The fact that lawmakers proposed an anti-nonconsensual AI porn bill after Taylor spoke up against the AI pics of her, and people still have the nerve to say, celebs speaking about political issues has no use or impact is WILD! USE YOUR FOLLOWERS!
Especially after Xochitl Gomez, and underage actress, spoke out about deepfakes of herself as well as that teenage who committed suic*de because people spread deepfakes of her. But no- Taylor Swift is the priority here
I’ve never really heard that ? Do they say that a lot ? I’ve only heard how people don’t get why celebs don’t use their platforms because they can bring more awareness especially if their super popular like Taylor swift
I'm not entirely disagreeing. But I think it's worth remembering that there's a lot of steps in between proposing bills and making real change. We saw a lot of performative bills and actions in 2020 but, despite all the present gaslighting, police were never de-funded or even significantly reformed in almost any major city or country. When you focus on major changes celebrities do in fact have quite limited power. Firstly because, by dint of being celebrities 99.9% of them will not challenge the power structure in meaningful ways e.g. how many of them actually put their money where their mouth is and fund truly radical groups that are pressuring for things like de-fund the police. And secondly, because the power structure is just too good at making superficial changes to make people think they're listening when they aren't. When the bills celebrities push for do things like return the country to the old school antitrust laws for every major monopoly, or if they're actually creating major changes in labour relations or the structure of society, then I think you'll see real power. Me too is probably the only recent example I can think of where there was a real sea change in terms of where companies put their resources.
@@somethingunusual8456 that's not true at all. she postponed a show in brasil due to extreme heat and during one of her concerts she was the one telling the security to bring water to the fans, it was the stadium's organization that lacked.
@@werecookie I live in the damn city that it happened. Tickets for fun was atrociously criminal? For sure, they're scum, they had fcking metal floors installed knowing it would be 40°C heat and cut off mechanical air circulation for God's sake, but to tell me Taylor's team didn't know about the structure and the climate is just laughable. They have a say on every aspect of the Tour, but let's say they magically didn't know. DOZENS of people were already fainting during Sabrina's opening. The concert should have been cancelled right there at that point. There wasn't even enough medical aid to all the people fainting. No matter how many water bottles Taylor asked for the fans, it was not enough for everybody, also the water was hot. Ana was near the stage after all, and this fact didn't help her whatsoever!!! I strongly suggest you stop denying evidence. Taylor doesn't care, she actively denied it happening during the concert in her "letter" instagram post (which the authorities confirmed it DID happen during the show, after the second song of Taylor) just to avoid legal problems. There are actual WITNESSES but Taylor said it happened BEFORE the concert. Ana wasn't even from Rio, she and her friend paid almost 5k to get there. It was her dream to see Taylor live. Taylor didn't even help the family to pay for the body to be transported back to her hometoen, the brazilian fans did. No matter what PR stunt Taylor did the next week after that to save her neck, we will never forget, neither will Ana's parents and loved ones.
@@werecookie also we know she postponed the concert on the 18th because of the backlash. It was the day after Ana died. HUNDREDS, if not THOUSANDS of people were ALREADY inside the stage when the news about the postponing were dropped. It caused a lot of chaos afterwards. Inform yourself.
Duh, happily announcing your new album when I'm sure people have been begging her to speak out speaks volume. Oh and the album's name hmm what a hilariously, dark coincidence
the thing is you can't justify silence anymore imo when it comes to the point when you actually realize how much influence these people have. you literally have millions of people who will hear what you have to say. celebrities don't have to be activists, but just posting a donation link isn't activism, it's just trying to help out.
Posting a donation link is a minor form of activism, and that's okay. I don't like this idea that being an activist is controversial, so celebrities need to be made comfortable with what's asked of them. Especially when they're mega rich and have a cult-like following.
Y'all are expecting celebrities to do the heavy work for you and spoon-feed you where to click, where to vote and for whom. Do you hear how ridiculous this is? C'mon celebrities are not bigger than the news and news networks. When anything major happens most people would've heard about it. That's one. Two. Y'all are grown adults. Go donate yourself, go write letter to congressman yourself. Everything you're asking from a celeb, you can do yourself. What you're basically expecting from them is for them to *organize* this for you. And what's holding back grown individuals who are particularly interested in this issue from looking up how they can support the side they picked?? Go reflect on what you just said, taking into point my message. People don't actually need these celebs for activism the way you think you do. In the end, only people interested will be involved. And those who want to be would do so without a celebrity intervention and speaking. Matter of fact - Americans biggest cities are so heavily dense unlike smaller countries - that you can go downtown and set up a stall and you'll draw up enough attention for your favourite cause. And the longer you spend there (days) the more visibility and people you'll reach. What's holding back highly interested in this topic individuals from doing it all themselves? Y'all act like you ain't got the power but these celebs do. Don't wait on celebrities go and do it yourself if you care that much. Stop using them as an excuse why _you_ aren't doing more
@LovelyLittleLillies The thing that's stopping interested individuals from engaging in all the forms of activism that suit them is time and finances. It's that simple. The vast majority of people need to work on order to even have a place to go back to after canvassing. Canvassing is extremely expensive in the long run, and it was done in the past and today through finals and large scale organization. Most donations don't tend to simply come from other workers in your immediate area. Being sponsored by a wealthy benefactor in a capitalist society goes a long way. It's also disingenuous to ignore that, in America, grassroots movements, especially ones that directly counter capitalist interests, tend to be directly sabotaged by the even more powerful interests they're protesting. You're engaging in the dumbass "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" mentality that plagues the conservative, reactionary mentality of America as a whole. Celebrities have an exceptional amount of power. It isn't about convincing activists, it's about convincing their millions of followers, as well as utilizing their millions of dollars in capital to help support these grassroots movements. And claiming they neither have a responsibility or even power to do so is just showing how narrow your grasp of politics is. You know how pretty much every single celebrity you know does ads? That is one of the many, many things they're obligated to do to curate an image for themselves and the people that pay them. Making sure that people don't know a company engages in slavery or partially funds a dictator is an expensive campaign. Ads exist, in part, to present an appealing image to a wider audience in order to increase the passivity of the populace towards capitalist endeavors. Just because you're ignorant about how connected every system under capitalism is doesn't mean people are just being lazy or stupid. You're just not informed. Celebrities are not just popular people.
@@muntu1221 you bought the lie, sold exclusively to you, that you have less power as an individual than you actually do - so you're mad at me. I know very well the resources average people - especially someone from middle class - has to create movement and change. Because as a marginalized person I used many resources, be it financial or emotional or other, from small charities and spaces created by no one particularly big. They just put in the time to fund rase or seek out financial aid for sustenance wherever they can. And also buying groceries from East European markets and following the conflict in Eastern Europe, I'm well aware of who did what and helped how. Help for Ukrainians came first and foremost from their own people - if you look at refugees at the Mexican border, they were not taken in by some us organization but they managed to get into us by knowing someone (like a relative or friend) there. Then there was Poland - who gave the most help. And who's Poland, if not a neighbour and friend to UA. And at Eastern European local delis they set up donation boxes along with websites that organized donations and help in Ukraine. In the end, most of the help and financial aid came from Ukrainians living abroad and the other biggest help came from a neighboring country that gave temporary shelter. So while that country asked for help from everyone they could - as a westerner, you wouldn't know that North America did very little for Ukraine in aid other than the sanctions. Majority of aid came from fellow slavs. So if Eastern Europeans can come together, then so can Arabs - which have been helping p a Les tine for a while now. You just have a very western perspective on this conflict bc in us people think silly little social media posts do anything or comments from celebs are more useful than financial aid for people who are left without homes and food.. to organize financial aid for pal est inians doesn't require a celebrity intervention It's a statistic that when it comes to charities, most charitable donations are done by the lower classes and not the wealthy. So again, you're misinformed. Most donations for poverty, ex, are done by nobodies. Go look at Value Village - do they have ads and celebrities campaigning? Only public celebrity campaigning is done for organizations that are known for cop most of the money for themselves. So again, you don't need a celeb. I told you, didn't I - big metropolitan cities in US are so heavily dense that you can supplement a NYC times sq billboard ad by just setting up your own table downtown. Who needs to pay for ads when you got free access? My family used every resource imaginable and available when we were poor, that's how I know you don't need big names just to create organizations that facilitate help in your local community. Idk about where you live, but where I live even big name companies and banks donate annually locally for small local charitable things - you just gotta reach out and apply. So like I've showed you, I'm much more versed on this matter than you because you clearly have never been involved in any function that was organized and funded nor charitable organizations nor used any financial aid in local communities, like price organizations. You're busy speaking of "I can't" instead of doing something. There's a famous quote out there that will tell you Mu sk (or was it Bez os?) got where he did, and created what he did because he didn't focus his energy on "you can't" and never took a no. People are creating all this fuss online over celebrities all for nothing. It just shows your mentality of waiting in on others and being dependant then to start up things yourself. Oh and I remember a little boy who got famous in 2000's for setting up access to water for Africans simply because he aspired to, and he successfully managed to raise fun in hundred thousands or millions. But none of what I said had anything to do with the bootstraps mentality - you're just regurgitating common famous themes.
Posting a donation link is like passing a flyer you received to someone else. "Here, you deal with it." When you have .000000001 cent for every dollar they have and they ask for donations, it comes off very disingenuous.
I used to appreciate Taylor, Selena, Beyoncé, lady Gaga, Rihanna and more. But at the end of the day, they are not people like us, they are billionaires, they are not even humans anymore. It’s all about power.
Wdym? They’re still humans. Humans with different life experiences from most people, but humans nonetheless. I don’t think entertainers occupy the same power space or greed as politicians. But anyway, No sense in seeing people who disappoint you as non-human. We don’t need to completely write them off we Just need to appropriately temper our expectations.
I think that can be refuted in many cases. Many a dictator were native to their land but destroyed it. Same applies to a lot of the world's leading industrial powers. Governments screw the people for personal gain and are quite corrupted.
RUclips seems to have deleted my initial comment, but this is easily refutable by mere seconds of research. There are multiple accounts of indigenous people destroying their own land, either via civil war, having an authoritarian regime take power, corrupt politicians or simple industrialization and population growth which is in general pretty harmful to the environment.
Seeing these celebrities and normal everyday people alike completely disregard any of the multiple genocides taking place has only confirmed for me further the relationship between hyperindividuality, racism and capitalism. Thank you for using your platform, Palestine will be free.
i remember thinking during the holocaust if they had the internet we could save them but now i have learned that communication does not work they can still pretend to be deaf
@@yayayayahaikyuu4261 They do believe they are gods…and most of them are following an agenda, and do spells in their music and performance… They do not care about the fans only if , you in love with them. Humans were never meant to be put on position with that much of money if it leads them to think they are above us.
I am really glad to see this comment . At this point its just too necessary that we should have at least ‘a day’ where celebrities should be realized they are just humans like all of us . We should ignore them . We are the ones let em be celebrities in the first place , or is it ? Because they are generally ppl get ‘chosen’ by someone and served us as the talented great ppl . Many things are wrong in this world system, i am just glad too many ppl are getting aware that it wont help but it will harm all of us in the first place . Its basically even turns into ‘idolizing’ em and acting they are superior , which leads em all to do anything to be like em . Its so sick. They are all love Israel , but why ? Bcz they are the one got chosen by them and just keeps getting all money just for themselves but for also another reason. Even that lqbt stuff is reduced only to stop ppl breeding . Cuz to this idea , world have to be owned by jews . If i wrote these in 2021 ppl would be laughing at me , but here i am , seein ppl realized, i know who is guilty and they will be punished by us or the next generation so heavily. War is soon guys .
I bet you don’t have the same when it comes to Iranians, yemenis, or the uyghurs in china, as a matter of fact im willing to bet money you’re actually against Ukrainians and don’t even know about Armenians
@@normandy2501 Millions of people rallying, protesting, getting arrested, contacting their representatives, confronting senators face to face, camp outside blinken and bidens house, showing up wherever those dirty politicians are....are done just purely for their own benefit? Let's get things straight Miss Taylor swift with her millions of dedicated fans? Miss Taylor who can amassed mass hate in a snap towards people she said she doesn't like? Miss Taylor who cause thousands to turn up to vote just cuz she said so? Miss Taylor swift who biden and trump are fighting over to get in her good gracious? Miss Taylor who was crying saying she wannabe on the right side of history and want to speak on politics more? That person, can do what took millions of people marching and protesting from all around the world for the past 4 months, with just 1 post to influence people to at the very least search about this issue and have more people aware of things that actually matters that also actually can and will affect them. She becomes the Times magazine person of the year in the middle of gen0cide backed by her own country is fking hilarious
@@somethingunusual8456 Ana's death was the reason I no longer listen to Taylor (nor do I care about her) and she had been my most listened to artist on Spotify since 2018.
@@michelcomenta vou falar em português, que eu acho, pelo seu username, que vc também fala kkkk enfim, até como brasileira mas sobretudo como ser humano eu aplaudo de pé sua decisão de não ser mais fã da Taylor apesar da história que tem com a música dela. Isso mostra muita maturidade e comprometimento com as lutas que valem realmente a pena. Não posso dizer que fiz o mesmo porque nunca fui fã da Taylor, mas até gostava de algumas músicas. Agora, quando elas aparecem no rádio, nas lojas, enfim (me sinto no panóptico rs) só sinto um gosto amargo na boca
@@candylove49 We are not asking them to fix the world. Raising awareness is the start and BARE MINIMUM. Look at Beyonce she stood up for BLM, raises black voices, literally ENCOURAGED focused protesting for BLM and donates to HBCU's. Similar pathways can be taken to show support in Palestine....yet celebrities dont do it including Bey. Of course Beyonce cant single handedly solve police brutality but she can help raise awareness, donate money to the right sources and even skew people's opinion and share knowledgable information to a large amount of people at one time.
Also even if it doesn’t it will teach more people about it and even if it doesn’t do that you re at least not gonna look like a pro genocide blood hungry loser
they surely did not think that way when they brought war criminals hillary clinton biden obama to their concerts and showed their support for them in votes, they cannot claim now that they are ignorant about politics when they already got themselves involved with war criminals
Great video! I'll add that celebrity activism in North America often suffers the same problem as rich philanthropy: white savior syndrome. Instead of working with Palestinians to achieve the liberation of Palestine, they use their wealth and influence in a paternalistic way to push their own vision of what Palestine should be
Aren't the Sudan and Congo conflicts civil wars? That are happening in countries that are notoriously unstable? The whole conversation about Palestine and Israel is happening because a foreign power (Israel) is attacking Palestine and enacting a genocide on the people. That makes it an international conflict, and thus creates conversation around the world. At the same time, Sudan and Congo have internal civil wars, that kind of makes it their problem to solve, right? The point is, it's up to Sudan and Congo not to have a civil war.
@@nickklavdianos5136Actually Israel is retrieving territories that we're forcibly taken away by foreigners centuries ago. And the Middle East is notorious for being unstable itself so people should ignore the Palestine affair just like we should ignore the Congo and others, right?
@@BroJo676 wait wait wait..... Israel is retrieving territories? What territories? The same ones Israelis left from and didn't go back until after WWII? Those ones? It's not like they stayed there, is it? They left, they let the Arabians take full control, and after centuries passed, they went back, removed people from lands in which they were living for hundreds of years, because somehow, even after leaving, those lands still belonged to the Israelis? How does that make any sense? Let me explain nationalism to you, because you clearly don't get it. In nationalism, the borders of the state coincide with the borders of the nation. Meaning that wherever the population is in its majority of one nation, that land belongs to that nation. So tell me again, how does that principal work with Israel and Palestine? Was the majority of people living there Israelis? No, they were Arabs. So, it is therefore rightfully Arabic land.
I understand but they are getting some great coverage on socials where it starts and of course we can do more. I think Palestine right now has gotten the most because it has happened for over 70 years at this point and they don't even have a country of their own at the moment and are being pushed out their own land by someone else. Their population has also decreased drastically. In a perfect world all three would be getting huge coverage but at the moment it's hard to get people and celebs to care about Palestine which is truly heartbreaking. We already having boycotts, posting, and outraging and its still happening.
@@user-fe8uq9zp2g Kurds don't have a country of their own either. Many peoples have historical countries without having one recognized by the United Nations.
Girl, I love your videos, you're probably my favourite youtuber in this area right now. I used to be a really big fan of Taylor Swift, when she came to brazil i travelled the country to watch her live, it was a very chaotic, we were going through a heat wave and a girl died while attending her concert. She said nothing about it, only a short cold note on a Instagram story, she didn't pay her any homage at the concert, didn't even say her name, and her family had to go to national tv begging for the fans to help transport her body back to where she was from, there's no proof Swift did anything but invite her family to another concert. Her fans worldwide seems to ignore this has happened, and makes me think if it was an american or even european fan it would have the same silence, silence from her, her team, the media, it just seems like our lives don't matter, the 3rd world lives are just not as important as americans. I used to think Taylor was a decent human being till that day, then i realized she probably doesn't care, when she talked about american elections was because maybe she thought it was safe enough for her to get envolved in this subject, would cause more good than harm or maybe because she cares about american politics, but what happens in the rest of the world? I don't think she gives a damn, and that was very sad to realize because I loved her and she said in her documentary that she wanted to take part in politics more often and she wanted to be in the right side of history. But she wants that only when it's convenient. That's all I had to say, great video. Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
hey! i am not from brazil nor have i ever been close to going to see her live, but i definitely agree with everything you said. when i learned about the story of the poor girl who died, i was absolutely disgusted by how she handled the situation : the videos of her singing « bigger than the whole sky » in homage or whatever were very unsettling for me to watch because people were singing along as if the whole situation was yet again about her, not about a poor girl who lost her life because of bad management AT HER CONCERT, i couldn’t understand how she managed to victimize herself when she was (even if its indirectly) responsible for the loss of a life cause after all it’s HER show !! i found that very disturbing and one life is already a big loss but no one cared so how would you expect these delusional and heartless people to feel bad about tens of thousands of innocent people getting killed ?? i too used to love her a lot but it’s all changed and even though we may not have enough power to voice our morals with significant impact because she’ll always have obsessive fans who only breathe for her music, we can still boycott and stop supporting her, so that if no matter what happens we can say that we stood on the right side!! also i agree on what you said about her involvement in american politics, once again taylor swift only cares if SHE has benefits so.. ❤ 🇵🇸
Mandela legit targeted only structures and very careful was not targetting people. Because he wanted them live together in peace, he as president held also his still pretty angry party back while dealing with rassists. The big reason why the apartheit ended as rainbow nation, was that it had peace in mind to begin with by mandelas party and compromises, like while ther was violence still going on, he relentlessy negogiated and compromised for peace as president. Its pretty obvious that hamas dont. That is no excuse for the idf actions that , also, but hamas clearly isnt having that intentions. if it ther plo and fatah, ok that arent needlessy zealot, but hamas is. (which excuses no warcrimes ok) And i know abbot was assasinated so, yeah thats bad, but ther are 2 other parties that arent there, and israel is guilty not using them to delitigitimize hamas unbloody, , but comparing hamas to mandela is just offensive. Like the other 2 parties only do if actions that are specific not civilians and idf. If they do, hamas, are legitr terrorists, that stir up trouble. Ok and mandela too did only attacks on trade and economy , not human lives, or did his best.
Haven’t watching the whole thing yet but want to thank you for being vocal about this! We need more RUclipsrs speaking up, and opening up discourse. Talking and spreading information is really so powerful.
I would argue celebrities ARE NOT people. They are people who play a celebrity role. Taylor Swift is a person, but Taylor Swift the celebrity is a brand, an amalgamation of publicists, marketing companies, advisors, etc, etc. No matter what Taylor the person believes privately, Taylor the celebrity can only present as much as the amalgamation can agree on is good for the brand. Celebrities are more-than-people.
I want this video to have engagement, so this is my comment. Being an activist has costs--tangible costs. Some people are willing to pay, some aren't. There aren't easy answers, and I'm glad you engaged with some of the nuance.
@@FriendlyBatDoomin general whether it was during elections (2016 and backwards) Taylor Swift remained unequivocally silent and she does so in my regards when it comes to major issues arising in the US or elsewhere like during Black Lives Matter movement she was silent. She only speaks on issues to capitalize on them and make her look good. She showed a very LGBTQ+ front during her lover era but has remained incredibly silent since even tho there have been some pretty controversial bills passed regarding the LGBTQ community to further marginalize them
@@xoxsabrina Thank you for the clarification. I've always been told just how much she genuinely cared about issues and the people those issues affect. Guess those people were wrong.
I realized this about her when she released “You Need to Calm Down.” Everyone praised her like she did something revolutionary but it made me angry. That song is not going to help ANYONE, it’s just going to make the LGBT+ community look like an even bigger joke.
I agree that it's a moral obligation to stand in support of Palestine, but I simply don't see celebrities as moral models in any way. We should see them as the funny corporate toys they (more often than not) are. The fight is happening far away from social media accounts and movie studios. Power, i.e., the potential for change, rests in the hands of the workers and soldiers who are either blocking supplies to Israel or fighting to defend the Palestinian people.
The thing is because people (who are often "not into politics") blindly follow everything these celebrities say they would have a huge impact to reach these people, but then they would risk their popularity so that won't happen. There is no Limit to rich peoples greed.
The problem is these funny corporate toys hold too much influence, it can shift the tide. But pretty sure the most condemned are the one who propped themselves as activist and is currently popular like miss swifti and gomez
In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends. - Martin Luther King, Jr. Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence. - Leonardo da Vinci
I do feel that the kind of people who would do the right thing in these situations would mostly be excluded from these industries before they became big and influential. Like if you were someome trying to make it in the entertainment industry, and you were publicly supporting Palastine before, you wouldn't've made it up the ranks
i understand the frustration, and the fantasy of having big influential people sway the stance of politicians. when they did the Live Aid broadcast fundraiser in 1985, they raised a ton of money for the famine in ethiopia. if they can do it back then, why not now? but instead of raising money, urge people to write to their representatives. the answer is, it’s easier to raise money but how that money is managed is out of our control and almost futile. politics will always make people wary, because the established powers that be are firm with their stand. artists are human too and are beholden to their industry which sadly is pro-Israel and can’t fathom the idea that supporting Palestine doesn’t mean you’re antisemitic. the only thing we can do is do our part. but thank you for contributing to the discourse, cheyenne. always love listening to your takes.
I’ll expand it further. We’re ALL obligated to speak. If not, who will?! If I saw a child get followed by a grown adult and get harassed, I’m not “obligated” to do anything. Should I? Yes. But if I convince myself it is none of my business, I won’t. That child might get hurt because I didn’t help them, but I didn’t have to, so it’s okay. Right? That’s a big percentage of the population’s mindset. Remember this moving forward. People are NOT moving around life with well intentioned actions. Many people don’t have a will to help others and will excuse themselves. Wow. ☹️
The matter of whether or not celebrities should speak out about these issues was never a debate in the past. Many of the artists that they look up to were holding benefit concerts for resistance groups, mobilising and joining protests. I’m South African, many of our musicians during the apartheid era would release songs that were anti-apartheid and they were widely popular and used their gifts to spread the message of freedom. They drew more attention to the issue locally and internationally and were often jailed, exiled or had their music banned. Cultural boycotts matter!
I do think a lot of these celebrities are probably being aggressively told by their PR to not even hint at their stance on the situation, regardless of how they actually feel. People like Selena Gomez and Dua Lipa that are signing the letter but otherwise remaining silent at the least give me that vibe -- that they care but are being told not to speak out publicly by some sort of manager or agent. I know I saw Dua Lipa get bad press about what her stance *might* be (based on nothing but her family being Muslim from what I could see) without even saying a word.
Selena Gomez does not care when fans asked her to speak up she ignored it and said she was taking a break off social media. She then proceeded to post about her new boyfriend when she was called out on it her response was so what
the thing that gets me is that we ask these people to be representatives of their community to the point of forcing them to come out, but then act like we don’t want the people representing us to ACTUALLY represent our views.
this is not about representing the everday person. This is about raising your voice against genocide regardless of what people say about your intentions. Your argument is weak when we can clearly see that the celebrities speaking out against this have seen genuine support and appreciation for their efforts
I think I'm too far removed from celebrity/influencer culture to have any meaningful input. In the same way that ads on YT just make me never want to buy those products, celebrity endorsements of anything (be it products or causes) only serve to increase my skepticism of said thing. I don't get my news from them and I don't believe they're better informed than me just because they have millions of dollars (in fact, much like you said, they're probably NOT as well informed as me due to the detached nature of their existence) I think this argument is, for me at least, pointless. I already know who I'm voting for long before Taylor announces her endorsement and while I appreciate her help in making civic engagement "cooler".. I'm not convinced it's a net positive.
I agree with what you said completely. On one hand I understand why people want celebrities to take stands because fans would be pointed onto an issue. However, I think that in itself is a problem. Because how is it that people depend on celebrities to know what is going on in the world. People need to inform themselves regardless of what celebrities think or do. I don't know how to explain it but I don't put that expectation on celebrities because I inform myself on issues and make my stance on what info i got. I am a fan of taylor swift but I don't expect her to speak out on things because shes famous. I already know from school that getting informed on political matters is my responsibility not hers to tell me I should and such. Thanks for your pov!
ok that s history, as much as supporting some legit ssouth korean dictators in the past , consrequences still felt. To ne clear , north korea is way worse, but thats a low bar to clear.
Makes me think about all the “regular people” who should be standing for something but are so self-involved they can’t be fucked to vote bc it’ll never affect their very personal lives
And one last comment got to quote my man Uncle Ben one more time "with great power comes great responsibility" we are all beholden to one another that's the only way the world gets better ❤️
Thank you so much for making this video. I truly appreciate your talent with words, because i felt weird about the whole celebrity apathy and the debate it generates whether they have to speak or what they are expected to do, and you perfectly put it into words, I'm sending this video to my friends bc it's really well done and well explained
How is it you never miss? It's remarkable, really. Just found out about your channel at the end of 2023 but already came to love it so much. You are an insparation for me, as a latin american who wants to start making video essays about culture and politics. Please, never give up on this channel. We all will be watching as many videos are necessary to keep it afloat. Sending you love from Venezuela❤
thank you for making this video!!! one of the most significant powers any celebrity-billionaire can possess is the ability to cast distractions upon our already besieged attention spans. taylor swift, and the news cycle dedicated to her, can generate instant attention for her newest unreleased album and dominate people's feeds. imagine instead if attention was directed meaningfully towards the BDS movement, if she had told her fans and attendees at the Grammys to quit drinking starbucks, for example?? someone of her caliber has the capacity to mobilize MILLIONS for the freedom of Palestine. the least we can do as non-famous, non-elites is try to resist their ceaseless diversions ):
"...you can't say celebs are people too, but then not act like a fellow human being." You absolutely nailed it! Thank you for making this video. Palestine will be free
I just discovered your channel and the content you make is so incredibly well thought out and put together- it brings not only great information but a sense of hope
Tbh, I’m annoyed how much trust people place in celebrities for activist causes. They are influential, but people also vastly overestimate their power. Taylor Swift has previously endorsed political candidates who didn’t win, she’s not going to stop fighting in Gaza. It’s easier to be an activist for feminism and LGBT rights because they can relate to these personally. And the average American barely has a grip on domestic politics. Most of us can’t even find Palestine or Israel on a map. I don’t expect celebrities to do better than the average American. Ultimately, nobody owes you their activism. I’m not saying this to defend their inaction. I wish they would speak out. But I’m just being real and urging we spend less energy on this. Sure we can continue to pressure celebrities but it’s more important to pressure politicians and reach out to our friends and community, spheres we actually have influence over, than try to make heroes out of entertainers. Celebrities will not do the work for us.
we should be pressuring politicians but what's one way to build pressure on them? to build more support for and awareness about your cause so you can get people to mobilize. who can possibly help with that bc of their insanely large platforms, reach and influence? celebrities. you can argue till you're blue in the face about how yes most of the energy shouldn't be directed towards them (and it isn't by most activists!) but these criticisms are fair and valid and it's important to have a conversation about how those we keep giving so much power, money and influence show so little humanity at times and what it says about our culture as a whole and the need to transform it.
@@em-ri3ph The thing is, exactly those celebrities are products of this/our culture. In principle I don't want to contradict; on the other hand, every person - even a prominent multi-millionaire - has the right not to share their point of view with millions of others. And if you're honest... How much knowledge can such people have about such sensitive topics? With this in mind, I personally prefer it if they say nothing at all.
@@glitzerplastikchichi I don't really expect them to be knowledgeable but I do believe that even with the perceived 'complication' that's built around this topic, with the information we have about what's currently happening in Palestine *rn* it's hard to believe anyone could be a decent person and not to be in opposition to it. I personally believe when you're living in a time when something as horrific as this happening, you have a *moral* responsibility to do whatever is in your power to stand against it. I do wish we would collectively stop giving these people this much money and power though for their actions to even hold this much weight.
Thank you for using your platform this way! This is something have been thinking and obsessing over for months now, and It's a first time I find a well put together video about the topic.
Cheyenne, an excellent contextualization in the beginning of this video. Thank you for your research I think this video does a great job at taking back the narrative and explaining why apathic or apolitical attitude cant be what we expect from eachother let alone from celebs
most celebrities are also influencers their job is to INFLUENCE , cancel culture is all about cancelling people using their influence in a bad way , we all know not speaking out is still a choice and in this situation reaching out and informing people is a must and not doing it more than making you inhuman and freaking monster means you're not someone we should look out to.
Reminds me of the Wisecrack video _Celebrities Suck At Politics_ which explored both the glamour of being seen as an activist and the power that being a celebrity can bring to activist organizations. The top two comments, I think, are reflective of these ideas, and both were quotes. “All governments suffer a recurring problem: Power attracts pathological personalities. It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible.”- Frank Herbert (commenter archer1949) "I understand the absurdity of a rich rock star standing next to a vulnerable child. But being a celebrity is a currency that should be used to bring change.” - Bono (commenter shkee23) Being a celebrity brings a lot of sway with it, but it's better to be indirect with it, to show people to good causes they can help, rather than run them yourself. Unfortunately, this word is "influence" but the message still holds.
I stand for the Palestinian people but since I moved to a new country last summer I haven’t found people who do to. I’m agoraphobic so assisting a protest on my own is a lot of anxiety. I have been informing myself and informing those around me but I feel I’m the only one who cares. (I’m now in France, where there is a lot of Islamophobia or other issues I’m not aware but it’s not as easy when I lived before where I have friends who are more vocal. I can’t protest let alone wear a keffiyeh) Peace and love and free Palestine 🇵🇸 ✌️
beautifully put together, beautifully written and said. it’s free palestine and eat the rich, even when you parasocially love the rich in question. FREE PALESTINE, FREE CONGO, FREE SUDAN.
i cannot express how glad and thankful i am that you made this video ! first of all the fact that you were able to give context, summarize the genocide of palestinians by israel, highlighting important elements in just a few minutes is incredible : there are so many sources online, quick to read and understand for pretty much everyone but some people apparently are not able to do the bare minimum of educating themselves and sharing information. for the past four months i've seen so many of my favorite artists and content creators do : NOTHING. i've seen so many of my friends do nothing. i know i should put my energy else where (and i do so, by sharing information on social media despite my very small number of followers) but this makes me so angry and sad, i just can't understand how some people can literally just sit here and stay silent and not lift a finger while a genocide is happening (and so many other crisis and issues in the world). (kinda using this comment as a diary here sorry but i need to vent) tbh i've been very conflicted the past few months because on the one hand i want to radically change my media consumption and only listen to or watch people who do try to do something (the bare minimum at least) (i am definitely learning to not put my favorite artists on pedestal like i used to); and on the other hand i still kinda turn a blind on some artists who haven't spoken up because tbh it would disrupt my comfort as well (a part of me still waits for something or wants to believe they have a good "excuse" for not speaking up even though there's really no justification at this point). same for my friends, i've been thinking about reducing my circle to only keep friends who have showed interest in various national and international issues and cutting ties with the ones who have stayed silent all this time ; i'm honestly afraid of doing that once again because it would be a radical change for me and my comfort but at the same time my friends' silence has also been something that has angered me and made me upset so idk what to do. if anyone reading this has been through a similar situation, i would love to know your perspective on that ! anyways thank you again for this video and thank you, as someone who admires you and the content you make, for using your platform ! this is such a long comment for no reason sorry :/
@@iamfukked7064 thank you sooo much for recommending this channel ! i'm writing this after watching her 2 last videos (" a socialist lifestyle") and i really liked it, it's exactly the type of content i'm looking for these days !
@@annemxma hey!! it’s not my video or my comment section but i still wanna say you don’t have to apologise for the length of your comment 🫶🏻 your words really resonated with me and i am going through the same situation as you, meaning that i want to change my media consumption radically and stop supporting anyone who doesn’t share my morals or values especially about a subject that is so heartbreaking and awful: it’s a genocide not a trend or scandal, how crazy is that ?? but yea i’ve been struggling as well and sometimes choosing to ignore my moral compass and listen to music (taylor’s for instance) or watch content because just looking at our brain chemistry it’s not easy to cut off habits like these especially if we have emotional attachment to them or they remind us of fond memories, however, i can tell you that going out of your comfort zone will not kill you or change your life drastically, if you put all your heart into setting these boundaries you will find yourself naturally growing out or it ! i genuinely stopped liking taylor’s music and its been sounding like trash to me even though i used to looove her and only listen to her because it’s been established in my mind that she is not a person that i want to support and when i stopped altogether i felt so much better and i started listening to a whole other genre and local artists of my community, don’t worry about feeling bad, celebrities only have the power we give them over us and you can take it back anytime !! you might think its just a stream or whatever, but it’s all about core principles and values even though we may not be powerful enough to change the world we have a say over who we support and give our time and money to and it sure as hell shouldn’t be people who choose not to take sides and spread awareness about a genocide. and for your friends, i understand that its may be more touchy and complicated so i can’t give you solid advice (because i havent been put in this situation lmao i dont even have friends) but i understand that it may take a lot of courage to do it and it may have a more sensible impact on your life as opposed to just unfollowing an artist on social media, but one thing i can tell you is if you really care about the palestinian cause because you have good morals and you’re a good person, you’d be better off without people who don’t share your values, because if you’re not directly affected by the conflict it may not seem as morally dutiful but in my opinion, its a very divisive topic that shows you people’s true colors, if someone can turn a blind eye and justify the killing of innocent people daily then i am sure sooner or later they will hurt you or do you wrong because i firmly believe these people are not good people you want to surround yourself with !! that’s all i had to say, i hope you will be able to find your path peacefully but no matter be proud of yourself for standing on the right side of history and supporting the oppressed who are completely ignored by the world :) i’m always here if you need to talk
A counterpoint, in my mind, against that screenshot on Lady Gaga's subreddit/forum at 7:28, was that Lady GaGa and other famous people have strings or connections related to some political party. If their political views align with helping push a ceasefire in Gaza, they can do that! The most a non-famous person can do now is get word out and talk to politicians advocating for ceasefires! Famous or not, you can definitely put in the energy, time and money (what the average person could possibly afford, not accounting the wealthy) into calling a ceasefire and refuge for Palestinean/Gaza people. Even if posts on Instagram equate the same to the black photo image during the BLM movement, it certainly got the word out, and you knew who you aligned with.
I sometimes wonder if celebrities should be thought of as people we've voted for by making them popular, unlike politicians they're not selected to represent us in government but they still do represent us culturally and have a lot of clout.
While the idea of celebrities using their platform for advocacy is well-intentioned, it’s essential to consider the limitations and potential risks. The social contract between celebrities and society primarily revolves around their professional roles-be it in entertainment, sports, or arts. This contract doesn’t necessarily extend to political or social advocacy, especially on topics outside their expertise. One significant concern is the risk of misinformation. Celebrities, despite their influence, may not always have the depth of knowledge required to address complex issues accurately. Misinformed advocacy can lead to public misunderstanding and potentially harm the very causes they aim to support. It’s crucial to remember the value of expertise; informed discussions should ideally be led by those who have dedicated themselves to studying the relevant fields. Moreover, obligating celebrities to engage in advocacy infringes on their autonomy. Everyone should have the freedom to decide whether or not they want to engage in public discourse on societal issues. Genuine advocacy comes from a place of personal conviction and understanding, not from a perceived obligation due to one’s public status. In essence, while celebrities have the potential to influence, we must respect their decision to engage in advocacy as a personal choice, grounded in their areas of knowledge and interest. It’s about striking the right balance between leveraging influence and recognizing the importance of expertise and personal autonomy.
"a post won't change the world" even putting aside the influence they have... ok? neither will one vote or one donation - it's part of a *collective effort*
I really appreciate you letting us know which celebrities are taking which stances (or none at all)! Some of them really surprised me, like Mayim Bialik. I thought she had a good head on her shoulders, apparently not.
Yall dont boycott these Celebs on behalf of Congo, Sudan or even West Africa where child trafficking and forced labour is still very much a thing . Sure what is Happening to Palestine id EXTREMELY TERRIBLE.But so is what is happening to other parts of the world
Dan and Phil didn't just raise that much money, they raised it so fast that they had to pretty much throw out their tier system as originally planned and make up new ones on the spot. Dan ended up giving Phil an eyebrow slit
Honestly, I think any form of help is good even if it comes from vanity. As long as they do something right instead of looking away, I don't really care for the reasons behind it
Before even seeing the video I do think a post can change the “world” specifically I refer to the posts the former president of the US would pull of course it changed a lot of dynamics between the public . Influencers/celebrities have more power than they think they do . They don’t owe us anything of course but when everyone is watching you unfortunately you will have the pressure to always speak up that comes with that job I don’t agree with it but again I don’t make the rules of society.
literally presented your talking points to my friends while talking about politics and I had to drop a good amount of them for their stances on the genocide 😢
Your point about whether or not celebrities do acts of charity out of the goodness of their heart or because they just want to look good reminds me of an old Jewish joke. A wealthy man goes to a Rabbi for advice. "I want to build an orphanage where homeless children in need would have decent beds, good food and stable shelter but I wonder if the only reason I want that is to be praised for it. Am I selfish? Maybe I should hold off until I have a better understanding of myself." The Rabbi responds "If the orphans get all that they won't care about your selfishness. Build it."
great video!! the framing of fame as (ideally) a symbiotic social contract between celebrities and the audience/working class that provides them with the means of existing is so important. in my opinion things like this don't even have to be labelled as "being an activist" -- i think using the money and attention youve earned from your audience to protect and provide for people in life-threatening situations should be pretty par for the course. the fact that Palestinians and their history have been dehumanized and deemed "taboo" to the point where even basic acknowledgement of them is viewed as socially unacceptable and worthy of punishment. is a problem. this fear and subsequent silence being passed off as politeness is really just reinforcement/normalization of violence as the status quo. this should not be an acceptable status quo.
Of course it is admirable when an entertainer/artist speaks out on an important cause like Gaza/Palestine etc What I don't understand is why some people seem to prioritize activism in a entertainer/artist when that is not the core business of a entertainer/artist. Artists/entertainers have always existed to make art or entertain us .Sometimes that art had a political bent sometimes it didn't . But it was only just art or entertainment ,something mostly meant to distract us from the ills of the world. However for a politician ,creating change and making the world a better place should be their core business. Why isn't there the same push from citizenry for politicians in their country to state their position on issues they care about? Why vote for Joe Biden when he is using your tax dollars to fund this genocide in Gaza ? Why vote for Donald Trump when you know he is also very pro-Israel ? Celebrities /entertainers /artists are a fun distraction but that's all they are no matter how rich or loved but its not exactly a profession that requires you to be well -educated or informed
It is the core priority of a DECENT HUMAN. And a decent human with power will use that power for good because they can. And self expression it an artist's JOB.
my thing is, I feel like celebrities are quite in tuned with the world around as they maintain their image while knowing what to say and what not to say but what is confusing is if they are in tuned and they are seeing the same horrors as us, as a human who is seeing what other humans are going through, you dont want to say anything? Like nothing at all? I dont really expect much from celebrities cause it very disappointing but you dont want to say where you stand? I also wish celebrities group together and did something against an industry that seems so against celebrities speaking for themselves and their views, if that makes sense.
The fact that lawmakers proposed an anti-nonconsensual AI porn bill after Taylor spoke up against the AI pics of her, and people still have the nerve to say, celebs speaking about political issues has no use or impact is WILD! USE YOUR FOLLOWERS!
See also: the antitrust investigation into and hearings about Ticketmaster following the Eras Tour debacle
Especially after Xochitl Gomez, and underage actress, spoke out about deepfakes of herself as well as that teenage who committed suic*de because people spread deepfakes of her. But no- Taylor Swift is the priority here
I’ve never really heard that ? Do they say that a lot ? I’ve only heard how people don’t get why celebs don’t use their platforms because they can bring more awareness especially if their super popular like Taylor swift
I'm not entirely disagreeing. But I think it's worth remembering that there's a lot of steps in between proposing bills and making real change. We saw a lot of performative bills and actions in 2020 but, despite all the present gaslighting, police were never de-funded or even significantly reformed in almost any major city or country. When you focus on major changes celebrities do in fact have quite limited power. Firstly because, by dint of being celebrities 99.9% of them will not challenge the power structure in meaningful ways e.g. how many of them actually put their money where their mouth is and fund truly radical groups that are pressuring for things like de-fund the police. And secondly, because the power structure is just too good at making superficial changes to make people think they're listening when they aren't. When the bills celebrities push for do things like return the country to the old school antitrust laws for every major monopoly, or if they're actually creating major changes in labour relations or the structure of society, then I think you'll see real power. Me too is probably the only recent example I can think of where there was a real sea change in terms of where companies put their resources.
@@IshtarNike This comment completely ate, tysm for the insight! These are good points to remember!
I don't think taylor swift, a billionaire taking 13 minute jet rides, cares about Palestinian people
Also she doesn't even care about latine fans in her own concert (Ana Benevides literally died) it comes as no surprise
@@somethingunusual8456 that's not true at all. she postponed a show in brasil due to extreme heat and during one of her concerts she was the one telling the security to bring water to the fans, it was the stadium's organization that lacked.
@@werecookie I live in the damn city that it happened. Tickets for fun was atrociously criminal? For sure, they're scum, they had fcking metal floors installed knowing it would be 40°C heat and cut off mechanical air circulation for God's sake, but to tell me Taylor's team didn't know about the structure and the climate is just laughable. They have a say on every aspect of the Tour, but let's say they magically didn't know. DOZENS of people were already fainting during Sabrina's opening. The concert should have been cancelled right there at that point. There wasn't even enough medical aid to all the people fainting. No matter how many water bottles Taylor asked for the fans, it was not enough for everybody, also the water was hot. Ana was near the stage after all, and this fact didn't help her whatsoever!!! I strongly suggest you stop denying evidence. Taylor doesn't care, she actively denied it happening during the concert in her "letter" instagram post (which the authorities confirmed it DID happen during the show, after the second song of Taylor) just to avoid legal problems. There are actual WITNESSES but Taylor said it happened BEFORE the concert. Ana wasn't even from Rio, she and her friend paid almost 5k to get there. It was her dream to see Taylor live. Taylor didn't even help the family to pay for the body to be transported back to her hometoen, the brazilian fans did. No matter what PR stunt Taylor did the next week after that to save her neck, we will never forget, neither will Ana's parents and loved ones.
@@werecookie also we know she postponed the concert on the 18th because of the backlash. It was the day after Ana died. HUNDREDS, if not THOUSANDS of people were ALREADY inside the stage when the news about the postponing were dropped. It caused a lot of chaos afterwards. Inform yourself.
Duh, happily announcing your new album when I'm sure people have been begging her to speak out speaks volume. Oh and the album's name hmm what a hilariously, dark coincidence
With power comes apathy.
with great power comes great responsibility. These people should be held accountable
More like power lacks apathy 😢
And with billions comes psychopathy.
the thing is you can't justify silence anymore imo when it comes to the point when you actually realize how much influence these people have. you literally have millions of people who will hear what you have to say. celebrities don't have to be activists, but just posting a donation link isn't activism, it's just trying to help out.
Posting a donation link is a minor form of activism, and that's okay. I don't like this idea that being an activist is controversial, so celebrities need to be made comfortable with what's asked of them. Especially when they're mega rich and have a cult-like following.
Y'all are expecting celebrities to do the heavy work for you and spoon-feed you where to click, where to vote and for whom. Do you hear how ridiculous this is? C'mon celebrities are not bigger than the news and news networks. When anything major happens most people would've heard about it. That's one. Two. Y'all are grown adults. Go donate yourself, go write letter to congressman yourself. Everything you're asking from a celeb, you can do yourself. What you're basically expecting from them is for them to *organize* this for you. And what's holding back grown individuals who are particularly interested in this issue from looking up how they can support the side they picked??
Go reflect on what you just said, taking into point my message. People don't actually need these celebs for activism the way you think you do. In the end, only people interested will be involved. And those who want to be would do so without a celebrity intervention and speaking. Matter of fact - Americans biggest cities are so heavily dense unlike smaller countries - that you can go downtown and set up a stall and you'll draw up enough attention for your favourite cause. And the longer you spend there (days) the more visibility and people you'll reach. What's holding back highly interested in this topic individuals from doing it all themselves? Y'all act like you ain't got the power but these celebs do. Don't wait on celebrities go and do it yourself if you care that much. Stop using them as an excuse why _you_ aren't doing more
@LovelyLittleLillies The thing that's stopping interested individuals from engaging in all the forms of activism that suit them is time and finances. It's that simple. The vast majority of people need to work on order to even have a place to go back to after canvassing. Canvassing is extremely expensive in the long run, and it was done in the past and today through finals and large scale organization. Most donations don't tend to simply come from other workers in your immediate area. Being sponsored by a wealthy benefactor in a capitalist society goes a long way. It's also disingenuous to ignore that, in America, grassroots movements, especially ones that directly counter capitalist interests, tend to be directly sabotaged by the even more powerful interests they're protesting.
You're engaging in the dumbass "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" mentality that plagues the conservative, reactionary mentality of America as a whole. Celebrities have an exceptional amount of power. It isn't about convincing activists, it's about convincing their millions of followers, as well as utilizing their millions of dollars in capital to help support these grassroots movements. And claiming they neither have a responsibility or even power to do so is just showing how narrow your grasp of politics is. You know how pretty much every single celebrity you know does ads? That is one of the many, many things they're obligated to do to curate an image for themselves and the people that pay them. Making sure that people don't know a company engages in slavery or partially funds a dictator is an expensive campaign. Ads exist, in part, to present an appealing image to a wider audience in order to increase the passivity of the populace towards capitalist endeavors.
Just because you're ignorant about how connected every system under capitalism is doesn't mean people are just being lazy or stupid. You're just not informed. Celebrities are not just popular people.
@@muntu1221 you bought the lie, sold exclusively to you, that you have less power as an individual than you actually do - so you're mad at me.
I know very well the resources average people - especially someone from middle class - has to create movement and change. Because as a marginalized person I used many resources, be it financial or emotional or other, from small charities and spaces created by no one particularly big. They just put in the time to fund rase or seek out financial aid for sustenance wherever they can. And also buying groceries from East European markets and following the conflict in Eastern Europe, I'm well aware of who did what and helped how. Help for Ukrainians came first and foremost from their own people - if you look at refugees at the Mexican border, they were not taken in by some us organization but they managed to get into us by knowing someone (like a relative or friend) there. Then there was Poland - who gave the most help. And who's Poland, if not a neighbour and friend to UA. And at Eastern European local delis they set up donation boxes along with websites that organized donations and help in Ukraine. In the end, most of the help and financial aid came from Ukrainians living abroad and the other biggest help came from a neighboring country that gave temporary shelter. So while that country asked for help from everyone they could - as a westerner, you wouldn't know that North America did very little for Ukraine in aid other than the sanctions. Majority of aid came from fellow slavs.
So if Eastern Europeans can come together, then so can Arabs - which have been helping p a Les tine for a while now.
You just have a very western perspective on this conflict bc in us people think silly little social media posts do anything or comments from celebs are more useful than financial aid for people who are left without homes and food.. to organize financial aid for pal est inians doesn't require a celebrity intervention
It's a statistic that when it comes to charities, most charitable donations are done by the lower classes and not the wealthy. So again, you're misinformed. Most donations for poverty, ex, are done by nobodies. Go look at Value Village - do they have ads and celebrities campaigning? Only public celebrity campaigning is done for organizations that are known for cop most of the money for themselves. So again, you don't need a celeb.
I told you, didn't I - big metropolitan cities in US are so heavily dense that you can supplement a NYC times sq billboard ad by just setting up your own table downtown. Who needs to pay for ads when you got free access? My family used every resource imaginable and available when we were poor, that's how I know you don't need big names just to create organizations that facilitate help in your local community. Idk about where you live, but where I live even big name companies and banks donate annually locally for small local charitable things - you just gotta reach out and apply.
So like I've showed you, I'm much more versed on this matter than you because you clearly have never been involved in any function that was organized and funded nor charitable organizations nor used any financial aid in local communities, like price organizations. You're busy speaking of "I can't" instead of doing something. There's a famous quote out there that will tell you Mu sk (or was it Bez os?) got where he did, and created what he did because he didn't focus his energy on "you can't" and never took a no. People are creating all this fuss online over celebrities all for nothing. It just shows your mentality of waiting in on others and being dependant then to start up things yourself. Oh and I remember a little boy who got famous in 2000's for setting up access to water for Africans simply because he aspired to, and he successfully managed to raise fun in hundred thousands or millions. But none of what I said had anything to do with the bootstraps mentality - you're just regurgitating common famous themes.
Posting a donation link is like passing a flyer you received to someone else. "Here, you deal with it."
When you have .000000001 cent for every dollar they have and they ask for donations, it comes off very disingenuous.
I used to appreciate Taylor, Selena, Beyoncé, lady Gaga, Rihanna and more. But at the end of the day, they are not people like us, they are billionaires, they are not even humans anymore. It’s all about power.
exactly. I'm a swiftie but I'm really disappointed that Taylor won't speak up for an issue of this magnitude. guess all her activism is superficial...
What makes them not human anymore?
@@Rebamonica-c6f She has a record of speaking out only when it’s directly affecting her. She is the perfect example of a performative activist.
I'm afraid this might be true@@chrissis1944
Wdym? They’re still humans. Humans with different life experiences from most people, but humans nonetheless. I don’t think entertainers occupy the same power space or greed as politicians. But anyway, No sense in seeing people who disappoint you as non-human. We don’t need to completely write them off we Just need to appropriately temper our expectations.
As iconic RUclipsr Indie Nile said, "you know who doesn't destroy the land? People who are indigenous to it."
Lol false
I think that can be refuted in many cases.
Many a dictator were native to their land but destroyed it.
Same applies to a lot of the world's leading industrial powers.
Governments screw the people for personal gain and are quite corrupted.
Indigenous people also say this 😁
RUclips seems to have deleted my initial comment, but this is easily refutable by mere seconds of research.
There are multiple accounts of indigenous people destroying their own land, either via civil war, having an authoritarian regime take power, corrupt politicians or simple industrialization and population growth which is in general pretty harmful to the environment.
Not this...
Seeing these celebrities and normal everyday people alike completely disregard any of the multiple genocides taking place has only confirmed for me further the relationship between hyperindividuality, racism and capitalism. Thank you for using your platform, Palestine will be free.
Well said!
To me it just proved that Iam right about the disconnect people have toward other human lives and the lack of empathy in this country
I couldn't have said this any better myself. Humanity means engaging in it, not just creating sympathy for the self
Omg Bryony you’re literally here in Cheyenne’s comment section!
I subscribed to your channel sis
i remember thinking during the holocaust if they had the internet we could save them but now i have learned that communication does not work they can still pretend to be deaf
im so over celebrities.. we should all collectively just ignore them and remind them who they are
Same I’m also so over people who treat them like gods it’s soo annoying 😭
@@yayayayahaikyuu4261fr its getting old 😂😂
I’ll never understand why people are so fascinated with a stranger’s life. I could not care less.
@@yayayayahaikyuu4261
They do believe they are gods…and most of them are following an agenda, and do spells in their music and performance…
They do not care about the fans only if , you in love with them.
Humans were never meant to be put on position with that much of money if it leads them to think they are above us.
I am really glad to see this comment . At this point its just too necessary that we should have at least ‘a day’ where celebrities should be realized they are just humans like all of us . We should ignore them . We are the ones let em be celebrities in the first place , or is it ? Because they are generally ppl get ‘chosen’ by someone and served us as the talented great ppl . Many things are wrong in this world system, i am just glad too many ppl are getting aware that it wont help but it will harm all of us in the first place . Its basically even turns into ‘idolizing’ em and acting they are superior , which leads em all to do anything to be like em . Its so sick. They are all love Israel , but why ? Bcz they are the one got chosen by them and just keeps getting all money just for themselves but for also another reason. Even that lqbt stuff is reduced only to stop ppl breeding . Cuz to this idea , world have to be owned by jews . If i wrote these in 2021 ppl would be laughing at me , but here i am , seein ppl realized, i know who is guilty and they will be punished by us or the next generation so heavily. War is soon guys .
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
FREE CONGO 🇨🇩
FREE SUDAN 🇸🇩
FREE EVERYONE ✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾
I bet you don’t have the same when it comes to Iranians, yemenis, or the uyghurs in china, as a matter of fact im willing to bet money you’re actually against Ukrainians and don’t even know about Armenians
bro stfu i bet u don't even care abt them also the person literally says free everyone @@statisticallyspeaking2067
@@statisticallyspeaking2067 pls why do u always bring the ukrainians they literally heavily supported across the world especially the west
@@statisticallyspeaking2067what’s this whataboutism about?
@@bubblebubbly5551 lol tell me you don't care about any of these people without telling me you don't care for them
“If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.”
Their activism is only for their bank account.
Then left leaning people are oppressor
Or your disabled, traumatized, or not informed and can't participate.
With Taylor Swift, she would do something if it affects her.
Not even that, unfortunately. She handled Ana Benevides' death so poorly it's honestly upsetting no one talks about it anymore
That's a lot of normal people too though, especially if they're even in the middle class.
@@normandy2501
Millions of people rallying, protesting, getting arrested, contacting their representatives, confronting senators face to face, camp outside blinken and bidens house, showing up wherever those dirty politicians are....are done just purely for their own benefit?
Let's get things straight
Miss Taylor swift with her millions of dedicated fans?
Miss Taylor who can amassed mass hate in a snap towards people she said she doesn't like?
Miss Taylor who cause thousands to turn up to vote just cuz she said so?
Miss Taylor swift who biden and trump are fighting over to get in her good gracious?
Miss Taylor who was crying saying she wannabe on the right side of history and want to speak on politics more?
That person, can do what took millions of people marching and protesting from all around the world for the past 4 months, with just 1 post to influence people to at the very least search about this issue and have more people aware of things that actually matters that also actually can and will affect them.
She becomes the Times magazine person of the year in the middle of gen0cide backed by her own country is fking hilarious
@@somethingunusual8456 Ana's death was the reason I no longer listen to Taylor (nor do I care about her) and she had been my most listened to artist on Spotify since 2018.
@@michelcomenta vou falar em português, que eu acho, pelo seu username, que vc também fala kkkk enfim, até como brasileira mas sobretudo como ser humano eu aplaudo de pé sua decisão de não ser mais fã da Taylor apesar da história que tem com a música dela. Isso mostra muita maturidade e comprometimento com as lutas que valem realmente a pena. Não posso dizer que fiz o mesmo porque nunca fui fã da Taylor, mas até gostava de algumas músicas. Agora, quando elas aparecem no rádio, nas lojas, enfim (me sinto no panóptico rs) só sinto um gosto amargo na boca
Lov this for actually calling out rich celebrities. They don't need a free pass.
"One post won't change anything." Why don't we test that theory?
This theory has been proven many times. Many celebrities posted about BLM; yet there is still plenty of police brutality every year.
@@candylove49 We are not asking them to fix the world. Raising awareness is the start and BARE MINIMUM. Look at Beyonce she stood up for BLM, raises black voices, literally ENCOURAGED focused protesting for BLM and donates to HBCU's. Similar pathways can be taken to show support in Palestine....yet celebrities dont do it including Bey. Of course Beyonce cant single handedly solve police brutality but she can help raise awareness, donate money to the right sources and even skew people's opinion and share knowledgable information to a large amount of people at one time.
Also even if it doesn’t it will teach more people about it and even if it doesn’t do that you re at least not gonna look like a pro genocide blood hungry loser
they surely did not think that way when they brought war criminals hillary clinton biden obama to their concerts and showed their support for them in votes, they cannot claim now that they are ignorant about politics when they already got themselves involved with war criminals
EXACTLY
Great video!
I'll add that celebrity activism in North America often suffers the same problem as rich philanthropy: white savior syndrome. Instead of working with Palestinians to achieve the liberation of Palestine, they use their wealth and influence in a paternalistic way to push their own vision of what Palestine should be
I wish Sudan, the congo & other places got the coverage that palestine does😭 #ceasefire #freeusall
Aren't the Sudan and Congo conflicts civil wars? That are happening in countries that are notoriously unstable?
The whole conversation about Palestine and Israel is happening because a foreign power (Israel) is attacking Palestine and enacting a genocide on the people. That makes it an international conflict, and thus creates conversation around the world.
At the same time, Sudan and Congo have internal civil wars, that kind of makes it their problem to solve, right?
The point is, it's up to Sudan and Congo not to have a civil war.
@@nickklavdianos5136Actually Israel is retrieving territories that we're forcibly taken away by foreigners centuries ago. And the Middle East is notorious for being unstable itself so people should ignore the Palestine affair just like we should ignore the Congo and others, right?
@@BroJo676 wait wait wait..... Israel is retrieving territories? What territories? The same ones Israelis left from and didn't go back until after WWII? Those ones? It's not like they stayed there, is it? They left, they let the Arabians take full control, and after centuries passed, they went back, removed people from lands in which they were living for hundreds of years, because somehow, even after leaving, those lands still belonged to the Israelis? How does that make any sense?
Let me explain nationalism to you, because you clearly don't get it.
In nationalism, the borders of the state coincide with the borders of the nation. Meaning that wherever the population is in its majority of one nation, that land belongs to that nation.
So tell me again, how does that principal work with Israel and Palestine? Was the majority of people living there Israelis? No, they were Arabs. So, it is therefore rightfully Arabic land.
I understand but they are getting some great coverage on socials where it starts and of course we can do more. I think Palestine right now has gotten the most because it has happened for over 70 years at this point and they don't even have a country of their own at the moment and are being pushed out their own land by someone else. Their population has also decreased drastically. In a perfect world all three would be getting huge coverage but at the moment it's hard to get people and celebs to care about Palestine which is truly heartbreaking. We already having boycotts, posting, and outraging and its still happening.
@@user-fe8uq9zp2g Kurds don't have a country of their own either. Many peoples have historical countries without having one recognized by the United Nations.
Girl, I love your videos, you're probably my favourite youtuber in this area right now. I used to be a really big fan of Taylor Swift, when she came to brazil i travelled the country to watch her live, it was a very chaotic, we were going through a heat wave and a girl died while attending her concert. She said nothing about it, only a short cold note on a Instagram story, she didn't pay her any homage at the concert, didn't even say her name, and her family had to go to national tv begging for the fans to help transport her body back to where she was from, there's no proof Swift did anything but invite her family to another concert. Her fans worldwide seems to ignore this has happened, and makes me think if it was an american or even european fan it would have the same silence, silence from her, her team, the media, it just seems like our lives don't matter, the 3rd world lives are just not as important as americans. I used to think Taylor was a decent human being till that day, then i realized she probably doesn't care, when she talked about american elections was because maybe she thought it was safe enough for her to get envolved in this subject, would cause more good than harm or maybe because she cares about american politics, but what happens in the rest of the world? I don't think she gives a damn, and that was very sad to realize because I loved her and she said in her documentary that she wanted to take part in politics more often and she wanted to be in the right side of history. But she wants that only when it's convenient. That's all I had to say, great video. Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
hey! i am not from brazil nor have i ever been close to going to see her live, but i definitely agree with everything you said. when i learned about the story of the poor girl who died, i was absolutely disgusted by how she handled the situation : the videos of her singing « bigger than the whole sky » in homage or whatever were very unsettling for me to watch because people were singing along as if the whole situation was yet again about her, not about a poor girl who lost her life because of bad management AT HER CONCERT, i couldn’t understand how she managed to victimize herself when she was (even if its indirectly) responsible for the loss of a life cause after all it’s HER show !! i found that very disturbing and one life is already a big loss but no one cared so how would you expect these delusional and heartless people to feel bad about tens of thousands of innocent people getting killed ?? i too used to love her a lot but it’s all changed and even though we may not have enough power to voice our morals with significant impact because she’ll always have obsessive fans who only breathe for her music, we can still boycott and stop supporting her, so that if no matter what happens we can say that we stood on the right side!!
also i agree on what you said about her involvement in american politics, once again taylor swift only cares if SHE has benefits so..
❤ 🇵🇸
Well if Israel has a right to exist then the Palestinians have a right to resist South African apartheid style occupation.
Mandela legit targeted only structures and very careful was not targetting people.
Because he wanted them live together in peace, he as president held also his still pretty angry party back while dealing with rassists.
The big reason why the apartheit ended as rainbow nation, was that it had peace in mind to begin with by mandelas party and compromises, like while ther was violence still going on, he relentlessy negogiated and compromised for peace as president.
Its pretty obvious that hamas dont. That is no excuse for the idf actions that , also, but hamas clearly isnt having that intentions.
if it ther plo and fatah, ok that arent needlessy zealot, but hamas is. (which excuses no warcrimes ok)
And i know abbot was assasinated so, yeah thats bad, but ther are 2 other parties that arent there, and israel is guilty not using them to delitigitimize hamas unbloody, , but comparing hamas to mandela is just offensive.
Like the other 2 parties only do if actions that are specific not civilians and idf. If they do, hamas, are legitr terrorists, that stir up trouble.
Ok and mandela too did only attacks on trade and economy , not human lives, or did his best.
Haven’t watching the whole thing yet but want to thank you for being vocal about this! We need more RUclipsrs speaking up, and opening up discourse. Talking and spreading information is really so powerful.
I never thought that I'd live in a time where calling for the protection of children is so unpopular.
I would argue celebrities ARE NOT people. They are people who play a celebrity role. Taylor Swift is a person, but Taylor Swift the celebrity is a brand, an amalgamation of publicists, marketing companies, advisors, etc, etc. No matter what Taylor the person believes privately, Taylor the celebrity can only present as much as the amalgamation can agree on is good for the brand. Celebrities are more-than-people.
Less than tbh
@@reeds576as much as I’d like to agree with you, when it comes to power, they’re not regular people.
I want this video to have engagement, so this is my comment. Being an activist has costs--tangible costs. Some people are willing to pay, some aren't. There aren't easy answers, and I'm glad you engaged with some of the nuance.
I LOVE Taylor Swift, but her activism has always been very self centered.
If white feminism were a person, it would be Taylor Swift
@@FNFNFN99KKKcan you please explain more because I'm on the outside on this one? Outside of this genocide issue are there other examples?
@@FriendlyBatDoomin general whether it was during elections (2016 and backwards) Taylor Swift remained unequivocally silent and she does so in my regards when it comes to major issues arising in the US or elsewhere like during Black Lives Matter movement she was silent. She only speaks on issues to capitalize on them and make her look good. She showed a very LGBTQ+ front during her lover era but has remained incredibly silent since even tho there have been some pretty controversial bills passed regarding the LGBTQ community to further marginalize them
@@xoxsabrina Thank you for the clarification. I've always been told just how much she genuinely cared about issues and the people those issues affect. Guess those people were wrong.
I realized this about her when she released “You Need to Calm Down.” Everyone praised her like she did something revolutionary but it made me angry. That song is not going to help ANYONE, it’s just going to make the LGBT+ community look like an even bigger joke.
I agree that it's a moral obligation to stand in support of Palestine, but I simply don't see celebrities as moral models in any way. We should see them as the funny corporate toys they (more often than not) are. The fight is happening far away from social media accounts and movie studios. Power, i.e., the potential for change, rests in the hands of the workers and soldiers who are either blocking supplies to Israel or fighting to defend the Palestinian people.
I agree. We shouldn't be wasting our time worrying about what celebrities are doing.
@@iamfukked7064 exactly!
The thing is because people (who are often "not into politics") blindly follow everything these celebrities say they would have a huge impact to reach these people, but then they would risk their popularity so that won't happen. There is no Limit to rich peoples greed.
The problem is these funny corporate toys hold too much influence, it can shift the tide.
But pretty sure the most condemned are the one who propped themselves as activist and is currently popular like miss swifti and gomez
@@beep3121 most Americans support Palestine tho
In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends. - Martin Luther King, Jr.
Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence. - Leonardo da Vinci
I do feel that the kind of people who would do the right thing in these situations would mostly be excluded from these industries before they became big and influential. Like if you were someome trying to make it in the entertainment industry, and you were publicly supporting Palastine before, you wouldn't've made it up the ranks
Support them as an independent artist then.
Thank you for calling the celebrities out, it's so frustrating to see people with such power stay silence
always ALWAYS with the hits. i appreciate how succinct your writing is
Your take is so well nuanced, thank you. Even though I’ve always been pro-Palestinian, you’ve sharped my view🫶🏼😭 I love your content 🫂
i understand the frustration, and the fantasy of having big influential people sway the stance of politicians. when they did the Live Aid broadcast fundraiser in 1985, they raised a ton of money for the famine in ethiopia. if they can do it back then, why not now? but instead of raising money, urge people to write to their representatives. the answer is, it’s easier to raise money but how that money is managed is out of our control and almost futile. politics will always make people wary, because the established powers that be are firm with their stand. artists are human too and are beholden to their industry which sadly is pro-Israel and can’t fathom the idea that supporting Palestine doesn’t mean you’re antisemitic. the only thing we can do is do our part. but thank you for contributing to the discourse, cheyenne. always love listening to your takes.
I’ll expand it further. We’re ALL obligated to speak. If not, who will?!
If I saw a child get followed by a grown adult and get harassed, I’m not “obligated” to do anything. Should I? Yes. But if I convince myself it is none of my business, I won’t. That child might get hurt because I didn’t help them, but I didn’t have to, so it’s okay. Right? That’s a big percentage of the population’s mindset. Remember this moving forward. People are NOT moving around life with well intentioned actions. Many people don’t have a will to help others and will excuse themselves. Wow. ☹️
The matter of whether or not celebrities should speak out about these issues was never a debate in the past. Many of the artists that they look up to were holding benefit concerts for resistance groups, mobilising and joining protests.
I’m South African, many of our musicians during the apartheid era would release songs that were anti-apartheid and they were widely popular and used their gifts to spread the message of freedom. They drew more attention to the issue locally and internationally and were often jailed, exiled or had their music banned.
Cultural boycotts matter!
I do think a lot of these celebrities are probably being aggressively told by their PR to not even hint at their stance on the situation, regardless of how they actually feel. People like Selena Gomez and Dua Lipa that are signing the letter but otherwise remaining silent at the least give me that vibe -- that they care but are being told not to speak out publicly by some sort of manager or agent. I know I saw Dua Lipa get bad press about what her stance *might* be (based on nothing but her family being Muslim from what I could see) without even saying a word.
Selena Gomez does not care when fans asked her to speak up she ignored it and said she was taking a break off social media. She then proceeded to post about her new boyfriend when she was called out on it her response was so what
@@ccvv1119 To add Selena is kind of notorious for taking alot of breaks off of social media as well as being kind of messy
the thing that gets me is that we ask these people to be representatives of their community to the point of forcing them to come out, but then act like we don’t want the people representing us to ACTUALLY represent our views.
Yes, and then turn around and say they are privileged anyway, and “don’t represent the everyday person”.
this is not about representing the everday person. This is about raising your voice against genocide regardless of what people say about your intentions. Your argument is weak when we can clearly see that the celebrities speaking out against this have seen genuine support and appreciation for their efforts
I think I'm too far removed from celebrity/influencer culture to have any meaningful input. In the same way that ads on YT just make me never want to buy those products, celebrity endorsements of anything (be it products or causes) only serve to increase my skepticism of said thing.
I don't get my news from them and I don't believe they're better informed than me just because they have millions of dollars (in fact, much like you said, they're probably NOT as well informed as me due to the detached nature of their existence)
I think this argument is, for me at least, pointless. I already know who I'm voting for long before Taylor announces her endorsement and while I appreciate her help in making civic engagement "cooler".. I'm not convinced it's a net positive.
I agree with what you said completely. On one hand I understand why people want celebrities to take stands because fans would be pointed onto an issue. However, I think that in itself is a problem. Because how is it that people depend on celebrities to know what is going on in the world. People need to inform themselves regardless of what celebrities think or do. I don't know how to explain it but I don't put that expectation on celebrities because I inform myself on issues and make my stance on what info i got. I am a fan of taylor swift but I don't expect her to speak out on things because shes famous. I already know from school that getting informed on political matters is my responsibility not hers to tell me I should and such. Thanks for your pov!
And what should not be forgotten is that the state of Israel as well as Japan stuck by apartheid South Africa and Rhodesia to the very end.
Really? I didn’t know that.
ok that s history, as much as supporting some legit ssouth korean dictators in the past , consrequences still felt.
To ne clear , north korea is way worse, but thats a low bar to clear.
Makes me think about all the “regular people” who should be standing for something but are so self-involved they can’t be fucked to vote bc it’ll never affect their very personal lives
And one last comment got to quote my man Uncle Ben one more time "with great power comes great responsibility" we are all beholden to one another that's the only way the world gets better ❤️
Thank you so much for making this video. I truly appreciate your talent with words, because i felt weird about the whole celebrity apathy and the debate it generates whether they have to speak or what they are expected to do, and you perfectly put it into words, I'm sending this video to my friends bc it's really well done and well explained
I think Susan Sarandon is the only one vocal on Palestine but also actually showing up to protests, love her
I don't think they are Obliged to speak out, but if they dont they cant be surprised when people pick a side for them
How is it you never miss? It's remarkable, really. Just found out about your channel at the end of 2023 but already came to love it so much. You are an insparation for me, as a latin american who wants to start making video essays about culture and politics. Please, never give up on this channel. We all will be watching as many videos are necessary to keep it afloat. Sending you love from Venezuela❤
thank you for making this video!!! one of the most significant powers any celebrity-billionaire can possess is the ability to cast distractions upon our already besieged attention spans. taylor swift, and the news cycle dedicated to her, can generate instant attention for her newest unreleased album and dominate people's feeds. imagine instead if attention was directed meaningfully towards the BDS movement, if she had told her fans and attendees at the Grammys to quit drinking starbucks, for example?? someone of her caliber has the capacity to mobilize MILLIONS for the freedom of Palestine. the least we can do as non-famous, non-elites is try to resist their ceaseless diversions ):
"...you can't say celebs are people too, but then not act like a fellow human being." You absolutely nailed it! Thank you for making this video. Palestine will be free
A true reason is these celebrities don’t want to lose that bag
I just discovered your channel and the content you make is so incredibly well thought out and put together- it brings not only great information but a sense of hope
Celebrities are soo disconnected from this world
Tbh, I’m annoyed how much trust people place in celebrities for activist causes. They are influential, but people also vastly overestimate their power. Taylor Swift has previously endorsed political candidates who didn’t win, she’s not going to stop fighting in Gaza. It’s easier to be an activist for feminism and LGBT rights because they can relate to these personally. And the average American barely has a grip on domestic politics. Most of us can’t even find Palestine or Israel on a map. I don’t expect celebrities to do better than the average American. Ultimately, nobody owes you their activism. I’m not saying this to defend their inaction. I wish they would speak out. But I’m just being real and urging we spend less energy on this. Sure we can continue to pressure celebrities but it’s more important to pressure politicians and reach out to our friends and community, spheres we actually have influence over, than try to make heroes out of entertainers. Celebrities will not do the work for us.
way to miss the point
we should be pressuring politicians but what's one way to build pressure on them? to build more support for and awareness about your cause so you can get people to mobilize. who can possibly help with that bc of their insanely large platforms, reach and influence? celebrities. you can argue till you're blue in the face about how yes most of the energy shouldn't be directed towards them (and it isn't by most activists!) but these criticisms are fair and valid and it's important to have a conversation about how those we keep giving so much power, money and influence show so little humanity at times and what it says about our culture as a whole and the need to transform it.
@@em-ri3ph The thing is, exactly those celebrities are products of this/our culture. In principle I don't want to contradict; on the other hand, every person - even a prominent multi-millionaire - has the right not to share their point of view with millions of others. And if you're honest... How much knowledge can such people have about such sensitive topics? With this in mind, I personally prefer it if they say nothing at all.
@@glitzerplastikchichi I don't really expect them to be knowledgeable but I do believe that even with the perceived 'complication' that's built around this topic, with the information we have about what's currently happening in Palestine *rn* it's hard to believe anyone could be a decent person and not to be in opposition to it. I personally believe when you're living in a time when something as horrific as this happening, you have a *moral* responsibility to do whatever is in your power to stand against it. I do wish we would collectively stop giving these people this much money and power though for their actions to even hold this much weight.
very knowledgeable*
Thank you for using your platform this way! This is something have been thinking and obsessing over for months now, and It's a first time I find a well put together video about the topic.
Cheyenne, an excellent contextualization in the beginning of this video. Thank you for your research
I think this video does a great job at taking back the narrative and explaining why apathic or apolitical attitude cant be what we expect from eachother let alone from celebs
“With great power comes great responsibility”
-Uncle Ben
Thank you so so much for speaking up. I'm so glad that I've been watching you for years
Thank you for making this video. We must never stop talking about Gaza.
Never stop talking about Palestine until Palestine is free
most celebrities are also influencers their job is to INFLUENCE , cancel culture is all about cancelling people using their influence in a bad way , we all know not speaking out is still a choice and in this situation reaching out and informing people is a must and not doing it more than making you inhuman and freaking monster means you're not someone we should look out to.
Reminds me of the Wisecrack video _Celebrities Suck At Politics_ which explored both the glamour of being seen as an activist and the power that being a celebrity can bring to activist organizations. The top two comments, I think, are reflective of these ideas, and both were quotes.
“All governments suffer a recurring problem: Power attracts pathological personalities. It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible.”- Frank Herbert (commenter archer1949)
"I understand the absurdity of a rich rock star standing next to a vulnerable child. But being a celebrity is a currency that should be used to bring change.” - Bono (commenter shkee23)
Being a celebrity brings a lot of sway with it, but it's better to be indirect with it, to show people to good causes they can help, rather than run them yourself. Unfortunately, this word is "influence" but the message still holds.
Celebrities are usually there to perpetuaute the systems in place. By keeping the people mindlessly entertained and living vicariously through them.
Thank you for doing your part
DAN AND PHIL DID WHAT?! That is fcking amazing. Holy shit. Always loved them but my respect just increased dramatically.
"With great power comes great responsibility"
Great video, and it is something to look back on with pride ❤
I stand for the Palestinian people but since I moved to a new country last summer I haven’t found people who do to. I’m agoraphobic so assisting a protest on my own is a lot of anxiety. I have been informing myself and informing those around me but I feel I’m the only one who cares.
(I’m now in France, where there is a lot of Islamophobia or other issues I’m not aware but it’s not as easy when I lived before where I have friends who are more vocal. I can’t protest let alone wear a keffiyeh)
Peace and love and free Palestine 🇵🇸 ✌️
what does agoraphobic mean
beautifully put together, beautifully written and said. it’s free palestine and eat the rich, even when you parasocially love the rich in question.
FREE PALESTINE, FREE CONGO, FREE SUDAN.
i cannot express how glad and thankful i am that you made this video ! first of all the fact that you were able to give context, summarize the genocide of palestinians by israel, highlighting important elements in just a few minutes is incredible : there are so many sources online, quick to read and understand for pretty much everyone but some people apparently are not able to do the bare minimum of educating themselves and sharing information. for the past four months i've seen so many of my favorite artists and content creators do : NOTHING. i've seen so many of my friends do nothing. i know i should put my energy else where (and i do so, by sharing information on social media despite my very small number of followers) but this makes me so angry and sad, i just can't understand how some people can literally just sit here and stay silent and not lift a finger while a genocide is happening (and so many other crisis and issues in the world).
(kinda using this comment as a diary here sorry but i need to vent) tbh i've been very conflicted the past few months because on the one hand i want to radically change my media consumption and only listen to or watch people who do try to do something (the bare minimum at least) (i am definitely learning to not put my favorite artists on pedestal like i used to); and on the other hand i still kinda turn a blind on some artists who haven't spoken up because tbh it would disrupt my comfort as well (a part of me still waits for something or wants to believe they have a good "excuse" for not speaking up even though there's really no justification at this point). same for my friends, i've been thinking about reducing my circle to only keep friends who have showed interest in various national and international issues and cutting ties with the ones who have stayed silent all this time ; i'm honestly afraid of doing that once again because it would be a radical change for me and my comfort but at the same time my friends' silence has also been something that has angered me and made me upset so idk what to do. if anyone reading this has been through a similar situation, i would love to know your perspective on that !
anyways thank you again for this video and thank you, as someone who admires you and the content you make, for using your platform !
this is such a long comment for no reason sorry :/
Do you know fab socialism? I think her recent videos and lives may be of interest to you.
@@iamfukked7064 thank you sooo much for recommending this channel ! i'm writing this after watching her 2 last videos (" a socialist lifestyle") and i really liked it, it's exactly the type of content i'm looking for these days !
@@annemxma no problem, I'm so glad you like her videos!
@@annemxma hey!! it’s not my video or my comment section but i still wanna say you don’t have to apologise for the length of your comment 🫶🏻 your words really resonated with me and i am going through the same situation as you, meaning that i want to change my media consumption radically and stop supporting anyone who doesn’t share my morals or values especially about a subject that is so heartbreaking and awful: it’s a genocide not a trend or scandal, how crazy is that ?? but yea i’ve been struggling as well and sometimes choosing to ignore my moral compass and listen to music (taylor’s for instance) or watch content because just looking at our brain chemistry it’s not easy to cut off habits like these especially if we have emotional attachment to them or they remind us of fond memories, however, i can tell you that going out of your comfort zone will not kill you or change your life drastically, if you put all your heart into setting these boundaries you will find yourself naturally growing out or it ! i genuinely stopped liking taylor’s music and its been sounding like trash to me even though i used to looove her and only listen to her because it’s been established in my mind that she is not a person that i want to support and when i stopped altogether i felt so much better and i started listening to a whole other genre and local artists of my community, don’t worry about feeling bad, celebrities only have the power we give them over us and you can take it back anytime !! you might think its just a stream or whatever, but it’s all about core principles and values even though we may not be powerful enough to change the world we have a say over who we support and give our time and money to and it sure as hell shouldn’t be people who choose not to take sides and spread awareness about a genocide.
and for your friends, i understand that its may be more touchy and complicated so i can’t give you solid advice (because i havent been put in this situation lmao i dont even have friends) but i understand that it may take a lot of courage to do it and it may have a more sensible impact on your life as opposed to just unfollowing an artist on social media, but one thing i can tell you is if you really care about the palestinian cause because you have good morals and you’re a good person, you’d be better off without people who don’t share your values, because if you’re not directly affected by the conflict it may not seem as morally dutiful but in my opinion, its a very divisive topic that shows you people’s true colors, if someone can turn a blind eye and justify the killing of innocent people daily then i am sure sooner or later they will hurt you or do you wrong because i firmly believe these people are not good people you want to surround yourself with !!
that’s all i had to say, i hope you will be able to find your path peacefully but no matter be proud of yourself for standing on the right side of history and supporting the oppressed who are completely ignored by the world :) i’m always here if you need to talk
wonderful video thank you so much for speaking up
Thank you for useing your voice 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
i’m so glad you made a video on this subject
Thank you for making this video and spreading awareness. I hope we would live to witness a free Palestine.
Who controls the entertainment industry? That's why you don't see any action taken..even with universities
A counterpoint, in my mind, against that screenshot on Lady Gaga's subreddit/forum at 7:28, was that Lady GaGa and other famous people have strings or connections related to some political party. If their political views align with helping push a ceasefire in Gaza, they can do that! The most a non-famous person can do now is get word out and talk to politicians advocating for ceasefires! Famous or not, you can definitely put in the energy, time and money (what the average person could possibly afford, not accounting the wealthy) into calling a ceasefire and refuge for Palestinean/Gaza people. Even if posts on Instagram equate the same to the black photo image during the BLM movement, it certainly got the word out, and you knew who you aligned with.
I sometimes wonder if celebrities should be thought of as people we've voted for by making them popular, unlike politicians they're not selected to represent us in government but they still do represent us culturally and have a lot of clout.
I don’t see how dehumanizing celebrities would make us any better off. As if we don’t dehumanize them already by how we and the media talk of them.
So glad I found your channel
Thank you for this video cheyenne ❤
While the idea of celebrities using their platform for advocacy is well-intentioned, it’s essential to consider the limitations and potential risks. The social contract between celebrities and society primarily revolves around their professional roles-be it in entertainment, sports, or arts. This contract doesn’t necessarily extend to political or social advocacy, especially on topics outside their expertise.
One significant concern is the risk of misinformation. Celebrities, despite their influence, may not always have the depth of knowledge required to address complex issues accurately. Misinformed advocacy can lead to public misunderstanding and potentially harm the very causes they aim to support. It’s crucial to remember the value of expertise; informed discussions should ideally be led by those who have dedicated themselves to studying the relevant fields.
Moreover, obligating celebrities to engage in advocacy infringes on their autonomy. Everyone should have the freedom to decide whether or not they want to engage in public discourse on societal issues. Genuine advocacy comes from a place of personal conviction and understanding, not from a perceived obligation due to one’s public status.
In essence, while celebrities have the potential to influence, we must respect their decision to engage in advocacy as a personal choice, grounded in their areas of knowledge and interest. It’s about striking the right balance between leveraging influence and recognizing the importance of expertise and personal autonomy.
Finally, one actually thoughtful comment in this comment section.
Thank you for using your voice
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
"a post won't change the world" even putting aside the influence they have... ok? neither will one vote or one donation - it's part of a *collective effort*
I really appreciate you letting us know which celebrities are taking which stances (or none at all)! Some of them really surprised me, like Mayim Bialik. I thought she had a good head on her shoulders, apparently not.
Yall dont boycott these Celebs on behalf of Congo, Sudan or even West Africa where child trafficking and forced labour is still very much a thing . Sure what is Happening to Palestine id EXTREMELY TERRIBLE.But so is what is happening to other parts of the world
Dan and Phil didn't just raise that much money, they raised it so fast that they had to pretty much throw out their tier system as originally planned and make up new ones on the spot. Dan ended up giving Phil an eyebrow slit
Honestly, I think any form of help is good even if it comes from vanity. As long as they do something right instead of looking away, I don't really care for the reasons behind it
Extremely common Cheyenne W
Yes ❤ more people should speak about the cause
Before even seeing the video I do think a post can change the “world” specifically I refer to the posts the former president of the US would pull of course it changed a lot of dynamics between the public . Influencers/celebrities have more power than they think they do . They don’t owe us anything of course but when everyone is watching you unfortunately you will have the pressure to always speak up that comes with that job I don’t agree with it but again I don’t make the rules of society.
Thank you Cheyenne
this sums up my same feelings exactly, thanks for putting it into words
I'm not usually a big commenter, but adding a comment to help with the engagement
No one is free unless everyone is free. If we can stay silent in the face of genocide then when will we speak!
I've also heard some mission trips they literally just unbuild what they build so the next group can do it
I hate when celebrities pretend to care.
literally presented your talking points to my friends while talking about politics and I had to drop a good amount of them for their stances on the genocide 😢
Found ya channel recentlly, already loving the content sistah ❤
If you do not take too much, you do not have to "give back".
it's a shame how people only care about the deaths of their favorite celebrities as opposed to the actual real-world tragedies that are happening
Your point about whether or not celebrities do acts of charity out of the goodness of their heart or because they just want to look good reminds me of an old Jewish joke.
A wealthy man goes to a Rabbi for advice. "I want to build an orphanage where homeless children in need would have decent beds, good food and stable shelter but I wonder if the only reason I want that is to be praised for it. Am I selfish? Maybe I should hold off until I have a better understanding of myself." The Rabbi responds "If the orphans get all that they won't care about your selfishness. Build it."
great video!! the framing of fame as (ideally) a symbiotic social contract between celebrities and the audience/working class that provides them with the means of existing is so important.
in my opinion things like this don't even have to be labelled as "being an activist" -- i think using the money and attention youve earned from your audience to protect and provide for people in life-threatening situations should be pretty par for the course.
the fact that Palestinians and their history have been dehumanized and deemed "taboo" to the point where even basic acknowledgement of them is viewed as socially unacceptable and worthy of punishment. is a problem. this fear and subsequent silence being passed off as politeness is really just reinforcement/normalization of violence as the status quo. this should not be an acceptable status quo.
Some people have faced terrible retaliation in the past... so who knows. Maybe they've been "taught" 🤐
such an important video
Of course it is admirable when an entertainer/artist speaks out on an important cause like Gaza/Palestine etc What I don't understand is why some people seem to prioritize activism in a entertainer/artist when that is not the core business of a entertainer/artist. Artists/entertainers have always existed to make art or entertain us .Sometimes that art had a political bent sometimes it didn't . But it was only just art or entertainment ,something mostly meant to distract us from the ills of the world. However for a politician ,creating change and making the world a better place should be their core business. Why isn't there the same push from citizenry for politicians in their country to state their position on issues they care about? Why vote for Joe Biden when he is using your tax dollars to fund this genocide in Gaza ? Why vote for Donald Trump when you know he is also very pro-Israel ? Celebrities /entertainers /artists are a fun distraction but that's all they are no matter how rich or loved but its not exactly a profession that requires you to be well -educated or informed
It is the core priority of a DECENT HUMAN. And a decent human with power will use that power for good because they can. And self expression it an artist's JOB.
my thing is, I feel like celebrities are quite in tuned with the world around as they maintain their image while knowing what to say and what not to say but what is confusing is if they are in tuned and they are seeing the same horrors as us, as a human who is seeing what other humans are going through, you dont want to say anything? Like nothing at all? I dont really expect much from celebrities cause it very disappointing but you dont want to say where you stand? I also wish celebrities group together and did something against an industry that seems so against celebrities speaking for themselves and their views, if that makes sense.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 love you ♥️