Need for Speed: Underground (GameCube vs Xbox) Side by Side Comparison | VCDECIDE
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- An Audio-Visual Comparison of NFS: Undergrounde between the Nintendo Gamecube and Xbox Classic (Original Xbox).
Support my work on RUclips: patreon.com/vcdecide
Technical data -
Full Game Name: Need for Speed: Underground
Alternative Name: NFS: Underground
Developer(s): EA Games (Eletronic Arts)
Publisher(s): EA Games (Eletronic Arts)
Release: 2003 (GC) 2003 (Xbox)
Comparative Region: 60 hz
Genre: Racing Game
Mode: Single-player or Multiplayer
Dual Gameplay by VCDECIDE 
Игры
That reflection on the asphalt of the GameCube version...
Simply amazing at the time!
Who needs Raytracing xD
It was big jump. Damn, those roads look phenomenal even today for a 21 year old game
Xbox has that as well? :)
@@MH-yp6wgIt's very faint it doesn't have as good a reflection as GC
@@jayclarke777 What are you talking about... it is very noticable on the Xbox and looking great.
Gamecube's biggest issues with this game are lower texture resolution across the board, mis-matched / stretched aspect ratio for 3D stuff, and less stable frame rate. Xbox should also have superior sound quality
Nintendo always make it cheap
Gamecube was more powerful than ps2, but the mini disc format held back gamecube quite a bit, as average dvd rom can hold a lil under 5gb on a single layer, while mini dvd can only hold 1.5gb of data.
It looks like the GameCube version is running with an unlocked frame rate
nfsu1 only needed 1,1gb semi compressed. You are right but that was nor the point. take a look at modern vintage gamer on RUclips. he will explain
@@MisticDW yes, Gc is the only with v Sync off
The cut-scenes are even because both consoles could output the the video's original "low, subpar" resolution.
The in-game graphics resolution is much better on the box, because of it's high-def 720p & 1080i resolution output.
I had all three versions including PS2, (all my consoles were modded). All three had the same cut-scene resolution, but in-game graphics ranked Xbox #1, Gamecube #2, PS2 #3 (which was usually the case graphically for most games). Add in that the Xbox had the better controller for this game, it wins hands down.
It was a really good experience on the Xbox, especially considering the PC version took a fairly modern rig to run smoothly at it's release.
Even if OG Xbox can output video up to 1080i, this NFS was in 480.
Actually the GameCube had better controls for racing games. It had analog triggers that had a huge range and than an extra button press at the end for something like a speed boost.
Too bad modern controller designs went away from the triggers of the GC and went with more gun style since FPS games are popular now.
@@BurritoKingdom and Nintendo completely dropped analogue triggers which is really anti consumer.
PS2 was the lead platform in the development of the game. Gamecube, XBox and PC are good ports but not better. You can see the difference especially on the better motion blur effects on PS2 if you compare them. The 480p resolution output and widescreen support is on the XBox better of course but this is console specific. XBox would always win if you compare only the picture output.
What I hated about this generation was that the GameCube and Xbox mostly got hand me down PS2 ports without much improvement, we never got to really see what both systems could do with multi-plats (multi-plats were still best on Xbox though)
Except for True Crime: New York City. I had it on GameCube & it played better but I could also complete it. I got an Xbox not long after & this game was with it. You legit can't finish the game on Xbox because of a bug on a boss battle on top of a container your stuck in an endless loop. I remember trying for like an hour to finish that one fight & find out its not possible due to a shoddy port lol
You know what? You are right! I'm glad somebody realized that. I use to think i was the only one who noticed that back then. Back in those times what ever console was the leading platform, Devs would design their games around it then port the games to other platforms in a non improved state.
From my experience it’s usually hit and miss. Simpsons Road Rage runs at a slightly choppy framerate on PS2, Xbox obviously has the best clarity in the little details but if you mainly care about framerate, you’d be as happy with the Gamecube version as you’d be the Xbox version. Need for Speed Underground looks best on Xbox but the PS2 version is the only one to offer online play. Games like FIFA 2004, SSX 3 and Rayman 3 I gotta opt for the Gamecube versions as they have GBA connectivity! The Incredibles I chose the Xbox version for its exclusive DLC, Crash Tag Team Racing and OutRun 2006 I got for PS2 for their PSP connectivity. Wallace & Gromit: Curse of The Were Rabbit looks and runs perfectly fine on the Xbox but the PS2 version can be mistaken for a PSone version! What went wrong in making the PS2 version?!?
Also hot pursuit for the ps2 was much better than the Xbox and GameCube versions it’s almost a different game
I feel the same way we barely saw xbox and gamecube style graphics I mean wreckless was made on xbox first and it shows a generational leap compared to the latter ps2 version,splinter cell got penciled in for ps2 and had things cut out,burnout 2 had crashes ps couldnt do but butnout 3 was a pure ps2 port and it looks like it with low polygon style PS2 held back xbox and gamecube from showing off and almost really made us miss a true 6th gen exp
Xbox has better specular highlighting in the garage and smoother frame-rate in gameplay.
No
La versión de Xbox se ve a 16:9 y la imagen mas nítida, los tiempos de carga son ligeramente mas cortos en GameCube, pero este ultimo tiene algunas caídas de FPS en el inicio de la carrera
en gamecube tuvieron que renderizar de otra forma mas optima, por eso a los objetos lejanos se les baja la calidad de las textura y se les ponen un efecto blur para disimular un poco el bajón en las texturas, pero los coches están a la altura de Xbox al parecer.
xbox puede mostrar edificios y objetos lejanos en alta calidad por eso no necesita usar ningún efecto como niebla o blur.
gamecube es un excelente sistema, dicen que el mas equilibrado de su generación, pero Xbox es el mas potente de su época
Los fps en GC son "uncapped" no son fijos a 30 como en Xbox. En GC van desde 20fps a 50fps cuando no hay carga grafica. Es una interesante opcion. Hay tramos en GC que va a 40-45fps constantes.
@@yoquese2.026 sería una pena que el formato de GC límite su capacidad, tal ves la diferencia de ram total es la responsable, Xbox es la que más tiene de las 3
@@yoquese2.026 no sabía que tenía esos problemas GameCube por los discos, generalmente en GC se ven mejor los juegos que en PS2, ya que tenía algunas ventajas en el hardware
De hecho la culpa es de los mini disc de gamecube, la gamecube estaría casi a la par de Xbox si usara dos discos, un ejemplo obvio fue la versión de resident evil 4 que destrozó a la de ps2 pero el juego era en 2 mini disc
Por quê a EA não faz mais jogos fantásticos como esse?!?!? Ótimo trabalho!
Porque ela não e mais a mesma empresa
@MEGA NOOB tipo Battlefield 2042 que è o mais recente,e dlcs suas também.
Ninguém na indústria do entretenimento não fazem mais nada com qualidade.
Galera pra quem não entendeu do porque tiraram as músicas do jogo, é para evitar problemas com direitos autorais 👍 / Guys for those who didn't understand why they took the songs out of the game, it's to avoid copyright problems 👍
puta baguio chato, vsf
@@sandrosfc eu sei, é chato
@@Evolution_BR811 Foda q esse game têm uma trilha sonora fodástica, fico puto com essas coisas kk
@@sandrosfc "doron dom dom!" 🎧🎵
I don't know how many people notice these things but from the get go:
3:05 - the window of the club in front here is broken on all versions except PS2, it's supposed to be transparent
- fog is missing on PC and GC versions (fixable via reshade if you really miss it)
- GC version's reflection update rate is 15FPS vs 30FPS on Xbox (EDIT: actually i can't tell from this video, this might not be true)
- Xbox and 360 versions of NFS games (all of them) have scaled down FrontEnd - this seems to be because of some Xbox guidelines to not show any UI in the overscan area - some people thought that the UI in MW 360 was designed with it in mind but that's false info
- GC versions do a similar thing except only vertically
- GC versions do not use proper texture compression for GC - this will always result in worse textures than even the PS2 versions
- GC versions normally use 32khz audio, whereas Xbox uses 48khz audio - music in UG1 is half the sample rate
Thanks for the breakdown tech head. Nice one
GC has built in hardware texture compression. IT ALWAYS uses it, because if it didnt it would onlyhave 1MB for textures....the reason for the worse textures is because of the low RAM
Xbox.
There was a difference in the fmv but couldn't say one was better than the other.
I dont like the stretched look of the GC either.
Gamecube version is using a 4:3 aspect ratio. XBox is using 16:9.
Also it seems the GC version is missing reflections in the upper parts of the car but has full environment reflections on the sides and low back part of the car which the Xbox doesnt have. The GC also has greater motion blur effect and also runs at uncapped framerate that goes from 25 to 45 fps while Xbox is constant 30fps.
The textures are definitely the worst part of the GC version but at those speeds is barely noticeable. Overall i think the GC version looks the best and sometimes runs the best also if you play it on Wii with Nintendont it can reach 60fps even. Its a great port taking in count Xbox is a more powerful console.
Os gráficos de ambos estão bonitos, mas gostei mais do Xbox pois esta na proporção certa, a versão GC parece um tanto achatada o carro parece levemente esticado...
Xbox are better than the Gamecube in Framerate (konstant 30 fps), Sharp Graphics (Environment), aspect Ratio(16:9) and Loading times(HDD).
But not in reflections in car and track. From min 6:52
UI scale on xbox is slightly smaller and darker. GC version seems to have better looking text.
Xbox don't use HDD in Underground, It reads from the disk. Unless you mod the Xbox, then you can install the entire game into HDD.
Gc had 16:9 and unlocked frames
Probably the game I like the most vs. stream the least, because the soundtrack gets the stream shut down in about 5 minutes. Lil Jon's lawyers don't mess around.
Xbox is obviously superior but man the gamecube did a fair job keeping up, despite some issues.
More than true
2 vídeo games monstros da época. Eu tive a oportunidade de ter os 2. Que época nostálgica.
En las cinematicas se ve mejor el color en Gamecube en Xbox se ven los colores lavados y negro gris. En cambio en gameplay se ve mucho mejor en Xbox, se nota bastante mejor resolución y los coches se ven como deberían no se ven ensanchados como en la versión de Gamecube, luego en Xbox se ven reflejos de las farolas en las ventanas y faros del coche. Xbox gana la comparación.
Otro dato es la capacidad de almacenamiento del disco de gamecube no permite sacar provecho lo que hicieron con la nfs most wanted da ganas de llorar
@@amaterasuu7067 Si, creo que tenia una capacidad como la de los UMD de la PSP unos 2gb, si la GameCube hubiera usado DVD's como la competencia quizás se hubiera aprovechado mas y algunos juegos como los GTA hubieran salido y con mejores gráficos que en la PS2. La cagaron igual con la Nintendo 64 que por prestaciónes era superior a la PS1 y la Saturn pero la cagaron con el formato cartucho y se vio muy limitada.
what's the point of muting the in game soundtrack when you already played the whole opening scene with copyrighted music in it?
Is the GC version stretched horizontally? Or is the Xbox version 16:9 but squished into 4:3 frame?
Fun Fact: As a kid I never started the game because I thought it was a freeroam like its sequel!
But since this is on Gamecube I can play it on my Wii = )
Id suggest playing it on a PC if you have one. Moddable, and can run at 60 fps on almost all computers made in the last decade
@@Sh-hg8kf Ik but I don't have it there, I at least can have it on Wii...
The first one I played was on PC though.
Thanks anyways for the advice 😃
@@vittosphonecollection57289 U can always download it online ;)
@@Sh-hg8kf Ok 😃👍👍
O Hardware do primeiro XBOX era muito superior ao da concorrência, uma pena possuir uma biblioteca pequena...
Why are the cars wider in the Gamecube version?! Plus it seems the GC runs a tad smoother than XB?!
Because no widescreen in the Gamecube version
I’ve noticed that the GameCube and Wii versions of the Need for Speed games (specifically from the developer Blackbox) always had an uncapped frame rate. They’ve never been capped to 30fps.
I didn’t have this game when it was new, but 2 of my friends each had the Xbox version! Got to play it at their places, loved it!
My criteria for choosing which versions of each game to pick are down to the functionality on offer, or if each version is as functional as each other, I go for the best looking one, or just go with whichever system is my favorite of the ones the game in question is on.
Fifa 2004 and Rayman 3 I picked the Gamecube versions for their GBA connectivity.
Had GCN Need for Speed Underground also offered GBA connectivity, I would also have picked that version, but it doesn’t, so I would’ve instead gone for the PS2 version, which has online play!
I know the Xbox version of Out Run 2006 is the version of that game that runs best, but I still had to go for the PS2 version, which links to its PSP counterpart!
Simpsons Road Rage, you may want to pick the Xbox version if you’re REALLY picky over every tiny background detail being as clear as possible, but if like me, you mainly care about framerate, both the Gamecube and Xbox versions are as good as each other! The PS2 version is slightly choppy.
That binaural audio is cool
Esse jogo é demais!! A versão do Xbox é disparada a melhor!! A definição dos carros do cenário!!! Mas a do Game Cube é excelente também!! Até quero baixar a versão do Game Cube pra jogar no meu Wii desbloqueado!! Quero fazer uns vídeos de jogos de corrida nas gerações de 8 bits até a oitava geração!! É bem interessante pra ver a evolução!!!
Eu tenho a versão do Xbox clássico e a melhor disparado
@@afrosamurai9527 Top demais!! Era um console muito a frente do seu tempo!!
Não existe console de 512 bits, na verdade se quer existiu de 128 bits, isso foi um apelido que deram para a geração do ps2/gamecube/xbox, mas na verdade, todos os consoles atuais são 64 bits
@@Kaio1000 o PS3 é 32 bits
@@Kaio1000 É mais eu acredito que seja a evolução né!! Mas até pode ser!! Todo console uma geração a frente dobra o processamento!! Por isso eu falo sempre que cada geração é o dobro!! Seria na verdade a 7 geração!!
6 geração os consoles + poderoso
1 Xbox clássico
2 GameCube
3 PlayStation 2
4 Dreamcast
Believe it not, Dreamcast is actually superior hardware-wise than Playstation 2. There's a lot of info on the net to check, in case you're wondering.
1. The XBOX version's menu's look higher resolution than the GameCube's
2. Also the Building's in the Gamecube version look lower resolution than the one's in the XBOX version.
3. During racing the GameCube version seems to run smoother than XBOX version. The XBOX version seems to be a little choppier.
4. Audio wise the XBOX version sounds a little crisper.
5. Gameplay looks about the same.
It's really surprising how the ps2 version keeps up with both the Xbox and gc version
You'd think the ps2 version would fall far behind
@@Sh-hg8kf You will be even more shocked to know that the PS2 version of Underground 2 is better than GameCube I'm guessing the cube got a rushed port of that one.
@@wizzgamer the media somehow helped the port to be worse
I'll take the X-Box's stable 30fps frame rate.
this deserve a 4 system comparison!
I don’t remember GameCube looking this good
This GOOD? Are you joking?
@@Anathem22 yes, is good
@@molo-molo5103As a person that had the game on the gamecube, i can say that it is good bc of a lot of things such as the lights.
Xbox is way better but both are good!
I don't understand why the GC version needs to be stretched? Not that it is wide screen anyway? 🤔
I believe this is because the GC's native resolution is a little weird, it's 640x528, which would be a slighter taller 4:3.3 aspect ratio instead the conventional 640x480 4:3 frame that the xbox uses. The game was then programmed to render with the aspect ratio of the GC's native resolution rather than forcing 4:3. But since there is no such thing as a 4:3.3 aspect ratio display, it looks stretched because the frame is taller, then gets squished to fit into the 4:3 frame.
Ahh I see! 😯
Thank you for the reply 👍
Now that's what I like.
Can't wait to see more spectacular comparisons, like Undercover (PS2 vs PS3) and ProStreet (PS2 vs PS3)
I prefer the smoothness of the GC
Que buenos gráficos de ese juego para la época
Best intro ever
Nunca entendi esse aspect ratio zuado dos underground do GC, a imagem parece achatada mesmo na TV de tubo; não sei se o GameCube rodava esses jogos em uma resolução diferenciada ou simplesmente foi algo que os devs quiseram.
Mesmo assim o Underground 1 do GC não deve nada pra versão de Xbox/PS2, principalmente em framerate. Agora o NFSU2 foi portado mal e porcamente pro GC
this has to be the golden years of the nfs franchise then
It's crazy how powerful was the innocent babyish-looking GameCube, nobody saw what a beast it was. This version still have Progressive Scan mode!nfan
Blurry/upscaled image that is also stretched, lower frame rate in spots, less reflective detail... yeah, the Gamecube is definitely not the winner here (I think Xbox was target console) but it's a decent representation.
I wonder how the Gamecube version stacks up against the PS2 version.
Gamecube version is better but sadly Underground 2 is worse than PS2 so just buy them both for the unstoppable the legendary the unbeatable regardless of game quality PS2.
@@wizzgamer lol! I should have expected this. I'll go with the PC versions ;)
@@wizzgamer Underground 1 for PS2 is superior than Gamecube version.
Better framerate, textures, car reflections and sound quality.
@@mackalan Black Boxe's NFS on NGC is always weired on graphic effects,I do agree the reflection on PS2 is so crazy that the feeling is actually quite different from PC and Xbox.
@@sunray2818 Yes, for some reason, NFS games are inferior in GC than in PS2, PS2 always has better effects, car reflections and textures.
Probably because of the smaller DVD size.
It's a tradeoff between versions, a matter of preference. The Xbox has more crisp and clean detailed backgrounds, but it detracts from the sense of speed while driving. The GameCube's roads look more life-like and the car model looks more true to life while the Xbox car models are more squished and glossy, giving them a polished toy car look. The colors look richer on the GameCube. So yes, the Xbox version is higher res, but does it make for a better visual experience in this game? Given this is supposed to be an arcade style racing game, I prefer the GameCube graphics.
Xbox is better. but I liked the smoke effect of the cars in the game cube version. It was a more visible effect and lasted longer on the set.
We all know xbox has more grunt
For some reason despite being less powerful the Tarmac reflections and headlight effect look much better on GC than on Xbox.
Miren el reflejo del suelo y las luces del coche mucho mejor en GC.
I don't understand what's going on , it feels like GameCube run true 60 fps while Xbox only 30 ? Hows that possible
Gamecube version looks to have had the framerate unlocked. In some spots the framerate reached 60 for a bit but will drop down again to 25-40 fps or so. The Xbox's stable 30fps is much more desirable since it's stable and doesn't fluctuate like it does on GC.
Parece que os shaders do Gamecube eram melhores. Xbox fica com melhor frame rate. Enfim, consoles incríveis.
é comparação,não competição;é bom conhecer as diferenças entre os 2
Em comparação sempre vai existir competição, uma coisa está ligada a outra.
cortou o dorondondon =(
de todo modo toma o like fera... tu é fera de mais
Nice video.
The stretched image in the GameCube port is a bit disappointing.
GameCube is my favorite console ❤
Wow split screen mode, we don't see those anymore in today's modern driving games other than Cruis'n Blast.
F1 2021 and Dirt 5 has split screen mode so maybe with the power of the new consoles it'll see a resurgence. I hope so. And Dirt 5 has 4 plater split screen on ps5. Not sure about other systems. So good work from Codemasters on those games.
A versão GameCube tem os tradicionais cortes causados pelo Mini DVD, é ridículo ver um sistema mais forte que o PlayStation 2 ser prejudicado por empresas só pq não sabiam aproveitar as várias tecnologias de compressão empregadas no sistema. Por incrível que pareça, o GameCube se saiu melhor exatamente no NFS que deveria ter dado mais trabalho, o Carbon, EA finalmente aprendeu a tirar proveito do hardware de forma eficiente e a versão GC do Carbon é a mais completa da 6° geração em termos visuais (tirando as texturas, que por falta de "espaço" são low res).
Gamecube mais forte que o Xbox ? De onde tu tirou isso ?
O XBOX é superior ao Gamecube em praticamente todas as especificações, desde a velocidade do clock, até a quantidade de memória RAM. Aliás, o XB é o console mais potente daquela geração.
Mais forte que o PS2, vcs são brasileiros mas tão agindo igual gringo, precisa dar todos os mínimos detalhes ao invés de ler nas entrelinhas, Underground não é um jogo de Xbox com Port pro GameCube, é um jogo de PS2 com Port para os outros sistemas, pelo amor de Deus! E caso não saibam, o GameCube tem shader level superior ao do Xbox, Xbox é shader level 1.1, GameCube é shader level 1.4, mas consegue chegar a feature level 2.0 parcial no seu Texture Enviroment Unit, mas nem todos os devs sabiam usar ele o que fez com que muitos ports ficassem inferiores até aos de PS2. Posso não ter dito PS2 antes (mas editei pra evitar novos mal entendidos) mas pensei que a galera ia sacar que eu tava falando dos ports de PS2 que saíram inferiores no GameCube, já que o mesmo deveria ficar melhor que o PS2 e inferior ao Xbox, fazendo o meio termo.
Se quiserem um bom exemplo, vejam TimeSplitters Future Perfect, a versão GameCube é de longe a melhor, as texturas tiveram uma redução na resolução mas pra compensar os efeitos de shader são superiores aos do Xbox e o framerate é impecável, já que no Xbox rola slowdown em vários momentos aonde no GC não tem. E sim eu tenho ambos os sistemas aqui para comparar lado a lado.
@@ZinhoMegaman a comparacao do video eh entre Gamecube e Xbox, nao sei o que tu colocou o PS2 no meio, o xbox ser superior ao gamecube eh um fato, nada mais que isso, vi pelo teu avatar q tu deve ser un nintendo fanboy
Não sabia que esses 2 consoles já tinham raytrace 😂😂 mas é bem legal como o carro reflete o que está em volta, desde as faixas do chão até os prédios. Eu como jogo mais o Dreamcast dos 128bits, estou mais acostumado com aquele reflexo bem fake. Queria saber como seria um versão para o branquinho da Sega se ele tivesse durado mais alguns anos....
Tem um port de um game de corrida da atomis wave pra dreamcast e uma copia de need for speed underground até a cidade e os predios sao parecidos é o game tem texturas mais bacanas q o need no ps2 e surpreende tbm na iluminação e reflexos dessa mesma forma o dreamcast era capaz d fazer esse tipo de reflexos ai tbm
No dreamcast o game faster tanth speed portado do atomis wave q é o dreamcast puro com mais canais de audio e pouco mais de ram em forma de arcade...o game e praticamente a copia do need for speed e exibe excelentes texturas reflexos e iluminação provando q esse game poderia sim chegar ao dream se ele nao fosse descontinuado depois procura p vc ver
@@mayconwilliam600 O Faster Than Speed é bonitinho mas não dá nem pra comparar, o jogo deve ter tido 1/10 do orçamento e tempo de produção do Underground.
O Dreamcast podia estar vivo até hoje que não receberia esse jogo, a EA se recusou a trabalhar nele por desavenças com a Sega, infelizmente.
@@thalesonic mas falando em termos de hardware com adaptação o dream rodaria sim as texturas ate melhores q o ps2 problema seria frame e draw distance menor
The firsr Xbox was a beast indeed. Better resolution and framerate..
In the cutscenes the box has very flushed out colours but in game it looks better
Wish this game come back online .
So i can use IT on my Xbox serie s.
Xbox runs in 60fps. Game Cube in 30fps. Besides, there is "kinda ray tracing" on the Xbox.
This could have been my first Game Cube game but instead I choose Star Fox Adventures 🤣
Starfox adventure wasn't bad, last Rareware game before being owned by Microsoft.
xbox is the boss. Like with many games when it comes to graphics. Og xbox. When microsoft fired on all cillinders. 360 ehem red ring of death and xbox one,still waiting for those games.
Xbox tiene reflejos dinámicos en tiempo real en la carrocería. Mayor definición y estabilidad en los FPS.
E é por isso que adoro as comparações feitas pela princesa caju.
NFS Underground 1 on Gamecube demolishs the PS2 and Xbox version, even more using the original component cables
Just imagine how good this game could have looked if ps2 didnt exist
Xbox versión wins in framerate and resolution but Gamecube version has better lightning effects, road reflections especially.
what are you talking about with fps, gamecube's fps is twice higher than xbox
@@maxsanchez764 Hummm maybe...
Xbox has clearly better textures, lightning and framerate. And is 16:9 too.
Xbox easily but is there something wrong with the capture during FMVs on the Xbox. It looks much darker than the GameCube version which makes it look washed out.
here is a power comparison: 1st)Xbox 2nd)GameCube 3rd)Playstation 2
i think theres a config in gamecube to deal with wide screen that had to be activated so cars doesnt look so streched if my memory doesnt fails me...
UG1 does not have widescreen mode on any platform. It's UG2 which stated to include widescreen config on Xbox/PS2/NGC version.
This game didn't have widescreen mode, but you can get it widescreen if you play it through Nintendont and enable forced widescreen patch (can do progressive scan too). It stretches the UI but the world and FOV look good. The widescreen hack in Dolphin works ok too.
Both are great.
Para coleção melhor de Xbox ou de ps2. Os discos de gamecube descascam com o tempo, principalmente no Wii que puxa o disco. No gamecube preserva um pouco mais porque é tampa.
Isso é um problema de solucao simples. voce deveria jogar jogos de game cube em um game cube.
PC wins.
Frame rate is higher on GameCube.
And it looks a lot worse because of it, very unstable.
They have different aspect ratio, more than that and Xbox a little more sharper edges and Gamecube a little more colorfull they look the same, can you do Midnight Club from Xbox with PS2? 🤲
I need a time machine. I want to go back
edit......I just heard the dialogue and now I don't want to go back
Porrompompon! The audio is now muteeed! 2:00
melhor versão
1 Xbox clássico
2 GameCube
3 PlayStation 2
La versión de ps2 es superior a la de de gamecube.
Acho que se o GameCube, tivesse problema de pouco armazenamento, eles comprimido mais, a qualidade das cgs
XBOX bem superior... Bom video!
raytrace* é foda! o mais interessante q o reflexo dos predios sao mais visiveis no chão molhado no game cube, no xbox o reflexo dos predios é no carro q é mais nitido
Gamecube: Sharper decals, louder sound, remarkably faster load time
XBOX: Correct aspect ratio, better graphics, higher resolution textures, better FMVs, more responsive HUD
XBOX wins.
also Gamecube is 60fps to compensate these flaws
@@LazyPersian Gamecube is running at 30 fps.
@@mackalan it's not 60fps. I said that based on what I watched on this video because GC is smoother than the others. it has actually uncapped framerate on GC between 30 to 45 depending on area
gamecube has that wide body kit yo
Versão do XBOX Classic ganha, aliais todos os jogos Need for Speed lançados na época para as 3 plataformas caseiras as versões do XBOX eram as versões definitivas.
Correção exceto a versão Need for Speed Hot Pursuit, onde a versão do Ps2 ganha***
@@giovannimarcelodasilva768 Versão exclusiva do NFSHP 2, jogaço!! Pra mim um dos melhores da franquia 👍
@@sfwilliamGuileJogaço mesmo, e foi muito bem programada essa versão para Ps2 a ponto de superar as demais versões
Mejores reflejos en GC y tiempos de carga menores en lo demás gana el exbox
Ps2 nem apareceu pra não passar vergonha kkkk
O PS2 é bem mais fraco que os dois, talvez iria levar uma surra mesmo ;-; ainda mais pq o Xbox clássico chega a ser MAIS POTENTE que o Nintendo WII!
Of course PS2 was a lot less powerfull than Gamecube and Xbox but none had a game like Gran Turismo 4
Passar vergonha como mano, se a versão de ps2 tem texturas e reflexos melhores que do gamecube? Só pode ta de zueira!
Não sei se a informação procede, mas ouvi dizer que no gamecube caparam as texturas por conta do tamanho do disco
@@Evolution_BR811 chega a ser nao ele é quase 20% mais parrudo q o wii q so o sistema operacional mata boa parte da memória ram kkkk
E a "roda quadrada" no PS2 hehe
a versão de Xbox deve ser similar a de Windows que é minha preferida
O único que aproxima do pc é o xbox
Xbox much better, it was ahead of his time
A versão do Xbox clássico é melhor em gráficos sem comparação eu tenho do play2 também os efeitos de luz o motion Blue é muito diferente os gráficos.
Pode chora a vontade a versão do Xbox e idêntica ao do PC do Windows XP
The intro gave me wet dreams all over again
The resolution on the Xbox should be 720p here as opposed to Gamecube's 480p, so yea it looks better on Xbox. Otherwise, In don't see much a difference in draw distance or number of polys (lol number of polys isn't even much a thing anymore).
No this game is only 480p and since it's not backwards compatible on Xbox 360, there's no way to get 720p output at all.
@@sunray2818 It's backwards compatible on my JTAG 360 and it looks and plays perfect :)
@@Biggus_Dickus_69 Oh piracy glory, I get it, but still less relfection when compared to PS2 versions.
@@sunray2818I don’t think this game has the reflection issues of Underground 2 on xbox, and the reflections update faster on xbox than ps2, after playing both through the hard drive.
The main issue with the Xbox version is the broken window transparency on the diner in the beginning. That’s it. It’s basically the PS2 version with nicer lighting and reflections
@@Obviousthrowawayaccount Weird, my playthrough shows it's reflection is not as overload as PS2 version. I will try again.
NFS UNDERCOVER PS2 4:3 (30fps) VS WII 16:9 (60fps)
PS2 version of Undercover supports widescreen.
Das 3 versoes que joguei, a do Gamecube eh a que mais mantem os 60 fps constantes. a do ps2 é a pior.
60fps? 😂
@@lucas-1630 sim, 60 fps.
Terribles tiempos de carga de XBox, que desastre era jugar con esa consola.
En tus sueños
Tu és burrito
Mijo se nota que no la tuvo , a nivel técnico fue la mejor. Y por la general al tener disco duro era una consola rápida.
@@orlox2 Es increíble que niegues la realidad. Los tiempos de carga eran terroríficos. Como se nota que estáis acostumbrados a ellos... pero eso no quita que fueran mucho mayores a GC. Es la realidad, no es algo opinable, es medible.
2:58 Xbox 🏆
Boa comparação a do x box está um pouco melhor a. Melhor versão ea do PC
Is it just me or gamecube has a more stable image? I kinda like to look at it more than on Xbox's side :D
The GameCube’s CPU is slightly faster than Xbox, one advantage that tiny purple console has.
@@CarbyGuuGuunot really, although it probably doesn’t run into memory contention problems as frequently as the Xbox in some situations.
GC 16:9 XBoX 4:3 Why ?
please do a need for speed hot pursuit 2 comparison..
Xbox is better but at least you can play the GC version on a sd845 phone fairly smoothly.
XBOX