🕹️ Explore retroserk, my other channel dedicated to retro game reviews and comparisons in Spanish. Join the fun! youtube.com/@retroserk 👉 Check out more EVOLUTIONS of SONIC GAMES HERE! ruclips.net/video/dw-QWAU0ZQ0/видео.html
Not really. Compared to today's emulation accuracy, it might seem quite shoddy, but this was still around the infancy of emulation, and the Dreamcast wasn't a particularly powerful machine compared to the other three consoles in its generation, so the fact that it can - to a certain degree of accuracy - emulate a console that only released nine years prior is quite impressive. The modern equivalent would be the Playstation 5 emulating a base model PS4.
@@alfo2804 I'm sorry what? You really don't know your hardware if you think the Dreamcast wasn't powerful. The Dreamcast was based off the Sega Naomi arcade hardware which inspired hardware like Atomiswave nearly a decade later. The Dreamcast was the second hardware to bring home a 1:1 arcade experience next to the NeoGeo AES. Believe me the Dreamcast was more than capable in performing emulation. At best the software emulation was in it's infancy as you said but the Dreamcast hardware was more than capable of delivering which is why Naomi lived on even after the fall of the Dreamcast. I think you need to do a little research in the history and specifications of the Dreamcast. The reason it failed wasn't because of it's performance. It was because of piracy.
@@bruno-vicious What the fuck are you even talking about? I know what the Dreamcast is, what it was based on and what it's capable of. I also know that it's very common knowledge that emulation requires a device to be exponentially more powerful than the console it's emulating, which the Dreamcast simply wasn't. Even the PS2, Xbox and Gamecube couldn't emulate the Mega Drive with great accuracy. Plus, the MD is a notoriously difficult system to emulate, especially with its sound hardware, so it's no wonder it came out the way it did. And what on Earth does the console's failure have to do with this? The reason you gave was a complete myth, anyway, so it's even less relevant to the topic.
4:01 That's a joke, right? I think it's an emulated version with a messed-up emulator that gives this 8-bit sound. Just look at Sonic's posture, there's already a display bug.
Well, it is an edition of Sonic 1. It's running on the emulator used on Sega Smash Pack Volume 1, which was rushed to be ready for release by launch day. They didn't have enough time to make an accurate emulator.
Oh that's interesting, I also have the Glu J2ME version (first flip phone game I owned and also first Sonic game I owned) but it looked different, sprites were actually the same size and looked much more similar to the Mega Drive ones :o There was even a background in the title screen and everything! Save system, level select, How to Play, and leaderboards! (I think there was a password on Part 2 to transfer chaos emeralds if you got all of them but I never could) Probably version for smaller screen resolution thing. It's still a very very good port especially for the system it's on, spent hours upon hours on it despite starting with part 2 that starts at Labyrinth Zone and getting part 1 about 6 months later... I'd gladly share the version I own if I can get it out of my phone!
Everyone’s talking about the Dreamcast and GBA ports but the J2ME fone has: Glitchy title screen Music problems. Less sound effects But I can forgive the glu port as it was inferior but the fone port, it’s almost as bad as the Dreamcast or gba port.
Im late to the comments, but@@Creg-ev2qm The gba could handle some advanced music and it could had a better port if it wasnt rushed. Check out the proof lf concept made by stealth iirc. I dont renember exactly who did it but they did an better green hill on gba
The line scrolling and parallax are actually better in the MegaDrive Japanese release. It’s strange given that they’re the same exact system. There are no scrolling clouds in the US version. For some reason, I always thought that the first time the clouds scrolled independently was the Saturn Sonic Jam Sonic 1 port. The cloud scrolling effect makes the first 3 stages look much more alive since there’s always some form of motion occurring on the screen. Thanks for posting this, it’s a great video.
The Dreamcast version almost reminds me of the @games version. But I grew up with the DS version on Sonic Classic Collection, so many memories playing that compilation
My first experience of Sonic 1 was a J2ME port split in 2 parts. I don't think it was the iFone version, but it certainly wasn't the Glu one showed here (maybe they had 2? one for low-end device, another for high-end ones). My phone had a far better MIDI sound bank however so the music didn't sound nearly as bad as in this video -- somehow the uploader managed to find a J2ME runtime which actually uses a *worse* MIDI bank than the one Sonic Genesis uses (which uses the same midis in theory).
Yeah that really should have been included, though I suspect finding a way to play it might be a problem now. It was such a bugger to play with the clickwheel.
@@bmhedgehog2 The first iPhone versions were different from iPod version. Also, there was a port of the Game Gear version for some PDA if i remember correctly.
DS was such a lazy emulation, it ran terribly if you used an old model DS. I remember when I played it on 3DS, all the lag was gone, but the picture still looked a bit squished/flickery in spots, and the sound quality is lacking. Still it was great to have those games portable on the DS, but it was a letdown for sure when I first got it.
Imagine someone that never played the first sonic and started with the Dreamcast version and being like: *this game sucks it sounds so awful !* And then talking about how shit it is not realising that the real one is better.
I think the reason is that, whereas the Green Hill Zone of _Sonic Mania_ and _Sonic Generations_ is an elaboration of the original, the one found in the 8-bit versions is quite different even though it was clearly inspired by the 16-bit game.
Game Gear is also different from Master System in many ways, even though much less ways than GEN to MS. There's a whole one hour video covering the things Ancient did to make sure the Game Gear version won't feel unfair or unpolished on the Game Gear.
iOS and android versions are the versions of this game that sega should be porting to newer consoles. They are not emulations but faithfully re-created versions of the game with a lot of care put into them and the sound is essentially what the genesis is capable of doing but digitally ripped from real hardware so it's technically more accurate than playing the game on original analog output hardware.
@@alfo2804 Because you're not dealing with a digital source, the sound chip converting the sound to analog using the built-in DAC in the genesis then being piped out after going through filters and possible noise inside the console itself. Instead the sound itself was ripped from the source before it could be converted to an analog signal in the first place. You're right it is 100% accurate but the original hardware itself is not 100% accurate which is self evident also from model 1 and model 2 consoles using different chips also.
I'm surprised you didn't include the Dreamcast Sonic Adventure 2 Green Hill Bonus level, where it starts out on a 2d plane and then switches to 3D. And the PAL Europe version of Sonic 1 (different from NTSC USA Sonic 1 ) would have been nice to see the speed difference. Would have been nice to have seen Sonic 1 3DS on a real 3DS to see that 3D perspective
@@thesupervideogamenerdmore3171 Generation's version of Sonic 1 is also in 3D and it was featured in this video, yet I don't hear you complaining about it.
You left out the Gamecube, PS2, Xbox, PS3, Xbox 360, Wii, Xbox One and PS4 versions that were included in compilation titles, plus the Green Hill stage's inclusion in Sonic Adventure 2.
@@sonicwithagun2347 I say that in Sonic Adventure 2, there is also the Green Hill bônus phase to unlock. Besides that there is another emulator that reproduces Sega Genesis perfectly in Dreamcast
MD/Genesis - A 90's Classic Arcade - Countdown SEGA Saturn - Spindash Dreamcast - Enjoyable But The Audio Is Bad And It Has Graphical Errors J2ME (Glu) - Look Even More Pixelated And No Sound Effects J2ME (IFone) - Looks Better But Still No Sound Effects GBA - We Dont Talk About That Version Nintendo DS - Better Than The GBA Port Nintendo 3DS - Oh Look 2D But With A 3D Filter Android/IOS - The Defenitve Expirence Nintendo Switch - The Drop Dash Is Added To Sonic 1
I call the Sega Saturn version it's own port since it's not running emulation. That's why the ring sounds are a bit different and the spring sounds like it came from flash games on Newgrounds.
Funny, I used to own Sega Smash Pack and dont remember Sonic sounding like Master System...but I like it. STILL, why didn't they just use the Genesis music as red book audio? Couldn't they have hooked up a model 1 Genesis to a tape recorder and gotten the music that way?
Everyone be ignoring the Sonic Generations 3DS version of Classic Green Hill. That one was a complete copy and paste of the original with 3DS graphics.
🕹️ Explore retroserk, my other channel dedicated to retro game reviews and comparisons in Spanish. Join the fun! youtube.com/@retroserk
👉 Check out more EVOLUTIONS of SONIC GAMES HERE! ruclips.net/video/dw-QWAU0ZQ0/видео.html
Hey, the version I have does not come out, in my case for some reason I start in the spring yard zone and there are no checkpoints. . _.
SONIC 30 ANOS
@@alex7770_ i think thats a nes bootleg
The Dreamcast version is like a master system that had the capability of a genesis but still had the master system sound chip.
Lol, it sounds exactly like that
That is sooo bad sorry dreamcast 😔
That's called a Genesis with only psg.
I don't think it's that good...
Dreamcast sounds awful imo. 😖 Don't hate me
I played the GBA version and immediately contemplated cutting off my thumbs.
Same
@@nintendogp2017 'picky'. The game is almost fucking unplayable on Original Mode
Gba version is better on pc
@@fazlizorer3517 If you've experimented with Clickteam products back in the day and its default movement then maybe
@@nintendogp2017 Then you're bloody sad
There's technically also the Master System version.
It’s not the same game.
Harry Humble/IME Entertainment By that logic, neither are Sonic Mania and Generations.
@@retroreina400 well, Sonic 1 is playable in Sonic Generations, and it's the full game!
diana loayzat That is also true! I was mostly referring to the fact that they used the actual generations iteration in this video.
Mania and Generations are there to show how the old game has evolved into the modern day.
6:59 This, THIS... Was the first game I ever played
Ohh.... Poor soul..
It can only get better so at least you have that
I am so sorry you had to experience that
F
Oh God I'm so sorry for you
The dream cast versions title is...disturbing!
i think that bug was also in the original game i believe
@@_pulstar Its a side effect of poor emulation. Its not like that on better emulators or on real hardware.
Are you talking about the dact his body goes through the flag thingy?
@@reactingchannelgamingchann2919 yep...and sonic has no body!
@@blazerplays8008 legless sonic
Wow they royally screwed the Dreamcast version up!
*really
@@SN64YT no ROYALLY SCREWED UP. It's a trope to mean that something has reached it's apex of all things wrong.
Not really. Compared to today's emulation accuracy, it might seem quite shoddy, but this was still around the infancy of emulation, and the Dreamcast wasn't a particularly powerful machine compared to the other three consoles in its generation, so the fact that it can - to a certain degree of accuracy - emulate a console that only released nine years prior is quite impressive. The modern equivalent would be the Playstation 5 emulating a base model PS4.
@@alfo2804 I'm sorry what? You really don't know your hardware if you think the Dreamcast wasn't powerful. The Dreamcast was based off the Sega Naomi arcade hardware which inspired hardware like Atomiswave nearly a decade later. The Dreamcast was the second hardware to bring home a 1:1 arcade experience next to the NeoGeo AES. Believe me the Dreamcast was more than capable in performing emulation. At best the software emulation was in it's infancy as you said but the Dreamcast hardware was more than capable of delivering which is why Naomi lived on even after the fall of the Dreamcast. I think you need to do a little research in the history and specifications of the Dreamcast. The reason it failed wasn't because of it's performance. It was because of piracy.
@@bruno-vicious What the fuck are you even talking about? I know what the Dreamcast is, what it was based on and what it's capable of. I also know that it's very common knowledge that emulation requires a device to be exponentially more powerful than the console it's emulating, which the Dreamcast simply wasn't. Even the PS2, Xbox and Gamecube couldn't emulate the Mega Drive with great accuracy. Plus, the MD is a notoriously difficult system to emulate, especially with its sound hardware, so it's no wonder it came out the way it did.
And what on Earth does the console's failure have to do with this? The reason you gave was a complete myth, anyway, so it's even less relevant to the topic.
The Dreamcast version sounds more like an arcade game
An arcade game on crack
@@andknuckles101 you get a like for nose exhale
Nah, it's sounds 8 bit
Man, I grew up with the iOS version. I love it.
It's awesome. It even plays beyond 16/9 on modern full screen phones.
Me too
You're that young? I know I'm only 8 but still
SAME
And I’m 8
Dreamcast version: it's evolving, just backwards
Devolving, is the word you're looking for ;).
exactly
@moppedstick what?
@moppedstick did you even read this thread?
@@yellow94 EGGsactly
4:01 That's a joke, right?
I think it's an emulated version with a messed-up emulator that gives this 8-bit sound.
Just look at Sonic's posture, there's already a display bug.
Well, it is an edition of Sonic 1. It's running on the emulator used on Sega Smash Pack Volume 1, which was rushed to be ready for release by launch day. They didn't have enough time to make an accurate emulator.
@Josue And Gamy ? How is it funny?
This 4:01 is fatal poison to sonic.i cant imagine sonic adventure
@Josue And Gamy you’re the type of person that contributes nothing
Well, i like this 8-bit sound
Oh that's interesting, I also have the Glu J2ME version (first flip phone game I owned and also first Sonic game I owned) but it looked different, sprites were actually the same size and looked much more similar to the Mega Drive ones :o
There was even a background in the title screen and everything! Save system, level select, How to Play, and leaderboards! (I think there was a password on Part 2 to transfer chaos emeralds if you got all of them but I never could)
Probably version for smaller screen resolution thing. It's still a very very good port especially for the system it's on, spent hours upon hours on it despite starting with part 2 that starts at Labyrinth Zone and getting part 1 about 6 months later...
I'd gladly share the version I own if I can get it out of my phone!
Everyone’s talking about the Dreamcast and GBA ports but the J2ME fone has:
Glitchy title screen
Music problems.
Less sound effects
But I can forgive the glu port as it was inferior but the fone port, it’s almost as bad as the Dreamcast or gba port.
There not music problems the gba hardware could not handle the music form the genesis so that had to make an entire different soundtrack
@@Creg-ev2qm I was talking about the J2ME fine port
Can't forget about the weirdly misaligned sprites!
Im late to the comments, but@@Creg-ev2qm The gba could handle some advanced music and it could had a better port if it wasnt rushed. Check out the proof lf concept made by stealth iirc. I dont renember exactly who did it but they did an better green hill on gba
I think the iFone version is better than Glu version.
Cool comparison. My personal favorite is the sega genesis version. Especially since I grew up playing that game. Good times.
I grew up with the android/ios version, they were my first unterduction to sonic the hedgehog (sorry for my bad english)
11:47
Genesis does what nintendont switch
Ninten *dont* swich?
@@fazlizorer3517 did u not get the joke
It “doesn’t” switch.
YOU CAN'T DO SHIT ON NINTENDO
@@fazlizorer3517 U dont understand anything
The line scrolling and parallax are actually better in the MegaDrive Japanese release. It’s strange given that they’re the same exact system. There are no scrolling clouds in the US version. For some reason, I always thought that the first time the clouds scrolled independently was the Saturn Sonic Jam Sonic 1 port. The cloud scrolling effect makes the first 3 stages look much more alive since there’s always some form of motion occurring on the screen. Thanks for posting this, it’s a great video.
The Japanese version was released a bit later the other versions, so Sonic Team was able to give it a little more polish.
The Dreamcast version almost reminds me of the @games version. But I grew up with the DS version on Sonic Classic Collection, so many memories playing that compilation
Same
My first experience of Sonic 1 was a J2ME port split in 2 parts. I don't think it was the iFone version, but it certainly wasn't the Glu one showed here (maybe they had 2? one for low-end device, another for high-end ones). My phone had a far better MIDI sound bank however so the music didn't sound nearly as bad as in this video -- somehow the uploader managed to find a J2ME runtime which actually uses a *worse* MIDI bank than the one Sonic Genesis uses (which uses the same midis in theory).
Wow the Dreamcast version should have never passed QC.. that was rough in all areas
You forgot the iPod click wheel version
" Other versions based on emulation as the first iPhone version (2008) have been excluded. "
@@bmhedgehog2 but the IPod release isnt normal emulation
Yeah that really should have been included, though I suspect finding a way to play it might be a problem now. It was such a bugger to play with the clickwheel.
@@SomeInterestingName sadly nobody has cracked the code for it. It might be lost to time.
@@bmhedgehog2
The first iPhone versions were different from iPod version.
Also, there was a port of the Game Gear version for some PDA if i remember correctly.
DS was such a lazy emulation, it ran terribly if you used an old model DS. I remember when I played it on 3DS, all the lag was gone, but the picture still looked a bit squished/flickery in spots, and the sound quality is lacking. Still it was great to have those games portable on the DS, but it was a letdown for sure when I first got it.
Aside from the Gameboy emulation, the DS is a terrible emulation device. They should have just ported it instead.
But its still better than gba
Sonic 2 bonus video
Sonic 2 bonus video
Sonic 2 bonus video
The version I played was on the Sonic Mega Collection on GameCube. This, 2, and Mania are my favorite Sonic games
what about sonic 3k?
@@maximumcrystal3562 3&K is definitely on my top 5 sonic games list but I didn’t like it as much as 1,2,and Mania. Still a great game though
@@TheDerpyDolphin huh, okay then
Remember: you could play TWO versions of sonic 1 on DS (OG and Lite): the GBA version and the DS emulation
wow
We now have a choice:
Bad version (GBA)
Good version (DS)
Please don't tell me someone grew up with the J2ME version
I did.
@@mizzix Dafuq?
@@sonicwithagun2347 yes
C'mon, it's pretty good for its limitations.
Only now did I realize that the water is dark blue on the title screen but light blue in the actual gameplay.
The Android/iOS version by Christian Whitehead puts all other versions to shame.
But yet, this remaster is so good. No wonder why it can be played on other consoles and PC as a decompilation.
The Nintendo DS and 3DS has 2 screens so that’s why it looks weird
I have both versions and they’re really good ports
@@McCoy-00 noice
@@McCoy-00 But the DS version doesn't have spindash
It's from a compilation called Sonic Classic Collection
When I first saw the very low quality one, I thought this was clickbait
boy was I wrong
10:01 The wider aspect ratio from android/ios plus the cleaner sfx made this version the best one after the original
Imagine someone that never played the first sonic and started with the Dreamcast version and being like: *this game sucks it sounds so awful !* And then talking about how shit it is not realising that the real one is better.
Why would they think it sounds bad if they never heard the original? It sounds just as good as the 8 bit ones
They got the jump sound right
@@theshinycharmander258 Because that sound is 8 bit
The original version is still awesome but really the Christian Whitehead remake is so good. I wish every Megadrive game was remade that way.
It's rare but you can find the Arcade version today. I've played it. It doesn't have Marble zone and it's really weird.
That sounds like an improvement over genesis tbh
When I was a 6 year old kid, i thought the arcade version was the same that the mobile version lol
Hey, if there's the Sonic Mania version in this video, why did the Master System one isn't on it?
@Super Retro guy Sonic Mania and Sonic Generations' versions too, but they're in.
I think the reason is that, whereas the Green Hill Zone of _Sonic Mania_ and _Sonic Generations_ is an elaboration of the original, the one found in the 8-bit versions is quite different even though it was clearly inspired by the 16-bit game.
@@reillywalker195
Yeah, I agree with you. The Master System GHZ has nothing in common to the original one in terms of level design.
Game Gear is also different from Master System in many ways, even though much less ways than GEN to MS. There's a whole one hour video covering the things Ancient did to make sure the Game Gear version won't feel unfair or unpolished on the Game Gear.
Considering generations and mania are not even the same game, just have a version of GHZ.
5:04 we are never EVER allowed to call sonic 1 gba’s music bad ever again.
the midis still have higher quality though
it's actually not too bad
Sonic Mega Collection: Am I a joke to you?
you should have more subs an wiews ,you put much efforts in your videos
I don’t really get why people are freaking out over the Dreamcast version, it’s kinda cool with the 8-bit remix
Thanks for the video
U R true
So nobody is going to talk about the first J2ME version?
5:59 the first Sonic i played
Damn..
@@Eden_M0rgan I was in my grandfather's Nokia it was a demo
@@AxelFluff Oh shit. I thought that was the GBA version
By your bonus inclusion standards you should've also added SA2 and Sonic 1 on Master System since both had Green Hill Zone in it
iOS and android versions are the versions of this game that sega should be porting to newer consoles. They are not emulations but faithfully re-created versions of the game with a lot of care put into them and the sound is essentially what the genesis is capable of doing but digitally ripped from real hardware so it's technically more accurate than playing the game on original analog output hardware.
How can it be more accurate than original hardware? That's literally impossible. It can be up to 100% accurate, but not any more.
@@alfo2804 Because you're not dealing with a digital source, the sound chip converting the sound to analog using the built-in DAC in the genesis then being piped out after going through filters and possible noise inside the console itself. Instead the sound itself was ripped from the source before it could be converted to an analog signal in the first place. You're right it is 100% accurate but the original hardware itself is not 100% accurate which is self evident also from model 1 and model 2 consoles using different chips also.
Well, I've fallen down a rabbit hole I won't be escaping from
wow generations looks amazing. I need to go back to the old games. Special times.
Mania absolutely
I think the reason for creating Sonic Generations and celebrating Sonic's 20 year anniversary. Isn't it ?
5:03 If nintendo made sonic
Carter Kwakye-Safo U must be fun at parties
@Carter nice roast,can i steal it?
@Carter shut up
Carter Do you not get a jo- I mean wtf
I have a soft spot for the DS version from Classic Collection. It’s the best of the handheld Sonic 1’s.
The J2ME version is just the GBA port but with no sound effects and different music.
EDIT: Actually the J2ME version has better physics.
Yep
Same with the glu J2ME but worse graphics
i like how the j2me sounds better than dreamcast lmao
Nothing beats the genesis/mega drive original. Though it is interesting to see the spin dash included on ports like on the Saturn.
2013 mobile port is right there
7:04 the way the music ends XD
0:01 Mega Drive
1:04 Sega Genesis
2:03 Arcade
3:04 Sega Saturn
4:01 Dreamcast
5:02 J2ME
5:59 J2ME
6:58 GameBoy Advance
7:57 Nintendo DS
The Classic Collection was how I found out about the classic games
I'm surprised you didn't include the Dreamcast Sonic Adventure 2 Green Hill Bonus level, where it starts out on a 2d plane and then switches to 3D.
And the PAL Europe version of Sonic 1 (different from NTSC USA Sonic 1 ) would have been nice to see the speed difference.
Would have been nice to have seen Sonic 1 3DS on a real 3DS to see that 3D perspective
Sonic Adventure 2's version is too different because it is 3D.
this video is about sonic 1 the game, not just green hill zone
@@thesupervideogamenerdmore3171
Generation's version of Sonic 1 is also in 3D and it was featured in this video, yet I don't hear you complaining about it.
@@marissawolff8491 It is visually 3D, but Classic Green Hill from 3DS Generations is still only 2D movement.
@@thesupervideogamenerdmore3171
Okay. Well, I haven't played either version of that Sonic game, so I'm not gonna go any further in this conversation.
I grew up with the Dreamcast version so that ones always gonna be my favorite lol
You left out the Gamecube, PS2, Xbox, PS3, Xbox 360, Wii, Xbox One and PS4 versions that were included in compilation titles, plus the Green Hill stage's inclusion in Sonic Adventure 2.
They cannot be included as they all emulated.
Dreamcast too
@@sonicwithagun2347 I say that in Sonic Adventure 2, there is also the Green Hill bônus phase to unlock. Besides that there is another emulator that reproduces
Sega Genesis perfectly in Dreamcast
@@jotabese6530 But sonic adventure 2 is a modern game and this vid includes classic stages
I grew up with classic collection on the ds, so I have WAY too much nostalgia for that game
Same!
It was my fav childhood game.. It was so nostalgic.
MD/Genesis - A 90's Classic
Arcade - Countdown
SEGA Saturn - Spindash
Dreamcast - Enjoyable But The Audio Is Bad And It Has Graphical Errors
J2ME (Glu) - Look Even More Pixelated And No Sound Effects
J2ME (IFone) - Looks Better But Still No Sound Effects
GBA - We Dont Talk About That Version
Nintendo DS - Better Than The GBA Port
Nintendo 3DS - Oh Look 2D But With A 3D Filter
Android/IOS - The Defenitve Expirence
Nintendo Switch - The Drop Dash Is Added To Sonic 1
Dreamcast: sounds and music in the 8-bit version
4:01 I like 8-bit music and this is epic. More like a master system
Codin' Ninja booooo
2:04 Upgrade
3:05 Go back
4:02 I SAID GO BACK
5:03 *_Why are we still here..._*
What's wrong with the saturn version ?
@@adamator00 The music and sfx are a bit messed up in that version.
@@adamator00 Anything changed but the audio only
Spindash is from Sonic 3/ Sonic dash/Sonic generations it's just messed up
@@brandoncourtney57 Yea but dont need to ask
I call the Sega Saturn version it's own port since it's not running emulation. That's why the ring sounds are a bit different and the spring sounds like it came from flash games on Newgrounds.
Where's genesis mini version?
11:14
retrosutra: spin dashes in sonic 1
Nintendo: wait thats illegal
Sega owns Sonic, not Nintendo.
@@blazerplays8008 oh wait I forgot lmao I'll change it
@@werlux5613 ok
@@werlux5613 When will you change it?
And just when I thought the Sega Saturn was bad.... The Dreamcast was a full ear assault!
Edit: The J2ME can make a person's ear bleed!
I don't see anything wrong with J2ME's music. It sounds okay to me.
Say that to the GBA version
0:47 HOL' UP!
4:01 SONIC MY BOY!!!! What did they do to you.
Look at how they've massacred my boy
It's a depressin' error, or it happens everytime you play the dreamcast version
@@dusanstojsin4938Say that to 6:58
Say that to 6:58
Funny, I used to own Sega Smash Pack and dont remember Sonic sounding like Master System...but I like it.
STILL, why didn't they just use the Genesis music as red book audio? Couldn't they have hooked up a model 1 Genesis to a tape recorder and gotten the music that way?
Sonic advance 3 versions is my favorite, still hoping for the day Sega acknowledges the that advance trilogy and ds trilogy.
4:01
Sound like 8 Bit
Yep it can be beter
(I thing be couse it is end of SEGA :'(
Yea, is a bootleg port
@@sonicwithagun2347 please, i'm no want to perish
Feels bad when the best version of one of my favourite games can only be played on a phone🤦♂️
Is something wrong with it? You can take it with you anywhere!
The Japanese version is actually the second revision. The American one is actually the first revision...
Best versions:
Mega Drive/Genesis
Saturn
J2ME Glu
Nintendo DS (Because this version is like the emulator)
IOS/Android
Sonic Generations is the kind of concept they should have strived for with the Dreamcast. They squandered the Dreamcast.
GBA feels like you’re trying to hold your dog while he slips on the Waxed floor
Intro Music on Sonic Generation is a reference of Ending Music of Sonic the Hedgehog 1
15:16 cool music and plus that song was first in sonic 1 at the end of sonic 1
The glu version sounds like a cool remix
At least, but a moment in the green hill zone remix was similar to mania lol
Man, Genesis sound emulation was ROUGH in 2001 lol
one of my cousins used to have the 2nd j2me version
This is the first time I've heard the Dreamcast version and... ew.
9:00 Nintendo 3DS
10:00 iOS
10:00 Android
11:04 Nintendo Switch
12:08 Sonic Mania
15:16 Sonic Generations
You should’ve included the Sonic Generations 3DS version because that one is also a direct recreation of the first Green Hill act.
You Missed the Fire TV Stick version
The usa version and Europe version are different. The music is slower in the European version
@Carter indeed, but the slow music was more noticeable to me when I first played ntsc sonic. Pal 50hz sucks. Im glad those days are over.
Yes I agree...
One thing that the DS version could have added is a progress line similar to New Super Mario Bros.
Oh god no
It's emulated! What did you expect?
@@JoseGregorioValeroVillarroel People can hack or add to emulated games. Also, remaking parts of the Sonic trilogy is not that hard.
J2ME sounds cool grafic was like sonic pocket advanture (glu version)
Fazli Zorer it’s iFone
Both of you are wrong it's Iphone
Ivan Chupp no it’s iPhone not Iphone
@@ivanchupp602 U fool, the iPhone version is the same that Android/iOS
@@sonicwithagun2347 I was correcting someone. I think the mobile version is the best.
I don't remember Sonic Jam having such a poor jump sound....
I like it.
Sonic is my favourite game
Can you upload Sonic death Comparison?
I'll be waiting
MegaDrive/Genesis version for the win!
I'm surprised they didn't show the OG Sonic port in Sonic Generations
4:01 If Sonic Was On A NES:
My favorite 4 Versions, Sonic mania and sonic generations and DS & 3DS
I miss the Game Gear and Master System Version
Sonic Mania is hands down the best sonic game ever
... Mega Drive wins ... 🥇
Best music, speed ... the original !
Android and IOS came in second
What about sonic mania
And i have to admit that i love sonic generations Its so cool
I Love GBA SoundTrack
Everyone be ignoring the Sonic Generations 3DS version of Classic Green Hill. That one was a complete copy and paste of the original with 3DS graphics.