I wouldn't call it ignorance exactly but a sort of self-imposed and group induced ideology that requires a delusion an ignoring of reality to hold that ideology.
As a trained geneticist and cytogeneticist I 100% support her. I have looked down the microscope thousands and times, looked at thousands of scans and instrument outputs and never have I seen "gender" but always have I seen SEX.
@@StevieTiller-ze5yfPROTECT CHILDREN FROM WHAT? YOU MUST BE KIDDING. HAVE YOU BEEN LIVING UNDER A ROCK GO READ THE CASS REPORT SHAME ON YOU ITS CHILDREN BEING HARMED AND BANG.... CENSORSHIP IN THE PARLIAMENT WE NEED TO HIDE THE ABUSE. ruclips.net/video/H9c118CAsOU/видео.html
Bravo, Sophia, from Scotland. I cannot believe the loud refusals you received when you requested to present scientific evidence from Cass. Ideologies only survive when facts are suppressed and questions are forbidden. The more we expose the truth and continue to question the misinformation, the weaker the ideology becomes. ❤
Fantastic speech, given calmly and showing great compassion for all people and their struggles. What a bunch of ignorant jerks to deny this motion. How on earth did such oddballs, who care nothing for women, children, people suffering from mental, sexual or other problems, get elected in the first place. They should be named and made to explain why they reject this motion.
Fantastic speech that couldn't be made even a couple of years ago when we were in "peak woke" and her delivery would have been shut down, and/or this video removed.
Fantastic speech, shame on the men who deny truth, reality and decency. I can't help wondering, given how quickly and vehemently they said 'no', if some of them are indeed AGPs themselves. For what other reason would their denial be so strong?
Get educated, well what do I expect from a country that was at the bidding of the UK because you didn't have enough to stand on your own. At least the UK is becoming a failed state, Well when Putin marches through I guess you will be out waving flags, aye!
And you know this because you somehow know every other body in the world and how they should feel. Amazing, sounds like father Xmas everywhere at the same time.damn amazing….or you are just one of those that want everyone else to bow to your superior opinions, damn straight!
Well said. The calmest clearest speech I have seen on this issue. Shame on the members who denied you tabling of the 2 reports. Do they believe ignorance is bliss.
The Cass report took 4 years to complete, the UK parliament has stopped giving kids puberty blockers because of it, but the WA parliament won’t even look at it!! USA and UK will pass Roger Cook all their left over puberty blockers because they’ve come to their senses. I’m sure this will be the big election winner for Labor 🏆 Great speech Sophia!
Hilary Cass said no one should come off their medical regimen if they are currently benefitting. You've taken it out of context and removed any nuance.
Can someone explain what happens at 4:00 when the chairman states that the member "seeks leave to table two documents" and a couple of random voices are heard, yet immediately the chairman states "leave is not granted"? Is this the "heckler's veto"? No roll was called, no votes counted... the chairman just acquiesced almost immediately because a couple of members shouted something?
Wonderful to hear such a dispassionate and clear speech on the subject. Thank you Sophia Moermond. Pity about the naysayers who are intent on damaging children and ignoring adults' mental health issues. Science deniers.
Excellent statement. Calm, cool, collected, smart, smart, smart. Incredible that some of them wouldn't at least feign impartiality by accepting the documents. But so glad others said "yes." Bravo. Thank you.
Children that are afraid and confused as they enter puberty, wanting to escape the fear of their developing sexuality, have now been handed these horrific options that might provide short term relief but with life long negativity and side effects.
I generally love Australia & Australians. I've often said that if I could live anywhere in the English speaking world it would be Australia. In recent times though it seems Australia has lost its attributes of factual & common sense when it comes to subjects like this.
Take everything away from people for over a year. Economy, lifestyle - all of it and what do you get. I am amazed at what we have seen since the shut-down of work and life.
"People brought up eating unnatural food develop into artificial, anti-natural human beings with an unnatural body prone to disease and an unnatural way of thinking. There exists the frightful possibility that the transfiguration of agriculture may result in the perversion of far more than just agriculture." -Masanobu Fukuoka, The Natural Way of Farming "Annual agriculture is all about living through our [false] concepts... we can never input enough to make our false concept correct." ruclips.net/user/clipUgkxQPUJ50mdLoffCtSHRsBaMZZhfydMAKEH
If I understand rightly the term "to table a document" I wonder why there would be objection. Does it mean parliamentary members are obliged to discuss it? Do you have a link to these two documents?
No one has any respect. Running around, talking. The British parliament seems like such a bad place to me. Shouting. So weird for a country like UK. Agree with everything she said.
she is in Australia. But I agree, it was disrespectful. It was as thought they knew what she was going to say (which is not truly possible unless she released the text of her speech first) and they discounted it - and her. That’s downright insulting.
@@pamelaroyce5285 They had no prior access to my speech but I have spoken about gender ideology before. Their issue is with me, even though I was speaking the truth. Facts are simply facts.
@@sophiamoermondmlc8576 I thank you from the bottom of my heart for standing up for us women and children . The misogony is even worse today than 100 years ago. At that time, no one tried to take our woman hood from us, men just wouldn't let us share power. Now these sick men want to erase us. And look at how those men behind you, disrespected you. I mean, one WOULD think it was 100 years ago.
It would have been a lot easier to watch if the rude men weren’t walking around you, leaving and talking: edit it was a great speech. What’s with them not allowing you to submit your papers?
If people can be born in the wrong body maybe they could take a boy who thinks he's a girl and a girl who thinks she's a boy and do a cross brain transplant? Save all that messy butchery of body parts? The surgery could be done by a butcher's apprentice who self-identifies as a brain surgeon.... 🤔
Exactly. Picture this scenario. Some man tells me that he self-identifies as a woman and I respond that he is NOT a woman. What do you think would be his reaction? Most likely screaming rage and adamant insistence that self-identity is valid. Then at some point he happens to develop a brain tumour. I then walk up to him and say that I self-identify as a brain surgeon, so I will perform brain surgery on him. What do you think would be his reaction?.
I blame Michel Foucault, I blame John Money, and I blame Judith Butler. And I blame everyone who has decided that virtue-signalling is more importantly than facts.
You are born with their hair you are born with. You can change it momentarily with chemicals, but it will continue to come out of your head the color it was meant to be.
It would be funny if something THAT superficial and insignificant as "hair colour" had similar implications like, ehm, sex. Like the difference between the ability to impregnate someone or getting pregnant. You can't change THAT - not even on a superficial level. Gender ideology really shows how massively stupid, gullible, cowardly and superficial people are -but at the same time thinking of themselves as "being the nice/tolerant/inclusive ones". Sex is real, get over it!
It is encouraging to hear the facts presented so simply and shame on them for refusing to table the scientific documentation. Imagine if anorexia or bulimia were treated as the present social contagion? We would have been told as parents that we should put a padlock on the fridge and pantry doors and only allow our delusional kids to eat a handful of rice crackers every few days or suck on half an apple every week. This would be our way of showing affirmation, a way to show we really only want a skinny child, right?
Treatment is not decided on the basis of "self diagnosis" as then if that were true there would be no doctor, psychologist, or psychiatrist involved which is required to obtain the medication you list. You could furthermore make the case that gays and lesbians would be unhappy because they grossly misuse their body parts and have "sexualized" their ideal self as a future partner. Either way you want to "grease the wheel" and "sharpen the blade" and take an ax to any medical or marriage rights either group has obtained over the last 50 years. Furthermore, I'm an adult who uses gender medicine because simply put I want to look like I was when I was a boy while I still have hair on my head. I was castrated and use low dose estrogen. I've even lowered my cholesterol, blood pressure, and triglycerides with this regimen without any medical harm over the last 15 years. Jeff Landry, the conservative Louisiana governor, has said this treatment can be used without any medical harm for paroled sex offenders. My question to you is, why do I need to commit a felony to get a treatment my doctor has effectively provided me over the last 15 years?
@@sophiamoermondmlc8576 If someone doesn't accept their secondary sex traits during or after puberty, that's not accepting one's development. If they go on cross HRT to attempt to undo that first development and they subsequently improve mentally, then they are taking the right steps to have the desired sex traits. Gender medicine can provide sex trait modification much like proper diet can provide a reasonable weight. Furthermore most people who have gender dysphoria try to curtail their first development through protein and calorie restriction so they don't fill out in their natal sex with wider hips for females, wider chest, and advanced height for males, etc. People who are dysphoric don't want to go further into their natal sex's development much like you don't want to become an old lady with mobility issues. Sometimes there's smaller issues like breast reduction or augmentation for people who are born the sex they identify with. We believe in existentialism and making our own destiny and currently you are standing in the way of that. Personally I've improved for 15 years and now socialize when between ages 15-34, I didn't. I went to therapy for almost 20 years prior and met with medical rejection until one psychologist signed off on my treatment. I first presented to health care professionals at 15 after my identity permanently formed by 12.5. I wasn't treated until mid 30's with medicine. Are you planning on applying the same argument for birth control, vaccines, and SSRI's as well and gaslight patients who are improving under doctor's care? RFK Jr. and religious fundamentalists have no problem with letting nature take it's course and if one has to live with untreated gender dysphoria, Aids, measles, untreated depression, or children they can't afford, then so be it. It's not their problem and they have a mandate to rule! This attitude is unsustainable and as I've shown, it permeates to other forms of medicine and goes other places. Let a patient and their doctor decide. If there is any mistreatment, there is private litigation.
that should encompass young adults too.... their brains are not develop till late 20s.. In fact, why should anyone have surgery and cross-hormones instead of learning how to cope and love their body
Actually this was unproven in the early 60's when it was removed from the Mental health diagnostics , but what do I expect from people who have a heavy Neanderthal genetics ....too bad that the homo sapiens of your tribe mated with them. It shows in your limited ability to think
Scientific proof for that has existed for more than 20 years. Of course you can be born in the wrong body. People with AIS (Androgen Immunity Syndrome) are people wirh an XY chromosome, so theoretically male. But due to an immunity to testosterone, they grow up in female bodies (without internal reproductive organs). But they don't suffer as much as X-women, women with just one X chromosome. Also infertile, but suffer horribly as the are set up as extremel feminine with an incredible wish to be morhers, but they can't.
Talkin from ignorance. Have you EVER met or talked to a Transgender person about their journey or struggles? I was born in the wrong body. I had not been traumatised, sexually abused, and nor were my parents homophobes. I do not have Autogynephilia. I lived in depression for 50 years that has been alleviated since I transitioned. I have lost over 30kg since I transitioned because I am finally happy! The Cass report is failed science simply as IT DID NOT TALK TO ANY TRANGENDERED PEOPLE. A report about a group of people that did not study the people that the report is about! Thank you to the members who objected re tabling the report
Gender distress is real, but no one can be allowed to get away with undermining the excellent Cass report in the UK. Every word this politician says is true. We don't have to take people's word about who they say they are. Society must decide on the best treatment for transgender patients.
The Cass Review is 122 pages and is available online. Did you read it for yourself or are you just spouting someone else's talking points? Because you evidently skipped page 45. It's clear through out that not only were trans individuals with lived experience consulted but their families, medical professionals, support and advocacy groups as well. You should be treated with dignity and respect but you also deserve evidence based treatment. It's also clear that although adults can do as they please children are not capable of making long term decisions that can leave them mutilated and sterilized while turning them into lifelong pharmaceutical patients.
No one can be "born in the wrong body", our brains ARE our body just as much as any other part of it. We are the sex we are, regardless of what our personal relationship is with the sexist stereotypes in society. "Trans" ideology, is regressive and sexist, as there is no "correct way" of being a boy or girl, man or woman, all those terms do is indicate sex and stage of maturity - decoupling sex and gender and trying to make gender into this ludicrous concoction of personality and sexist stereotypes is beyond regressive - it actively harms people who buy into it - the idea that there is something wrong with a kid's body that needs to be chemically altered because they believe living up to sexist stereotypes is some real measure of whether they are a boy or a girl (and man or woman for adults obviously), is insanity. Explain what specific standards “trans” people are measuring themselves against to determine that there is a "mismatch" - THEY are the ones with a regressively sexist idea of what it means to be a boy/girl or man/woman and that is the issue causing all the problems - their own misunderstanding and severely limited perspective/sexist misunderstanding of what sexist stereotypes/"gender norms" actually entail - they are not rules, they are not real boundaries, they are regressive ideas and generalisations - no one needs to live up to any such nonsense or feel comfortable with those stereotypes to be a boy/girl/man/woman - all those terms represent, and all they should represent, is sex and stage of maturity - by creating this whole "gender identity" nonsense they create an unnecessary distorted framework which needlessly causes distress. How are men or women "supposed” to think or feel, want to dress like or act? You must be able to provide specific standards for each sex for what you are contending to make any sense whatsoever. If there is no correct way of being a man or a woman, then how can there be a "mismatch" between what they are and how they feel? How can anyone “identify” as something you cannot even define? Female rights and protections are sex-based. Why should males be allowed to "identify" into spaces and activities exclusively reserved for the opposite sex?
Did you ever consider going into psychotherapy to understand WHY you feel you were born into the wrong body? Though you claim not to have had a traumatic childhood, it is curious that the majority of people who claim to be trans grew up under highly dysfunctional circumstances.
@@nomnom4225 So you've taken the next step and decided as a voter that this adult person who is improving on their regimen needs to come off because you don't like transgenders in sports. Are birth control, vaccines, SSRI's, IVF, tubal ligation, and vasectomies next? You put us a dangerous position because we have nothing left to lose. Hilary Cass said there was not enough evidence to support gender medicine for adolescents and that no patient should be taken off their regimen based on the report.
I would like to congratulate this woman for having the courage to state facts in the face of ignorance.
Add you got your degree from where? hide your bigotry and cruelty and denial of what you really are
@@francishooper9548 thank you 🙏
💯 ❤
I wouldn't call it ignorance exactly but a sort of self-imposed and group induced ideology that requires a delusion an ignoring of reality to hold that ideology.
As a trained geneticist and cytogeneticist I 100% support her. I have looked down the microscope thousands and times, looked at thousands of scans and instrument outputs and never have I seen "gender" but always have I seen SEX.
I have seen genitalia.
A biological term.
Excellent presentation, 100% truth, succinct, calmly delivered. Thank you, Sophia Moermond. Appreciating your work to protect children.
You mean condemn children....So sorry that you hide your true desires and you are ashamed of what you are
Protect children from what ?
Do enlighten us , it would be clergy would it ?
@@StevieTiller-ze5yf Protect children from any ideology that harms their natural bodies and limits their futures.
@@StevieTiller-ze5yfPROTECT CHILDREN FROM WHAT? YOU MUST BE KIDDING. HAVE YOU BEEN LIVING UNDER A ROCK GO READ THE CASS REPORT SHAME ON YOU ITS CHILDREN BEING HARMED AND BANG.... CENSORSHIP IN THE PARLIAMENT WE NEED TO HIDE THE ABUSE. ruclips.net/video/H9c118CAsOU/видео.html
@@StevieTiller-ze5yfstop playing stupid or maybe you are.
Bravo, Sophia, from Scotland. I cannot believe the loud refusals you received when you requested to present scientific evidence from Cass. Ideologies only survive when facts are suppressed and questions are forbidden. The more we expose the truth and continue to question the misinformation, the weaker the ideology becomes. ❤
🙌 ❤
Great speech!!!
Fantastic speech, given calmly and showing great compassion for all people and their struggles. What a bunch of ignorant jerks to deny this motion. How on earth did such oddballs, who care nothing for women, children, people suffering from mental, sexual or other problems, get elected in the first place. They should be named and made to explain why they reject this motion.
Brilliant! You nailed it
Who said no at the end? Name and shame. That speech was simple, calm and truthful.... so who said no? Need to know so we don't vote them back in.
WoW you are the essence of what is evil and misleading in this world
@@rymkervic123456 Labor and the Greens were loudest. I am unsure about the opposition or others on the cross bench.
@@sophiamoermondmlc8576get labour out asap😢😢 and conservatives didn't do anything while they were in power either. They are all the same🙈
Keep up the good work. Dripping water wares away stone❤
Excellent summary.
Fantastic speech that couldn't be made even a couple of years ago when we were in "peak woke" and her delivery would have been shut down, and/or this video removed.
Fantastic speech, shame on the men who deny truth, reality and decency. I can't help wondering, given how quickly and vehemently they said 'no', if some of them are indeed AGPs themselves. For what other reason would their denial be so strong?
Get educated, well what do I expect from a country that was at the bidding of the UK because you didn't have enough to stand on your own. At least the UK is becoming a failed state, Well when Putin marches through I guess you will be out waving flags, aye!
All those male voices saying No😢
More upsettingly, the first and the loudest voice was definitely a female 😢
The patience you have displayed here is absolutely spectacular.
No one is born in the wrong body - damn right!
And you know this because you somehow know every other body in the world and how they should feel. Amazing, sounds like father Xmas everywhere at the same time.damn amazing….or you are just one of those that want everyone else to bow to your superior opinions, damn straight!
Well said. The calmest clearest speech I have seen on this issue. Shame on the members who denied you tabling of the 2 reports. Do they believe ignorance is bliss.
Cosmetic treatments to treat mental health issues makes as much sense as liposuction to treat obesity.
Denial of the Cass Review equals denial of reality. Perfect job for politicians.
What an intelligent and courageous woman. Much admiration from Canada.
Yeh, look at all those politicians leaving the chamber while she's speaking. Disgusting.
wonder how much pharma lobbies them.......
Well done senator. Well done. You have done your reseach. I applauud you. Peace and love to you
Thank you so much for speaking the truth……, ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS SPEECH……….HOLD THE LINE ❤……….PROTECT CHILDREN & WOMENS SPACES FROM PERVERTS.
@@julietteusmar4446 Sounds like you are holding the line too. Thank you for your bravery 😊
The Cass report took 4 years to complete, the UK parliament has stopped giving kids puberty blockers because of it, but the WA parliament won’t even look at it!! USA and UK will pass Roger Cook all their left over puberty blockers because they’ve come to their senses. I’m sure this will be the big election winner for Labor 🏆 Great speech Sophia!
Hilary Cass said no one should come off their medical regimen if they are currently benefitting. You've taken it out of context and removed any nuance.
Well said! 👏
Can someone explain what happens at 4:00 when the chairman states that the member "seeks leave to table two documents" and a couple of random voices are heard, yet immediately the chairman states "leave is not granted"? Is this the "heckler's veto"? No roll was called, no votes counted... the chairman just acquiesced almost immediately because a couple of members shouted something?
@@robws007 I was giving a member’s statement versus a motion to lead a debate.
they refuse to table the truth
So perfectly and succinctly put! Well done. Pure facts. Can’t be argued with.
What the hell is going on in the background?? Can't they show respect for the speaker? And sit the f*** down?!?
Thank you for this.
Wonderful to hear such a dispassionate and clear speech on the subject. Thank you Sophia Moermond. Pity about the naysayers who are intent on damaging children and ignoring adults' mental health issues. Science deniers.
Excellent statement. Calm, cool, collected, smart, smart, smart.
Incredible that some of them wouldn't at least feign impartiality by accepting the documents. But so glad others said "yes." Bravo.
Thank you.
This needs more views
💯
Thank you for standing up for the safety of girls/women ❤️❤️❤️
Children that are afraid and confused as they enter puberty, wanting to escape the fear of their developing sexuality, have now been handed these horrific options that might provide short term relief but with life long negativity and side effects.
A valiant effort. Thank you for trying.
This woman 100 %right , not afraid to speak the truth
This puts the distressed closer to getting the care and suppirt they need ❤❤❤
How are they able to stop you presenting evidence
@@geraldcoffey3303 apparently those are the rules. Imagine being this wilfully ignorant for everyone to see yet not be embarrassed.
I generally love Australia & Australians. I've often said that if I could live anywhere in the English speaking world it would be Australia. In recent times though it seems Australia has lost its attributes of factual & common sense when it comes to subjects like this.
Shame on the person who said No.
@@DK-yq5nx that’s the Greens and Labour.
"on sex-based stereotypes" ... BRAVA! AT LAST someone says it as it is!
Take everything away from people for over a year. Economy, lifestyle - all of it and what do you get. I am amazed at what we have seen since the shut-down of work and life.
Well done.
Good work! There's really no need to debate this issue...
God created a man and a woman.. full stop. End of discussion.
"People brought up eating unnatural food develop into artificial, anti-natural human beings with an unnatural body prone to disease and an unnatural way of thinking. There exists the frightful possibility that the transfiguration of agriculture may result in the perversion of far more than just agriculture." -Masanobu Fukuoka, The Natural Way of Farming
"Annual agriculture is all about living through our [false] concepts... we can never input enough to make our false concept correct." ruclips.net/user/clipUgkxQPUJ50mdLoffCtSHRsBaMZZhfydMAKEH
If I understand rightly the term "to table a document" I wonder why there would be objection. Does it mean parliamentary members are obliged to discuss it?
Do you have a link to these two documents?
Hear, hear.
Would like to know which members voted 'No' the tabling the document !?
@@Max-ht9hf I’m not entirely sure but definitely Brad Pettitt from the Greens and the Labor party.
She's totally right. Therapy first.
she makes some very valid points. keep up the struggle ma'am 💙
No one has any respect. Running around, talking. The British parliament seems like such a bad place to me. Shouting. So weird for a country like UK. Agree with everything she said.
she is in Australia. But I agree, it was disrespectful. It was as thought they knew what she was going to say (which is not truly possible unless she released the text of her speech first) and they discounted it - and her. That’s downright insulting.
@@pamelaroyce5285Everyone knows the truth of what she says, but they are intimidated by activists who threaten their careers.
@@pamelaroyce5285 They had no prior access to my speech but I have spoken about gender ideology before. Their issue is with me, even though I was speaking the truth. Facts are simply facts.
@@pamelaroyce5285 I should have picked up on the language. I thought the seats were those of the British parliament.
@@sophiamoermondmlc8576 I thank you from the bottom of my heart for standing up for us women and children
. The misogony is even worse today than 100 years ago. At that time, no one tried to take our woman hood from us, men just wouldn't let us share power. Now these sick men want to erase us. And look at how those men behind you, disrespected you. I mean, one WOULD think it was 100 years ago.
It would have been a lot easier to watch if the rude men weren’t walking around you, leaving and talking: edit it was a great speech. What’s with them not allowing you to submit your papers?
@@msbecks7004 they are entirely captured by gender ideology.
This is the truth, plain and simple.
If people can be born in the wrong body maybe they could take a boy who thinks he's a girl and a girl who thinks she's a boy and do a cross brain transplant? Save all that messy butchery of body parts? The surgery could be done by a butcher's apprentice who self-identifies as a brain surgeon.... 🤔
Exactly. Picture this scenario. Some man tells me that he self-identifies as a woman and I respond that he is NOT a woman. What do you think would be his reaction? Most likely screaming rage and adamant insistence that self-identity is valid. Then at some point he happens to develop a brain tumour. I then walk up to him and say that I self-identify as a brain surgeon, so I will perform brain surgery on him. What do you think would be his reaction?.
I blame Michel Foucault, I blame John Money, and I blame Judith Butler. And I blame everyone who has decided that virtue-signalling is more importantly than facts.
@@drmitchelltulau671 and porn.
No one can be born with the wrong hair colour. No one can change their hair colour.
You can change the colour but not the hair. It's like makeup, cloth and cosmetics.
You are born with their hair you are born with. You can change it momentarily with chemicals, but it will continue to come out of your head the color it was meant to be.
@@Viracocha88 Exactly.
It would be funny if something THAT superficial and insignificant as "hair colour" had similar implications like, ehm, sex. Like the difference between the ability to impregnate someone or getting pregnant. You can't change THAT - not even on a superficial level.
Gender ideology really shows how massively stupid, gullible, cowardly and superficial people are -but at the same time thinking of themselves as "being the nice/tolerant/inclusive ones".
Sex is real, get over it!
Hurray Sophia! At last, facts and common sense. 😁
It is encouraging to hear the facts presented so simply and shame on them for refusing to table the scientific documentation.
Imagine if anorexia or bulimia were treated as the present social contagion? We would have been told as parents that we should put a padlock on the fridge and pantry doors and only allow our delusional kids to eat a handful of rice crackers every few days or suck on half an apple every week. This would be our way of showing affirmation, a way to show we really only want a skinny child, right?
Brilliant. 😁 so clear and factual.
Wow, they would allow the gold standard Cass review to be tabled!? Shameful 😮
@@Lou-Lou-pop science deniers.
Important message and well presented!
I like you a lot, you are brilliant. Thank you!
💜🤍💚
Who tells children they are gay.
Good Day. Now how do get around the Luciferins and cohorts?
👏👏👏🙌👍🏼gender confusion!
Treatment is not decided on the basis of "self diagnosis" as then if that were true there would be no doctor, psychologist, or psychiatrist involved which is required to obtain the medication you list. You could furthermore make the case that gays and lesbians would be unhappy because they grossly misuse their body parts and have "sexualized" their ideal self as a future partner. Either way you want to "grease the wheel" and "sharpen the blade" and take an ax to any medical or marriage rights either group has obtained over the last 50 years.
Furthermore, I'm an adult who uses gender medicine because simply put I want to look like I was when I was a boy while I still have hair on my head. I was castrated and use low dose estrogen. I've even lowered my cholesterol, blood pressure, and triglycerides with this regimen without any medical harm over the last 15 years. Jeff Landry, the conservative Louisiana governor, has said this treatment can be used without any medical harm for paroled sex offenders. My question to you is, why do I need to commit a felony to get a treatment my doctor has effectively provided me over the last 15 years?
@@DorianPaige00 please provide proof that people can be born in the wrong body. Thank you 🙏
@@sophiamoermondmlc8576 If someone doesn't accept their secondary sex traits during or after puberty, that's not accepting one's development. If they go on cross HRT to attempt to undo that first development and they subsequently improve mentally, then they are taking the right steps to have the desired sex traits. Gender medicine can provide sex trait modification much like proper diet can provide a reasonable weight. Furthermore most people who have gender dysphoria try to curtail their first development through protein and calorie restriction so they don't fill out in their natal sex with wider hips for females, wider chest, and advanced height for males, etc. People who are dysphoric don't want to go further into their natal sex's development much like you don't want to become an old lady with mobility issues. Sometimes there's smaller issues like breast reduction or augmentation for people who are born the sex they identify with. We believe in existentialism and making our own destiny and currently you are standing in the way of that.
Personally I've improved for 15 years and now socialize when between ages 15-34, I didn't. I went to therapy for almost 20 years prior and met with medical rejection until one psychologist signed off on my treatment. I first presented to health care professionals at 15 after my identity permanently formed by 12.5. I wasn't treated until mid 30's with medicine. Are you planning on applying the same argument for birth control, vaccines, and SSRI's as well and gaslight patients who are improving under doctor's care?
RFK Jr. and religious fundamentalists have no problem with letting nature take it's course and if one has to live with untreated gender dysphoria, Aids, measles, untreated depression, or children they can't afford, then so be it. It's not their problem and they have a mandate to rule! This attitude is unsustainable and as I've shown, it permeates to other forms of medicine and goes other places. Let a patient and their doctor decide. If there is any mistreatment, there is private litigation.
👏👏👏👏👏👏
that should encompass young adults too.... their brains are not develop till late 20s.. In fact, why should anyone have surgery and cross-hormones instead of learning how to cope and love their body
Underlying reasons
Bull's eye!
👏 👏 👏 👏 ❤
Those men are so rude.
@@carolinejamieson1402 💯
There's no such thing as "born in the wrong body"
@@sarahainscough6264 physically impossible.
No one know why the body is born one sex and the inward gender is opposite but it is real. However God knows and we should work within his will.
Did I get this right ( I am germna ) , that this Lady wasn ´t allowed to leave a paper with scientific evidence to proof her point ?
@@WMeier-kd8hz that is correct. I wasn’t allowed to table the Cass review and another paper.
@ Thank you for taking the time to answer and for upholding the stansards of democracy.
👍👏👏👏👏👏👏
Who is this person ? How did she did she sneak her way into parliament, is she an endocrinologist ?
@@StevieTiller-ze5yf as much of an endocrinologist as men are women.
Shame you're talking to the closed minded. Great work.
Find the gut brain axis, find the answer
“…proves they have mental health issues…” Communicating something unusual proves a “mental health issue.” Explain please.
Actually this was unproven in the early 60's when it was removed from the Mental health diagnostics , but what do I expect from people who have a heavy Neanderthal genetics ....too bad that the homo sapiens of your tribe mated with them. It shows in your limited ability to think
It is not simply 'unusual', it is dysfunctional and, since it is an ideation, must be viewed as a mental health issue.
@ What is an “ideation”
@ Can it be asymptomatic? That is, independent of the person’s communication of said “disorder?”
Scientific proof for that has existed for more than 20 years. Of course you can be born in the wrong body. People with AIS (Androgen Immunity Syndrome) are people wirh an XY chromosome, so theoretically male. But due to an immunity to testosterone, they grow up in female bodies (without internal reproductive organs). But they don't suffer as much as X-women, women with just one X chromosome. Also infertile, but suffer horribly as the are set up as extremel feminine with an incredible wish to be morhers, but they can't.
@@terribrad24 those are certainly words.
Follow the science, sure just not Cass quackery.
Why are you calling the Cass report quackery?
Talkin from ignorance. Have you EVER met or talked to a Transgender person about their journey or struggles? I was born in the wrong body. I had not been traumatised, sexually abused, and nor were my parents homophobes. I do not have Autogynephilia. I lived in depression for 50 years that has been alleviated since I transitioned. I have lost over 30kg since I transitioned because I am finally happy! The Cass report is failed science simply as IT DID NOT TALK TO ANY TRANGENDERED PEOPLE. A report about a group of people that did not study the people that the report is about! Thank you to the members who objected re tabling the report
Gender distress is real, but no one can be allowed to get away with undermining the excellent Cass report in the UK. Every word this politician says is true. We don't have to take people's word about who they say they are. Society must decide on the best treatment for transgender patients.
The Cass Review is 122 pages and is available online. Did you read it for yourself or are you just spouting someone else's talking points? Because you evidently skipped page 45. It's clear through out that not only were trans individuals with lived experience consulted but their families, medical professionals, support and advocacy groups as well. You should be treated with dignity and respect but you also deserve evidence based treatment. It's also clear that although adults can do as they please children are not capable of making long term decisions that can leave them mutilated and sterilized while turning them into lifelong pharmaceutical patients.
No one can be "born in the wrong body", our brains ARE our body just as much as any other part of it. We are the sex we are, regardless of what our personal relationship is with the sexist stereotypes in society. "Trans" ideology, is regressive and sexist, as there is no "correct way" of being a boy or girl, man or woman, all those terms do is indicate sex and stage of maturity - decoupling sex and gender and trying to make gender into this ludicrous concoction of personality and sexist stereotypes is beyond regressive - it actively harms people who buy into it - the idea that there is something wrong with a kid's body that needs to be chemically altered because they believe living up to sexist stereotypes is some real measure of whether they are a boy or a girl (and man or woman for adults obviously), is insanity.
Explain what specific standards “trans” people are measuring themselves against to determine that there is a "mismatch" - THEY are the ones with a regressively sexist idea of what it means to be a boy/girl or man/woman and that is the issue causing all the problems - their own misunderstanding and severely limited perspective/sexist misunderstanding of what sexist stereotypes/"gender norms" actually entail - they are not rules, they are not real boundaries, they are regressive ideas and generalisations - no one needs to live up to any such nonsense or feel comfortable with those stereotypes to be a boy/girl/man/woman - all those terms represent, and all they should represent, is sex and stage of maturity - by creating this whole "gender identity" nonsense they create an unnecessary distorted framework which needlessly causes distress.
How are men or women "supposed” to think or feel, want to dress like or act? You must be able to provide specific standards for each sex for what you are contending to make any sense whatsoever. If there is no correct way of being a man or a woman, then how can there be a "mismatch" between what they are and how they feel? How can anyone “identify” as something you cannot even define?
Female rights and protections are sex-based. Why should males be allowed to "identify" into spaces and activities exclusively reserved for the opposite sex?
Did you ever consider going into psychotherapy to understand WHY you feel you were born into the wrong body? Though you claim not to have had a traumatic childhood, it is curious that the majority of people who claim to be trans grew up under highly dysfunctional circumstances.
@@nomnom4225 So you've taken the next step and decided as a voter that this adult person who is improving on their regimen needs to come off because you don't like transgenders in sports. Are birth control, vaccines, SSRI's, IVF, tubal ligation, and vasectomies next? You put us a dangerous position because we have nothing left to lose. Hilary Cass said there was not enough evidence to support gender medicine for adolescents and that no patient should be taken off their regimen based on the report.
Brilliant, thank you!
❤