The fact that he knew he doesn't sing and couldn't hit every note but still did it not caring if anyone had something bad to say about him singing ( just like half the comments on here ) to show Judy there's nothing he wouldn't do for her is such an amazingly sweet thing for him to do. Kudos to you and benji Judy! You have a beautiful marriage and babies!:)
i literally came here after the kids asked how the proposal went... judy: "he was wearing a white robe and glasses and sang in the garage and proposed..." LOLOLOL, the way she put it, compared to the way it actually was.
It's great that their babies will be able to look back at these type of videos and see how much love their parents have for one another. I teared up. Love your family so much!
Watching this July 2, 2022 And I literally cried of happiness and joy just like I did the first time I watched this video. God bless you Judy God bless you Benji and your beautiful family. You guys were one of the very first RUclipsrs I ever watched and continue to do so till this day, and will continue to for as long as you guys keep making videos. Thank you for showing that true love does exist. ❤️
I've watched this video probably 5 times now in the past 3 years and it still gets to me because seeing Judy so happy warms my heart and knowing still in 2015 Benji is still the most amazing man for her! Your relationship is truly an inspiration!!
i first watched this when i was 12 and i turn 19 this year and you guys i cry everytime it has been a crazy 5/6 years and honestly i cant believe it!!!!
Came across this video and I feel so emotional watching this!!!! I have literally watched you guys from day one and I can't believe how close I feel to you guys!!! I love your relationship and how amazing and honest you both are.. love from Australia!
This is the first itsjudytime video I ever watched. Five years sure flew by! Add in building a home, three little girls...a lot has happened in 5 years! Congratulations on your engagement anniversary :)
Awww benji that was the best proposal EVER! I cried lol. you guys are such a sweet sweet couple and have such a beautiful growing family! Wow soon you'll have 2 more little ones to shower with love. You guys are such great parents! Love ya guys and god bless♥♥♥
1st comment in 2021.. teary-eyed watching this Judy & Benji.. I've been watching your vlogs since 2012. but only got to see this today.. praying that I'll experience this kind of proposal someday....
Awwwww I've never seen this video until now June 30, 2015 and this is the sweetest thing ever I've been watching itsjudy's life for 2 years and this is my first time seeing this video I almost cried
I've been following u for about a year now judy and this is my forst time watching this video and your wedding videos and let me tell u im crying like a big baby at work to at that omg I love your love you are blessed with a great man and family
Wow this is the first time I saw this, I am sitting here boo hoo-ing like you guys just got engaged. Great job Benji! Thanks for sharing your life together!
***** My neither! I remember watching this video a few days after Judy posted it and I was so happy for her, and now, looking back at it, it warms my heart to see how lovely her family is, and how happy Benji and her are. Cutest couple on RUclips
Wow almost 10 years later i bet they never would've thought they'd have a family with 4 beautiful girls. How amazing is it to have their engagement, wedding, births of all babies videoed to look back on?
Seeing how far you guys have come (of course only with the videos you share with us). I feel like I'm a friend to you guys only we haven't met and I am glad you guys have Julianna and the twins now. Also, last but not least you guys are still together and still love each other.
A beautiful blessing this moment was, still is. No one saw the true life beauty that came years after. Juliana that blesses them with hyper fun ready and prepped for the twins. Now baby Leah brings the calm. (We’ll see for how long.) I feel so lucky to have stumbled upon Judy’s page one day years ago... such a beautiful journey to be a part of without even being there. Thanks for sharing with us Judy. ❤️
Awh. I watched your other vlogs and I cam back to this and began tearing up. You have such an awesome life ❤️ your lucky to now have a romantic husband & 3 young beautiful girls. I love how you have fun memories. Your my favorite youtubeer! Love you & live the rest of your lives happily 💋
I had seen this before and thought it was super amazing... but after watching your lives day to day, years later, living with baby Julianna and twins on the way, i came back to watch this and it seriously made me cry of joy and happiness for you guys. You are so blessed to have each other and to have it all on video for wonderful memories. Thank you for sharing your lives with all of us! Your videos brighten up my days!
Who’s watching this in the year RONA aka 2020 after baby Leah’s birth?! ✋🏼
Here! Don’t know how this video popped up lol
✋
🤚
Me! Hahahah
Me!! I've been watching them 4 Years and have never come across this until today!
Who else is here crying 10 years later 😭♥️
After how many years, they did not change!! They’ve grown as a beautiful family with 4 lovely girls!! 💖
The fact that he knew he doesn't sing and couldn't hit every note but still did it not caring if anyone had something bad to say about him singing ( just like half the comments on here ) to show Judy there's nothing he wouldn't do for her is such an amazingly sweet thing for him to do. Kudos to you and benji Judy! You have a beautiful marriage and babies!:)
Isn't it crazy that JB Keira and Miya can see how their parents got engaged and everything!?! *.* :-)
I wish i could see my dad and moms wedding
and now baby Leah too
And now baby Bella 😊
Watching this after watching their 10 year vow renewal. Your love is still so wholesome and pure.
I swear I like to come back to their wedding series at least once a year! & every time I watch it, I love it and get teary eyed.
I do the same thing.they are such a cute couple
i literally came here after the kids asked how the proposal went... judy: "he was wearing a white robe and glasses and sang in the garage and proposed..." LOLOLOL, the way she put it, compared to the way it actually was.
Benji can't sing, even if his life depended on it, but he had excellent stage presence. ♡♡♥♥♡♡♥♥
hahaha even he admitted it himself.
Admission is the first step...LOL;)
Shelley Jones lol! Judy would pay millions for his concert though :p
aww i just cried :/ Benji is seriously the most sweetest guy ever ! you 2 are perfect for each other.
If only every man was like Benji!! lol Judy you got a good one
True! Lol
Deffo agree!
Guys like Benji are rare nowadays. :(
TRUE
True
Barf
RAREEEEE!
Not really Benji doesn’t do much but cook and workout you can find that type anywhere
This made me cry. Like seriously, Benji's so sweet.
I cannot believe I am crying my eyes out this is so beautiful oh my gosh
Almost 4 years later, and I'm STILL bawling!!! LOL Nothing like L-O-V-E!!! =)
I'm crying!!! omg I can't wait to be engaged to the love of my life!
And now you are married!!
It's great that their babies will be able to look back at these type of videos and see how much love their parents have for one another. I teared up. Love your family so much!
i can't wait until julianna and the twins watch this and think "gee, dad was such a dork but i love him."
And even baby L 😍
@@miru.instablonde Baby L brought me here too😁😁
"Like this song, I know I don't always hit all my notes in this relationship.." AWWW!! This was so dang cute!!
Watching this for the first time in 2016! So sweet to see this beautiful couple at the very start :)
me too:)
Me too and omg they re still in love like nothing has changed.💕
me too😍😍
is this their first vlog
me
Watching this July 2, 2022
And I literally cried of happiness and joy just like I did the first time I watched this video. God bless you Judy God bless you Benji and your beautiful family.
You guys were one of the very first RUclipsrs I ever watched and continue to do so till this day, and will continue to for as long as you guys keep making videos.
Thank you for showing that true love does exist. ❤️
Who is watching this 2016!? this marriage proposal so beautiful & sweet couple it made cry! 😍😢😢😭
Who else came to watch this after watching the vlog? This video makes me cry everytime I watch it.
I came here because judy reminded me that is was there anniversary and showed us a clip.
same
me too!
yup
LOL YUP
That has got to be the most adorable thing ever. I was crying at the end, so beautiful! You guys are such a wonderful couple.
I just cried watching this. The look on Judy's face is priceless. Can tell these two are really in love and support each other to the end. Love it!!!!
Benji and Judy should do a commentary on this video!!!!
true
First time watching in 2016 and I cried omg 😩😭💖
Me too 😭😘
aiiiiraaaaa 😘
me too ^^ so much!
Aira Joie Amosin
me tooo.....
Who else watching this while on quarantine 2020?
This made me cry. Just simple words from benji but it sound so sweet. You can truly feel the sincerety. ☺️😊😊
i cried watching this and then i scroll down to the comments and realized everyone was crying too haha.
I've watched this video probably 5 times now in the past 3 years and it still gets to me because seeing Judy so happy warms my heart and knowing still in 2015 Benji is still the most amazing man for her! Your relationship is truly an inspiration!!
AW I AM SMILING SO HARD THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL
I teared up when he got on his knees.. so romantic
Benji's singing was indeed awful but this was precious.
i first watched this when i was 12 and i turn 19 this year and you guys i cry everytime it has been a crazy 5/6 years and honestly i cant believe it!!!!
Lmfao the wolf person nxt to judy😂
Came across this video and I feel so emotional watching this!!!! I have literally watched you guys from day one and I can't believe how close I feel to you guys!!! I love your relationship and how amazing and honest you both are.. love from Australia!
This still makes me cry lol Benji is so sweet
Watching this video again after watching JB's 10 birthday...What a beautiful family you have!!!
OMG! I cried! i love you two :*
I WAS CRYING THE ENTIRE TIME BECAUSE THIS IS HOW I IMAGINE THE BEST WEDDING PROPOSAL EVER MY MAN SINGING MY FAVOURITE BAND GOSH IM ONLY 16 WHY
Are you 23 rn?
I don't cry much..but gosh, that made me tear up! Sooo sweet! You have a great man :)
watched this again after the renewal of vows.. and this video always makes me cry
I just cried watching this!!! So amazing and sweet! Judy you look SO happy!!!!
This is the first itsjudytime video I ever watched. Five years sure flew by! Add in building a home, three little girls...a lot has happened in 5 years! Congratulations on your engagement anniversary :)
i watch this today in 2017, can't stop crying, really true love, hope you all the best in your live with your babies.
This made me cry!!! Just beautiful!!! A few years later with three beautiful BLESSINGS!!!! I love you guys!!!!
I finally understand where the intro clip came from.... :D
I was just about to say the exact same thing. Been watching for a while now and just saw this and I'm blubbering like a baby!
I remember when I was in middle school when I watched this. benji set the bar for me since I was a little girl!
Watching this in 2022😭🤍 & im in tears. I love you guys so much. Such a beautiful love story.
Awww benji that was the best proposal EVER! I cried lol. you guys are such a sweet sweet couple and have such a beautiful growing family! Wow soon you'll have 2 more little ones to shower with love. You guys are such great parents! Love ya guys and god bless♥♥♥
I still come back to watch this! This was so incredibly beautiful :')
This video always makes cryyyy!!
And even until now, he still treats Judy like a queen. Such a good man. True to his promises.
Had to watch this after benjis little romantic dinner
Me too!!! lol
Sameee
Me too :)
Same here :)
msprettyk6102 sameee!!
1st comment in 2021.. teary-eyed watching this Judy & Benji.. I've been watching your vlogs since 2012. but only got to see this today.. praying that I'll experience this kind of proposal someday....
OMG this literally made me cry I wish every guy was like Benji ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I cried so much watching this, you guys are truely blessed 💞
This video never gets old.♡
I first watched this about a year ago. Thought I'd watch tonight again. How lovely was that proposal? Tears streaming down my face. Remember the love.
Watching this again, you two are really meant for each other! Happy Anniversary and may God continue to bless you both and your kids!
Awwwww I've never seen this video until now June 30, 2015 and this is the sweetest thing ever I've been watching itsjudy's life for 2 years and this is my first time seeing this video I almost cried
Makes me cry every time :)
I still sit here and watch it for the hundredth time and cry like a baby!!
Benji always doing the most for Judy ❤️
Went here coz im lonely how does someone just found their soulmates this is everything
I always find my self crying when I see this
Thank you both for letting us all share your moment! x
I always cry watching this vid
Omg how am I just seeing this 🤣🤣🤣 Judy you should film a reaction video with the girls! How cool would it be to see mom and dad when it all began
i just bawled my eyes out.
Couldn't stop smiling while watching!! I'm so thankful that you chose to use YT as a platform to showcase your life!
your life is a fairy tale! I love you, it's crazy how much you've accomplished both of you together. most perfect couple ever!
I've been following u for about a year now judy and this is my forst time watching this video and your wedding videos and let me tell u im crying like a big baby at work to at that omg I love your love you are blessed with a great man and family
Wow this is the first time I saw this, I am sitting here boo hoo-ing like you guys just got engaged. Great job Benji! Thanks for sharing your life together!
dang! I've watched this gazillion times and yet I still cried and touched by this lovely/sweet proposal.
4 years later and you have 3 girls!
***** My neither! I remember watching this video a few days after Judy posted it and I was so happy for her, and now, looking back at it, it warms my heart to see how lovely her family is, and how happy Benji and her are. Cutest couple on RUclips
wow 162 likes for mee
195 oh this might be my most like comment!
225 likes!
That's generally the idea! Lol
And to think they now have three daughters(: so cute
Nessa Gonzalez 4 :)
@@TheBre123456 now almost 5!
I'm cracking up at his singing, but he attempted it anyways! I'm still crying over this video
It’s 2020 and this is still awesome! Texas loves ITS JUDYS LIFE 🤍🤍🤍
I did a full on ugly cry watching this. This is literally something out of a movie!😭
can you two make a baby boy, a benji junior and make him grow fast! I'll wait for him. HAHAHAHAHAHA. :D
LOL
Hahaha! That would be awesome for you ;)
Wow almost 10 years later i bet they never would've thought they'd have a family with 4 beautiful girls. How amazing is it to have their engagement, wedding, births of all babies videoed to look back on?
This is the video that started it all for me - I love how I have seen them grow over the years!
You know I don't sing, at all... I'm singing right now because I just want you to know that I will do anything for you, baby.
OMG I DIED
Seeing how far you guys have come (of course only with the videos you share with us). I feel like I'm a friend to you guys only we haven't met and I am glad you guys have Julianna and the twins now. Also, last but not least you guys are still together and still love each other.
I watched this on repeat like 10 times you two are the perfect couple I hope one day I'm in a realationship like this
A beautiful blessing this moment was, still is. No one saw the true life beauty that came years after. Juliana that blesses them with hyper fun ready and prepped for the twins. Now baby Leah brings the calm. (We’ll see for how long.) I feel so lucky to have stumbled upon Judy’s page one day years ago... such a beautiful journey to be a part of without even being there. Thanks for sharing with us Judy. ❤️
I would literally DIEE to have a love like Judy & Benjis.... ;-; 😭😭😭😭
Awh. I watched your other vlogs and I cam back to this and began tearing up. You have such an awesome life ❤️ your lucky to now have a romantic husband & 3 young beautiful girls. I love how you have fun memories. Your my favorite youtubeer! Love you & live the rest of your lives happily 💋
watching this in 2015
I know wat i would do for a marriage proposal when me older
hhhhh
???
wat does hhhhh mean
Hey its Connor
I had seen this before and thought it was super amazing... but after watching your lives day to day, years later, living with baby Julianna and twins on the way, i came back to watch this and it seriously made me cry of joy and happiness for you guys. You are so blessed to have each other and to have it all on video for wonderful memories. Thank you for sharing your lives with all of us! Your videos brighten up my days!
The gesture that benji pulled was so sweet. I just had to race here to see the video where it all started :)
Watching this because of today'a blog 👏
I love that even though Benji couldn't carry a tune in a bucket, he went and sang for you Judy. He certainly wins a person over.
Omg, I cried like a baby!. This was sooo sweet!.
that was so cute ! It was my first time watching this ! 4 years later and they have 3 kids.
10 seconds in and im already crying
omg😂 first time i watch today crying like baby love you guyz
made me cry, you guys are literally relationship goals!