Germany to impose stricter rules to curb migration influx | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 июл 2024
- Chancellor Olaf Scholz spoke of a "historic moment" after his federal government and the premiers of the 16 states agreed on a series of measures to amend Germany's refugee policy.
Benefits for refugees are more generous in Germany than in many other EU countries. Conservative politicians have described this as a "pull factor" attracting refugees to Germany, and have suggested paying out less or no more cash to new arrivals.
Currently, it takes an average of six to 18 months for an asylum application to be processed. Until now, applicants would receive higher benefits after they had been in the country for 18 months. That threshold will now be extended to 36 months. Until then, the reduced rate of €410 (about $440) per month will apply. Benefits such as food in state accommodation are offset.
After the announcement of the changes, Finance Minister Christian Lindner (FDP) wrote on X, formerly Twitter, that this could lead to savings of €1 billion. This would "not only relieve the burden on states and municipalities," he wrote, it would also "reduce the appeal of the German welfare state."
To date, the states have had to renegotiate with the federal government every year about who pays what costs for the care of refugees. Now, there is to be a lump sum of €7,500 per refugee per year.
So far in 2023, some 220,000 migrants have made an initial application for asylum. And of the 1 million Ukrainian refugees from the war, more and more are now registering with the authorities to be housed by the state.
Cities and municipalities have long been asking for support with accommodation, ranging from a simplification of legal procedures to an increase in social housing programs.
At the moment, there are around 250,000 people in Germany who have had their asylum applications rejected. Some people simply cannot be tracked down by authorities. But 200,000 of them can't be repatriated as there is either no country willing to take them in, or their country of origin is a war zone or they themselves have serious health issues that cannot be treated in their countries of origin.
Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Germany #Migration #Refugees
Germany will regret giving asylum to so many individuals who won't fit in into the german society and will build a parallel one which has totally different value set.
Its allready too late.
Aww. Desi vouching for Germans. How unsurprising. Germans actually treat Arab and Turk peasants (who are visually white) much better than Desi PhDs and Engineers.
Around 100 years from now and beyond, western countries will begin to look more and more like Lebanon. Absolutely nothing will save Europeans from this dilemma.
Yep but the west lost the war. We have had multiculturalism vs state with Rome v indigenous and Egypt v Judaism. Then we had State v State within Europe and between old and new western national systems. Then we had Zionism v The state with WW2 and the state lost that war. It’s the most lied about period in human history by far. The real victory went to something larger and more powerful than this world has ever seen. Now the west is largely controlled by those victors and it will continue to get worse for western citizens. The EU will break shortly as it is the last powerful non Big J controlled institution.
that's exactly what happened 20 years ago :)
I’ve never understood why asylum seekers need to be given permanent residency. If they’re fleeing persecution surely they can be helped without giving them citizenship.
Permanent residency is not the same as citizenship and does not confer the same rights. Moreover, while eligibility requirements for permanent residency are standardised across the EU, citizenship requirements are not. Each member state retains full control over its citizenship requirements and application process, and can choose whether or not to grant a citizenship application. Permanent residency is usually a prerequisite for citizenship, but does not guarantee or entitle the holder to citizenship.
@@DarkWanderer675 I don’t think they should be given either permanent residency or citizenship. Temporary leave to remain only until they can return to their country.
They should only be given free transport back to their country of origin.
@@livelife5947 while I fully agree with your point, for a lot of middle eastern countries "until they can return" might very well be never.
@johnbartholf777 No, they should work for the return tickets. So tired of native citizens paying for them.
It only took them 8 years to realize. What a shame but better late than never.
Yup what he said!
Agreed
Well said
They didn't do anything yet lmao
They said to limit, not stop it! They're not serious about it! It's time for a change!
"more hardline approach" they call this. It's not even an attempt at that.
Too-Iate. 8 million Ukrainians have arrived.
@@babblo1389 that quantity is is a problem but of all migr. groups those are the least worrisome
@@mistressfreezepeachyep. Russians and Ukrainians are ethnically and socially easily assimilated.
Sadly not so much for other ideological groups.
@@babblo1389 Stop spamming the same comment.
He has to, it's his job 😂@@Penta_Penguin_237
It is good to hold a candle for humanitarian causes, but don't let it burn your arm off.
Crocodile tears ? Or offer an equal chance to life?
At this point i dont think its good to hold a candle for humanitarian causes at all.
@@Splintzequal chance does not mean equal result. And that is a big problem.
True. I also think German diamond companies should pay triple the amount of taxes that they're paying now to provide fair payment to the African countries that they've historically taken advantage of that allowed them to build their economy to what it is today. It's only fair.
Iraq, Lybia, Syria etc who destroyed them?
As a woman living in EU, I don't want people here who don't share our values.
Watching thousands of "peaceful" Palestine supporters chanting pro Hamas slogans on the streets of Berlin has a sobering effect.
Talk about self sabotage 😂
They dont realize that millions are pro Israel!
Why would you import your enemies?
But everyone did...
Remember the slave trade.
Because you feel guilty for all inhumane things you have done to them
thats one thing. the main problem i have is that deportation doesnt happen enough. ignore our rules and laws - get out
Exactly! They're not serious about it! This new measures won't change much! They will just keep coming!
Germany get them out of there while you can!Save your country!
exactly! this rule definitely needs to be applied
Funny thing, now Europe understands why Trump wanted to build the wall. Well, guess Europeans are racists just like when they called Trump racist for wanting to secure the borders.
Hello👋👋
The EU should extradite the people smugglers. Put them behind bars and make an example out of them.
Have to give the EU more power then, nationalist politicians dont like that.
@@GleebyDawk EU barely has any power except what the EU council allows.
They say immigration is a human rights and that is the law especially people who are maltreated by thier government..but I think by this volume human rights should be ignore for host country people
True. We should do this to all the diamond companies that basically stole resources from Africa or paid pennies on the dollar for them. Justice for EVERYONE. 😊
Hello👋👋
Like stopping with smoking, when you already have lung cancer.
This is unreal. DW knows who people smugglers are. Local authorities don’t do anything about it and what does Europe do ? Just take everyone who comes in ? IT IS ABSURD
😂😂😂
Lol funny. Atleast they applied , when Germans invaded and colonized Namibia, they didn’t apply.
Uhhhh... let's be honest... both governments want it to happen. Tunisians may not want dissatisfied youth that can revolt and Europe is aging and facing catastrophic demographic collapse and the governments know it but people are in denial
@@dryusuf7246so colonialism good?
Hello👋👋
How to combat migration? "Build an architecture, legal certainty, binding rules and links in a chain"- Spanish politician. How do politicians get away by living an answer like this?
They don’t have an answer, they will just say some bs and do nothing
It's okay, I've been reassured that they have "mechanisms" in place. Also, they have been talking (in the strongest of terms) so we should be good! 🙃
those particular immigrants are potential voters for the politicians, so that's why politicians from certain groups will 'welcome' illegal immigrants more than others.
Hello👋👋
@@Gikkeoi hello👋👋
EU is unable or unwilling to effectively tackle this migration problem and these measures in Germany will achieve nothing. Migration to Europe from Africa is now seen as a desirable objective by increasing large numbers of people. Notwithstanding the Mediterranean and through Eastern Europe, there have been 32,000 land on Spain's Canary Islands from Senegal alone, and they will not stay in Spain when reaching the mainland..
Too-Iate. 8 million Ukrainians have arrived.
They will, simple because they have no choice. If they don’t, right wind parties will win elections and do it for them.
Therefore, stricter immigration & deportations are the only way.
If America is any indication of future events, people will continue to flood in who will vote directly or indirectly for open borders. Eventually it will be picked up and supported by a major party until the system is ready to collapse.
@@babblo1389arrive to what? Europe? The place they're already from for thousands of years? The place they share the same religion and a lot of the time even same ethnicities? Tankies will never not find a reason to whine.
@@babblo1389 True, in my country they have already made sure that the rent prices have skyrocketed and that there are far fewer options for housing in the cities. The problem is the governments like Germany and everyone else will only do something after the problem has been created instead of thinking ahead
Looks like Germany its tightening the screws, finally.
Not working😂😂 .it's too late
Millions are ready for next months😂
If you're fleeing a warzone with your wife and children, I can understand why temporary asylum is the right thing to do. The emphasis however is on families coming, and only temporarily. Giving citizenship to people who haven't entered through the proper citizenship processes is just wrong for the rest of us. I'm an American who is bidding for German citizenship and living in Germany, and I have to prove myself as an asset to German society. I came because I love German food, culture, and people. It's not fair that people don't have to go through such a hard process just because they're seeking "economic asylum". Economic asylum seekers should be deported en mass, you're not a family, you're not a woman or child, and you're not running from a warzone. You're a working or military age single man (far more often than not) who paid to be illegally smuggled into the country. If I try to smuggle goods on a plane into Germany, I get in huge trouble and, but if they smuggle in people it's just fine? How is any of that fair.
the Gvt is bringing this people to save them an for a cheaper labour, smugelers bring only a small percent
@@lzak72601don't forget their drigs to bring to them for they can get caught and scouff at the position.
Another great example of such prostigious stances they do have from spanish only stopping its legal prostitution once it was their women who were the majority.
Man Stop....I'm an American too...living in Germany...LOL you came here for the German Food??...then you came here for the wrong reason...food isn't that good here.🤣🤣..all jokes aside...I understand what you're sayin
relax. learn the language, study, stay on the right side of the law. you'll get in.
@@lzak72601 hello👋👋
About time, but the real question is what took so long and why
politicians didn't want to admit failure.
When it comes to germans it's money. It's always the money.
Due to Merkel's policy?
They said to limit, not to stop it! They're not serious about it! This new measures won't change much! Only a new government can solve the problem!
SPD is losing to the AfD over this issue
Arrest and deport!
Too late, too weak, too ineffective.
EHRC is the problem, it needs to be reformed. Both the convention and the adjudicating court
Hello👋👋
The eu should act like Australia
Hello👋
I agree with this comment. ❤
Giving so much money for asylum, but creating so many difficulties for foreign students who actually bring money from their home country
@geranienbaum you don’t get my point. I‘m not defining the foreigners student. But you just don’t know how difficult it is to extend your visa. I’m complaining about why they are given so much money to asylum. Why not focus on bringing or making more qualified workers. Why isn't the money being invested to make Germany more attractive to skilled/qualified foreign workers?
All EU should do the same.
Ok
Yeah just come to Europe for tourism. Not much there besides that.
Too little too late.
France desperatly needs this. The situation is far worse than in Germany but the government ignores the problem.
France is just reaping the consequences of colonization
why france desperatly needs this. This situation is doomed to be like this, since the colonie time. how to well manage it and turn it into advantages is the work politicians should work on
What goes around comes around. You’re paying for what your grandparents did to Africa
But France is still a colonial master!
Hello👋👋
It is also clear that European countries have assisted the people smugglers. European politicians have a great deal to answer for. They are in deed the problem.
Can you kindly explain it further?
@@malindaranatunge7848 Hungary, Austria, Serbia, Russia and Belarus.
Hello👋👋
@@malindaranatunge7848 hello 👋👋
@@leme5639 hello👋👋
They said to limit, not stop it and that's the problem! They're not serious about it! It's time for a change‼️
Hello👋👋
Lmao Europe is getting reverse colonized and they’re just like “okay 😔”
At least colonized countries in the past got new infrastructure and economic development (although the left doesn't like to talk about that)...while Europe is getting crimes, drug dealing, human trafficking and foreign mafias. Colonizers in the past brought new technology to terribly underdeveloped tribal countries, now Europe is being invaded by people having absolutely no skill or academic knowledge
Very smart this Mahmoud guy. He covered his face but not his body. He could be easily recognized by his scars. Living on this planet is never boring. Unfortunately Germany had its blls cut. They can't afford adopting the measures Poland or Hungary did without being labeled fascist.
That is old history. I'm American but think the German people have to take control even if that means the AFD. The Elite don't listen to the people. The German elite did this. Vote them out.
Too late. You are ruined
The CDU, the party of “We can cope” criticizing any party is hilarious!
The human traffickers who captain and sail the boats need to be put in prison for it.
Hello👋👋
If people know that they will be allowed to enter UE, they will depart and be willing to pay for the passage. It is so simple.
On the other hand, if someone comes to Australia illegally and asks for asylum, they’re locked in prison camps forever and never see any Australian city or village because the county’s immigration policy says that “if you come by boat, you will never settle in Australia”. So, after spending sometime in those camps and understanding that the policy doesn’t change, they beg to be returned to their country.
I would love this for Europe too. Closing borders is huge inconvenience for local people but this is the way some governments has decided to fight illegal migration. Leave the problem to Greece and Italy, we will be cool guys. Why should Europe be open for everyone that wants to come over here? !
Lol funny. Atleast they applied , when Germans invaded and colonized Namibia, they didn’t apply.
@@dryusuf7246 Namibians also did alot of bad things in the past i am sure, how do we punish them?
@@earlygrey1923 Europe can’t because they were the first people to migrate to Africa, so simple as that. What goes around comes around
@@Ismael_jagne who would stop us?😀
Words, words, words.
Don't believe any of them.
Those politician only care for appearence in order to stay relevant.
Oh dear AFD got you worried?
😅😂
Actions should be about the ones already in Germany including some ones who were granted the citizenship
Lol funny. Atleast they applied for asylum and citizenshin, when Germans invaded and colonized Namibia, they didn’t apply for anything.
They had weapons.
Hah German citizenship is one of the most hardest in the EU
Hello👋👋
That’s a sign of economic problems ahead
Oh well, they said the word “asylum”.
I guess that settles it…
.
Too late too little. Germany is screwed beyond repair at this point
Parelally check ground also if there is any tunnel network constructed or not
i think some countries can learn to adapt to the rules and norms of another country .however many countries today don´t want to adapt and bring their own customs and still think they deserve residency
Absolutely!
I'm from Asia with a Buddhist background and live in Germany for the past 20 years. I had absolutely no difficulties in getting integrated into the German society and had never any difficulties in embracing German values and the lifestyle.
Hello👋👋
@@royatapattu1 hello👋👋
i understand people wanting to move to other countries to improve their life ,but at the same time respect the country you are going to by embracing their culture ,learning their language ,and customs . However today alot of people don´t understand that
Some cultures think they're superior to others.
Thus they will never mix with the resident culture.
Finally Germany waking up! Better late than never! People coming legally and educated will feel more confident!
Lol!! When the hatred starts it grasps everyone. How will you know which one is which? I came as an engineer. What I see on the streets is hatred. I dnt see anyone asking me my degree or occupation before giving that terrible hateful stare. The thing is getting rid of illegal migration is a good step. But they are late and they are doing it with hate. They should have done earlier, before people getting pissed and hateful.
Hello👋👋
Camps that are concentrated?
about time...what took so long?
Nothing will change here, it is just hot air. Greetings from Germany
Too late, you are full of those losers 😂
How much extent will I, who am from SEA, be affected in student visa while studying abroad for Bachelor degree and seek to get the job there?
Don’t come here
@@phoenix2225 may I ask why?
@@phoenix2225my guy your body doesn't belong to you let alone your country. God calls his people to the land he wants.
none this is only for illegal immigrants, but if you keep idolizing europe and europeans boy you will get a bad surprise
Stop wasting my hard earned money in the upkeep of people who come to Germany just for the 500€ unemployment pay. Please 🙏
Nothing is going to change. There will maybe be some committee forming which will cost a lot of tax money.
Then they'll present an 10-issues plan for the next 5-10 years. They even may call it "agenda-something".
Then they will spend even more money for contracters for them actually write a detailed execution plan.
Which never will be executed because of budget cuts an some other catastrophic issue which then'll come along.
This is my pessimistic take.
My optimistic take: The'll just ask ChatGPT and spare is lots of money😂 And the result will be actually feasable...
Not enough money's
Wise Federal Governments invest heavily into their own native population first and secure their borders.
too little too late
The problem is that once you let people into your country they get to vote either directly or indirectly, they're on he same path as the u.s. just 10 years behind.
Hello👋👋
the problem is that germany has already a big shortage on living space, not talking affordable living space. we dont have enough space for more people, because our actual citizens are not getting enough living space. the sad thing is that we would NEED more migration, because germany is lacking skilled workers, academics and such. i would welcome everyone who wants to work here, hence everyone working here is paying their taxes here too. BUT we dont have enough living space right now and we're not building new ones fast enough. not even close.
Germany had also workers shortage. The rich commant politicians' decisions; cheap labor from illegal emigrants is a sweet deal for them. Why they accept them in.
I am a skilled immigrant and I discourage anyone to come here. Hate is in the air. And people do not ask me about my education and occupation before judging and hating me. We come here, work here and spend all our money to get what? Hatred!!
Feel free to leave
@@guusgeluk3693Nope. I have paid more taxes than you might have earned in your lifetime. So keep quiet. Of course I will leave. 50,000 skilled workers are leaving Germany every year. Don'T worry I will leave, but not because of your order. I will leave by choice.
@@sajidurrahman7903 leave as soon as you can please
I dont think most folks have any idea the correlation between immigration and a country’s economy
If they care that much then they should impose trade sanctions on Tunisia until they do something about it
Change your smoke alarm battery
once the internal problems increase , just shift focus on blaming foreigners 😂..nice strategy
I don’t get this. You are trying to curb irregular immigration, and you pay more to states for each asylum seeker? Is that not going to cause a tendency to have have more asylum seekers in state?
Nothing is going to change people are gullible.
So taxpayers' money will now be booked differently. What should this bring in the long run?
Can't the EU establish a kind of Patrol-line ; e.g. Say P.T-boats with super Radar equipments to put up on a Line from Gibraltar to - around - Port Said, Egypt ..
Would have already been implemented if not for Poland and Hungary vetoing it for the past 10 years or so.
........and have thwir factories shut down???? 😅😅😅
This reminds me of the film Danes with wolves, Kevin Costner were his asked by his friend the medicine man how many white people are coming.
He said like the stars in the sky there's millions coming from Africa, that's without the Arabs
"WI Chompi"! That's what he said to Kicking Bird.......WI Chompi............that being said, now Europe understands how the Native People's felt when they invaded their Lands! Turn about is fair play, dontcha think? And Europe FINALLY gets to pay the price! 😂
Nothing changed ... Theres more discourse now, but we are still accelerating towards a brick wall
That is an insane amount of blinking you are doing lady.
She met Blinken yesterday.
I think it’s a medical issue
If germany can do it why not the uk?
@@madapro03 the uk isn't stopped the pro-palestine protests in uk and it's getting out of hand the uk is too weak and useless and lazy against it
@@MarkPiccoloyes I’m terrified to go to parts of London now. It looks like Tehran
@@scarletsletter4466 London isn't London no more it's better to avoid that place for now on it's not a English city no more far from it
9:10 Keynotes. I doubt the points reported by the reporter EU even have those basic information or even close to handle illegal immigrant.
I won't believe any of the turnback vowes and deportation promises until we actually see them. Talking and acring on it are 2 seperate things.
Lol funny. Atleast they applied for asylum and citizenshin, when Germans invaded and colonized Namibia, they didn’t apply for anything.
They had weapons. 😂😂😂
Hypocrisy
I think the DW shouldn’t use Chancellor’s picture like that.
My daughter, who studies in Germany and works in a restaurant, experienced sexual harassment from a Syrian immigrant who worked as a cook.😭😭😭😭😭

There should be prison for short-sighted politicians.
Finally!
What these politicians talk will never happen
It really hurts to think that someone would pay 4000 Euros to emigrate to Europe, despite the sky-high chances that this journey would be the last in their life
😥😥
Its so simple, just give power to people. If someone want to take to own home imigrant let it be, that person or family should pay for language school and help find job, if that will not work, then that family will pay for ticket back to home country. Simple easy way.
Not a bad idea
Asylum seekers should speak German, they should go find work and pay tax. Why should they be exempt from all the things that "normal" immigrants endure?
Lol funny. Atleast they applied for asylum and citizenshin, when Germans invaded and colonized Namibia, they didn’t apply for anything.
They had weapons.
That's not an excuse. That is some low mentality
@@dryusuf7246so colonialism is good thing?
@@michaelarivony7409 rational mentality you mean.
True they should do all, like other immigrants.
But at the same time, Europe is making financial reparations for what they did many years ago.
Angry young men coming for revenge.
Already too late
Germany is the best in the world, it produces many 1st class lecturers with 0% economic growth! They go out everywhere in the world to lecture others even people are laughing privately. The best examples: Baerbock and von der leyen.
They are a joke.
It’s the third largest economy in the world.
@@andrewboyd6517third according to the IMF
@@Just_another_Euro_dude Germany is third. According to the IMF 2023y
These simps wishing the death of Europe better wake up. Germany is calling.
Don't forget, Germans don't make small mistakes!
Hope the US will follow.
Thank you Germnay
Awesome . China best nation
Too little. Too late. The problems have only begun.
The state will never be able to pay enough as each person has additional costs to society. Jobs, houses, healthcare criminal activity, food supply, water supply and additional power requirements are just some of the long term costs of increasing the popularity of a country.
Hello 👋👋
Don't forget their families when they come over.
If USA or Canada gives residency right to Germans, half of German engineers would run away.
Nope . None of them.. Chinese engineers don't move
What???
Only half
True. America knows business well, and knows how to pay its productive workers well.
I hate socialism. If your a doctor, engineer, programmer, or tradesmen, you get paid 3x more, and taxed 5x less in America.
Germany and Canada would rather start welfare programs for starbucks workers.
As a Canadian, Im making the move to the states. Trudeaus incompetent, and the government bloat here is high.
That dont mean Germany and Canada dont have its perks though.
I just prefer one system of government over the other.
Host of this video begins to feel nervous
Should be applied in the UK as well as
Enough, Europe is waking up.
Too late for Europe it is overwhelmed...but still good businesses for those European organisations who are encouraging mass migration of all sorts.
Doesn't ECHR apply to germany and france ? Funny how they just seem to change the goal post as n when it suits !!!!!!
They can get that close to him but couldn't arrest him on site 😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂
Millions are ready next everyday😂😂😂😂
OMG!!!
The garage shall be sent back to the native dumps
can you imagine a beauratic body actually working for the people of the country they serve. What a novel idea.
Dun worries! Singapore welcome!
I’m the guy’s in the white shorts fun! He’s so self-confident and poised, he even has his own philosophy on how to change history!
Is he wrong about history?
Lol no. My friend is immigrating next year and he doesn't even know the difference between "eminent" and "imminent".
Rip Germany
The main reason Germany has been allowing high immigration is the demographic issue. Alas, no one in government seems to feel it necessary to explain the fact that Germany needed 8 million immigrants - studies from 2010 - by 2030 to ensure that pensions can be paid and we are able to retain services at current levels.
The main reason the government has turned on its pro immigration stance is the fact that the AFD is growing in power and that there is the real risk of them losing the next elections. Recent polls suggest 20+% votes for the AFD, which will make it one of the strongest parties in Germany. Thus, like the UK with Brexit and the conservatives kowtowing to their right wing and the risks of the growing Brexit party, we’ve seen a shift by the present government.
The impact of a higher immigration base is being felt across the EU and the right is thus becoming stronger and stronger in many countries.
Alas this shift kinda reminds me of 100 years ago: wars, economic decline, the rise of extremer right wing politics.
Just saying
Hello👋
Do you expect a self-selecting people to fit in with your society's norm?
@@RUHappyATM to an extent, I do. The old proviso: When in Rome…, seems to make sense. Personally I’m half German and half English. In England I’m the kraut and in Germany I’m the Pomme… that’s how others see me… and there are fairly large differences between these nationalities, however not as large as got someone non European and/or different religious outlook.
I love Londons diversity and international base… however it’s got to a point now that over 60% are non British Londoner’s and the city is struggling to accommodate all the different back grounds into something people can identify with.
Germanys first bout of immigration was in the 60s/70s and it took 1..2 generations for the local German born Turks to fully “fit” into German society.
End of the day it is a given countries culture that one is entering. A culture that respects you and your rights for various freedoms. However with freedom comes responsibility and part of that is to become part of the society that one lives in.
I know there is no “one size fits all” solution… it just isn’t an easy topic and many individual interests need to be taken into consideration.
8:30 what he said? good to know "brother"