Farmers Protest Explained | Faye D'Souza
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Farmers across the country are protesting against the latest farm laws that were passed by the government.
In this explainer video, we try to analyse the entire situation of farmers and simplify the laws to understand the entire context and importance of the story.
Check out the other explainer videos here- bit.ly/33oyMKS
More Videos by Faye D’Souza:
Live with Faye at 8:30 PM: bit.ly/37ji1Ci
6:30PM Live Stream: Amitha Balachandra: bit.ly/2V9b9Sc
Interviews by Faye D’Souza: bit.ly/3fDyUeF
Best of Faye D’Souza: bit.ly/36c9W2Y
Follow Me Here:
► Follow us on Instagram: bit.ly/3eUXB5y
► Like us on Facebook: bit.ly/2VHVZEk
► Follow us on Twitter: bit.ly/3aDIWZ7
You're probably one of the best anchors.
Faye, I wish you could teach journalism in colleges
@@asr4327 spam💀
@subhadeep mandal hahaha you still continue to do what you do best! It's been sometime since I last scrolled the comments section on Faye's videos. However, I very clearly remember seeing your comments consistently on her videos couple of months back too, most of which are only spewing negativity, hatred and some more hatred. Going by your comments, it seems you hate Faye/the work she does, however you continue to watch each of her videos and never miss a chance to non-sensically troll her!! Guess that's a big win only for Faye! :D
She's spreading fake news and fear psychosis. India doesn't need such bigots.
Faye works for Corporates and earn 5 digit . But she doesn't want farmer to deal with corporates..what a Hypocrites.. who are we to decide wher should farmer sell their products.. Doesnt Milk and Poeltry are under corporates?? Are they suffering from corporates?? See at what price milk and Poeltry are selling and how Farmers benefited from it...
@@shashankmijar2694 she left mirror now because it is biased as all news channels, she does not work for corporates, don't spread hate.
She has her own online news platform and youtube channels.
I am from Guatemala, and we are currently fighting against unfair bills as well and this farmer protest makes sense to me, I totally support the farmers. Greetings from Guatemala!
And the funny part is this bill is supporter by many farmers working on Field as well as many politicians and main opposition congress mentioned in their election manifesto. The unions demanded it long ago...this is complex politics u won't understand
@@MsManasi People's will, should prevail.
@@Sinserg There r many farmers who r in favour and demanded for long. Especially the poor farmers who suffered because of middle man and currently they r busy in farm... The other side r ready to block road in protest for 6 months... Now 5 % of so called Farmers + Communists +opposition's +anarchist are on road and trust me this way they r defaming the real Farmers. U need to know the background of this
For real? Have you even read these laws? I hope you are not protesting in Guatemala without reading the laws 🙈
@@mohitkhurana163 I know India is far away from where I live and I know that sometimes there is a lot more that one can see, about our situation here, I can tell you that our government and its laws are attempting against a lot of peoples well being but as always time will tell.
If every journalist in India was this lucid and brave, half the problems would disappear. Glad to see some journalistic integrity left in the country.
Such a quality news. It’s been some years since I heard such concise, precise, and unbiased news. Please continue to be the same and deliver news in the same way. Wish you all the best.
◽ SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE ◽
@@asr4327 spam💀
Many fact have been intentionally or unintentionally burried by Faye
Unbiased😂😂
She is a biased and fake journalist....anti Hindu and western influenced
Lady
Very well explained and a lay man can understand this on going conflict of interests easily. Thank you ma'am once again. 🙏
🟠SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🟠
Same with sheaker Gupta too just check the print , Faye is baised leftist , she can't talk about the other side of the issue, she dint talk about the real problem there in Punjab and Haryana. There are loop holes in the bill that I can understand , but to completely remove it is really bad for india
Whoever speaks the truth is called leftist.
@@somnatharcot2088 yes because there idology is leftist , when you say corporates will make farmer suffer that's communists idology , only talking about one view and not talking about what system exists rt now that's wrong
@@somnatharcot2088 Don't need to go right man, just some centrist view for you man, try its once - ruclips.net/video/B9hSADKW3Cc/видео.html&ab .... If you dont like it stay with Faye.
With so much clutter and chaos in the media regarding this issue
It was so difficult to understand what's going on
Thank you for being the clear voice!
Much love and Respect!❤️
Thank you so much Faye! This is so helpful! This is everything journalism should be. Factual +unbiased, meaningful, and easy to understand.
But you won't express your views on the Farm Bills.
🧶SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🧶
There is nothing unbaised in what she said. It's nothing but biased.
I adore Faye Dsouza's journalism. It's simplicity can open a heart💗 and mind, yet boggles the mind how she crafts her masterpieces🖼️🎨🖌️. Where would our world be without people like her?☺️
Also add your comment on the ongoing farmers'agitation.
🟢 SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🟠
@@asr4327 spam💀
Farmers always have had the discretion to sell their produce either to govt at MSP or to traders. So, the crux was that farmers always used to get atleast MSP either by selling to govt or to trader. However, farmers have never had any means nor will they ever have any means to take their produce to sell in other mandis or states, say from Chandigarh to Bangalore. This is also a known fact that only about 6% of entire produce was being bought by government at MSP and rest everything was sold to traders by farmers.
Secondly, passing of all these laws has to be coupled with the intention of Indian Govt. These laws have also removed the storage limit and abetted hoarding, so as to say, govt has rather made hoarding legal. Without pointing out any specific names, everyone knows which business house(s) are ultimately going to establish their monopolies.
Agree, just like issuing 2000 rupee note after banning 1000 rupee note and told that corruption is now over.
Namaste I am from Maharashtra.My friend is farmer , he just completed his engineering. Throughout engineering he used to say me i will never do farming. After passing this laws he sees some hope in farming. Today he is doing farming and he thinks laws are good . Yes he do agree on corruption in mandis .
Why do Punjab farmers almost exclusively grow Wheat and Rice? Whereas India has to import in large quantities of oil seeds and various types of millets and pulses every year? Logically, they would stand to make a profit if they change their crops, but they don't ask yourselves why? Also, every year tons and tons of wheat rots at FCI warehouses (or at least thanks to Nitin Gadhkari made into ethanol), why are we still growing wheat when we have surplus?
tell government to ensure fair price for said oil seeds , pulses etc , they will definitely grow them. In fact variety of crops are grown in Punjab though maximum acreage is under wheat & rice only because timely payment of msp is given in case of wheat/rice. people grow sugarcane too but their payments gets delayed by year or so, it becomes difficult to sustain when you do not get paid for a year . Surplus grains can be exported but our government is reluctant to do so. there is still lot of hunger around the world, even In India there is large population which is not able manage 2 square meals a day with ease . Haven't you seen during lockdowns how people were distributed with food grains, so what surplus are you talking about( the same surplus came handy in times of emergency like in covid lockdowns). Crux is government is pro corporate rather than pro common man.
Amazing journalist 😊, top scribe, the best of the best.
⚪ SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔘
Faye D'Souza has mastered the art of subtly pass on her politically coloured opinions as news analysis. To be fair she set a context based on some facts and not pure rhetorics but she, quite expectedly , does not address the elephant in the room. How MSPs and Food stocking have been taking money from we the taxpayers from all over the country and passing it to the RICH , sometimes STINKING RICH "Farmers" or rather middlemen, musclemen from Punjab and Haryana while the food purchased from them get rotten to the tune of 2 LAKH Crores. YES that's the amount we have been paying to the rich "FARMERS" of Punjab and Haryana who then make Punjab "Udta Punjab". Thats why these so called Poor framers who can afford the most expensive cars, drugs and foreign travels are sending people on the street to protest.. coz there FREE WEALTH making machinery at the cost of tax payers money is being challenged.
Thank you Faye! This is so informative and important to know.
👍
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Clean and Neat. It sure does take a lot of hardwork to cut down such complex things to present in a simpler way. Kudos to all the teams hard work 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 and to you especially Faye
Faye, You have always been a superb journalist. Loved watching your debates and missing them too, we can understand the hurdles all good journalists are going through these days..Keep up the good work in these challenging time. All the Best!
It’s good that you have parted your ways from sycophancy journalism and became an independent player in the world of politics
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Huge respect for you mam. Thank you for explaining it so thoroughly.
Any one with basic intelligence can understand that the prices of basic food materials will go up at the same time farmers will not get what they deserve.
how?
@@shaurav8008 private companies can buy the produce from farmers at low prices, since farmers won't have any other buyer, then hoard produce to drive up prices. Then sell at high prices, while having to no obligation to give the farmers a fair deal.
@@hemantakaushik4635 see farmers can still sell at mandis who the fk gave you half baked info there are total 3 bills..
@@drbh6331 the fear is that govt will stop operating the apmc mandis in a matter of time. and private companies are under no obligation to purchase at msp. thank you for abusing me.
Get a few facts right, before going public. For example:
1. The dispute resolution is left to parties . Recourse to SDM is optional to be mutually agreed. Only when SDM is opted and order passed courts are excluded. Further of course constitutional courts of records cannot be excluded by any law. This is settled law already.
2. Hoarding makes sense if there is supply side constraints. By making it national market outside Mandis farmers are not left to mercy if Artiyas and can choose any buyer across India. Now with deregulation investment in supply chain and quick excavation of produce from farm gate will take place. This will not only reduce table prices for consumers but will pre empt lots of wastages.
Who is impacted most? Of course the Artiyas whose predatory monopoly ends.
Have you visited a APMC mandi ? And seen how trade happens on rigged prices and how dispute resolution happen....
Amazing !!!
If a corporate hoards tons of potato which is not a essential commodity now and he has two options in front of him
1) to sell potatos in open market
2) bake them into fries and chips from their branded shops
Any sane corporate chose the latter option given thag he achieved economies of scale in chips n fries making..
And you say hoarding is good.
Imagine you have only one borewell at your town and previously there was a rule that only two buckets of water per house for a day. Now they changed.. anyone can take any amount of water depend on their storage capacity. Obviously the Rich would take the most of the water leaving nothing to poor... Ask yourself whether govt has made any regulation that hoarded onions and potatoes are to be sold to end users only!!
I can watch Faye whole day 😍
True
This is the best explainer series I have seen Faye. Please do more of these! Most insightful work on the issue around the topic.
Introducing this new feature in your show has been a great idea..... everything lucidly explained, in simple words.👏👏👏
🔲 SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔲
@@asr4327 spam💀
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Thank you Ms.Faye D'Souza for bringing everyone upto the speed to understand the farmer's protest! Very crisp and no-nonsense reporting as always. Keep up the good work !!
Can I give 1 MILLION likes to this video? I am not happy giving just 1 like.
Only 6% of the farmers get the msp,so 94% sell at a higher price or price below the msp. Mainly the farmers from Punjab gets the benefits of msp.
See that's the problem,you don't know actual thing.punjab and haryana farmers sell their product at msp,but they are not only beneficiary.other state's farmers also benefit msp, through state procurement scheme.when there is distress sell,and private sector don't procure and price fall,states intervene and procure at msp.
journalism in not dead, bought, sold and pimped out !!! dont expect mrs. faye to like the cooment but huge respect maam
You should also do an story on how the mandi system in haryana and Punjab is so effective that they are so worried about it losing it
The whole issue explained so well in detail .Always a pleasure to view your channel.
🟦SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE ⬜
They are trying to repeat 1984
@@rajpandey8326 may I know your points on how can you say that?
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Government can surely amend the bills and end the tug of war.
But farmers do not what to amend the bill. They want them to be gone.
Thank you so much. Previously I don’t know which side to support.
Now I support the farmers protest with full clarity.
Farming is the god's gift. He works for people for their living and almighty through nature helps them.
Middle class people pay taxes and don't get food for free.
Stop forcing socialist mindset on people
@@rightlibertarian8355 again you read correctly and understand correctly.
Thank you so much for developing a space where we can gather facts and form our own opinions!❤️
Faye should really start a Patreon account.
So true faye is a gem💎
Have you been to Mandi - seen how a farmer is blackemailed by dalals in mandi- they offer their price which is not near the MSP and farmer has no option to take it back additional expense and what will he do after taking it back
Donald Wirathu
- rightly said
*Let's support our farmers ... Remember, without them we won't exist!*
🔷SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔷
What a load of bull
Yes but which farmer ??😖😖 khalistanis ??? Or farmers getting biryanis from mosques ?? R farmers present only in punjab ??
What about the farmers of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Maharashtra,Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Jharkhand, Chattisgarh,North east Indian farmers ?? We all support it. If only Punjab and Haryana farmers are going to decide the fate of bills passed by parliament then what is the use of sending our representative to the parliament.
Love the concept of an explainer series, Faye. There's so much noise and clutter surrounding these issues and the media exhausts viewers with endless debates and discussions. It's good to have just a simple, straightforward and factual breakdown of events without opinions or views in them. Thanks for this.
Looking forward to more of this format of informative videos on this channel, Faye! Please keep going! ♥
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Coloured reporting, as always. Didn't talk about how MSP will not go away, how this government has bought so much more on MSP than its predecessor, how these very same laws were in the Congress party manifesto, being a Khalistani does not automatically translate to having an India-hating family (Yograj-Yuvraj Singh is an example), Punjab has squeezed the individual farmers and gets 1000s of crores from annual central government purchases plus subsidies ... Hence the middlemen are protesting, NOT farmers. But kudos to the protest managers for optics management.
Last two MAIN points:
- among the list of demands of the farmers were two non-farming related clauses: repeal the air pollution act and let them continue stubble burning AND to RELEASE FROM JAIL THE "INTELLECTUALS" AND "FREE THINKERS" AND "POETS" (basically islamo-communist anti nationals) who've been jailed by the present administration. This protest is not about farmers at all
- this is like protesting against disinvestment in the 90s. History is going to remember you as the turds who opposed Liberalization of the fam economy
Thanks Faye, always crystal clear in you explanation. Will always hear your talksand please continue for your eager viewers.
Faye thankyou for bringing truth to the fore.
I think we've got ourselves a new and independent media. Keep up the good work and this was very informative. Thank you so much for putting this out for us.
She missed out on 3 important points:-
1) Yograj Singh, openly supported Jarnal Singh and made derogatory statement about Hindu women. Obviously, Khalisthani elements have entered this movement. Protestors should themselves physically kick out these rogue elements out of the protest site and all Indians should see it. Otherwise, however right is the protest, it won't be supported by most Indians.
2) APMC which are run by state governments should remove cess which makes them less compitetive as compared to corporates. Total charges in Punjab is 8.5%. Before GST, it was even more. This is the hypocrisy and this is the reason Punjab State government is organising this protest through proxies. No organized protest is possible without political support, directly or indirectly. There is nothing called spontaneous protest. Common people think it's spontaneous but they are actually not. She should have been truthful in mentioning that.
3) Punjab and Haryana farmers are getting more than the ideal market price that should have been determined by market force (demand & supply). FCI is having excessive stock of paddy and rice but still giving MSP. Much of the stock is wasted every year. Farmers should reduce rice and paddy production and go for other options like oil seeds, which India is importing. MSP for long is not sustainable for any economy.
But I don't support the introduction of corporates in strategic areas. Food is definitely strategic.
I can't understand why government is not taking the following steps:-
1) Export excess Rice and Paddy. If quality is an issue then give MSP as per quality and upto certain quantity, then automatically some farmers will shift to other crops.
2) Introduce and promote attractive packages for crops which we import or has great export possibility.
Outsourcing to corporates is not a great idea. If at all government can't do it then it should be outsourcing it to educated youths not to the Ambanis of the world.
Centralisation of wealth and power should be avoided.🙏
For your kind information first read the law carefully...These laws are only given as an OPTION to farmers, there is no compulsion that farmers have to sell all their produce to private sector..they still continue and follow their old traditional of APMC method of selling produce..
Now the real reason why these so called farmers are protesting??
1.Because they don't want other small and marginal farmers to sell their produce to private sector as Punjab government will face huge loss in terms of state taxes and agent commission will also be impacted.
2. Big/Giant farmers they give loans to small and marginal farmers and when they cannot repay the loan, these big/giant farmers take the produce in cheap prices and sell the same to apmc on MSP..
In short, small and marginal farmers don't even know what MSP is😒.. Reality is quite harsh and different from your explanation.
Thank you.
I doubt if u ever visited village and explore how farming is going on.
Still the private player, middle men, gave, lend, money to farmers or engage them in contract farming. Difference is, this time big players will enter. They will not buy poor quality product. Very soon, the middle men will be abolished; who r huge in number. We will produce much better quality product.
Govt will not buy, most probably or reduce, food grains from farmers.
And of course, big farmers will be on loosing side, who are selling poor product to govt and get full money.
If possible visit fci godown, you will know quality of food grain we procured. Of course, govt officials are involved in this corruption.
One of your info is wrong. Punjab or Haryana is not the biggest producer of peddy or wheat in india. It's WB and UP.And farmers in those states are Okey with these laws. Farmers in punjab mainly grow wheat and rice and get max profit of MSP. Govt never removed MSP on first place..so no need to put it back. As we are over producing wheat and rice every year it's very tough for govt to buy and store unnecessarily. In most of states in India apmc already gone ...so farmers should think wisely and be reasonable and govt should give assurance of MSP. This is not the season so this farmers from Punjab is protesting...what they were doing in last four months ! Why they didnt protest that time? All this incidents are connected
You've debunked it so well, that too in a "neutral" and simple manner. Really appreciate what you've been doing ❤️
What do you mean by debunked it? Are you saying the protest is incorrect?
ruclips.net/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/видео.html
Probably the best explanation why farmers are protesting....Subscribed
But govt assured that the APMC will always be there and MSP will always be provided there, APMC will never be shutdown, its farmers choice to go outside and explore more options or to go to APMC, just like BSNL is there along with other private telecom operators to regulate the telecom tariff, My father is a farmer from karnataka, he is very hardworking person, we grow paddy, here from 40 years what i am observing is only the middlemen and millers are benefitting from our crops, after working so hard and investing so much on labour's and pesticides, facing natural calamities, labour problems, water problems, machinery problems, new type diseases in the crops and all, what we are earn is just to accommodate our basic needs of food, cloths, bike thats it, forget our hardwork, sometimes we won't get back our investment also, present crop cutting done in this dec month is a complete loss for all paddy growers here, yield reduced very drastically due to new virus in our crops just like covid on humans, we not made any property from past 40 years, we don't get any thought of making some property with that earnings, just life goes on with hardworking forever, so something to be done to benefit the farmers, all these days only businessmans, middlemens are having decent earnings and making properties everywhere, small farmers fate remains same even after another 50years until unless if something is done now, our country is developing means everyone of us should develop, everyone be a part of it, only few sector people are developing is not a whole development of the country, these farm bills are not a big news here in South India or at least in our locality, big protests and all happening there in North India, I doubt does farmers really able to understand these farm bills properly, mostly some opposition parties, middlemens and others who are benefitting now are having knowledge to understand these bills and its impacts and to safeguard their earnings in future they are provoking farmers with false predictions to protest against those bills, I trust our PM Modi like our family head, he never do anything harmful to the farmers or any other sector hardworking people, he doesn't have intentions to earn something by supporting corporates bcz he not even have children's to earn for them, treats all of us as his children's
You people are such a good team. We need more journalists like you in this country.
Mam u don't know ... how much my heart gets filled with so much joy n tears when I hear u break the news piece by piece to us. Thanks a lot faye mam. I would pay to listen to u. God bless u. Long live farmers🙏🙏
You are absolutely incorrect by saying that APMC purchase on MSP. It never happens. The local brokers decide the rate for day and farmers have to sell it on those prices. The farmers couldn't take away his products wherever he could get more price due to APMC act.
You making points that private sector companies make monopoly but farmers are not bound to sell it him locally . Therefore the companies has to pay at par rates but in previous system farmers are bound to sell locally registered vendors. The farmers can't carry his products outside to get optimum rate of his products. The previous system help to establish monopoly of the local brokers.
In reality the local registered brokers have monopoly to fix rate considering his profits and all possible expenses. These all arbitrary expenses real or imaginary has to bear by the farmers.
incomplete analysis...very smartly mam you as normaly most if the journo do...hide the actual data.... to support your view u shud provide d data thn that wud help us to understand the actual picture....
Mam, farmers are "determined" and not "adamant".
There is nothing wrong in being 'adamant' for the right cause. The word adamant may sound bad only if you put a negative connotation to it. Just like how it is ok to say 'proud' Indian, but hurtful when someone is called a 'proud' person.
Adamant is not necessarily a bad word... It just means that the person won't budge
Mohan is right. Adamant has an adverse connotation. It's like saying they are stubborn. They are determined. Committed.
@@natalieg34 right cause? The complete protest is without cause. Total drama
You seriously have a problem with 'adamant'. dude people like you love to find excuses to get offended
Faye! agricultural problems in India are too complicated to be addressed in a few minutes. One of the biggest hurdle is our current political system where power is centralized. Despite centralization of power on many subjects, agriculture was kept state subject for a reason. Current government abused constitution to intervene significantly in agricultural matter without realizing its impact in certain parts if India and its eventual impact on PDS. Current Govt is making same mistake Mrs Gandhi made to bring Green Revolution. Bookish solutions may sound very good academically but sustainable solutions come from real life experiences. And real life experiences in agriculture are different in different parts of India and solutions will also be different. One size fit all does not work in India. It may work in Finland, Germany, France etc but India is very unique country and needs unique system for it to sustain growth and stability. Current chaos is totally unnecessary and will lead to more problems than we had before new laws in agriculture. Current govt's effort to turn India into one market will fail. This diversity is the biggest strength and defense of India against Imperial hegemony. Instead of using it for benefit of India, current Govt is experimenting to color it with one shade of Hindutva to create one big market. I can write for hours on India, and bore you with dry ideas. So I shut up and continue listening to brilliant minds like you.
In short she tried to explain the same thing how the bill 'll kill small farmers
@@bharathsy You are right that she took a clear position that these new bills are not in favour of farmers. But why agriculture in India is distressed is beyond these laws. Current political structure is faulty and instead of improving it, current govt is making it worse by implementing bookish ideas formatted in successful western countries. China and Vietnam didn’t grow by following Russian Model or Western Model. They developed a unique system which dominant western economists are baffling to categorise in their format. India has to develop their own system based on its unique ground realities. In reality it would not happen overnight but during mass agitation there is a chance of improvement if a truthful narrative based on reality gets traction. There are lot of good intentioned politicians but they feel disheartened as people are less willing to hear them during normal times. I have a feeling that demand for decentralisation will get some traction if farmers got successful in getting these laws repealed. As of today it still seems very difficult that India as nation will do a meaningful course correction to be a healthy partner of international community. Current govt is determined to stay its course despite clear warnings that it will not work in India. Electoral loss or win won’t make much difference but if there are more people like. Faye processing/moderating information reaching out to public, there is a chance that we as nation will make better decisions. My views are not that important, Faye and other journalists who are not only intelligent but fearless good communicators also.
Govt. need to have a seperate agency to act as a business resource center for the farmers in each state that they can go to; to give them business guidance, teach them business & negotiating skills etc.
Without that, it's like throwing them out of the ship and they're saying, they don't even know how to swim!
I was of the view that there were valid arguments on both sides - after listening to P Sainath once again - I am shifting more towards the farmers view.
As an individual who has worked and gained 25 years of work experience - objective of any activity is to be efficient and effective. The whole narrative changes when it becomes conspiratorial, attacks individuals on being misled and sheer force of authority being used to discredit the others POV.
Why are we not seeing the discussions based on each line of the old / new / positive and possible acts and move forward by the government.
Their intention is being questioned and rightly so because of the past actions and behavior.
Faye, please include info about Punjab govt getting money from the mandis. Its in heaps which they are afraid they may loose.
Also please mention that the farmers are free to sell even to the mandis if tgey offer more than thr corporate. Nothing is stopping them.
Also please clarify as I read that every state has the liberty to implement the rule.
Also mention that MSP is already there for 32 essential commodities and that includes rice and wheat, so why worry.
So far we faced loads of far
We can digest our food and sleep well only if our brothers in farming sector are satisfied with filled stomach.
Great explanation. You've earned a new subscriber. Thank you from 🇨🇦
Very good information Thank you Faye D
Dr. Kanhaiya Kumar for farmers
ruclips.net/video/6huRbIFQkBc/видео.html
Please also see Cut The Clutter by Shekhar Gupta dated December 5, 2020
Thank you.
We need gormint employees like this DeSouza to tell us about the evils of the private sector.
Thank you for sharing everything in detail, Ma'am!
BSNL and Jio perfect example
Really?! .. What prices did you pay for Call & Data with BSNL v/s after Jio came to the market?!
@@arunsar7893 BSNL is wiped out and from January Jio is increasing their prices. so first know the basic sense of jio plan. obviously bhakths won't agree with anyone except illiterate PM
@@ramkikumarsingamaneni8271 BSNL is inefficient & a wastage of Tax Payers money. It deserves to be wiped out & Jio prices are 1/10th of the prices people used to pay before Jio came to the market. Jio will need to increase the prices by 10x before consumers start paying what they used to pay in 2015.
So first, stop talking out of your stupid ass & call people Bhakts because you don't understand economics & really it's you who is illiterate.
@@arunsar7893 oh really then why didn't the government allow bsnl to roll out 4g when it had al the resources to do so.. instead of taking advantage of it they let the private players take the pole position... ?? Have any answers mate !!? And this is what the government is trying to do with farmers.. soon you will see ambani opening their own farm mills .. they'll buy as a corporate from these farmers , rework the collected yield and sell in their own retails... isn't this fucking awesome bhakt... don't tell me now that ambani hasn't bought or took over the Big bazar groups aren't you aware of that . Tjis process is nothing but illegally legalising their monetary status with our own money.. if u have any matter left in ur brain bloody use it... Fucking Fascist Government
@@asifahmed6568 I am aware of everything you have mentioned. I am also aware for every Muslim Guy whatever this govt. does is always wrong, that's why you use the word Facist so loosely that it has lost it's value and evoke zero reaction.
Everything that you have said is going to happen in the agricultural sector is categorically wrong. You think so because you have an extremely superficial Understanding of the situation and your views are basically what Barkha Dutt, Faye D'Souza & Rana Ayub are telling you.
I don't want to waste my time explaining Econ 101 to you online. You can believe whatever you want. It's up to you.
Would recommend people here to go watch Shekhar Gupta's take on this issue on today's episode of cut the clutter.
Shekar gupta ... so funny he's just another Arnab of social media
Weren’t the farmers already selling in the open markets anyways, read that only 6% of farm produce were getting sold into Mandis
Government buys maximum rice and wheat for FCI at MSP in Punjab and Haryana. So in these two states role government mandi is more dominant than any other states thats why these people are protesting to save mandi. Land holdings percentage is highest in these two states compared to marginal land holdings in other states. Once corporates get hold over market, then they manipulate for their own benefit. It's well known truth
Not 6% selling in mandi 6% is getting the benefits of the MSP.
Exactly. The government is advertising the new ordinances as "freedom for farmers", when they already had that freedom in the first place. This ordinance is clearly not intented for the benefit of farmers
@@ankurms corporates holds Milk market ..did they hold their market there??
@@shashankmijar2694 milk and agricultural produce don't stand on the same footing. Onion price is soaring in sky after essential commodities act is relaxed. Tones of onions are rotting in godowns near patrapada (Bhubaneswar) but still they don't release into market to maintain high price.. maneuvering skills of corporates are not same for all products , they keep changing as per times.
Ha ye baat to kisi ne sochi hi ni...ki waha khaane k liye to langar he ...lekin Hagne k liye Shochlay ni h
Bhai subhe k 4 baje h aur main has has ke pagal ho gaya hoon
Excellent explanation, Faye. Thanks. Is it true that MSP was not legally binding on the government even in the previous format of farm laws and was only an administrative provision and still worked well enough? If yes, then couldn’t the same kind of implementation of MSP still work as the government seems to state? Also the issue of real farm reforms in India (that ensure future food security, economic growth for the farmers, and reverse the detrimental effect on the environment of current farming practices to make agriculture sustainable) need a wider ambit than the MSP issue that the public needs to be informed about. In the real reforms the MSP will anyway have to go in favour of a market driven farm economy. But these new farm laws don’t seem to take us to the real reforms needed in the farming sector.
A journalist who inspires
You’re the best journalist.
Shekar Gupta did a good breakdown on the print
IT cell views are everywhere
Every one has the rights to express their views
We don't know exactly who is going to benefit farmer or traders it can go either way corruption is every where
Punjab and Haryana should concentrate on some other crops we have abundance of wheat and rice
This was amazing...the way you explained everything in the best way possible....doing your share. Thankyou. People will definitely benefit from this.
PM Modi Should not Step Back. This Farm Bill is important for the Country . MSP Issue can be solved 👍
Someone who doesn't even know what farming is fucking commenting on this
Explained in such a simple way.. the best explanation so far.. awesome mam. It's always pleasure listening to you. Thank you!
Watch the print shekhar Gupta has done a great job on this topic
Faye, I feel the agriculture sector reforms miss the moot point. The farm holdings are small, they are managed by poor farmers who have several members of the family dependent on income from the farms, they cannot employ technology, mechanization or resources to improve yields and are pitched against the system whether it is the APMCs or the private mandis where they don't have any negotiating power. As long as these factors remain, there cannot be any future for Indian farm sector. I feel the only solution is to invite large private sector houses to be on the side of the farmers and not on the side negotiating with them. The govt should invite 10-20 ethically run business houses to invest in agriculture sector, take the farms on lease from farmers for a fixed income to the farmers, employ technology and resources to improve farm yields, and set up downstream cold storages and food processing units. This way, the farmers will earn income from farm lease and employment on the farms or in downstream units. The cooperate sector working on the side of farmers will help reduce the number of players in supply chain and also fetch better prices. The crop wastages will reduce and may also help bring down consumer prices. The participating private sector players can be offered tax breaks in their other profitable businesses linked to their investment in this venture. Agriculture reform is a national priority. Almost 50% of people in the country depend on income from an inefficient sector which contributes less than 15% to national GDP. Providing them alternate employment in the rural areas will not only reduce their migration to overcrowded cities but will also help improve literacy levels and curb population growth. The govt must take an active role in bringing private sector participation in this national mission. It simply cannot be done in public sector or informal sector. This is not crony capitalism but public-private initiative for reform of a critical sector.
Government should take care of farmers and help them implement the use of modern technologies and use of new updated equipments.. rather than taking upon themselves they are just passing the baton.. and do u think any corporate house would care if u are implementing technology or not.. they would just be preying on these weak farmers and snatching even the smallest piece of pie they would even have..
Can I pay via bank since I don't have GPay.
🍞 SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON RUclips HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🍞
There is no doubt that these bills are for corporates and not for farmers. That's why farmers are protesting for their rights. And it also can't be forgotten that the government passed these bills undemocratically. If corporates succeed to establish their monopoly on food industry then common man will be at receiving end. Government can not run from its social responsibility.
@subhadeep mandal You should not talk about ideal situation. But the reality is Modi Government has developed very close relationship with these corporates, and receives millions of rupees as party fund. BJP has become a richest party. It has nothing to do with common man, small trader or a farmer. As they have realised the power of money.
very good Faye! thankyou
Farm bill was part of Congress manifesto as well. In the long run this will be good for farmers. None of the well known economist have spoken against the bill coz they know the benefits farmers gets in the long run.
sorry bro , economists are not GOD they haven't done farming themselves, so are not aware of real problems of agri-sector. real life is different than discussing theoretical scenarios. Contract farming has already failed in India , with only exploitation of farmers at the hands of corporates. See the condition of farmers outside punjab/haryana it is pitiable , many are still using bullock carts in 21st century , they do not have strong mandi system/ lack of pucca roads/no msp , they suffer at the hands of private players and corrupt government officials.
Watch Prof. Gulati. Enlightening.
best report thanx 🙂
A good and sincere effort to make every body understand the farmers protest. But the private mandis bring competition environment eventually the farmers get price. Government mandis working for some brokers
I miss you on Mirror now.. Urban debate is lifeless without you.. Tanvi Shukla is good but you are best..
Dalals are disguised as farmers - their insterest is in danger
What would you do if your livelihood is is danger and the future of your children ?
@@hela6208 You mean If i have been sucking your blood and at point of time society stops me than i should fight back to ?
I understood so well that I can sit for an exam. My friend, GOI is a worse student and doesn't understand a thing. He is only interested in my other friend, Jio.
Get well soon illiterate 😏👉
So basic argument is private sector is bad..I get it..
Humne sub private band kar dena chaheye, fir pata chalega kaise chalta hai desh.
0:16 Delhi is not a state.
80% of wage earners in India are such as the owners of your corner store and “Paan Walas” and “Chai Walas”are “Private Sector.” They are not “wolves” They are the tru job creators, wealth generators. They do not take handouts from the government or get minimum prices from the government.
Making an "explainer series" on issues that she herself doesn't understand.
@2:40 Also using the word "hoarding" instead of 'storage' shows her bias.
Let's not forget, these are the same people who talk about 'Economic Inequality' & 'Job Creation'. The Irony.
Biased. She's another rice bag.
@@ManjunathKamathKochi You are not doing yourself any favor by calling her "rice bag". It's an abuse and it says more about you than her.
Faye OP please you are getting the youth interested in current affairs, its amazing
ಚೆನ್ನಾಗಿ ವಿವರಿಸಿದಿರಿ. 👌🏽
Dear Faye, I watch your videos and find it very interesting and it encourages me to listen to you more cause the way you explain is so simple and clear. But the background noise and also your voice needs a little check name adjustment.
Thanks Faye for this new segment Explained! Short and direct! Good. Keep up the good work Faye and team!
I wish my india friends, all people there all best for this protest....greetings from turkish man from germany........Namste 🙏 may Shiva protects us all..
Wow I did not know the little details. The freedom to farmers somewhat fixed me to say that it was good for the farmers, but no check on the private mandi's that us messed up and if these are the reasons for protest I'm all for the protest.
Stand with farmers
You explained it in such a simple and unbiased way. Thank you Faye. I have become your fan😊🙏