and also be beautiful.
I can't imagine how much coward you have to be ,to become so afraid of other country sending spies , I mean you are a dictator for Godsake . I see now they may be dictator but they are just figureheads, the country is being managed and actual power processing guy is the one who inforces these rules and they are a group of corrupt malevolent animals hiding behind this coward rat fatface like bastard. Same as China where xi being afraid of these power hungry people is now offing them up as means of accidental deaths. Haha cowards idiots pussies all in the race of showcasing their power as a whore leader.
Saddest thing for me is seeing how everyone is a simpleton, uneducated and sad.
Why were you saddened by a crossing guard?!
"The traffic lady in an empty intersection signaling like a puppet gone mad" i felt kind of sad for her.
Don't she is on 50 cents an hour double the average wage.
@@joblogs8886 50 cents an hour? She wishes.. More like 3 cents.
She has to keep moving, she's on camera. She's being watched by someone to make sure she's working. But she is living a better life than most. But of course she is , she's good looking.
It gives her purpose in a purposeless society along with a better wage and party status than some.
She certainly doesn't feel sad. She's so brainwashed that she considers what she's doing as an honor and very fortunate to be doing it. There's much worse jobs she could be doing.
A quem foi lá arriscar a vida pra fazer esse documentário, muito obrigado!
Esse sim é um documentário de verdade, essas pessoas não podem mais ir lá, pisou já era kkkkk
A mulher do transito realmente é uma das cenas mais bizarras que ja vi em documentarios desse tipo
When you're having a bad time in life simply watch this kind of documentary to make yourself remember how good of a life you have still compared to this.
Exactly! Remember when you don’t bow down to the US like it’s puppets from Europe, Japan , 5 eyes et al they will impose unilateral sanctions to isolate and stave your people
how do you know this is real?
@@johnskrelnik it's obviously real. there's a whole video of it right in front of you. i mean did you think it was a cartoon? I think you mean "how do we know if this is propaganda "
the information in this video has been verified time and time again from defectors. in fact the defectors have said its actually a lot worse than portrayed. go see for yourself. there's testimonies all over the internet. as well as ample proof that times are rough there.
plus the elites only allow tourists to see what they want them to see. and they do that because they have a lot to hide.
@@johnskrelnik What is not real? Do you not believe this is filmed in North Korea? Do you think the video is just CGI? If this video is not real do you think the real conditions are worse or better? Do you think it is not possible to tell that a video is real or not?
@@johnskrelnik they can give you all these video. what things you can give us to prove it's false? doubt it without any evidence? it's not valid. --- a Chinese in China, a hell (north Korea is worse)
That entire school segment filled me with sadness more than anything else. The best thing about kids is that they are genuine, and to see them forced to keep up appearances at such a young age is very hard to see.
Enjoyed your freedom cause those kids will never will
At least they will never do either meth or fentanyl. I´m German and thus do not liver under some stone. And as far as I know, America´s kids have to do a flag oath. Hint, hint. Totalitarian regimes love that shit.
These people are living like Robots in a land of Fantasy.
What's sad is at least the North Korans know they are being fed propaganda 24/7. NoKo and Kim Jung Un look at the American media propaganda machine and is jealous.
@@anchuto where did you get that from?
Um parque calmo, ruas com áreas de lazer vazias, um museu lindo com diversas peças históricas sem um nativo sequer visitando? Não precisa ser especialista pra entender que algo acontece nesse país e que o real povo nativo está vivendo uma realidade totalmente oposta do apresentado... Se uma coisa aprendi nessa vida é que o ser humano gosta de conforto e tudo que eles mostraram para os turistas é impecável, não tem cultura ou ser humano que vá deixar de usufruir sequer um pouquinho disso tudo. Fico triste pelo povo norte coreano que é refém da terra natal mas que ainda assim precisa fingir que está tudo certo.
Assista " o show de truman,o show da vida " .eis a Coreia do Norte 😂😂
A “marionete humana” em forma de Agente de Trânsito é a parte que me pegou. 😳😢
cara aquilo foi bizarro , a mulher e uma marionete 😢
Ela está feliz da vida por servir o líder supremo e seu amado país, é assim o pensamento 😅
“You can have fun with the slot machines, but there’s never any jackpot”
Sooo incredibly dystopian.
Like Twilight Zone episode or something 😂
Ok
How could he possibly know this? I've never once seen a slot machine give a jackpot myself, doesn't mean it never happens. A preposterous assertion that says a lot about the journalistic standards.
🤣🤣🤣
@@frank327 I stopped watching because while NK is obviously a state utilising propaganda trying to counter it with ridiculous statements like that merely show the documentary maker is quite happy to use propaganda himself.
I am a doctor and was sent to NK for a year with Doctors Without Borders
The worst country and experience ever. I was afraid all the time because i feared doing something “ wrong “
I stuck it out but NEVER again…
Tell the commies who want the US to be like NK, tell them to move there and enjoy their "socialist paradise"
Are you okay？
God Bless you & yours.
Mexico is worse.
Must a paid you nice tho to go NK
The Jacqueline tourist made my blood boil💀
Lol the worst
what did she do that was so bad ? i seem to have missed it
the woman directing non existent traffic is so eerie
The most ironic part of these videos is that North Korea always talks about how horrible the US and west are, yet puts so much effort into putting on a great show for them
Not ironic....that's how propaganda works!
I admire the people there for their spunk. They prop up our old tanks and submarines as relics in their museums and routinely depict us in their artwork, sculptures. You don't give someone that much attention unless there's some level of admiration involved. Don't forget the Dear Leader had a mancrush on Michael Jordan, who was an American and unapologetic capitalist.
North Korean leaders attack the US but have no problem being fans of basketball players like Michael Jordan aa well as American movies
@@ionvrabie9082🤣🤣🤣🤣
@ionvrabie9082 well atleast you wouldn't be fat lol
I like how finally one of the guides at the end was all "Look they'll kill me so please just chill out"
Lmao fr, not really funny but yeah 😐
I really hope that every guide in this documentary are okay and didn't get punish
@@rieriesungob That's my thought. After this made it to RUclips, how many of the not-observant-enough guides simply vanished, and their families too? A horrifying possibility.
Can you tag the time?
@@gykg3202around 51:20
What I want to say is that the videographers were too arrogant. It was a good thing that they tried to explore, but they made things difficult for the staff and did not provide post-technical processing for the staff to protect them. Many ordinary North Koreans are powerless with their lives. The staff that these tourists can encounter can only do things according to the procedures. The consequence of not complying is death.The behavior of the visitors is really embarrassing for these ordinary people. They have no way and cannot give the "democratic answer" that the video shooter hopes to see.
Só penso uma coisa , se desde que nasci eu fosse treinado para ser um escravo eu com certeza iria morrer achando que tive uma vida plena , isso é realmente assustador. Embora em meu país tenha políticos corruptos e safados , o povo ainda pode tira-los de 4 em 4 anos.
Procure a entrevista do fugitivo de um campo dw concentração de la... o cara parece que nao tem mais alma
Show de Truman
I lost it, when she was so seriously directing nonexistent traffic and a little old man/woman walked by pushing a trash can!
Can u imagine doing that all day😳
these ppl were brought up heartless
When he said, like a puppet gone mad, I couldn’t help but 😂. It’s truly sad because their leader is in complete control of millions of people.
@@hongng3963 they have hearts that beat because they are human.
@@theresalally1620 drive you mad just so pointless
It's so unfair to put the "guides" in such compromising situations by trying to do things which are forbidden. I really don't understand why anyone would do this.
Rich entitled people always believe they are abkve any countries laws. And they wonder why tourists are watched so closely. Maybe cause they can't be trusted to follow simple rules , no matter how many times they are told.
Guide: "It is so damn hard to earn today's salary."
Psst... tell them they're a 3rd world country and ask em wtf is wrong with them.
Being a wealthy douchebag to be able to return back to France and tell stories about your time in a place no one gets to do. It’s the same thing with people climbing Everest. It’s the Sherpas doing quite literally all the work. And you get something to talk about at your shitty parties on Saturday nights.
@@PartyingInPortland amd you live where? Portland? The shithole capital of the USA!!!
At the 13:48 mark when the guide walks over to talk to the older woman, I wonder if the guide is a family member whom the employee is allowed to have them come in and do that work. The smile on her face and warmth in her eyes as she looks up, they obviously have a close relationship and the guide wasn't being rude, you can see they point behind them subtly and she understands and quickly gets up and leaves.
Tourists to North Korea support the regime by going there. They bring foreign money that the regime desperately grasps for. The regime doesn't want or need the approval of foreigners. It's a Faustian bargain, where they put on a show and their best face in exchange for the money... If you really want to help North Koreans, don't forget their plight and don't go there.
Am I the only one to have seen and heard all of the North Korean documentaries and use them for sleep?
Yea
I do the same! 😂 What is wrong with us 😴
Me too
I love them
I use astronomy videos for sleep. Never tried a north Korea video
Those tourists didn’t even realise they were risking their guide’s lives by attempting to defy their rules. If I ever travel to NK, I will obey everything they tell me because I could not live with myself if a guide was executed because I chose to be a rebel
是的，游客们试图用自己的世界观去带入到朝鲜，但是对这个国家来说并不是一种好的方式
@@user-yj5vc9df2b can you translate to English for me?
@@Jordysegs89It reads: "Yes, tourists try to bring their own worldview into North Korea, but it's not a good way for the country."
And look what happened to Otto Warmbier. I personally am interested in visiting the country, only theoretically, but I would never dare to provoke anything.
Especially at the end when the French man said to the guide “this other guide said we can go for a walk outside” like did they not think how that would affect the other guides life? 😳
모든것이 위정자를 위한 거짓과 선전으로 둘러싸인 북한의 현실~
그저 한심스럽고 답답합니다. 언제 저들은 깨어나서 제대로된
삶을 살 수 있을지 요원합니다.
are you from North Korea?
A verdadeira face do que é comunismo!
The fact that they managed to get this much footage out is probably why things are extra strict now
And how many people went to prison for life or died _because_ that footage is aired in the West to N. Korea's eternal embarrassment?
It's amazing that they thought they'd be able to fool anyone. They have drunk their own Kool aid yet don't realize how much more advanced the rest of the world is. The US can take a picture of any beach they want to with satellites, all this photography co trol is a waste of time.
Extra?
The French visitor's are very accustomed to their earnings of thousands of Euro's per month .🤸♀️.. they fly from bus stop to cheese croissant shop 🐣 🇦🇴
RICHTIG TRAURIG ARME MENSCHEN DA😪😥😠😓
Two things in this documentary really struck me. Despite all the attempts of North Korea to look perfect they’re still hopelessly outdated a don’t seem to know it. And the naïve nature of the tourists who tried to slip the minders to see normal civilians. It was never going to be possible given how everything is staged.
dude you realize that docu is like 25 years old ?
No it’s 12 years late 00’s early 2010’s
@@viraloracle5151 it’s not much different today. Just add fake IPhones that don’t actually have any apps or internet
This is old as dirt. It says Kim Jong Il is president. He died in 2011.
it's an ideology as old as mankind,, Make yourself look good , by making someone else look bad.
Podia levar muito brasileiro pra lá, né Castanhari 😂😂😂
That poor woman polishing rocks. They chased her off. I almost cried.
The fact these ppl risked their lives to give us this is just fascinating
you dream this a stolen video from a french tv documentary north korea was ok with EVERYTHING you see
no they fucking dint go to beinjing and go to one of the many agencies that will take you there you ignorant fuck
Most of them are old French communists who are trying desperately to keep their faith. They’re actually saying positive things.
@@davethebrahman9870 he literally refers to their leader as the worst dictator in the world
not likely! they acted like imbeciles! and entitled..their reckless behavior could've git the security guards in a lot of trouble. even death..
I love how the tourists came to a dictatorship and were shocked when they had to follow the same strict laws as the general populous.
Try to live like this. That's why there are no contacts with people from outside.
como e que sois tao parvos ide la para vrer
Vai viver na Coreia do Norte.
Está fazendo o que em país capitalista?
Como te puede gustar una MIERDA de leyes??? Tienes que estar ENFERMO. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
You just summarized up every woke people.
Muito triste uma realidade como essa. :(
Those French Tourist are not bright....lol
Can you imagine being upset that you can't buy or see an embroiderer that's probably child or a person forced into horrible working conditions.
The Frenchman saying that dictatorships are "clearner" "no homeless" yea because they all die and starve together
if you open a cupboard in north korea, homeless people would probably come tumbling out....
@@marycanary86 Exactly. The idea that N Korea doesn't have homeless is laughable. They're just smart and stay hidden because the alternative is death.
Organ donor too.
When they said at the beginning that he went to Iran and loved it I was like "Ok well probably he means like the historic sites and landmarks and food and stuff" but by the time he was happily bowing to statues of Kim and saying how everything was so "ordered" I realized he actually thinks dictatorships are not that bad.
Sounds like that french guy is a typical WEEB
The scene with the old woman polishing rocks made me sad... She smiles cheerfully at the guide, the guide tells her something, then her smile immediately drops and her gaze falls on the camera. 😥
Yesua is God and loves you read the Holy Bible 📖❤️
all over the world exist that scenes
BUT NOT IN LIECHTENSTEIN :)))))
You can thank the brainwashed marxist pedophiles being churned out of our colleges for this, as this is the future of the USA. Remember, under communism everyone is equal!!
Time?
So sad 💔
That background music in the morning is BLEAK.
Right? It's like the one from the Squid Game! 🐙
Bleak and eerie! Smh!
Bleak and eerie! Smh!
Quem está aqui por causa do Castanhari?
Eu
Kkkk
Eu
Eu kkkkkk
O que ele fez?
Freaking depressing how everything is controlled.
Njima nije ,eu ,sad globalno nev mozemo bez googla,mobitela !
Ekloni ga na par dana pa da vidimo tko je depresion?
Mi ilinS Koreja
Krajnost yas ekstremno ,ali u zdrave svrhe
Its the exact same here in the west. You just dont realize it just like the North Koreans do not realize it.
Exactly what the wef have planned for the planet.
@@cdoe3395 lmao you are crazy if you think the west is even close to North Korea's situation.
@@cdoe3395 Naa.. only if the religious fascist get their full ways.. Like hitIer would of wanted, every conservative culture loves "hitIer". Every conservative "culture" tends to revert back to this "authoritarian" behavior. Its why their cultures fear "liberals", as they don't OBEY under a "auth" society. Even in china they dont like liberals, even our conservatives in the west, hates them; its why they all parrot, hitIer speeches to incite fear. Even China is evolving backwards to their old conservative fascist ways of behaving.
The west isnt even there yet; they try but their backwards conservatives are failing, its just a bunch of old decrepit white guys trying to control their women and people in congress. We'll eat the rich one these days.
Considering what they show on NK docs, like they do china, they are "fear" mongering, they arent showing any "real" sides to it, they are nit picking, they are only pandering to the west. NK has been evolving from those past "dark" ages of auth. Any country that develops a "nuke" means they have actual freedom; its why ukraine fell.
A North Korean fisherman while out at sea heard South Korean radio program broadcast and in the radio program a character was having a conversation with another character about why they were late and said because "all of the vehicle parking places were taken" so she had to drive further away to finally find a place to park their car. The Sailor laughed at what he thought was silly South Korean propaganda. But he went home and that thought tumbled around in his head and the next few times he went out to sea he would listen to the radio broadcast and eventually something made him think that it might really be true that there could be a place in the world where they had so many cars that they had no place to park them. So eventually he wanted to find out and he defected taking his boat to South Korea.
He's like the majority of people. Believing the sophistry they were force-fed by their respective governments' media propaganda machines. We are not that different.
i hope he's doing ok.
Wouldn't it be wonderful if North Korea was not under decades of American sanctions, imagine car parking space might in North Korea be as hard to find as in South Korea.
@@kingKong-fd7wm 🤡
What mind manipulation crazy hoq the whole country is head messed by one man shamefull
É muito bizarro isso, as pessoas tem medo constante do regime.
Tristeza saber que os norte coreanos sofrem com esse regime, décadas e décadas 😢
Eles tem pena de nós 😅 ! São doutrinados desde bebês , nem sentem ...
I hope maybe in my lifetime I’ll see the liberation of the NK People. Keeping up the facade of everything being fine is heartbreaking. The guides knowing damn well that 60% of the people live in abject poverty.
The unfortunate reality is that bloodshed is almost certain. The regime will not go down without a fight.
It wouldn’t surprise me if American politicians secretly admire the dictator ship in North Korea seeing that a lot of the same things are starting to take form in America itself. Control of the Internet, Control of medical decisions, The removal of liberties, children being educated and brainwashed by the state, and I could just go on and on. You people really need to wake up.
@@timburss3335 North Korean starve to death, and their military is weak. The only thing fearful about them is their nuclear bombs
More Americans live in poverty than north koreans
Plz See Jw/Jehovah's Witnesses😔People were not meant to go through this. I say this as comfort that these terrible conditions people endure are not permanent.*Soon, All Governments on Earth will be affected by one incoming Kingdom. It will bring Safety + true Freedom to the Entire planet 🌎earth.
The Education, Invitation, +Warning is going on, even there--before the takeover from this 1 Global Goverment. It's being done quietly underground. It will replace our not good enough systems + Fix All Earth problems including Homelessness Poverty Disease Death❤
@@timburss3335 If we're all extinguished, borders won't matter. Nukes would bring nukes in return.
This tour took place in 2010 for those like me who were wondering.
Thanks fo mentioning. Thought/calculated the same (2011).
Yeah thought it was looking a bit dated. Still, if not for the pc's and flat monitors in that one bit, i'd think its footage from the 90's or earlier even, i grew up in the 90's in the post soviet times, and even our shitty poor cities looked far more colorful, free and alive than this hellscape, most people had tv's too.
I was.... thanks
@@Etaoinshrdlu69 they literally shot missiles over south Korea last week wtf are you talking about? The entire country is controlled all day everyday so I guess if you're a democrat that's what progressive means..
@@Etaoinshrdlu69 nowhere near “super progressive”. still very dated
O castanhari não curtiu esse documentário 😅
Dios bendiga a quienes realizan este tipo de documentales, literal, arriesgan su vida por un reportaje para el mundo donde muestran cómo es verdaderamente Corea del Norte, que miedo vivir ahí.
ma va a cacare
@@federicoponzo7092
Gli unici caf0ni qui sopra siete voi itagli0ti. Che goduria nell'est a vedervi in difficoltà perché parlate solo inglese , e loro non lo parlano , e voi senza dire una parola nella loro lingua. Vi lascio da soli e g0d0. Tu , tira la catena😂
Everything in NK is so sterile, desolate, and depressing. The entire country reeks of dispair.
kinda like the US
@@bluegamer4210 lol ok dumbass😂
@@bluegamer4210 What?
So that fat man can get fatter.
@@bluegamer4210the US has its faults, a lot of faults, but NK is just a whole nother universe compared to the States, not even comparably close for “like” and “kinda” to be in the same sentence
33:00 ive worked 6 years in a kindergarten in China. And the differences are insane.
Every single facial expression of these kids in North Korea, is completely and utterly orchestrated and trained in, nothing is natural child emotions.
I can spot this from a mile away. And the teacher too, each smile is fake.. Anyone that has worked with kids can see this.
It's astonishingly sad, that even from the age of 3, they are growing up never having seen, or themselves expressing, real genuine external emotions.
So how was it in China?
The same as in the West, frankly, genuine happy playing kids, goofing off, teasing each other, hugging the teacher, good quality teachers that genuinely cared for the kids. They were obviously way more diciplined kids, but mostly in a good way. The fair but firm mentality.
But when i look at every face in this video, not a single one of the kids are showing genuine emotion.
Perhaps they never learnt how to, since all their teachers also only show them fake smiles.
This is a huge issue for their future development as emotional real human beings.
It's the equivalent of being raised by sociopaths in a basement with no connection to anyone real.
that whole class will be forced into the military, until they die. youre right, theyre not being raised normally. theyre for show. and then theyll probably be thrown into military service and a new group will be pulled from the country and treated the same
Thanks for sharing your perspective. I still think of the whole thing as a show. They might or might not have freedom of expression among themselves, they are just not allowed to show it when the "guests" are around. I could imagine emotion management must be hard for kids, but it's a great deal of selection: you can pick a few "model citizen" children among 25 million country for a single show kindergarten (and I guess conditions and opportunities are much better for those kids hence the incentive).
Если про Китай много лжи, почему ты думаешь, что они не могут врать про Северную Корею?
Listen to Yeonmi Park, a woman who escaped from North Korea. She said everyone is numb, death means nothing. All anyone thinks about is how to get their next meal.
@@shannonwhite474Don’t listen to her as she lies a lot! The same themes are repeated by other defectors too so just milks on that to lie through her teeth.
That image of the woman directing non-existent traffic creeps me out for as innocuous as it seems.
Gastar ese dinero para conocer COREA del norte a sabiendas que no hay LIBERTAD ni para respirar lo encuentro un peligro innecesario que
The line that hit me the most is "The woman is directing nonexistent traffic; the movements those of a puppet gone mad".
That got me, too.
Obviously this is just a training video of sorts...get off her back man.
@@Asianbrat😅
Don’t forget, Pyongyang, as desolate as it is with no cars and buses that look like they’re falling apart, is the most privileged of North Korean society. Their most privileged live worse than the poorest of the west
But look, there's even thin blankets in the closet where you can sleep on the floor! Even plastic buckets to relieve yourself in and a truck comes and takes it away every morning! Such luxury!
china same
D leadership should b hung slowly 😨😨😨😨😩😩😨😩
@@terrytaylor808 another anti-China bot
Mostre esse documentário ao Castanhari
What is the music? Shazam can't recognize it, can't find :(
That last part trying to get around where you're not allowed really irritated me.. You might not get into trouble but there could be a serious risk to the guides or other innocent citizens.. Kinda looked stupid trying to sneak into restricted areas..
Without people breaking the rules like that, you wouldn’t know what’s there
@@user-vs6uq9xz2p yep, time to steal a painting so everyone knows how its like
Yes, good idea to put everyone in danger just because you're curious @@user-vs6uq9xz2p
COVID-esque?! 🤣🤣
"You didn't follow up the question, did you? You were scared."
"I just didn't have the courage to"
I dont blame you,mate. Infact, kudos for even venturing into North Korea. I dont have the balls to!
excelente documental, pero lastima que no concuerde el video con el audio...
أتمنى للشعب الكوري الشمالي العيش بحرية وسلام وامان دون كيم جونغ وديكتاتوريته
Whoever filmed all this is so freaking brave
Indeed
RUSSIA _ N.KOREA ,,,,FREEDOM>>!!!!!💩🤡👺❤🩹💤💤💪💪💪💪
or suicidal
It's probably not truce that you are so controlled!
@NettiesKid things you don't understand must scare you easily.
To pay to go on vacation at a country that is a prison is a bit insane. I feel bad for the people who live without freedom.
Hypocrisy, evil westerners, white people, in America, you break into someone's house with a weapon, and someone else will shoot you directly, you white pigs admit it, in turn, the United States and its allies are wary of the Korean War Isn't it wrong? Germany slaughtered Jews, and later admitted the mistake, apologized, compensated, what about the United States? Why can't the North Korean people hate the United States? You say the war is over and it's all right? Shouldn't you hate America? It's so hard to kill a person in the US, and then kill it, after the killing is over, is it all right? This is a crime,,,, in the United States you break into someone else's house to kill, and say nasty words, I have killed your husband or wife or child, and then said to you or your husband or wife: The killing is over, You shouldn't hate me, it's hypocrisy and evil.
@@sheilamorrison1954 tell me
@@sheilamorrison1954 not as bad as communist north korea.
@@sheilamorrison1954 bro heard that oppression exists in America for the first time and thinks she’s experiencing less freedom than literal north Koreans
its mindblowing that these people that give power to him in the first place just so diginitily follow everything he says without any thought. i for sure, if born there, would have crushed the government with force, gain access to military and beat it down from within or with a massive bomb, a huge sacfrifice for the future of the people.
Paranoia y hambruna, pues, en Latinoamérica eso también hay eh, pero algunos lo niegan y dicen que todo está bien...🤷😄
Pues vete a vivir en Corea del norte entonces
aqui al menos tienes libertad de usar internet, de expresarte si algo no te gusta del gobierno pero en Corea del Norte ni de chiste puedes tener una vida digna y libre en lo mas minimo.
En latinoamerica estamos a años luz de corea del norte almenos acá les podemos mandar al diablo a nuestros políticos y gritarles en la cara y tenemos nuestros servicios basicos medianamente satisfechos
I can't believe they even tried to just go out for a stroll at 10pm, then proceeded to ignore the porter the first time when he asked them to go back in. Seemed like a great way to ens up like Otto. Idiots.
I was surprised and slightly concerned myself.
They think they are entitled às they think they are is America. Not there!
@@patricianewman5233 aren't they from France though?
@@whatever5091 they were and this was film way before that happened
@@tsundokus Yeah but as the commentary in this video shows, NK already had a reputation for disappearing tourists at the drop of a hat if they said or did something wrong. I'm not one of these people over here saying that it would be their fault if something bad happened, but I do think they are kinda crazy for speaking any criticism while still inside the country. I don't care how sure I was that nobody could hear me, I'd save it until I had civilization under my feet again.
A friend of mine in Australia was, a number of years ago, involved in EU aid programs in North Korea. He described how he travelled everywhere with an official "guide" who just followed him around and made sure he only went where the government wanted him to.
In every town he stayed in there was a single restaurant for officials and high ranking party members only. The food was plentiful in these restaurants and usually wasn't bad. As a "guest" of the government, he was compelled to eat in the towns party restaurant each night.
My friend said that his guide, invariably a low ranking secret police employee, just loved going out to the restaurant each night. He would just eat until he nearly burst.
It was quite a fringe benefit for a low ranking party official, like the guide, to eat in a high ranking party restaurant. He was going to make the most of it while it lasted.
EU aid programme in North Korea? Tell another joke.
@@pauloreis8958 Food production. Hydroponic glasshouses, apparently.
@@pauloreis8958 i guess its to help north Korea ppl but not their goverment but the problem was its not gonna ez too confince the goverment
@@pauloreis8958 bravoi l-ai mirosit pa mincinosul manipulator Ha, ha, ha Tare minciuna cusuta cu ata alba
Man tha propaganda never stops
북한은 김정은을 제외하면 뚱뚱한 사람이 없다
Pues como no es el único que traga como marrano mientras las demás gentes padeciendo hambre 😢
Beautiful children, I hope they’re ok. :(
Impressive spoken French by some of them! Having citizens learn fluency in major international languages definitely makes sense for this regime, especially when offering tours. I honestly laughed when the guy near the end casually told the French tourist "je connais ton truc" ("I know what you're up to") after he tried to trick him.
That's the truth. The guide knew what the tourist he was taking was doing.
The proof is the narrative and opinions that are deliberately built in this video.
I learn French in many years but i only know the word "truc" when i went to France, clearly, this word is popular in France but rarely we know it in school where we learn foreign language. Honesty, they speak French very well.
The kids so talented musically , imagine if that kid on the piano had access to Pagganini or Llist
Trained spies?
@dimasd24_23 are you defending North Korea? 😭
It really annoys me when people visit North Korea and try and out the workers in situations where they will be punished ! Completely unfair! I understand if this doesn’t happen we wouldn’t know all of this but my heart really goes out to them
Seriously how I felt, especially with the war museum section. If you were a tourist and would be the only person facing consequences for poking the bear with a stick, then do whatever you want. But the fact that other people could face repercussions for your actions, intentional or not, it's completely out of pocket if you're trying to provoke something
I bet you got vaxxed, retard
I agree. I also wish they would've censored the face of the guy on the beach
I feel the same way. These workers knows that its all lies. But they dont have any choice, and they may be punished becuse of the turists actions or questions.
Yes. They were putting those workers in comprising positions, to prove a point to themselves. To what avail? Confront the lies your own governments tell. The all lie. I understand some of the lues we're ridiculously infuriating, but they have rules, that these visitors agreed to follow. They are free to make all the critiques they want when they leave. Endangering themselves and those workers, for the satisfaction of a snarky remark or two was stupid. They were being rude and disrespectful, when they paid to visit that place.
O Castanhari me jurou que esse país é um paraíso 😢😭
What a horrible way of life! That eerie music at sunrise would drive me insane.
I remember reading somewhere that it isn't the punishment that is so terrifying, but the threat of punishment that terrifies people. So, when tourists misbehave and are disrespectful, the guides really do fear for their lives, and also fear the ''loss of face.''
possibly so, but the reality is they are completely willing and prepared to follow through with any and all threats. they are merciless.
You can tell in the look of that woman at the museum.
Whats different to our western regimes?
Most of you peasants are doing what the government and the people in power want from you, doesnt matter if its wrong what you are doing as long you get a little bit paid.
Chasing Dissent LIVE EU Goes INFINITY LOOPY WAR ! - CDL ep.247
ruclips.net/video/dT4gxv7CieE/видео.html
Giving money to officials legally and then monopolizing the market is called democracy. A place where all the housing, medical care, education, equal development, and only talk about ability is a dictatorship. It seems that I have to re-read philosophy again.
saw a documentary some years ago about 'doctors without borders' (or a similar organization) - who had arranged for a group of ophthalmologists to go into NK to help people suffering from major vision loss due to cataracts and other degenerative eye conditions that had gone untreated for many years - some of these people were nearly completely blind and in most cases the surgeons were able to restore their eyesight - and as you would expect these people were emotionally overwhelmed once they could see again - and they gave tremendous thanks - but not to the surgeons - they effusively declared their love and gratefulness to "dear leader" (Kim Jong-un - or maybe at that time his father Kim Jong-il ) - but they barely acknowledged the doctors & nurses who had actually restored their vision - and you got the distinct impression that it was out of absolute fear that they were doing this - fear that if they gave thanks to anyone other than their "dear leader" - they would be severely punished ..
I saw this documentary aswell, awhile back. That was wild, the way they cheered and thanked their "dear leader". I feel like some of them were even crying for joy
That's shocking, to me it's the same when people thank a deity for something another person did, and they deny the person will to help them, and insted just praise 'God' 😂
I remember that doc. I watched it some years ago as well. one doctor did some like 3000 surgeries in a couple days. I will never forget, like you stated, all the people thanking their 'great leader' and never the doctor because in their mind it was all because of their 'great leader' that made it happen.
I remember one older man, prob in his 60's, thanking the leading and saying something like 'I can now see the evil of Americans and I can kill them!" absolutely horrible stuff....
@@avril6922 that's exactly their mentality. They see the Kim family as Gods.
That was a great documentary. I think some did it out of fear.
Eu hein, é horrível nascer e ser obrigado a viver numa ditadura como essa. Deus tenha misericórdia desse pobre povo que é refém de um ditador megalomaniano a frente de um regime falido como esse. (I am brazilian)
Eae, também sou do Bostil
@@israelsales9096 Comparado com a Coreia do Norte (e tb mais alguns lugares no mundo) vivemos num paraiso amigo, portanto não reclame.
Chocada e muito triste com a vida desse povo.
I felt sorry for the woman giving the museum tour. She looked sad and scared. Knowing it felt like lies but knowing also she had to do what she'd been told. I pray for these people
yeah every thing you learn from school is truth
Similar to Karine Jean-Pierre at the White House press breifings.
pray for they is useless
@@donyao5950 where did that even come from. Your reply to the comment looks like you are just in your head and assume we understand what you are saying. Delusional
Your prayers do NOTHING
The two things that made me shake my head: the lady directing imaginary traffic and the fact that people actually got on that scary plane to go to the north
They have squads to move the puddles off the roads because they're roads weren't engineered to drain the water on their own like they are in developed countries
Other than the woman seeing her father's homeland & her friend accompanying her...you mean the equally scary _people_ who got on that plane to go north?
@@TheAnnoyingBoss If they have poor people "cleaning stones" who have to be moved from camera view, then road-water-movers are certainly believable.
Imagine how _poverty stricken_ a country would have to be to have the man-power to clean stones & remove water puddles. Positively prehistoric.
I don't know, it was a lot more sickening that kids are taken away from their parents to be brainwashed.
was that turbine or old propelled
Documentário verdadeiro e excelente
Parece que até a natureza manifesta tristeza profunda, imagens deprimente
My anxiety was off of the scale watching this documentary. All of the money in the world couldn't convince me to visit that country. It's heartbreaking and terrifying.
It's heartbroken and terrifying to watch the American streets filled with junkies and the world's richest. In North Korea there is no such thing. That's one of the differences that western media doesn't show.
You are right, no amount of money will be enough if one is killed for anything. I’m with you, I don’t want to visit a country where people are treated inhumanly.
@@pauloreis8958Yes these people are free to do what they want with their bodies and many could get out if they really want to. So I don’t see any similarities.
@@julianrandall3550 I do not live there, but I respect the sovereignty, customs and governments of other countries.
@@pauloreis8958 at least in America, we have the right to choose. In North Korea you’ll be a poor soldier
I have been doing research on North Korea for some time now. No internet, hospitals without proper machines to treat people. No medicine, the government controls every aspect of life. Hunger is at it's worst. Unbelievable.
Cuba has some of the same problems because the United States has a tight economic blockade suffocating the nation's economy.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq
Ricardo,I understand about Cuba 🇨🇺 and the suffering of the people of Cuba. My parents are from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷. I am Latino/Hispanic. But what I don't understand is why these dictators after so many years don't stabilize their relationships with America so they can lift all these sanctions and their people could improve their lives and ways of living.
@@oswaldoreyes9066 simple, they are still in war, their country is still splitted into 2, NK hasnt defeated their enemy - the US - who still maintain supports and appearance in the south, not until 50-100 years later we could see some great change to the situation
@@oswaldoreyes9066 but why should anyone answer to the US. They aren't the global police. These blockades are unjust and only hurt citizens.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Many countries sanctioned still does not have the same problems Cuba have. Could somebody Cuba’s problem be their dictatorship fault? Yes it can.
Pior que tem muitos que defendem isso ai.
"Quanto mias miseravel melhor"
Muito triste!!!
The amount of sarcasm in this documentary is amazing, and the delivery of these sarcastic lines from the commentator is… is top-tier👌🏾👌🏾👌🏾
Love British humor too
@@rogerh2694 It's french lol
@@emzee1148 The commentator speaks British English, no? If not there, somewhere else in Europe etc
@@emzee1148 The Narrator is definitely english
If NoKor doesn't have nuke then Kim would have long been assassinated by US.
What a nightmare, my heart goes out to their people. I hope they can see freedom in the future.
Yes it really is that place is said to be blacked out at night, people use their own $@# for fertilizer and well there's plenty of nightmare things that you have to look up that would end badly or get you thrown in prison there I'm sure seeing this in North Korea is illegal there and also RUclips is banned there along with other things that well Goggle it.
You'll be "hoping" a long long long time.....
AIR DROP MILLIONS OF GUNS, AMMO, EXPLOSIVES...
@@AECRADIO1
........or, catapult syphilitic roadkill Sushi into the starving masses, K.Y.Un will have to contend with millions of clamoring sychophants pressing their noseless faces against his windows begging for ointment.....
@@AECRADIO1 That is something though then again North Korea isn't Ukraine though.
As Italian I'm horrified by North Korean Pizza! 😅
I'm not even Italian, but I was also a little surprised(Not to say perplexed )
podiam recomendar esse documentário pro Castanhari
While I understand there is some desire to ask 'politically charged' questions, there's little point in harassing the tour guide. She's just doing her job, and it's not fair to harass her over something she has NO control over and probably has no awareness of anything that she hasn't been brainwashed into believing.
fr
Now that’s the thing westerners should know about people living in dictatorships and authoritarian regimes. We aren’t the same. We can’t do some things you are allowed to
You sound like a communist
We know the camera guy never gets killed, but this whole smart-Alec production crew would have tested the patience of Western countries, too. These tourists are guests and should behave accordingly, as in, show a little respect.
@tohru2910 idk, as an American I was cringing the whole time and begging to my screen for them to stop lol and making all their criticisms aloud for everyone to hear and pushing at every chance to go anywhere they wanted to go made me scared for their lives
It’s like the Truman show
It truly seems like that after seeing that woman direct non-existent vehicles
Seems to me that the country is one gigantic prison camp!!
Yes
The tour guide was a hot.
Undeniable Beauty(People... especially Asian women have their charm).
They took a crazy risk getting that footage out. The man that was like "if you go there i'm dead" legit shocked me.
One of the best NK documentary i've seen.
13:47
"She was spoiling the scenery by being poor."
That was both extremely amusing to hear and extremely depressing as well...
how tf is that funny in any way
Where do you live???
@@justahyundaiIt's dark humor.
Its like Undertale humor, but dark humor version
@@justahyundai It's funny because it's stupid.
O pior é que existe pessoas que falam bem e exaltam isso…
Tipo a esquerda brasileira 😊
Que horor gente! Jamais conseguiria suportar isso!
As harsh as this is it's really interesting how one man can hold so much power over a whole nation. It's like jail but for a whole country.
It makes me wonder if that is where we are headed in this country.
@@fourbirdstos If you mean America, I don't it. I don't think it will be that bad. But it is going to get bad.
And they are probably more compliant and there's no crime that they are committing crimes. They have to be perfect but yes it's definitely like a jail in a way.
@@Eren-nn7cm There's no crime because it's already a jail.
@ACEKING It's going to be a liberal socialist country just like the rest of the world. The royal family will rule the political world and the Rothschild family will rule the economy. That's the New World Order.
Sadly, for the citzents of North Korea: they are suffering. Thank you for the upload very educational.