There is a small problem with this video. Most Iranians living in Iran dont want the regime. They want to get rid of it. But when they protest in mass, the IRGC comes to the streets and spraying their guns into the crowds. Civilians do not own weapons themselves. There are no weapons shops for citizens to buy and arm themselves.. that is why Iranians want International help/intervention for the removal of its regime.
Dr. Mordechai you are 100% right. right now in Lebanon there is hope that is rising again in the possibility of rebuilding a sovereign country! Thank you 🙏
Mordechai Kedar is the deepest strategic thinker. His ideas will sprout and grow long after he passes on! People will appreciate him many decades into the future.
I used to follow and respect Mr Keder, but after this commentary, I must say I am disappointed and angry. Iran is and will remain a united country. Mr. Kedar's suggestion of dividing Iran is disgusting. I am pro-Israel and an Iranian. Shame on you.
Let’s hope the minorities ask for help as they can’t prevail alone. Israel needs help in order to keep peace inside its border. Thanks for the video!!!🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
The main division in Iranian Society today is between the regime supporters & non supporters. 20% VRs 80% modern Iran was founded by the Safavi dynasty in 1501 they were from the Kurdish region & made Shiism the official religion of their kingdom. After them came the Zand dynasty ( Persians) followed by the Qatar & Pahlavi who are Turks from Ajarbayejan. The various tribes have each taken turn at controlling the sceptre of central governance… The only non-Iranian tribe is the Arabs who came after the Islamic invasion and since the revolution is mainly an anti-Islamic revolution that region above all has the least amount of opportunity to declare independence because collectively all the tribes see them as Arabs and not Iranians, who came part of the invasion of seventh and eighth centuries.
Dr. Kedar, if the various distinguishable tribes inside Iran separate into small, independent nations or even emirates, will they then fight each other over land, natural resources, etc.? Or will they be able to draw borders everyone can agree on and keep peacefully stable?
Iranians mostly do not want to separate. They just want to get rid of the evil regime so they can live their lives how they wish and have a government that invests in them, not in te33o wrists and nukes. Zan Zendigi Azadi - Am Yisrael Chai
@@JeSuisunHumain-222 This is true, even Khomeini's grandson Hassan Khomeini has condemned Khamenei's regime as being corrupt, neglectful, and far too militant. In fact that are numerous clerics and Ayatollahs in Iran who have come out against the Khamenei regime. I guess they have to many followers for Khamenei to risk killing them and turning them into martyrs. I know they did arrest cleric Akbarnejad but I think they may have released him. He's a very cool Iranian cleric.
Big problem. While most Iranians living in Iran don't want the regime, they also don't want to lose their culture/country and turn it into piecemeal or a dog's breakfast. If the Iranian sub-cultures were to gain more power/autonomy on a province-by-province level, they would most likely become part of the culture they are a part of. There is a large Pakistani subculture in the southeast of Iran which would no-doubt become part of Pakistan. There is a large Turkish subculture as well, which Turkey would want. So, the country would collapse/shrink, somewhat, and be swallowed by the other countries. And no Iranian wants that either.
Yes, and politics of divide is the thing east dislikes about west. No country in modern world can effectively have modern economy being divided into ethnic microstates. Its death.
Sorry, but Iran is not Yugoslavia. Iran is one of the oldest civilizations in the world and all Iranian ethnic groups live for thousands of years together and will never allow the separation of the country. Yes we want to get rid of the mullah terror regime but people who talk about separation help indirectly the mullahs.🛑🛑🛑🛑
Tech advice for your future videos: your light is way too bright,.it washes out the temperature of the picture, also your face. Try a filter or a lower setting
Mr. Mordechai blessings to you. I'm just curious about the flag behind you with the green star on it. Would you kindly teach me about it . Thank you. Edited . Thanks, you already mentioned the flag .
Dr. Kedar, thanks. Being honest, we always hear these narratives, and I understand the point "we know what will happen," but it's difficult to have the transparency to trust this fully, and believe that what is being done will alleviate the risks on both sides. I don't think anyone doubts that Hamas and Hezzbollah had a decay function which equates to terrorism which cannot pose as anything else? And what's the reason we say and believe that military action was *the singular diplomatic lever* which these organizations would use? And what's the geopolitical significance? Besides autonomy and free choice, why does the strange balance between Jordan, Iran, Yemen and Syria somehow vote for or against these nationalized and religious forms of governance?
So first there is no Palestinian nation (1000s years old), then there is no Iranian nation ( 1000s years old) , Is Israel , ( 76 years old) the only nation in the Middle East?
So you think he's making stuff up, and I think you're making stuff up. The Palestinian identity is clearly a 20th century identity. Doesn't mean it's not real.
@@davidk2471 When I read my bible, i read about the Kainites and the Phillistines, , (thats Palistinians) and how they existed in the times of Jesus...So only an ill informed person will say such things.
@@fannycasteel7118 why don't you read history instead of a book of fables. If I called myself an Edomite would that mean I'm the offspring of Jakob's older brother Esau from the Bible? The Philistines were seafaring people from Greece who had settlements along the coastal plain in what is now Israel and Gaza. They left after the Assyrians conquered the area (not sure, it might have been the Babylonians). They have zero connection with modern Arabic speaking people who call themselves Palestinians. The area was named Syria Palestna after the Romans put down the lady Jewish rebellion (circa 135), using the term to allude to the Jews traditional enemy from centuries before. All of this information is out there if you're ever done with reading fairy tales.
The philistines in the bible are not the same as the Palestinians of today . Those people from the bible are from Crete. The Palestinians of today are mostly Arabs came with Khalifa Omer in the islamic conquest of Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jerusalem, and Egypt. And later, another conquest by Salah Aldin Ayobi, ottomans. I am glad you are interested. Please continue reading your Bible daily. You find the truth . I encourage you to join us daily in the (bible bus) . Just Google it Blessings to you .
Mr. Kedar, are you receiving money from Saudi Arabia? Let me tell you something. The Iranian people lost over a million soldiers in the 8-year war with Iraq. Millions died from all across Iran to preserve Iran's integrity. Those soldiers were from all over Iran, from Azerbaijan, Gilan, and Baluchistan. They died to keep Khuzestan part of Iran. Those one million were all Iranian patriots, not Basij or IRGC. They were Persians...we all know Saudi Arabia has been supportive and has tried to create a separatist movement in Khuzestan.
For those who don't know about the " Al Ahwaz" separatist group in southern Iran. First, it is a tiny group of people. Secondly, this separatist group was created by the Saudi Arabis as a means to pressure the Mullahs who support the minority Shia in Saudi Arabia. Once we get rid of the Mullahs the support for the Saudi Shia will end. So, Saudis will stop supporting the "Al Ahwaz". Mr. Kadar's support of the Al Ahwaz" sad and pathetic attempt. Also, everyone in Iran is mistreated all across Iran. The regime is an occupied foreigner. This poverty is not exclusive to the minorities such as the Arabs Baluch or Kurds...everyone in Iran is suffering. Iran and Persia are one united nation and united. Shame on you...Iran has been around for 5000 years. Shame on you.
Mr. Kedar has one solution only : 'divide and conquer'. He is calling for Palestinian Emirates and now is calling to divide Iran. Using the same logic, Israel should also be divided into multiple states : Religious Israel, non-religious Israel, Arabs, Ultra Orthodox Jews, etc....
No, that's not true at all. Dividing Israel would not help out anyone in Israel. In Israel all people share approximately equal rights. No group of people is oppressed in any meaningful way. The country is prosperous to the degree that the middles class is rather large and most people enjoy a very high quality of life, aside from having to run to bomb shelter now regularly, and the government indeed represents the people. Israel has 30 political parties in the Knesset and still Israel operates more or less very smoothly. Iran is much different where most of the population is oppressed and very angry because they have no representation and are kept in poverty and absent any rights or freedoms. It's a prime example of the difference between democracies and authoritarian regimes. 75% if Iranian people didn't even vote in the last election to protest Khamenei. Tje majority of Iranians aren't interested in war with Israel and could care less about the Sunnis Muslims in Palestine. Sunnis and Shiite really hate each other, which shows to us Hezbollah is not operating out of any honest affection toward the Palestinian but out of loyalty to its puppet masters in Iran. Hezbollah was created for one purpose and one purpose only, identical to Hamas, and that is to help Iran destroy Israel. The Middle East is far more complex than most of the world knows. Keep listening to Dr. Kedar to help educate yourself on those complexities. And for a large dose of reality, check out my videos.
@@greybushMEproductions I was merely mentioning dividing Israel to illustrate how ridiculous dividing Palestinians into different "emirates" , which Mr. Kedar calls for. The solution to the Palestinian issue is a Palestinian state (Arab majority), Israel (Jewish Majority) , under one confederate country, with a constitution separating state and religion and declaring everyone equal. One economy, one currency, and a national education system that teaches the next generation how to respect the existence of one another under one country. I would even dare to say one army. To address the long standing 1948 refugee issue, quotas for migrations between the 2 states can be established under strict control and supervision. A religion Jew who wants next to Abraham's grave in Hebron can do so but to accept that he is living in the Arab state and pays state taxes to that state. Pretty much a model where a common destiny is established, modeled after the united states.
How shameful can you be? Iran and Iran are one united nation and we love each other. You are toeing and repeating what the mullahs have been saying that Israel wants to divide our country. Shame on you to put the "Khozestan" flag behind you. Iran is and will always remain united....I am sick of you now, I used to respect you.
Who do you think you are? Mr. Kedar. You are repeating what the Mullahs in Iran are saying. I am so angry...Baluch, Kurds, Azaries, Gilak, Lors, and many other ethnicities in Iran ARE Iranian and Persian. Shame on you...We are even older than Israiliates...Iran is the oldest continuous nation...remember that...
Why don't you say how much Saudis have paid you? Your interest and crying wolf for the minorities in Iran is not because you care about them. It is because you think, that by dividing Iran into smaller pieces, you have reduced the threat against Israel. This is a sad and pathetic way to deal with the problem. Iranian people( the Persians) do love and respect Israel and the Jewish states. Your misguided rant is sad and dishonest. The entire country is mistreated by the Islamist mullahs. In the 70's war between Israel and the Arabs, The Shah of Iran and Israel supported the Kurds to fight against Iraq. Do you know why? Because that kept Iraq occupied and could not join the war against Israel. So, if tomorrow Mullahs are gone and we have a democratic government in place, everyone in Iran will be treated the same. When people rose up for Mahsa, the women's life freedom movement, was across the country from north to south and east to west, and all ethnicities and languages. You are doing a disservice and creating war in Iran. Israel does not have a better friend than the Persians...What is wrong with you Mr.Kedar?
Excellent commentary.
He is an idiot...
One of the best analysts and highly knowledgeable gentleman. Your videos offer great insight.
No, I disagree..he is one ignorant ass..most likely on a take from the Saudi Arabia...read my comment above
Brilliant analysis as always!
No , I have no doubt he is getting paid by the Saudis...hence the "flag" behind him...disgussting
Thank you Mordechai, your comments are always welcomed.
Well done, Well said
You can trust everything Dr. Kedar says.
May Hashem bless you, Dr Kedar, with שנה טובה ומתוקה כמה בריאות וכל טוב ❤️
Brilliant 👏
There is a small problem with this video. Most Iranians living in Iran dont want the regime. They want to get rid of it. But when they protest in mass, the IRGC comes to the streets and spraying their guns into the crowds. Civilians do not own weapons themselves. There are no weapons shops for citizens to buy and arm themselves.. that is why Iranians want International help/intervention for the removal of its regime.
But the video is not a problem
Thank you for the intellectual commentary.
Thank you Dr Mordechai Kedar.
Thank you for starting a channel!
Dr. Mordechai you are 100% right. right now in Lebanon there is hope that is rising again in the possibility of rebuilding a sovereign country!
Thank you 🙏
Mordechai Kedar is the deepest strategic thinker. His ideas will sprout and grow long after he passes on! People will appreciate him many decades into the future.
Thank you!
שבוע טוב
Why don't we hear from you more, sir?
I used to follow and respect Mr Keder, but after this commentary, I must say I am disappointed and angry. Iran is and will remain a united country. Mr. Kedar's suggestion of dividing Iran is disgusting. I am pro-Israel and an Iranian. Shame on you.
@@rostamr4096 Iran has a civilization let islamists conquer their land, they should be embarrassed about it.
Great insight.
Dr. Kedar, very excited to see you speaking on your own channel.
The real Iranian flag has the Lion sun and sword!
Sounds better than that red sh!t in the middle of it
Well said. Now we can actually see the possibilities.
Thank you.
You are blessed with wisdom sir ..why the Arab world won't listen to you.!?
Genuis analysis!
Hallelujah
Thanks Dr
Am Yisrael Chai
🕎✡️🇮🇱🇨🇦✝️🇻🇦
Wonderful.
Let’s hope the minorities ask for help as they can’t prevail alone. Israel needs help in order to keep peace inside its border. Thanks for the video!!!🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
God Bless Dr. Mardokay
The main division in Iranian Society today is between the regime supporters & non supporters. 20% VRs 80% modern Iran was founded by the Safavi dynasty in 1501 they were from the Kurdish region & made Shiism the official religion of their kingdom. After them came the Zand dynasty ( Persians) followed by the Qatar & Pahlavi who are Turks from Ajarbayejan.
The various tribes have each taken turn at controlling the sceptre of central governance…
The only non-Iranian tribe is the Arabs who came after the Islamic invasion and since the revolution is mainly an anti-Islamic revolution that region above all has the least amount of opportunity to declare independence because collectively all the tribes see them as Arabs and not Iranians, who came part of the invasion of seventh and eighth centuries.
Dr. Kedar, if the various distinguishable tribes inside Iran separate into small, independent nations or even emirates, will they then fight each other over land, natural resources, etc.? Or will they be able to draw borders everyone can agree on and keep peacefully stable?
peace amongst Muslim tribes? That would be something! It's like asking is Sunnis and Shiites can stop from killing each other.
They will most likely behave as Moslem dictatorships usually do.
Iranians mostly do not want to separate. They just want to get rid of the evil regime so they can live their lives how they wish and have a government that invests in them, not in te33o wrists and nukes. Zan Zendigi Azadi - Am Yisrael Chai
@@JeSuisunHumain-222 This is true, even Khomeini's grandson Hassan Khomeini has condemned Khamenei's regime as being corrupt, neglectful, and far too militant.
In fact that are numerous clerics and Ayatollahs in Iran who have come out against the Khamenei regime. I guess they have to many followers for Khamenei to risk killing them and turning them into martyrs.
I know they did arrest cleric Akbarnejad but I think they may have released him. He's a very cool Iranian cleric.
Big problem.
While most Iranians living in Iran don't want the regime, they also don't want to lose their culture/country and turn it into piecemeal or a dog's breakfast.
If the Iranian sub-cultures were to gain more power/autonomy on a province-by-province level, they would most likely become part of the culture they are a part of. There is a large Pakistani subculture in the southeast of Iran which would no-doubt become part of Pakistan. There is a large Turkish subculture as well, which Turkey would want.
So, the country would collapse/shrink, somewhat, and be swallowed by the other countries. And no Iranian wants that either.
Yes, and politics of divide is the thing east dislikes about west.
No country in modern world can effectively have modern economy being divided into ethnic microstates. Its death.
interesting
Sorry, but Iran is not Yugoslavia. Iran is one of the oldest civilizations in the world and all Iranian ethnic groups live for thousands of years together and will never allow the separation of the country. Yes we want to get rid of the mullah terror regime but people who talk about separation help indirectly the mullahs.🛑🛑🛑🛑
Tech advice for your future videos: your light is way too bright,.it washes out the temperature of the picture, also your face. Try a filter or a lower setting
It is what he says that matters, point taken.
Ahhhhh, the serious stuff. Too bright. OK. I'm sure he's really concerned about that. We all are.
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🇮🇱🇮🇱👍👍❤️💙🤍
Mr. Mordechai blessings to you. I'm just curious about the flag behind you with the green star on it. Would you kindly teach me about it . Thank you.
Edited . Thanks, you already mentioned the flag .
👏👏👏👏
Some suggestions what should come next: Haschim Safi al-Din, Ali Khamenei and Wladimir Putin are some names that come into my mind.
Dr. Kedar, thanks. Being honest, we always hear these narratives, and I understand the point "we know what will happen," but it's difficult to have the transparency to trust this fully, and believe that what is being done will alleviate the risks on both sides.
I don't think anyone doubts that Hamas and Hezzbollah had a decay function which equates to terrorism which cannot pose as anything else? And what's the reason we say and believe that military action was *the singular diplomatic lever* which these organizations would use?
And what's the geopolitical significance? Besides autonomy and free choice, why does the strange balance between Jordan, Iran, Yemen and Syria somehow vote for or against these nationalized and religious forms of governance?
The israeli model/gcc arab models work very well . The iranian model of having militia running states is obviously a failed model .
Funny things the French condem israelfor what they did ?????
So first there is no Palestinian nation (1000s years old), then there is no Iranian nation ( 1000s years old) , Is Israel , ( 76 years old) the only nation in the Middle East?
So you think he's making stuff up, and I think you're making stuff up. The Palestinian identity is clearly a 20th century identity. Doesn't mean it's not real.
@@davidk2471 When I read my bible, i read about the Kainites and the Phillistines, , (thats Palistinians) and how they existed in the times of Jesus...So only an ill informed person will say such things.
@@fannycasteel7118 why don't you read history instead of a book of fables. If I called myself an Edomite would that mean I'm the offspring of Jakob's older brother Esau from the Bible? The Philistines were seafaring people from Greece who had settlements along the coastal plain in what is now Israel and Gaza. They left after the Assyrians conquered the area (not sure, it might have been the Babylonians). They have zero connection with modern Arabic speaking people who call themselves Palestinians. The area was named Syria Palestna after the Romans put down the lady Jewish rebellion (circa 135), using the term to allude to the Jews traditional enemy from centuries before. All of this information is out there if you're ever done with reading fairy tales.
The philistines in the bible are not the same as the Palestinians of today . Those people from the bible are from Crete. The Palestinians of today are mostly Arabs came with Khalifa Omer in the islamic conquest of Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jerusalem, and Egypt. And later, another conquest by Salah Aldin Ayobi, ottomans. I am glad you are interested. Please continue reading your Bible daily. You find the truth .
I encourage you to join us daily in the (bible bus) . Just Google it
Blessings to you .
@@davidk2471 The Palestinians have more connection to occupied Palestine than all the jews in israel currently. Because all of them comes from Europe.
Which flag do you have behind you except Israel?
Thank you,Israel 🇮🇱 ❤
Zen lebanon, Syria, jordan and sinai. Mwoo hah hah, zen yemen and ve control ze red sea. Mwoo hah hah, ze vorld isz ourz
Godspeed Israel 🇮🇱☦️🙏
Mr. Kedar, are you receiving money from Saudi Arabia? Let me tell you something. The Iranian people lost over a million soldiers in the 8-year war with Iraq. Millions died from all across Iran to preserve Iran's integrity. Those soldiers were from all over Iran, from Azerbaijan, Gilan, and Baluchistan. They died to keep Khuzestan part of Iran. Those one million were all Iranian patriots, not Basij or IRGC. They were Persians...we all know Saudi Arabia has been supportive and has tried to create a separatist movement in Khuzestan.
Greetings from Palestine
Seems like Fauci’s brother…!
For those who don't know about the " Al Ahwaz" separatist group in southern Iran. First, it is a tiny group of people. Secondly, this separatist group was created by the Saudi Arabis as a means to pressure the Mullahs who support the minority Shia in Saudi Arabia. Once we get rid of the Mullahs the support for the Saudi Shia will end. So, Saudis will stop supporting the "Al Ahwaz". Mr. Kadar's support of the Al Ahwaz" sad and pathetic attempt. Also, everyone in Iran is mistreated all across Iran. The regime is an occupied foreigner. This poverty is not exclusive to the minorities such as the Arabs Baluch or Kurds...everyone in Iran is suffering. Iran and Persia are one united nation and united. Shame on you...Iran has been around for 5000 years. Shame on you.
Mr. Kedar has one solution only : 'divide and conquer'. He is calling for Palestinian Emirates and now is calling to divide Iran. Using the same logic, Israel should also be divided into multiple states : Religious Israel, non-religious Israel, Arabs, Ultra Orthodox Jews, etc....
Israeli "sectarian" divides don't prevent the country from thriving and individuals from living freely
You can't seriously be this dumb?
No, that's not true at all. Dividing Israel would not help out anyone in Israel. In Israel all people share approximately equal rights. No group of people is oppressed in any meaningful way. The country is prosperous to the degree that the middles class is rather large and most people enjoy a very high quality of life, aside from having to run to bomb shelter now regularly, and the government indeed represents the people. Israel has 30 political parties in the Knesset and still Israel operates more or less very smoothly.
Iran is much different where most of the population is oppressed and very angry because they have no representation and are kept in poverty and absent any rights or freedoms. It's a prime example of the difference between democracies and authoritarian regimes. 75% if Iranian people didn't even vote in the last election to protest Khamenei. Tje majority of Iranians aren't interested in war with Israel and could care less about the Sunnis Muslims in Palestine. Sunnis and Shiite really hate each other, which shows to us Hezbollah is not operating out of any honest affection toward the Palestinian but out of loyalty to its puppet masters in Iran. Hezbollah was created for one purpose and one purpose only, identical to Hamas, and that is to help Iran destroy Israel. The Middle East is far more complex than most of the world knows. Keep listening to Dr. Kedar to help educate yourself on those complexities.
And for a large dose of reality, check out my videos.
@@greybushMEproductions I was merely mentioning dividing Israel to illustrate how ridiculous dividing Palestinians into different "emirates" , which Mr. Kedar calls for. The solution to the Palestinian issue is a Palestinian state (Arab majority), Israel (Jewish Majority) , under one confederate country, with a constitution separating state and religion and declaring everyone equal. One economy, one currency, and a national education system that teaches the next generation how to respect the existence of one another under one country. I would even dare to say one army. To address the long standing 1948 refugee issue, quotas for migrations between the 2 states can be established under strict control and supervision. A religion Jew who wants next to Abraham's grave in Hebron can do so but to accept that he is living in the Arab state and pays state taxes to that state. Pretty much a model where a common destiny is established, modeled after the united states.
Iran will remain one united nation and country. Shame on you. I am an Iranian who supports Israel...I am disgusted by your unintelligent comment.
thank you
How shameful can you be? Iran and Iran are one united nation and we love each other. You are toeing and repeating what the mullahs have been saying that Israel wants to divide our country. Shame on you to put the "Khozestan" flag behind you. Iran is and will always remain united....I am sick of you now, I used to respect you.
Who do you think you are? Mr. Kedar. You are repeating what the Mullahs in Iran are saying. I am so angry...Baluch, Kurds, Azaries, Gilak, Lors, and many other ethnicities in Iran ARE Iranian and Persian. Shame on you...We are even older than Israiliates...Iran is the oldest continuous nation...remember that...
Why don't you say how much Saudis have paid you? Your interest and crying wolf for the minorities in Iran is not because you care about them. It is because you think, that by dividing Iran into smaller pieces, you have reduced the threat against Israel. This is a sad and pathetic way to deal with the problem. Iranian people( the Persians) do love and respect Israel and the Jewish states. Your misguided rant is sad and dishonest. The entire country is mistreated by the Islamist mullahs. In the 70's war between Israel and the Arabs, The Shah of Iran and Israel supported the Kurds to fight against Iraq. Do you know why? Because that kept Iraq occupied and could not join the war against Israel. So, if tomorrow Mullahs are gone and we have a democratic government in place, everyone in Iran will be treated the same. When people rose up for Mahsa, the women's life freedom movement, was across the country from north to south and east to west, and all ethnicities and languages. You are doing a disservice and creating war in Iran. Israel does not have a better friend than the Persians...What is wrong with you Mr.Kedar?
May Yahweh bless and protect Israel!
Next is khamenei
Thank you