He’s on the board for the national security council, he is different and far qualified and knowledgeable than many many political commentators in India.
Excellent interview, one of the finest I've seen in recent times concerning India's external relationship - especially with Pakistan. Clear-headed, articulate, and objective. Kudos to both interviewee and interviewer.
Many thanks for this Wonderful Podcast and thank you for bringing Mr Tilak Devasher, A Brilliant Analyst when it comes it to Geo Politics and especially relating to Pakistan China Axis. Best Wishes from Canada!!
Why is Pakistan , presently ,in such a dire state ? 1. Agrarian Feudalism 2 Oversized / political role of the Army 3 Dual citizenship which means dual loyalties 4. Extreme religious inclination 5 Anti India / Anti Hindu mindset 6. Over reliance on foreign powers like the USA and , now China 7 Dominance of Punjab over other regions of Pakistan.
Dual citizenship is making Pakistan's elite take money / precious foreign exchange out of Pakistan and invest it , especially in the Real Estate , of foreign lands. Also , this elite , at times , places foreign countries' interests above those of Pakistan .
Does Indians have Pro Pakistani Mindset?? Nahin to fir Anti India kya bol raha he be?? Anti Pakistani mindset tum logo main bhi he. Tum log anti Muslim ho..hum anti Hindu nahin hein. Stop projecting your thoughts on others. Pakistan's dire state is due to its Corrupt Leaders and Agrarian Feudalism. That's it. Nothing else.
@@shahidanusrat6086hum tumhare haatho se kashkol kabhi bi alag nahi hone denge..yeh jahaalat hi TUMHARI saza ha duniya jaha mai beekh maagte raho😅😅 be ezzat hote raho😅😅😅i
These are very basic questions boy, if you follow news we will know this, but tilak sir is a legend and you haven’t went deep in waters and this not how a podcast is done, watch some of tilak sirs podcast and look at how deep he can talk. Podcasts are not done like this, you need to learn boy! Stop interrupting and stop humming when someone is saying !
The host was clueless and didn't do much research. Some of his Qs were very basic to not have been asked at first place. He should have extracted much more such a seasoned guest.
Apart from the pensions even the civilians employees of the defense services are payed from the civilian budget. Besides a large chunk of budget is spent on debt servicing against defense purchases that stays outside defense budget. Whereas revenues from defense exports as well as coalition support funds do directly to the kitty of GHQ.
Tilak should not do such basic interviews about Pakistan, He is an expert and i think he wasted his time here. Such basic information is available online anyway. Vaibhav singh is best suited to be Tilaks interviews as ab avid Pakistan watcher
Sir, is absolutely right about politicial parties of Pakistan. The muslim politicians before sepration from India and created Pakistan were experience of ruined a movement instead of politicial party. All the politicial activities before Pakistan in India lead by muslim leaders were movements like Khalafat movement , and also the All Indua Muslim League was absolute failed as politicial party and then Muhammad Ali Jinnah turned the All India Muslim League from Politicial party to movement and the party acted as movement to git support from muslims of India which later turned into movement for Pakistan. The support from estanlishment mind set developed before Pakistan and the All India Muslm League got support from British establishment and assured the British rullers to serve for the intersts of British Establishment and got bless from British Establishment at that time. This is the way of short cut to get success in politics and post Pakistan the Muslim League operated as movement because as a politicial party it delivers to peoples and needs home work about the peoblems of peoples as well as for progress of country rather then the movement requies just emotional religious slogans to live and satisfied the peoples. The Pakistan all politicial parties are acted as movements and they all have slogans which are against India Israel and now America and almost rest if the world of non muslims to get the support from peoles with these nationalist religious slogans . All the leaders like Quaud e Azam Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Madame Banazir Bhutyo Nawaz Sharif and later Imran Khan all gives the dream of Riyasat Medina to get the piticial support from peoples. Conqured the Kashmir from India is the other lollipop for Pakistani nation used by all politicians. No economicial agenda and economist in any politicial party in Pakistan. The Islam is used as a opium to satisfied the minds of peoples of Pakistan. The death is more glorified in Pakistan then life and the young peoples wants and wish to die ( Shaheed ) in Islamic point of view. There are no thinking in Pakistan from politicial parties to Media to become a better life for the peoples of Pskistan and live peacefully. All ways lissned the Word JIHAD and the piticial leaders not only religious the politicial leaders educated from UK abd Anerician Universities are all take benfits from this word JIHAD like Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Madame Banazir Bhutyo Imran Khan Bilawal Bhutto all are creating and intensified hate emotions against India and Israel particularly and then now America and Europe and all the nonmuslins to get suppoet from peoples. Thanks.
Just a recommendation for the host, do not jump quickly from one topic to another stick to one topic complete all your questions related to the topic and then jump to a different topic. For example finish your questions on Pakistan then jump to China post which you can jump to Bangladesh jumping from one topic to another shows lack of preparedness also annoying.
U can do better. The questions r very juvenile , basic ,school kid level to ask tresure trove of pak gyan, specialist like Devashar sir. 🙏Pls, for God sake do some research and ask relevant questions. Best wishes.
When you interview someone - whoever it is - you should not call them “sir.” Call them by their name (last or first). Calling them “sir” automatically brings in a transactional quality to the relationship where you are the one without power or agency. In an interview, you need to be on par with the interviewee. Unless we can get rid of this “sir” culture in India, it will always be an unequal, skewed society. Just my opinion. Otherwise a good interview although a bit too overt on the anti-Pakistani flavor.
We are experts in copying. You could have come up with an original name and logo idea for your podcast channel instead of blatantly copying famous YT channel "Diary of a CEO". You even copied his logo man! Such a shame.
Having read your books on Baluchistan and Pathans, am of the opinion that u seriously lack intellectual honesty or your research is fatally flawed. If u fail to address core issues and keep playing with non issues and again one sided than offcourse intellectual honesty is brought to question.
40:00 at the time of watching this video on the 21st of November just 6 days after the video released, I just saw a news that 40 to 50 ppl have been killed in a terrorist attack in Northwest Pakistan kurram region.
They are talking about like they Modi made india a first world country. we are your neighbors we knew rich getting richer & poor getting more poor in India. slums illiteracy, unrest in Manipur/Asam. get your house in order first bragging kings
Indian unhealthy obsession with Pakistan continues. Focus on Public issues within your country, People want their problems solved. Don't deceive your own people.
As if you are doing the same in Pakistan. You are wasting time on you tube searching Indian podcasts you better work for poor people of your country boss.
@@vivekpaliwal2037 No offence meant Vivek, I am referring to Indian Media, Intelligentsia and Ruling party's Unhealthy obsessions' towards Pakistan. Take a Chill Pill.
@@ghalibthemagnificent Bro Indian media and bla bla may be obsessed with Pakistan but have you ever seen Pak media they can't earn their daily bread without Endia Endia and what not. Actually common public is fool to listen to them and make false opinions. My pill is chill already
@@vivekpaliwal2037 Pakistan's media is fooling 250 Million people while Indian Media is brainwashing Population of more than 1.53 Billion. Understand the difference.
not much as Pakistan and its media is obsessed with India for sure. yes Tilak Devasher sir is a Pakistan expert and he is called on many podcasts. But truth is Pak military is obsessed with India and Indian Govt doesn't really care much about PAK.
@@abish83 Nah...you don't know anything about Pakistan. Pakistanis don't care about India. It is your country and your people who do Pakistan Pakistan in everything
Excellent point. India seems obsessed with China and Pakistan. In Pakistan, we hardly see any focus on India. Seems odd for a country that wants to be a player on the global stage.
@@garfieldzzzzzzzzzz we tend to be more than trying to get to the neighbor, our internal political is based around them , our fears are around them, we seem to run our news channels and RUclips channels around them. Thia is a little more than trying to get to know the neighbors . And what neighbors? This current govt has isolated us in the region. Not a single neighbor likes us, let's be real..
We are not obsessed. You are. This is some random video in some random corner of youtube. Ppl who follow and find pakistan discussion jnteresting watch it. This interview is not a national tv debate. But you are here. You are the one obsessed by pakistan.
I like this tilak boy.
Please excuse my informality
I am 77 years old as well.
He is a very knowledgeable, especially on the subject of Indo-Pak relations :)
He’s on the board for the national security council, he is different and far qualified and knowledgeable than many many political commentators in India.
Excellent interview, one of the finest I've seen in recent times concerning India's external relationship - especially with Pakistan. Clear-headed, articulate, and objective. Kudos to both interviewee and interviewer.
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Thank you for your kind words means a lot, stay tuned for more such interviews!
Great analysis, coming to fruition!!! Bharat Zindabad!! Pakhtunistan coming VERY soon🎊🎊🎊
Many thanks for this Wonderful Podcast and thank you for bringing Mr Tilak Devasher, A Brilliant Analyst when it comes it to Geo Politics and especially relating to Pakistan China Axis. Best Wishes from Canada!!
Thank you for your kind words means a lot, stay tuned for more such interviews!
Why is Pakistan , presently ,in such a dire state ?
1. Agrarian Feudalism
2 Oversized / political role of the Army
3 Dual citizenship which means dual loyalties
4. Extreme religious inclination
5 Anti India / Anti Hindu mindset
6. Over reliance on foreign powers like the USA and , now China
7 Dominance of Punjab over other regions of Pakistan.
Dual citizenship is making Pakistan's elite take money / precious foreign exchange out of Pakistan and invest it , especially in the Real Estate , of foreign lands. Also , this elite , at times , places foreign countries' interests above those of Pakistan .
Does Indians have Pro Pakistani Mindset?? Nahin to fir Anti India kya bol raha he be?? Anti Pakistani mindset tum logo main bhi he.
Tum log anti Muslim ho..hum anti Hindu nahin hein. Stop projecting your thoughts on others.
Pakistan's dire state is due to its Corrupt Leaders and Agrarian Feudalism. That's it. Nothing else.
😂😂😂 Kuch bhi karlo chahbar port project kabhi banayga inshallah hum isko nahi banaydengay sartay raho rotay raho
Jenab @@shahidanusrat6086 sahib. Adaab
@@shahidanusrat6086hum tumhare haatho se kashkol kabhi bi alag nahi hone denge..yeh jahaalat hi TUMHARI saza ha duniya jaha mai beekh maagte raho😅😅 be ezzat hote raho😅😅😅i
Enjoyed listening to Tilak ji , wonderful person and more about his contribution to knowledge about Pakistan
Very good discussion between a curious nephew and a wise uncle willing to share his insights to his curious nephew.
Thank you for your kind words, that does sound pretty apt! stay tuned for more such interviews!
Very true!I suggest you to write book purely on army.Pak Army businesses.I listen you.Best wishes from Pakistan
He is currently working on a book that includes the subject of the Pakistan Army! Thank you and stay tuned for more such interviews!
Which books he wrote,?is there link of books?
He has written multiple books, shall add it in the description. Thanks for the reminder!
Very nice analysis by the expert he has good knowledge of the region
Thank you for your kind words, that does sound pretty apt! stay tuned for more such interviews!
These are very basic questions boy, if you follow news we will know this, but tilak sir is a legend and you haven’t went deep in waters and this not how a podcast is done, watch some of tilak sirs podcast and look at how deep he can talk.
Podcasts are not done like this, you need to learn boy! Stop interrupting and stop humming when someone is saying !
Missing Reform Equilibrium and inability to orchestrate strategic readjustments
@@getevennow yes
Thank you for your comment, do subscribe for more such content
Very nice video
Number one reason, Allah wanted it. The all knowing master planner. Qur'an says that.
Good one.
Great knowledge
He is a very knowledgeable, especially on the subject of Indo-Pak relations :)
The host needs to be much much better prepared.
Thank you for your feedback, will improve on it, do subscribe for more such conversations
The host was clueless and didn't do much research. Some of his Qs were very basic to not have been asked at first place. He should have extracted much more such a seasoned guest.
Apart from the pensions even the civilians employees of the defense services are payed from the civilian budget. Besides a large chunk of budget is spent on debt servicing against defense purchases that stays outside defense budget. Whereas revenues from defense exports as well as coalition support funds do directly to the kitty of GHQ.
Thank you for your comment, do subscribe for more such content
Tilak should not do such basic interviews about Pakistan, He is an expert and i think he wasted his time here. Such basic information is available online anyway. Vaibhav singh is best suited to be Tilaks interviews as ab avid Pakistan watcher
Thank you for your feedback, will improve on it, do subscribe for more such conversations
@ShivamAryaa good on you Shivam for taking the feedback positively. I’m sure with little bit of effort and prep you can nail your future podcasts.
I don't know what is new in this discussion.
And what is actually the cause of Pakistan's collapse? In a word or two?
Islamic nation expert in killing muslims.
(Bong Muslims, Pashtun, Baloch, Ahmediya, Hazara, Shia. Silent on Uighur issue.)
I would say that the constant obsession with being better than India is a problem, while also the military leadership!
Good podcast, Tilak sir is a gen but the host is also good..
Sir, is absolutely right about politicial parties of Pakistan. The muslim politicians before sepration from India and created Pakistan were experience of ruined a movement instead of politicial party. All the politicial activities before Pakistan in India lead by muslim leaders were movements like Khalafat movement , and also the All Indua Muslim League was absolute failed as politicial party and then Muhammad Ali Jinnah turned the All India Muslim League from Politicial party to movement and the party acted as movement to git support from muslims of India which later turned into movement for Pakistan. The support from estanlishment mind set developed before Pakistan and the All India Muslm League got support from British establishment and assured the British rullers to serve for the intersts of British Establishment and got bless from British Establishment at that time. This is the way of short cut to get success in politics and post Pakistan the Muslim League operated as movement because as a politicial party it delivers to peoples and needs home work about the peoblems of peoples as well as for progress of country rather then the movement requies just emotional religious slogans to live and satisfied the peoples. The Pakistan all politicial parties are acted as movements and they all have slogans which are against India Israel and now America and almost rest if the world of non muslims to get the support from peoles with these nationalist religious slogans . All the leaders like Quaud e Azam Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Madame Banazir Bhutyo Nawaz Sharif and later Imran Khan all gives the dream of Riyasat Medina to get the piticial support from peoples. Conqured the Kashmir from India is the other lollipop for Pakistani nation used by all politicians. No economicial agenda and economist in any politicial party in Pakistan. The Islam is used as a opium to satisfied the minds of peoples of Pakistan. The death is more glorified in Pakistan then life and the young peoples wants and wish to die ( Shaheed ) in Islamic point of view. There are no thinking in Pakistan from politicial parties to Media to become a better life for the peoples of Pskistan and live peacefully. All ways lissned the Word JIHAD and the piticial leaders not only religious the politicial leaders educated from UK abd Anerician Universities are all take benfits from this word JIHAD like Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Madame Banazir Bhutyo Imran Khan Bilawal Bhutto all are creating and intensified hate emotions against India and Israel particularly and then now America and Europe and all the nonmuslins to get suppoet from peoples. Thanks.
What a twisted mindset,get your head examined
@@sohailaahmed9996 Thanks for your comments.
Are you another Indian Troll?
Thanks for your comment, subscribe for more such content!
@ShivamAryaa I am also thankful to you for encouraged me. Thanks and with my best regards to you.
Just a recommendation for the host, do not jump quickly from one topic to another stick to one topic complete all your questions related to the topic and then jump to a different topic. For example finish your questions on Pakistan then jump to China post which you can jump to Bangladesh jumping from one topic to another shows lack of preparedness also annoying.
U can do better. The questions r very juvenile , basic ,school kid level to ask tresure trove of pak gyan, specialist like Devashar sir. 🙏Pls, for God sake do some research and ask relevant questions. Best wishes.
Diary of a publisher
Inspired by “Diary of a CEO?”
In some ways, you are right! but we are trying to have a persona of our own :) stay tuned for more such interviews!
@@ShivamAryaa Thanks for your candid response. Wish you all the best!
lack of preparation for the interview.
Thank you for your feedback, will improve on it, do subscribe for more such conversations
Your accent switches from the intro to the actual interview. Dont fake it. Keep it real and genuine, you will gain more trust and more listeners.
Thanks for your feedback, shall work on it. do subscribe for more such content!
Interviewer seems to have just doing pasrt time pastime
Its Economic …. Pronounced eco-nomic and not Econ -mic
The background music is so annoying :(
Thanks for your feedback, will improve on it going forward!
IkNiyazi did Same Kind of Act to His Host & Society,
What Jinnah Did Long Time Ago...
.
When you interview someone - whoever it is - you should not call them “sir.” Call them by their name (last or first). Calling them “sir” automatically brings in a transactional quality to the relationship where you are the one without power or agency. In an interview, you need to be on par with the interviewee. Unless we can get rid of this “sir” culture in India, it will always be an unequal, skewed society. Just my opinion. Otherwise a good interview although a bit too overt on the anti-Pakistani flavor.
damn pakistan lets focus on our country
We are experts in copying. You could have come up with an original name and logo idea for your podcast channel instead of blatantly copying famous YT channel "Diary of a CEO". You even copied his logo man! Such a shame.
This host is so childish, immature and ignorant that he has no clue to asking the appropriate questions to Mr Tilak!
Hey host !
The way you talk seems like its an copies accent
You picked a good topic though
Too much Adieu
This Anchor doesn't know anything
Thank you for your feedback, will work on being more prepared in future, do subscribe for more such conversations :)
Having read your books on Baluchistan and Pathans, am of the opinion that u seriously lack intellectual honesty or your research is fatally flawed. If u fail to address core issues and keep playing with non issues and again one sided than offcourse intellectual honesty is brought to question.
Thanks for your comment, do subscribe for more such conversation
Core issues?? Balochistan nd Pathans?
Sir, with all respect, keep your facial expression, especially eyes, like a normal person.
Pakistan is hiramandi for chiana and usa
40:00 at the time of watching this video on the 21st of November just 6 days after the video released, I just saw a news that 40 to 50 ppl have been killed in a terrorist attack in Northwest Pakistan kurram region.
Why do these kids who do podcasting get some basic education before calling the experts
More so like complete basic schooling, to know the bare minimum about the subject on hand
Thanks for your feedback will work on it, hope all is well :)
Start comparing India with China
India is doing much better than China which is on downswing
They are talking about like they Modi made india a first world country. we are your neighbors we knew rich getting richer & poor getting more poor in India. slums illiteracy, unrest in Manipur/Asam. get your house in order first bragging kings
Come outta your madarasa b*llah 🤣🔥
Poor are not getting poorer, no evidence of it.
South and West getting rich faster than north and east
Indian unhealthy obsession with Pakistan continues. Focus on Public issues within your country, People want their problems solved. Don't deceive your own people.
As if you are doing the same in Pakistan.
You are wasting time on you tube searching Indian podcasts you better work for poor people of your country boss.
@@vivekpaliwal2037 No offence meant Vivek, I am referring to Indian Media, Intelligentsia and Ruling party's Unhealthy obsessions' towards Pakistan. Take a Chill Pill.
@@ghalibthemagnificent Bro Indian media and bla bla may be obsessed with Pakistan but have you ever seen Pak media they can't earn their daily bread without Endia Endia and what not.
Actually common public is fool to listen to them and make false opinions.
My pill is chill already
@@vivekpaliwal2037 Pakistan's media is fooling 250 Million people while Indian Media is brainwashing Population of more than 1.53 Billion. Understand the difference.
@@ghalibthemagnificent P*kris who started 4 wars and got banged by us all the time talking about obsession 🤣
BORING 😴🥱
😂😂😂
You people are obsessed about Pakistan
not much as Pakistan and its media is obsessed with India for sure. yes Tilak Devasher sir is a Pakistan expert and he is called on many podcasts. But truth is Pak military is obsessed with India and Indian Govt doesn't really care much about PAK.
❤❤❤ from Pakistan more than that only military is obsessed not common Pakistani @@abish83
@@abish83 Nah...you don't know anything about Pakistan.
Pakistanis don't care about India. It is your country and your people who do Pakistan Pakistan in everything
@@IronMan-nu3rbHeera mandi chalogay
@shahidanusrat6086 Tum jao
Our CPEC port project worth value is more stronger than your nonsense meaningless Chahbhar port project
Please 🙏. Keep it there. Great for you and your country.
Yes, India is building a similar thing with less investment and better opportunity to succeed
@@Shva927 Lmao in Gujrat yes made your port in Gujrat not near Pakistan Balochistan province
@@SultanHasanKhanPakistan is a western vassal state. You cannot move a finger without the nod from America
Color of the cat isnt imp.,Whether it eats Rats or not is imp.!
Kuch bhi karlo Chahbhar pot project kabhi successful nahi hoga hum isko nahi bananaydengay insahllah
I guess, more trade is happening in charbhar in spite of USA sanctions than your port which is under construction and will always be in construction
@@Shva927 Lmao where did you get this news from, from DR Jhonny heheheheheeh
Stop sending baggers to Saudi first then ask some dollers from IMF Daddy 😂😂
Pakbhikaristaani, ammi ko atta Mila Kya aaj😢
@@pranavkumar3782😂😂😂 lmao 😂
So, this man is an expert on Pakistan because his father was in the Indian Air Force?? Really??
That was the beginning of his interest with National Security
Why are we so obsessed with Pakistan? We have thousands of internal issues that we should look into.
Not a good argument. We should know learn discuss neighbours
Thanks for your comment, do subscribe for more such conversation
Excellent point. India seems obsessed with China and Pakistan. In Pakistan, we hardly see any focus on India. Seems odd for a country that wants to be a player on the global stage.
@@garfieldzzzzzzzzzz we tend to be more than trying to get to the neighbor, our internal political is based around them , our fears are around them, we seem to run our news channels and RUclips channels around them. Thia is a little more than trying to get to know the neighbors . And what neighbors? This current govt has isolated us in the region. Not a single neighbor likes us, let's be real..
We are not obsessed. You are. This is some random video in some random corner of youtube. Ppl who follow and find pakistan discussion jnteresting watch it.
This interview is not a national tv debate.
But you are here. You are the one obsessed by pakistan.
Missing Reform Equilibrium and inability to orchestrate strategic readjustments