It is sad that Gilmour will no longer play this live. Thanks Nick for keeping the Pink Floyd classics alive. My favorite version though is Live at Pompeii.
They have worked hard to get Echoes as close as this! Well done! I have followed Pink Floyd all my life! First saw them City Hall Newcastle in 1969. They travelled on the same train, same carriage back to Kings X. Great memories!
I appreciate and honor what David Gilmour has decided what is appropriate for him. However, I am very glad to hear this once again played by a member of Pink Floyd. It is also a suiting tribute to a musician who made incredible impressions to the frontiers of music, and to the careers of future musicians.
I saw them in York. Utterly mind blowing. Incredible sound. Wonderfully performed by world class players. Gary kemp what a legend. Playing with his hero. I filmed part of this myself but wanted to just listen to it. I also got to meet the band after still can't believe I met Nick Mason! Go see this while you can people 😊
Saw them in Cardiff last night. Gary Kemp a revelation. Echoes and Set the Controls were in particular wind blowing. Awesome night. Thank you Lee Harris for setting everything up
I saw Nick twice in the Austria and twice in the Czech rep., and can´t wait to see him again this year in Graz, the shows are full of the early floydian magic...
I first saw Floyd on the meddle tour and then the world premier of Dark Side at the Finsbury Park rainbow in 1972. Subseqiuently saw them in Torono and Buffalo New York in the following winter. Memories are made of these.
Same. In miami.. had tapes, maybe not all lost. Real cool in quad: the seagulls flew around The Hollywood Sportatorium. Water's teeth were terrifying in Be careful... I was 4th row in '72..
One of the exciting things about owning a Nord Stage keyboard is that you can use the Lesley effect on one of the Pianos, and lo and behold you are Pink Floyd!
I can't get enough of this almost classical piece of music , 50 years ago , i was 16 years old then, I bought the album Meddle, in my opinion the best album of PF.👍🏽
Завидую всем кто видел их вживую! Слушаю эту замечательную группу 50 лет!много различных версий,а когда слушаешь кавер, мыслленно сравниваешь с оригиналом. Это достойная версия,много красок,но они не испортили исходный вариант.Браво❤❤❤
❤❤❤ I will see Nick in Ostend the 3.7. Can't wait. Also will see David Gilmour in the RAH in London on the 9.10. Looking forward to it. Greetings Dirk Belgium.
Remenber also that Guy Pratt, playing bass here played bass on both the mega tours for Momentry Lapse and The Division Bell back in the 80's and early 90's, so I'd say he's a 'member' of Pink Floyd also.
Guy Pratt is playing here? I didn't know that he went on the tour with Nick, but now that you mention it,,, I hear him.. The certain little things that distinguish his bass playing. Way cool- and yes, I'd consider him a member of Floyd.
Still trying to process Gary Kemp's involvement with this. A big talent and his all time favourite album is....."Liege and Lief"!! Extraordinary!. Whatever misdemeanors he committed with SB, Gary...I absolved thee...go forth my man and record an album with Nick and Mates before it's too late
Met Nick Mason & he is the nicest guy going! Thought he be grumpy & he was completely the opposite! Agree why David wont play it as done it 2006 tour with Rick & dosent feel right for him to play it without Rick! However the Saucers are probably is close to a Floyd music experience. 👌💯👍
I saw them after a couple of delays because of covid in 2022. I think with this project Nick is somewhere rendering himself justice. He deserved the musical project he didn't find in the past. I am wondering if Guy Pratt is joining Gilmour's brief tour and then stop the collaboration with Nick for a while
Original vintage Floyd never tried to reproduce music from the albums live on stage. That was part of the magic that disappeared when additionnal musicians came in to try to emulate the albums.
As close to perfect as I have ever heard it. even the time is 30 seconds short of the album timing. Only thing I would point out is that the piece is playing just a little slow but not much.
With all due respect to Nick Mason, and his rights, it's a strange effect to see other (paid) musicians playing and praising themselves with Pink Floyd's music, sounds and songs. I find it obnoxious! I find it disrespectful to the fans and aficionados of P.F. and to the members of the original band. Other Pinks have done similar things... However, mine is a hot emotion, without thinking too much about it. Con tutto il rispetto per Nick Mason, e i suoi diritti, fa uno strano effetto vedere altri musicisti (pagati) suonare e lodarsi con le musiche, sonorità e canzoni dei Pink Floyd. Lo trovo antipatico! Lo trovo poco rispettoso per i fan e cultori dei P.F. e per gli stessi componenti della band originale. Anche altri Pink hanno fatto cose simili...comunque la mia è un emozione a caldo, senza pensarci troppo.
If David Gilmour refuses to play this masterpiece live due to Richard Wright's passing... I think that's the ultimate tribute not only because of Richards passing but as a close friend and the magic couldn't be replicated without Richard Wright, who says it's all about the music... it's very close but when friendship enters the equation nothing else comes close, both of those guys bounced off each other musically and personally as friends and that's a rare gift and unmeasurable in the world of Rock and Roll
@@Silverado2021 echoes has been played live several times by Pink Floyd, David Gilmour and now Nick Mason, but in my opinion the worst recording and performance was by Pink Floyd of the Dark Side of the Moon tour at Wembley which was released on the Early Years box set. Substituting David Gilmour’s guitar solo in the first half of the track with Dick Parry’s saxophone, just did not work and for me was awful. The best released version, again IMO, was by David Gilmour Live in Gdansk. The version by Nick Mason has received many positive reviews from those who were lucky enough to be there, as well as many who have heard this RUclips video and I thought it was excellent to hear again. However this recording probably doesn’t do it justice, unfortunately the sound is not great in the top tier of the Royal Concert Hall in Nottingham. But hearing it in the Symphony Hall Birmingham from the stalls was superb.
Grauselig diese Darbietung, unproffessionell ... bin Super- Fan, habe sämtliche Platten / CD's etc. u. habe viele Konzerte live erlebt ... dieses war furchtbar❗❗❗
So having all the CD’s makes you an expert, I expect that Nick Mason, who might not have been to so many Pink Floyd concerts as you, now he has been told how horrible and unprofessional he is, will be very disappointed in his performance 🤔
Gilmour not playing Wish You Were Here is like Springsteen not playing Born to Run. Pretentious and cruel to those who will pay good money to hear his new age crap.
Mi dispiace dirlo,qui a Roma,in un centro Anziani. l'ho suonano meglio e con un OTTAVA piu alta...Fa bene Gilmour a non farla piu.il piano forte elettrico una pieta.cosi,cosi il chitarrista lato destro,CMQ,deluso...😢,...A NICK,...❤.
one day you people may come to realize the brain is not the mind if our senses are our minds... it is that simple... it is the magnetic lines of flux emanating from the center of our planet that is responsible for aligning things....
It is sad that Gilmour will no longer play this live. Thanks Nick for keeping the Pink Floyd classics alive. My favorite version though is Live at Pompeii.
It is not sad, it is HONORABLE, something few know about today.
Remember that Nights version is my personal favorite. It's a f****** masterpiece actually,,.
A great hommage to Rick Wright 's unique playing ,and too in this track where hé was still shining greatly ....a perfect rendition .
They have worked hard to get Echoes as close as this! Well done! I have followed Pink Floyd all my life! First saw them City Hall Newcastle in 1969. They travelled on the same train, same carriage back to Kings X. Great memories!
Iam jealous.Great memories i bet.Floyd fan.
I appreciate and honor what David Gilmour has decided what is appropriate for him. However, I am very glad to hear this once again played by a member of Pink Floyd. It is also a suiting tribute to a musician who made incredible impressions to the frontiers of music, and to the careers of future musicians.
I saw them in York. Utterly mind blowing. Incredible sound. Wonderfully performed by world class players. Gary kemp what a legend. Playing with his hero. I filmed part of this myself but wanted to just listen to it. I also got to meet the band after still can't believe I met Nick Mason! Go see this while you can people 😊
As a footnote can we just acknowledge that Nick Mason is 80 and still able to play a full show and tour. Amazing 👏
Im tempted to go tonight in Glasgow. so checking comments to see what people are saying.
Just go you won't regret it. Live at pompeii in small venue. If it were gilmour or waters would be an arena
I also went to York to see them, it was a totally captivating experience.
How good was the sound. I've seen a lot of shows but the sound was spot on
Nick Mason, toda una leyenda!!! gracias nick por mantener viva la llama de Pink Floyd.
Mr Nick Floyd keep high the flame ❤
That was fantastic. Thanks for filming, thanks for posting😊
Thanks for uploading and reviving the Floyd magic!
Every one claps and cheers when the radar sounds come in, love it😂
Sonar.
Saw them in Cardiff last night. Gary Kemp a revelation. Echoes and Set the Controls were in particular wind blowing. Awesome night. Thank you Lee Harris for setting everything up
A friend of mine seen them in York recently. Raved how good they were.
Mr. Mason thank you brother for everything you and your bandmates have given us.
The Pinks will always be my favorite.
Thank you so much for bringing it to us
Gracias NICK , sigue brillando 💎
Great Version of Echoes well done Nick and band members thumbs up for me.
Mind blowing!
I saw Nick twice in the Austria and twice in the Czech rep., and can´t wait to see him again this year in Graz, the shows are full of the early floydian magic...
Muchísimas gracias por la aportación.
Fantastic, thanks for sharing.
i was there tonight and what another fantastic show it was!!!! nice one for filming this masterpiece and uploading so soon
pink floyd are ALIVE and sounding great
I first saw Floyd on the meddle tour and then the world premier of Dark Side at the Finsbury Park rainbow in 1972. Subseqiuently saw them in Torono and Buffalo New York in the following winter. Memories are made of these.
Same. In miami.. had tapes, maybe not all lost. Real cool in quad: the seagulls flew around The Hollywood Sportatorium. Water's teeth were terrifying in Be careful... I was 4th row in '72..
I also was there wonderful early Floyd magic
*fantastic* ❤❤
Thanks Nick always one of my Floyd faves
Going next Friday at the Armadillo, Glasgow with my wife and 13 yr old son
The outro is fantastic. Thanks to Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets. Thanks to John for uploading.
I’m going tonight in Ipswich on the anniversary 56 years today 28th June can’t wait
Wish 👁was there. Over the pass five decades 👁
Saw Pink Floyd
Four times but never heard MEDDLE- one of my favorite.
One of the exciting things about owning a Nord Stage keyboard is that you can use the Lesley effect on one of the Pianos, and lo and behold you are Pink Floyd!
I can't get enough of this almost classical piece of music , 50 years ago , i was 16 years old then, I bought the album Meddle, in my opinion the best album of PF.👍🏽
Terbaik Mason! 👍👍
❤️Daripada 🇲🇾
Beautiful.!
Завидую всем кто видел их вживую! Слушаю эту замечательную группу 50 лет!много различных версий,а когда слушаешь кавер, мыслленно сравниваешь с оригиналом.
Это достойная версия,много красок,но они не испортили исходный вариант.Браво❤❤❤
I was there also. Fantastic set
Thankyou,going to the Beacon tomorrow can't wait
A great hommage to Rick and his mesmerizing creativity ...
Brilliant, seeing them in Gateshead on the 22nd, was at Newcastle a couple of years ago when they played this on that tour , blown away…..
❤❤❤ I will see Nick in Ostend the 3.7. Can't wait. Also will see David Gilmour in the RAH in London on the 9.10. Looking forward to it. Greetings Dirk Belgium.
Remenber also that Guy Pratt, playing bass here played bass on both the mega tours for Momentry Lapse and The Division Bell back in the 80's and early 90's, so I'd say he's a 'member' of Pink Floyd also.
Guy Pratt is playing here? I didn't know that he went on the tour with Nick, but now that you mention it,,, I hear him.. The certain little things that distinguish his bass playing. Way cool- and yes, I'd consider him a member of Floyd.
Great show! You can tell it’s definitely not Pink Floyd but pretty close.
Still trying to process Gary Kemp's involvement with this. A big talent and his all time favourite album is....."Liege and Lief"!! Extraordinary!. Whatever misdemeanors he committed with SB, Gary...I absolved thee...go forth my man and record an album with Nick and Mates before it's too late
Met Nick Mason & he is the nicest guy going! Thought he be grumpy & he was completely the opposite! Agree why David wont play it as done it 2006 tour with Rick & dosent feel right for him to play it without Rick! However the Saucers are probably is close to a Floyd music experience. 👌💯👍
Waiting see the Band in PARIS Olympia , next 4 july !!
I saw this at the Sage Gateshead on the 22nd high asf on an edible, 100/10
C est une très bonne idée qu à eu nick mason de redonner vie à ces morceaux de la premiere ère pinkfloyd, le tout sans grandiloquence ni démesure.
Fantastic! I see Nick, but is that Guy Pratt on bass?
Yes indeed - so in a sense a half of Pink FLOYD as the main members were after Waters departed Gilmour Pratt Wright and Mason
I saw them after a couple of delays because of covid in 2022. I think with this project Nick is somewhere rendering himself justice. He deserved the musical project he didn't find in the past. I am wondering if Guy Pratt is joining Gilmour's brief tour and then stop the collaboration with Nick for a while
💖
I wonder if those are the same drums Nick used at Pompeii in 1972.
Looking forward to RAH!
Original vintage Floyd never tried to reproduce music from the albums live on stage. That was part of the magic that disappeared when additionnal musicians came in to try to emulate the albums.
i am 73 and this was limper than my todger
It prolly too sad for David cause he used to echoe Richards notes especially at the end in that beautiful fadeout. 😢
Been a Floyd fan 50 years
Sorry but this is rubbish .
The keys to Echos are Richard’s and Dave’s vocals, blank keys here I’m afraid
Strangely enough Nick Mason has been a Pink Floyd fan for 59 years and he seems to think it is quite good
Nonsense. Music doesn’t belong to anyone. Everyone can play songs and if you don’t like it don’t listen.
Correct and I won’t !
Take care 👍
As close to perfect as I have ever heard it. even the time is 30 seconds short of the album timing. Only thing I would point out is that the piece is playing just a little slow but not much.
Even more sad that the fans who made him a millionaire and he won't play it
With all due respect to Nick Mason, and his rights, it's a strange effect to see other (paid) musicians playing and praising themselves with Pink Floyd's music, sounds and songs. I find it obnoxious! I find it disrespectful to the fans and aficionados of P.F. and to the members of the original band. Other Pinks have done similar things... However, mine is a hot emotion, without thinking too much about it.
Con tutto il rispetto per Nick Mason, e i suoi diritti, fa uno strano effetto vedere altri musicisti (pagati) suonare e lodarsi con le musiche, sonorità e canzoni dei Pink Floyd. Lo trovo antipatico! Lo trovo poco rispettoso per i fan e cultori dei P.F. e per gli stessi componenti della band originale. Anche altri Pink hanno fatto cose simili...comunque la mia è un emozione a caldo, senza pensarci troppo.
There's no "Echoes without DG & RW. Sorry Nick!
If David Gilmour refuses to play this masterpiece live due to Richard Wright's passing... I think that's the ultimate tribute not only because of Richards passing but as a close friend and the magic couldn't be replicated without Richard Wright, who says it's all about the music... it's very close but when friendship enters the equation nothing else comes close, both of those guys bounced off each other musically and personally as friends and that's a rare gift and unmeasurable in the world of Rock and Roll
Far from as good as the real thing... Not even close... I saw the real Floyd 5 time starting with Dark side of the moon in the 70's
@@Silverado2021 echoes has been played live several times by Pink Floyd, David Gilmour and now Nick Mason, but in my opinion the worst recording and performance was by Pink Floyd of the Dark Side of the Moon tour at Wembley which was released on the Early Years box set. Substituting David Gilmour’s guitar solo in the first half of the track with Dick Parry’s saxophone, just did not work and for me was awful. The best released version, again IMO, was by David Gilmour Live in Gdansk. The version by Nick Mason has received many positive reviews from those who were lucky enough to be there, as well as many who have heard this RUclips video and I thought it was excellent to hear again. However this recording probably doesn’t do it justice, unfortunately the sound is not great in the top tier of the Royal Concert Hall in Nottingham. But hearing it in the Symphony Hall Birmingham from the stalls was superb.
nope ..did not enjoy that
Grauselig diese Darbietung, unproffessionell ... bin Super- Fan, habe sämtliche Platten / CD's etc. u. habe viele Konzerte live erlebt ... dieses war furchtbar❗❗❗
So having all the CD’s makes you an expert, I expect that Nick Mason, who might not have been to so many Pink Floyd concerts as you, now he has been told how horrible and unprofessional he is, will be very disappointed in his performance 🤔
Gilmour not playing Wish You Were Here is like Springsteen not playing Born to Run. Pretentious and cruel to those who will pay good money to hear his new age crap.
@@johngibbin1416 Of course, just some of the comments mention DG touring without seventies material which is a shame.
A lovely version of this epic song. Certain moments are just as The Floyd played it. Bravo! 😊
rimarra' senza tempo...come i floyd, come nick
Mi dispiace dirlo,qui a Roma,in un centro Anziani. l'ho suonano meglio e con un OTTAVA piu alta...Fa bene Gilmour a non farla piu.il piano forte elettrico una pieta.cosi,cosi il chitarrista lato destro,CMQ,deluso...😢,...A NICK,...❤.
gold dust woman....
one day you people may come to realize the brain is not the mind if our senses are our minds... it is that simple... it is the magnetic lines of flux emanating from the center of our planet that is responsible for aligning things....