Heaven to hell: Ukraine liberated Kherson, now it's under Russian attack
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- Kherson was liberated from Russian occupation in November 2022 by Ukrainian forces, sparking ecstatic scenes in the main square.
Subscribe to The Guardian on RUclips ► bit.ly/subscrib...
But with Russian troops retreating just over the Dniepro river, joy has quickly turned to nightmare, with the city suffering daily bombardment by mortars, missiles and even tank shells. Simply surviving each day has become a matter of luck and many civilians have fled.
The Guardian's Luke Harding and Christopher Cherry speak to remaining residents to find out what life is like among the awful booms of artillery fire, and why they have chosen to stay.
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made. possible by supporters.Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com...
Website ► www.theguardia...
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on RUclips:
Guardian News ► bit.ly/guardia...
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardia...
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfoot...
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnspor...
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardia...
#Ukraine #Russia #Kherson #Military #Zelenskiy #Putin #News
Vasili is a true man. He did not persecute his friend on the phone. He asked what he wanted, mainly to be coy of course, but then wished his friend well regardless of the situation and his lack of response.
Nice report.
So you think that call was a nice birthday present? As if Shura could know where Ukrainian soldiers are hiding in Kherson area...
I could never do that. It would become lifelong hatred.
It's a lie
@@jerekuusrainen6475 I can tell you one thing, even if soldiers were hiding in the children’s hospital, they wouldn’t still be hiding there after it’s already been shelled twice. Vasili is a man of true restraint, if a former “friend” was attempting to justify my civilian neighbors and relatives being indiscriminately shelled by cluster munitions and whatever artillery they can find, the kindest words I’d probably be able to muster would be something to the effect of “I hope the same happens to you and your descendants remember you as a complacent coward who helped carry out the war crimes of a sadistic oligarchic dictator committed against his own comrades”
Surreal call. Why should that Russian's birthday be joyous when his country is wrecking misery upon their neighbors and former friends?
Unfortunately that breakdown between Vitaly and Shura strikes me as all too common. It has amazed and appalled me over my life how people I considered close and trustworthy have proved the exact opposite when something happened that challenged their interests.
“it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” - Upton Sinclair.
This is my all time favourite quote for a reason. It is bitterly disappointing but if you understand this fact the world makes an awful lot more sense.
It's been a long time since I've read Sinclair. That quote is quite appropriate.
I've learned of this when I was in the 3rd grade. Money controls the world.
@@Kopie0830 and murica is desperately trying to control the money. Then we have WAR
The Ukrainian himself said that the Russians cannot even receive images, as the RUSSIAN GOVERNMENT controls the media, so why would that be Shura's "interest"?
Luke Harding had a conection with Julian Assange as you knowe. Look howe that played out.
I want to express my condolences to all those who died in this war.
Take care of your loved ones. ❤️
Хочу выразить соболезнования всем погибшим в этой войне.
Берегите своих близких.❤️
What a cool dude. Stuff blown to bits and he's concerned about others and hospitality. 12:12
Your city is not dying. It's just winter and we have no idea when spring will come. We pray for your safe passage. Slava 🇺🇦 🇺🇦
Spring comes when Russian troops return
@@user-rd1hz9zj9l return home :)
@@user-rd1hz9zj9l Wont return, most will die in ukraine.
@@user-rd1hz9zj9l orc you're getting wrecked
@@MultiJejje Nope......the Counter-Offensive has failed
The mongols taught imperial russians well in whatever concerns cruelty, mischief and cowardice…
Now Mongols are nobodies. Russia is the mighty one.
The mongols? You mean modern history? The same is done by violent governments across the world. Mongolia has been relatively peaceful for centuries, compared to Russia, the US, Germany, Israel, Britain
RIP Little child.
The horrible selfishness of Sura, the Russian "friend", who complains about his Ukrainian friend who is under constant shelling by Russians forgetting his birthday is really nauseating. He clearly does not deserve Vasilij as a friend. Such a kind-hearted man ❤
The russians must be held responsible.
Сразу после вас
0:25 No matter what happens in the war he has a heart of a child and strength of a lion 🦁 ❤️❤️❤️
Not at all
Yes he does 💙💛
This hurts to watch. I've been in Kherson three times, and I remember this city as bright and lively. The amount of damage done to Kherson is shocking. I can't imagine what it was like to live through all those atrocities.
How about we stop speculating and just ensure the freedom and the continuance of democracy in the world.
Dear Kherson: ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🇺🇦💪
You say that like it's so simple! But what are you advocating? Just, us, the forces of freedom n democracy, stop ponderously deliberating, and get out there with the guns and defeat the bad people so the others can live happily ever after!?
I don't disagree about the overarching vision. But you are urging a material action.
Yet I'd suggest that carrying that from merely voicing the theme, onto fruition, it's a gap requiring more than just stating an idealised goal and then saying go...
thank you from Kharkiv for the report
Love & Grace to Kherson May Everyone Be Safe.
Top notch journalism at its finest. Luke Harding is an absolute legend!
The Russian will be fertilizers for Ukraine land.
The sooner the better.
Far more Ukrainians have already been turned into dust. It is beautiful.
@@carolwilliams8511 The sooner western hegemony ends, the better.
@@cosmicwanderer891You mean "Russian imperialism", right?
I'm a foreigner and my home Kherson been living there for 6 years now I'm in Poland
I used to live in the city of Dnipro and now I’m in Canada I hope that you and I can go back home and our mother Ukraine will win
Courageous Khersonians!✌️
Stay strong Ukraine in your fight for your freedom 🇺🇦🇵🇹💪🏼🇪🇺🇪🇺🇪🇺🇪🇺🇪🇺💛💙🇺🇲🇬🇧
Can’t wait for this war to end. So many lives taken 😢
Ask Putin to leave his forces from Ukraine then.
@yuusukeAre you even comparing a civil war with a brutal invasion?
They could live happily under Russian rule, instead they prefer death and destruction. I have no sympathy to people who say "we would rather die, than live together with Russia". I'm like yeah... ok. Then may you rest in peace my friend.
@@user-rd1hz9zj9l Say thanks to imperialistic Russians that invaded Ukraine in 2014 and 2022.
@@user-rd1hz9zj9l you're the one who invaded an independent country, not british or americans (this time)
Hoping your city is safe and peaceful again soon.
😢 So sorry for the innocent citizens and children of Ukraine. Russia must stop this mindless war at once.
The problem is that Russia does not want to end the war on Ukraine's terms, so there will most likely be a lot of innocent bloodshed on both sides.
@@Lalala33331 Agree. Putin is a completely crazy, unrepentent madman (pardon my strong language).
@@vishaalbhatnagar3924 Putin is not crazy, he is a bad person who acts purely in his own interests, just like many other politicians in the world.
That's all I'll write.
All the best.
@@Ridethebomb777 you dont negociate with a guy that took your lands and ask for more. Ukraine never saw prosperity with Russia. and when Ukraine decided to try with Europe they got invaded. This is an illegal war of agression
@@borali26 So, what you are saying is that you condone Ukraine shelling its own people in the Donbas .... and that Russia should never have come to their aid .... is that right ??
Tragic and we need to support the courageous people of Ukraine.
"War is war. But it should be on the battlefield." No truer words have ever been spoken.
Putin needs to go the same way as Sadaam.
Did Saddam killed as many civilians as J Bush?
Or Khaddafi...
And zelensky the sale way as Mussolini
@@Gerrard_Pike2008 Hahaha.
@@Gerrard_Pike2008 Tu portes bien ton nom toi.
Bro... his Russian 'friend' is just on another level. wow.
The Russian people have entirely stuck their heads in the sand concerning this war. When Reality comes knocking, the Revolution in Russia will be swift and deadly...
My heart goes out to all Ukrainians fighting for their freedom from Russian imperialism, Putin and his USSR fantasies.
American Imperialism started this war, stop listening to the TV news people.
Ukrainians are staging terrorist attacks on peaceful objects in Russia and Belarus. Peaceful areas of Donbass are being shelled daily simply because they have a lot of shells. Their desire is to cause maximum damage. This is the meaning of the Ukrainian sect. They talk about hate all the time.
My great selut for Ukraine heroes
Спасибо союзникам за помощь ❤️
❤
We are NOT going away 💙💛
So pleased to see the you reporting factual news, keep it up
Excellent presentation, excellent reporting, thanks. 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦Salford uk
How about UK media covering Palestinian life under Israeli occupation?
Western using tactic and method of Special war
Whatabout ?!! WHATABOUT ?!!! I'm sure if you search you will find.
If the Russians are just across the river and shelling Kherson daily, why have 1 or 2 HIMARS not been brought in to eliminate the threat? That’s easily within HIMARS range.
Because the missles are rare
a massive response.
Яибы еще добавил, что и военные объекты в украине не являются какими-то "законными целями", Украина не на кого не нападала, мы обороняемся, и это наши защитники на нашей территории, такие же граждане Украины как и мирные люди.
Донбасс так же ни на кого не нападал. И ветераны на 9 мая спокойно ходили к мемориалам.
А в Донецк каждый день идут прилеты по гражданским объектам. Просто потому что на украине много снарядов.
@@Dirtmiy конечно, так как донбасс это донецкий угольный бассейн, который считаеться донецкой, луганской и частьб днепропетровской области в то числе и часть ростовской области , донбасс по факту не является каким либо государством, что бы нападать на кого либо.
И причем здесь ветераны ?
Платили рублями. какая жестокость 🤣
Ну Просто ЗВЕРИ!
Bravo ukraine ❤❤❤❤
Doesn't look very safe in Liberated Kherson...
Liberated you say, Guardian? Tell us the real news, I say.
kremlin bot
yeah russians have to go home and stop these bombings
When surrounded in a city, declare it is of no importance - Sun Tzu
The Russians left it...the Ukrainians brought in troops and artillery.
Excellent reporting. Wish there was a way for Russians to see this. There must be some people there with empathy.
They are told that it is Ukrainian artillery that is bombing Kherson.
They don't care. Realize this already
@@Danielklark нет, нам так не говорят. Мы прекрасно понимаем, что раз там украинские войска, то войска РФ их обстреливает. Это логично. Логично и то, что Сумы, Бучу, Донецк, Горловку и другие города, где стояла или стоит армия России - обстреливает Украина. Ведь так? Глупо с этим спорить! Но почему тогда украинцы и Европа не говорят, что убивали своих же людей, а это сделали «орки»? Что за лицемерие?
@@tanya_nechso who's making it up? One of the main things I've been reading from presumably russian bots is how Ukraine is apparently shelling eastern... Ukraine, hence why Russian invasion is apparently "justfied" to protect Ukrainians and Russians living there from the """""neonazi government of Ukraine"""""".
Are you saying this is not being told in Russia and only told to Europeans? That's interesting (and very weird)
Zelenskyy didn't know a word of Ukrainian when he took power.
he is a CIA spy, elections were conned
You're absolutely the best journalist on earth. Tanks for all your reports and the new book.❤❤❤
The orcs took out all the furniture ... Well, they just rammed the truck, put the furniture there and took it away. XD
Glory to Ukraine
It’s nice that a reporter can speak the language instead of having an interpreter
Viva kherson! Viva 🇺🇦 Ucrania libre, soberana e independiente.
Rip to everyone who died in the war…
0:25 💀💀
DON'T EVER BELIEVE THE GUARDIAN
Thanks for the Closed Captioning, only in Russian, 'The Guardian' and 'RUclips' ('Google') Top notch work... >_
people can withstand everything ...
Russia agreed to Ukraine sovereignty.
russia guaranteed to protect Ukraine in 1996 as well, if you look at it like "russia = lies" then everything makes sense, simply liers all day
Ukrainian sovereignty was based on certain conditions. After the Maidan, they were ignored. The result is the loss of Crimea, long negotiations and war.
Grauniad propagandised hopium
🇺🇸🇺🇦ALAVA UKRAINE🇺🇦🇺🇸
It's like deja Vu all over again.
Vitaliy and Shura were friends before the war and hopefully remain friends.
Northern Ireland must be independent
Finland has joined Nato & Sweden is joining NATO soon and Millions of professional soldiers from 43 NATO/Friends countries They wanted to join because of Putin aggression to small democratic countries
This soldier not want died for Usa establishment man
Crazy… Russian soldiers paid for the coffee… Mind warp..
What a waste.
Of what
Everything was going so well, and then 200000 heavily armed Russian hove into sight
My heart is with Ukraine and the Russian opposition.
Береги свое глупое сердце, ибо оно тебе хрень говорит
impossible
Red cross workers are brave
Similar killing of civilians happened in Iraq when the US invaded it
زنده باد اکراین زنده باد ازادی
Nuremberg Trials-2 !!! Ruscism
Ukraine didn't liberate anything, the Russian army just WITHDREW from there. :)
flew in panic u mean
It's not mutually exclusive.
All Ukrainians interviewed speaking Russian.
"waiting for you to wish me a happy birthday"? what in the world is wrong with these people 🤦
The red cross does not leave the safety of the city center, ride around in expensive suvs, help is needed outside of the city but most importantly the red cross also helps out the Russian occupiers...
The Red Cross are supposed to be neutral in all wars. No matter what side a person is on, if someone needs medical attention, they are sworn to help.
SLAVA UKRAINE 🇺🇦
$LAVE UKRAINE
☠️🇬🇧🇮🇱🇺🇸☠️
@@lw1zfog don’t embarrass yourself Ivan 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@The Guardian Tolong menambahkan subtitle Bahasa Indonesia /Please add Indonesian subtitles 🙏🙏
❤ 🇺🇦 ❤
is he talking in Russian or Ukrainian i cant tell
"Ukraine above all" 👀
Feel what donesk city feeling for 8 years.
Yeah, all of it magically started 🙄
Another liar 😂
Два последних года там ничего не происходило , и надо было кому-то политический рейтинг поднимать
Ah yes, 8 years of bombing Donetsk and it looked perfectly normal. 2 months of russia bombing Mariupol, and it looks like WW2 Stalingrad.
Or maybe, just maybe, nobody would be bombing Donbas at all, not even a tiny bit, if people like Girkin wouldn't be there along with "volunteers" and "found in the mines" equipment of the russian army.
Slava roosia.
With love from India ❤
Hi from Ukraine. India is part of China
Can't the capable Ukrainian army set up ant-battery artillery to hit back?
i guess they dont want to smash locals, no russian style
@@iggvec5769 00:40 Have you watched the video?
Ukraine does fire back. But is that the best use for the limited numbers of shells it has? These are deecisions the professional military leaders need to take, the like's of me sitting in western Europe at a keyboard can't know such things.
@@carelgoodheir692 true
You can see some of Zelensky's Kvartal 95 translated on the RUclips channel Yasmin Ali Mentor💙🎹💛
Ничего не прячется, все выступления 95 квартал в свободном доступе. То же самое не могу сказать о выступлениях президента России , который за 20 лет наговорил , а потом и натворил сами знаете чего.
Slava Ukraini
This video is just like scenes of the London blitz, except in the blitz films it was indiscriminate bombing but here all the houses are well spaced out and each house seams to have its fare share of the available shelling. It’s definitely targeted I can’t see any lines of craters of sticks of bombs from aircraft. This is almost proof of gentrification or more likely attempted genocide of Ukrainians from their own country.
Russia does not bomb civilians. There are attacks on strategic objects. Sometimes the Ukrainian air defense deflects the trajectory of the projectiles and then they fall into buildings. There are also cases when shells are deflected for another reason. If the Ukrainian government cared about people, it would have carried out the evacuation of civilians from the combat zone, as Russia did in Kherson.
Bridge layers are coming!!!
The Russians just pulled out back for a better defensive position. Ukraine didn't liberate anything.
Why did they do that? Because they would be unable to hold ot
@@dsebbebridge2674 Wrong ! It was a strategic move and it worked ,Ukraine didn't Free it they walked right into the trap.
@@thebearrules9729 the trap is taking a while to happen
@@thebearrules9729 what trap? LoL. Kherson is officially (by russo constitution) is part of russia. Kherson is being targeted by missiles just like any other city on the front lines. Before Kherson it was Mykolaiv. Now it's not because it's too far to reach
@@thebearrules9729 Kiev, Chernihiv, Kharkiv, Mykolaiv and Kherson.
Weren't these areas occupied by Russia last year? What happened, withdrew to strategic defensive positions? 😂
Actually Russia retreated from Kherson, Ukraine claims they liberated it.🤣🤣🤣🤣
Cringe
Who is cringing now🤣🤣
They killed russians while the took their city back. slava ukraini
No difference. The retreated then the ukrainians liberated the city.
Triller film
🙏🏼
Dont love this journalist tbh..
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦l,ukrainien fait partie de l,Europe et le monde libre doit soutenir le peuple ukrainien ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Zneužívanie detí. V mene koho.
Lol😂🤡 Ukraine didn t liberated Kherson, because the RF retreated orderly, evacuated the civilians,saved their troops and equipment...
Kiev, Chernihiv, Kharkiv, Mykolaiv and Kherson.
Weren't these areas occupied by Russia last year? What happened, withdrew to strategic defensive positions? 😂
So they withdraw from Afganistan several years ago for more defensive position and to save their troops...is that so?
was there no more bulletproof vest and helmet for the guy you paid a bit of money to show his dangerous city to you
Putin is jealous he can’t do this 0:27
These Ukrainian women need not to be on the frontline to save lives.
hey atleast they payed the coffe
Always this lies, Ukraine will lose, stop foling the Ukraine people
The Russian city of Kherson was shelled every day when it was occupied by Russian troops. Ukraine fired at it from artillery, every day civilians died in the city.
hmm why did they fire... oh wait russians invaded Kherson
💪🇺🇦❤️
He speaks Russian . How come?
A lot of people in Eastern Ukraine are Bilingual or speak Russian first.
Because he is Russian living in the land of Rus. Historically, Ukraine was just a region, not a country.
Is this about Kherson or her son?
They said Ukranian soldiers liberated Kherson, which was even celebrated, but the man tells on a phone there are no soldiers. Then how Kherson got liberated, by whom, did they liberate the city and left???
😂 Потому что ничего они не освобождали, лжецы. Русские просто спокойно покинули город и эвакуировали большую часть жителей. А эти просто зашли через несколько дней (сразу боялись 😂) и теперь там хрень. Даже мусор не могут вывозить после того, как ушли городские власти России 😂
@@mariarussia5886 If that's true why did you back off what reason do you want to say?😆
They mostly left because, after Russians bombed the bridges and crossings, Kherson became a dead end. Most forces were regrouped into the Eastern front, mostly around Bakhmut and Donetsk.
@@diogorodrigues747 ah, ok then
My friend there is not a Ukrainian soldiers every meter. You question is a bit weird.