No contest. How could it be? The Show was basically a documentation of Charlie Sheens life. Berta, Rose, Alan - they all played their parts really great, but Charlie was the heart of the show. Walden could not touch him.
@@margaretlatocha1474 Charlie never delivered. It was the same Charlie sheen we’ve always seen. He was lame on Spin City and he was lame here. Ashton made the show a lot better
@@1UpChuck- Chuck Lorre pbly just kept the show going just to say to Charlie sheen "i don't need you" even though the show wasn't funny and people weren't watching it
It didn't end because of that, the show had gone on for 12 years, it was expected to end, a few seasons after Kutcher's arrival, he joined the show pretty late.
Here is an easy way to break down this 'Charlie vs Walden... - With Charlie, you just had fun with whatever he was doing and were always excited to see what he was going to do next. - With Walden, you don't care what he was doing and only paid attention to whoever he is interacting with.
I like Walden, but Charlie will always be my favorite, he was funny without really trying to be and it never felt like he was acting but just going through an average day and really could’ve led the show himself, Walden always felt like he was a backup dancer like he needed funny situations to be in to be funny not his dialogue or mannerisms.
No brainier ...my two and a half men series collection ends at season 9 ep.1 after Charlie is written off and the remaining Ashton DVDs were trashed and replaced by Charlie's Anger Management seasons 😂!!!!
Make no mistake, Kutcher did a great job acting, but a poor job of replacing Charlie. It's too bad for him that he had to fill Carlie's shoes, which is imposible to begin with.
No disrespect to Walden. He's a great actor but when it comes to two and a half men, Charlie takes the cake. The show gravitates around Mr.Sheen. No bs
Nobody wanted to do this show after Charlie because it was impossible to top Charlie, yet there was Ashton, the pretty boy, who has not one memoriable acting performance 😂😂
Charlie! Hands down... Walden was also a great selection of character to do their best to replace Charlie... That little mermaid episode.. Laugh My Asimov!! Kandi awesome too..
Charlie's demeanor is enough for people to laugh. Even Alan & the women cracked better jokes than Walden's. It isn't Kutcher's fault but very few people could have filled in Charlie's role. Maybe Steve Carell or Jim Carrey could surpass him but still Charlie's jokes were surreal.
to be honest they should have got either rob lowe, or john stamos because he was around charlies age, they would have been a lot funnier, honorable mention matt dillion
If you think there is any competition between this two,let me tell you the time charlie left the show. I never watched two and half man again.Thats why charlie is the best he is the show.
No contest. How could it be? The Show was basically a documentation of Charlie Sheens life. Berta, Rose, Alan - they all played their parts really great, but Charlie was the heart of the show. Walden could not touch him.
hence why the show went off the air
Charlie was a sarcastic weak link. He didn’t carry the show John Cryer did.
@@soulsreaper7145 after 3 more years where it was better than it had ever been
@jjgreen5206 this is serious cope. If it was so great after he left, why did all the ratings tank and it got canceled? Makes you wonder 🤔🤔🤔
@@jjgreen5206 and you wonder why the show dropped
There is no comparison. Charlie wins decisively.
Nope, i liked walden better.
@@yosi1653 "Said no one ever"
Nope berta wins
@@yosi1653 me too
@@McQueen98 two people already
U sure about that?
Charlie - player who breaks hearts
Walden - guy who gets his heart broken
So Alan with charlies money times 100
Walden can't deliver like charlie
Great, so now we have 2 Alans. Terrific, bc you know, he was always the funny one.
It's a difference but I hope the Charlies describtion doesn't mean to be better.
@@margaretlatocha1474 Charlie never delivered. It was the same Charlie sheen we’ve always seen. He was lame on Spin City and he was lame here. Ashton made the show a lot better
No contest, Charlie Harper all the way, he was much better at this role.
Walden can’t even brush off a Charlie’s shoe. There IS no comparison. Charlie is the best ❤️
The fact the after Charlie left and Walden showed up and not long after this show died speaks for itself.
Every producer should know that when Patton Oswalt shows up on your set your show has officially gone belly up.
Not really. They had 4 seasons with Ashton. Half the length the show had with Charlie.
@@glenbeltz9740agents of shield had a long successful run after Patton showed up.
@@1UpChuck- Chuck Lorre pbly just kept the show going just to say to Charlie sheen "i don't need you" even though the show wasn't funny and people weren't watching it
Worst idea to continue serial without Charlie....
You can't compare them.
Charlie is the soul of the show while Walden is just a supporting actor 🙏
Still makes me laugh, "I don't mean to be rude, but I'm tired of talking to you", SLAM. lol
charlie will always be better
Charlie wins on every front. He made the show great.
Charlie made the show.they got rid off him.When Ashton took over it went down hill that’s why it didn’t last .Charlie and the producers realised it.
Charlie.....and Jake made the show.
@@giovannigiovanni.7220 and alan
@@TechyWis I respect your opinion.
@@giovannigiovanni.7220 well ofc in the later seasons s1 he was meant to be all serious
It didn't end because of that, the show had gone on for 12 years, it was expected to end, a few seasons after Kutcher's arrival, he joined the show pretty late.
Charlie is obviously funnier
Charlie any day any time
Charlie had humour and was funny by just speaking. Whereas Walden had to dance move a lot and do funny gestures to make the scene funny.
And it still wasn't funny
@@DeadManA8 agree, it really wasn‘t
No, he was horrible no matter how much he danced moved and gestured.
@@SovereignStatesman true that.
@@DeadManA8 You're completely delusional
Charlie harper, all day, every day. It's not even a discussion.
I don't even watch the reruns with Walden. This isn't a competition.
l continued to watch even with Kutcher, but after the show ended l deleted his shows, kept all of charlies.
@@garyschumacher6531 I mean the best part of Walden episodes were allan
@@TechyWis You are like Evelyn, alan has one "l" 😂😉
There isn't a show without Charlie.......this role was made for him. No one could replace Charlie
But Walden didn't replace Charlie in that role, he had a different role
Charlie was the real deal in 2.5 men. He was THE SHOW.
They should've called it quits once Charlie left the show. There's no comparison, man was a legend
Not gonna lie, charlie Sheen all the way! The show is not the same without him.
You can remove "Not gonna lie" because literally everyone shares the same opinion on it 😎
I don't think Walden was a bad character...but everyone around him sure was. They all became caricatures of themselves after Charlie died
Charlie always going to be better that's for sure
Who says, "let's watch, two an a half men" we all say,let's watch Charlie!
Here is an easy way to break down this 'Charlie vs Walden...
- With Charlie, you just had fun with whatever he was doing and were always excited to see what he was going to do next.
- With Walden, you don't care what he was doing and only paid attention to whoever he is interacting with.
I feel sorry for Ashton Kutcher for trying to fill Charlie's shoes. How did they convince him to play the role is past me!
Do you know how much he got paid per episode? Anyone would do it
@@kadajnoir7369 wayy less then Charlie
Sheen was like that guy that every guy wanted to be and every girl wanna be with him so you can say no comparison
Charlie is the clear winner and all time favorite 👍
There is no competition whatsoever.... Charlie was magic on this show
Charlie is natural winner of this comparison
I like Walden, but Charlie will always be my favorite, he was funny without really trying to be and it never felt like he was acting but just going through an average day and really could’ve led the show himself, Walden always felt like he was a backup dancer like he needed funny situations to be in to be funny not his dialogue or mannerisms.
I couldn’t agree with you more.
No brainier ...my two and a half men series collection ends at season 9 ep.1 after Charlie is written off and the remaining Ashton DVDs were trashed and replaced by Charlie's Anger Management seasons 😂!!!!
This video is humiliating the memory of Charlie
Kutcher tried though. There is no comparison or competition between Charlie and Walden. Two and a Half Men died when Sheen left
Make no mistake, Kutcher did a great job acting, but a poor job of replacing Charlie. It's too bad for him that he had to fill Carlie's shoes, which is imposible to begin with.
Kutcher can’t act. He is bad, this is one more example.
Agree
Kutcher rhymes with butcher for a REASON>
@@SovereignStatesman can’t believe I didn’t string that together…
No he didn’t, his acting was utterly terrible…
Absolutely no competition Charlie's the freak we love
After Charlie left, I never watched another episode. I've been told that I never missed much.
This thumbnail is not fair Charlie was obviously the better actor in this series
There should be no argument. Charlie was the best!
You are right Charlie is a Billionaire in talent and charisma. While Walden is not even a Thousandaire
with chalie there were reasons to continue and with Walden there were reasons to stop the sitcom
It's like comparing a first-class meal to the time you flush it.
it was all the way charlie ,ashton kutcher could not even do 10% of what charlie could.
Charlie Harper the best
We are here for Charlie only... legend
I don’t think Walden is that bad tbh. He couldn’t touch Charlie but he’s not terrible
Walden is not funny at all just shows chuck lowie, did not haveca clue picking Walden. Charlie wins hands down by a mile
Who is Chuck Lowie?
No competition Charlie hands down
Charlie!
Nobody can replace him.
No disrespect to Walden. He's a great actor but when it comes to two and a half men, Charlie takes the cake. The show gravitates around Mr.Sheen. No bs
In French, the show is named "Mon oncle Charlie". That says it all.
Nobody wanted to do this show after Charlie because it was impossible to top Charlie, yet there was Ashton, the pretty boy, who has not one memoriable acting performance 😂😂
Waldren never came in thinking he could be better.He just ran out the clock for the cast .
I love Charlie and he is my favorite character in the show and I like walden too
Bertha was such a blessing... And Charlie is the winner on all occasions because he is the ultimate chad
this show died with Charlie.
Charlie WAS the show. The number 1 rule of watching Two and a Half Men is to watch it till Season 8.
I love how, when women realize how much money walden has, turn they behaviour real quick (shown in 1 episode especially).
You need grammar lessons
Stopped watching after Charlie left .... Legend
@ 1:35 most valuable life lesson. How to get take charge of a crazy cow.
Charlie without a doubt. Not even a contest.
Charlie! Hands down... Walden was also a great selection of character to do their best to replace Charlie... That little mermaid episode.. Laugh My Asimov!! Kandi awesome too..
Charlie rocks. Walden, no.
the boss, CHARLIE SHEEN! 👑
Poor guy never stood a chance.
Millionare surpasses Billionaire
And charlie takes the billion, soloing walden
Like day and night charlie much better
Charlie's demeanor is enough for people to laugh. Even Alan & the women cracked better jokes than Walden's. It isn't Kutcher's fault but very few people could have filled in Charlie's role. Maybe Steve Carell or Jim Carrey could surpass him but still Charlie's jokes were surreal.
Charlie made the show , he was a true G
Theres a reason why charlie was the highest paid in the tv show
Never watched the show without Charlie.
I've never seen one episode with Walden on it, that speaks volumes.
I love 2 and a Half Freaks, regardless of who's playing the lead role. I just love the show!
2:00 Charlie wins, game over.
Its a no show on Kutchers side. Charlie wins every time.
Charlie 100%
Charlie.
Allen is starting to sound like his brother alittle in the new seasons 😂😂😂
Charlie wipes the floor with Walden
Fact!
to be honest they should have got either rob lowe, or john stamos because he was around charlies age, they would have been a lot funnier, honorable mention matt dillion
Yep, Stamps for sure
I love watching both Walden and Charlie. ❤
Me too
THERE REALLY IS ABSOLUTELY NO COMPARISON
Show ended when they got rid of Charlie.
It was at this time, that Ashton stopped laying his golden eggs.
If you think there is any competition between this two,let me tell you the time charlie left the show. I never watched two and half man again.Thats why charlie is the best he is the show.
The fact that the french version is named My Uncle Charlie makes it even more weird that Charlie wasn't there anymore.
Charlie, Alan, Jake, Berta, Rose, Evelyn
Alan, Jake, Berta, Rose, Evelyn..... Walden somewhere in between
the only one who can replace Charlie is Robert Downey Jr lol
Charlie made this show .
CHARLIE IS THE BEST HANDS DOWN
Everyone trashing on Walden and keeps comparing him with Charlie. Of course Charlie was one and only, but I really like Walden's kind personality
Well Walden was replacement for Charlie after Charlie left the show
I love Charlie & Walden
Walden tried but Charlie was GOATed
Charlie win (no competition from from whats his face)
This was Charlie's show. i couldnt even remember any episode of Walden, barely even remembered his nale 😆
Nale?
Charlie=Winning!!!
Charlie was the show,
No contest..
Charlie was worlds ahead. No way of comparing.
Really ? Charlie no brainer