@@s.m.d7212 yeah i really like that about aot thats just like reality no matter how much good you say no matter how much pain you endure you'll still be a monster in someone eyes
@@liiran664 He had to send Titan to his mother so that Eren could be motivated to become strong. Which in the end can protect Paradise and its friends
The scene where the Edit goes from Young eren being Horrified at his older self instead of the Colossal is absolutely Bone-Chilling absolute masterpiece of an edit my man
I feel like Eren was flashing back to all those memories in the normal scene,we just didn't see it in the original,he was looking back on his past,realizing that he was broken from the start,that there was always just something messed up about his existence,something in his brain that was always there and in that moment he finally embraced it,becoming the devil the world wanted him to be
Honestly, could you imagine how much more impactful it would have been had THIS been the real scene instead of just a fan edit? With all the people screaming “fuck eren” going into the last half of season 4, it would’ve served as a much needed reminder of just how much pain and pushing it took to bring things to this point. Eren’s character is such a tragedy not only because he bears the pains of the horrors witnessed in his own life on his shoulders, but he’s also witnessed the horrors of marleyan eldians through his fathers memories. Eren is just a kid still, aged about 18 or 19 and he’s witnessed countless people brutalized and devoured by titans including his own mother, caused the death of his father, and watched as a bystander as his aunt was ripped apart by dogs and his father was tortured on Marley and his friends were all turned into titans. All of this happened BEFORE feeling he had no other option but to become the monsters Bertolt and Reiner were to his people, yet they are good guys now? Now don’t get me wrong, the warriors’ stories are tragedies as well, no doubt. Life as second class citizens raised for the military and, if chosen, forced to take on short lives to make the ultimate sacrifice for the safety of their nation, but all of that doesn’t even compare to the hell Eren marched through to get here. Thank you so much for making this edit. Incredible job! So much told in just two minutes.
because it wasn't revenge . he understood it more than anyone. the scene was to show how unpredictible and cruel eren has become for his which is no longer taking revenge but breaking free from chains, to show that eren is no longer naive but a ruthless war veteran who can do anything to achieve his goals. that was the original ost, a sudden unexpected start and a sudden end. this is a great edit and if they were to add it to blueray for a rewatch it would be perfect but not for the first time.
Sorry, but the new ost fit better because like someone below said, he wasn't doing it for revenge but for the big picture. And it's very hypocritical to take this view on Eren and still hate on the warriors. Everyone is a victim.
@@adinonymous640 in this case it isn't clear because he already knows the future but he said it himself, even if he didn't know the future he would've still done the rumbling
I’d like to think that since titan shifters can share memories like Reiner did with porco before he died, that in this moment eren gave Reiner a summary of what he had lost because of his actions
Love when Eren is going through his memories, with all the bad that happened and he has remembered, right before he turns into his titan form his last memories are of armin and mikasa cause he’s doing it for them and the people of paradise
I don't have any words to express my feelings . You, my friend have a talent . Please make more edits like these . All things are temporary only GOD EREN YEAGER IS ETERNAL .
Most of people think that Eren has completely changed by season 4, but the reality is that he hasn't changed at all, he's still "ippiki nokorazu, kuchiku shteyaru" as he was at the very beginning.
Wow, not bad. Especially the scene with little Eren at 1:30 was very well put. The same facial expression, Bertholdt in his Titan inflicted into Eren and his friend when he broke Wall Maria, he himself is inflicting into all of those people watching him in his own Titan form. If Mappa did this scene exactly this way, it wouldn't have been any less epic than we have it now. Maybe even more epic.
this is by far my favorite alternative for this scene, even better than the fan animation!! the memories are such an important factor and they really should've added it in the anime, also i never realized before how good this theme fits the scene!
I like the idea of this song being in this scene. It's also nice because the first scenes we get of season 4 are in Marley, with Marley characters and Marley OSTs. It would have been nice if this scene had Vogel im Käfig, because then its like reminding us where the real problem lies. The problem of Paradis, and how these Marleyans caused all of what we have seen in season 1-3. It would have been a nice introduction back into the characters, where you see Eren finally get "pre-revenge" for his mother's death when he declares war on Marley. And then the song opens into the Scouts coming to rescue him. It would have been such a good addition.
it was not until later that I realised...Erenn's dad was not crying because he was scared or worried about his son...he was crying because he was creating a monster.
Yesss I'm watching AoT too & can only wonder how much grief & fear Grisha is feeling the whole time he's talking to young Eren, hopeless & trapped to committing atrocious deeds by that very child :(
Honestly, they should have played this soundtrack instead, this would have fitted so much more better after everything Eren's been trough. The OST that played when his mother was killed on the very first episode by Marleyans attack, now he comes back for revenge... "On that day, humanity received a grim reminder.."
honestly, this edit is goddamn amazing. it really is. but you can't say this should've made it to the final cut. because everyone who read the manga to the end knows that all this is not what eren is about anymore. he doesn't act out of revenge for his mother, even if it would've made sense. at this point, eren has fully become the attack titan, pursuing its sole main objective. which is essentially freeing ymir off its curse. and as he has seen all possible futures and outcomes (dr strange like) so he has to push through this one timeline where everything works out so it won't just reset at one certain point, and then the carousel starts again... he has seen it all and his sole purpose in life, ever since he kissed historia's hand, is to break the carousel, the eternal loop of time, and to free the subjects of ymir from their miserable cursed fate.
YES YES 1000% YES. How the conflict between Eldia and the rest of the world was depicted is my only criticism of the show. What they needed to do was mirror the sequences and world building of Eren, Mikasa and Armin in the eyes of Gabi and her life. Then, reenact the Attack Titan and Colossol Titan's appearance as an exact mirror to the season 1 appearance of the Colossol Titan and the Armored Titan. This would have shown the horrors of "just wars" to the eyes of children who are born into this world. What a beautiful edit. Made me tear up. This is how I choose to remember the show.
I can also see how Armin contrasting Bertolt (both shy guys possessing the Colossial Titan) and Eren contrasting Reiner ironically (Which both shows the Armoured and Attack Titan aggressively charging and attacking the enemy territory). Makes perfect sense.
the first time you see this scene it feels like erens trying to make a truce then it feels scary due to how he just destroyed a building then ate a guy then after the rumbling you realise its eren apoligizing for the things he will do the song fits all 3 reasons perfectly
at the end of the day the marleyans were still preparing an invasion of paradis. they still declared war first. they were still going to try to genocide the eldians again no matter what eren did . a vast majority of the world hate and oppress the eldians for crimes that may or may not have been committed 1000 years ago they're the ones bringing that hatred into the modern day and the ones actively trying to kill the other side. the rumbling is not only necessary but just.
Glad to see I'm not the only one who has this theme running through my mind the entire time while reading this in manga. Tbh was quite disappointed it wasn't the case when Anime came out but now my disappointment is abated with your edit 😭 thank you!!
1:26 This flashback scene between the same vision of fear that the Eldians had in the first season, transmitted to the Marleyans in the second is really crazy
This scene perfectly shows that Eren was not the one who started this war. He patiently waited for Tybur (or whatever his name was) to finish his declaration. Many people say that they didn't like how Eren changed and stopped supporting him. They saw all the sad stories about different characters and felt pity for them. Well, that's to be expected, it's obvious that every single person have someone or sth they love but that doesn't change the fact that war is war and it won't stop until either side is wiped out. The hatred and fear towards Eldians was deeply rooted in people hearts and it wouldn't dissapear no matter how much they would talk with each other. If Eren didn't do it, someone else would. It was meant to happen one day but Eren was the one to have balls big enough to do it despite the fact how much he wanted to just stay with his friends till his last days. Since 1st episode I was rooting for Eren and that didn't change until the end of the story. All of you who turned their backs on him are despicable.
The Attack titan will always seek freedom no matter which era he is in or what situation he has found himself in . For the sake of freedom he fights . And the attack titan is the only titan which even the founding titan can't control cuz of his will of freedom .
That’s not accurate, Ymir can control any Eldian under the sun. Does not matter if they are Ackerman or Attack Titans. The previous founders that didn’t have Ymir’s full power like Eren, they couldn’t influence Ackermans and the Attack Titan.
@@deletekeys ymir can control attack titan and all titan and even ackerman but attack titan's will of freedom is so strong that it can reject orders even from ymir
@@origin02 No it definitely cannot…they are all extensions of her and products of the Hallucigenia…definitely cannot overcome the will of the god that literally fabricated it into being.
I have many episodes which I would like to call best episodes, but of course there cannot be several best ones. So instead of rating them, I might say that different episodes deliver a different feeling, they're best in their own way. If each best episode would have its own word or two, like grief or sorrow, heroism etc, then this episode would have word: epic. Each single detail about this episode and especially this scene - is perfect. Soldiers preparing for... Something. They don't know what is coming, they just know something is about to go wrong. Eren talking about the past and Raynor feeling how the history is about to repeat itself. A huge scene with rulers of the world. And of course, a declaration of war from the world to one single country - which punishes them in return, immediately. The same second after declaration. And, of course, the music - everything fits just perfectly in this scene. And the episode in overall... Epic.
What's beautifully ironic about this entire series is the notion of self-fulfilling prophecy. If Paradis had been left alone, they never would've become the threat they were perceived as.
The attack titan was one who could resist the founding titans powers as its ability to look into the past present ad also future fuck with timelines. It has always been a titan that poses the royalfamily. it is yumirs titian of choice it came about after the eldians lost the titan war.
Imagine if this was the scene and they also added "on that day humanity received a grim reminder.." chillsss
That would be C. O. L. D. as Shit
"On that day, humanity received a grim reminder, and deserved it."
"The world was a pen. Humans? Cattle."
better yet, it could be armins voice over playing over the moment he looks around at the destruction he caused
EREN DID NOTHING WRONG
And despite all this memories and all that happened to him, Eren did NOT declare war, he only responded to it
Texas in a few months.
@@daviouscram2101 lol
And somehow they portray him as the monster?! He literally lost everything because of Marley massacring his people.
@@s.m.d7212 yeah i really like that about aot thats just like reality no matter how much good you say no matter how much pain you endure you'll still be a monster in someone eyes
@@s.m.d7212because he killed 80% of the world population?
This was sick, the memories really add to it
Thanks mate
Bro had all reasons to be a villain
Bro Made the reasons 😂
But he's not a villain. He's just living in this cruel world. If everyone in the world thinks that you are a monster, show them a real monster.
@@liiran664
He had to send Titan to his mother so that Eren could be motivated to become strong. Which in the end can protect Paradise and its friends
@@MsDenegjust like gold roger
@@MsDeneg Yeah not villain, just a little bit 80% population of world right?
The scene where the Edit goes from Young eren being Horrified at his older self instead of the Colossal is absolutely Bone-Chilling
absolute masterpiece of an edit my man
Thank you brother
Eren was right thou
I's perfec
Hits different when you've watched and followed it since 2013.
The flashbacks and the music made this scene x100 better. Goosebumps man.
I feel like Eren was flashing back to all those memories in the normal scene,we just didn't see it in the original,he was looking back on his past,realizing that he was broken from the start,that there was always just something messed up about his existence,something in his brain that was always there and in that moment he finally embraced it,becoming the devil the world wanted him to be
Bcz that's not actually the point of the attack lmao.
👍👏
Honestly, could you imagine how much more impactful it would have been had THIS been the real scene instead of just a fan edit? With all the people screaming “fuck eren” going into the last half of season 4, it would’ve served as a much needed reminder of just how much pain and pushing it took to bring things to this point. Eren’s character is such a tragedy not only because he bears the pains of the horrors witnessed in his own life on his shoulders, but he’s also witnessed the horrors of marleyan eldians through his fathers memories. Eren is just a kid still, aged about 18 or 19 and he’s witnessed countless people brutalized and devoured by titans including his own mother, caused the death of his father, and watched as a bystander as his aunt was ripped apart by dogs and his father was tortured on Marley and his friends were all turned into titans. All of this happened BEFORE feeling he had no other option but to become the monsters Bertolt and Reiner were to his people, yet they are good guys now? Now don’t get me wrong, the warriors’ stories are tragedies as well, no doubt. Life as second class citizens raised for the military and, if chosen, forced to take on short lives to make the ultimate sacrifice for the safety of their nation, but all of that doesn’t even compare to the hell Eren marched through to get here. Thank you so much for making this edit. Incredible job! So much told in just two minutes.
blah blah blah you loved the edit
because it wasn't revenge . he understood it more than anyone. the scene was to show how unpredictible and cruel eren has become for his which is no longer taking revenge but breaking free from chains, to show that eren is no longer naive but a ruthless war veteran who can do anything to achieve his goals. that was the original ost, a sudden unexpected start and a sudden end. this is a great edit and if they were to add it to blueray for a rewatch it would be perfect but not for the first time.
and his goals aren't affected by his past but the future he saw so adding previous cuts could be misleading
@@scarletwitch1204 mappa was more focused on making the mf Marleyns pure souls 😂😂😂
Sorry, but the new ost fit better because like someone below said, he wasn't doing it for revenge but for the big picture. And it's very hypocritical to take this view on Eren and still hate on the warriors. Everyone is a victim.
I think this is the best edit I've seen for this scene. Why didn't the MAPPA do this?
Because this paints the image that eren is acting with vengeance in mind, which is untrue.
@@adinonymous640 in this case it isn't clear because he already knows the future but he said it himself, even if he didn't know the future he would've still done the rumbling
you answered correctly, and also partly he takes revenge, but also just fights for the freedom of his friends.
@@adinonymous640 i think the images represents that he Is fighting for his friends and his own freedom rather than revenge
I feel like It would've been really obvious what erenw as gonna do if this one played
"This was Perfect... perfect ... everything down to the last minute details."
I'm 6 months late and I'm in class watching this and getting chills
GODDAMN THIS A MASTERPIECE
Damn this was 2 years ago 😢
I’d like to think that since titan shifters can share memories like Reiner did with porco before he died, that in this moment eren gave Reiner a summary of what he had lost because of his actions
Bruh, it was not Reiner who shared them, it was Marcel's, I'm sorry that you didn't understand that properly.
No matter how many times you see it this scene and Erwin's last charge hits soo hard
Love when Eren is going through his memories, with all the bad that happened and he has remembered, right before he turns into his titan form his last memories are of armin and mikasa cause he’s doing it for them and the people of paradise
erens first transformation: in the belly of the enemy
erens 2nd to last transformation: in the belly of the enemy
I don't have any words to express my feelings . You, my friend have a talent . Please make more edits like these . All things are temporary only GOD EREN YEAGER IS ETERNAL .
Yes light ❤️❤️🔥
found the jaegerist
@@Xboxlove1 you mean found a weeb, the people who watch anime 24/7
@@Rolexis99that’s just an addiction, weeb is a completely different thing.
YEAGERIST SPOTTED 🚨🚨
I have seen this scene in so many variations.....this was the only one to satisfy my thirst
For me, this beats the original three times at least. Thank you man, good job!!
This is how the scene should have been done
Crying with Goosebumps
Most of people think that Eren has completely changed by season 4, but the reality is that he hasn't changed at all, he's still "ippiki nokorazu, kuchiku shteyaru" as he was at the very beginning.
Wow, not bad. Especially the scene with little Eren at 1:30 was very well put. The same facial expression, Bertholdt in his Titan inflicted into Eren and his friend when he broke Wall Maria, he himself is inflicting into all of those people watching him in his own Titan form. If Mappa did this scene exactly this way, it wouldn't have been any less epic than we have it now. Maybe even more epic.
Watching this was an amazing experience
1:23 that was the roar we all wanted. IS EPIC
Eren's been a punching bag till this very moment
Now he fights back against those who have beat him up
this is by far my favorite alternative for this scene, even better than the fan animation!! the memories are such an important factor and they really should've added it in the anime, also i never realized before how good this theme fits the scene!
I like the idea of this song being in this scene. It's also nice because the first scenes we get of season 4 are in Marley, with Marley characters and Marley OSTs. It would have been nice if this scene had Vogel im Käfig, because then its like reminding us where the real problem lies. The problem of Paradis, and how these Marleyans caused all of what we have seen in season 1-3. It would have been a nice introduction back into the characters, where you see Eren finally get "pre-revenge" for his mother's death when he declares war on Marley. And then the song opens into the Scouts coming to rescue him. It would have been such a good addition.
it was not until later that I realised...Erenn's dad was not crying because he was scared or worried about his son...he was crying because he was creating a monster.
Yesss I'm watching AoT too & can only wonder how much grief & fear Grisha is feeling the whole time he's talking to young Eren, hopeless & trapped to committing atrocious deeds by that very child :(
Honestly, they should have played this soundtrack instead, this would have fitted so much more better after everything Eren's been trough. The OST that played when his mother was killed on the very first episode by Marleyans attack, now he comes back for revenge...
"On that day, humanity received a grim reminder.."
honestly, this edit is goddamn amazing. it really is. but you can't say this should've made it to the final cut. because everyone who read the manga to the end knows that all this is not what eren is about anymore. he doesn't act out of revenge for his mother, even if it would've made sense. at this point, eren has fully become the attack titan, pursuing its sole main objective. which is essentially freeing ymir off its curse. and as he has seen all possible futures and outcomes (dr strange like) so he has to push through this one timeline where everything works out so it won't just reset at one certain point, and then the carousel starts again... he has seen it all and his sole purpose in life, ever since he kissed historia's hand, is to break the carousel, the eternal loop of time, and to free the subjects of ymir from their miserable cursed fate.
Well he didnt achieve that and became a plot device in the final chapter
@@uzairahmed4197 he did break the curse
There is no other possible future. There is only one future that is determined by everyone's choices that ultimately lead to this moment.
A clear but rare example of a fanedit which is actually better than the original
Hardly lmao
Nah it just doesn't hit the same the og still the goat fast and amazing
YES YES 1000% YES. How the conflict between Eldia and the rest of the world was depicted is my only criticism of the show. What they needed to do was mirror the sequences and world building of Eren, Mikasa and Armin in the eyes of Gabi and her life. Then, reenact the Attack Titan and Colossol Titan's appearance as an exact mirror to the season 1 appearance of the Colossol Titan and the Armored Titan. This would have shown the horrors of "just wars" to the eyes of children who are born into this world.
What a beautiful edit. Made me tear up. This is how I choose to remember the show.
I can also see how Armin contrasting Bertolt (both shy guys possessing the Colossial Titan) and Eren contrasting Reiner ironically (Which both shows the Armoured and Attack Titan aggressively charging and attacking the enemy territory). Makes perfect sense.
If only WIT made season 4, then we'd have gotten something like this
What you expect from Mopper they always fumbles Iconic moments especially in JJK
I love the additional flashback scenes you put in there, masterfully crafted
Despite the siege on liberio being erens idea he still said he didn’t have a choice because the future always plays out the way he saw it in the paths
the first time you see this scene it feels like erens trying to make a truce then it feels scary due to how he just destroyed a building then ate a guy then after the rumbling you realise its eren apoligizing for the things he will do the song fits all 3 reasons perfectly
The fact we watched our boy become the main villain 😢
'Lend me your strength', it's exactly what Eren said to Ymir
The fear in eren’s eyes after his future self commits a horrific war crime in his declaration of war
"You Either Die A Hero, Or You Live Long Enough To See Yourself Become The Villain" - Harvey Dent / Two Face
Daaaaamnnn...this was sick. When the editor decides to edit better than the original editor... Absolute cinema!
at the end of the day the marleyans were still preparing an invasion of paradis. they still declared war first. they were still going to try to genocide the eldians again no matter what eren did . a vast majority of the world hate and oppress the eldians for crimes that may or may not have been committed 1000 years ago they're the ones bringing that hatred into the modern day and the ones actively trying to kill the other side. the rumbling is not only necessary but just.
bro dropped the most badass edit
"On that day, humanity wanted to fight the devil , but he came to them
To Revenge"
I think erens roar wasn’t even a roar but a cry
I'm crying over a bunch of drawings.
thousands of moving drawings
Eren had a reason
Glad to see I'm not the only one who has this theme running through my mind the entire time while reading this in manga. Tbh was quite disappointed it wasn't the case when Anime came out but now my disappointment is abated with your edit 😭 thank you!!
The TIMING!!! Insane!
This anime is differnt this anime hit me in the core i am so happy that i was able to watch suchs a masterpiece
Reminds me of seeing this moment for the first time before it got animated thanks to SoulMadness motion manga
This edit of that scene is so much more powerful.
this is basically the last time eren and reiner meet in the real world and speak.
Pretty awesome video man
👍🏻
Best I’ve seen so far
sliding down the wall crying
i dream of a world where we got S4 with the original S1-S3 animation
This is a good edit!
This is way better than the original
that scene of his mother getting eaten actually tears me apart man
1:26 This flashback scene between the same vision of fear that the Eldians had in the first season, transmitted to the Marleyans in the second is really crazy
This scene perfectly shows that Eren was not the one who started this war. He patiently waited for Tybur (or whatever his name was) to finish his declaration. Many people say that they didn't like how Eren changed and stopped supporting him. They saw all the sad stories about different characters and felt pity for them. Well, that's to be expected, it's obvious that every single person have someone or sth they love but that doesn't change the fact that war is war and it won't stop until either side is wiped out. The hatred and fear towards Eldians was deeply rooted in people hearts and it wouldn't dissapear no matter how much they would talk with each other. If Eren didn't do it, someone else would. It was meant to happen one day but Eren was the one to have balls big enough to do it despite the fact how much he wanted to just stay with his friends till his last days. Since 1st episode I was rooting for Eren and that didn't change until the end of the story. All of you who turned their backs on him are despicable.
Based. Exactly.
This gave me chills
If the studio WIT created season 4....
Perfectly fine tuned to the best theme from aot, well done!
Damn bro this was a sick edit
The Attack titan will always seek freedom no matter which era he is in or what situation he has found himself in . For the sake of freedom he fights .
And the attack titan is the only titan which even the founding titan can't control cuz of his will of freedom .
That’s not accurate, Ymir can control any Eldian under the sun. Does not matter if they are Ackerman or Attack Titans.
The previous founders that didn’t have Ymir’s full power like Eren, they couldn’t influence Ackermans and the Attack Titan.
@@deletekeys ymir can control attack titan and all titan and even ackerman but attack titan's will of freedom is so strong that it can reject orders even from ymir
@@origin02 No it definitely cannot…they are all extensions of her and products of the Hallucigenia…definitely cannot overcome the will of the god that literally fabricated it into being.
You nailed it bro. This was so heartwhelming ❤️❤️
Attack on titan :- the greatest masterpiece ever created in the history of mankind 🗿.. shinzou wo sasageyo 🔥✊🏻
He avenged whole Paradis Island
Damn... this at night hits harder!!
This edit is perfect!
Utter Perfection
It wasn't Erens declaration of war, it was his response to Tyburs declaration of war.
I have many episodes which I would like to call best episodes, but of course there cannot be several best ones.
So instead of rating them, I might say that different episodes deliver a different feeling, they're best in their own way.
If each best episode would have its own word or two, like grief or sorrow, heroism etc, then this episode would have word: epic.
Each single detail about this episode and especially this scene - is perfect. Soldiers preparing for... Something. They don't know what is coming, they just know something is about to go wrong. Eren talking about the past and Raynor feeling how the history is about to repeat itself. A huge scene with rulers of the world. And of course, a declaration of war from the world to one single country - which punishes them in return, immediately. The same second after declaration. And, of course, the music - everything fits just perfectly in this scene. And the episode in overall... Epic.
Can u give a list of the best episodes in ur opinion
Tell me reiner , why did my mom have to die
Chills
Eren was so cool
Masterclass 🫡🔥
He didn’t take it personal , none of them were his enemy it was fate and the shackles of the sands of time that were his enemy
Tybur willy: i, in the name of Tybur Will, declare a war to parad-
Eren Yeager: accepted.
A DECLARATION OF *ROAAARRRRRRRRRRRRR*
I find it perfect that eren attacked the moment willy declared was on paradis.
wow... and that's how you tell a story!
I really hope they use old tracks like this in the final episodes at least...
0:43 when the person who bully you all the time try to reconciliation with you
100% agree with Eren's decision
Perfect! This is canon to me.
What's beautifully ironic about this entire series is the notion of self-fulfilling prophecy. If Paradis had been left alone, they never would've become the threat they were perceived as.
Eren gave the whole world the true devil, to shut them up, literally, for eternity.
The attack titan was one who could resist the founding titans powers as its ability to look into the past present ad also future fuck with timelines. It has always been a titan that poses the royalfamily. it is yumirs titian of choice it came about after the eldians lost the titan war.
Espectacular
TMW the edit is better than the original show. god damn! Epic! it brings a tear to my eye to see how well it was done!
That's the best edit I watch
this video is amazing. This is better than the original
BRO WHY IS THIS SO GOOD
seeing this, made me feel like Eren back in season 2 episode 6... (betrayed by Mappa)
Masterpiece
It will be insane for someone to hold a grudge for that long.
Eren:"We accept!"