Who is the Greatest Classic Doctor Who Companion? (Hunger Games Simulator)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
  • it's time for Round 2 in the search to find the greatest Doctor Who companion with the help of a Hunger Games simulator! Who will take the crown as the best Classic Who companion?
    ► Patreon
    / harbowholmes
    ► Subscribe!
    / harbowholmes
    ► Twitter
    / harbowholmes
    ► Discord
    / discord
    ► Reddit
    / harbowholmes
    #DoctorWho #HungerGames

Комментарии • 160

  • @HarboWholmes
    @HarboWholmes  4 года назад +12

    Check out my Discord if you want:
    discord.gg/9VEtaET

    • @zedstrains3460
      @zedstrains3460 4 года назад

      do a villains one with:
      the master
      davros
      missy
      cybermen
      daleks
      weeping angels
      rassilon
      silence
      the beast
      cassandra
      great intelligence?
      and abzorbaloff (just cos)
      judoon
      ood etc.
      should make for some juicy content

    • @Cameron115
      @Cameron115 4 года назад

      I'm a little late and its difficult to get into discord for me so you might not see this but; I have an idea: Many people are asking for a villains episode but I'm thinking that after that (if you do it) what about the best of the companions (after the hunger games between classic and modern doctor who) versus the best of the doctors. Just an idea though, could be interesting.

  • @Domisbeast
    @Domisbeast 4 года назад +101

    11:48
    K9 climbs a tree to rest
    HHMMMMMMMMM

  • @tidmouthmilk12
    @tidmouthmilk12 4 года назад +89

    10:24 "Susan sprains her ankle whilst running away..."
    *Insert clip from the Five Doctors*

  • @NitroIndigo
    @NitroIndigo 4 года назад +68

    "The almighty, bloodthirsty K-9s."

    • @crimsonbutterfly2282
      @crimsonbutterfly2282 3 года назад

      Oh god the K-9's became the Dogs from Black Mirror: Metalhead! 😨

  • @danielcooper3332
    @danielcooper3332 4 года назад +36

    The only way I can deal with the utter betrayal or K9 killing Sarah Jane is to imagine that K9 saw her a legitimate threat and knew he had to kill her first.

    • @rassilontdavros3004
      @rassilontdavros3004 4 года назад +12

      To be fair, that was K9 Mk. I, who never actually met Sarah Jane. She only knew Mks. III and IV.

  • @vibingwiththewind2889
    @vibingwiththewind2889 4 года назад +65

    5:15
    The best part about this is that Brigadier was placed by Nicholas Courtney - but he also played Bret Vyon, Sarah Kingdom's brother. To make it worse, Sarah Kingdom killed him in the original timeline. This is karmic justice.

    • @eclecticdog2k901
      @eclecticdog2k901 4 года назад +7

      And it gives further irony to Jean Marsh (Sara Kingdom's actress, but this time playing an evil queen) later telling the Brigadier that she'd kill him next time she saw him.

    • @vibingwiththewind2889
      @vibingwiththewind2889 4 года назад +5

      @@eclecticdog2k901 You're right - she fought him as Morgana in Battlefield, didn't she? I'd forgotten about that!

  • @juliova2315
    @juliova2315 4 года назад +49

    I loved the end, cause almost all the survivors in day 7 were iconic companions

  • @ishaandw
    @ishaandw 4 года назад +17

    Susan Foreman sprains her ankle while running away from Barbara Wright.
    The Dalek Invasion of Earth anyone?

  • @finnstewart4747
    @finnstewart4747 4 года назад +10

    Barbara missing and accidentally killing Ian is very reminiscent of that time she accidentally knocked him out in The Romans.

  • @ptcarbonproductions2013
    @ptcarbonproductions2013 4 года назад +66

    This one's probably the best yet. Ten days, no hurricane and the winner is the very first companion!
    Though c'mon Nyssa! Couldn't you wait a bit longer with this suicide pact? I was rooting for you, and you just barely missed top 14!
    Oh, and you missed Vicki snuggling with Turlough.

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад +1

      I WAS ROUTING FOR SUSAN SO FUCKING HARD, also so depressed jo never was able to use her escapology

  • @Jedi_Spartan
    @Jedi_Spartan 4 года назад +47

    I was hoping one of the incompetent companions would win... at least there wasn't a hurricane this time.

  • @sinisterinspace
    @sinisterinspace 4 года назад +54

    Nobody:
    K9 Mk2: *fishes*

  • @DogsAreTheBest312
    @DogsAreTheBest312 4 года назад +24

    Love these. Do one where you pair the first 12 Doctors with their most well-known companion. So 1 and Susan, 2 and Jamie, etc.

  • @TheMorlun
    @TheMorlun 4 года назад +9

    5:00 *In Tom Baker's voice* 'Good job, Harry.'

  • @larissa5699
    @larissa5699 4 года назад +13

    I love that the Brig killed Sara because Sara killed her brother, Bret, who was also played by Nicholas Courtney. He got his revenge!

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад +1

      that literally make her missing episode so much more fucked up imo

  • @pharaohrose6070
    @pharaohrose6070 4 года назад +90

    Susan winning. The time lord victorious.

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад +1

      STOOOOPPPPPPP I WOULD LOVE THIS SO MUCH

  • @lornapottinger1142
    @lornapottinger1142 4 года назад +39

    Really enjoying these. Can you do Hunger Games of Dr Who villains ?

  • @bmvthemoviefanatic7282
    @bmvthemoviefanatic7282 4 года назад +6

    The first companion wins. How poetic.

  • @ghstudios5087
    @ghstudios5087 4 года назад +11

    brigadier sings himself to sleep...
    I need that in my brain forever

    • @Quirderph
      @Quirderph 4 года назад +4

      He *does* sing in the ''Doctor in Distress'' song... not very well.

  • @ishaandw
    @ishaandw 4 года назад +6

    Harry Sullivan and Grace Holloway run into each other and decide to truce for the night.
    Doctors Unite!

  • @rassilontdavros3004
    @rassilontdavros3004 4 года назад +5

    So Barbara accidentally killed Ian, Susan was so horrified all she could do was cry, Barbara suddenly decided to kill Susan- possibly to spare her the pain and trauma- and the whole experience broke Susan so completely that all she could do was kill in her anger, becoming the last one standing.
    I’m torn because that’s really kinda fucked up, but I also really kinda want Big Finish to do it

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      if they dont in five years we can sue them

  • @No1ShalkaFan
    @No1ShalkaFan 4 года назад +11

    Maybe Sara woke up and mistook the Brigadier for her brother and didn't think anything of it before he quickly killed her.

  • @royalewithcheese9291
    @royalewithcheese9291 4 года назад +12

    😥 Ace never blew anything up. Loving these simulations there so unpredictable and fun. So far the winners are:
    Doctors - Atkinson
    Modern - Strax
    Classic - Susan...
    And now I really want to see a story with those 3 😎

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      omg let alone just susan and atkinson, atkinson and strax and better yet STRAX AND SUSAN BIGFINISH WHERE YOU AT??

  • @abduthegreat7865
    @abduthegreat7865 4 года назад +24

    Lmao, everytime I picked a favourite they would die a round later.

  • @tardisglitch547
    @tardisglitch547 4 года назад +4

    The reason why they keep using swords is because its classic who so they don't have the budget for explosives

  • @nightowl8477
    @nightowl8477 4 года назад +24

    The Brigadier should have won.

  • @ptcarbonproductions2013
    @ptcarbonproductions2013 4 года назад +4

    7:06 Quiet down, it's in character for them.

  • @luchoney5868
    @luchoney5868 4 года назад +25

    Nobody: ...
    Peri: *Surviving and killing Barbara*
    Harbo: Peri might actually be doing something.🤔
    Also Peri: *Steps on landmine*

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      BRUUHHHHHHH THE FACT PERI KILLED BARBARA IS SOOOO ASTONISHING TO ME

  • @KillerMeme
    @KillerMeme 4 года назад +4

    Love the joke about Tourlough , as if chameleon is the big OG we know from the 5th Doctor’s era

  • @jgr2637
    @jgr2637 3 года назад +3

    Peri is a botanist so actually she'd be good at foraging for food

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад +1

      Im actually pretty excited to see her, im only at season 18 so i still have hella time i feel like but like there hasnt been a single companion im not excited to see, but like im anxious for the fifth doctor's era cause of the things ive heard and like his companions arent as well known or talked about aside from maybe tegan and adric and only adric cause he dies and is the most hated...... but like nyssa, kamileon, tourlough, and peri? fucking super interested, and like i then mel and ace? mel has been mentioned similar to river in how they meet out of order and like obvi river and mel arent leaving the same impact or doing the same but like stuff like that just interests me a lot and like yea ace need i say more?

  • @hernerwerzog9700
    @hernerwerzog9700 4 года назад +13

    It's me again, leaving another insightfull and comedic comment.

  • @cosmichobo4216
    @cosmichobo4216 4 года назад +9

    K-9 Has a Secret Arm

  • @jamesgrieves2669
    @jamesgrieves2669 4 года назад +7

    I will admit I lowkey wanted Peri to win by the end.

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      I DEADASS SAID I WANT SUSAN OR BARBARA TO WIN BUT WATCH PERI WIN LMAOOOO

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      BUT also i cant say shit because id probably do the same exact thing as peri

  • @jaded6530
    @jaded6530 4 года назад +4

    “Three of the best *and Peri*”

  • @SHallAdiag
    @SHallAdiag 4 года назад +5

    "Everyone's favorite companion, Adric." The snark...

  • @mtaimry
    @mtaimry 4 года назад +6

    I like it when you say "shambles"

  • @shortangel333
    @shortangel333 4 года назад +9

    "No one likes Dodo." WRONG! I like her.

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      FUCKING SAME AND HER "LIFE AFTER THE DOCTOR" IS BEYOND FUCKED UP AND DESERVES JAIL TIME BECAUSE WTAF?

  • @dethlokprime8655
    @dethlokprime8655 4 года назад +2

    Susan does a back flip, snaps the Brigadier’s neck, and saves the time stream.

  • @dalekinthewater4708
    @dalekinthewater4708 3 года назад +1

    02:23
    Looks like K9 was angry they cancelled K9 and Company

  • @user-jn1wm3tb8v
    @user-jn1wm3tb8v 4 года назад +16

    I vote for Jo to survive. I'll edit when I find out.
    Edit:😮

  • @ishaandw
    @ishaandw 4 года назад +5

    Leela, Ian Chesterton, Romana II, K9 Mk2 track down and kill Cpt. Mike Yates.
    This broke me. I'm rofl

  • @Alia-bc3rc
    @Alia-bc3rc 4 года назад +2

    In real Hunger Games, Turlough gonna cheat and backstabbing everyone and ended up dead literally backstabbed by Leela in the end.

  • @her0880
    @her0880 4 года назад +4

    You should do one with doctor and companion in each district.

  • @lummy15th
    @lummy15th 2 года назад +1

    You should do more of these for the masters incarnations and other characters like the villains from each doctors era

  • @matthewduncan8523
    @matthewduncan8523 4 года назад +3

    Why does everyone hate Adric? Genuine question. Granted I’ve not watched every episode with him in, only a few if that. But from what I’ve seen he’s really quite sweet
    Oh, and who’d have known this would be such a goldmine for K9 images in my head. Such as him using a sword, drinking, climbing trees, fishing and even being poisoned

    • @matthewduncan8523
      @matthewduncan8523 4 года назад +1

      Layla like I said I haven’t watched a whole lot so I haven’t seen his weird character moment. But so far he just seems like Luke or Adam from the new series but not super narcissistic. I actually like Adric, Adam never.

  • @thereyvan
    @thereyvan 3 года назад +1

    1:38 nah, i think it’s the botany skills, allowing her to figure out which plants are safe to eat, which plants can help treat injuries, and which plants she can trick others into eating /hj

  • @finnstewart4747
    @finnstewart4747 4 года назад +1

    Vicki definitely has it in her to kill, she could be pretty badass quite often. She also very nearly poisoned Emperor Nero and didn't give a shit.

  • @dubliam8064
    @dubliam8064 4 года назад +11

    6:04 Great now someone is gonna make some erotic fan fiction

  • @alfiethomas5632
    @alfiethomas5632 4 года назад +6

    Sarah Jane Smith dies instantly
    THIS GAME IS NULL AND VOID PEOPLE

  • @CineScarborough
    @CineScarborough 4 года назад +1

    Susan Foreman is a great companion, so I'm happy with that.

  • @UgandanPrinc3
    @UgandanPrinc3 4 года назад +3

    TIME LORD VICTORIOUS LETS GOOOOOOOO.
    Also no hurricane

  • @greghawkins59
    @greghawkins59 2 года назад +1

    I like how the events don't track from round to round, I'm surprised people stay dead

  • @timrob12
    @timrob12 4 года назад +2

    Maybe you can also do one like I did where I had the most famous behind-the-scenes crew members from Doctor Who in the Hunger Games, starting with Verity Lambert and ending with Chris Chibnall. (In case of the TV Movie, I threw in Geoffrey Sax, the director, just to represent that era) I know I also threw in a district with Mary Whitehouse and Michael Grade, just for fun. Again, not forcing anything onto you, merely making a fun suggestion.

  • @clueingforbeggs
    @clueingforbeggs 4 года назад +3

    Susan sprained her ankle... Again.

  • @KurtVersaie321
    @KurtVersaie321 4 года назад +4

    Nyssa Appreciation Society wants ro know your location

  • @greghawkins59
    @greghawkins59 2 года назад

    I'd love to see this made into a series

  • @mpawood
    @mpawood 4 года назад +3

    🤣🤣OMG "by three of the best...... and Peri"

  • @bmvthemoviefanatic7282
    @bmvthemoviefanatic7282 4 года назад +1

    Damn K9! Activate MAXIMUM DEFENCE MODE indeed XD

  • @paddystrongjaw9995
    @paddystrongjaw9995 4 года назад +1

    Damn looks like Bret Vyon got revenge on his sister

  • @majortoad101
    @majortoad101 4 года назад +1

    Should do a simulation for the villains next!

  • @thelandofthebears8170
    @thelandofthebears8170 4 года назад +2

    When Benton died I shouted nooooooooooooooo

  • @robertk2194
    @robertk2194 4 года назад +3

    PLEASE DO DIFFERENT VILLAINS

  • @briangressett902
    @briangressett902 4 года назад +1

    I never understood the Adric hate.

  • @gregkava1276
    @gregkava1276 3 года назад

    no because susan is legit iconic and took down a bunch of people, including barbara, like deadass she could win the timewar lol

  • @anemictant587
    @anemictant587 4 года назад +1

    I´d totally buy the Brigadier War Ballad album!

  • @lilianderson8256
    @lilianderson8256 4 года назад +2

    i hope sarah jane wins
    edit - okay nevermind. time to root for ace
    edit - oh for fucks sake

  • @loggior.speedweed4345
    @loggior.speedweed4345 4 года назад +1

    “That’s pretty much in character, since Victoria screams a lot...”
    Don’t you mean Zoe too?

    • @intergalactic92
      @intergalactic92 4 года назад

      Logan R. I mean basically every female companion up until Sarah Jane (and even a few after her) were there to scream and be rescued. Doesn’t mean they are all terrible characters just outdated.

  • @samuelbarber4154
    @samuelbarber4154 4 года назад +2

    Well he's traitorous, she was his loving owner for years.

  • @mrjekyllandhyde9941
    @mrjekyllandhyde9941 4 года назад +4

    FYI Nyssa is pronounced Nissa not Neesa

  • @LicencetoWho
    @LicencetoWho 4 года назад +1

    Turlough was great imo :D

  • @samuelbarber4154
    @samuelbarber4154 4 года назад

    I didn't see the winner coming but I support it, I did like her as a companion. Hey there's a thought, the original cast, Susan, Ian, Barbara, all made it to fight the top New Who companions, so did the full series 11 cast to fight the classic Who companions.

  • @blobfish5730
    @blobfish5730 4 года назад +1

    Great video, Love the content

  • @destinedwarlord2128
    @destinedwarlord2128 4 года назад

    *K9 Mk1 questions his sanity*

  • @RD-uq4hg
    @RD-uq4hg 4 года назад

    Should do another with evil timelords, there should be plenty if you count The Eleven and stuff (and who could forget Scongo)

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 4 года назад

    Most female companions from the classic era screamed a lot, that was their role in the show. In fact Carole Ann Ford (Susan) and Mary Tamm (Romana I) both left the show because they didn’t like this.
    Victoria was certainly a screamer, and they do use her scream in order to defeat the monster in her final episode, but to say that that's all she did misses the point somewhat. It’s like saying the first Doctor is just a grumpy old man, it’s one aspect that does not capture the whole picture. Victoria demonstrates in Tomb of the Cybermen that she is cleverer than she looks and should not be underestimated, one of the villains holds her at gunpoint twice, the first time a cybermat attacks the villain and despite Victoria's warning does not look back as they assume it is a trick, (Victoria then kills the cybermat using the villain's gun) then later when they have her at gun point again she screams (despite there being nothing there) and the villain looks around for the danger allowing them to be disarmed.
    I’m not defending every classic companion, I always found Peri annoying but that could easily be down to the fact that her relationship with the Sixth Doctor was fraught and antagonistic. In fact it is slightly unbelievable that she stays with him as long as she does. I mean why would she want to stay?

    • @matthewduncan8523
      @matthewduncan8523 4 года назад

      It certainly got a bit old. A lot of first doctor stories I spent waiting for Susan to sprain her ankle. It was basically how I could tell the monsters were coming in soon as it seemed to follow the same format most of the time. Susan hurting her ankle means the real meat of the story is getting started

    • @gregkava1276
      @gregkava1276 3 года назад

      Carole Ann Ford not only left because of that but also because she was promised that Susan was going to be on the same level as The Doctor, she was also gonna have telepathy (which up to season 17 romana doesnt have/use it either which was imo should have been) and they obvi never kept the promise...... They did the same thing with leela and the actress would always refuse because it wasnt in character for leela a mf warrior yanno??? like how you gonna have leela be like imma cut your throat and then turn around see an alien and scream?

  • @GregInHouston2
    @GregInHouston2 4 года назад

    Your picture of K9 Mk I is out of date; he received an upgrade at some point before the time war. He fell through a crack and ended up in Australia with his memory gone. (See K9 tv series. And it was established that it was the original K9 in that series.) Although she was established as Galifreyan, she was never established as a Time Lord.

  • @shortangel333
    @shortangel333 4 года назад

    Also if Peri doesn't win in the next video, we riot. She's the only one with the assets to win.

  • @powerking8426
    @powerking8426 4 года назад +1

    You have won a sub

  • @DoctorMysterio63
    @DoctorMysterio63 4 года назад

    these are criminly underated

  • @fadikhoory5350
    @fadikhoory5350 4 года назад

    Could you do a Dalek, a cyberman, a zygon, an auton, a Silurian, an ice warrior, a yeti, a weeping angel, an ood, a monoid, a quark, a Sontaran, an axon, a krynoid, a flood, a silent, a monk, a pting, a drashig, a sea devil, a terileptil, the kandyman, a haemavore, a slitheen.

  • @bensimmons8042
    @bensimmons8042 4 года назад +1

    Almost left when Sarah Jane died AT THE VERY START I mean come on! 😡

  • @recon0282
    @recon0282 4 года назад

    After Companions, Do Best Dr Who Enemys

  • @asterisms7021
    @asterisms7021 4 года назад +1

    haven't seen this yet but my bets are on peri idk i just have a feeling

  • @baconwithmoreeggs7938
    @baconwithmoreeggs7938 4 года назад

    I don’t know who most of these are but I’m here for K9 on a kill spree.

  • @QuantumFantasy
    @QuantumFantasy 2 года назад

    Susan still mad over the doctor leaving her on earth

  • @jeffgalus8454
    @jeffgalus8454 4 года назад

    It's going to go down between Jamie and Sarah Jane

  • @SomeUsernameSomeoneElseTookIt
    @SomeUsernameSomeoneElseTookIt 4 года назад

    epic video bro

  • @NankitaBR
    @NankitaBR 4 года назад +2

    NOOOOOOO!!!!!! JAMIEEEEE!!!!!!
    CURSE YOU, BARBARA!!!! ✊✊✊✊

  • @katokianimation
    @katokianimation 4 года назад

    It is Fred, i mean Romana, obviously

  • @samuelbarber4154
    @samuelbarber4154 4 года назад

    Well K-9 did get Larinjitus.

  • @NankitaBR
    @NankitaBR 4 года назад

    And then a hurricane kills most of them

  • @ethanp1348
    @ethanp1348 4 года назад +1

    I've only started watching, so I voted Susan from the start since she was one of the ones I knew! I can't believe I was right!

  • @samuelbarber4154
    @samuelbarber4154 4 года назад

    I don't really have a favourite but I like the Brigadier.
    Also Ian.

  • @QigongXifu212
    @QigongXifu212 2 года назад

    00:00:ありがとうございます。

  • @TxSonofLiberty
    @TxSonofLiberty 4 года назад

    Seriously? There should only be two options on this list: Sarah Jane Smith aka Good Ole Sarah Jane and Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart aka The Brig, not even K-9 aka Good Dog can rival Sarah Jane and the Brig for longevity, resourcefulness, loyalty, and eternal excellence.

  • @gussyt1761
    @gussyt1761 4 года назад +1

    Turlough is not a forgettable companion

  • @vincentikea3518
    @vincentikea3518 4 года назад

    I hope that the brigadier wins

  • @mrjekyllandhyde9941
    @mrjekyllandhyde9941 4 года назад

    k9 mark 1 goes full feral mode Lol

  • @whoyougot2998
    @whoyougot2998 4 года назад

    What are you favourite episodes of doctor who and why? You’re by far the best DW related channel 👍

  • @BecauseICantEdit
    @BecauseICantEdit 2 года назад

    K9 has telepathy.