@azuren I was a little aggressive with my downgrade of the laptop GPU...a 4080 laptop is comparable to a 3090 desktop...about a generation behind, not 1.5 generations.
I got the 18" I believe the positives have been covered. I will share the negatives I have: 1. The laptop fans are extremely noisy. 2. The laptop is heavy. I cannot hold it with one hand no matter what 3. The keyboard keys are small and uncomfortable. If you are planning on using this laptop for anything else than gaming, this is not the right keyboard. 4. The power cable is short. The power plug is not straight, it bends. It sits right next to the LAN cable and can interfere with it. Why would I want to bend any of the cables?? 5. The laptop gets extremely hot. You cannot use it on your lap. It has to be on a table/desk. You cannot use it on your bed unless you have a stand for the laptop. It needs to breathe and when it breathes it is lava... Would I buy it if I knew these details? No. This laptop is not for me.
Bought both of these for €1600 each, mine was a year old then & the one I bought for my brother is brand new. Prices for the new 2023 are way trough the roof, but it was similar for these two when they got released out. Either buy a generation older or buy a used one with extended warranty (mine has 5y). Mine: Asus RoG Strix G17 G713QR-HX023T CPU: R7-5800H GPU: RTX3070 RAM: 16GB-DDR4-3200 SSD: 2TB Brother: ASUS RoG Strix G17 G713RW-KH129W CPU: R7-6800H GPU: RTX3070Ti RAM: 16GB-DDR5-4800 SSD: 1TB
Thank you for the video, I see a lot of reviews for the scar 18, but none for the 16. Would you mind a follow up comparing both in terms of thermals and performance? Both laptops have the same internals, but the 18 has more surface to dissipate the heat, I wonder how much variation there is between the two models. Thank you again for posting this video.
Incase you were wondering, the 16 and 18 have the exact same thermal capabilities. Despite 18 being bigger, it hadzero advantages except more screen real-estate. The 16 is more expensive than the 18 because it costs more to make a product smaller, but the mini led screen is superior. So unless you want it to be in the cheapest possible configuration or like the extra screen real-estate and willing to spend a few hundred dollars more, the 16 is better
@@AgastyaXV actually, the 16 is less expensive, $3699 vs $3899 for the 18, but that’s not much of an issue, I’m definitely leaning more towards the 16 because of it being just a bit more portable, and was just wondering if the smaller cooler surface area would make any difference in the cooling performance. Unfortunately so far, no one seems to have posted any online reviews for the Scar 16.
@@Warlock15th dave 2d has uploaded a video. Gizmo tech has also done benchmarks, the 16 runs a bit hotter, but the TDP is exactly the same, same performance on both. The 16 might be a bit louder too But considering mini led display, and portability, you should just go for the 16. Don't bother going with the scar edition, as the only thing that's added is rear and deck RGB, that's it. The 16 inch gets numpad on the trackpad but again that probably wouldn't matter to you
I have the 2024 Strix Scar 16 and it is fantastic! I travel a lot for work so a tower just doesn’t make sense for me. All my mates have really impressed self built pc’s and I was always struggling to play games with them. I had a medion erazer with a 1050 and i5 so the difference now is absolutely insane!
I have same laptop 32.0 GB ram edition. Tested ton of games, only had problems with Star Citizen which is poorly optimized, on max setting 4k resolution it could run only on 50+ fps... Rest games runs minimum on 120+ fps. I only have 2 problems, but I think it is most of from software. Sometimes it makes static noises on battery and GPU switching system is not really good. At the end it is superb laptop, the sound is awesome, it even have bases, screen is nice. Build quality is very nice. I think it is best option for people who travel a lot.
Yeah the Asus is definitely the one I want, I'm hoping in 3 weeks when I have the funds to purchase one they will be available again. People are saying that they're too much money but they're getting bought up pretty quick
@@GeekTherapyRadio facts, the launch of the rtx 4080/4090 were the same as the rtx 1080/1080 ti. They're is no competition and it will be impossible to get a better laptop then one based off the desktop rtx 4080 for at least 2 years and 4 years for more then a 50% boost in performance.
Great review! I almost pulled the trigger on one of these until I started reading many people are experiencing black screens. Has anyone else had any of these issues and has Asus addressed this issue?
The screens turns black when unplugging the laptop from the power brick? Because if that's the case I'm pretty sure it's completely normal, it's just the screen changing the refresh rate to make the battery life better, I own a scar 16 and I haven't had any sort of problems with it so far
@@ME-dr3mr Thanks for the reply. I’m glad you’re not having any issues. I’m going to take a look at the Strix again. Maybe find some good Black Friday deals.
Hey I got a question I am thinking about buying a laptop. Right now my top 2 are: asus rog 18 highest specs 4tb, 64gb ram for 4700€ or Msi gt77hx 2tb, 32gb ram for 4700€. Which is better in your opinion? Also can I reach the max stats if I uograde the msi with kingston 64gb ram set or should I just wait and buy the more expensive version? If you know anything that would help me decide I would really appreciate it. Watched nearly every video from you and other youtubers but still cannot really decide.
THX a ton for this beautiful video. Did U present SCAR 16 with miniLED? Or your SCAR was just regular display? MiniLED is my reason to wait for SCAR 16. Could you please test that miniLED display compared to SCAR 18 without miniLED? THX
The problem with laptops like these is that almost always the GPU/CPU are undervolted massively or downclocked and not delivering the full performance that the desktop variants offer.
@@possiblyunmatched1323 understandble, but most people are expecting the full-size performance a 3090 has for example. If I buy a 3090 for that price I want the full power of that GPU instead of a laptop customized one. Same with the I9 in this laptop it’s customized specifically for laptops while the full-size desktop version is simply more powerful. Don’t forget that you pay quite a lot of money. Most people see 4090 in the specifications and are thinking getting the exact same performance from a 4090 while the laptop version is like 20/25% worse.
@ItsMeMars if those people expect desktop-quality CPUs and GPUs on a thin portable machine, then they're in for a rude awakening or maybe they should've done more research. I understand Nvidia doesn't have the M marker on their laptop GPU but in this day and age, people should know what to expect beforehand.
Hello which one is the best for solo gaming ( games like cyberpunk dead Space alan wake 2 etc .. ) : this one or the asus scar 17 with ryzen 7945 rtx 4090 and ips ? Thanks
Its really a STRIX and it STRIKES in performance 😊🤠that i would wanna own but due to price 😢🥺i just have to see it in reviews😌 but WE LOVE YOU and your reviews💚💚🤩😊👍
I wish they'd come out with a 20" one. The extra size would provide more space for cooling too. 18inches is alright, but we already have 17.3 inch options. So, 18 inches isn't really all that significant of a duff compared to the 17inche models. I mean, I LOVE beast & beefy laptops. They represent raw power & dominance Lol,... but I just really just the bigger screen.... if you're willing to do 18inces, then you might as well just go all out & shoot for that big two'O right? ? Might as well. It's an extra 1.6 inches. I LOVE the Scar 18,... that cthir efforts were half arsed for that low increase. That 4090 mixed with that 24 core 13980 CPU combo is pretty damn insane though Lol
Does the SCAR 16 have bad bloom? I saw someone on reddit say it was pretty bad, posted a pic and yeah its pretty bad. I am wondering if this is a per-display issue, or an all around issue. Thanks!
Can you get your hands on the new Lenovo legion Pro 7i RTX 4080 core i9 13900hx and hopefully later the RTX 4090 as well? Will be nice if we can also see how the lower tier Lenovo legion pro 5i is. The materials, performance, design in the former flagship appears a let down for most people, but Hardware and upgraded Vantage and other softwares look like they will perform
Why can't you buy this laptop anywhere I can't find it on any site no one is selling it if you can send a link to the sale and not to the site where it can be seen
Get a normal Strix G18 ie a non scar version: everything is same except the RGB bar n logo at back. I got it for 2200 USD for i913980hx and a rtx 4080.
For those of you who are wondering and haven't done the research...the 4090 speeds comparable to the 4080 speeds are nowhere ahead enough to justify the 4090 tax price. Please save your wallet and go 4080
I never thought I’d see the time when laptops had desktop level performance. But one thing remains the same, my empty wallet 😂
😵💫😜😅🤣😂 likewise
A laptop 4080 is much more comparable to a 3070 desktop...at best. Laptops are always 1.5 gens behind desktops.
@@j0hnny483 lol no, 4080laptop is to 4070 desktop, it may have less Gpu ram but is still a 4000 series, way better than a 3000 series
@@intrepidomartv236 incorrect.
@azuren I was a little aggressive with my downgrade of the laptop GPU...a 4080 laptop is comparable to a 3090 desktop...about a generation behind, not 1.5 generations.
You can tell these laptops are epic
Asus are always the best at making very good speced laptop
These are literally the most powerful and best gaming laptops. Nothing compares to the technology
Yeah, I was going to buy the 16 inch mini led with 4090.. but they are not selling them in the UK... checked with all suppliers
That's weird. They do sell them in the Netherlands. It's on the Asus website.
I got the 18"
I believe the positives have been covered. I will share the negatives I have:
1. The laptop fans are extremely noisy.
2. The laptop is heavy. I cannot hold it with one hand no matter what
3. The keyboard keys are small and uncomfortable. If you are planning on using this laptop for anything else than gaming, this is not the right keyboard.
4. The power cable is short. The power plug is not straight, it bends. It sits right next to the LAN cable and can interfere with it. Why would I want to bend any of the cables??
5. The laptop gets extremely hot. You cannot use it on your lap. It has to be on a table/desk. You cannot use it on your bed unless you have a stand for the laptop. It needs to breathe and when it breathes it is lava...
Would I buy it if I knew these details? No. This laptop is not for me.
Is it portable for day-to-day life? Can I carry it to my university every day?
@@rubayetalam8759 no! I cannot hold it with 1 hand. I have to use 2 hands to move it between rooms. Keep in mind that I have the 18"
Its less of a laptop but a portable desktop replacement, students like me who have to move around who also like to game wont have these problems
lol, it'sn't hot
@@tfuu5144 boiling then?
Wonderful video, you were able to cover key features in a short period of time. Beautiful lighting quality on your video as well. Enjoyed it.
Glad you enjoyed it! 😊
Can’t wait to order the 16
Bought both of these for €1600 each, mine was a year old then & the one I bought for my brother is brand new. Prices for the new 2023 are way trough the roof, but it was similar for these two when they got released out. Either buy a generation older or buy a used one with extended warranty (mine has 5y).
Mine:
Asus RoG Strix G17
G713QR-HX023T
CPU: R7-5800H
GPU: RTX3070
RAM: 16GB-DDR4-3200
SSD: 2TB
Brother:
ASUS RoG Strix G17
G713RW-KH129W
CPU: R7-6800H
GPU: RTX3070Ti
RAM: 16GB-DDR5-4800
SSD: 1TB
6800H battery king more than twice battery life than intel model. Some 3070 laptop have 10 hour on 6800h.
My intel 11800h last only 1.5 gour straight out of the box. When both CPU and GPU running got 40min .
but he's showing with rtx 4090, which is aroung 3.5k usd....in 2023
Thank you for the video, I see a lot of reviews for the scar 18, but none for the 16.
Would you mind a follow up comparing both in terms of thermals and performance?
Both laptops have the same internals, but the 18 has more surface to dissipate the heat, I wonder how much variation there is between the two models.
Thank you again for posting this video.
Incase you were wondering, the 16 and 18 have the exact same thermal capabilities. Despite 18 being bigger, it hadzero advantages except more screen real-estate. The 16 is more expensive than the 18 because it costs more to make a product smaller, but the mini led screen is superior. So unless you want it to be in the cheapest possible configuration or like the extra screen real-estate and willing to spend a few hundred dollars more, the 16 is better
@@AgastyaXV actually, the 16 is less expensive, $3699 vs $3899 for the 18, but that’s not much of an issue, I’m definitely leaning more towards the 16 because of it being just a bit more portable, and was just wondering if the smaller cooler surface area would make any difference in the cooling performance. Unfortunately so far, no one seems to have posted any online reviews for the Scar 16.
@@Warlock15th dave 2d has uploaded a video. Gizmo tech has also done benchmarks, the 16 runs a bit hotter, but the TDP is exactly the same, same performance on both. The 16 might be a bit louder too
But considering mini led display, and portability, you should just go for the 16. Don't bother going with the scar edition, as the only thing that's added is rear and deck RGB, that's it. The 16 inch gets numpad on the trackpad but again that probably wouldn't matter to you
@@AgastyaXV only scar versions are 4090 and 4080 en in some cases, so there is a real diference
16 inch laptop run hotter due to less thermal headroom and will perform slightly slower around 5%.
Are these the RTX 4090 16gb Vram?
They also have the scar 17 as well. Wonder if the 16 is already big enough for portability?
Disassembly would be nice!!!
I have the 2024 Strix Scar 16 and it is fantastic! I travel a lot for work so a tower just doesn’t make sense for me. All my mates have really impressed self built pc’s and I was always struggling to play games with them. I had a medion erazer with a 1050 and i5 so the difference now is absolutely insane!
The sunglasses compliment the ROG logo alright 😎
Hey Saf, quick question:
1. Any Coil Whine while Gaming and also when doing normal stuff like RUclips, Browsing etc?
2. How is the screen bleeding?
One of the best gaming laptops
I wish I could buy one of these but I need to work at least 15 years in Afghanistan to be able buy one 😞
I have same laptop 32.0 GB ram edition. Tested ton of games, only had problems with Star Citizen which is poorly optimized, on max setting 4k resolution it could run only on 50+ fps... Rest games runs minimum on 120+ fps. I only have 2 problems, but I think it is most of from software. Sometimes it makes static noises on battery and GPU switching system is not really good. At the end it is superb laptop, the sound is awesome, it even have bases, screen is nice. Build quality is very nice. I think it is best option for people who travel a lot.
Thank you, so both are the same, the only difference is the size of the screen right?
If you can find them for sale, that is. They are out of stock everywhere. (Comment written 2/14/2023)
Yeah the Asus is definitely the one I want, I'm hoping in 3 weeks when I have the funds to purchase one they will be available again. People are saying that they're too much money but they're getting bought up pretty quick
@Gman 749 $2500 is a lot of money...but good value for the hardware against the competition. This laptop will be my workhorse for 2-3 years minimum.
@@GeekTherapyRadio facts, the launch of the rtx 4080/4090 were the same as the rtx 1080/1080 ti.
They're is no competition and it will be impossible to get a better laptop then one based off the desktop rtx 4080 for at least 2 years and 4 years for more then a 50% boost in performance.
This channel is on fire
Amazing Laptops 😍
does 2 inch matter in display size?
That mean that everything is same just the inches and the luminosity is better for the 16?
Does it come with classic non translucent body ?
I got the 14gen 49series 18inch screen, that screen is ridiculously nice and big dont need a extra monitor and hell divers 2 look amazing with this.
Great review! I almost pulled the trigger on one of these until I started reading many people are experiencing black screens. Has anyone else had any of these issues and has Asus addressed this issue?
The screens turns black when unplugging the laptop from the power brick? Because if that's the case I'm pretty sure it's completely normal, it's just the screen changing the refresh rate to make the battery life better, I own a scar 16 and I haven't had any sort of problems with it so far
@@ME-dr3mr Thanks for the reply. I’m glad you’re not having any issues. I’m going to take a look at the Strix again. Maybe find some good Black Friday deals.
Are there a big difference between the Mini LED and the IPS in these models?
Mini led is almost basically oled without the problems of an oled panel
@@tareqislam1434 Can you notice if a panel is Mini LED only seeing? I can not choose between the Scar 16 and the MSI GE78 by the displays.
I a confused about the "you can buy" part as these are completely sold out and I cannot buy any of them so far..
Hey I got a question I am thinking about buying a laptop. Right now my top 2 are: asus rog 18 highest specs 4tb, 64gb ram for 4700€ or Msi gt77hx 2tb, 32gb ram for 4700€. Which is better in your opinion? Also can I reach the max stats if I uograde the msi with kingston 64gb ram set or should I just wait and buy the more expensive version? If you know anything that would help me decide I would really appreciate it. Watched nearly every video from you and other youtubers but still cannot really decide.
This or the strix 16 or legion pro 7i 8 gen?
Can’t Decide!
G16 is worse than scar 16 and I hear legion was a let down
THX a ton for this beautiful video. Did U present SCAR 16 with miniLED? Or your SCAR was just regular display? MiniLED is my reason to wait for SCAR 16. Could you please test that miniLED display compared to SCAR 18 without miniLED? THX
Yes
So I have a question, does the g18 come with mini led as well or only g16 has mini led?
Please compare with MacBook Pro with M2 Max
Does the 16 have mini led and 4090 options?
Yes. The exactly model is: ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 16 G634JY-NM014W
This is nice I'd like to have one of these since they have 4090 RTX GPUs not to mention the capabilities of passively mining crypto :)
The problem with laptops like these is that almost always the GPU/CPU are undervolted massively or downclocked and not delivering the full performance that the desktop variants offer.
it does not matter much. desktop gpus are insanely fast that even if you can get 75% of that speed in a laptop form, it will still be blistering fast.
@@possiblyunmatched1323 Epic 🫠
@@possiblyunmatched1323 understandble, but most people are expecting the full-size performance a 3090 has for example. If I buy a 3090 for that price I want the full power of that GPU instead of a laptop customized one. Same with the I9 in this laptop it’s customized specifically for laptops while the full-size desktop version is simply more powerful. Don’t forget that you pay quite a lot of money. Most people see 4090 in the specifications and are thinking getting the exact same performance from a 4090 while the laptop version is like 20/25% worse.
That’s litterly why it’s called a laptop. How the fuck are you supposed to cool down a full power 4090? Even the desktop version has issues smh
@ItsMeMars if those people expect desktop-quality CPUs and GPUs on a thin portable machine, then they're in for a rude awakening or maybe they should've done more research. I understand Nvidia doesn't have the M marker on their laptop GPU but in this day and age, people should know what to expect beforehand.
I'd love to buy one, but I can't seem to find it in stock anywhere.
You didnt show games how they run on these machines? Just wondering...
When will these be able for purchase? I don't see any available at main retailers, only ebay etc..
From where i can buy this? Prices not mention at website
Can the red light of the power button be deactivated?
Unfortunately no, neither can the 3 lights under the screen
i really like rog but i dont have money to buy.i will support your youtube channel for new content
Hello which one is the best for solo gaming ( games like cyberpunk dead Space alan wake 2 etc .. ) : this one or the asus scar 17 with ryzen 7945 rtx 4090 and ips ? Thanks
What about battery life ? Watching movies for example
Its really a STRIX and it STRIKES in performance 😊🤠that i would wanna own but due to price 😢🥺i just have to see it in reviews😌 but WE LOVE YOU and your reviews💚💚🤩😊👍
just got the 16 inch, 240 hz qhd+, rtx 4090 ...top!
What did it cost ?
When asus rog g16/18 rtx 4050 lap will release 🥹💕
Really want the scar 16,but I absolutely cannot find it anywhere on the market right now...
It was up for pre-order on Newegg last week. Might want to keep checking to see if it comes back in stock.
What is the model of the 18" screen that Asus is using in this laptop?
I wish they'd come out with a 20" one. The extra size would provide more space for cooling too.
18inches is alright, but we already have 17.3 inch options. So, 18 inches isn't really all that significant of a duff compared to the 17inche models.
I mean, I LOVE beast & beefy laptops. They represent raw power & dominance Lol,... but I just really just the bigger screen.... if you're willing to do 18inces, then you might as well just go all out & shoot for that big two'O right? ? Might as well. It's an extra 1.6 inches.
I LOVE the Scar 18,... that cthir efforts were half arsed for that low increase.
That 4090 mixed with that 24 core 13980 CPU combo is pretty damn insane though Lol
True,
Thank You for the video Sr it helped me out sense your the only one with both particular model sizes
How many nits of brightness in G16? Plz tell me
Does the SCAR 16 have bad bloom? I saw someone on reddit say it was pretty bad, posted a pic and yeah its pretty bad. I am wondering if this is a per-display issue, or an all around issue. Thanks!
Can you get your hands on the new Lenovo legion Pro 7i RTX 4080 core i9 13900hx and hopefully later the RTX 4090 as well? Will be nice if we can also see how the lower tier Lenovo legion pro 5i is. The materials, performance, design in the former flagship appears a let down for most people, but Hardware and upgraded Vantage and other softwares look like they will perform
Is the volume louder?
Very fun content❤️, may your RUclips progress😊
you are an legendary unboxer
The fastest comment that you can see ⚡
Why can't you buy this laptop anywhere I can't find it on any site no one is selling it if you can send a link to the sale and not to the site where it can be seen
If someone could explain to me, the miniled screen is also Ips? Or they're totally different?
Show 5g capability gaming 17 inch laptops I just mow purchased Samsung galaxy book 3 Pro 360 5g it's not powerful enough
I got the Scar 18, but how do I fix the contrast being awful
Wait.......when did you start reviewing laptops?
Can i bring legion 7i 12800HX 3070TI
Does the scar or strix G18 get black bars on both sides of the screen while playing games as the aspect ratio is 16:10..
I am afraid of Liquid Metal Is there any risk of Liquid Metal leakage?
No
For that price I
Might as well get a desktop
Get a normal Strix G18 ie a non scar version: everything is same except the RGB bar n logo at back. I got it for 2200 USD for i913980hx and a rtx 4080.
Wish you compared gaming on on both :)
Please do more laptop reviews
Will do!
🙌
the per key RGB on the keyboard doesnt look as nice as the razer blade
For those of you who are wondering and haven't done the research...the 4090 speeds comparable to the 4080 speeds are nowhere ahead enough to justify the 4090 tax price. Please save your wallet and go 4080
I want mini led on the 18” 😡
Can this be used for video editing like premiere pro and After effects?
Yes, absolutely. Mainly my use as I don't have time to game much 🥲
@@SuperSaf Do you think it`s worth spending that extra money for the 18 with the RTX 4090 or not much of a difference with the 16 RTX 4080?
@@d.o.m.e.n.i.c.o_d.e.n.t.i.c.e Depends on what you gonna use this for. Only consider 4090 if you're into heavy 3d stuff.
Are they have oled screen?
No display ports?
S23 vs iphone 14 comparison video pls pls
Transparent edges and vents looks soooo cheap
Rog is always a beast and beauty.
so it is an 8 bi disply, not 10 biT?
Please make 3 or 4 USB 3.2 and RTX 4090 or 5000. Ram 64gb 3 slot SSD. 2 SSD Picie 4x4 & 1 SSD Picie 5.
when will we get a review on OnePlus 11?? you are very late
G16 is the g614ji model?
Review the galaxy book 3 ultra
Let's see how many motherboard failures on this one.... I'm on 3 now for the 2022 version...
You can turn your light down if they are too bright. That way you don't have to wear those ridiculous shades lol.
I just don't know how I feel about that cheapy looking plastics they use round the sides of the machine. I mean what were they thinking
Exynos 2200 > RogStrix any CPU/GPU
Lol
Blue meth > Rationality/reason
Reminds me how poor I am😂
nope...this one is slower than the next year version.
Wait until you hear about the next year after next year version
Translucent, not transparent :D !
Whats the Bgm sauce?
I'll give you a like and a sub if you tell me
ur the best
Send me laptop scar 18 ...
Or you could spend the same money on a macbook with half the specs that only gets used to read text in cafés
Does supersaf answer
Sometimes
@@SuperSaf 😆
India
Doesnt matter what i am still buying Macbook pro for office, in 2023 laptops are not an options now (windows)
Asus aren't even marketing these as office laptops 🤦
Mac sucks compared to windows