Amber Heard v. Danielle Redlick: Victim or Vindictive?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2024
- Victim or Vindictive? #CourtTV’s Michael Ayala speaks with a body language expert about the testimony of #AmberHeard and #DanielleRedlick and who was more believable and why.
Redlick was found not guilty of the murder of her husband she says was abusive during their marriage.
WATCH #CourtTV LIVE - court.tv/live
COURT TV IS BACK! 24/7 LIVE gavel-to-gavel coverage, in-depth legal reporting, and expert analysis of the nation’s most important and compelling trials.
WATCH COURT TV LIVE:
www.courttv.co...
WATCH TRIALS ON DEMAND:
www.courttv.co...
WHERE TO WATCH:
www.courttv.co...
![Quando Rondo - Grow Up [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8zFnCg3BO4Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Danielle is a genuine and heartbroken woman who deserves to be treated with kindness and compassion. AH has no place among real victims of DV.
You are exactly right Holly. We still have to believe women when they been abused. But we all seen day and night between Danielle and AH. We all can watch a trial and just about tell who's telling truth and who is not.
Plain and simple
This proves that all the comments about Johnny’s victory being a loss for women were complete trash. Justice wins. I’m sorry, but this woman was dependent on him her whole adult life. She didn’t add extra details. Her attorney had to pull most out of her. A lot of victims underplay, not overplay what happened to them (unlike amber).
YEP, also she’s way calmer and actually retelling events
Beautifully said. Also, her details are details that MAKE SENSE. She gave phenomenal testimony. She and her attorney won this case (imo) with her on the stand. I’m glad she was found not guilty and I hope she gets ‘time served’ at sentencing.
I saw so many survivors coming forward saying that they are happy for Johnny and mad at Amber. They see see there abuser in her and so do I. I saw men coming forward and read a twitter post of somebody that works for a DV hotline and said 2 male survivors called and that this is more in the last 1 or two years. So it‘s a victory for survivors. Based on facts/evidence ppl should acknowledge Amber lied.
Agree totally, A H is INSANE!
Uh thank you Ambers loss was a victory for me and every woman that was physically or mentally abused. I cry EVERYDAY and my tears are REAL!!
Bless her heart. I didn’t know what to make of her until her testimony. She did a phenomenal job on the stand and the jury agreed. This is what it looks like when a REAL VICTIM tells their story. Yesterday was a good day for Ms Redlick, as well as, abuse victims around the country!
agree, I waited until she testified there are things that don't add up, but I believe her.
Its disgusting that Heard is portrayed as a victim. Even more disgusting that Mainstream Media gives this abusive woman a platform. I am so releived the jury believed Danielle. I knew nothing when I happened across her trial on the day she was testifying. She was a broken woman. The prosecutor was repulsive. As a victim of sexual violence I thought his questioning was abusive.
I didn't know much about Daniel redlick trial prior to stumbling upon it myself But I also believe the prosecutor was really Abusive He was just badgering her left in right Belittling her How she didn't break down. But this is certainly not the 1st time and abusive wife has finally fought back and killed the bastard Who abused her
Heard is no victim. She is the victimizer, IMO.
I watched this trial, the state was so disrespectful to her and her lawyers. They spoke to them as if they were superior to them. They spoke like our evidence is much more then yours.
When she told her story, she cried TEARS. When she was telling her story, I cried, she told the truth, she owned up to the lies she told and she seemed afraid for her life. It was so wonderful to see her smile.
That's what they do
@@julieraichart7961 it is sad really. Like okay we get it you have loads of evidence.
BUT there was alot of evidence contamination and also unessisary witnesses.
I feel Danielle's lawyers were very calm and very collected. They represented her very well. Their questions were straight to the point.
This women really shows how exaggerated and unbelievable Amber Heard is. This women used the right tenses the whole time, she just went through facts step for steps and didn’t start talking about the type of counter top or what she was thinking. She also didn’t preface anything with “I remember”, she just said what she remembered. Also! Her body was in position to the situation where as Amber heard was positioning as the aggressor like with the bottle saying “did you drink all this” before throwing it rather than having defensive blocking like she said she had.
Very well said! You’re absolutely right.
You can tell this lady has been victimized for a long time!! I'm glad they found her not guilty!! As for Amber, I have one word:LIAR!!!!
She didn't ramble on like AH did, she just answered the questions of her. The jury found her credible.
She wasn't replying to the jury each time a question was asked
Danielle absolutely saved herself. I watched the entire trial. Her lawyers were terrible. She was credible and explained the 11 hours in a way that made sense and was believable. This was night two of a brutal fight. the night before she provided texts between herself and two children, while she was hiding in the bathroom and the kids were waiting for him to pass out. They were all scared. Her testimony wasn't elaborate. She didn't embellish. She acknowledged she made bad choices after stabbing him once in a place that wouldn't seem to be fatal. imo the jury got this one correct as they got the JD/AH mostly correct. AH wasn't the victim. JD was the victim. AH shouldn't have received a dime.
The difference in both testimonies is AH 's hand kept pointing to the wrong side considering JD is right handed DR is placing her hands in the correct place if her husband was right handed.
Yes and she did not act out what was done to her as you usually do.
Exactly!! I was wondering how no one asked her this question her bruises are all on her right side. Which is crazy. So what JD hit her from behind to keep the same side? Would t he have punched her o. The left side if he is standing in fro t of her??
Amber is vindictive. You can tell and fits her pattern.
Amber heard went
Out of way to ruin Johnny maliciously!
This is how a witness is supposed to respond to questions 🙄
Not that crap that Amber Heard was spitting out of her mouth 💀
every time she opens it she proves Dr Curry was correct in her diagnosis!
Amber is mental
She was not freaking out the jury by staring at them and seeking approval. She was not combative or defensive when answering the questions, just very matter of fact. "Truth tellers tell, liars sell."
I notice that the attorneys seem to be extra rude to the real victims when they are trying to defend the wrong side. Not sure how these people can live with themselves.
I didn’t see a stoic person I saw a lady who was just deflated & exhausted, the emotions that she must of gone through from then until now will more than likely take a while for her to come to terms with, I feel the state prosecutor was an awful example to be involved in this way! Aggressive towards a potential domestic violence victim was painful to watch he made me feel attacked, just so wrong!!
Yes. Someone that learned from when she was 22 or so to not react. She probably spent their whole relationship trying not to set him off.
yes. i hated the prosecutor. he was on a 10 level of aggression constantly for no reason. She wasn't evasive. There was no reason for him to attack her nonstop. It was a really bad look. She had me completely on her side by the end of the testimony.
You become so tired of it all; the headaches, the tears , retelling the ordeal, etc. After 6 years of it being over, AH definitely had crocodile tears
What IF the prosecutor did it purposely...?? Knowing his aggression would not play well with the jury. Maybe he secretly believed she was innocent but had to comply with instructions from his superiors...
As the man guest commented, the prosecutor did not do such a good job on cross. That big a mistake?? In a murder trial...??
Just saying........✌😀
@@shaneisaac1184 I must admit I’ve seen other cases where I’ve thought the same too
As they say.... Truth tellers tell.... Liars SELL! 🤷♀😌 IM SO GLAD SHE WON and it's proof that real victims will be "Heard" 😏
A better comparison would be between Jodi Arias and Amber Heard.
YES!
Ha ha ha lol yesss
Danielle Redlick was correctly judged, Danielle was a victim. Her actions right after the incident are very questionable, but she acted in self defense at the moment.
Im sure she was in shock.. she knew she had to kill or be killed by that Man.
I think it's shock and consistent with JD taking several hours to go to hospital after his injury, he was in shock.
But…but…Amber Heard told me that women who speak out will fail. There’s no amount of prepping and coaching that could prevent Amber Heard’s narcissism from doing what she did on the stand.
IN MY VIEW
When you first brought the subject comparing Danielle Redlick with Amber I almost stopped watching the video.because I thought it was going to be sensational comments. I am so glad I kept watching because you and your guests were professional with all of your simple, clear and common sense explanations.
The jury are so valuable in any trial and I think they take their duty very seriously and get to the truth of the matter
From the button of my heart, I do thank Danielle Lawyer's for take her case and make the difference in her life, our communities and her children.
I never understand why people get physical. Even in their 60s? If someone betrays you, ditch them and move on.
I hope you are never in the situation to find out.
@@theoryofpersonality1420 I slapped my ex ONCE in my teens. That was the ONLY Time I ever hit a girl. People normally outgrow their emotional immaturity but not Michael Redlick.
Because you are a clueless idiot. Get real.
Well Amber nothing was set back as you said. Justice wins
The fact that anyone would ever call amber heard a victim after hearing a REAL testimony of domestic violence is ridiculous. She should be charged with harassment at this point.
Very interesting to have both of these trials happening during the same time. I’m happy for Danielle, I didn’t follow the case but I saw pieces of it, but I liked when she was hearing the verdict and if you listen closely you can hear her ask her lawyer “can I thank them? (Jury)” I thought that was a true testament to her character. She did try thanking them as they were released.
She was on dating apps while she waited 11 hours to call 911.
There is no justice for male victims of DV still.
I watched Redlick’s direct n cross examination, she was so candid n believable, completely different from AH!
why don't you compare JD who was a victim to Danielle 🤔 there is no comparison to Amber except being women
This is highly interesting on so many levels. As a real victim, I could feel Danielle's pain and I could feel her strength to be able to get through this all. But Amber's testimony, I just felt complete anger cause I just had a bad feeling the whole time.
Contradicting with what AH and her attorney, Elain, claimed about the “set back” for women whose the victim of DV, with the verdict of “not guilty” proven there’s NO set back. There’s life lost and yet the jurors rendered the verdict “not guilty” because the jurors believed Danielle’s victim of DV where in AH’s case - AH was not believed by neither the jurors nor the public.
No contrast she looks exhausted and very believable.
Amber heard was very bad acting and the looking at the jury constantly and she came out with crazy things.
Her new interview where she said johny convinced the world he has scissors for hands was a did she just say that moment. 🤯
Also her testimony doesn't add up to him calling 911 before all of that
V is for Vindictive. Well I don't see why she would make step dad her husband in the first place too weird and creepy to me. As for Amber Vindictive as usual.
VINDICTIVE!! Sorry, but I just needed to shout. Someone is going to be walking free soon and I think many of us know exactly what she did.
I agree with you. She was the vindictive toxic one
I watched both of these and was astounded at the difference. Danielle, true DV survivor. AH, a prevaricator.
AH was putting on a elaborate performance, not a good one at that! This poor woman on the other hand has been through a horrific experience without performing to jury. Bless her.
When AH do the gestures of physical abuse, her acts were as she the aggressor
AH is vindictive
Heard is probably studying this case for future reference.
She is done.... 😂 😂
Mr. Redlick is gone and it wasn’t from old age. She is guilty. JMO
Danielle is believable because she actually shows the people what happened, not staring at the jury box answering the questions
There is absolutely no comparison. "...Bee-YOU-tiful wooden floors..."
"And I remember thinking, WHY is this CARpet so DIRty..."
"Omg it's night and day" lol damn
So happy for Danielle Redlick. Jury did their job.
She didn't have any injuries and yet it's self defense
you dont need to be injured physically to be afraid for your life. And defend yourself. Danielle may have meant to stab him, but she did not mean to kill him.
Thoughts on Amber dressing like Johnny everyday…especially that brown, it out and was very noticeable and CREEPY? Was that trial strategy or straight crazy stalking him or trolling him??
I wish this narrative of Danielle "waiting" to call 911 would shift. It's not as though she sat tapping her foot just running out the clock, she was put into a sort of manic state in which her instinct told her to just clean up the terrifying bloody scene in front of her. To me it didn't appear as though her aim was to obstruct evidence, it was just an emotional irrational response to the horror.
Yes Danielle is❣️real victim
The prosecutor was too aggressive, period. I know that's his job, but it was too much.
Yes but she didnt break as she was being truthful about her abuse. She lied about cleaning up and confessed after. But she was truthful about her abuse.
She got away with killing that man.
no, she spent over 3 years in jail and has paid her dues- what she did was a defensive-action as self-preservation. the context is extremely important.
@@sarahok6589 not being convicted for killing a man in cold blood is not paying her dues.
I'm glad she got to walk away. At least she did 3 years
The fact that he was her step father before becoming her husband is disgusting. Even if she was an adult the power imbalance is clear!
Mmmmm.....IMO....she is GUILTY....I can't understand how she is not!!! I listened to this entire trial..I just don't find her credible...
@ Nancy Munroe 100%,,,,well said..... have you noticed how Danielle put her head down before the verdict was read because deep down she knew she was going to get convicted,,that's until she realized from her lawyer that she was found not guilty??? you noticed how shocked she was when she found out it was a not Guilty???....and also she gave the jurors a kiss (hands expression) and she also looked at them and said thank you,,,,,Insane verdict
There is such a difference between their stories first Mrs Rednick was not telling a story she was talking about the real abuse she had went through how he manipulated her mind psychologically and how he physically abused her that brought her shame and guilt to speak about what she was living, he had poisoned her self-knowledge of herself and by diminishing her to the point it incapacitated her will to leave him and in these kind of abusive relationship it end very badly with the death of one or the other usually the abused one end up dead.
AH thought she was playing a part in a movie she wrote, nothing about her story was matching her character, her mouth is so dirty and her mind as filthy mixed with her audacity had nothing to do with a real abused women or men but even after losing her case she continued to display to the world what kind of wicked witch she really is so if l was her I would disappear for a very very long time.
As well as her kids where there for her to think about, she may not have had means remember he was her step father before he became her husband. Like he was grooming her.
DR was an excellent witness. I believed her.
What happened to posting the FULL show???
You can't compare the two cases at all!!
After watching the neighbour say she had seen her slapping him around on the driveway and after hearing Michael's call to the police saying he needed a car because she was being a danger to herself and him it was obvious she attacked him. Their daughter testified she was the aggressor and manipulator. I saw a different trial. RIP Michael 😢
the world is crazy
So I learned it IS important of how you look for the outcome of the trial. I have crazy hair and I guess I would loose in court only because of that. Lol
Yep. Better tame it for the jury
@@mangos2888 Can people even do that WHILE being in jail?
She was completely the opposite of Amber Heard. You could tell she was telling the events of something that actually happened. She was forthright in admitting she changed her story and why. She was consistent in her telling of the events under cross examination. She didn’t put on a hysterical, tearless crying show with mountains of inconsistencies and contradictions. So much for Heard’s defeat being a setback for real victims. I’ll also say they could that while wardrobing and hairstyle definitely play in, when you are a liar like Amber Heard hair off your face means absolutely nothing lol. The lies still shine through.
Heard vs Redlick, 10 rounds.
This woman is a true victim, unlike Amber Heard. I'm so tired of hearing Amber on TV and every other medium she can get someone to listen to her.
a true victim could have left though
@@canaryinacoalmine7267 You clearly don't know how it works
@@julieraichart7961 right, because I've never been abused, gotcha.
I agree with the analysis of Count Dracula.
I have mixed feelings about Danielle, she wasn't a submissive, poor little thing controlled by the husband; she slapped him, cursed at him, threw his clothing out on the street, etc. and as her daughter said she was the abuser, she was the one that initiated the arguments, but anyway, that is done, and if she did indeed leave her husband to bleed to death, she will pay, one way or another. Comparing Danielle to Amber is a different story, Danielle was much smarter than Amber and now we can see that the verdict in the J Depp case did not set women back.
My ex literally kicked me in my ribs w/his work boots on. I laid down till he left. Got up, showered, went to work. NO bruises. I couldn’t pick up things from t/floor. But he got away again
My ex would grab my throat to get me down, then punch t/back of my head. No bruises. It was constant. I did go to police. They took him out. However, he was always released. As many times he hit, dragged, chocked, I never bruised.
I’m not siding w/either. I lived it. The 1st time I hit back & went for his sack shocked him. He hit harder. But it was a slow beginning to his end of leaving me alone
She was in need of her mother and he used her .hes so old thank God she getting released she can move on .
🤔🤦♀️🤷♀️ wow
Danielle was in her mid 20’s when he dated her mom. She knew what was going on.
@@Sweetpeabanana 22
Well that's really interesting I never knew about the image consulting and wardrobe shopping for trial although it makes perfect sense to me I have to say whoever was doing amber's hair, make up and her wardrobe Did a fantastic job
Imagine if AH played this lady in a movie? 😂
🤣🤣
She murdered him she never walked away but chose to kill him , what’s the difference a women kills it’s ok a women abusing it’s ok it’s not ok for anyone, , it’s not night day , leave.
you should try and educate yourself - many women have gone to prison for murder - in this case it was a self-defensive reaction
Daniella victim
The other one vindictive
Hey from Sanford!!!
Amber is watching this and taking NOTES so next time she will act more believable since this is expected.
Daniele was certainly abused but what makes my blood boil are these damn prosecutors ! They could get their point across towards the defendant without their vindictive and disrespectful behavior. I'm happy the jury saw the truth. Sadly, from what I've read, Danielle's kids aren't speaking to her. Its a tough situation because their father could have been a great Dad to them but obviously he abused his wife. I hope they can all heal from this.
Court TV - Susan Constantine
Witness preparation with respect to wardrobe, hair, etc. would be very interesting topic for an exclusive feature episode.
Bond is $15,000
She was guilty and got away with murder
She wasn’t though
If he beat her and she meant to kill him.... Can't really blame her sorry
@@sandra969 yes you can blame her. Neighbors family and friends all said she was very aggressive and abusive to him. He even told people that he was afraid she would kill him. He called the police right before she killed him. She lies says he has heart attack and stabbed himself. Then she waits 11 hours to report it after doing a bunch of clean up. Come the f on now. She murdered him in cold blood
I pray the husband's family hire Camille Vasquez and Ben Chew to appeal this case for his justice, or even Juan Martinez because he is a wonderful excellent prosecutor. This case is so heartbreaking! She is really psychotic and does not have traits or an abused woman, I think she is lying too. When I think of woman who were victims of domestic violence, I think and remember the cases of Francine Hughes ("The Burning Bed,") Lorena Bobbitt: "John & Lorena Bobbitt," Betty McMoody ("Not Without my Daughter,") and Nicole Simpson. I think her husband's family really needs to appeal this case, this is really sick and reminds me of Jody Arias as well as traits of Amber Heard. I want to share with everyone part of what I wrote for a book report I did in one of my Psychology courses. This is" insightful" and really describes Amber Heard and sociopaths for everyone's understanding. I hope you like it:
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS
A SOCIAPATH'S PERCEPTION
1. Thou shall not have no
other Gods before me.
I'll worship money, sex, power and the devil himself if I please.
I give allegiance to no one, ever.
2. Thou shalt not take the name
of the Lord, thy God, in vain.
I like being vain and I'll say anything I want to if it impresses, seduces,
controls or destroys others.
3. Thou shalt sanctify the holy day.
The only holy day is when I get my
way, and the darkness is my
best friend. (Many sociopaths have
allegiances and pacts with the devil) to
feel in control. An example of this
would be Jody Arias who practiced
"wicca" which is also witchcraft. The
Columbine High School shooters who
were in the "trench coat mafia" and
had some sort of delusional allegiance
with Adolph Hitler, associating jocks
with Jews.
4. Thou shalt honor thy father
and mother.
I secretly hate and despise my parents and all those authority figures who
want me to be loving and do things
their way.
5. Thou shalt not kill.
I enjoy killing living things and
watching the hopelessness and
helplessness on my victims faces. I
like killing other people's happiness
and dreams. When someone is happy
and doing really good in their life and or has
been really successful in their life
a sociopath is angry and wants to destroy their happiness and success
but if someone is not happy or not doing well in their life
then the sociopath is happy and appears to fixate on their unhappiness.
It's real sick and twisted. Also, family pets are mistreated and mysteriously
disappear without explanation and become real people later on in a sociopath's life.
6. Thou shalt not commit adultery.
Every woman (or man) is fair game
for sexual conquest.
7. Thou shalt not steal.
If I see it and I want it, then it's mine.
8. Thou shalt not bear false
witness against thy neighbor.
I can lie with more confidence than you can tell the truth. Conning,
slandering and verbally manipulating
others is what I do best. This is a true trait of all sociapathic people. This sounds a lot
like Amber Heard and many people I myself as well as other people
have personally observed with some of the people in Abilene, Texas. Cultural difference!
9. Thou shalt not covet thy
neighbor's house.
I see no reason why not, since I deserve it more than him.
10. Thou shalt not covet thy
neighbor's wife or husband.
If it hurts him or her and makes me feel good for the moment, nothing else
matters.
the point : cops n court should treat each case separate So far they don't . they usually take women side automatically
I didn't watch Danielle's trial but it was such a weird thing to know that she married her stepfather so she was groomed in a way. She wasn't perfect for sure and I don't know how she explained away the 11 hours before she called 911 but it must have convinced the jury so she was acquitted. Kudos to her defense lawyer, the guy, not the woman who gave the opening statement-she was terrible.
There's a difference between the two. Danielle must have shown facts and evidence for the jury to be convinced she was defending herself while the Turd was more her 'truth' which were LIES and had no corroborating evidence to back it up. According to the JURY, Danielle was a victim and Amber Turd is a VINDICTIVE PSYCHOTIC LIAR.
Yes! She was groomed! He was a predator and she was abused by him emotionally as well. I only hope she gets the help she needs and will be able to finally find her own voice.
I don't think her hairstyles or clothing choices would work much to the jury. I don't believe she told the truth about her husband 's death either. she looks like a murderer talk like a murderer but there's nothing which could convince me that after one stab, her husband would just go unconscious. it's her husband's choice to not to call 911 for whatever reason he has.
Well both are nice sweet girls but something set them off and turned them so aggressive.
Let’s not forget that he was her step father 🙄 there’s no man in his right mind who will marry his step daughter 🙄 I think she was sexually abused by him that’s why she doesn’t have a choice but to marry him..
Strange isn't it that he phoned 911. That absolutely everyone around him says the same. A lovely guy, who loved his kids
The friends saw her weirdness. He could be sarcastic at times. As so many partners are. That doesn't make them abusers. He was going to be killed one day, this was just the day. She is a very troubled female. Her emotions are strange. She is cold. She was abusive to the children verbally, if not physically. It is troubling that so many females here are so misguided. If they are raising daughters, that troubles me even more.
Objection your honor Hearsay
@@allrise9923 overrule lol
how does this affect lebrons legacy?
IMO, AH had a lot of actions of this poor lady. I wonder if she “borrowed” some of her actions?
I agree with Danielle verdict A young girl in my town left her abuser which made it worse because she got a restraining order He went to her job while she sat in her car on her break and shot her in the head leaving her children without a mother So I believe this man would of killed her So for all the people who has never been in DV relationship don't understand until they walk in someone else's shoes This women is an example of a victim AH is not a victim she is the abuser
All I can say is.....What’s with the ugly hair bun !!! Is that suppose to make you look more innocent !??
Just my opinion you cannot compare her cade with Amber this was a murder case and in my opinion she got away with his murder
@ Priscilla Carter 100%..... have you noticed how Danielle put her head down before the verdict was read because deep down she knew she was going to get convicted,,that's until she realized from her lawyer that she was found not guilty??? you noticed how shocked she was when she found out it was a not Guilty???....and also she gave the jurors a kiss (hands expression) and she also looked at them and said thank you,,,,,Insane verdict
@@pumalogo204 l agree
So amber heard is the state?
This Susan "expert" is easy to dislike.
Vindictive
AH is an obvious case but most women can act better than her
I’m team Danielle . She is a genuine victim. Amber herd is a spoil vindictive person.
Stop stop stop stop 🛑.
👋
As a human we have gut feelings that often lead us right with redlick I just felt she was telling the truth as humans sometimes we feel things and see things with our own eyes she seemed genuine to me and spoke honestly about her actions after the stabbing and before and plus this man was her stepdad turned lover that dynamic alone is not ok in my opinion
A