After hearing the studio recorded version and this live one, I think this song sounds better with Marco singing than whoever the guy is that sings the studio version.
The song is FUCKING EPIC! I saw Nightwish last Friday in San Francisco, Annette did okay with the way Nightwish has toned things down to accomodate her "vocal skill." But this song is a perfect example of the height Nightwish can never get back to with her in the band. I posted previously that Floor could have done an awesome job replacing Tarja. I saw Floor w/ After Forever last year at Progpower USA, OMFG she is goddess in her own right, sadly videos w/ Tarja will be my only way of enjoing NW.
@Nemesis18x It's not so much who's better, (any true fan knows that) It's just that Tarja was and always will be the iconic voice of Nighwish. Their good stuff is decent, but (in my opinion of course) will never be on the same level. They were a band with a lot of chemistry. They lost that when they went their seperate ways.
I have nothing to say... Simply the best... Tarja is TARJA! Anette is really good, but the strong vocals of Tarja, dont have any vocalists can make more than she. Anette says than want sing 10th Man Down, but she go turn the song in something totally diferent... Well, Nightwish today is two diferrent bands, before and after Tarja! Aha, End Of An Era make sense now...
lol why are we still fighting over whos better? tarja and annete both have their high and lows.. enjoy their music.. -_-... why make it so hard on yourselves and others?.. btw.. nice vid, love the song :) and love new nightwish too ^_^
disagree with you on that. She can sing English pretty good to me, i've heard it myself on several concerts, but i think she just wasn't on her best at this one... she sounds like she has a bit of a cold too, but that might depend on me...
One of the few parts where the talking male voice part is actually performed by a band member (Marco). I assume that since they had Marco on had at the time, they may as well use his remarkable voice for that particular part. All in all, great song and aforementioned part.
If Floor is Nightwish 3.1, than who is nightwish 2.0, and 3.0? Nightwish 1.0 is Tarja without Marco, and 1.1 is Tarja+Marco, right? Floor would be 2.5 cause she's temporary, 3.1 will be The Third( The Fourth?) Girl
Floor Jansen from AFTER FOREVER could have brought the same vocal power and class to Nightwish! Currently they are taking a one year break which would have made Floor available, if only they hadn't found Annette already......
hey.....the new bimbo is in her land a famous singer....just pop..when tarja was at nightwish it was a symphonyk metal band now it's a pop-rock band..just the style and the singer is changed...amaranth is much better that some tarja songs:|
Yeah should be "Century Child" Tour, I've seen a show on that one and it fits. Tarja says "Dankeschön" so I guess it has to be some Festival or Open Air show in Germany.
probably she's not famous in sweden...i even didn't heard any song from her...I even heard about her before...one thing is sure..he changes completly the style of the band.
After hearing the studio recorded version and this live one, I think this song sounds better with Marco singing than whoever the guy is that sings the studio version.
The fan Jukka is using looks like he either bought at a dollar store, or stole from his kids LOL! :)
This song sounds better with Marco singing in it!
The song is FUCKING EPIC! I saw Nightwish last Friday in San Francisco, Annette did okay with the way Nightwish has toned things down to accomodate her "vocal skill." But this song is a perfect example of the height Nightwish can never get back to with her in the band. I posted previously that Floor could have done an awesome job replacing Tarja. I saw Floor w/ After Forever last year at Progpower USA, OMFG she is goddess in her own right, sadly videos w/ Tarja will be my only way of enjoing NW.
@Nemesis18x It's not so much who's better, (any true fan knows that) It's just that Tarja was and always will be the iconic voice of Nighwish.
Their good stuff is decent, but (in my opinion of course) will never be on the same level. They were a band with a lot of chemistry. They lost that when they went their seperate ways.
I have nothing to say... Simply the best... Tarja is TARJA! Anette is really good, but the strong vocals of Tarja, dont have any vocalists can make more than she. Anette says than want sing 10th Man Down, but she go turn the song in something totally diferent... Well, Nightwish today is two diferrent bands, before and after Tarja! Aha, End Of An Era make sense now...
lol why are we still fighting over whos better? tarja and annete both have their high and lows.. enjoy their music.. -_-... why make it so hard on yourselves and others?.. btw.. nice vid, love the song :) and love new nightwish too ^_^
disagree with you on that. She can sing English pretty good to me, i've heard it myself on several concerts, but i think she just wasn't on her best at this one... she sounds like she has a bit of a cold too, but that might depend on me...
One of the few parts where the talking male voice part is actually performed by a band member (Marco). I assume that since they had Marco on had at the time, they may as well use his remarkable voice for that particular part. All in all, great song and aforementioned part.
If Floor is Nightwish 3.1, than who is nightwish 2.0, and 3.0? Nightwish 1.0 is Tarja without Marco, and 1.1 is Tarja+Marco, right? Floor would be 2.5 cause she's temporary, 3.1 will be The Third( The Fourth?) Girl
Floor Jansen from AFTER FOREVER could have brought the same vocal power and class to Nightwish! Currently they are taking a one year break which would have made Floor available, if only they hadn't found Annette already......
hey.....the new bimbo is in her land a famous singer....just pop..when tarja was at nightwish it was a symphonyk metal band now it's a pop-rock band..just the style and the singer is changed...amaranth is much better that some tarja songs:|
Yeah should be "Century Child" Tour, I've seen a show on that one and it fits. Tarja says "Dankeschön" so I guess it has to be some Festival or Open Air show in Germany.
probably she's not famous in sweden...i even didn't heard any song from her...I even heard about her before...one thing is sure..he changes completly the style of the band.
Itìs a pity they didn't play this song in the End of an era concert, a live version with a proper quality would have been great
Tarja..^^ (me hates AMy too...but Amy never sang with Nightwish :P....and she doesn't have an operatic voice like Lady Tarja)
Or they'll just include her in the 3.0 update and in 3.1 update the band with retro-compatibility with old material.
Anyone else get the feeling that Jukka stole that toy fan from his kids? XD
They should have released this on one of their studio albums instead of just their EP. This is just a great song, period.
I think Nightwish is the greatest band ever lived because their music is so different from other bands music.
@HighestMetal This song was released in the Over the hills and far away EP, try to find it through that...
Me too! The first NW song I adored - the one that made me buy and listen to all their other music. :)
Insisto, esta canción debieron incluirla en uno de sus discos, no en un EP. Es excelente!.
sorrYYY my bad. i meant that knights of cydonia sounds WAY better live than it does in mp3 form.
this song got me into nightwish and will also remain my bestes along with their song ever dream
great song...and yeah i don't think that marco was in the band during the century child tour...
Ohhh, cool^^
Emppu looks like a hobbit xD or is Marco too tall?
Funny:p
I loved the song!
yes he was....He joined Nightwish in the Century Child CD and that's him there,,singing....
no after marco joined the band they don't need topio wilska to sing anymore with them .
la poderosa tarja ya no es parte de nightwish lastimosamente se saparo del grupo
Actually this is my favorite song by Nightwish, period. I just don't like it live.
oh, so they should have ALSO given her her own tour bus, besides a private plane?
It always just sounds better when you see them live! Wait, not "them"... anyone!
I think I prefer the music moreso than the singing, but that's just my opinion.
Emppu looks like the crazy punker from the The Police Academy-films at 2:50! XD
Good song yeah, even though Tarja never could speak or sing english good enough.
this video makes me realize how anxious I am to see more on Tarja's new album
Marco performs this song even better than Tapio does!
I love this song! Looking forward of hearing it when Anette is singing.
I much prefer Tapio Wilska's vocals instead of Marco's for this song.
¿Cual seria la traduccion al español del nombre de la canción?
tarja sang better than today..and marco scream realy good as ever
I know. That video even made the crappy power rangers look cool.
tarja and nightwish 4eeeeeeeeeeeeee!!! this song is really great!!!
theyre Male singer Sounds AWFUL live!!! AHHH My ears are Bleeding!
This song along with Nemo and Dark Chest got me into Nightwish.
la mejor banda de metal melodico larga vida al metal.....
It's song like this that make one wish they'd bring Tarja back
I dont think this is their best performance of 10th Man Down
Me to. This is so well played! I like the male voice though.
anette will never reach this level, not even get near it...
La mejor canción de gotic metal en todo el mundo
The weird thing is iTunes didn t put up that albulm yet
she definitelly had that presence!!!!and the voice!!!
In my opinion, the greatest Nightwish song up to date.
@Nemesis18x wow dude. couldnt have been better said
they're kinda creepy in person... but I like the song
I love this song on the Super Sentai Tribute Video.
@bobrunger
in reason of this comment im the 10th
Well I think once was theire best album so : D....
lol 4:42 - Everyone at once now! :)
This is my favorite song! Love it!
i think this is the best song of nightwish ever .
hahaha tarja low notes here are so funny
X'D
This song and this performance are just amazing.
canta re bien , lastima qe la hayan echado
DESDE PERU.. BIEN ALLI BUENA MUSICA TARJA.
Nw 2.1 (with Floor Jansen) should play this...
Genia Tarja !! Saludos desde Argentina !!
This is the Only Nigtwish, not the actual one
@VersionSlipKnot Not one of the best.BEST!!!!
Almost peed myself....rare song perfomance...
I wish they played this song at End of an Era.
@neil7859
Its Synphonic Metal not heavy
i think they are amazing ^_^
LOVE this song! Love it, love it, love it!
love this song =) Nightwish is awesome!!
The worst performance I've ever heard by the old Nightwish.
I thought that when I heard this the first time but I think they were all really drunk, especially Marco :)
this is summerbreeze in 2002 I guess
damn they sound even better live :)
one of my favorite songs!!! splendid
it was in the Wacken Open Air...
decimo hombre caido kreo ^^
10 dislikes... 10 men down! :p
This song is not on iTunes :(
a dj.brian le gusta esto :D
Marco Hietala is the best :)
awesome just fucking awesome
like knights of cydonia? =]
I love this song very much!!
simply amazing . I love them
love nightwish!!
amazing song
Can't agree with you more.
Best song of Nightwish!!!!
best song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I totally agree with you:)
great song great Tarja
TARJA I LOVE YOU SO MUCH
it sounds better live
this song is awesome
this song is awesome!!