Lotr S Tier hands down! One of the very few films that are faithful while living up to the source books which the books are better at S+ but that is just because so much couldn't be put on screen due runtime & budget constraints. Cinematic master Piece. Lotr I treat as 1 seamless film that is in the top 3 of all movies. Hobbit trilogy is B as honestly they stretched that it into a trilogy when a split of the book in 2 movies would have been fine. They stuck so much pointless stuff in an already to long screen time. The Book is so much more vastly better as the book is S while these films are B as a whole. I do think the 1st hobbit gets way to much unwarranted dislike compared to the 2nd with slight over praise. 1st= B, 2nd= A- & 3rd=C The ending was just disappointingly displayed while being all over the place. Every director has to experiment & try to spin their nonsense on film rather then bring a faithful rendition of the source material the fans want. If a director wants to experiment then just do it on a non book adaption movie! Not much to ask & this should be a golden rule!
@@Querymonger Agreed. It felt like a complete journey beginning to end, leaving off with a very interesting and sad cliffhanger. The pacing definitely was the best as well.
I can do this list better Fellowship - S Two Towers - S ROTK - S Unexpected Journey - C Desolation - D BOTFA - *creates tier under D because it’s so fucking bad*
B tier fellowship and A tier desolation is fucking wild
Fellowship is the most complete movie out of all of them.
Lotr trilogy: S tier
Hobbit trilogy: A tier
Done
Lotr S Tier hands down! One of the very few films that are faithful while living up to the source books which the books are better at S+ but that is just because so much couldn't be put on screen due runtime & budget constraints. Cinematic master Piece. Lotr I treat as 1 seamless film that is in the top 3 of all movies.
Hobbit trilogy is B as honestly they stretched that it into a trilogy when a split of the book in 2 movies would have been fine.
They stuck so much pointless stuff in an already to long screen time.
The Book is so much more vastly better as the book is S while these films are B as a whole.
I do think the 1st hobbit gets way to much unwarranted dislike compared to the 2nd with slight over praise. 1st= B, 2nd= A- & 3rd=C
The ending was just disappointingly displayed while being all over the place.
Every director has to experiment & try to spin their nonsense on film rather then bring a faithful rendition of the source material the fans want.
If a director wants to experiment then just do it on a non book adaption movie!
Not much to ask & this should be a golden rule!
Good banter, but bro if this isn't the worst list. Just put fellowship in A, two towers and rotk in S, and scatter the hobbit across the bottom tiers
Fellowship is the best one though
@@Querymonger Agreed. It felt like a complete journey beginning to end, leaving off with a very interesting and sad cliffhanger. The pacing definitely was the best as well.
I can do this list better
Fellowship - S
Two Towers - S
ROTK - S
Unexpected Journey - C
Desolation - D
BOTFA - *creates tier under D because it’s so fucking bad*
I tried watching these movies but kept falling asleep despite that this video was funny loved watching presidents argue
I feel the hobbit films are too overhated, they're not as bad as people say. Inferior to the first trilogy yes but not terrible.
F tier take
Five armies was cack
Agreed
bruh, at the beginning, I switched over to discord because I thought i was being called lol
Fellowship is the best.
Agreed. My personal favorite
Fellowship belongs in A tier alone just for sticking to the source material of the first book.
None of the other movies got close...
Trump, Biden, and Obama all have very realistic looking avatar. :D
Tbh all hobbit movies are below D imo
That’s harsh the first two were enjoyable but i agree the 3rd movie was garbage
The first 2 are ok. The third one is trash tho.
hobits - D - orginal movies all S not that hard
Ok this is actual blasphemy