Whether or not Joe actually saw god isn't really important. What's important is that he left the status quo life and had an experience that changed his worldview. It's like your friend who went away to college and came back a fervent idealist, or your friend who traveled abroad and came back speaking in worldly platitudes. Or your friend who went to Burning Man for the first time and came back having found some ambiguous spirituality. You may question the actual substance of the change in their personality, but regardless, the change has happened. Meanwhile, Gus never left the status quo. He sees his own lack of ambition as pragmatic, but in reality he is afraid of change. He works in a movie theater because he likes movies. He dates his friend's ex-girlfriend because she is familiar. He blames his girlfriend for his position in life because he is unwilling or unable to accept responsibility for his own choices. Joe's return brings to the surface Gus's bitterness about his own life, which is at least partially justified in my opinion. How can he compete with someone who has literally been to space, and whom everyone believes has seen god? In the end, no one is really in the right or the wrong. Joe may very well be full of shit and only using his experience to selfishly make himself appear deeper, but maybe he's telling the truth, and what happened to him may as well be real, because it affected him in a very real way. Gus may very well be a bitter, envious prick who tears people down to feel better about himself, but maybe he actually is the only one to see through all the bullshit and it drives him crazy. If you liked OMG, I highly recommend checking out the film/play "SubUrbia" by Eric Bogosian, which explores similar themes.
I feel like Kristen is the worst out of the three, being afraid of change is natural, changing as a person is natural. But Kristen clings on to something that isn’t there anymore, it seems like Joe is just being nice and doesn’t want to hurt her feeling. Kristen clings to Joe, even though he chose space over her. She likes the idea of dating Joe, instead of the actual Joe. I’m not good at analysis type things so yeah.
Or he wants to spread the word of God like the bible says to he could just want to know who was saved by it now im no super jesus freak and i dont go preaching on the side of the street but i do have my own beliefs so please dont hate me just cause im christian
+Noel Gonzales I didn't mean that at all. I just meant that the character was lying about seeing God, not that He's not real. Sorry if it came of differently :)
Wow, Denise is an amazing actor, cuz man I hated her character from beginning to end in this vid. She played the star struck believer well. Boiled my blood when she said "Don't be selfish" in response to someone saying they're in pain and when she was smiling when Joe was freaking out. Just really freaking creepy to me. Well done for sure. This was incredibly interesting. Very well done short. The ending had me pondering for a good long while. I agree with hallucination thing, especially considering the way it was done.But there is so many things one could guess about what really happened to Joe. That or he was lying, the biggest key being that he once lied about being surprised, but then when asked what God said, he said "How many views did this have?" Actually, I'm more and more thinking he's lying. Specially when saying "He wants us to love each other" which is about a blanket statement as you can say.
She didn’t really believe in what Joe was saying, she just wanted to devote herself to and believe in him and his love for her. She’s a classic fanatic.
This is actually one of the surprisingly deepest videos I've watched on YT. Surprising because right before this, I watched Starship, and while sure, you could say there's a moral in Starship, it's the ambiguity in this one that makes it good. The fact you have a love triangle where all three characters are relatable. The questions it leaves you with. Did he actually see God? Does God know where the library is? Is God a vicious two-faced prick? Maybe we're looking too deep into a short made by Starkid. Regardless, I like it! Terrific job!
Although everyone did a great job, I have to say that Denise just really stood out to me. In the absolute best way. Comparing this to her role as February in Starship has really made me take her more seriously as an actress. But really, great job to everyone involved. Proud of you guys!
The part about Joe telling Kristen that he was surprised but admitting to Gus that he was lying was a nice touch. Joe told Kristen what she wanted to hear while Gus told her the flat truth.
rockinrodney5000 No sorry maybe I worded it wrong. Gus didn't lie, Joe was the one who lied about being surprised. Gus told the truth at 0:36 and Joe lied at 3:57 and then admitted it at 6:21
this is really under-rated and it's got such a great, open-ended ending, because different people would assume things. People who believe in god would think that at the end Joe saw god in the sky. Others might think that Joe died at the end, but I really doubt that because he's standing and that's a dumb way to end it. Other others might think like Lupi- sorry, Gus' later opinion and think that he's pretending to see god to make Febru- dammit, I mean Kristen not doubt him. Other other others might think like Junio- FUCK I mean Gus' first opinion and think that he's hallucinating god in the sky, which is what I reckon happened. Or maybe some people just think this video is a good place to make starkid references in the comments. Which it is. Thanks for reading this far. Bye.
There's a difference between what you want to hear/ believe and what you hope to hear/believe. Kristen wants to believe Joe didn't abandon her. Gus hopes he isn't losing Kristen to his best friend(again). There is selfishness on all 3 characters parts. They are focused on their own desires. On a side note, Chris Allen looks a lot like his British actor counterpart Marc Warren...
Brian Holden. Wow. Incredible acting. He really brings the story, brings the emotion, oh my I really don't know how to say it. Gosh the feels 05:01-05:09
was I the only one who was like oh my god shut up you did not see god! I was so mad that everyone believed him Gus was the only sane character here! Great short film though! I adore Brian and joe so much!!
I was expecting to have some sort of explanation and then it just had the video of freaking out lol "How do you know it's God?" "He's BIG!" I was like "Are you kidding me?"
All I can say is, omg. What an incredibly deep meaning and a super cool short movie. Which is it; is he crazy? Did he see god? Is this about atheism vs. religion?
I feel so bad for Brian because every one just ganged up on him and the love of his life said he was being selfish when he wasn't, but this was totally awesome.
I think that people have many different reasons for believing or not believing in things, like God. Maybe Joe was feeling empty; maybe he felt like he went to space and that was the end, his dream was done, so he saw God, or "saw God", (who knows, right?) and that brought back some meaning. Whether or not he did see God, that was his truth. And maybe Joe's friends believed he saw God because they didn't give second thought to it, they had Joe back and they were willing to believe that anything was possible after seeing their friend go the distance. And maybe Gus doesn't believe in God because he prayed for Kris to love him, he prayed for Joe to come back and for everything to be normal like how it was, he prayed for a life that was exciting and worth living so he could say he did something worthwhile like Joe did; maybe when those prayers didn't come true, he gave up and became jaded. But all their reasons are reason enough.
I spent a good hour thinking about the ending and I think my mind is broken now. I feel like Joe was lying about seeing God when he was in space, but at the end he actually did see God. Who knows?
+Julia Flora I know that the ending will mean different things to different people but I see it as showing that he's mentally unstable. I think that being in space did break him and he went a little insane. When he "saw god" he had a break down from what was happening to him.
Yeah, that's how I've always interpreted it. That Joe's character is mental but it's like he is the lie that everyone wants to believe in. It was like it didn't matter what Gus said because everyone (Kristen) most of all, preferred Joe and sort of hero-worship him. But also, the irony was that Gus said Kristen would never know what it was like to love someone who doesn't love you back, but at the end it showed that Joe was never going to look at her the way she wanted. He's fixated on the sky.
after rewatching this after 10 years, i felt my perspective has changed drastically. i used to very much be on joe/kristen's "side" but now that i'm older, i feel gus' pain and understand his perspective, painfully, more. "don't be selfish, gus," punched me in the gut, leaving me genuinely feeling nauseas. a heart wrenching, yet enjoyable watch
What really gets me about this, is the fact that Joe's character just shut down the other person who said they saw God. Like, he saw God once and decided he was an authority on the matter. And what makes me scream is that everyone's fawning over him, and when people disagree they just shut them down and refuse to consider their point. Really good acting, but not at all what I expected after watching Starship .-.
“Hey, how many views does this have?” “God wants us to love each other.” “There’s always gonna be a naysayer” Ladies and gentlemen, the clearest and most dynamic representation of fanaticism. Also, how others are led into their paths. It isn’t God that Kristen believes in, it’s Joe.
this proves they are amazing actors and I'd love to see more serious things from them. I love the comedy don't get me wrong, but every now and again it's nice to see serious things that make you stop and think or feel.
chris allen I love how deep and thought provoking this short is. The story, acting, music, camera work is just perfect. I was expecting something funny to happen but it never did, but it really is refreshing to see Starkid being serious. I was reading the other comments and I just think it is so great how people are interpreting this in so many ways and are being mostly civil to each other. Anyway, best wishes for the future! PS I loved you in HMB, AVPSY and ANI! You sure are talented! PSS it's 5:30 am and I have The American Way song stuck in my head
Such an inspiring piece of film - the premise and script itself was incredible, but the cinematography really blew me away. That 'shaky' camera technique really enhances the absurd feeling of the film. The soundtrack fits perfectly too! I really hope we can see more work from Chris Allen soon.
All of these peoples are good actors. But I will admit my favorite is Joey Ritcher, and Brian Holden is up there too. His performance in this film is diffidently showing his skills in drama; where I had only seen him as comedic characters.
Ok I was NOT emotionally ready for the StarKids to act out really serious stuff, like Brian's bits legit tore my heart into shreds. We should all be glad they usually stick to comedy they're all really exelent actors and I don't think the world is ready for this level of emotion being portrayed
Elizabeth Rabinovich thank you so much for watching my short film! Feel free to check out my latest short, “Last Ride to Liberty High”, ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Chris, your short film is amaizing! We just spend a whole hour talking about this incredible deep meaning - my english teacher is blown away:) Thank you, Starkids♡
This is so strange to see Brian acting so... sad and everything. It breaks my heart. This is when you can tell he really is a great actor. That man's gonna be big.
Oh my God. This actually brought a tear to my eye. What even is this? I am legit questioning everything. What am I supposed to do now? God, Brian is SUCH a good actor.
I totally agree with you. He gave up everything for her and she doesn't respect that. She leaves him for Joe after not seeing him for five years. She's the selfish one. You just can't help but feel bad for him.
King Cranberry Joe’s great in this movie and I’m glad you liked it! Please check out my latest short film, “Last Ride to Liberty High” when you get the chance! ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Chris has always been in my top 5 favorite members of starkid but I didn’t know that he was also capable of creating such creative and thought provoking films like this.
P.Taylor wow! Thank you so much, you just made my day! If you haven’t checked it out already, you can watch my latest short film “Last Ride to Liberty High” here: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
internetbelle thanks a lot for watching my movie! Please check out my latest short “Last Ride to Liberty High”; ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
God damn, Chris Allen. This film is a winner. I've watched it three times now and I'm impressed by all the thoughts it provokes. That's what short films are supposed to be about. Thank you
How can anyone dislike this?! This is an amazing short film! The music, the camera work, the story, the actors, the emotion, it's all amazing! Thank you for making this short film Chris. Hope you make more in the future.
Anyone asking for "part 2" seem to misunderstand the beauty of a short film. We always want more, but in this case, the more can be found within the sweetness of the short lived abruptness of it all. This is lovely, and the music was stellar. I've watched it several times, and it's really helped me cope with some tough stuff lately. Chris Allen is a really wonderful writer. 3
barbaro267 "a deep conversation about change and belief" That right there is probably the reason why. Religious faith is an inherently uncomfortable topic to discuss because of the myriad different degrees of belief out there and this short is deliberately ambiguous about where it stands. It's almost like it was designed to make people feel somewhat uncomfortable.
Theres a lot of amazing acting in this, but for some reason, Brian Holden really stood out to me. I'm so used to seeing him play the goofy, lovable-loser guys, but he is really good at playing an average joe, jealous boyfrend-type. Also, this was filmed really beautifully. The soft light, the close-ups, and the slow motion walking and glances. And the music was perfect for it. I could've watched for another hour! Looking forward to seeing more short films from Chris Allen.
"it just hurts, you know? Its like, you're never gonna know what its like to love somebody, and have them not love you back." "don't be selfish Gus." that really has to be the saddest yet most beautiful thing i have ever heard
Every time I see this, it makes me cry. Beautiful acting, directing, camera work, music, story, everything. Gus and Kristen at the end is particularly beautiful. Thank you for this.
I've been reading the comments, and it seems a lot of people have been misinterpreting it. I think that at the end, he was "seeing god" again, but really I think he was just pretending he was. Joe wasn't supposed to be the good guy, and I don't think he died. At least that's what I got from this. It was really good. Great job!!!
People aren't really misinterpreting it, they're just interpreting it differently from you. It's like a book or a song, or any other work of art. It's open to interpretation, and even if everyone has a different interpretation, they're all correct, because that's what it means to that person.
WhatThe Blah. It doesn't really matter what the author was trying to say, because if a person is religious then they may think Joe's the good guy, and there is no evidence in the short that one or the other is bad.
okay all things aside.. being a starkid and a gleek, did anyone not notice that the space helmety thing Joe was wearing is the same one as what Kurt fr Glee was wearing in s6 when he sang that duet w Blaine..? something tells me Darren had a hand in this ;)
Also Joey richter guest starred in an episode. I think it was the one with the Adam’s apples. He’s only there for a moment but you can clearly see him if you pause.
Everybody is talking about how they feel bad for Gus/Brian's character so i guess my only question is am I the only one who thinks that he was being rude and even if Joes character was lying, why did he have to be the one to just ruin everybody's mood. This may just be cause I'm a christian but i enjoyed the possibility of religion side of this and while people "hated" Denise's character, i actually loved her character and yes i did feel bad for him because yes he did have a bad case of unrequited love but...i don't even know what I'm saying anymore i guess maybe I'm just another starstruck side character and I'm really late on this but I've wanted to say this since i first saw it but honestly i don't know maybe i took this the wrong way but i don't care because i took this the way that i wanted/needed to and i have wanted to say this since i first saw it but this is getting too long
I seriously am on Junio- WAIT NO SORRY Gus' side about this video. I personally think Volde-SORRY Joe went crazy and I don't think he saw God. I mean how would February and Draco believe that?
It really does. I came for the Starkids, but I stayed because it's actually incredibly beautiful. It's deep, the story itself is extremely complex, the acting is phenomenal.
Watching this was really an experience. I don't quite know how to feel about this. I mean obviously most people will side with Brolden's character, Gus. He appears to be the most rational minded and is very easy to sympathize with despite his bitterness and inability to assume responsibility for his life choices. I know I do. But at the same time I kind of wish Joe DID actually see God and that the world is truly full of miracles. I don't know, it's so hard to explain? I'm very glad I watched this and know that I'm going to keep thinking about it for a long long time.
Manasi Khade I really appreciate you watching my first short and taking the time to write a thoughtful comment. If you haven’t seen my latest short film “Last Ride to Liberty High” you can find it here: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
coming back to this every few months, it's just so surreal. the acting, writing, lighting and perspectives. everything was just... amazinggggg. oh, and the music! I'm overwhelmed haha. I wish I could be more profound than this
i saw this when i was younger and it didn't make any sense to me. i had sort of fever-dream-esque memories of it, i remember Joe's helmet reminded me of Little Big Planet and the surrealism of that game. i came back to it now, and the feeling is just amazing. i dont know if Joe really did see God, but i like to believe he saw something. maybe he hallucinated, or experienced something traumatic that his brain formed into a vision of God, but whatever happened up there, it clearly changed him. i think at the end, you see how hes not right. hes unstable, and hes never going to be able to let go of space and whats out there. there's nothing here on earth for him anymore, because he's seen too much to ever go back to being someone like Gus. or maybe, at the end, he really did see God. i guess we'll never know, and i guess it doesn't really matter.
ALDERDICE thanks a lot for sharing your thoughts on seeing my first short again. If you haven’t already, feel free to watch my latest short “Last Ride to Liberty High”: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Oh my god!!! I saw this a few years ago and didn’t finish it but it came back into my recommended after I’d found starkid and I totally freaked out because of joe in the thumbnail of a video I’d half seen but didn’t remember watching
I just saw a verry potter sequel, and I can't help myself but think Lupin and umbridge are best friend, but after the fisrt couple minutes I'm like woah man that's deep
If you enjoyed my first short film, please consider watching my latest, "Last Ride to Liberty High": ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Holy crap they are so good at serious acting. I didn't even realize.
i know im so used to them being absolute idiots i just
Are they? I think they are so much better in theatre
Everyone is all serious, and Lauren is just😂
the first thing i heard of when they said he'd gone to space was
"I CANT GO TO PIGFARTS ITS ON M A R S"
phanic ! at the 5sos twenty øne crybabies SAME
Pigfarts , Pigfarts here I come!
Pigfarts , Pigfarts yum yum yum!
I like how everything is so serious and then there's Lauren.
Leighcifer lmao that should be her motto “everything in a moment could be so serious. And then there’s me”
Wow, Brian really was VERY good in this. Just... wow. So good. He's such a good actor.
He probably just saw rumbleroar...
Or maybe the wizard god
I love Joe
No it’s the duck
HAHHAHAHAH
I love that his "hightech" helmet is a bucket
I'm 75% sure it's the ice-man helmet from holy musical b@man
@@QualitativeVacuum it is exactly the helmet
Whether or not Joe actually saw god isn't really important. What's important is that he left the status quo life and had an experience that changed his worldview. It's like your friend who went away to college and came back a fervent idealist, or your friend who traveled abroad and came back speaking in worldly platitudes. Or your friend who went to Burning Man for the first time and came back having found some ambiguous spirituality. You may question the actual substance of the change in their personality, but regardless, the change has happened.
Meanwhile, Gus never left the status quo. He sees his own lack of ambition as pragmatic, but in reality he is afraid of change. He works in a movie theater because he likes movies. He dates his friend's ex-girlfriend because she is familiar. He blames his girlfriend for his position in life because he is unwilling or unable to accept responsibility for his own choices.
Joe's return brings to the surface Gus's bitterness about his own life, which is at least partially justified in my opinion. How can he compete with someone who has literally been to space, and whom everyone believes has seen god? In the end, no one is really in the right or the wrong. Joe may very well be full of shit and only using his experience to selfishly make himself appear deeper, but maybe he's telling the truth, and what happened to him may as well be real, because it affected him in a very real way. Gus may very well be a bitter, envious prick who tears people down to feel better about himself, but maybe he actually is the only one to see through all the bullshit and it drives him crazy.
If you liked OMG, I highly recommend checking out the film/play "SubUrbia" by Eric Bogosian, which explores similar themes.
I feel like Kristen is the worst out of the three, being afraid of change is natural, changing as a person is natural. But Kristen clings on to something that isn’t there anymore, it seems like Joe is just being nice and doesn’t want to hurt her feeling. Kristen clings to Joe, even though he chose space over her. She likes the idea of dating Joe, instead of the actual Joe.
I’m not good at analysis type things so yeah.
I think Joe had a traumatic experience and this is his way of coping. His brain, in the mist of chaos, calmed him by creating an image of God
so i definitely did think this was just going to be a bunch of starship jokes
4:05 Holy...wow, okay, I cannot handle Joe's deep, soulful eyes. I normally just see him, you know, playing silly roles. I think I'm BLUSHING.
ME
ThePeasles I love him so much
He is actual perfection I can't
I just replayed it six times.....
He is a beautiful snowflake. I am proud to be in love with him. Why do these people get to work with him when I can’t? 😥
Junior's still smoking, I see...
*YeAh I'm SmOkInG pOt*
Just the fact that he asked "How many views did this get?" proves he was lying.
OMG i love your profile pic about the book
Thank you so much!
Or he wants to spread the word of God like the bible says to he could just want to know who was saved by it now im no super jesus freak and i dont go preaching on the side of the street but i do have my own beliefs so please dont hate me just cause im christian
+Noel Gonzales I didn't mean that at all. I just meant that the character was lying about seeing God, not that He's not real. Sorry if it came of differently :)
+Stella O. Oh okay sorry for overreacting
Wow, Denise is an amazing actor, cuz man I hated her character from beginning to end in this vid. She played the star struck believer well. Boiled my blood when she said "Don't be selfish" in response to someone saying they're in pain and when she was smiling when Joe was freaking out. Just really freaking creepy to me. Well done for sure.
This was incredibly interesting. Very well done short. The ending had me pondering for a good long while. I agree with hallucination thing, especially considering the way it was done.But there is so many things one could guess about what really happened to Joe. That or he was lying, the biggest key being that he once lied about being surprised, but then when asked what God said, he said "How many views did this have?"
Actually, I'm more and more thinking he's lying. Specially when saying "He wants us to love each other" which is about a blanket statement as you can say.
OMG yes! I have so many questions and this got really deep. Like Mariana Trench deep
She didn’t really believe in what Joe was saying, she just wanted to devote herself to and believe in him and his love for her. She’s a classic fanatic.
Oh come on everyone knows God is dead. Duck will replace him.
Shannon Ravenclaw chorn: oh... there is no god.
joe: 😶😧
He was a vicious two-faced prick anyway.
Sam and dean still haven't killed him we have to wait until October
@@geicolizard5577 i know I just had to make a reference
slippery when wet chopped him into little tiny pieces and fed him to her starving children
OMG those starkids are seriously good actors
"Oh my god, that's fucking beautiful"
Lauren Lopez is one of my favourite people
This is actually one of the surprisingly deepest videos I've watched on YT. Surprising because right before this, I watched Starship, and while sure, you could say there's a moral in Starship, it's the ambiguity in this one that makes it good. The fact you have a love triangle where all three characters are relatable. The questions it leaves you with. Did he actually see God? Does God know where the library is? Is God a vicious two-faced prick? Maybe we're looking too deep into a short made by Starkid. Regardless, I like it! Terrific job!
he totally went to pigfarts and met rumbleroar!
adream ofpointlessdreams yesssssss
YES. and rode on rumbleroar's back
And Professor McGonagills
plot twist rumbleroar was god
Although everyone did a great job, I have to say that Denise just really stood out to me. In the absolute best way. Comparing this to her role as February in Starship has really made me take her more seriously as an actress. But really, great job to everyone involved. Proud of you guys!
The part about Joe telling Kristen that he was surprised but admitting to Gus that he was lying was a nice touch. Joe told Kristen what she wanted to hear while Gus told her the flat truth.
Can you give me the time stamps to when Gus admitted he was lying? o.o
EDIT: I meant Joe!
rockinrodney5000 No sorry maybe I worded it wrong. Gus didn't lie, Joe was the one who lied about being surprised. Gus told the truth at 0:36 and Joe lied at 3:57 and then admitted it at 6:21
this is really under-rated and it's got such a great, open-ended ending, because different people would assume things. People who believe in god would think that at the end Joe saw god in the sky. Others might think that Joe died at the end, but I really doubt that because he's standing and that's a dumb way to end it. Other others might think like Lupi- sorry, Gus' later opinion and think that he's pretending to see god to make Febru- dammit, I mean Kristen not doubt him. Other other others might think like Junio- FUCK I mean Gus' first opinion and think that he's hallucinating god in the sky, which is what I reckon happened.
Or maybe some people just think this video is a good place to make starkid references in the comments. Which it is. Thanks for reading this far. Bye.
I agree. It makes sense that Bat- damn it, Volde- shit, Commander U- FUCK, sorry, I mean JOE is hallucinating God in the sky.
TheWolfyGrace So Dick, oops Joe thinks he saw God but was hallucinating, totally awesome.
Yes, that is correct, and Redvines made it awesome.
Haha, just kidding, they don't like Redvines...
TheWolfyGrace It's left open for you to interpret
aeris44
Yes, it is.
But I was agreeing with the OP :)
I just imagine Umbridge, Voldy, batman, Tiger f**ker all in one going to space and can't stop laughing.
and ducker
And this ladies and gentleman is what's it's like to be the only atheist in the room
Katrina Turner agreed
Yea
Truth.
Love ur name
Lol
He saw a starship ranger.
He saw Commander Up, dead God dammit! And he couldn't have seen God anyways because imperical science killed God (according to Tootsie anyway) xD
Or Rumbleroar...
It's just like, Brian sad while watching Denise and Joe, and then, PURPLE BALLOON!
There's a difference between what you want to hear/ believe and what you hope to hear/believe. Kristen wants to believe Joe didn't abandon her. Gus hopes he isn't losing Kristen to his best friend(again). There is selfishness on all 3 characters parts. They are focused on their own desires. On a side note, Chris Allen looks a lot like his British actor counterpart Marc Warren...
Brian Holden. Wow. Incredible acting. He really brings the story, brings the emotion, oh my I really don't know how to say it. Gosh the feels 05:01-05:09
Lupin can't sing, but he definitely can act
was I the only one who was like oh my god shut up you did not see god! I was so mad that everyone believed him Gus was the only sane character here! Great short film though! I adore Brian and joe so much!!
ikr lol
+phanic ! at the 5sos twenty øne crybabies I've seen you comment on so many videos
kayla dennis we know Joe didn't see god because we know that science killed god
I was expecting to have some sort of explanation and then it just had the video of freaking out lol "How do you know it's God?" "He's BIG!" I was like "Are you kidding me?"
Nicole Cranham it’s weird. The ending is amazing cause it can go two ways
I love the balance of the blatant and the ambiguous in this. It's mesmerising.
+Equihan Me too
LAUREN KEPT MAKING ME LAUGH!
laurens face during the vid
I love her hat too
+Cara Spann Just Lauren in general
the whole time she’s just 😦
All I can say is, omg. What an incredibly deep meaning and a super cool short movie. Which is it; is he crazy? Did he see god? Is this about atheism vs. religion?
I feel so bad for Brian because every one just ganged up on him and the love of his life said he was being selfish when he wasn't, but this was totally awesome.
I think that people have many different reasons for believing or not believing in things, like God. Maybe Joe was feeling empty; maybe he felt like he went to space and that was the end, his dream was done, so he saw God, or "saw God", (who knows, right?) and that brought back some meaning. Whether or not he did see God, that was his truth. And maybe Joe's friends believed he saw God because they didn't give second thought to it, they had Joe back and they were willing to believe that anything was possible after seeing their friend go the distance. And maybe Gus doesn't believe in God because he prayed for Kris to love him, he prayed for Joe to come back and for everything to be normal like how it was, he prayed for a life that was exciting and worth living so he could say he did something worthwhile like Joe did; maybe when those prayers didn't come true, he gave up and became jaded. But all their reasons are reason enough.
I don't know if this is low key making fun of christians, atheists, both or neither
Yes
I spent a good hour thinking about the ending and I think my mind is broken now. I feel like Joe was lying about seeing God when he was in space, but at the end he actually did see God. Who knows?
+Julia Flora I know that the ending will mean different things to different people but I see it as showing that he's mentally unstable. I think that being in space did break him and he went a little insane. When he "saw god" he had a break down from what was happening to him.
Yeah, that's how I've always interpreted it. That Joe's character is mental but it's like he is the lie that everyone wants to believe in. It was like it didn't matter what Gus said because everyone (Kristen) most of all, preferred Joe and sort of hero-worship him. But also, the irony was that Gus said Kristen would never know what it was like to love someone who doesn't love you back, but at the end it showed that Joe was never going to look at her the way she wanted. He's fixated on the sky.
"ow its cold" DYING XD but really its such a great short film!
“It’s the worst smell I’ve ever heard” has the same energy as it lol
after rewatching this after 10 years, i felt my perspective has changed drastically. i used to very much be on joe/kristen's "side" but now that i'm older, i feel gus' pain and understand his perspective, painfully, more. "don't be selfish, gus," punched me in the gut, leaving me genuinely feeling nauseas. a heart wrenching, yet enjoyable watch
What really gets me about this, is the fact that Joe's character just shut down the other person who said they saw God. Like, he saw God once and decided he was an authority on the matter. And what makes me scream is that everyone's fawning over him, and when people disagree they just shut them down and refuse to consider their point. Really good acting, but not at all what I expected after watching Starship .-.
I didn't realise how pretty Denise Donovan is and what a great actress she is. You should do more of these kind of videos, I want to see more!!
she always ends up with the “dumb blonde” characters but in my opinion this is a really good role for her
“Hey, how many views does this have?” “God wants us to love each other.” “There’s always gonna be a naysayer”
Ladies and gentlemen, the clearest and most dynamic representation of fanaticism. Also, how others are led into their paths. It isn’t God that Kristen believes in, it’s Joe.
Thanks for watching my first short film! Be sure to check out my latest, "Last Ride to Liberty High": ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Dylan saying *ow it’s cold* is such a mood
this proves they are amazing actors and I'd love to see more serious things from them. I love the comedy don't get me wrong, but every now and again it's nice to see serious things that make you stop and think or feel.
Kaylee Witmer thanks for the kind words. Glad u enjoyed it
chris allen I love how deep and thought provoking this short is. The story, acting, music, camera work is just perfect. I was expecting something funny to happen but it never did, but it really is refreshing to see Starkid being serious. I was reading the other comments and I just think it is so great how people are interpreting this in so many ways and are being mostly civil to each other. Anyway, best wishes for the future!
PS I loved you in HMB, AVPSY and ANI! You sure are talented!
PSS it's 5:30 am and I have The American Way song stuck in my head
poor Gus :( Brian is such a good actor
Such an inspiring piece of film - the premise and script itself was incredible, but the cinematography really blew me away. That 'shaky' camera technique really enhances the absurd feeling of the film. The soundtrack fits perfectly too! I really hope we can see more work from Chris Allen soon.
All of these peoples are good actors. But I will admit my favorite is Joey Ritcher, and Brian Holden is up there too. His performance in this film is diffidently showing his skills in drama; where I had only seen him as comedic characters.
JOEY fans up in here
+BrandiNichole Kelly Joey Richter wasn't in this Joe WALKER was.
I know. I was saying in that group, those had been my favorite actors. And that Brian is a fantastic one as well, especially in this video.
+BrandiNichole Kelly Okay, I know what you mean
“Ow it’s cold” Dylan Saunders everybody
I can't look at joe without thinking he's umbridge/voldy. I just can't hold it and burst out laughing 😂c
Sarah Cole same I was like voldy went to space
OMG, IKR!
Ok I was NOT emotionally ready for the StarKids to act out really serious stuff, like Brian's bits legit tore my heart into shreds. We should all be glad they usually stick to comedy they're all really exelent actors and I don't think the world is ready for this level of emotion being portrayed
Elizabeth Rabinovich thank you so much for watching my short film! Feel free to check out my latest short, “Last Ride to Liberty High”, ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Chris, your short film is amaizing!
We just spend a whole hour talking about this incredible deep meaning - my english teacher is blown away:)
Thank you, Starkids♡
You can't talk about religion in school. Get reported kid
Swagii Boii What do you mean " I can't talk about Religion in school."
?? Of course we can, we're free to say whatever we want:)
Swagii Boii They are allowed to talk about religion in schools, teachers just aren't permitted to teach or promote a specific religion.
@@swagiiboii2197 don't question Humanity themselves!
I'm just gonna point out that I tweeted chris Allen and he said that the ending was self explanatory
Did he say Barf? and way to use the Mr. Freeze's goggles and helmet from Holy Musical B@tMan
“Ow it’s cold”
Ah yes cold the number one cause of pain
This is so strange to see Brian acting so... sad and everything. It breaks my heart. This is when you can tell he really is a great actor. That man's gonna be big.
Oh my God. This actually brought a tear to my eye. What even is this? I am legit questioning everything. What am I supposed to do now? God, Brian is SUCH a good actor.
I totally agree with you. He gave up everything for her and she doesn't respect that. She leaves him for Joe after not seeing him for five years. She's the selfish one. You just can't help but feel bad for him.
'I don't know, it's not like he said 'hi Joe, I''m god, where's the library' I just died omg 😂💗💗
CAN I MARRY BRIAN RIGHT NOW!?
Abby Meyers sorry Meredith beat you to it
Lauren Lopez is just priceless this whole film.
The way the camera moves, just a little, made me feel so many more emotions. I love this, and I love all these actors. Joe did so well.
King Cranberry Joe’s great in this movie and I’m glad you liked it! Please check out my latest short film, “Last Ride to Liberty High” when you get the chance! ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
Chris has always been in my top 5 favorite members of starkid but I didn’t know that he was also capable of creating such creative and thought provoking films like this.
P.Taylor wow! Thank you so much, you just made my day! If you haven’t checked it out already, you can watch my latest short film “Last Ride to Liberty High” here: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
And Lauren looked so cute in her space hat
Lauren in the space helmet holding the whiskey is a mood
When you realize the goggles and helmet joe wears in the space scene is LITERALLY ICE MAN'S COSTUME FROM HOLY MUSICAL B@TMAN
THATS ALL I COULD THINK ABOUT
adore the starkids doing serious stuff like this. wish there were more.
internetbelle thanks a lot for watching my movie! Please check out my latest short “Last Ride to Liberty High”; ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
God damn, Chris Allen. This film is a winner. I've watched it three times now and I'm impressed by all the thoughts it provokes. That's what short films are supposed to be about. Thank you
How can anyone dislike this?! This is an amazing short film! The music, the camera work, the story, the actors, the emotion, it's all amazing! Thank you for making this short film Chris. Hope you make more in the future.
Chris, you're unbelievably talented. :) And, of course, you picked a killer cast.
It's so cool seeing StarKid members in a medium other than theatre! Weirdly refreshing somehow.
Lauren is literally my life
Anyone asking for "part 2" seem to misunderstand the beauty of a short film. We always want more, but in this case, the more can be found within the sweetness of the short lived abruptness of it all.
This is lovely, and the music was stellar. I've watched it several times, and it's really helped me cope with some tough stuff lately. Chris Allen is a really wonderful writer. 3
This would honestly be such a good movie, as in a full movie not just short.
Oh Lauren you were the highlight of this whole thing. LOL
I don't know why but I feel very uncomfortable watching this for whatever reason
Olivia Berger same
Why? It has fantastic acting and a deep conversation about change and belief.
barbaro267 "a deep conversation about change and belief" That right there is probably the reason why. Religious faith is an inherently uncomfortable topic to discuss because of the myriad different degrees of belief out there and this short is deliberately ambiguous about where it stands. It's almost like it was designed to make people feel somewhat uncomfortable.
Same but like it’s really good
Me too-
Theres a lot of amazing acting in this, but for some reason, Brian Holden really stood out to me. I'm so used to seeing him play the goofy, lovable-loser guys, but he is really good at playing an average joe, jealous boyfrend-type. Also, this was filmed really beautifully. The soft light, the close-ups, and the slow motion walking and glances. And the music was perfect for it. I could've watched for another hour! Looking forward to seeing more short films from Chris Allen.
Wow, this was amazing. I was so captivated, Chris, well done!
"it just hurts, you know? Its like, you're never gonna know what its like to love somebody, and have them not love you back."
"don't be selfish Gus."
that really has to be the saddest yet most beautiful thing i have ever heard
My heart!! *clutches chest dramatically*
Every time I see this, it makes me cry. Beautiful acting, directing, camera work, music, story, everything. Gus and Kristen at the end is particularly beautiful. Thank you for this.
I've been reading the comments, and it seems a lot of people have been misinterpreting it. I think that at the end, he was "seeing god" again, but really I think he was just pretending he was. Joe wasn't supposed to be the good guy, and I don't think he died. At least that's what I got from this. It was really good. Great job!!!
People aren't really misinterpreting it, they're just interpreting it differently from you. It's like a book or a song, or any other work of art. It's open to interpretation, and even if everyone has a different interpretation, they're all correct, because that's what it means to that person.
But people seem to have been seeing Joe as the good guy, which doesn't seem to be what the writer was trying to say.
WhatThe Blah. It doesn't really matter what the author was trying to say, because if a person is religious then they may think Joe's the good guy, and there is no evidence in the short that one or the other is bad.
Okay but can we talk about the whole scene with the mirror!!! It was fantastic! All of those shots! Beautiful.
I just realised how much i love Brian Holden...his acting is amazing, especially at the end i was like "wow, thats fucking beautiful!"
Haha, I must say, Lauren gets some of the best lines in everything! xD LOL
okay all things aside.. being a starkid and a gleek, did anyone not notice that the space helmety thing Joe was wearing is the same one as what Kurt fr Glee was wearing in s6 when he sang that duet w Blaine..? something tells me Darren had a hand in this ;)
Also Joey richter guest starred in an episode. I think it was the one with the Adam’s apples. He’s only there for a moment but you can clearly see him if you pause.
This is amazing! They have to do a long film! Joe is so supermegafoxyawesomehot! *.*
Everybody is talking about how they feel bad for Gus/Brian's character so i guess my only question is am I the only one who thinks that he was being rude and even if Joes character was lying, why did he have to be the one to just ruin everybody's mood. This may just be cause I'm a christian but i enjoyed the possibility of religion side of this and while people "hated" Denise's character, i actually loved her character and yes i did feel bad for him because yes he did have a bad case of unrequited love but...i don't even know what I'm saying anymore i guess maybe I'm just another starstruck side character and I'm really late on this but I've wanted to say this since i first saw it but honestly i don't know maybe i took this the wrong way but i don't care because i took this the way that i wanted/needed to and i have wanted to say this since i first saw it but this is getting too long
I love Brian's character
He is just like me
I love the little context clues sprinkled here and there.
I seriously am on Junio- WAIT NO SORRY Gus' side about this video. I personally think Volde-SORRY Joe went crazy and I don't think he saw God. I mean how would February and Draco believe that?
It really does. I came for the Starkids, but I stayed because it's actually incredibly beautiful. It's deep, the story itself is extremely complex, the acting is phenomenal.
Watching this was really an experience. I don't quite know how to feel about this. I mean obviously most people will side with Brolden's character, Gus. He appears to be the most rational minded and is very easy to sympathize with despite his bitterness and inability to assume responsibility for his life choices. I know I do. But at the same time I kind of wish Joe DID actually see God and that the world is truly full of miracles. I don't know, it's so hard to explain? I'm very glad I watched this and know that I'm going to keep thinking about it for a long long time.
Manasi Khade I really appreciate you watching my first short and taking the time to write a thoughtful comment. If you haven’t seen my latest short film “Last Ride to Liberty High” you can find it here: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
coming back to this every few months, it's just so surreal. the acting, writing, lighting and perspectives. everything was just... amazinggggg. oh, and the music! I'm overwhelmed haha. I wish I could be more profound than this
Where was Jeff Blim in this? I didnt see him
+PrinceTrexus He was the guy Joe was communicating with in the video where he sees God
+Emma Downes oh wow ur right I totally missed him the first time! Lol
ohh it has been SO long since i saw this. so delighted to remember it exists, this is still phenomenal
Spacemadness Cult: The Movie 😂
Oh my God, yes! Brian seemed like the only one who was fully alert!
i saw this when i was younger and it didn't make any sense to me. i had sort of fever-dream-esque memories of it, i remember Joe's helmet reminded me of Little Big Planet and the surrealism of that game. i came back to it now, and the feeling is just amazing.
i dont know if Joe really did see God, but i like to believe he saw something. maybe he hallucinated, or experienced something traumatic that his brain formed into a vision of God, but whatever happened up there, it clearly changed him.
i think at the end, you see how hes not right. hes unstable, and hes never going to be able to let go of space and whats out there. there's nothing here on earth for him anymore, because he's seen too much to ever go back to being someone like Gus.
or maybe, at the end, he really did see God. i guess we'll never know, and i guess it doesn't really matter.
ALDERDICE thanks a lot for sharing your thoughts on seeing my first short again. If you haven’t already, feel free to watch my latest short “Last Ride to Liberty High”: ruclips.net/video/5w1sC391Ock/видео.html
@@chrisallenshow sure man, id love to. i think this film is one of my favourites of all time, im sure this will be just as good
I think this short is great! Beautiful shots, stellar acting, and important themes. I want more!
Joe pissed me off so much in this video, but I can get past his character by staring at his freaking beautiful face and remembering that's not him ;)
Oh my god!!! I saw this a few years ago and didn’t finish it but it came back into my recommended after I’d found starkid and I totally freaked out because of joe in the thumbnail of a video I’d half seen but didn’t remember watching
I just saw a verry potter sequel, and I can't help myself but think Lupin and umbridge are best friend, but after the fisrt couple minutes I'm like woah man that's deep