Dear brother I am from South Africa, I have been following all of your discussions on the various channels viz. Peghamehaq, Only the truth matters... I have also read your book. I have been having a lot of difficulty understanding how traditional Sunnis practice islam in this age. For many years I questioned a lot of the traditional practices. I have utmost respect for the time and effort you have put in to research hadith, abrogation, ijtima etc. May Allah bless you for having the conviction of speaking out. I am so glad to have come across your discussions.
Very grateful. Your book came in the post yesterday. Muslims' Greatest Challenge: Choosing between Tradition and Islam. Very grateful to Dr Omar Zaid as well. I might not agree with Dr Hany's Abrahamic Locution and Marvelous Quran channel but very grateful for everything else. Especially since those mind-blowing conversations with Sh. Omar Baloch in 2020. May Allah bless you both in pursuit of the truth and may He bless us all in using our reasoning faculties gifted to us by Allah.
It's all back to the Umayyad.....😆😆😆. Always them.... Btw, I really hope you, Dr Omar can have a dialogue too with Dr Hany Atchan from Marvelous Quran. I hope Allah will grant this,
Salamun alaykum, 1. I also think that the Umayyads are the main source of the corruption in Islam, but why the Shia hold on to friday prayers as well? 2. I dont think that Dr Ramahi and Dr Atchan will give much credit to each other. I also would like to see them discussing a lot of topics, but I dont expect a satisfactory result.
14:47 might want to clarify this. People will misunderstand you and get triggered over this. I think you were saying that the verses of the mushaf today were written down much later after the Prophets death (PBUH). At first it sounded like you said verses were added when you said "made verses". I say this respectfully. Not attacking. With appreciation.
salam brother. Many thanks for pointing out this potential point of confusion. What I said was that the demarcation (i.e., the numbering and separation) of what we refer to today as verses, was not done while the Prophet was alive, but many years after he passed away. You are absolutely right in that I am NOT saying the "verses" were created by humans. Thanks once more.
[30/08, 21:49] Ilyas @ CIS: ruclips.net/video/d0RY6nZHoek/видео.htmlsi=hUVEKO5fIpueJZdV [31/08, 13:31] Fahim Lafir: Assalasmu alaikum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakatahu. Barakallaahufeek wa jazakallah khair. We are subjected to varied levels of covering up of the TRUTH ( AS IN THE HOLY QURAN).. we seek protection from the DHAALLEEN' S ( Surah Al Fathiha)... but increasingly we become subjected to SUBLIMAL Seduction of this deception ( from every known sector and increasingly from within the muslim community). All I can state is BEWARE!! THE TRUTH IS COVERED UP!! And each one of us must truly and sincerely strive to RECONNECT WITH ALMIGHTY ALLAH SUBHANA WA TA'ALA upon the SIRAATHAL MUSTAQEEM. Rabbanaa laa thajallanaa ma alqawmul dhaallimeen wa Ihdeena wa Saddidnaa alaa Ad Deenul Islam. Wassalaamu alaikum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakatahu
I do agree, no proof for obligation for the khutba. But the Salah after the khutba is clearly obligatory from the verse and doesn’t limit it to a specific can time frame so it’s general to all those who take heed (Mu’mineen). And the Salah is the Thikr of Allah as His verses are mentioned and recalled.
37:32 Thank you again for digging deeply and finding no hadith that says we MUST go to Jummu'ah and if we miss 3 in a row we are out of the fold of Islam.
41:17 sorry i dont want to fill up your comments section but you've hit on one of my big research questions, looking into Quranic Chronology... we don't seem to have the mentioning of "weeks". Not even once.
@@rabbi619 But Allah swt talks about days, months and years, but He spares the mentioning of weeks. A day is (yaum) consists of dayphase (nahār) and nightphase (layl). A month lasts from crescent to crescent. A year is a set of 12 months reguarly. But what is a week according to the Quran or is it an unit without any importance, just created by man to let others walk in circles?
@@manndesfriedens5248 You are either illiterate or you have no eyes allah will never talk about man made day and man made months whatever is manmade allah wont say anything about it.
Brother omar why few people are doing this defining words from quran using hebrew dictionary.And yes there is no prophet called muhammad muhammadun is a title used for the quran and other prophets i think you already know this.
salam brother Rafiqun. You have raised a very good question. I am equally and deeply puzzled by those folks. I could not find a rationale behind their definitions or their methodology. At the end of the day, let each one think and decide for him/herself whether their definitions make any sense. I, for sure, did not.
hebrew is a dead language , i mean was but it had been "revived" by muslim scholars and retaught hebrew to other people. they use arabic to revived the hebrew. the problem is that concepts and definition often collide when picking up words.
35:40 but Allah also says We have given you 7 repeated and a Great Quran. Is Surah Fatiha not the Quran? Also we have raised a Messenger from themselves, reciting the BOOK and the WISDOM. You want to tell me t he Book and The wisdom are distinct? Ofc not.
1. Kinda. The whole surah is in the perspective of believers. So no other surah like it. Even surah an-nas, al-falaq, al-ikhlas begin with a command "qul:" or "say:" 2. Yes. The Book is full of Wisdom. But God's Wisdom is infinitely greater (quran 18:109). So we cant confine it in a book nor in a library which the sectarian calls it sunnah/ hadits. And He give wisdom tho whoever He wills (2:269), so, unlike the Book, God can inspire His Wisdom without going through messengers & prophets. So a person can have both the Book & Wisdom, can have the Book but God didn't bestow him Wisdom (most people of the religion today), or can be given some wisdom but not enough to recognize God & His Book ( -good- some people among atheist, agnostic etc)
How can a Muslim believe that the Quran was not compiled, complete and in circulation during the time of the Prophet when Allah in the Quran revealed the verse "This day I have completed for you your religion" while the Prophet was still alive and many Muslims already had all of the Quran memorized to heart? Muhammad did not leave the Quran incomplete with those who a day before were his worst enemies, nor did Allah ever allow men the choice in any matter in religion whether it be verse placement or choosing a leader. Allah in the Quran says that he does not trust His covenant to the unjust/wicked. Only those chosen by Allah can dictate the words of Allah which means that the Prophet would never have left the Quran to be compiled by the very people who fought him for years and immediately after began burning hadith and killing his family and companions. The idea that verses were revealed and hidden away to be compiled after the Prophet died was introduced by the rulers after Muhammad who rewrote Islam and forged countless sayings to legitimize their authority and justify their oppression. This belief leads one to doubt the Divine origin of the Quran eventually leading one to abandon faith altogether.
@@SI00000 can you put it in writing, huruf for huruf (without looking at the original text) the verses that you've memorised ? try with Quran 20:14 salaam
![Chino Pacas - Modo Capone (with Drake & Fuerza Regida) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zjv8TQ0gBkg/mqdefault.jpg)
Dear brother I am from South Africa, I have been following all of your discussions on the various channels viz. Peghamehaq, Only the truth matters... I have also read your book. I have been having a lot of difficulty understanding how traditional Sunnis practice islam in this age. For many years I questioned a lot of the traditional practices. I have utmost respect for the time and effort you have put in to research hadith, abrogation, ijtima etc. May Allah bless you for having the conviction of speaking out. I am so glad to have come across your discussions.
Brother please setup a meeting between you and Brother Benjamin Bilal! Thank you both for this educational discourse.
salam brother Yousef. Insha-Allah soon. sincere wishes.
Very grateful. Your book came in the post yesterday. Muslims' Greatest Challenge: Choosing between Tradition and Islam.
Very grateful to Dr Omar Zaid as well. I might not agree with Dr Hany's Abrahamic Locution and Marvelous Quran channel but very grateful for everything else. Especially since those mind-blowing conversations with Sh. Omar Baloch in 2020.
May Allah bless you both in pursuit of the truth and may He bless us all in using our reasoning faculties gifted to us by Allah.
Could you please share the link of this book
It's all back to the Umayyad.....😆😆😆. Always them.... Btw, I really hope you, Dr Omar can have a dialogue too with Dr Hany Atchan from Marvelous Quran. I hope Allah will grant this,
Salamun alaykum,
1. I also think that the Umayyads are the main source of the corruption in Islam, but why the Shia hold on to friday prayers as well?
2. I dont think that Dr Ramahi and Dr Atchan will give much credit to each other. I also would like to see them discussing a lot of topics, but I dont expect a satisfactory result.
Thank you for videos it such eyes opening ❤..
14:47 might want to clarify this. People will misunderstand you and get triggered over this. I think you were saying that the verses of the mushaf today were written down much later after the Prophets death (PBUH). At first it sounded like you said verses were added when you said "made verses". I say this respectfully. Not attacking. With appreciation.
salam brother. Many thanks for pointing out this potential point of confusion. What I said was that the demarcation (i.e., the numbering and separation) of what we refer to today as verses, was not done while the Prophet was alive, but many years after he passed away. You are absolutely right in that I am NOT saying the "verses" were created by humans. Thanks once more.
[30/08, 21:49] Ilyas @ CIS: ruclips.net/video/d0RY6nZHoek/видео.htmlsi=hUVEKO5fIpueJZdV
[31/08, 13:31] Fahim Lafir: Assalasmu alaikum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakatahu.
Barakallaahufeek wa jazakallah khair.
We are subjected to varied levels of covering up of the TRUTH ( AS IN THE HOLY QURAN).. we seek protection from the DHAALLEEN' S ( Surah Al Fathiha)... but increasingly we become subjected to SUBLIMAL Seduction of this deception ( from every known sector and increasingly from within the muslim community).
All I can state is BEWARE!!
THE TRUTH IS COVERED UP!!
And each one of us must truly and sincerely strive to RECONNECT WITH ALMIGHTY ALLAH SUBHANA WA TA'ALA upon the SIRAATHAL MUSTAQEEM.
Rabbanaa laa thajallanaa ma alqawmul dhaallimeen wa Ihdeena wa Saddidnaa alaa Ad Deenul Islam.
Wassalaamu alaikum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakatahu
قال الله تعلی: إِنَّنِي أَنَا اللَّهُ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا أَنَا فَاعْبُدْنِي وَأَقِمِ الصَّلَاةَ لِذِكْرِي (14)
I do agree, no proof for obligation for the khutba. But the Salah after the khutba is clearly obligatory from the verse and doesn’t limit it to a specific can time frame so it’s general to all those who take heed (Mu’mineen). And the Salah is the Thikr of Allah as His verses are mentioned and recalled.
37:32 Thank you again for digging deeply and finding no hadith that says we MUST go to Jummu'ah and if we miss 3 in a row we are out of the fold of Islam.
41:17 sorry i dont want to fill up your comments section but you've hit on one of my big research questions, looking into Quranic Chronology... we don't seem to have the mentioning of "weeks". Not even once.
Why would god talk about man made things days weeks months years these are all man made.
@@rabbi619 But Allah swt talks about days, months and years, but He spares the mentioning of weeks.
A day is (yaum) consists of dayphase (nahār) and nightphase (layl).
A month lasts from crescent to crescent.
A year is a set of 12 months reguarly.
But what is a week according to the Quran or is it an unit without any importance, just created by man to let others walk in circles?
@@manndesfriedens5248 You are either illiterate or you have no eyes allah will never talk about man made day and man made months whatever is manmade allah wont say anything about it.
Is Friday a Fardh or a Fraud? 😎
Brother omar why few people are doing this defining words from quran using hebrew dictionary.And yes there is no prophet called muhammad muhammadun is a title used for the quran and other prophets i think you already know this.
salam brother Rafiqun. You have raised a very good question. I am equally and deeply puzzled by those folks. I could not find a rationale behind their definitions or their methodology. At the end of the day, let each one think and decide for him/herself whether their definitions make any sense. I, for sure, did not.
So who was the Arabian prophet then ?
@@goodman_1955 Maybe ismael maybe ilyas.
hebrew is a dead language , i mean was but it had been "revived" by muslim scholars and retaught hebrew to other people.
they use arabic to revived the hebrew.
the problem is that concepts and definition often collide when picking up words.
@@GBL3092 Why did they revive it and how come there is a hebrew nation explain.
35:40 but Allah also says We have given you 7 repeated and a Great Quran. Is Surah Fatiha not the Quran? Also we have raised a Messenger from themselves, reciting the BOOK and the WISDOM. You want to tell me t he Book and The wisdom are distinct? Ofc not.
1. Kinda. The whole surah is in the perspective of believers. So no other surah like it. Even surah an-nas, al-falaq, al-ikhlas begin with a command "qul:" or "say:"
2. Yes. The Book is full of Wisdom. But God's Wisdom is infinitely greater (quran 18:109). So we cant confine it in a book nor in a library which the sectarian calls it sunnah/ hadits. And He give wisdom tho whoever He wills (2:269), so, unlike the Book, God can inspire His Wisdom without going through messengers & prophets. So a person can have both the Book & Wisdom, can have the Book but God didn't bestow him Wisdom (most people of the religion today), or can be given some wisdom but not enough to recognize God & His Book ( -good- some people among atheist, agnostic etc)
How can a Muslim believe that the Quran was not compiled, complete and in circulation during the time of the Prophet when Allah in the Quran revealed the verse "This day I have completed for you your religion" while the Prophet was still alive and many Muslims already had all of the Quran memorized to heart?
Muhammad did not leave the Quran incomplete with those who a day before were his worst enemies, nor did Allah ever allow men the choice in any matter in religion whether it be verse placement or choosing a leader.
Allah in the Quran says that he does not trust His covenant to the unjust/wicked. Only those chosen by Allah can dictate the words of Allah which means that the Prophet would never have left the Quran to be compiled by the very people who fought him for years and immediately after began burning hadith and killing his family and companions.
The idea that verses were revealed and hidden away to be compiled after the Prophet died was introduced by the rulers after Muhammad who rewrote Islam and forged countless sayings to legitimize their authority and justify their oppression.
This belief leads one to doubt the Divine origin of the Quran eventually leading one to abandon faith altogether.
well said! Thank you.
@@OmarRamahi2019
You are welcome brother.
@@SI00000
can you put it in writing,
huruf for huruf
(without looking at the original text)
the verses that you've memorised ?
try with Quran 20:14
salaam