**New** P2 Hadith Rejection!? Adnan Vs Hadith Rejector | Speakers Corner | Hyde Park
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- Yes we are back Allhumdulillah!
P2 - Adnan Speaks to a person who rejects the authenticity of the Hadith yet how can one do that without rejecting the Quran and its transmission!? as it was transmitted in the same manner!? Adnan eloquently dismantles this rejection.
2/2
Final Part
That's happened when a man disobeys Allah's guide and follow his/her own desire! That ignorant man does not know the basic of Islam. May Allah guide him.
RK Sumon yes right there this is what happend how false lies are spreads I feel sorry for if he had kids he basically growing them into the hell fire just because he can't be bothered to do the basic reach
My man jumping around like he is playing hop scotch loool
But he said there's 3 prays in a day you know prayer is most important because that means he not submitted so what happen if he teaches he children if he got any going umrah or Hajj will he pray only 3, prayer in the whole day come on he doesn't even know the basic English Quran has error done by man so read in Arabic the truth way
Mohd Khalid 1)www.quran-islam.org/faq/where_is_salat_in_quran_%28P1377%29.html
2)5:6
3)"Attaharu which is in another verse (9:108) translated as "purifying." My question is why in 5:6 it is translated as taking a complete bath". Purify yourself, but how do you know your purified? It's like how do you know if your angry? You either do or don't.
4)Also 5:6
5)77. Sodomy is to be avoided from what is gathered in this surah. You can claim it is only for men, but I don't see it that way. Me and my wife stay away from all sodomy (oral and anal by definition) and sexual devience. Though the latter is our interpretation extrapolated from the whole of the Qur'an.
Hope that helps.✌ and may God keep us on the right path.
syd james and by the end of Kamran started getting the better of Adnan at which point he decided to pull the plug because he had no comeback.
SubhaanAllah .May Allah swt forgive us and guide us to the straight path.Ameen😞
45:6) These are Allah's verses that We narrate to you in Truth. In what kind of discourse after Allah and His verses will they, then, believe?8
answer the question
The Qur’an is a book revealed by God that does not resemble hadiths at all.
Nobody can come up with the Qur’an, as for hadiths, they can
Wasn't it sufficient for them? We sent down the book to you, and it would be recited to them?
Answer this question also if you can
14:1 “Alif, Lam, Ra. [This is] the Book which We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], that you might bring mankind out of darknesses into the light by permission of their Lord - to the path of the Exalted in Might, the Praiseworthy “- Ponder and reflect on the verse ... the verse is clear and crystal clear ... and it means that the exit of people from darkness to light and then to the straight path is exclusively by the book. ... and people leaving the darkness to the light and then to the straight path is the highest goal, so if the servant attains that, what is our need for the prophetic Sunnah?
Fear God and may God teach you
Is piety scientific testimony or inside the heart?
Answer if you can
And if he was surprised, then he was surprised by their saying
I do not attack you, but I bemoan you association the Sunnah with the Book and I invite you to the religion of Abraham, to be honest, and he was not among the polytheists
If I tell you that prayer, zakat and all acts of worship are present in the Qur’an, then what is our need for the Sunnah?! .....
Do not be from those whom God said:
(42:21) “Do they have any associates (of Allah) who have laid down for them a way pertaining to faith which Allah did not sanction?”
Do not associate with God unless God has revealed authority,
And do not answer me with a demonic answer, such as those who say: Obey God and obey the Messenger, evidence of the existence of the Prophet’s Sunnah. This is a vague answer and the Qur’an is clear and not vague. Sincerely review yourself, you will find the right path with the help of ALLAH
@@TheoWrigt you quranist think prophet was like postman who delivered the message like this guy said “A guy called muhammad” subhanallah if you don’t believe the sunah and ahadith you aren’t muslim
may allah guide you
@@MSozil mushrik, Allah calls the Prophet "Muhammad", no shirk addition like you sunnis say "may prayers of Allah be upon the Prophet" in your corrupt translations, and as you talk to him 5 times a day, to a man in grave, you're quburi mushrikeen.
sunnah sunnah, you say, are you deaf to what the brother said to you? what other Hadith after Allah and His ayats will you believe? answer that question of Allah, you mushrik.
Prophet was just a postman, you like it or not, word "messenger" literally means someone who brings the message, that's it, no any shirk, no partnership for Allah, Prophet is only the postman, and that's taught in Quran verse 5:99, remove your shirk.
{ Not upon the Messenger is [responsibility] except [for] notification. And Allah knows whatever you reveal and whatever you conceal. (/ Quran 5:99) }
Adnan you are legend vith great history and knowledge,,may Allah protect you and family,ameen
He's a satan worshiper like all the extreme islamists. THERE IS TRUE MUSLIMS THAT ARE GOOD PEOPLE NOT BRAINWASHED LIKE THE ANIMALS. OR IS THIS BEING AN ISLAMAPHOBE? THAT IS SUCH A DUMB WORD. LOOK IT UP WHAT PHOBE MEANS. THEY NEED THE REAL GOD JESUS NOT A FAIRY TALE GOD AND A FALSE PROPHET PEDO.
Some people's job is to argue not debate !
They just need to prove you're wrong ! They don't want to learn
Why do hadith rejectors only rely on a translation of the Quran, instead of being sincere & learning the language of the Quran.
Br adnan slays again
Peace family
Get Adnan some advil! 😂
May Allah bless this brother for his knowledge, dawah, and his patience. Alhdullilah
Jazak Allah Khair
maaaaan AbdulHamid LOOOOOOOOOL. His laugh had me dying!!
ALLAHU AKBAR ..may we all be guided and forgiven....
This was like an Inquisition, people were laughing and mocking, this is not the way to do dawah, certainly not the way of our prophet, I Know its speaker's corner but sometimes we can be right in our arguments yet lose the argument due to our presentation. You don't gather flys with vinegar but with honey. Just words of frindly advice.
@@samanali4848 bruf he's saying he's Muslim and tbh this isn't dawah because dawah is only to nonbeliever
@@Sweeti924 This is dawah only since he is Hadith rejecter.
@@Sweeti924 Dawah is not only for nonbelievers, Dawah is a reminder, and Muslims also need to be reminded, every human needs to be reminded.
@@beast-master2094 dawah is only to nonbeliever
@@beast-master2094 reminding is not same as dawah
People around Adnan should please stop laughing and giggling. What are these people trying to prove? It reeks of arrogance and stupidity.
Yes its really disrespectful and childish
"Do you believe the Qur'an came to you from anonymous sources" That is by far, the best question I heard during this discussion. And in typical Cam'ron fashion, he replies, "that has no relevance".
Adnan said "let people judge" and we say "let God judge" Well done brother kamran !!
May God the almighty bless you
S M Quran only. Hahahahahahaha. How about you answer the question. How do you know the Quran is authentic? Who took the Quran and gave it to you? Stop being a Hypocrite
S M Quran only, you guys even lie on the commentary section, trying to take br Adnans words out of context, and on top of that, mis-qoute the brother. He said let the people DECIDE, an entirerly different word from judge....
I’ll destroy the ridiculous “Quranite” argument once and for all. I got the translation from your own ‘progressive ‘ Qurans. LOL.
17-18.
Mentions a life of haste. Well what is ‘a life of haste’ ??? You better be damn certain you aren’t living a life of haste because the penalty is hell fire. Explain what Allah means using Quran alone lol. The penalty is HELLFIRE so you can’t be guessing carelessly.
Or
17:27
Those who waste excessively are brothers to the devils, .........
What exactly is ‘wasting excessively’ ? Using Quran alone and nothing else. Seems to be an extraordinarily broad term. I wouldn’t want to be a brother of the devil. Do you?
Cry and cry about the Quran being ‘clear’ and ‘complete’ and ‘fully detailed’ then the response to these questions should be easy. The penalties are large so this is a huge deal. Unfortunately there isn’t an answer. You Need the Sunnah to clarify these verses and verses like them which there are more of.
And another great one. Surah 104. Define what exactly a backbiter is. Because again the penalty is being thrown into hell. What exactly or even approximately do you have to do to get thrown into a blazing fire? Using Quran only. Good luck with that lol. If you have any integrity you’ll explore to find out the truth instead of pretending to just know stuff from a translation which you actually don’t know the source of exactly how it got to you.
Please be kind in arguing to hadith rejector..They looks like sincere person trying to understand Quran as best they can. Not like the hypocrite Christian missionaries.
He made his mind up and no matter wat is said to him he will reject it, wats the point?
@@amjidali588 The point is he is still a muslim and believes in the Qur’an. He does not show arrogance or ego like some of the brothers watching in the background. He was sincere with his thoughts and explained his points well, whether you agree is disagree with his views is besides the point, he is an example of how one should conduct themselves during debates.
@@CR-ke4si He's been in speakers corner for 4 years using the same arguments and it's obvious he's there to discuss and not to change. They're literally creating their own religion by interpreting their own ideologies and understandings instead of reffering it to the messenger's explanation of such verses.
Indeed, Allah has done the believers a ˹great˺ favour by raising a messenger from among them-reciting to them His revelations, purifying them, and teaching them the Book and wisdom. For indeed they had previously been clearly astray.
Surah Ali Imran 3:164
and teaching them the Book AND wisdom
How will they get the prophet's wisdom by following the Quran?
It doesnt mstter where the Quran comes from. What is important is whether the Quran can convince us that it is the word of God.
Sahar2 Sahar lol how can you trust a source without any background?? so by your logic if you find any book that talks about God you just trust it?? the bible mentions God but has anonymous writers do you trust it as well? what about the Vedas? seriously think before you comment
The Quran claims it has been preserved, how do we know it has been preserved?
I laughed myself to death with the two brothers in the back hahahaha🤣😂
its not funny its a serious matter
I was laughing at the way the brothers were enjoying themselves at the back . Nothing to do with the content. The content was serious no doubt.
When he said which Quran is that 😂🤣😂
Hahahaha
Me too
This brother uses English translation to interprit the Quran, by attempting to link verses together. However this is very problematic because the English translation misses aloof of the richness of the Arabic language. Also there is the historical context of the translation on the verses. You cannot translate the Qur'an without using seraah(and hadith).
He's ignoring scholars of Arabic, Hadith, historians etc etc. Very flawed methodolagy
I would like to speak to this brother. If anyone has any contact with him.
Rejecting Hadith is rejecting the prophet , so how will you attain salvation
no it is rejecting the "alleged words of the prophet" you cannot prove the prophet said those things, since the so called people who heard someone say to someone else who saw some else saying etc etc.....(hearsay is always does not count as proof, especially if the people are dead so it cannot be verified, also the chain saying so and so is trust worthy so we should accept the hearsay...you cannot guarantee any of the narrators misheard, misquoted or misunderstood,took out of context, took literally or metaphorically or made other mistakes..
Believing in hadith is rejecting the prophet. The Qur'an is what was revealed to the prophet from Allah. You follow the Qur'an then you follow the Prophet.
the two brothers in the background in the white cap and black shirt are so wholesome
I hope this Hadith rejector will go home and contemplate about how wrong his beliefs are with regards to Hadith
Anime Xtreme and what am I mocking?
Anime Xtreme I have read the Quran in English and Arabic both
Anime Xtreme please show how and when rukku and sajda has to be done during namaaz from the Quran? Make sure you show exactly when rukku happens, what prayer is to be said, when Sajida happens what prayer to be said, what should be said before salaam of prayer. How many Rakats in fajr prayer, how many rakats in zohar prayer, asar, magrib and esha prayer. Make sure you show clearly from the Quran the details to Muslims on how exactly the prayer has to be done. Show how the namaaz for jannazah has to be prayed, how many rakats in Eid prayer.. without Hadith, you would know nothing
Anime Xtreme open the Quran and show me about Rakast before you ask me to open my eyes. Please don't deviate from what is being asked
Anime Xtreme astagfirullah ... you don't need to now how to pray namaaz!?!?!. That's such a sad belief to have. Especially when namaaz is one of the pillars of Islam. What kind of namaaz do you pray???
I think it's best to leave you to your beliefs.
You to your beliefs, me to mine
These hadith rejectors are turning the Word of God into merely another anonymous "divine" scriptures like the many other religions around the world 🤦 The beauty of Islam as a religion because of the *preservation* of the message by the oral traditions of the companions and their students.
There is an Aya in the Quran that destroys the hadith rejectors. Surat 16 Aya 44.
The Quran comes fr Allah[swt} THRU angel Jibreil to the messenger, and Allah says in the Quran that this book is well protected , so how it comes to us
is fr the Mercy of Allah{swt}.Adnan is a well read person, but sadly Allah[SWT] has not open his heart.. Allah has definetly open the heart of Qamaroon, welldone
Quranist bro. i only beleive in the Quran alone and it is the best Hadith fr Allah{swt}.
Brother do u pray salah??
@@omerfarukanik1834 no he dont he will say there are three but when you ask him how do you pray he will never answer you
@@TripWireEcho-oh6ot he is a hypocrite
@@omerfarukanik1834 they are interpreting quran in their own way by own desires by reading translation not even knowing arabic lugha.but the thing is when you dont belive the people who wrote quran are rightious then how come they know the quran is preserved
That's why the Quran is the primary source and Ahadith are there to support the Quran. In other words only those Hadith are to be accepted which are in line with the Quran. Otherwise those Hadiths have to be rejected which are against the teachings/spirit of the Quran.
“And it has already been revealed to you in the Book (this Qur’aan) that when you hear the Verses of Allaah being denied and mocked at, then sit not with them, until they engage in a talk other than that; (but if you stayed with them) certainly in that case you would be like them. Surely, Allaah will collect the hypocrites and disbelievers all together in Hell”
[al-Nisaa’ 4:140]
*Quran **24:54* _"Say: "Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger: but if ye turn away, he is only responsible for the duty placed on him and ye for that placed on you. If ye obey him, ye shall be on right guidance. The Messenger's duty is only to preach the clear (Message)."_
Obey Allah And obey the Messenger therefor they both have to be obeyed.
+NYC125street
It says OBEY ALLAH then it says OBEY THE MESSENGER. Anyone that is not trying to make a point will see that obedience is expected to both. The problem with people like you is that you do not respect the messenger and reject his honesty and his obedience to Allah. You try to make it seem that the messenger will order something that will contradict Allah’s law. Therefore, obedience should only be to what is in the Quran.
If that is the case how can we trust what is in the Quran. If you are going to say, that Allah promised to protect it. To which I will say, how do you know that? Wasn’t it the untrustworthy (in your option) messenger that said it? Or is it the case that you don’t trust the companions? If so, you are still in the same situation as they are the ones that brought the Quran to you. So they will be trusted with the Quran but not with the Hadith?
Now why do you go and call the Arabs hypocrites? Once again, whether you like it or not they are the ones that in the beginning spread Islam all over the world. In regards to the messengers and prophets that came before Mohammed (PBUH). We accept them and respect them but whatever law or message they brought was localised and temporary. Mohammed (PBUH) brought the final and open-ended message so that is what we follow.
+NYC125street
*Quran 9:73* what is your point? we know there is going to be disbelievers and the hypocrites.
When you say “HYPOCRITE /ARABS” do you mean the companions if so as I said in my last comment. Then how can you trust them with the Quran? These “hypocrites" are the ones that brought it to you.
_”which SECT do you know to follow.”_
I follow the Quran and the Sunna don’t follow any sect.
+NYC125street
I am finding it hard to understand how you understand verses in the Quran due to how you use them in an attempt to make your point.
*Quran 36:82* _”His command, when He wills a thing, is to say to it, "Be," and it comes to be.”_
You quote this verse and then say guidance comes from Allah. In an attempt to nullify the messenger (PBUH) roll altogether. While if you were a proper Quran only person you would have used the following verse instead
*Quran **28:56* _”You cannot guide whom you love, but God guides whom He wills, and He knows best those who are guided.”_
Which to be honest I don’t know why you are talking about guidance. The original post was whether the messenger (PBUH) had the authority to be obeyed or not. Which in turn would dictate whether we take the hadith in to consideration. Which we should based on the following verse
*Quran **33:21* _”You have an excellent example in the Messenger of God; for anyone who seeks God and the Last Day, and remembers God frequently.”_
What is meant by example? HIS SUNNA that’s what.
The Torah is not a source of guidance. I cannot use and the Injeel (gospel of Jesus (PBUH)) as it is lost and even if it were here. I would still not consider it a source when I have the Quran. It is weird that you reject the hadith but accept the Torah and Bible.
+NYC125street
*Quran 59:7* _"Whatever God restored to His Messenger from the inhabitants of the villages belongs to God, and to the Messenger, and to the relatives, and to the orphans, and to the poor, and to the wayfarer; so that it may not circulate solely between the wealthy among you. _*_Whatever the Messenger gives you, accept it; and whatever he forbids you, abstain from it._*_ And fear God. God is severe in punishment."_
+YC125street
Once again, you quote verses that have nothing to do with anything. Then you go on to say that I am arguing with God and since I am arguing with you that would mean you think you are God.
*Quran **24:54* _"Say: "Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger: but if ye turn away, he is only responsible for the duty placed on him and ye for that placed on you. If ye obey him, ye shall be on right guidance. The Messenger's duty is only to preach the clear (Message)."_
Obey who and who?
*Quran **33:21* _”You have an excellent example in the Messenger of God; for anyone who seeks God and the Last Day, and remembers God frequently.”_
What is meant by example? HIS SUNNA that’s what. Which we know through the hadith.
*Quran **16:44* _”With the clarifications and the scriptures. And We revealed to you the Reminder, that you may clarify to the people what was revealed to them, and that they may reflect.”_
They he may what? CLARIFY. His clarification make it to us through the hadith.
Now let’s see you quote some verse from the Quran that is talking about the Torah or the Injeel.
The real lions are the 2 brothers in the back. When the time came to support our Muslim brother against bullies who happened to be black, Muhammad and Abdul Haleem were ready any time. Soldiers MashaAllah
Salaams subhanallah it's scary to watch these hadith rejectors go to the lengths they go to in order to confirm their position.
I have a suggestion, I would really awesome if you put date on all videos, you upload.
If one believes there shall be ANY source needed after, besides, or amongst The Qur'an... Then that equals one who doesn't believe Allah & his Qur'an to be complete!! Go read Sura 6:114 (as well as 45:6 & 77:50)... #Qur'anRejectsHadith
How about you answer the question. How do you know the Quran is authentic? Who took the Quran and gave it to you? How can you be sure someone else didn’t add in 6:114 and 77:50??? Unless of course you were alive back then
The guy is a joker the one in black cap so silly but hard not to laught as he don't know what he talking about in a strange way understanding very poor of what the meaning is
I can understand why brother Abu could not stop laughing lol
ignoring the fact that sunnis talk to a man in grave 5 times a day saying "peace be upon YOU O PROPHET"?
sunnis are just quburi mushirkeen, just like their shia fellows who say "Ya Ali", sunnis and shias are deluded cuz of Ahadith.
how Quran came, how it was delivered doesn't matter, it's now stored in European museums, and kept by kuffar, it doesn't mean that we should follow kuffar, wake up.
world is proof for Quran with miracles, and that Quran has no any error, that was a good answer, but you sunnis can't suffice with Allah, so you seek contradictory Ahadith which can't be from Allah as per criterion of no contradiction (in 4:82).
besides, ignoring the funny case that Adnan literally believes that Shakespeare was divinely inspired XD, what a deluded case.
I challenge you to bring me any chapter from Shakespeare and other poets, and I can criticise and compare those to Quran, your poets are losers,
and your Adnan dares to attack Quran by those crippled poets? what a disgrace, you sunnis laugh at Quran and mock its followers in your hypocritic thoughts as if "following Quran alone misleads", what a nonsense.
Hadees are historical records
You have Quran and sunnha.
In prophet last “qhutba” he asked his companions if he has deliver the complete message.
So now if People follow Quran and sunnha you should be good.
Hadees are there for extra help to make us better Muslim.
The Sunnah is mentioned in the Hadiths. So rejecting the Hadiths is rejecting the Sunnah. Every single Sunnah you have learned is 100% from the Hadiths
and that last quthba is delivered to us int he form of hadith and you are rejecting hadith. Hadith is also equally important bro. Just think how do you pray without hadith. Hadith is not written by some lay man, it has been recorded by some of the great people (muhadith). Think carefully, rejecting hadith will be like rejecting prophet and sahabas. May Allah guide you.
@@mohammedasif1955
Exactly and also you cannot know the Sunnah except through Hadiths.
It is mentioned in the Hadiths one of the signs of the day of judgment is people will say "Quran is sufficient for me I don't need the Hadiths"
Kamran cameron lol keep it up brother were not all lost! Insha'Allah we link up soon and we will laugh at those who were laughing. Just another point when all the messengers came and im not saying i am a chosen messenger but its ironic they were all ridiculed and laughed at too
By that logic when we laugh at anti-islamic preachers, then they are also like the messengers??? You Quranists cannot even understand the Quran properly, that is the real irony.
@@mohammadrizwaan1890
That's a silly analogy.
Laughing at the ignorance of an anti-Islamic preacher shows spiritual maturity; it says to the hate preacher that: "Instead of me acting like the 'terrorist' you claim that I am, I'll take the higher road and laugh at you because God made my heart that way."
But on the other hand, laughing and mocking a fellow Muslim, with the most shameful display of condescendence, actually reveals their characters more than anyone else.
And this is something I notice with these individuals, they never actually engage in fair and honest debates. When making rebuttals, opponents are constantly interrupted and bombarded with questions which are instantly related to another issue.
For what reason should this man be mocked? Because he chooses to believe in solely the Holy Quran, words that were revealed to the Messenger himself, and those words only?
In a time where chaos is running rampant in the Islamic world, do you think it is necessary to debate about stories?
Yes Camran well done bro. Top man.
They are taking away the divinity of the Quran by saying that the only way to prove the divinity is coupled with assumption that it had to have human hands touch it. That there is no way that we could have received the message without man. If man has to be involved then it is no longer divine. Whereas carmon is trying to explain that the divinity is proven within the book itself. Not just comparing text within itself but also comparing itself to all other text and also alongside the signs of creation. The proof is in the book itself. The fact that it needs nothing to explain it, that it explains itself, freeing Allah from help of all others which is the very core of our deen!!! You would have to read Quran for yourself, seek ONLY Allahs guidance, in order to see it. Don’t listen to anyone else. Pray to Allah, trust that he will guide you no matter what and read a copy of Quran in the language you understand and let Allah guide you through His word in the language He gave you to understand. Watch the miracle happen.
“They are taking away the divinity of the Quran by saying that the only way to prove the divinity is coupled with the assumption that it had to have human hands touch it.” Where exactly did Adnan or any other of the speakers say this? If the Quran comes in Arabic and it wants to spread to China, does it or does it not need human intervention? If there is a verse of the Quran that needs explaining does it or does it not need human intervention? Simply explaining the verse is nowhere near “taking away the divinity of the Quran” if an explanation is trying to explain something in the Quran then it’s explaining, if it’s changing something in the Quran then it’s taking away something in the Quran and therefore making it not divine-the hadith does not do this. “The fact that it explains itself...freeing Allah from human help” the Quran requires no explanation? How about the “kill them where you find them” verse? Does the Quran explain this? If so where? If people saw this verses like these without an explanation (which is in the Hadith) they would definitely hate Islam and be drawn further away from Allah, we as Muslims should be helping people go towards Allah which is also part of our deen!
Your arguments are ludicrous.
Shakespeare and Hindu vedas doesn't make the claim that God will guard the Quran from corruption, therefore, it's an invalid comparison. This is why, it is reasonable to maintain that it is irrelevent who passed down the quran. It would have been muhammed himself and all around him. What does it matter? How are they relevent except by writing what was ordered from them? Regardless, I beleive the guru granth sahib to be my hadith. But even without the guru granth sahib, a true Muslim can get into heaven by following the quran alone
matt alan . It doesn't matter who sent down the quran to us because God, the author of the quran takes it upon himself to guard the Quran so muslims should just trust and use their intellect to ensure that there is not contradiction between the quran and the hadiths. And that was my point. I said u don't need the guru granth sahib to get into heaven, despite it being the best of the best hadiths
Allah says the Quran is the best Hadith not anything about SGGS. Where do you get that that is the best of the best Hadith. Allah says this (Quran) is the best Hadith and poses the question which Hadith after this will they follow. Following Allahs Word alone is the only “salvation” for lack of a better word.
I can’t believe some people they say they are Muslim and don’t believe in Hadith of Allah prophet (pbuh) , I think this kind of people will make laugh non muslim at our beautiful Islam and will not make them to think about Islam, may Allah guide them to straight path
5 against 1 ......show him kindness when you talk instead of 5 ganging up on him maybe he will reflect later on.
5? I only saw 3. And maybe a 4th, optionally.
there bukarist and follower of lawl hadith cannot run without such things...We are follower of Quran is true muslim.
Adnan bhaai you're so blessed with the knowledge and to deal with theses kind of people..
You could've ask all the hadeeth rejectors about dajjal?
I betcha they will run like chicken in sha ALLAH.
Because yoy know better than I do
That DAJJAL by word is not mentioned in whole of the QUR'AAN
All these hadith rejectors do is deter away from the points being made from Adnan instead of answering. Just shows there is no logic to what they say!
Their behavior makes it appear as if they do not believe in Allah and only believe in compaions and hadiths.
Where did you get this from??
What are hadiths? The behaviour of the Quranists appear to show the prophet having not fulfilled his job of explaining the Quran to the people. How do we even know the Quran we have today is the Quran of the prophet. The companions have been honoured by Allah, so it is part of our belief to believe in them, they are reason by Allah's will that we have the Quran today, alhumdulilah.
Then what about the Kitab al Ilal wa Ma'rifat al Rijal.
@@AllAllah777 The book you have mentioned looks at the errors within chains of narrations, those that have weak chains by the great Imam Ahmad RA. This is only goes to show the thoroughness of hadith sciences and how no one as you say can fake a hadith chain.
Very hard not to laugh but I had too. 😂
The Quran in itself is already a miracle. Addition with following the believing in Al Qaida and practicing sunnah sincerly, is all you need to be accepted into Jannah inchaAllah. These guy's study for intellectual competition...
that's what you made up, it's not what Allah said, it's your made up shirk sect. Quran with itself is enough, Prophet is just a postman, you like it or not, Allah clearly taught in Quran...
{ Not upon the Messenger is [responsibility] except [for] notification. And Allah knows whatever you reveal and whatever you conceal. (5:99) }
I wouldn't waste my my time arguing with someone that discards the ahadith. I have one question to ask them, and that is, who taught you how to perform salah and which is sunna and not?
I am surprised that the he doesn't know the name of any companion's of prophet mohammad صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم۔.not even the Khalifa's .انا للہ وانا الیہ راجعون
If the hadeeth were not to be followed then why did Allah swt reveal the Quran to Muhammad pbuh and ask us to follow his example? Why not just send the book down in boxes for us to read ourselves
*IT IS ONLY THE AHADITH THAT RAISES DOUBTS TO THE QURAN'S PRESERVATION*
It is shocking for me to hear Adnan Rashid, A man i respect so much STOOP so low in the above argument to equate the transmission of the Quran to that of the Ahadith.
Its either he is being insincere or he is ignorant of the transmission of the Quran.
Regrettably, many Muslims like Adnan above assert that the Quran has also reached us in the same manner as the Ahadith. *The Ahadith corpus is primarily an oral propagation reliant mainly on 'ahad' transmitters and later committed to text.* Adnan knows this, YET HE LIES IN THE OPEN... that the Quran is transmitted just as the Ahadiths are transmitted.. why lie soo openly???
The Quran on the other hand, has reached us both by a rigorous *oral and written* form along with the complete consensus of the Muslim communities. This is well captured in the comment below..
"...Thus, if the Qur'an had been transmitted only orally for the first century, sizeable variations between texts such as in the hadith and pre-Islamic poetry would be found, and if it had been transmitted only in writing, sizeable variations such as those in different transmissions of the original document of the Constitution of Medina would be found. But neither is the case with the Qur'an. There must have been a parallel written transmission limiting variation in the oral transmission to the graphic form, side by side with a parallel oral transmission preserving the written transmission from corruption. The oral transmission of the Qur'an was essentially static, rather than organic. There was a single text, and nothing, not even allegedly abrogated material, could be taken out, nor anything be put in..." _____BROCKETT. A.A, Studies in Two Transmissions of the Quran, University of St. Andrews, Department of Arabic Studies, Ph.D. thesis 1984, Chapter Conclusion, Page 142
As a matter of Fact there are manuscripts being discovered dating all the way back to the tiime of the prophet of the fact that, *THE QURANIC REVELATIONS WHERE WRITTEN DOWN AS THEY WHERE BEING REVEALED*... Contrary to the Ahadiths *which where penned down like 40, 150, 200 years later*, as well as memorized by a general community. NOT SAME CAN BE SAID OF THE HADITHS...
What is baffling is this.. THE HADITHS IN NO WAY is an indicator of Quranic protection or transmission TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE, IT IS ONLY THE AHADITH THAT RAISES DOUBTS TO THE QURAN'S PRESERVATION
Its the Ahadiths IN SAHIH BOOKS that claim :
That verses were missing and a goat ate the stoning verse with regards to adultery ___SUNAN IBN MAJAH, Book of Nikaah, Number 1944
That the Prophet of God introduced the Satanic verses ____AL TABARI, Ta'rikh Volume 1
That Caliph Uthman burnt the extant copies of the Quran ___SAHIH BUKHARI, Volume 6, Book 61, Number 510, Translator: M. Muhsin Khan
That there was a missing suckling verse (Ten clear sucklings which made the marriage unlawful, then it was later abrogated (and substituted) by five sucklings and then was somehow removed or missed from the Quran altogether ___SUNAN IBN MAJAH, Book of Nikaah, Number 1944,
That there was a missing Ibn Adam verse (regarding Ibn Adam's possession of a wadi of property) _____ BURTON. J, The Collection of the Qur'an, Cambridge University Press 1977, First published 1977, First paperback edition 1979, Re-issued 2010, Pages 82-83, Note (31) and (32) quoted. Note (31) - Burhan al Din al Baji, Jawab, MS Dar al Kutub, Taimur majami no. 207, f.17. Note (32) Itqan, pt 2,, p.25
That there was a missing 'pleasing' verse from the Quran (regarding those that were slain at Bi'r Mauna which included the verse "Inform our tribe on our behalf that we have met with our Lord. He has been well pleased with us and has satisfied our desires) ____BURTON. J, The Collection of the Qur'an, Cambridge University Press 1977, First published 1977, First paperback edition 1979, Re-issued 2010, Pages 48-49, Note (3). Note (3) Ibid. p26 (from previous reference Itqan, pt2)
And many others, from al-Baraa, verses that were lost with dead Muslims, cancelled and repealed verses and those forgotten by the Prophet himself and those lost by Quranic reciters ____SAHIH MUSLIM, Volume 1, Book 5, Book of Zakat (Kitab al-Zakat) Number 2286
If for nothing at all, FOR SAKE OF TRUTH, the issues of transmission of Quran and ahadith have been well documented. Maliki Muwatta being the earliest work of ahadiths came about 40-50 years after the Quran had been penned down and have reached several Muslim communities, not to mention Bukhari which came after 2 centuries when islam and the Quran where already well spread beyond the Arabian peninsula!!! THINK AND STOP SPREADING FALSEHOOD
Salaam!
Yakubu Yusuf. Sounds ridiculous. You say the Quran reaches us from rigorous oral and written transmission and consensus of the community lol. Well who were the first to record it from the prophet (saw)??? Who??? How do you know someone didn’t change something along the way ? Early on you know how easy it would have been for one the leaders to change a few verses.? Add some in. Take some out. Change wording. Easy. Unless of course we trust in the same individuals who recorded ahadeeth. The sahaba. Seriously dude. You sound like an ahmadi stooge
@EmeraldDiamon3 Where are these books of hadith written by the sahaba, as you claim? Sahih Bukhari or Muslim was not written by any of the Sahaba.
EmeraldDiamond3 Sahaba never wrote hadith get outta here.
Step in the ring with br adnan and see how he dismantles you too.
@@Khan-wf3mi Read science of Hadees so you could clearly understand the fallacy in your arguments against the reliability of those Hadees, which were only compiled by Imam Bukhari ra and Imam Malik to make it easy for the Ummah to take guidance from Quran in the light of these Hadees especially about issues that are only hinted in Quran as a sign for us to then learn it from the life and teaching of our beloved Prophet Sallalahu alaihe wassalam.
Without the teaching and explanation of the Prophet SAW, it would be impossible to interpret Quran using our own intellect and limited wisdom when we can never contextualise the verses that were revealed over different period of time and were taught by our beloved Prophet Mohammad Sallalahu alaihe wassalam along the way.
Besides, had it been left to us to understand Quran ourselves then imagine how many different translations and understandings we could have had by extrapolating different meaning from verses to suit our desires.
The way Allah SWT has preserved Quran is the same way He SWT preserved Saheeh Hadees so if you have problem of lacking faith in believing them ONLY because some of them are not going down your throat to inhale then you need to work on your faith and understanding of Islam by deeply pondering upon the reasons as to why Prophet Mohammad Sallalahu alaihe wassalam was sent in the first place when Gabriel AS could have done it for Allah, cuz obviously He (saw) wasn't sent to just pass on the revelations to Sahabas Ra and then left, hence leaving them with an impossible taskto interpret the verses by themselves in order to create havoc and divisions amongst them and would that be fulfilling the claim of Allah that He has perfected His Deen and that His messenger has completed his task? Idiots. 🤭
He is so funny may Allah bring him to the right path of true Islam.
Ameen
There needs to be more of these constructive comments ameen❤
Hypocrites are not described as companions - but people of Madinah
adnan rashid mashallah made sense in what he was saying. out of respect...the two brothers in the background were consistently laughing, be sensible please, yes we dont agree with quranists views but you never know....people sniggering may prompt someone from not returning back to the real islam.
adam lee they can't help but laugh at the stupidity. You can't respect someone who doesn't respect the life of the Prophet (saws) and chooses to follow their own interpretation of the Quran. Hopefully he can see how illogical his arguments are by people laughing.
Al Quran comes from Allah and he doesn't need help from anyone Allah protected the book. the Quran is divine because it comes from Allah you people who follow these hadith guys despite what the Quran says going get the punishment from what they mock on the day of Judgement.
Jeez so much sect against Islam the Shia the wahabi and now Hadith rejectors wut will come next, ya Allah protect the Muslim and your please religion Islam from madness and fitnah
1Question to hadith rejecters: Where in the Qur'an which were Muslims instructed to face Jerusalem as qibla before it is changed to makkah? If nowhere in the Qur'an, who told the prophet to do that?
Answer: of course ALLAH instructed prophet and Muslims regarding that but obviously not in the form of Qur'an but in the hadith.. it means inspirations (wahi) were not only in the Qur'an. Case closed.
If you need the Hadith to be a true Muslim then what type of Islam were the Muslims (Living all over the world) believing in, during the intervening 200-300 after the Prophets death, until Bukhari and Muslim collected the Hadith and spread these collected works of Hadith to all the Muslims? Were they Muslims or non-Muslims for just reading the Quran?
exactly!, they never answer that
they still had hadith and they had teachings from their forefathers as they closer to the time of the prophet, students of the sahabi were probs still alive at that time as well and also you had the 4 imams who were part of the salaf, the hadiths were still there they just werent collated
This brother schooled the hadiths followers congrats bro Kamran👏
Nice joke
All he did is go off on a non stop talking spree and didn't answer anything that was asked.
We pray as Prophet Abraham prayed, that's what prophet Muhammad was instructed to do, ثم أوحينا اليك ان اتبع ملة ابراهيم حنيفا
how can you know the story of first verse of surah israa. the night journy of the phorphet s.a.w with out the hadeeth.
the only person in this video who wasnt ignorant was this brother. You have the 2 in the back who have been in fights before on camera! soon as he said his name they started bashing him like little children, he put all of them in there place by not biting on their arrogance
This man is more dangerous than any other non Muslim.
How do we know the Quran is from Allah??? Scientific evidence. This is enough to believe the Quran can only be the true word of God without having any information on who compiled the Quran...
Quranist bro??
sara ali scienctific evidence?
Allah Almighty says in the Quran that "Obey Allah and obey the Rasool"
Now it is logical to reason that the "obey Allah" can be interpreted that obey the Quran.
Now the question is what is meant by "obey the Rasool"?
Now there can be two answers which are (a) "obey the Rasool" means obey the hadith and Sunna (b) "obey the Rasool" also means obey what is in the Quran. Now compare (b) with the interpretation of "obey Allah". So if that is someone's understanding then they are basically saying that Allah Almighty after already having said "obey Allah" (meaning obey what's in the Quran), Allah saying "Obey the Rasool" (meaning obey Quran) becomes redundant Astughfirullah. So one is left with only one logical solution i.e. "obey the Rasool" means obey the hadith and the Sunna of the Holy Prophet (PBUH).
Furthermore Allah says that His Prophet (PBUH) does not say anything from himself. His Prophet (PBUH) says what Allah wants him to say. Therefore rejecting Hadith is rejecting the word of Allah.
May Allah bless brother Adnan and other brothers who were trying to convince Kamran to start believing in the Hadith. Insha Allah one day he will.
Jazakullah for this beautiful video.
Obey the rasool means obeying the message he preached which is the quran. The prophet only followed what Allah revealed to him nothing else.
Why do you think Allah said obey the messenger and not Mohammed because we are not allowed to follow anything else but the message of Quran. What Allah wanted The prophet to say was revealed in the Quran. But history repeats itself God gave the jews and christians one book and instead they attributed other books to Moses and Isa and now follow their “words” instead of the Torah or Injeel. Same here people made a whole book attributed to the prophet and are now worshiping him beside Allah. For example the wudu is clearly written in the Quran but instead we follow how the prophet apparently did wudu in hadith and therefore you are putting the prophet his words above Allah which is shirk. Why would the prophet make wudu differently than in the Quran how God revealed it to him. The prophet was just a messenger and a human being like us. He was not a lawmaker or anything like that.
Quran never told us to kiss the stone.
Just because someone reported that prophet did it should everyone do it
If you have proof please show
I still don't get it... Adnan trying to convince him how we know Quran is from God if we don't know from where the Quran was transmitted. He tries to argue that if the Quran was transmitted from the chain of narration is true, then if the hadith was transmitted from the same chain of narration then the hadith also is true. The fact is, the Quran was written down and memorized by people at that time. .. and its different from the hadith.
I love Kamran and what he is saying. And these people making fun of him is ridiculous. To be Muslim and go to Jannah Quran is.enough. To be the slave of Arabs and tell tales on Khalifah and fight about Sunni and Shia is not relevant to me. He is making perfect sense. Kamran reply me, bro, i really like your videos and what you say.Kamran you are changing hearts keep doing the great work don't get mocked down by hecklers. they think they have command over Allah's text and ony they can interpret it and every other human is incompetent to them. Exactly what Jewish rabbis and Christian priests did... Quran is for every human being and every new convert accepts Islam on basis of Quran, not headeth. Quranist is the only sane and intellectually acceptable position for anyone right now. I believe in Sahih Bukhari but thinking of changing my beliefs.
321bluff Honestlt the hadith taught us the beautiful character of Muhammed pbuh and how just he was how patient he was how he cares for his wifes how he managed a whole nation. With out this it would be so difficult to govern a sharia country
Sheikh TV
Everything is in the Qur'an. Allaah praise the Prophet (pbuh) for his beautiful manners and characteristics. His grief for his people, his sorrow that his contemporaries were not accepting the message. So from this we can perceive that our Prophet was a humble and kind man who wanted others to be guided to the right path. We don't need narrations to tell us about the characteristics about the Prophet (pbuh) when we have the Qur'an.
What about narrations of killing women and children? Narrated by Jathama and yes many scholars has tried to explain away the narration by saying that it's abrogated or that it's not wrong if women and children are caught in the crossfire.
If there are many ahadith that speaks highly about the Prophet, we can also read many things that insult the Prophet
How can you obey Allah and his teachings when you are rejecting the Hadith which tells you exactly how you must follow Allah? Simple answer is...you ca't. You end up making your own rules and interpretations of the Qur'aan and get lost. Do't understand why you reject the Hadith. Makes no sense.
Why do you believe in the Quran and not the hadith when they were both transmitted by the same people?
Abbas aboud council of nicea comes to mind in your comment. ✌& may God keep us on the right path.
Brother Cameron speaks the truth.. Allah said in the Quran that the Quran is the last and final revelation!! Anyone that follows hadith as guidance has come to the understanding that they need more than the Quran for guidance.
Please explain how the Qur'an got to you?
I believe Allah will preserve the Quran.. not hadiths
Quran has been momorized in entirely by many Muslims worldwide wide. Cant say the same for hadith.
@@shawnmustapha2817 please explain how the Qur'an got to you...
🤣🤣☝️
The Quran does say it’s fully detailed.
So if you don’t believe that and it’s god word. How can you then go follow hadiths from people who are companions of the one who got the word directly when you don’t want to follow the revelation. We have to make sense. Those who read the Hadith should just say they read them cause it’s traditional instead of arguing against those who only read the Quran.
Our brothers need to be more patient, humble and understanding with the brothers that need guidance. They just standing there mocking him. They don’t even behave like that in front of christians, Kermits or disbelievers. Guide our brothers and sister with humbleness and not with mocking.
Adnan should refer them to hadith scholars who can answer them more clear and direct to the point, rather than bringing them around with questions which can lead them more confused about hadith and they keep staying as hadith unbelievet. This is not a topic to debate, but a topic more to be explained by the hadith professionals.. There are many in Jordan, Indonesia and Malaysia who are specialists in hadith..
Beautiful quran's meaning is twisted by many of the "true" believers ...they say quran is easy if it's that easy than why so many different interpretations...also why putting down noble of the noblest and honorable men of quran...why...
Shia spotted! I stop watching the video when he said he pray 3 times a day.
Quranist pray 3 times a day as well, because they interpreted from the Quran that the time of prayers are 3
shia pray 5 they just pair 2 of there namaz together
E. K Ex Shia English video part 1:- ruclips.net/video/kxQ_YABUmJ8/видео.html
Ex Shia English video part 2:- ruclips.net/video/_0SyGKXh-rQ/видео.html
Ex Shia Sister:- ruclips.net/video/b30nBs6cESI/видео.html
Ex Shia English video:- ruclips.net/video/Ecbu8XFGui0/видео.html
Ex Shia English video:- ruclips.net/video/ska4YIvMX7g/видео.html
Ex Shia English video:- ruclips.net/video/4-WY26iK7gY/видео.html
Ex Shias:- ruclips.net/video/lLhy6b_3IU8/видео.html
Shia Sunni English debate:- ruclips.net/video/S7sQbvcer0o/видео.html
Shia Sunni English debate:- ruclips.net/video/3Yq7weTi8WY/видео.html
Shia Sunni English debate:- ruclips.net/video/L8vpT_soOno/видео.html
Exactlt
45:6) These are Allah's verses that We narrate to you in Truth. In what kind of discourse after Allah and His verses will they, then, believe?8
answer the question
The Qur’an is a book revealed by God that does not resemble hadiths at all.
Nobody can come up with the Qur’an, as for hadiths, they can
Wasn't it sufficient for them? We sent down the book to you, and it would be recited to them?
Answer this question also if you can
14:1 “Alif, Lam, Ra. [This is] the Book which We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], that you might bring mankind out of darknesses into the light by permission of their Lord - to the path of the Exalted in Might, the Praiseworthy “- Ponder and reflect on the verse ... the verse is clear and crystal clear ... and it means that the exit of people from darkness to light and then to the straight path is exclusively by the book. ... and people leaving the darkness to the light and then to the straight path is the highest goal, so if the servant attains that, what is our need for the prophetic Sunnah?
Fear God and may God teach you
Is piety scientific testimony or inside the heart?
Answer if you can
And if he was surprised, then he was surprised by their saying
I do not attack you, but I bemoan you association the Sunnah with the Book and I invite you to the religion of Abraham, to be honest, and he was not among the polytheists
If I tell you that prayer, zakat and all acts of worship are present in the Qur’an, then what is our need for the Sunnah?! .....
Do not be from those whom God said:
(42:21) “Do they have any associates (of Allah) who have laid down for them a way pertaining to faith which Allah did not sanction?”
Do not associate with God unless God has revealed authority,
And do not answer me with a demonic answer, such as those who say: Obey God and obey the Messenger, evidence of the existence of the Prophet’s Sunnah. This is a vague answer and the Qur’an is clear and not vague. Sincerely review yourself, you will find the right path with the help of ALLAH
Adnan can also convince him by asking about history ( British empire)
Similarities between history & hadees
2:11 that's gonna be so ironic for him to hear back on the judgment day.
He believes in the Quran, he wants the Quranists answer on how we know the Quran we have is the Quran that was revealed to the prophet. You cannot prove the Quran is persevered from itself, that is a circular argument, the only way you prove the Quran is preserved is through an unbroken to the Prophet and this is the evidence and miracle that Allah has blessed the Muslims with this preservation. So by rejecting the chains of hadith and those who transmitted this, we reject the Quran.
They are more worried about knowing what a scholar stated about what supposed companions recorded 200 years after the prophets death that the words written in Quran. Salah is described fully in Quran. We are responsible for ourselves our own soul
When was the Quran written??? These "supposed companions" wrote the very same Quran???
@@mohammadrizwaan1890 reread what I wrote. You missed the point about the Quran being the guide for Salat. Further, these companions are supposed companions because neither you nor I can verify for ourselves who said what, we are taking the words of other men. But I will concede and accept this in the case of the Quran.
@@AllAllah777 We can verify that the companions wrote this as each and every hadith, each companion had 100s of students, we have the testimonies of thousands at each generation, such a witnessing has not been there for any other event/s in any civilisation, we know who studied from whom and who witnessed this from whom, there is no area left blank, read the basics of ilm e rijal, then come back to me. The Quran through this very same unbroken perfect methodology by Allah's blessings came to me and you today.
@@AllAllah777 Tell me how does one understand verses about jihad and the conditions of jihad, like you cannot kill women and children intentionally from the Quran??? There is no mention of this. In fact many stories in the Quran cannot be understood without the explanation the Quran mentions, from the prophet SAW.
Btw are u from the nation of Islam branch as I have had a chat with one of them before and they also seemed to be against the hadith.
@@AllAllah777 Imam Bhukari "the scholar" 200 years after did not transmit from.himself. do you not understand what a chain of narration is, he got the hadith from his teacher along with 1000's of student from his time, and they from theirs, and there's from the sahabah, and the sahabah from the prophet.
Just like we know Newton's laws today as professors have transmitted them down, but with more sophistication, and ensuring that those transmitting it are of the utmost reliability.
Not believing in the ahadith means you are making your own interpretations of the Quran. A person's understanding differs from the other. This will gv rise to many variations n eventually divisions in the ummah. Whereas, the understanding of the Quran together with the ahadith brings unity
I realised sunnis lack of evidence for sunnism.. i think Adnan do not aware that is dangerous to ignore the message and to argue with Quranic verses...
we have earliest manuscripts of Quran but not Hadith
@ muslims
I guess this guy doesn’t pray the 5 daily prayers because if you reject hadith you can’t pray; the 2, 3 and 4 rackats are not in the quran I think, it’s from hadith
If you want to know how christianity started just look at those supposed quranist
These people are super lost... Oh Allah please guide these brothers because they are from ummat of Mohammed sallallahu alaihiwasallam. Ameen
Yes, you hadithans are lost deviants,
how did he make the assumption that the quran is a mirculous text if he dont even know arabic???!!!!
How do you know this Qur'an is from God, it could be from anyone else? The question is for you too as a Sunni.
This same question is asked by non-muslims to sunnis and shias as well and believing in hadith doesn't bring a satisfactory answer to this question. Have non-muslims been convinced with the help of Hadith that Quran is from Allah? Non-muslims get inspiration by Vedas, Bible etc. Does that mean that if they read Hadith they will be convinced that Quran is from Allah? They read hadith and study all kinds of stuff and still don't believe the Quran is from Allah. Even if you prove that the Quran is coming from Mohammad using some stores from hadith, then you still have to prove it is from God and not from Mohammad.
Quran, 4:82 Then do they not reflect upon the Qur'an? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.
Quran, 2:23-24 And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down upon Our Servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah the like thereof and call upon your witnesses other than Allah, if you should be truthful. But if you do not - and you will never be able to - then fear the Fire, whose fuel is men and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.
Bro quran is from allah....its comes Through revelation to prophet mohammad (pbuh)....tell me how the quran that is today was compiled and how do u pray
Omerfaruk Anik did you learn how to pry from Hadith?? Where did learn it from? If it not from Hadith then Hadith is not needed. Quran is complete and Allah is our best teacher.
@@stoneisland6712 Holy Quran doesn't give directions to pray Salah! It is indeed from the hadeeth!
@@nuhashahmed7692 who taught you how to pray. Do you need Hadith?
@@nuhashahmed7692 in addition who told you which direction to pray, your father, or imam etc or was it Hadith?
Adnan is amazing and briljant سالم from Holland ☺
I wud just ask a question... Y was Quran revealed to prophet pbuh in 23 years...... It could have been sent to every1 individually to practice according to what they extract from it. And not the way of prophet taught it was meant to be.. Coz hadees is the way of prophet. And we belive from Quran to have belief in Allah and believe in his messenger.... 2 seperate belief words were used.... 1 for Allahs words. And 2nd for his prophets words
In the Qur'an, it is one belief. Allah tells us that if we obey the Messenger we obey Allah (SWT).
yh ok bud next time im in the heavens i will let god know not to reveal divine knowledge to a man in the desert in a 23 year gap.i'll let him know its inconvenient becuase shabaz khan said so
@ i dont think its inconvenient. I think it makes sense, coz if it was revealed naozbillah to steve jobs. You guys would be like. Look he has all that technology and algorithm to write it. And its not a word of god. And as hytham said its one belief, i agree. I meant it in 2 different approaches. Belief in prophet, and belief in Allah
In this case, brother adnans reasoning was as good as any christian evangelist in the park.
especially when Adnan believes that Shakespeare was divinely inspired XD, sunnis go to so much pathetic methods to attack Quran alone path.
I think br hamza needs to have a word with these guys lol
This guy is misguided....he doesn't care who transmitted the Quran !
one simple thing we can ask. If you reject Hadith then how do you pray, how do you fast, how do you give charity and how to you perform haj.
MAN IN CERTAIN PLACES HE TRY TO PUT pROPHET MUHAMMAD OUT OF THE PICTURE OF ISLAM BECAUSE OF HIS EGO EVEN HE WILL SAY AT ONE POINT HE WILL SAY THERE IS NO NEED OF MUHAMMAD S.A.W TO FOLLOW SUNNAH maY ALLAH GUID HIS SOUL
This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111
This verse alone shows we shouldn't be believe in any hadith. If God says, the Quran is a DETAILED ACCOUNT OF ALL THINGS, therefore there's no need for hadith. Saying stuff like prayer isn't in the Quran means this verse is false, and cannot be from God because he is the Perfect, Wise.
The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of God's message). 5:99
This verse shows the sole duty of the prophet Muhammad was to only deliver the Quran.
Obey God and obey the messenger. If you turn away then the sole duty of the messenger is the clear delivery (of God's message). 64:12
Now how do you obey the messenger, you listen to the message, which is the QURAN. This verse doesn't mean to follow Bukhari's false book which came much later after the the Prophet had died. If a messenger came to you with a message and you listened, it means your obeying the messenger, if you pushed away the message your disobeying the messenger. It doesn't say obey the PROPHET for a reason.
It (Quran) is a revelation from the Lord of the worlds. Had he (Muhammad) falsely attributed any sayings to Us, We would have grabbed him by the right, and We would have severed his aorta. None of you would be able to prevent it. And indeed, it is a reminder for the reverent. 69:43-48
This verse shows the job of the prophet was not to command any other teachings except the Quran.
A Book (Quran) has been brought down to you (O Muhammad), so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers.
Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember! 7:2-3
Once again, the prophet was commanded to follow what was brought down to him, and as per the words in 7:2, God mentions only the Quran for what was brought down.
Throughout the Quran, we cannot see any evidence of any revelation Muhammad received from God other than the Quran.
And thus We have made enemies for every prophet, human and jinn devils, inspiring to one another fancy sayings in deception. 6:112
If you really dig into the hadith, WHICH IS THE WORD OF MAN NOT GOD, there are some nasty stuff about the prophet. Its disrespecting him if we follow something that he wasn't there to authenticate. I mean if u really look into it you can clearly see its fabricated, but of course God, The Almighty guides whom he wills. Its also not my place to say most people are wrong, God is the best judge.
And the Messenger has said, "O my Lord, indeed my people have taken this Quran as [a thing] abandoned."
Why would the prophet Muhammad say this and why him. 1) the whole hadith is about him. 2) Islam says its primary book is the Quran, however literally everything Islam does is from the fabricated hadith. Such as the prayer, the 2.5 zakat and much more. Most Muslim recite the Glorious Quran in Arabic, when they don't know a single word in the language, and God says this book is a guidance for the believers. How is this right, nowhere in the Quran doesn't it say u must learn Arabic or recite in a foreign language. Of course it is good to learn and UNDERSTAND Arabic to get a deeper understand of the Quran but if u want the basic and important message, its unnecessary.
O you prophet, why do you prohibit what God has made lawful for you, seeking to please your wives? God is Forgiver, Merciful. 66:1
Saying the prophet made music haram, which is nowhere in the Quran, goes against the Quran. Music is just one example there are loads of haram things in the hadith, its a joke. I mean its so hard to live obeying the hadith. When you push all fabricated sources and follow the true law, the Quran, life becomes simple and clear, your eyes starts opening up to your true purpose, in this life.
Your an idolater if you uphold any religious book except the Quran. Your basically doing what the Christians did and following the word OF MAN AND NOT GOD.
Think about it God's previous books have been corrupted by man and shaytan. God has said he'll protect his last book, The Quran, but was has the shaytan done now, created the hadith to lead people astray.
There so much more with how the hadith contradicts with the Quran but 'll just leave you with one more verse.
We have placed veils over their hearts so that they do not understand it,
and deafness in their ears. And when you mention your Lord, in the Quran ALONE,
they turn their backs and run away in aversion.
17:46
All praise belongs to the LORD OF THE THRONE.
brothers have tapped him masha allah.... but they don't have to laugh at him... it may lead to further harden him in his stance just becoz of anger.... !! although i was also laughing throughout the time... this poor guy have no logic in rejecting hadidh.... !
These hadith rejectors seem to have the same weak formula. They seem to have gone through teh same kind of training.
How do I know that the Quran is from the almighty?
Holy Son read it. Allah gives us proofs to verify its authenticity within the book itself. Read it and trust Allah. Very simple.
Because of this kind of stubborn people Islam is so misinterpreted !
Hadith's are problematic as per Dr shabir Ally, then how we know which is right and wrong, so we need to Cherry pick, which verse according to our present time makes sense, this becomes like cheating the public,
45:6) These are Allah's verses that We narrate to you in Truth. In what kind of discourse after Allah and His verses will they, then, believe?8
answer the question
The Qur’an is a book revealed by God that does not resemble hadiths at all.
Nobody can come up with the Qur’an, as for hadiths, they can
Wasn't it sufficient for them? We sent down the book to you, and it would be recited to them?
Answer this question also if you can
14:1 “Alif, Lam, Ra. [This is] the Book which We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], that you might bring mankind out of darknesses into the light by permission of their Lord - to the path of the Exalted in Might, the Praiseworthy “- Ponder and reflect on the verse ... the verse is clear and crystal clear ... and it means that the exit of people from darkness to light and then to the straight path is exclusively by the book. ... and people leaving the darkness to the light and then to the straight path is the highest goal, so if the servant attains that, what is our need for the prophetic Sunnah?
Fear God and may God teach you
Is piety scientific testimony or inside the heart?
Answer if you can
And if he was surprised, then he was surprised by their saying
I do not attack you, but I bemoan you association the Sunnah with the Book and I invite you to the religion of Abraham, to be honest, and he was not among the polytheists
If I tell you that prayer, zakat and all acts of worship are present in the Qur’an, then what is our need for the Sunnah?! .....
Do not be from those whom God said:
(42:21) “Do they have any associates (of Allah) who have laid down for them a way pertaining to faith which Allah did not sanction?”
Do not associate with God unless God has revealed authority,
And do not answer me with a demonic answer, such as those who say: Obey God and obey the Messenger, evidence of the existence of the Prophet’s Sunnah. This is a vague answer and the Qur’an is clear and not vague. Sincerely review yourself, you will find the right path with the help of ALLAH
salaat (prayers) its from beginning from Adam A.S to Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Bath taking is from the beginning. wadoo befor prayers is from the beginning . Quran is the true word of Allah. its from Allah. I believe in the prophet Muhammad pbuh saying . but every Hadith is the the word of prophet pbuh. after the Death of prophet Muhammad pbuh. many hypocrites invented different hadiths to harm islam.
Inventing history are we? Funny how no one during that time and after, ever thought any of that harmed Islam, except the deviants that came long afterwards, that became accustomed to living among disbelievers and accepted that way of life and became ignorant of what their own religion taught, and learned and did not like what they found so they decided to start changing Islam to suit them and to please non muslims.
You can make all the claims you like. Facts do not support your made up nonsense.
Can you tell us the purpose of the life of the Prophet (saws)? Allah could reveal the Quran without the need of Prophet Muhammad (saws).
Show the Br the Quran(In certain Arabian countries) with no Instructions on how to read-Zubr Zerr and Peesh.
Then he will know what importance the hadith have.
Or show him the Manuscripts and ask him read them.
May Allah guide him or break his back in the hereafter!
Haz Med I did read my comment again please "may Allah guide him..."
gaza geeza or may Allah guide you for rejecting Allah in favour of man made books and having man as a guide over Allah.
Are you serious? Suposed to be good muslims, and they laughin and whispering like little girls. This disapointed me adnan, you should'nt let them stand beside you. And how can you stand there without shame when those two are bulliyng that guy.